Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 3 months ago

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:00The Atlantic Ocean, the scene of one of World War II's bloodiest battles,
00:06the Battle of the Atlantic.
00:09This is the forgotten front line.
00:12It's a battleground that saw the deaths of thousands of British sailors.
00:17And here, danger was everywhere.
00:20Not only did they have the harsh Atlantic weather to contend with,
00:25but beneath the waves could be a German U-boat ready to fire a torpedo.
00:35The Battle of the Atlantic is much more than just a single battle.
00:41It's a bloody and devastating campaign.
00:44In this war, we can't just survive it, we have to win it.
00:48Britain's forces risked everything they had.
00:51The war was an extraordinarily bloody conflict.
00:56As an ex-Marine, I'm fascinated by the actions of the Atlantic's unsung heroes,
01:02men and women who kept the Allies in the fight.
01:05Walker was convinced that the best form of defence was attack.
01:10And as an engineer, I want to get to grips with these incredible killing machines.
01:16What made them so deadly?
01:18The more ships it took down, the greater the fame and accolade.
01:23And how they were eventually defeated.
01:26This time, Britain brings out its big guns.
01:30A ship that could strike fear into the soul of U-boat commanders.
01:37Secrets and spies.
01:38A covert operation uncovers Nazi plans.
01:42The locals call it spy house.
01:47And the Allies are forced to unleash an experimental weapon.
01:51There was an awareness that we were up against, that the Germans had outsmarted us.
01:56This is the campaign that decides the outcome of World War II.
02:15As the Battle of the Atlantic enters its third year,
02:19convoys of merchant ships carrying crucial supplies from North America
02:23are under constant attack from German U-boats.
02:31The losses are mounting.
02:45Cape Verde.
02:48A remote archipelago in the Atlantic Ocean.
02:53It's a warm September's evening, and the waters are calm.
03:08Three German U-boats agree to meet on this remote island to restock their torpedoes.
03:21And with the Atlantic stretching out for more than 40 million square miles,
03:26this rendezvous in a secluded bay on a remote island in the middle of nowhere,
03:32they're confident that they're never going to get caught.
03:36But then, just after midnight, something extraordinary happens.
03:46A British submarine appears.
03:52The German submarines are amazed that they should be discovered in this remote location
03:59by a British submarine, HMS Clyde.
04:04This unexpected visitor is captained by Commander David Ingram.
04:13HMS Clyde lets rip.
04:16Six torpedoes zip through the water towards the German U-boats.
04:22It's a tough shot.
04:24These are small, fast-moving targets sitting not very deep in the water.
04:30The torpedoes miss, and the U-boats dive.
04:35Now, the hunt is on.
04:45And then there's a game of cat and mouse in this bay while the Germans try to find the British
04:51submarine,
04:52and the British are trying to pick off the Germans.
05:16After more than two hours of searching for a German U-boat beneath the waves,
05:20HMS Clyde surfaces.
05:23But, instantly, there is a German U-boat sailing directly towards them.
05:31The U-boat crashes into HMS Clyde.
05:35The bow rides up onto Clyde's hull,
05:37and the U-boat falls back into the water and dives again.
05:43Without hesitation, Ingram instantly starts to search for the German boat.
05:47But, like a ghost,
05:49it disappears beneath the waves.
05:53The Germans get the hell out of there.
05:56In their minds, they're absolutely convinced that this guy's not alone.
06:00This guy's got backup.
06:04While the U-boats beat a hasty retreat,
06:07news of the attack reaches German top brass.
06:12Admiral Karl Dönitz is immediately suspicious.
06:17What's a British sub doing in this part of the Atlantic?
06:21He knew that something must be going on here.
06:24This wasn't a normal course of events.
06:27This remote bay in the Cape Verde Islands,
06:29this should never have happened.
06:32Has there been a leak, wonders Dönitz?
06:35Or have the Allies figured out a way to track U-boat positions?
