Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 3 months ago
Greens MP Amanda Cohn tables the Mater inquiry report in NSW Parliament, with recommendations that the hospital's failed PPP be terminated and returned to public hands.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:01Mr. President, I table report number 68 of Portfolio Committee number 2 entitled
00:05Management, Maintenance and Operational Issues at Calvary Martyr Hospital, Newcastle,
00:10dated August 2026, together with transcripts of evidence, table documents, submissions,
00:14correspondence and answers to questions taken on notice and supplementary questions.
00:18Mr. President, I move that the House take note of the report.
00:23This inquiry has laid bare that the infrastructure issues at the Calvary Martyr Hospital
00:28started as soon as it was built.
00:30The extent of the foundational infrastructure problems at the hospital
00:34and the public-private partnership framework that enabled them to be ignored
00:39or superficially remediated would likely have remained hidden
00:43were it not for the advocacy of the hospital staff, patients and their families and local media.
00:50Without their courage and their candour, this inquiry would not have commenced,
00:54nor would the committee have been able to illuminate the dysfunction
00:57of the public-private partnership and the daily consequences
01:01of the unresolved infrastructure failures on clinical operations, staff, morale and public trust.
01:08Private profit has no place in public hospitals.
01:12Staff have been raising the alarm for nearly a decade.
01:16The failure to act was a direct result of the PPP model,
01:20which left no-one taking responsibility for the maintenance of the hospital.
01:24The only solution that will fix the infrastructure issues
01:28and restore the trust of staff and the community
01:30is for the ownership and management of the hospital to be brought into public hands.
01:35The New South Wales Government already conceded that the PPP model doesn't work
01:39when it brought back the Northern Beaches Hospital.
01:42Newcastle deserves the same response before the next tragedy, not after.
01:47And that's the consensus recommendation of this committee.
01:50The inquiry heard about maggots falling from the ceiling onto a patient,
01:55nurses funneling rainwater into garbage bins during the night,
01:59a doctor fainting during surgery because of high humidity in the operating theatre
02:03and explosive allegations of falsified maintenance records.
02:08These problems were preventable.
02:11Hospital management and the New South Wales Government
02:13knew about these issues for years and failed to address them.
02:17The only solution that will fix those issues
02:20and restore the trust of staff and the community
02:22is for the ownership and management of the hospital
02:24to be brought into public hands.
02:27Patients and healthcare workers should not have to rely on whistleblowers, tragedies
02:31or parliamentary inquiries before governments act on serious safety concerns.
02:37What shone through all of these issues
02:39was the extraordinary compassion and resilience of the hospital staff
02:43who keep coming to work day after day
02:46because they care deeply about the service they provide to patients and the community.
02:51It was heartbreaking to hear that cleaners had been abused by members of the public
02:56in response to the mould issue
02:58when they were the ones busting their guts to provide a safe hospital environment
03:01and set up to fail by under-resourcing and the HVAC system not being fit for purpose.
03:07It's clear that the MARTA is loved by its patients and staff.
03:11A hospital should be a place of healing,
03:13not a place that causes harm to people who need medical care
03:16and the people who provide it.
03:18This is not just a local issue.
03:21One thing that the rest of the state must learn from this sorry saga
03:25is that other public-private partnerships still operating across New South Wales Health must be scrutinised.
03:30We cannot afford to wait for patients and staff to suffer under this failed model
03:35like we've seen at Calvary Martyr and Northern Beaches.
03:38Every community deserves a public hospital that's accountable to patients, not private operators.
03:44Finally, the report recommends that the Parliamentary Evidence Act be repaired
03:47to restore the committee's ability to summons witnesses
03:50and presents a case study of a key witness that we were unable to question
03:55in the current circumstances.
03:59On behalf of the committee, I extend our sincere gratitude
04:02to those who contributed to the inquiry,
04:04particularly the patients, their families, hospital staff and whistleblowers.
04:07We recognise the psychological toll of working or receiving care
04:11in an environment where health and safety is compromised
04:13and the risk that some witnesses took in sharing their experiences publicly.
04:17I thank my colleagues for their thoughtful and genuine engagement in this inquiry
04:22and the Secretariat for their hard work.
04:24And, Mr. President, I move that this debate be now adjourned until the next sitting day.
04:28Question is to the motion of Dr. Amanda Conn be agreed to.
04:31All those of that opinion...

Recommended