• 3 months ago
Five years after the coup, Myanmar’s conflict has entered a new phase. As ASEAN explores renewed engagement with the junta, can diplomacy bring an end to the crisis? Nailah Huda speaks with human rights expert, Yuyun Wahyuningrum, on Myanmar’s changing realities and what comes next.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:07This is Awani Global with me, Nailah Huda, and this week on Awani Global, our attention
00:11is turned to Myanmar, where the Hunta Shif turned President Min Aung Hliang said that
00:16the country was, quote, on the path to democracy.
00:20He also recently pledged to improve ties with ASEAN as his government is said to be prioritizing
00:26stability, peace, and national reconciliation.
00:30Meanwhile, nearly a decade after the Rohingya exodus, hundreds of thousands of refugees continue
00:35to live in limbo, with justice still remaining elusive.
00:39So, in this hour, joining us to unpack the evolving conflict, what ASEAN's response looks like
00:46and how it is also evolving, the ongoing humanitarian crisis, of course, involving the Rohingya refugees.
00:52Joining me now is Yuyun Wahyuningrum, Senior Fellow for Atrocity Prevention and Southeast Asia
00:58at the Asia Pacific Centre for the Responsibility to Protect University of Queensland.
01:03Thank you so much, Yuyun, for joining us from Jakarta.
01:06Of course, a lot to unpack here and a lot of your recent articles being published recently
01:11focusing specifically on Myanmar.
01:13But perhaps before we go into the refugee crisis, we can look at what's going on in Myanmar,
01:19evolving quite a lot in the past few months.
01:23But just to get an overview of what's happening on the ground, many people still think of Myanmar
01:29as this conflict between two sides, between the Hunta and the opposition.
01:33But in reality, how has the conflict actually evolved?
01:38Yes, Myanmar is no longer experiencing a conventional civil war between government and opposition.
01:45It has evolved into highly fragmented conflict involving the military junta, long-established ethnic armed organization,
01:56people defense forces, and emerging local governance structure.
02:01But perhaps what is important development is that military has no longer a monopoly over territorial control
02:09across a significant part of the country, particularly in border region.
02:16Governance is increasingly exercised by other actors.
02:21Some administer school, health services, taxation, policing, and local justice.
02:28I went to Chiang Mai last month, I guess, and I met with a number of groups.
02:35They're already thinking and planning about immigration.
02:39So I think that's a very strong development in this area.
02:45So this means Myanmar is no longer facing security issue or security crisis.
02:51It is experiencing profound transformation of political authority.
02:57The central question is no longer whether military can defeat resistance,
03:02but what kind of political order will eventually emerge from this fragmentation.
03:10We'll talk a bit more about that fragmentation.
03:14Understanding the realities on ground, in one of your articles,
03:18you argued that Myanmar is no longer governed from just one center of power.
03:23Can you explain what you mean by that?
03:25Because, you know, we're also seeing the rise of ethnic armed organizations,
03:30some form of local administrations as well.
03:34How significant are these forms of power?
03:37Are they becoming more legitimate governing authorities in many parts of Myanmar?
03:43Well, I would like to start with the legitimation.
03:47First, ASEAN continued to engage Myanmar from NAPIDO because it is based on an assumption that the state spoke in
03:58one voice.
03:59But in reality, there are so many center of powers right now, especially within the borders of Myanmar.
04:10And so, for instance, like the establishment of NUG and then SCEF right now, gathering the voices, the power together.
04:23So these diverse actors exercising varying degrees of administrative control over different territories.
04:30And in many communities, people obtain, again, education, health care, security, and justice from local administration,
04:38rather than expecting the same facilities and services from military authorities.
04:46So, but I would rather reluctant to say that Myanmar is permanently divided.
04:54Rather, it means government has become plural and contested.
04:57And future political settlement between and among ASEAN and ASEAN member states will need to recognize these realities
05:07instead of assuming that power can simply be centralized in NAPIDO.
05:13You also described the emergence of federalism from below.
05:19Could you explain what that might look like on the ground?
05:24More and more now, ethnic groups like Karen, Chin, they establish their own local governance.