06:45During the Battle of the Atlantic,
06:47both the British and German navies
06:50communicate amongst themselves using complex codes,
06:53and both sides live in constant fear
06:56that their codes will be cracked.
07:00After the skirmish in Cape Verde,
07:03Dönitz suspects Nazi communications have been compromised.
07:07He just doesn't know how.
07:14The answer?
07:16One of the Allies' best-kept secrets lies deep inside a concrete fortress
07:22in the heart of London.
07:25This becomes the nerve centre for the Royal Navy during the war
07:30and earns the nickname the Citadel.
07:35This is the home of the submarine tracking room,
07:39where classified intelligence is used
07:41to build up a picture of U-boat movements in the Atlantic.
07:45And based in here in 1941,
07:48is a man determined to defeat Admiral Dönitz,
07:52Commander Roger Wynne.
07:57Most people have never heard of Roger Wynne,
08:00but this 37-year-old barrister is busy developing a strategy
08:05that will help alter the course of the Battle of the Atlantic.
08:08Roger Wynne was a very unusual figure to find in the Admiralty.
08:13He had had polio as a child, and so his back was twisted.
08:16He walked with a limp.
08:18He was a highly qualified lawyer before the war.
08:22Wynne knows the German Navy has around 32 operational U-boats.
08:27His job is to try and work out where they are and what they're doing.
08:32It's quite interesting the way both sides in this war personalised it.
08:36You have to try and work out what the enemy's thinking.
08:39You have to try and get in the enemy's head.
08:41So Wynne puts up a picture of Dönitz.
08:44And, you know, he's looking at him,
08:45and he's trying to work out what's going on in this mind of yours.
08:49What he wanted to do was not just to analyse what the U-boats had been doing,
08:54but what they might do in the future,
08:55to predict their actions in what became known as Admiralty guesses.
09:01At first, these guesses were rather hit and miss.
09:05But during the summer of 1941,
09:09Wynne's insights become steadily more accurate,
09:12because British intelligence has struck gold.
09:17The citadel is being sent information so top-secret,
09:22it's called ultra-intelligence.
09:24And it's being sent from a top-secret base in Buckinghamshire,
09:29known as Station X.
09:31But to locals, it has another name.
09:34Bletchley Park.
09:41Good intelligence is crucial in war,
09:44so I've come to Bletchley to find out how the Allies are getting theirs.
09:55In 1941, this building is home to some of Britain's brightest brains,
10:00who work day and night to crack the enemy codes
10:03created by one of the most sophisticated encryption systems on the planet,
10:08the Enigma machine.
10:12What did the Germans use Enigma for?
10:14Enigma is used for sending typically quite short military messages.
10:20In the naval terms, you're talking about 95% of all wireless messages
10:23sent by the German Navy are sent encrypted using an Enigma chip.
10:29If Bletchley can crack the Enigma encryptions,
10:32it'll give the Navy ears on Nazi plans for the Atlantic U-boats.
10:38But the codes are mind-bogglingly complex.
10:42On a standard Enigma machine,
10:45103,000 million, million, million possibilities.
10:49So you can't just work through them one at a time,
10:51you'd never get there.
10:53The code-breaking operation is led by maths genius Alan Turing.
10:58Here at Bletchley,
11:00his team have built six special electromechanical computers called BOMBS
11:05to help decipher the encryptions.
11:08But it's still taking far too long to crack the codes.
11:15All this changes in May 1941.
11:28A Royal Navy crew boards a damaged U-boat in the Mid-Atlantic.
11:34They seize what turns out to be a top-secret cargo.
11:39A working Enigma machine.
11:43And that's not all.
11:49More crucially, they get the associated codebooks.
11:51And these books describe how the keys are created each day.
11:58Now they have the codebooks,
11:59Turing and his team can speed up their code-breaking.
12:03It's amazing, isn't it,
12:05when you think about what was going on right here,
12:07right at these desks.
12:08By the summer,
12:09they're able to crack Enigma encryptions within 36 hours
12:13and feed this vital intelligence to the submarine tracking room.
