- 3 months ago
An India Today Mood of The Nation survey conducted in partnership with C Voter captures public sentiment on the Indian economy. The poll reveals that 47.2% of respondents rate the NDA government's economic performance as outstanding or good, while 28.6% rate it as poor or very poor and 18.4% as average. On policy beneficiaries, 55.7% believe big business benefits the most, compared to 8.1% for farmers, 7.4% for the salaried class, 6.4% for small businesses, and 5.5% for daily wage earners. Unemployment emerges as the biggest economic concern at 22.7%, followed by price rise at 18.1%, farm distress at 7.3%, family income poverty at 5.4%, and corruption at 4.6%. When comparing leadership, 47.3% prefer Narendra Modi's handling of the economy compared to 43.5% for Manmohan Singh, showing a decline from earlier ratings. Panelists SC Garg, Shankar Iyer, and Harsh Gupta Madhusudan discuss the data, analyzing inflation, GDP growth numbers, structural reforms, job creation, and external economic challenges.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:18Hello and welcome once again to the India Today Mood of the Nation Tracker Survey,
00:23biannual survey brought to you in partnership with CBOTA, the poll agency that tracks the
00:31sentiment in the country on various hot button issues. One of the issues that has concerned a
00:38number of people in recent months is the state of the economy. Therefore, we decided to have a
00:45separate Mood of the Nation where we will analyze the data and the numbers with experts. The Mood of
00:52the Nation on the state of the economy at the moment. Joining me on the show, S.C. Garg, author
00:59and former finance and economic affairs secretary, Shankar Iyer, political economy analyst, author,
01:06columnist and Harsh Gupta Madhusudan, fund manager, Ionic Wealth by Angel One. Good to have all three
01:13of you on the show. I'm going to kick start with the with the big numbers. Remember, this is a
01:18poll
01:18done by CBOTA, more than one lakh respondents done over the last month, along with tracking voter
01:26sentiment over this period. Okay, how would you rate the NDA government's handling of the economy?
01:35That's the direct question we posed. As per this, outstanding or good is 47.2 percent,
01:44average is 18.4 percent, poor or very poor is 28.6. So, it's roughly evenly divided, good and
01:55outstanding 47 percent and about 46 percent are saying poor or very poor or average. Who benefited
02:03most from the NDA government's economic policies? And here is a warning signal to the government.
02:1155.7 percent believe in this poll that big business is benefiting the most from the NDA government's
02:20policies. Farmers only 8.1 percent, salaried class 7.4 percent, small businesses 6.4 percent,
02:30daily wage earners are benefiting the most, only 5.5 percent seem to suggest. So, clearly,
02:37a large number of people believe big business is the major beneficiary, not small businesses,
02:43not daily wage earners, not salaried employees. What is the biggest problem India's economy is facing
02:51currently? Unemployment is at 22.7 percent, price rise inflation 18.1 and in most such polls you'll find
03:01price rise usually there at the top. Farm distress 7.3 percent, family income, poverty 5.4 percent.
03:11I also want to put a figure of corruption 4.6 percent is what many people believe is a concern.
03:19I'm going to give a tracker of how it's changed over the months but I want initial remarks from my
03:26guests starting with you Subhash Garg. Do you see any warning signals in these numbers I have thrown
03:33out because on the overall handling of the economy it's even Stevens but when it comes to specific
03:39issues like who benefits the most a large number of people believe big business benefiting more than
03:45small businesses. What stands out for you in these numbers?
03:49I think the clear message one gets is that the economy is not being handled very well in the sense
03:57that an overwhelming majority of the people don't think that this is doing very well. Of course,
04:05there is an average number of people around 45 percent or so who say it's fine. But this big message
04:13that which is consistently coming for many years now that's the big business which is benefiting
04:20from the government policies and the programs and the people who are supposed to be beneficiaries of
04:27the government's redistribution welfare programs are just very very marginal and they're declining.