05:34So it is like state within the state.
05:37And federalism has been the agenda, political agenda from four years.
05:43The latest election in 2020, one of the promises from NLD, for instance, was to pursue federalism.
05:55So that idea continued to be discussed.
05:59And there has been a strong interest and efforts, measures on the ground how to formulate federalism.
06:09In the earlier of 2021, for instance, we've met with a number of groups, we continue to hear different ideas
06:17about federalism from one group to another.
06:20One group said federalism should be based on ethnicity, but the other said federalism should only based on geography.
06:32So different ethnic groups can occupy or can stay in that area.
06:37So we continue to hear these ideas for some time, but only in 2024, 2025, we see the format, the
06:52shape of it becoming more reality.
06:58I have the privilege to talk to some of them, and they said, well, we have a lot of challenges,
07:04but this is common because we built from zero, like lack of budget, do not know how to arrange certain
07:15areas, but they learn by doing it.
07:18So the fact that last month they talk about planning an immigration affairs, that's something already beyond what I can
07:31think of in terms of the readiness of how this group tried to build their own federalism.
07:39So the way I, so I keep hearing that federalism is not something like decentralization of power, but having their
07:49own power themselves, having their own arrangement by themselves, separated or divorced from the center.
07:59But at the moment, they did not talk about separation.
08:04They continue to, they are busy, they make themselves busy of creating a system in which they can offer some
08:14protection, services, facilities that people of Myanmar living in that area deserve.
08:21So at the time, prioritizing local security, local governance before thinking of how power sharing might look like on a
08:31more national level.
08:33This might be a positive signal, but if we were to take into account the recent statement from the Hunta
08:40Chief, Min Aung Leng, describing this country's process towards a path to democracy, prioritizing stability, peace, national reconciliation, what do
08:54you make of this?
08:54Do you think that we can take this seriously?
08:57I personally have the least trust with the current authority in Myanmar because we receive a lot of mixed messages.
09:11So for instance, by in 2021, after leaving Jakarta, getting the five point consensus,
09:20Min Aung Leng said, it was not a five point consensus, but rather five road to democracy.
09:29And there has been assumption or understanding inside NAPIDO that five point consensus equal to five step to five step
09:41to democracy, which is not true.
09:46So there has been a different, again, signals assuming that Myanmar accept five point consensus, but in reality, it doesn't.
10:01And now with the statement of the parliament of Myanmar saying rejection to five point consensus,
10:09And also the public announcement that Myanmar, not condemn, but it's really denouncing five point consensus, that's to me giving
10:24a very different signal because Myanmar really, really put a lot of efforts to be included, re-engaged by ASEAN.
10:35But at the same time, rejecting ASEAN's consensus, ASEAN agreement.
10:43So again, this creates distrust, especially myself, the person, I'm not Myanmarist, I'm living outside of Myanmar, but this is
10:54how I see the messages so far.
10:59Yeah, you mentioned this effort of re-engaging with ASEAN through the five point consensus, but perhaps the strategy or
11:07the approach is now changing because we're seeing how ASEAN might appear to be softening its approach a little bit
11:14by re-engaging the junta through more bilateral forms of engagement and meetings.
11:20Why do you think this is happening now?
11:22Why do you think this is happening now? Is this more from the ASEAN side or is this the only
11:25way to approach the junta now?
11:27I believe it is not the only way, but ASEAN member states discuss that, share their situation.
11:39So we cannot compare our concerns in Indonesia or Malaysia with those who have, who share the borders with Myanmar,
11:48such as Thailand and Laos.
11:50So these different perspective, concerns, point of view, was discussed in the last summit, I guess, and there was an
12:00agreement among member states to gradually engage with Myanmar in the term that Thailand put as calibrated re-engagement.
12:14The explanation given to us was that this re-engagement not necessarily normalization, this re-engagement has conditions.
12:26One condition is to comply with five point consensus and number of steps that proposed by Thailand as the proponent
12:36of this idea.
12:39But I do not hear about safeguards, about milestones, about, I'm not, I'm not trying to, it is not sanctioned,
12:52but is there any milestones that they can establish, agreed between the two?