12:18It's a real-time, it's absolutely vital,
12:20so that you can redirect your convoys away from the submarines.
12:24The Battle of the Atlantic is now a battle of minds.
12:29And one of Bletchley's brightest
12:31is Cambridge graduate Caroline Rowett.
12:36She isn't a household name like Turing,
12:39but it's Rowett who'll go on
12:40to transform the way Enigma intelligence is used
12:45by creating a handwritten database of U-boat activity.
12:51She basically started making a record
12:53of which captain was on which submarine,
12:55how much fuel it's likely to have left, when it sailed.
12:59Rowett's system enables Bletchley's linguists and cryptographers
13:03to tap into some serious U-boat knowledge.
13:09And understanding that bigger picture
13:12is really, really important, strategically,
13:14because if you know how many submarines
13:16the Germans have operational at any one time,
13:18how many have been sunk,
13:24how many torpedoes each one's likely to carry,
13:26you can make strategic decisions about how to fight them.
13:31Intelligence from Bletchley Park is fed to the Citadel,
13:34and Roger Wynne's U-boat predictions
13:36are passed on to the Admiralty next door,
13:39with startling results.
13:45In July and August 1941,
13:48convoy sinkings fall to their lowest level
13:51for almost a year.
13:52For Wynne's nemesis, Admiral Carl Dernitz,
13:56the turnaround is baffling.
13:59Dernitz started to smell a rat.
14:01Why have you got a hit rate
14:04that's phenomenally decreasing?
14:07It doesn't stack up.
14:09The Allies are back in the game.
14:14By the end of the year,
14:15more convoys are arriving in Britain,
14:18having avoided a single U-boat attack.
14:21Commander Wynne is delighted with this success,
14:24but he knows there's a fine balance to be found
14:28when listening in on this top-secret intelligence.
14:32If he overplays his hand,
14:34the Nazis could figure out what's going on
14:37and change their codes forever,
14:39meaning this precious insight to the enemy's plans
14:43could be lost.
15:03The Battle of the Atlantic is on a knife edge.
15:07The tides are starting to turn
15:09in the favour of the Allies.
15:11A secret Nazi code has been cracked,
15:14and this new intelligence, known as Ultra,
15:17is being used to hunt down
15:18and destroy Germany's U-boats.
15:24But the Royal Navy soon discover
15:26that actually destroying U-boats
15:27is not as easy as they'd like to think,
15:30because after two years of fighting in the Atlantic,
15:33these battle-hardened warriors
15:35have perfected a form of attack
15:37known as the Wolf Packs.
15:52Wolf Pack tactics were incredibly successful.
15:56This was a new way of doing things,
15:58a means by which Dönitz could corral
16:02his relatively limited number of ships
16:05to attack a convoy in a group.
16:15The U-boat Wolf Pack spreads out in a line
16:18along the predicted route of the convoy.
16:21When one of the wolves spots a merchant ship,
16:24they send a signal to the rest of the pack.
16:29The key to the tactic is communication and convergence.
16:34One stalks, and the rest of them converge,
16:36and when they've all assembled,
16:38then they attack.
16:46At first, it was devastating.
16:49The Allies didn't really know
16:51how to counter these tactics.
16:53Time and again,
16:54Royal Navy warships look on helplessly,
16:57while sudden, violent explosions
17:00send ship after ship to the ocean floor.
17:04Escort Commander Donald McIntyre
17:07describes the carnage of a night attack in 1941.
17:12I had never before seen
17:14this most appalling of night disasters.
17:16We were shocked into silence
17:18by the horror of it
17:20and the immediate thought
17:22that none could survive.
17:26How exactly are the Wolf Packs
17:28able to penetrate the convoy so effectively?
17:32It's a mystery that will remain unsolved
17:34for another six months.
17:53The war that was fought on the seas
17:55was an extraordinarily bloody conflict
17:59that has tended to be erased from our memory,
18:02perhaps because it was so bloody.
