Skip to playerSkip to main content
This weekend, more than 4,000 DAP delegates will vote by secret ballot on whether the party should remain in the federal government until the end of the parliamentary term. After a series of electoral setbacks, has DAP reached the point where staying in government is costing it more politically, than it is gaining from being in government? On this episode of #ConsiderThis Melisa Idris speaks with Howard Lee, Political Education Director in DAP’s Central Executive Committee (CEC) & MP for Ipoh Timor.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:10Hello and good evening. I'm Melissa Idris. Welcome to Consider This. This is the show
00:14where we want you to consider and then reconsider what you know of the news of the day. This
00:19weekend, more than 4,000 DAP delegates will vote by secret ballot on whether or not the
00:25party should remain in the federal government until the end of the parliamentary term. Now
00:30after a series of electoral setbacks, has DAP reached the point where staying in government
00:36is costing them more politically than it is gaining from being in government? Well, let's
00:43ask our first guest today, who is Howard Lee, the Political Education Director for DAP as
00:48well as the MP for Ipoh Timur. Howard, it's good to have you back on the show. Thank
00:53you so much for joining me today. Can you begin our conversation today by maybe telling
00:57us exactly what DAP delegates will be voting on this weekend? What exactly is on that
01:03ballot paper? What question are they taking yes or no to? Melissa, pleasure as always. Thank
01:11you for inviting me. And yes, in party uniform white, getting ready for the vote. And what
01:17the vote means is essentially the CEC, normally when it comes to executive decisions, it is
01:25the chief of the central executive committee who makes such decisions. However, because
01:31of the gravity of the situation, situation means that there are there has been increasing
01:37calls for us to balance being in government versus being out of government and the political
01:43consequences of that. The CEC decided to let the decision or allow the decision or extend
01:52the decision to be made by the party conference, meaning which is the highest decision making
01:58of the body, the highest decision making body of the party. Sorry. And of course, being the highest
02:09decision making body, it is big. So it means it gives the highest level of a mandate for the party
02:16when
02:17it comes to a decision, right? So it is to decide whether to remain to remain in the party or
02:24not. The exact
02:25wording in Malay is sama ada untuk kekal dalam kerajaan. So, and of course, one says it's wishy washy, one
02:35can also say
02:36that it provides room, one could also say that is what's constitutionally provided in a sense that such
02:43decisions supposed to be made by the CEC. So we are seeking a wider mandate and a clearer mandate from
02:53the conference.
02:54Right. Okay. So just to jump in here, just to clarify, it's only two options, stay in federal government or
03:01leave federal government but stay within Pakatan Harapan. Is that correct?
03:05No, it is to stay or not. To stay or not. Right. So when it is to stay, the further
03:15decisions and work and deliberations still have to be conducted by the CEC
03:18on how to stay and in what way and what, you know, what extractions or what extractives do we want
03:25from
03:26that situation? And in the other situation, which is to not stay, we will still need to
03:31deliberate at the CEC level, whether it's strategic, whether it's tactical, how to not stay.
03:38Okay. All right. So the CEC will work out the details once it receives the mandate from the delegates.
03:43And personally, I do think Anthony Locke was right. It was politically smart in letting the delegates decide by secret
03:49ballots rather than announcing the CEC's position.
03:53I also think that this Congress is a great pressure release valve for any kind of grassroots frustrations.
04:00What are you hearing, Howard, from DAP members so far? What's your sense going into the Congress?
04:06And of course, I mean, it's not important what I hear. But what is important to know that I think
04:14is no longer a secret.
04:16A poll was commissioned, a poll was commissioned at a national level to to have a feel, to have a
04:25to have a reading of what the general sentiment is.
04:29It's not members, but actually voters. And it was quite intriguing in a sense that 85.7% of DAP
04:42and Pakatan Harapan voters wanted us to stay.
04:46And overall, across the entire electoral sphere, the entire electoral spectrum, 56.3%, if I'm not mistaken, percent of the
04:58voters want us to stay.
05:01And of course, then I bring in what I'm hearing from members and delegates, because we do do a lot
05:07of engagement and we have escalated the engagement, especially at the power out level where I'm the state, where I'm
05:13the state treasurer for the members, by and large, want us to say when I say by and large, it's
05:21a good 90% from what I'm hearing.
05:25And of course, it may be different in different states, but the feel is people want us to stay and
05:30even critiques towards us are normally now finished off with.
05:36But nonetheless, you must stay. Because you must solve the mess. That is what it is now.
05:44Right. Right. So everything is a mess. They're saying that when we're happy with this, we're happy with this, we're
05:50not happy with this.
05:51And what we're not happy with, you must stay to solve.
05:53OK, so let's talk about what they're not happy with.
05:57Is the unhappiness rooted in the fact that DAP has too little influence inside government, that it is being held
06:06responsible for decisions that it cannot control?
06:11Well, we're in an impossible quandary. Seems like a bit of a Kafkaesque situation where when we're told sometimes in
06:19the same critique where the reforms are too quick, but the reforms are not quick enough in the same sentence.
06:28And so and these are understandable and we must not minimise or we must not delegitimise any of these concerns.
06:36So let's say, for example, especially in the business community, a lot of compliance costs are biting people and biting
06:44business people from front, left, right and centre.