13:02There has been.
13:03There has been a lot of frustration.
13:05It seems like isolation does not necessarily provide a result that ASEAN expected to be.
13:14So again, the changing of strategy becoming very important, but without conditions to the re-engagement, without milestone, without trust
13:28in between, I doubt this re-engagement will produce anything fruitful.
13:39ASEAN perhaps need to really elaborate further.
13:44If they want to start with five point consensus, that's already a good start.
13:49And I understand one of the reasons why member states continue to emphasis on five point consensus, because the level
14:01of contestation, the amount of contestation of five point consensus was very, very high.
14:07So some member states find it more useful to start with whatever they already agreed forward.
14:16Perhaps five point consensus can be expanded a little bit.
14:24So five point consensus, so the way I hear now, some member states said we are not abandoning five point
14:33consensus by re-engaging Myanmar, but the other member states say we resist that five point consensus continues to become
14:44our main preference.
14:46So there are two different directions.
14:50So there are two different directions at the same time, but they can find a middle way, so they can
14:57expand some elements, some features of five point consensus.
15:02At least they can start from something they have agreed together in April 2021.
15:09Now, at the same time, of course, there is the refugee crisis and looking at how justice for the Rohingya
15:17refugees still remaining elusive for many of them nearly a decade after the Rohingya exodus began.
15:24How would you describe the current situation facing refugees today, especially looking at how we've discussed the sort of changing
15:33approach that ASEAN has towards the junta, towards the civil war?
15:37So it seems as though now some ASEAN member states have also positioned themselves a bit differently in terms of
15:45the refugee crisis.
15:46There's been a shift or a changing trend here as well.
15:50What do you make of this?
15:52Well, Rohingya remains one of the world's most vulnerable displaced population.
15:58Many continue to live in overcrowded refugee camps with declining humanitarian funding, limited education opportunity, restricted livelihood, and growing insecurity.
16:11At the same time, conditions inside Rakhine state remain far from conducive for safe, voluntary dignity and sustainable return.
16:23The crisis, therefore, no longer simply about displacement, I guess.
16:28It has become a protected protection crisis affecting the entire generation.
16:39So Rohingya now has been rejected in different parts of the countries right now.
16:47But going back home without guarantee of protection, citizenship, and safety, that's also an empty promises.
17:01Talking about that, we're seeing some progress in international courts, the ICJ, ICC, when it comes to Rohingya refugees.
17:10But why is it that you argue justice remains a foreign or abstract concept for a lot of Rohingya children
17:17specifically?
17:18Yes, I think international justice is essential because it reinforces the principle that mass atrocities cannot occur with complete impunity.
17:31But there are different understanding about what justice means for Rohingya.
17:41For Rohingya, for refugees, for parents, for instance, the one that I talk of for online conversation, justice for them
17:51is the free future for their children.
17:53Education, education, culture, they felt that there has been decreased understanding or space in which they can teach their children
18:09about their culture.
18:11So it really becoming their main concern.
18:15My interview with Rohingya in Aceh, they're also very, very concerned about their children, the future especially, the schooling, the
18:28education.
18:31So they think about their children rather than themselves, how to provide a better livelihood for their children.
18:41But at the same time, I also know that the Philippines has a program of scholarship, high education scholarship for
18:51Rohingyas.
18:52So some of the Rohingyas refugees in Johor Bahru and many places have been traveled to the Philippines and obtained
19:01scholarship.
19:03So some of them already graduated.
19:06Again, the question is what to do after this, going back to Myanmar is not the answer.
19:13So they do not have place to go back to return within that certificate of being master or certain certain
19:26discipline.
19:30So I understand that justice is not only in the courtroom, but justice is beyond what we think justice is,
19:44according to Rohingyas refugees.
19:48Apart from justice, there is of course the question of humanitarian responsibility that at least sometime before this, there was
19:57this sort of understanding of how this responsibility could be shared among ASEAN member states.
20:03But I guess now that comes into question as member states like Malaysia is now announcing how Myanmar has agreed
20:10to receive 5,000 refugees that's currently in the country.
