- 2 days ago
Category
🦄
CreativityTranscript
00:00Autumn, 1929. A servant finds a woman alone in a garden, arms wrapped around an old tree,
00:08dazed, hours after the last of her furniture is sold to strangers. Her name was Princess
00:14Victoria of Prussia, Queen Victoria's granddaughter, Kaiser Wilhelm II's own sister, born into
00:22the most powerful family in Europe. She had waited all afternoon for one of them to come
00:27and stop the sale. Not one of them did. This is the story of a woman her family could always
00:34find time to refuse and never quite enough to save. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to Crown Files.
00:43There is a kind of loneliness history rarely bothers to record, not the loneliness of being
00:49unknown, but the loneliness of being watched by everyone and helped by no one. Tonight's story
00:56begins in one of the most famous families Europe has ever produced. At its head stood two names
01:03every student of history still knows. Queen Victoria of England, who gave her children and grandchildren
01:10to nearly every throne on the continent, and earned for it the title the Grandmother of Europe.
01:17And her grandson, a young man who would one day rule as Kaiser Wilhelm II of Germany,
01:23and lead that empire into the war that ended it. This is not their story.
01:30It belongs to the woman who stood just behind them in every family portrait, Victoria's favourite
01:37granddaughter, Wilhelm's own sister. Born into the golden nursery of a dynasty that seemed,
01:44in the 1860s, as though it would last forever. She was raised to believe that a name like hers
01:51came with protection, that the family who gave her a title would also, when it mattered,
01:57give her a life. She would spend the next 63 years discovering exactly how much that belief was worth.
02:07Because in that family, in that world, love was never simply love. It was a matter of state. A question
02:16to be weighed by chancellors and emperors, granted or refused by men who never had to live with the answer
02:22they gave. She would ask permission to be happy twice in her life. Twice, the answer would cost her
02:31everything. Her name was Princess Victoria of Prussia. The people who loved her best called her Moretta.
02:40Her story turns, more than once, on a letter. One letter arrives too late to matter. Another she writes
02:49herself, in her final year, to a man who will not bother to read it. What lies between those two
02:58letters
02:58is the real subject of tonight's film, not scandal, not politics, but the particular arithmetic of a life
03:06in which every door marked happiness was guarded by someone else's permission.
03:12She began as the most protected woman in Europe.
03:18She would end it sharing a rented room with a woman who had once been her own servant.
03:25Tonight we go back to where it started, to a palace in Potsdam, in the spring of 1866,
03:33when a fifth daughter was born into an empire that did not yet know it was dying.
03:38On the 24th of May, 1866, her grandmother's 47th birthday, an infant princess was carried into a chapel
03:47in Potsdam to be baptized. The King of Prussia himself held her.
03:53Princess Marie of Hohenzollern stood at his side.
03:58Word of the christening would reach Queen Victoria in England within days,
04:02carried by the kind of letter that, in this particular family, seemed never to stop moving between London and Berlin.
04:09They named her Friederike Amalia Wilhelmina Victoria. It was a name built for state documents, not for a nursery.
04:21The people who loved her simply called Her Maretta.
04:26Her mother was Victoria Princess Royal, Queen Victoria's eldest daughter, married at 17 into a
04:33Prussian court that never quite forgave her the marriage. She had brought with her an English liberalism
04:40the Berlin aristocracy found faintly scandalous. A belief that a person's worth was not only their
04:47bloodline and that love, given a fair chance, ought to be allowed to matter. Behind her back,
04:54the court called her Die Engländerin, the Englishwoman. She raised her children on the same conviction that
05:01made her an outsider. The household she built at the Neus Palais ran by the standards of European royalty
05:08on unusually warm lines. There were English governesses. There were long afternoons in the gardens at Bornstedt,
05:16where the children were encouraged to run rather than pose. There was a father, Crown Prince Frederick William,
05:23known within the family simply as Fritz, who was gentle by temperament and progressive by conviction,
05:31a soldier who privately hoped he would never have to use the army he commanded.
05:36Into that household, eight children were born, though not all of them lived to grow up in it.
