00:10.
00:30.
00:30.
00:30.
00:31.
00:31.
00:31.
00:31.
00:31.
00:31.
00:32.
00:32.
00:32.
00:33.
00:33.
00:35.
00:35.
00:36.
00:36.
00:36.
00:36.
00:37.
00:37.
00:37.
00:37.
00:39.
00:41.
00:41.
00:41.
00:41.
00:41.
00:41.
00:41.
00:41.
00:41.
00:41.
00:41.
00:42.
00:42.
00:44.
00:44.
00:44.
00:44.
00:44.
00:45.
00:45.
00:45.
00:45.
00:46.
00:50.
00:50.
00:50.
00:50.
00:50.
00:50.
00:50.
00:52.
00:52.
00:52.
00:52.
00:52.
00:52.
00:52.
00:54.
00:54.
00:55.
00:55.
00:55.
00:55.
00:55.
00:55.
00:55.
00:55.
00:55.
00:57.
00:58.
00:58.
00:58.
00:58.
00:58.
00:59.
00:59.
00:59.
00:59.
00:59.
00:59.
00:59.
00:59.
00:59.
00:59.
01:00.
01:00.
01:00.
01:01.
01:01.
01:02.
01:02.
01:04.
01:04.
01:05.
01:05.
01:05.
01:06.
01:06.
01:09.
01:31to abstract arithmetic neither can such duty be performed in the shadows of absence
01:42nor from legal impediments as the elected representatives of the Filipino people
01:49your honor's mandate in my humble opinion demands a commonsensical interpretation of
01:56the Constitution indeed meaningful adjudication requires active participation in the search for truth and fairness
02:07dagdag pa ni panganiban ang mga senador na hindi nakakadalo sa impeachment trial dahil sa pagdatago
02:13na sa ibang bansa legally detained hospitalized at absent ay hindi mapag-aaralan ang mga dokumento
02:19hindi maririnig ang mga testimonya at hindi maoobserbahan ang demeanor ng mga testigo
02:24sinabi naman ni retired Chief Justice Reynato Puno na ang pariralang two-thirds of all members sa konstitusyon
02:31ay nagbibigay sa senator judges na right to consider
02:34article 11 section 36 should have simply stated that the number of votes to convict is 16 period
02:50but article 11 section 36 did not say so
02:57instead the language used a fraction
03:04it says two-thirds of all members of the senate
03:12by using two-thirds
03:17the number of votes to convict
03:20will have to move
03:24depending on certain factors
03:29but more than that
03:31your honors
03:32a strict
03:34stand-alone
03:36literal interpretation
03:38of article 11 section 36
03:42may result
03:45in absurdities
03:47and may result
03:50in injustices
03:53which will defeat
03:56the purpose
03:57of the constitution
03:59pero para kay retired Associate Justice Adolfo Ascuna
04:02dapat manatili sa two-thirds ang kabuuan bilang ng lahat ng mga miyembro ng Senado ang voting threshold
04:08kabilang ang mga senador ang hindi nakabuo ng lahat ng impeachment days hanggat na nun pa ito bilang Sen. Judge
04:14paliwanag niya
04:15paliwanag niya
04:15maaari namang basahin ng mga absent ng Sen. Judge
04:18the transcript ang testimonya ng mga witnesses
04:21samantala
04:21ayon naman kay Spokesperson for the Prosecution Representative Zia Alonto Adyong
04:26na mahalaga ang sinabi ng Ascuna na kailangan muna mag-took oath ang mga senador
04:30bago maging Sen. Judges at bumoto sa conviction o akwital sa impeachment
04:34kinwalify niya
04:36with the presumption that that
04:39senator judge
04:40took his
04:41his or her oath
04:42kasi yun ang qualifier doon eh
04:44you cannot be a judge
04:46if you do not even
04:47took your oath
04:48because you have to convert
04:50the legislative function of the Senate
04:52into a court
04:54no?
04:55so part of that
04:56is a requirement
04:58in the constitution
04:59for the senator
05:00to take their oath
05:02before they can even be considered
05:04as you know
05:06sitting judges
05:07matatandaang hindi nakapanumpa
05:09sa Sen. Ronald Bato de la Rosa
05:11bilang senator judge sa impeachment trial
05:13laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte
05:15nakataktang sumalang sa oral argument
05:17sa prosecution at depensa
05:18patungkol sa voting threshold sa September 23
05:21samantala
05:22ipinasabina para tumistigo
05:23sa susunod na linggo
05:25si na Davao City Mayor Sebastian Duterte
05:27Securities and Exchange Commission Director
05:29Atty. Gerardo Del Rosario
05:31at iba pang individual
05:32Velco Stodio
05:34para sa bayan
Comments