Skip to playerSkip to main content
Democrats challenge President Donald Trump’s public health nominees during a heated Senate hearing, raising concerns about healthcare policy, public health priorities and the consequences of proposed changes.

The Senate HELP Committee hearing features sharp exchanges as Democratic senators question Trump’s health nominees over their views and plans for America’s public health system. The phrase “People are dying” underscores the urgency of the debate.

Watch the key moments from the Senate hearing and the clash over Trump’s public health nominees and U.S. healthcare policy.

#DonaldTrump #Trump #Senate #SenateHearing #PublicHealth #Healthcare #HealthPolicy #Democrats #Republicans #USPolitics #TrumpNominees #HELPCommittee #Congress #Polit

~HT.410~PR.462~ED.103~GR.508~VG.HM~

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Thanks to all three of you for not only being here today, but for your willingness to serve your country
00:04and thank your families as well.
00:07I already asked Mr. Klomp this question at a different hearing yesterday, but to Dr. Sapphire, Dr. Westlake, before turning
00:15to other issues, I want to ask you a simple question.
00:18If directed by the president to take action, it would break the law. Would you follow the law or follow
00:22the president's directive? Dr. Sapphire.
00:27I have no intention of breaking the law, Senator.
00:29So you will follow the law?
00:31You will follow the law.
00:32And Dr. Westlake?
00:33My ultimate responsibility is to the American people. I follow the law.
00:38Dr. Westlake, I want to follow up on a conversation we had in my office.
00:42I recently met with groups in New Hampshire, including members of law enforcement, who work together to distribute overdose prevention
00:50kits, including fentanyl test strips.
00:51They told me that fentanyl test strips help prevent fatal overdoses and ultimately help engage people to get them into
00:59recovery.
01:00This is a small community, by the way, that hasn't seen an overdose now since 2020 because of their work.
01:06However, earlier this year, your agency released guidance that says that grantees cannot purchase or distribute test strips with federal
01:14funds.
01:15This guidance directly contradicts a bipartisan provision that I led in last year's Support Act to ensure that test strips
01:22can be purchased with federal funds.
01:24Now, because of this administration's actions, a community organization in New Hampshire is scrambling to reorganize its budget so that
01:32they can find a way to keep getting these test strips.
01:35Dr. Westlake, if confirmed, will you rescind the guidance that takes test strips away from recovery organizations?
01:42Senator Hassan, thank you for the question, and thank you for meeting with me, and thank you for the work
01:46in the past when we were working on Halt-Fentanylton.
01:48And so the thing, the question is harm reduction, you know, what is harm reduction?
01:53So harm reduction for me means eliminating the risky behaviors that lead to the devastating effects of the disease process.
01:59So when we look at the evidence on fentanyl test strips, there's no evidence that it reduces overdose.
02:04But that's not what we're hearing.
02:06You just gave very eloquent testimony about the importance of listening to people on the ground.
02:10Here's what's happening on the ground in my state.
02:12Tiny town I just told you about, they haven't even seen an overdose because the chief of police has worked
02:17so closely with families and the community to make sure that we are being evidence-based and effective and meeting
02:24people where they are as they're challenging their addiction and turning to law enforcement or to health entities for help.
02:32And one of the things that they tell me is that the fentanyl test strips build trust, among other things.
02:37In Manchester, New Hampshire, we can all celebrate today because in August, it's our biggest city, for the first time
02:44since 2015, we had zero overdose deaths.
02:47I have been to more funerals than I can count where parents have lost more than one child to this
02:52epidemic.
02:53We know that fentanyl test strips work.
02:55Also, the law says you have to provide them.
02:57So the evidence is really clear.
03:00However, I am looking for you to commit to follow the law and allow community organizations to purchase test strips
03:08with federal funds.
03:09Yes, Senator.
03:10So I've been, my first overdose that I resuscitated was more than 30 years ago.
03:15So I'm looking very, I have another question for you.
03:17So I'm looking very specifically, will you rescind this guidance?
03:21The evidence does not support that.
03:23There's anecdotal stories.
03:27My people, my people on the ground, you cannot tell me that it's important to listen to providers on the
03:33ground, that they have the best evidence, and they are very evidence-based.
03:37I am telling you, one, that the law requires it, and two, that it works, because people who are on
03:43the ground, who you say you trust, health providers, law enforcement, say it works.
03:50So I am, we will follow up, but what I'm looking for today is a commitment to rescind guidance that
03:56violates the law.
03:57I promise to follow the science and the evidence-based to the best dreams, including naloxone.
04:02How about following the law?
04:04You just said you'd follow the law.
04:06We have, the Support Act says the federal government must provide these test strips.
04:10Follow the law.
04:11My understanding is it says that they may be used for that and not shall be used for that.
04:15So we are, I believe we are following the law from what my legal counsel has talked to me about.
04:20Well, my legal counsel would differ with that.
04:23And I will likely not vote for you if you cannot commit to do that.
04:27Now, let me go on to one other thing.
04:29SAMHSA has hosted a system called the Drug Abuse Warning Network to monitor addiction-related visits to emergency departments across
04:37the country.
04:37This system has provided us with critical insight into where overdoses are rising across the country
04:43and has helped us direct resources to get people into recovery and prevent overdose deaths.
04:49One, are you familiar with this program?
04:52Two, are you aware that the program was shut down last year?
04:55And three, will you reinstate the Drug Abuse Warning Network if you're confirmed?
05:00Senator, so I was not, I'm not aware.
05:02I'm not up to speed.
05:03I've been here for five months.
05:04I'm not up to speed on every program.
05:05What I don't want to do is speak to anything that I'm not fully clear about,
05:09so I would need to get briefed on that to come up with that.
05:11And then what I promise to do is put the best policies, procedures, and practices in place
05:15to give the best mental health and addiction care to the people in the country.
05:19Okay, this is...
05:19And I look forward to working with you.
05:21This is an early warning system.
05:2360 hospitals across the country.
05:24It's been very effective, so I hope we can reinstate it.
05:29Subscribe to One India and never miss an update.
05:34Download the One India app now.
Comments

Recommended