20:15Although we've not heard a lot of clarity or clarification from the Myanmar side.
20:20You also recently talked about this in your article, of course, this premature repatriation program.
20:28What are your thoughts on this? What are some of the risks?
20:30Yes.
20:32I understand the situation of Malaysia.
20:34I think countries, Bangladesh, Indonesia also experience the same thing.
20:40But returning them or repatriate them is too early, or I call it as premature, especially without the guarantee of
20:51safety of Rohingyas inside Myanmar.
20:56I think it's a very difficult position for hosting countries at the moment, understandably.
21:08Actually, well, ASEAN doesn't have a mechanism for refugees, as we all know.
21:13But there are some programs that are available to facilitate the issue.
21:22ASEAN has the ASEAN Convention Against Trafficking in Persons in which can be used to reduce the crime against trafficking
21:34in person in the process of moving or transiting from one place to another experienced by Rohingyas refugees.
21:43ASEAN has ASEAN Centre. ASEAN has ASEAN Centre. ASEAN Centre is a body dealing with humanitarian issues, especially from natural
21:51disaster.
21:52But ASEAN has expanded the role of ASEAN Centre to look at the crisis, conflict or political crisis.
22:01So ASEAN Centre can be assigned if ASEAN member states have political will.
22:09So anything in ASEAN, in my view, if ASEAN member states have political will, they can do whatever they can
22:17to help Rohingyas, to sort many difficult issues.
22:24So non-interference principle, to me, is not necessarily really a big problem, as long as political will is there.
22:32We have been seeing a lot of examples of it.
22:36In fact, what consensus is one, ASEAN Centre assigned to different conflict situations.
22:43And ASEAN Centre has a lot of humanitarian aid packets, so they can also mobilise this kind of aid.
22:57So if ASEAN put together all the existing mechanisms, and then from this, last night I just listed down what
23:12kind of mechanism ASEAN has.
23:15If they come together with their own expertise, perhaps this is something that they can think of on how to
23:23deal with refugee issues.
23:25But again, the key from this is political will.
23:31So it means ASEAN doesn't have to start from zero.
23:35ASEAN can use and maximise the existing mechanism or related mechanism to address the issue, especially on Rohingya refugees.
23:46Yuyin, we have just about one to two minutes left.
23:50Ending on that note, and taking into account everything that we've discussed from the civil war to the refugee crisis,
23:57what do you think is one message that ASEAN leaders should take away as they continue to shape regional policy
24:03on Myanmar?
24:04Is it this note of political will? Is it this note of shared responsibility?
24:09What do you think ASEAN should take away from this?
24:14If ASEAN agreed on shared responsibility, ASEAN can assign roles to each member states.
24:22And ASEAN can also build funds, refugee funds, to help states that become the host of refugee crisis.
24:33So I think ASEAN should see this crisis an opportunity to grow.
24:40It's ability and capacity, especially dealing with humanitarian security challenge.
24:46ASEAN cannot shy away because it is not going to be away from our region.
24:54It is going to be here. As long as we don't deal with the issue, it's going to stay.
24:59And ASEAN at the point will have no choice other than dealing with the issue.
25:08And ASEAN has a sophisticated system and mechanism on humanitarian.
25:15So that's already a good modality to respond to the crisis.
25:21ASEAN has the mechanism, has the framework and has enough talent, of course, to be able to manage this.
25:27But it's a matter of political will and how much they're willing to invest the time and effort and money
25:34into this is the question.
25:35Thank you so much, Yuyun Wahyuning Room, Senior Fellow for Atrocity Prevention in Southeast Asia at the Asia Pacific Centre
25:41for the Responsibility to Protect University of Queensland.
25:45Thank you so much once again, Yuyun for joining us on Awani Global to share a little bit about some
25:49of the concerns and issues facing not just citizens of Myanmar,
25:57but the Rohingya refugees across the region, of course, as the civil war continues to evolve and as responses from
26:05ASEAN leaders also continues to shift according to different priorities and interests.
26:11That is all that we're discussing on Awani Global this week. We'll catch you next time.

Recommended