04:34I think that is a very very powerful and very much concerning kind of message for the government to my
04:42mind.
04:46Yeah, but at the same time just to say Mr. Garg 47 percent still believe that the handling is good
04:52or outstanding and remember the BJP in our surveys is consistently along with the NDA scoring about 43 percent
05:00of the vote as well. So, if you're an NDA voter, you still seem to believe Mr. Modi is doing
05:05government
05:06is doing a decent job. It's the sort of anti-BJP voters or the anti-Modi voters who seem to
05:12overwhelmingly
05:12believe that the handling has been poor. So, even on the economy, opinion is divided, Mr. Garg.
05:19Quite right. So, this gels quite well with the people's overwhelmingly voting behavior. If many
05:28people still believe that the BJP is the preferred party for being elected or for being voted, they
05:38tend to also give the economy also from that point of view. It's difficult for the people to separate
05:47the political preferences from economic preferences in this kind of surveys. If they were able to do it,
05:57in my judgment, on the economy, the judgment should be very clearly differentiating. It should be
06:05somewhere close to 70-75 percent if we were to believe that most people believe that the government
06:12is doing well economically. You know, the point Shankara here is that there have been several
06:21surveys which have put the BJP's performance in the past at over 50 percent. If I look at, for example,
06:27in August 2024, the numbers were much better. So, there has been a slippage from 52.1 percent then
06:34now to 47.2 in terms of handling of the economy. Do you believe that there is any cause of
06:41concern,
06:41particularly this belief that this is now a government that does more for big business
06:48than small businesses?
06:52Well, Rajiv, two points. One, the survey shows up a very interesting picture of the Indian economy.
06:59If you look at who's benefiting the top income owners or wealth owners are benefiting that 55 percent
07:07is quite a number to sort of work with. There is a difference between being business friendly and
07:14market friendly and governments have consistently struggled with the definition.
07:18So, if you split the economy, the political economy of India into three parts, the top half seems to be
07:24gaining, the middle doesn't seem to have a view, and the bottom is living off welfare or schemes or proposals.
07:32But to your point, whether the economy is being handled well or not, let's listen to the voices from the
07:41market.
07:41So, in the last one month, six CEOs of FMCG companies have been changed.
07:50The FMCG index is one of the worst performing index on the market.
07:56There is a very peculiar view in the inflation figures where the wholesale price is much higher,
08:03or almost twice that of the consumer price index.
08:07If you look at the performance of the nifty FMCG index, it is among the worst performers.
08:15Even today, the market has shot up. The IP index has done badly.
08:20And if you look at the protests on the street and the welfare announced by the government,
08:26there is a cause for concern. How good is the economy? We will know when the manifestos for UP,
08:34Uttarakhand and Punjab are launched. But on the face of it, even a 47% mark is not good enough
08:44for
08:44a government that has been in majority for 12 years and has no challenge.
08:52If you look at the response from investors, FDI, FDI net investment, that tells you a different picture.
09:02If you look at foreign investors' investments in the stock market, that tells you a different story.
09:11If you look at the rupee, it tells you a story. So we cannot, I mean, let me put it
09:17this way,
09:17to borrow from a Hollywood headline, it's complicated. And the government cannot say,
09:23Hossana, people have to recognize that there is a problem underlying the economy. The Nipi Ayok's
09:30report on employment, on graduate unemployment is another picture. So I would say that this
09:38is a cautionary tale for the government to sort of appreciate. You know, there is an old saying,
09:46Rajdeep, that if you live in the hall of mirrors, you will be perpetually blinded. The signals from
09:52outside suggests that there is much work to be done.
09:59Harsh Padusudhan, you want to pick up from what Shankar Iyer said. Do you believe that the government
10:05for much too long is projecting that sabkut changa hai, that, you know, all is well, we are moving
10:12towards a Viksit Bharat, five trillion economy. But there are concerns on the ground increasingly,
10:17particularly when it comes to how do you provide productive jobs? How do you raise income levels
10:23of a majority of Indians? Are these issues that the government now needs to confront squarely?