05:42Maretta was the fifth, younger than Wilhelm, the heir, younger than Charlotte, sharp-tongued and quick to gossip,
05:49younger than Henry, who would spend his life at sea, older than Waldemar, who would die of diphtheria
05:57before he turned 11, and Sophie, and the youngest, Margaret, the sister who would, four decades later,
06:04stand outside a hospital room in Bonn and not be allowed inside. None of that had happened yet. In the
06:121870s,
06:13they were simply a large, loud, English-inflected family in a Prussian court that regarded them
06:20all with faint suspicion. Maretta absorbed her mother's conviction more completely than any of
06:25her siblings. She grew up between two very different inheritances. From her Hohenzollern father's side came
06:33duty, hierarchy, the cold formality of rank. From her mother came the opposite instinct entirely,
06:41the quiet, dangerous idea that a princess might be permitted to choose. By the time she was 15,
06:49she had become the tallest of the three younger sisters, which in the arithmetic of a royal household
06:54meant one thing. She was now old enough to be considered for marriage.
07:00Her mother and grandmother had already settled, in their own minds, on the man they wanted for her.
07:07His name was Alexander of Battenberg. He was the reigning prince of Bulgaria,
07:13nine years Maretta's senior, and, by nearly every surviving account, extraordinarily handsome.
07:21He first visited the Prussian court in 1881 at her mother's invitation, ostensibly to be looked
07:29over as a prospective match. Maretta was 15 that year and merely curious. When he returned the following
07:38spring, something in her had changed entirely. She was, in the words of one biographer, thoroughly
07:45and helplessly in love. For a while it even seemed possible. Her parents approved. Her grandmother wrote
07:53from Windsor with unmistakable enthusiasm. Alexander, for his part, appeared willing enough, but a Hohenzollern
08:02princess did not simply fall in love and marry. Her grandfather, the elder Emperor Wilhelm I, and his
08:10Chancellor Otto von Bismarck watched the courtship with open alarm. Alexander's rule in Bulgaria had already
08:18provoked the Tsar of Russia, and a marriage tying him to the German imperial family, Bismarck feared,
08:25would provoke Russia further still. Her own paternal grandmother, Empress Augusta, put the family's
08:32opposition rather more bluntly. As long as she lived, she was reported to have said, a Hohenzollern princess
08:39would never marry a Battenberg. Even inside her own household, the match found no shortage of quiet enemies.
08:48Her eldest sister, Charlotte, who had never much cared for Maretta's happiness at the best of times, took to spreading
08:55gossip about her love life through the court. Gossip precise enough and cruel enough that Maretta eventually told her
09:03grandmother she no longer wished to marry at all. It did not last. Nothing, it seemed, could make her stop
09:11wanting Alexander. For seven years, whether she would be allowed to marry the man she loved stopped being a
09:19private matter at all. It became, quite literally, a question of foreign policy, debated in ministries,
09:27weighed against the temper of a Russian court, an ocean away from anything Maretta herself had a voice in.
09:34Bismarck tried more than once to steer her elsewhere. In 1885, the King of Portugal offered his own son,
09:43Crown Prince Carlos, as an alternative, on the single condition that Maretta convert to Catholicism.
09:51She refused. A year later, Carlos married someone else. Maretta, heartbroken over a match she had never
09:59even wanted in the first place, was sent across the channel to spend the summer with her grandmother.
10:05It was there, in that long English summer, that she wrote to Queen Victoria the kind of letter a 20
10:12-year-old
10:12rights when she has run out of other people to tell the truth to. My thoughts are not here tonight,
10:19she wrote, but far away where they always are. You know where, dearest Grandmama.
10:27By 1887, the waiting had cost Alexander something too. Under mounting pressure from every direction,
10:34Russia, Bismarck, a Bulgarian throne he could no longer safely hold, he abdicated as Prince of Bulgaria
10:42in September of 1886. The following year, while Maretta and her parents travelled to London for her
10:50grandmother's Golden Jubilee, and then on to the warm coast of San Remo, word reached her mother that
10:57Alexander himself had all but given up. He wrote, asking to be released from any claim on Maretta's
11:04hand, without any regard to himself, as he put it, as though the kindest thing left for him to do
11:11was to stop being the reason she suffered. Her mother did not accept the release. Neither in her heart did
11:19Maretta. They had come to San Remo that winter for another reason entirely. Fritz's voice had gone
11:26hoarse and would not clear, and the doctors gathered around him spoke to each other more than they spoke
11:31to his family. According to Maretta's own later account, it was there, on the Italian coast, in the
11:39last months before he became emperor, that her father personally promised her his blessing, regardless of
11:46what Bismarck or Wilhelm or anyone else had to say about it. He would have very little time left to
11:53make
11:53that promise good. The hoarseness that had followed Fritz from Berlin to San Remo did not clear.
