Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 3 months ago
The mounting concerns over the leadership style of CCJ President Justice Winston Anderson- was echoed in a series of internal emails obtained exclusively by CCN over the last week.

In one of the correspondences Justice Arif Bulkan stated that because of this ongoing internal issue about Justice Anderson's alleged "dictatorial" and "authoritatian" manner- it is very likely for that said reason that regional leaders like Prime Minister Kamla Persad Bissessar maybe distrusting of the CCJ.

Mark Bassant has more in this story.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00The mounting concerns over the leadership style of CCJ President Justice Winston Anderson was echoed in a series of internal
00:07emails obtained exclusively by CCN over the last week.
00:12In one of the correspondences, Justice Arif Balkan stated that because of this ongoing internal issue about Justice Anderson's alleged
00:21dictatorial and authoritarian manner, it is very likely for that said reason that regional leaders like Prime Minister Kamala Passat
00:29-Bissessa may distrust the CCG.
00:32Mark Passant has more.
00:34Justice Arif Balkan, one of the presiding judges of the Caribbean Court of Justice, CCJ, said the very concerns that
00:41led Prime Minister Kamala Passat-Bissessa to distrust the court centered on the risk of a single judge imposing a
00:48legal position contrary to that of the majority.
00:51He said the appellate process is designed to guard against such a bias and preserve the integrity of the institution.
00:57The Guyanese-born judge was responding to a chain of emails exchanged among the CCJ judges in June 2026 as
01:05complaints against Justice Anderson intensified.
01:09Allegations ranged from claims that Anderson had unilaterally enforced a judicial dress code to accusations of panel fixing and attempts
01:17to sway case outcomes.
01:19A majority of his colleagues accused them of running the court in what they described as an orthoterian and dictatorial
01:25manner.
01:26Justice Bulgan referred to a judicial dress code drafted by Justice Anderson raised other questions pertinent to its leadership style.
01:34He said, open quote,
01:36If a president can overrule a majority, there is no need for a panel.
01:39Viewed from another angle, the benefits of multiple judges sitting in review are to ensure rigor, breadth of knowledge and
01:45experience and safeguards from bias.
01:47The fear of this happening in the Caribbean is precisely one of the fears that has held the majority of
01:53the region back from acceding to the appellate jurisdiction of the CCJ.
01:57Both citizens in countries that have said no in referenda and regional leaders like PM Passat-Bissessa have clearly articulated
02:05the distrust of a local institution and its ability to judge with integrity and competence.
02:12Bulkan in that email also raised concerns about the collegial working environment and the cultivation of respect for work colleagues.
02:19He said, open quote,
02:21There are constructive ways of fulfilling obligations, one of which includes being respectful of colleagues' opinions, recognizing pairs as equals
02:28and treating them accordingly and not dismissing their concerns and affording real opportunities for input and dialogue.
02:36TV6 News and The Express sent questions via WhatsApp yesterday to Prime Minister Kamala Passat-Bissessa,
02:41seeking a response to the allegations surrounding CCJ President Winston Anderson and whether the claims raised by his fellow judges
02:49had affected her confidence in the leadership of the Caribbean Court of Justice.
02:53There was no response.
02:55Several legal luminaries and other regional personnel are calling on the Prime Ministers of CARICOM to launch an investigation into
03:01alleged serious concerns about the leadership of the Caribbean Court of Justice.
03:06Mark Bassant, TV6 News.
03:09The opposition leader, Azruddin Mohamed, says he is alarmed about issues raised in an internal dispute among judges at the
03:16Caribbean Court of Justice,
03:18which were revealed in an exclusive report by the Sunday Express.
03:22Mohamed's office on Sunday called for an independent examination of allegations contained in internal correspondence among CCJ judges,
03:31saying the exchanges raised concerns about the administration of the court, judicial independence and the handling of the Mohamed case.
03:39The allegations relating to Mohamed's case came from Justice Jamadar, who, according to the opposition's statement,
03:46described an increasingly toxic environment at the court and identified the extradition matter as one of two cases affecting the
03:53court's core judicial decision-making function.
03:56Jamadar said he experienced what he regarded as an attempt to influence colleagues whose opinions differed from those of the
04:02CCJ president,
04:03according to excerpts of the correspondence released by the Trinidad Express.
04:07The CCJ on July 29 dismissed an appeal by Mohamed and his father, Nazir Mohamed,
04:13challenging the decision by Guyana's Home Affairs Minister to issue an authority to proceed with extradition proceedings requested by the
04:20United States
04:20to face an 11-count indictment alleging conspiracy, money laundering and mail and wire fraud.
04:26The ruling cleared the way for proceedings to the Georgetown Magistrate's Court to resume.
04:35Meanwhile, former Ambassador and Assistant Secretary General of the Caribbean Community, Byron Blake,
04:41said that the allegations that have emerged within the CCJ should be urgently addressed.
04:45Blake said it was not a trivial matter and hopes that those responsible for the CCJ itself
04:50will in fact treat it with the urgency and the seriousness with which it deserves,
04:55according to a report in the Jamaica Gleaner today.
04:57He stressed that allegations are not proven facts
05:00and called for the CCJ to institute an appropriate arrangement to cauterize the situation before it gets out of hand.
05:07Blake was responding to articles published in the Trinidad and Tobago Sunday Express newspaper,
05:12which cited a series of emails it said it obtained,
05:16raising several allegations about the court's operations, the relationship among judges
05:20and what one email reportedly referred to as an increasingly toxic environment at the court.