10:29And is that the signal this poll is sending out?
10:34So, Rajdeep, I think we have to take all polling with a pinch of salt. In the US, a lot
10:38of similar polls
10:39happen. When the president changes, Republicans suddenly find the economy to be good, and Democrats
10:45find the economy to be not so good, and vice versa. Even in RBI polls, you know, inflation would
10:51constantly come at three, four percent, and people would expect inflation at nine or 10 percent. So,
10:56there is a bit of an art and science to find the nuances from a survey and what it is
11:02telling.
11:03What is very interesting to me from your survey was the price rise concern, which went from around 27 percent,
11:10if you could show that on the screen, to about 18 percent. Because you can see that most of the
11:14concerns are broadly in the same range as they were in 2022 and 23. I mean, unemployment 25 to 23,
11:24that is within statistical noise, so I would not take that very seriously. The other ones are all also
11:29five, seven, six in the same range. But price rise has fallen from 27 to 18. And we can see
11:34that in
11:35the data. I mean, this year is a bit of an exception because of the Iran war and what Shankar
11:39mentioned
11:39in terms of WPI being finally higher than CPI. But the last three years average on inflation CPI is
11:463.2 percent, which is below the 4 percent target. So, it seems like there is a bit of a
11:52lag. Of course,
11:53if you ask people, you know, has your life been improved better or big business life, as you saw,
11:59that 55 percent number is more or less consistent over the last four or five years. So, a lot of
12:04these surveys are also how you frame the questions. I think the economy's actual performance has to be
12:09judged not on surveys, but on actual numbers. So, on 31st August, which is only three days from now,
12:16we will get Q1 GDP growth numbers, right? So, I mentioned the inflation numbers,
12:20the real GDP year-on-year number for Q1 will be with us very soon. We are increasingly every
12:27month we are getting current account and trade data. So, I think given the things that have
12:32happened in the world from the pandemics to wars, the crude prices going up, and the biggest trade
12:38war in 100 years, the fact that India has had around seven to eight percent real GDP growth rate
12:43for the last three to four years, and inflation in the three to four percent, current account deficit
12:49almost always below one percent, this year will be slightly higher, shows a very solid, rock solid
12:56macro. I fully appreciate and agree with Shankar's concerns on net FDI, which have been very low. I
13:03mean, these are part of the global cycles on dollar and AI. Gross FDI numbers have been close to 95
13:08billion dollars or record numbers. The net numbers was very, very low. So, it seems to me that a lot
13:14of
13:14the India data on the external front, the rupee or the FDI, FII, is not just an endogenous function,
13:20it's also in part an exogenous function. The domestic numbers look by and large to be fine,
13:26and if you kind of use that art and science of going through these surveys, it does not seem
13:33incrementally better for the government, you're right, to go from 52 to 47 has to have some political
13:38economy concerns, and I'm not a political expert to see that. But from the data on inflation, unemployment,
13:44and the real data that we are seeing as market professionals, and of course, the earnings that
13:48have come out this quarter, ex-OMC, the earnings of corporate India were quite good. It looks like a
13:53balanced picture that is going in the right direction. I think the RBI's measures on 5th June
13:59will stabilize the external account on the rupee. We are close to have seen our 80 billion dollars.
14:04It's a short-term mandate, but it's nonetheless something that was required given the external
14:09front situation that was developing. I think the economy is on a good footing right now.
14:19That's an important point that Harsh just made because when I compare it to Jan to August now,
14:25when we did the last tracker, we've had global headwinds, the war in the Gulf, the Strait of Hormuz
14:30being closed. Given all that, you could argue that you would have expected a substantial
14:38decline possibly in growth numbers. That hasn't happened. Inflation is more or less under control,
14:44or certainly the survey also suggests people are not suggesting that inflation is top of the mind
14:50at the moment. Given all that, do you believe the government could well claim we've managed to contain
14:56the global headwinds? See, I think the people who are surveyed in this survey are essentially,
15:08to my mind, not very well clued on on the economic issues. They are general voters, kind of thing.