12:00By the time the family understood what it actually was, a cancer of the larynx, already advanced, there was
12:08very little left for the doctors to offer, beyond honesty, and not all of them were willing to offer even
12:14that.
12:16German physicians and English physicians argued over his diagnosis for months,
12:21each side reluctant to be the one who confirmed what the other already suspected.
12:27Fritz knew anyway. A man does not need a medical degree to understand what it means when he can
12:35no longer make himself heard. On the 9th of March 1888, his own father, the old emperor Wilhelm I, died
12:44in Berlin.
12:46Fritz, too ill by then to speak above a whisper, became German emperor Frederick III. He would hold the
12:54title for 99 days. It was during those 99 days, at the Neues Palais and later at Charlottenburg,
13:03that Moretta watched her father do something almost no one in her family had managed in seven years,
13:10use the only leverage he had left. He could no longer command an army, negotiate with Bismarck,
13:18or outlive the men working to keep his daughter from the oak. The marriage she wanted.
13:25But he could still hold a pen. And on the 12th of April, 1888, with his voice already gone,
13:34his throat too damaged to form the words aloud, Frederick III wrote by hand to his eldest son and heir.
13:46Should your mother or myself be suddenly called to depart this life, he wrote, I hereby wish to state
13:54definitely that I give my full consent to the marriage of your second sister with the ex-prince
14:01of Bulgaria, Prince Alexander of Battenburg. I charge you, by the love you bear your father,
14:10to carry out this, my wish. He signed it simply, your loving father.
14:17It was not a request. It was the closest thing to an order a dying man could still give,
14:23written to a son who was, within two months, going to inherit the power to grant it.
14:30He did not live to find out whether that son would.
14:35On the 15th of June, 1888, Frederick III died. From Balmoral, Queen Victoria wrote to her own
14:44widowed daughter the moment the telegram reached her. A letter with no diplomacy in it at all,
14:50only the plain language of a mother trying to reach a child across an ocean.
14:54Darling, darling unhappy child, she wrote, I clasp you in my arms, and to a heart that bleeds,
15:02I can't write what I feel. I can't collect my thoughts. I feel stunned.
15:08It was, for once, a letter that arrived exactly when it was needed. It simply could not do very much.
15:14Moretta's mother, now the dowager Empress Frederick, a title with considerably less power attached to it
15:21than the one she had held 99 days earlier, gathered her three youngest daughters and withdrew to Bornstadt,
15:28a modest farmhouse outside Potsdam that stood in almost comic contrast to the palace they had just
15:35left. There was no court there to manage, no chancellor to negotiate with. There was only a
15:43mother trying to shelter three grown daughters from a brother who now controlled all of their futures,
15:50and very little left with which to do it. Wilhelm, now Kaiser Wilhelm II, 29 years old and emperor of
15:59a
16:00nation he had waited his entire life to rule, moved through the Noyes Palais within days of his father's
16:07death, ordering every room searched for his mother's private correspondence. He wanted the letters his
16:15English-born mother had exchanged with her family, letters he suspected of undermining a court he now
16:22intended to run very differently than his father had. He did not find them. His mother, widowed less than a
16:30week, had already removed every page. What Wilhelm did find waiting for him was his father's letter about
16:38Moretta. In November of 1888, five months after her father's death, seven years after she first fell in love
16:46with Alexander of Battenburg, Moretta made one final appeal to her brother in person. She asked him
16:53directly to honour what their father had written. Wilhelm listened and Wilhelm refused. The reasoning he gave
17:02was in its essentials the same reasoning Bismarck had offered for seven years. A marriage to Alexander
17:09still risked antagonising Russia, still threatened to complicate a delicate balance of European alliances
17:16that a new Kaiser, only months into his reign, was not willing to disturb for the sake of one sister's
17:22happiness. Bismarck, for his part, had never much cared for the English influence he believed Moretta's
17:30mother had instilled in all her daughters, and he made no secret of being glad to see it checked.