06:49And when we were to ask them that from a from a nationalistic point of view, from a national agenda
06:54point of view, are these bad or good?
06:56They said they're good, but we can't handle it. It's coming too thick and fast.
06:59So compliance costs for businesses. So whether it's SST expansion, whether it's whether it's any anything to do with business
07:07compliance, these are coming too thick and fast.
07:10And on the flip side of that, we are also hearing critiques and essentially problems being accredited to being problems.
07:21The fact that, you know, there aren't enough people being arrested. There aren't people who have, you know, being who
07:30has been been told or the public has been told to have done the things wrong with wrongdoings or even
07:36criminal elements in what they've done, who are not behind bars yet or not even being charged.
07:40So you've got these two sides, you know, both sides of the same coin, but reflecting different light.
07:47Right. Well, so it seems to me that the vote this weekend is quite straightforward.
07:53And is it a vote decided by a simple majority? Yes. Yes. OK.
07:58So it seems pretty straightforward. You're looking for a renewed mandate from party delegates.
08:05Where the real work begins, I think, is what you do after that.
08:09So with the CEC in hammering out the details. Lay out for me the options on the table for the
08:15CEC.
08:16Should the party remain in federal government?
08:20There are way too many permutations, but I think let's let's go to the simplest ones.
08:27And of course, it's never simple. So let's say, for example, if the party was to decide that the CEC
08:34has the spectrum of choices of remaining.
08:37So it's remaining on condition. It's remaining remaining with a timeline remaining, of course, with a kind of like sliding
08:50scale of what we must do.
08:53And with certain policies that we want to put on the table on public or certain policies that we want
08:59to put on table at the cabinet level.
09:03So it's the permutations are way too multitudinous.
09:08So therefore, I think it's once we decided to once we decide to stay, there will be conditions imposed upon
09:16us staying or there won't be conditions we impose upon staying.
09:21But discussions will be had at the cabinet level or at the political level, at the pH level.
09:27These are the different options that we have available.
09:30OK, so my I think I must use this opportunity to inject some of my own thoughts here.
09:35But I do think that when we stay, if we stay, there must be things reviewed in terms of how
09:44we do things and how the government do things.
09:47You have to elaborate, Howard.
09:50I thought I was going to elaborate a little bit, but I think we must.
09:55I wouldn't use the word demand because demand would not be the correct way of doing things.
10:00But I think a very in-depth discussion at the political level of the survival and prosperity of Pakatan Harapan
10:12needs to be put on the table to be discussed.
10:14And what we need to do in order to return that.
10:17OK, so a stay vote need not be interpreted as unconditional loyalty.
10:23So you could stay in government, but drive a much harder political bargain, which could be smart.
10:30And here's what I want to ask you. How will you how will you communicate that nuance to those outside
10:37of the CEC?
10:38So not just the party delegates and the party members, but the DAP traditional voter base who are watching from
10:46the outside and saying, oh, they want to stay.
10:48What changes now?
10:49I think what is important for us to communicate at the conference is that we want the delegates to govern
10:58with us together.
11:00And I think in the last two or three or four months, a lot of things have come into light.
11:07The difficulties, the challenges and the impossible decisions and choices that the leadership has been put in a position to
11:16take in that not everything has been pink and fluffy.
11:20Not everything has been smooth sailing as one would expect when you're in government, because apparently all powers upon your
11:28shoulders.
11:29So therefore, one can exercise it fully is never like that, especially in the coalition government.
11:34And I think once these difficulties have come to the fore, a lot of our delegates have come to realize,
11:40actually, it hasn't been easy.
11:42And if it hasn't been easy, we need and the mandate isn't just to subcontract the decision to the delegates.
11:50It's actually to tell our delegates that we need you to help us at the leadership level to govern as
11:58a party together.
12:00And to govern the country as a party together would be a lot more, I wouldn't say easier, would be
12:09smoother because the critique that would come from the delegates would be a lot more valid and a lot more
12:16credible.
12:17And it will be easier for us to work with rather than sometimes the slightly, you know, out of fold
12:26critiques that is quite difficult to handle.
12:29Howard, do you think that you could in the minute and a half that we have left, tell us where
12:34you think DAP needs to go post Congress, post decision?
12:39What happens from here on out?
12:41It's a conference in the Congress, but post conference, I think what the DAP needs to do once the mandate
12:48is given to the CEC and the leadership by the party,
12:53we must deliberate immediately in terms of the different permutations available and the different options that we can take.
13:01And from that, we must be clear and we must govern together with the party delegates and the entire party
13:09as a whole governing together.
13:11Whatever means that we need to get them on board, keep them informed and as a party as a whole,
13:18keep the whole nation informed of what we can, what we can't do.
13:22Honesty is the best policy and we must be honest with our voters and our party delegates.
13:28And with that, we move forward as a big unit, as a DAP family, as a PH family.
13:35And honesty is not just with voters, honesty is not just with our delegates, it's also with our coalition partners
13:41within PH and outside of PH.
13:43Honesty is the best policy.
13:45Howard, thank you so much for being on the show with me today.
13:48All the best for the Congress this weekend.
13:49That was Howard Lee, Political Education Director of DAP and MP for Ipoh Timo.
13:54We're going to take a quick break here and consider this.
13:56We'll be back with more. Stay tuned.
13:57You're welcome.
14:07You

Recommended