15:16And there is a designer issue. If you look at the issues, which are uppermost in the minds of the
15:25people, the numbers you displayed for the five ones, total up to only 58. Then there are many other
15:33issues which have, so it looks that the surveyed person has been asked to pick up what is the best
15:40or what is the most concerning issue in their opinion. And there are 48 percent voters saying
15:47other issues. So if you pick up one, then you tend to make judgmental error that what do you
15:53want to say as the uppermost? So a price rise of 23 percent of people or 18 percent people picking
16:01up
16:02or unemployment, 23 percent people picking up as the biggest concern. Actually, if you ask them
16:11to rate three or four for each one is asked for that, then you may probably find unemployment being
16:20mentioned by more than 80 percent people. So I don't think these surveys actually can…
16:26No, I take your point, Mr. Garg. In fact, I would say maybe we need a survey of the top
16:35100 market
16:36investors. We need surveys of those in the MSME sector and maybe those surveys will give us a better
16:43sense of what is the mood on the ground. I take your point. I just want to just flag one
16:48more interesting
16:49little aspect. We asked in every tracker who managed the economy better, UPA versus NDA,
16:58Manmohan Singh or Narendra Modi. As of now, Narendra Modi in August 2026, 47.3 percent say he managed the
17:06economy better. Contrast that with Manmohan Singh, 43.5 percent. But significantly,
17:13in 2024, 57.4 percent said Modi was managing the economy better than Manmohan Singh.
17:21Now, that's numbers come down to 47. So there's almost a 10 percent decline in those who believe
17:28Mr. Modi handled it better than Manmohan Singh. Manmohan Singh was as low as 34.9 percent in August
17:34versus 43.5 percent. So Shankar, there's a sense that much like Manmohan Singh faced in the second
17:42term of the UPA, there are some tougher questions that are now being asked of the Modi government in
17:48Modi 3.0 compared to the previous two governments. And therefore, Manmohan Singh also is being looked at
17:55by some particularly with some sense of nostalgia. But broadly, do you believe Modi 3.0 has faced far
18:02more difficult economic conditions than the first two terms?
18:07Well, definitely, every regime has its own context. And particularly, if you look at
18:13this government, it has over the last five years faced the Ukraine war, the COVID pandemic,
18:21the war in the Middle East. All of these are issues. So let me sort of reframe that. I think
18:28the Modi government has been better at managing the exogenous factors, which is the outside issues.
18:36And it has done well to sort of keep the supply chain for fuel, etc. going. It has kept the
18:44supply
18:45chain for fertilizers and food grain availability going. Post the pandemic, it introduced the
18:52free ration thing. And so, and the state governments, the parties have also introduced the larki
18:59bhai, whatever the naming would be. So there has been an income support initiative that has been
19:08implemented at different levels. So you have income support for the woman voter, you have income
19:13support for the farmer, you have income support for the rural unemployed, you have income support
19:18for the base of the voters, the voting base. What you don't have is a credible plan for
19:28those who are holding that. I mean, I'm not saying this, the GTI has data that is sort of
19:36questioning whether enough has been done on the employment. My problem, my problem with the government
19:42is simply this. Has it done all that it could do to raise resources? So if you take out the
19:502.87
19:51lakh note that the RBI has given to the government, would its fiscal deficit or fiscal
19:59austerity look better or worse? Would the government have done better to
20:06divest from PSUs which are doing well? Does the government need to own 80 and 89 percent of shares?