17:37Whatever Alexander of Battenburg had once been to her, a prince, a possibility, the answer to seven years
17:46of waiting, he now became simply the answer she was not permitted to have. He would go on within a
17:53year
17:53to marry an opera singer in Austria. Moretta would not speak to her brother about him again. What she kept
18:00instead was the knowledge of what her father had wanted for her, written in his own hand in the
18:07final month he could still hold a pen, and the knowledge that the man with the power to honour it
18:13had chosen not to. She was 22 years old. She had just learned, in the most permanent way a person
18:21can
18:21learn something, that in her family even a dead man's last wish carried less weight than a chancellor's
18:29calculations. A husband would still need to be found for her. Within two years one was, a man Moretta had
18:38not
18:38chosen and did not love, but who came, at least, with her brother's approval already attached. In November of 1890,
18:48two years after the letter her brother chose not to honour, Moretta married Prince Adolf of Scharmburg
18:55Lippe. There is remarkably little to say about the wedding itself, and that, in its own way, tells the
19:03story better than any detail could. No biographer records what she wore. No letter survives describing her face
19:13that day, the way three separate accounts describe her face on her second wedding day, decades later.
19:22The archives that hold seven years of anguished correspondence about Alexander of Battenberg hold
19:29almost nothing at all about Adolf. He was not unkind, as far as history records. He was not cruel,
19:38not unfaithful in any way that made the newspapers, not a man anyone ever accused of ruining her.
19:46He was simply not the man she had spent seven years fighting for, and Moretta, 24 years old and finally
19:56out of auctions, her family found. Acceptable. Married him with her brother's approval already in hand, which was,
20:05by then, the only kind of approval that had ever mattered. What followed were 26 years that most
20:13accounts of her life pass over in a single sentence. It is worth sitting for a moment in that sentence.
20:2126 years is a length of time longer than the entire courtship with Alexander had felt to her.
20:28It is long enough to grow old in. Long enough that the passionate, headstrong young woman,
20:35who once told her grandmother her thoughts were always far away, grew, quietly and without anyone
20:43documenting exactly when, into a woman the court simply described as dutiful. There were no children,
20:51the biographers record. There were no scandals. There were, as far as anyone can now find, no love
20:59letters worth preserving between husband and wife, which is its own kind of evidence. A life that produces
21:06no letters worth keeping is not necessarily a life without feeling. Sometimes it is simply a life in
21:14which a woman has learned, very thoroughly, not to write down what she feels. The one correspondence she
21:22did keep, faithfully, through those quiet years, was with her youngest sister, Margaret.
21:30Mossie, the baby of the family, married by then to a Hessian landgrave, remained the one relative
21:37Maretta never stopped writing to. Those letters survive still, gathered today in an archive at Fasanerie Palace.
21:46Ordinary letters, the kind sisters write when nothing dramatic is happening, full of small news and small
21:52comforts. It was not much of a life, but it was, for 26 years, a life with at least one
22:00door that reliably
22:02opened when she knocked on it. In 1915, in the middle of a war that would end her brother's empire,
22:10Maretta and Adolf left Berlin for Bonn, where they settled into the Palais Schaumburg, a castle grand
22:17enough that one American newspaper, writing about her years later, would describe her at this point in
22:23her life as 50 years old, but very wealthy and young-looking. It is a strange, almost throwaway detail,
22:32but it is also the last time in the record that anyone describes Maretta as fortunate.
22:39Adolf died the following year, in 1916, at the age of 56, killed by the same war that was already
22:48dismantling the world both of them had been raised to inherit. Maretta was 50 years old. She had spent
22:55more than half her life married to a man history barely bothered to record, and she was now, for the
23:02second time, waiting to find out what her family would allow her to do next. She did not wait long
23:08to ask. Adolf had a nephew, young enough, close enough in the family, that a marriage between them
23:16would have kept Maretta within the same social world she had always known. She went to her brother once
23:23more and asked his permission. Wilhelm refused. No chancellor needed to weigh in this time. No foreign power
23:32stood to be offended. There was no Bismarck left to blame, no Russia to appease, no plausible reason of state
23:40it left to hide behind. It was simply Wilhelm's answer, offered, as far as any surviving account
23:47shows, without much explanation at all. Twenty-eight years earlier, he had refused her a prince because
23:55a marriage might have provoked the Tsar. Now he refused her a nobleman for no recorded reason whatsoever.
24:03The first refusal had at least worn the costume of politics. The second did not bother to wear a
24:10costume at all. Maretta did not fight this one the way she had fought for Alexander. She was fifty years
24:18old.
24:18She had already spent one war of attrition against her own family and lost it decisively. She stayed in Bonn,
24:28in the
24:28castle by the Rhine, a widow with a title and, for the moment, still a fortune. That fortune, however,
24:36no longer meant what it once had. The war that killed Adolf also broke the currency both of them had
24:43trusted
24:43their whole lives. Germany's defeat in 1918 was followed within a few years by an inflation so total
24:53that fortunes built over generations could be reduced to nothing within months. A family's entire
25:00savings by 1923, sometimes worth less than the paper the banknotes were printed on. Maretta did not lose
25:10everything in those years, not yet. But the castle that had once seemed like permanent, unshakable
25:16security began quietly and without any single dramatic event to mark it to feel less permanent
25:24than it had. For eleven years she lived largely alone in it. The empire her brother had ruled
25:31collapsed entirely in that same November of 1918 and Wilhelm, the man who had twice decided who Maretta was
25:41and was not permitted to love, fled into exile in the Netherlands, stripped of the throne he had once
25:48weighed against her happiness so carefully. Whatever power he had once held over her marriages,
25:54he no longer held any power over anything at all. It should have changed something. In one sense it did.
26:02There was no longer an emperor to ask permission of. In another sense it changed nothing whatsoever.
26:10Because by the time Wilhelm's power vanished, Maretta had already spent a lifetime learning what it felt
26:16like to want something and be told, calmly and without apology, that the answer was no. Sometime in the mid
26:25-1920s
26:27running low on money in a way her family's old fortune could no longer quite disguise,
26:34Maretta accepted a paid offer to write her memoirs. She had no way of knowing, as she began setting her
26:41life down on paper, that the story was not yet finished, or that the ending she would eventually
26:48write for herself would arrive from a direction none of her family's chancellors, and none of their
26:55careful calculations about kings and czars had ever thought to guard against.
27:02In the summer of 1927, Maretta opened the gates of Palais Schaumburg to a crowd of university students.
27:10It was, by the standards of her life, a small and unremarkable gesture, the kind of afternoon garden
27:17party a wealthy widow might host for young people from the local university. A way of filling rooms that had
27:23grown very quiet since Adolf's death eleven years earlier. Students from Bonn wandered the grounds in
27:31the July light, and Maretta, sixty-one years old, moved among them as a hostess, not yet as anything else.
27:39Among the guests that day was a twenty-seven-year-old law student who called himself Alexander
27:47Anatolyevich Zubkov. He told her he had once been a baron in Russia, that he had, led the revolution
27:54with nothing, that everything he had once been entitled to had been taken from him by history,
28:01in exactly the way Maretta might have thought that history had a habit of taking things from people
28:07who least expected it. He was Russian, he was charming, and his name, in its familiar form, was Sasha.
28:16It is worth pausing on that name, because history rarely repeats a detail this precisely,
28:22without meaning to say something by it. Forty-five years earlier, the man Maretta had loved,
28:29and been forbidden to marry, went by his own diminutive, Sandro. Now, in a garden in Bonn, a stranger
28:37with the same first name, called by the same kind of nickname, was standing in front of her,
28:42the second Alexander of her life, though this one had walked in through a side door of history,
28:47rather than a throne room. Whether Maretta noticed the echo herself, no letter records. What the record
28:55does show is how quickly she stopped being merely a hostess to him. Within weeks, she was showering
29:01him with gifts. Within two months, he had proposed. Around the university, and soon around Bonn society
29:08more widely, questions about the young Russian had already begun, circulating before Maretta ever heard
29:15them. No one could confirm the barony, he claimed. No one could confirm very much about him at all,
29:22beyond a string of odd jobs, dishwasher, waiter, dancer, occasional film extra, that sat uneasily
29:31beside his talk of a lost estate, and a title stripped from him by revolution. It was the kind
29:38of gossip that, in a smaller decision, might have reached her in time to matter. It reached her anyway.