20:15Surely nobody is going to run away with LIC, even if there are conspiracy theories. Should it not
20:21delist some more of those shares? Those are the questions. If you raise the resources, you will
20:26find the programs. As of now, across state and central government, there are roughly 25 lakh vacant
20:34posts. And these are not posts about which are just sitting on the sideline. These are posts for
20:39police. These are posts for teachers. These are posts for health care professionals. Those posts are not
20:45being filled. Now, if you ask this question in parliament, you would be said that this is a state
20:50subject. Now, obviously, now, even if you have 850 or 900 or 1200 MPs, this question will receive the
20:57same answer. So what are we doing about the oversight on governance? Those are the questions. Forget the
21:04central public sector units, Rajdeep. The state public sector units, which in quite a number,
21:09don't even file their returns. So these are issues. How do you manage? There are two task forces for
21:15regulatory reforms. Where is it? Do I have a situation where I have less permissions than yesterday?
21:26Suppose I want to build a power plant or build a hospital. If 10 years back or five years back,
21:33I was asked to get 90 clearances or 110 clearances. Is it at 50 now? Is it at 30 now?
21:40Have we improved
21:41the process? Is it less time consuming? So the proof of the pudding really is the introduction of the
21:49deemed clearance principle. I will leave it at that.
21:54Right. You know, Harsh, quick one minute on that. Do you believe, therefore, that if this
22:02comparison between Modi years and Manmohan Singh years, Manmohan Singh years also, the second term,
22:08there were lots of global headwinds that he faced. The Modi years have also faced that. Do you believe,
22:14as Shankar is saying, that we've handled the external shocks better than we've handled internal situation,
22:20that we still haven't. Many of the states are facing huge revenue deficits and there is little
22:25sign of any change there. A quick answer. No, very quickly, I think I agree more
22:32disinvestment can be done. This year, I think with IDBI, we'll finally cross the stated number,
22:38which we had not done for many years. Nonetheless, fiscal devolution to states have increased over the
22:42years. So I don't think there is any automatic way to devolve more revenue to the states per se.
22:49So that is about the state capacity of states. More generally on the unemployment point, I see
22:53there's a very interesting piece in Financial Times just last week. There are 350 million gig workers
22:59in China. So China used to publish an unemployment rate for the graduate youth, and then it stopped
23:05publishing the number and changed it. So you see, unemployment is not a blue collar problem in
23:10India. It's a white collar problem where people want government permanent jobs in an office setting
23:16immediately after graduating. Now, we do not have those kind of jobs. No economy has those kind of jobs.
23:22So unemployment also needs to be understood the way in terms of income generation and the kind of
23:28permanent job security that people naturally desire. They are not always in consonance. So I'll just simply
23:34say that, of course, Dr. Manmohan Singh's term, whenever there are economic headwinds, some nostalgia is
23:40normal again. People have that with Bill Clinton in the US every now and then. My only point is,
23:46the structural reforms that have happened in terms of GST, IBC, RERA, etc., with all of their quibbles,
23:53such structural reforms were perhaps not done in UPA 1 and UPA 2. Maybe they were not a majority
23:59government. Maybe there were coalition politics, political imperatives there. But that was more of a
24:05global capital kind of story, mostly UPA 1 and then UPA 2, as you rightly mentioned, at headwinds.
24:11Whereas in NDA 1 and 2, there were structural reforms. NDA 3 has seen a lot of headwinds. And I
24:16think let us see what happens in the coming years. I… Okay, I'm going to leave it there. As I
24:24said,
24:24it's fascinating to see how these economic concerns will play out politically. Will that affect election and
24:32voter behavior? And is there a sense that the feel-good factor, which perhaps existed a few
24:38years ago, is not there at the moment? And perhaps that's one of the warning signals that the government
24:44is facing. It's an issue of perception as much as it is of the reality on the ground. The perception
24:51that there isn't that kind of feel-good about the economy at the moment. I want to leave it there.
24:57Thank my guests for joining us on this Moon of the Nation Economy special. Thanks for watching.