29:45She did not appear to let it change anything. Her family reacted the way her family had always reacted,
29:52to Maretta's attempts to choose her own happiness, except that this time there was no Bismarck to
30:00consult, no Tsar to appease, no plausible argument dressed up as statecraft. There was only a 61-year-old
30:09widow and a 27-year-old stranger nobody in her circle could vouch for, and a family that was, by
30:17every
30:17account, united in horror. Word of the engagement reached her brother in Dorne, the small Dutch
30:25estate where the former Kaiser had lived in exile since 1918, stripped of an empire, but apparently
30:32not of opinions about who his sister was permitted to marry. He made his disapproval known. It changed
30:39nothing. For possibly the only time in her adult life, Maretta had stopped waiting to hear what
30:45Wilhelm thought. She did not ask her brother this time. She did not write to anyone for permission.
30:52Whatever it had cost her, across 46 years, to keep asking and keep being told no,
30:59she appeared to have finally run out of patience for the asking itself.
31:04On the 19th of November 1927, she married him, first in a civil ceremony at Bond's Town Hall,
31:12as German law required, and then in a Greek Orthodox chapel, where custom and Zubkov's own faith took over.
31:21She wore for that second ceremony the same lace bridal veil her mother had worn nearly 70 years
31:28earlier at her own wedding to Frederick III in 1858, a piece of family lace that had by then survived
31:36an
31:36empire, a war, and a revolution, only to be brought out one more time for a marriage almost no one
31:44in
31:44the family believed in. The chapel was small enough that the empty pews were impossible not to notice.
31:51No brother, no sister, no cousin, aunt, or childhood friend from the golden years at Bornstedt.
31:59Only witnesses, a priest, and a groom. The date was not an accident.
32:05It was the 37th anniversary, to the day, of her wedding to Adolf. No one has ever fully explained
32:14why she chose it, whether it was meant as a private joke at her own expense, a way of folding
32:19one loveless
32:20marriage inside a new one she still believed might be different, or simply the only date that happened
32:26to be free. What is certain is that not a single member of her family came to see her marry
32:33on the
32:33anniversary of a marriage none of them had wanted for her either. To the press that gathered outside,
32:41curious about a Hohenzollern princess marrying a penniless Russian student less than half her age,
32:48Maretta gave an answer that read in the newspapers the following morning, less like scandal and more like
32:54relief. She was, she said, seeking to exchange the title of princess for that of a happy woman.
33:02It is, of everything she has recorded as having said in 63 years, perhaps the most honest sentence
33:09attributed to her. It is also, in hindsight, almost unbearable to read. She renounced her royal rank and
33:18her German citizenship to marry him, gave up in a single afternoon the one inheritance no chancellor,
33:26no Kaiser and no war had ever managed to take from her. For a short while afterward, by the thin
33:34evidence
33:35that survives, she seemed genuinely happy. A woman in her sixties, newly married, telling anyone who would
33:42listen that she had finally found the companionship a lifetime of royal calculation had never allowed
33:49her. Whatever Zubkov actually was, and the truth, as it would soon become clear, bore very little
33:56resemblance to the baron he claimed to be, Maretta walked toward him with both eyes fully open,
34:03believing, believing at sixty-one, that this time the door might actually stay unlocked. She could not have
34:11known, standing in that half-empty chapel in her mother's veil, that she had just married a man whose
34:18only fluency was in the very thing her family had spent her entire life protecting her from, taking something
34:27that was never really his to take. The happiness when it came did not last through the winter.
34:35By the early months of 1928, the young husband who had proposed after two months of acquaintance
34:42had begun spending Maretta's dwindling fortune with the same speed and confidence he had once, used to
34:49describe a Russian barony no one could ever quite locate. There were debts, there were nights he did not
34:56come home. There were, soon enough, headlines. Zubkov's name appearing in the German press, attached to bar
35:04fights, to bounced checks, to a public misconduct serious enough that within months of the wedding,
35:10German authorities deported him from the country entirely. He crossed into Luxembourg. He found work
35:17there almost immediately, in a restaurant willing to make use of exactly the kind of story he told so
35:23well. The owner hung a sign in the front window, where every passer-by could read it.
35:30The emperor's brother-in-law is serving you here. It is worth sitting with that sentence,
35:36the way one sits with a wound. The man Maretta had married, to escape the weight of her own title,
35:43now traded on that same title for tips, in a language of irony he almost certainly did not intend.
35:50In a country his wife had never once visited with him. He was expelled from Luxembourg before long as
35:57well, on charges that mirrored the ones that had gotten him thrown out of Germany. He returned to
36:03Bonn only briefly, long enough, it seems, to be photographed once more beside the woman who was still,
36:11on paper, his wife, before the pattern repeated itself a second time.
36:19Somewhere in the middle of it, a Bonn barmaid became part of the story too, an affair Maretta would
36:26later cite, formally and without much elaboration, as grounds for the divorce she was no longer willing to
36:32delay. By 1929, the fortune that had once made her one of the wealthier widows in the Rhineland was
36:41almost entirely gone. What Zubkov had not spent outright, his creditors were now pursuing through her.
36:48In October of that year, the contents of Palais Schaumburg, furniture, portraits, silver,
36:57the accumulated inheritance of a woman who had once been a Hohenzollern princess,
37:02was sold at public auction to satisfy claims against her totalling, by newspaper estimates at the time,
37:09somewhere near $180,000. She had believed, until very nearly the last hour, that someone would intervene.
37:19According to the Chicago Daily Tribune, Maretta held out hope that her brother,
37:24or some other member of her family, would step in at the final minute and stop the sale before it
37:30happened.
37:30They did not. The auctioneer's gavel fell on the last of it, and no one came.
37:38A servant found her afterward, alone in the garden of the castle that was no longer,
37:43in any meaningful sense, hers, standing with both arms wrapped around the trunk of an old tree,
37:50dazed, as though the tree were the only solid thing left in a life that had just been sold
37:55out from under her, in a single afternoon. She moved, not long after, into a single rented room
38:03in Mehlem, a modest suburb on the edge of Bonn, sharing the space with a woman who had once
38:09worked for her as a servant. There was a certain arithmetic to that arrangement that no one needed
38:15to spell out. The distance between employer and employed had simply collapsed, the way distances tend
38:23to collapse once the money that maintained them disappears. She had one card left to play, and she
38:30tried to play it. She reached out to Zubkov, through lawyers now, not through affection, with an offer to
38:37settle 10,000 marks on him, a little over 2,000 dollars, in exchange for a batch of her own
38:44letters
38:44he was reportedly holding somewhere in Luxembourg. What those letters said, or why she wanted them
38:51back so badly that she would pay for, their return with money she barely had, no source has ever fully
38:58explained. What is certain is that even at the end, even with almost nothing left, Moretta was still
39:06trying to control what the world would be allowed to know about her own heart. In early November of 1929,
39:15she filed for divorce. The petition stated plainly what the marriage had become. Zubkov's conduct,
39:23it read, had left him unable to support his wife, and no true matrimonial union had existed between them
39:30for some time. It was around this same period that her memoir reached bookstores, the ones she had agreed
39:39to write, for money, back when her fortune had first begun to thin. She had written it before the wedding,
39:48before Luxembourg, before the auction, before the rented room in Merlem. She had written it while she still
39:55believed, with the particular conviction of a woman who has waited sixty-one years to be right about
40:01something, that Sasha was the answer, at the very end of a very long question. Its final lines, printed
40:10and bound, and sitting in shop windows the same autumn her furniture was being carried out of Palais
40:16Schaumburg, under a creditor's inventory, read,
40:21I feel that a fresh life has opened out to me, one that, with the graciousness of providence,
40:27will be full of happiness in my newly found companionship. No one could recall the words
40:34and pull them back. They were already in print, in her own name, in her own hand, a promise to
40:41herself
40:42that the world could now read at exactly the moment it stopped being true.
40:47She wrote one more letter that year that survives. It was addressed to Sasha, dated the 13th of July,
40:551929, months before the auction, months before the divorce filing, when the unravelling was already
41:03well, underway but not yet complete. It said, in full, what sixty-three years of careful diplomatic
41:12language had never once allowed her to say to anyone who mattered.
41:18Well, she wrote, such is life. Nothing but disappointments and misery.
41:27No answer to that letter has ever been found. Whether Zubkov read it and chose not to reply,
41:34or never read it at all, the record does not say. Either way, it joined a small, quiet collection.
41:43Her father's letter, decades earlier, asking for a happiness he did not live to see granted.
41:50And now this one, asking for almost nothing at all, and receiving, in return, exactly nothing.
41:58By the first week of November, Moretta was ill. It would not take long for anyone left who was
42:04watching to understand that this time there would be no petition, no memoir, and no letter that could
42:12change what came next. On the 6th of November 1929, a doctor forced his way into a room in Merlem
42:20that no
42:21one outside its four walls had thought to check on in some time. He found a 63-year-old woman,
42:27burning with fever, too weak to have called for help herself, sharing a bed with the former servant who
42:35had become, by then, the only person left in her daily life. She was carried out to Bonn's Hospital of
42:43St. Francis. The diagnosis when it came was pneumonia, the kind of illness that in a healthier body,
42:50in a less exhausted year, might have simply passed. Word reached her family quickly. Word, by then,
42:59always did. Her sister Margaret, the one relative who had never stopped writing back, whose letters
43:06filled an archive at Fasanari Palace with three decades of small, ordinary, faithfully answered news,
43:13travelled to Bonn and arrived at the hospital within days. She was not permitted to see her. No account
43:20fully explains the decision, or whose it actually was. What survives is simply the fact of it. A sister
43:28standing somewhere in that hospital, close enough to be in the building, and a door that stayed close
43:34to her anyway, on instruction, until it no longer mattered whether it opened at all.
43:40In Berlin, or rather, from the modest Dutch estate at Dorne, where he had lived in exile for 11 years,
43:47a spokesman for the former Kaiser Wilhelm II answered questions from the press about whether he intended to
43:54attend his sister's funeral. His attendance, the statement read, was wholly out of the question.
44:02Princess Victoria of Prussia. Moretta, granddaughter of a queen who had once been called the Grandmother
44:09of Europe, sister to the man who ruled and then lost an empire, died on the 13th of November 1929,
44:18in a hospital bed in Bonn. She was 63 years old. She died under the name of a man who
44:25was, by then,
44:27somewhere in Europe she could no longer track, still calling himself a baron to whoever was willing to
44:33believe it. She was buried three days later, on the 16th of November, not in any palace that had ever
44:40belonged to her, but at Schloss Friedrichshof, the home her sister Margaret had inherited, the one address
44:48in her entire life that had never once turned her away. It is worth remembering, at the end of a
44:55story
44:55like this one, what actually happened and what did not. No one poisoned her. No one struck her. No war
45:04was
45:05fought over her broken heart. No country rose or fell because a chancellor once decided her happiness
45:11was worth less than a foreign policy. What happened to Moretta happened quietly, across 63 years,
45:20in a series of rooms getting smaller. From a golden nursery in Potsdam, to a castle by the Rhine, to
45:27a
45:28rented room she shared with a woman who had once curtsied to her, to a hospital bed no family member
45:34was allowed to sit beside. She had asked, across her whole life, for one particular thing, permission
45:42to choose, for herself, who deserved her. Twice she was refused, by men who had every reason in the world
45:51and used none of them particularly well. And once, only once, she stopped asking and chose for herself
45:59anyway. It cost her everything she had left. Somewhere in an English archive today, in a box, among letters
46:10between a queen and the daughter she called, unhappy child, sits the paper trail of a family that wrote to
46:18each other constantly, urgently, across sixty years and two world wars, and somehow still could not manage
46:27to be in the same room when it mattered most. The lace veil she wore twice, once for her mother's
46:35sake,
46:35in 1858, and once for her own, in a chapel with empty pews, in 1927, does not appear again in
46:45any inventory
46:46after the autumn of 1929. No record says what became of it. It simply stops being mentioned, the way most
46:56of
46:57what belonged to her stopped being mentioned, folded into an auctioneer's ledger and carried out through
47:02a door that closed behind it.
Comments