18:05With just under 100 U-boats,
18:07Admiral Dönitz is heaping terrible losses
18:10on the convoys.
18:11His plan is to grow his fleet to 300,
18:15the number he's calculated he needs
18:17to deliver a mortal blow to Britain.
18:22We're aware that in this war,
18:24we can't just survive it,
18:25we have to win it.
18:26So we have to master our shipping lanes
18:29and we have to keep them safe.
18:32Britain calls on the skill and vision
18:34of its naval engineers.
18:37Facing threats on all sides of the Atlantic
18:40means that Britain has to have a vessel capable
18:43of taking the fight back to the Nazis.
18:52And that vessel is here.
18:56A ship that could strike fear
18:58into the soul of U-boat commanders,
19:00the British destroyer.
19:07As an engineer myself,
19:09I'm fascinated by these awesome warships
19:12and what makes the destroyer
19:14the perfect ship to hunt U-boats.
19:23destroyers were a crucial part
19:25of the convoys in the Battle of the Atlantic.
19:28What roles did they play within the convoys?
19:31I think destroyers are just a crucial part
19:33of everything the Royal Navy does
19:35and they are that essential multi-role vessel.
19:38Very, very well-equipped ship.
19:40Very fast.
19:41Capable of doing 32 knots.
19:43It's got a huge amount of speed.
19:46These are the greyhounds of the fleet, so to speak.
19:5032 knots is almost twice the surface speed
19:53of most U-boats.
19:57Destroyers are amongst the fastest ships in the fleet,
20:01built to hunt and to kill.
20:04What type of weaponry were these destroyers equipped with?
20:08The principal weapons of a destroyer are the guns.
20:11So Cavalier has four 4.5-inch high-angle guns
20:14capable of taking on aircraft,
20:16capable of taking on surface ships.
20:18She had a set of torpedo tubes,
20:21anti-submarine weaponry,
20:23a series of depth charge throwers.
20:33Armed to the teeth,
20:35she's also got eyes on her prey 24-7.
20:38All ships of her vintage had open bridges.
20:41It allowed the watchkeeping crew to see all the way round.
20:45Which is a great advantage, I imagine,
20:47as a convoy ship.
20:50And as the Battle of the Atlantic unfolded
20:52and the losses mounted,
20:54then destroyers actually were just thrown in
20:56to every action that was going.
20:59But the convoys are still losing merchant ships,
21:03despite having the ultimate predator in their armoury.
21:10Their success comes down to largely the commander in charge.
21:14And one captain in particular, in 1941,
21:17stands head and shoulders above the rest.
21:19His name was Frederick John Walker,
21:22or Johnny Walker, to his friends.
21:28Johnny Walker is a veteran sailor
21:31with an obsession in anti-submarine warfare.
21:36Known for rubbing his superiors up the wrong way,
21:39he's been passed over for promotion.
21:42But in 1941, he's given command of a convoy escort.
21:48He had a very different attitude to most of the Admiralty.
21:51Walker was convinced that the best form of defence
21:54was attack.
22:09Johnny Walker's escort is shepherding a convoy
22:12from Gibraltar to Liverpool.
22:15Under his command are destroyers, corvettes
22:18and, unusually, an aircraft carrier.
22:24But Walker's escort has a stalker.
22:36The wolf pack closes in.
22:40From the aircraft carrier,
22:42a plane spots a U-boat on the surface.
22:45And Johnny Walker decides to do things his way.
22:49Walker goes for it in a hell of a way.
22:55Using one of his ships
22:57to just drive U-boats into a kill zone
23:01where the rest of his escort ships
23:03can converge and just flood the area
23:06with death charges
23:07and destroy whatever U-boat is in there.
23:12And for the U-boat commanders,
23:14this was a very new approach.
23:17They weren't used to the British ships
23:19attacking with such kind of aggression.
23:23And it really made them quite anxious
23:26about attacking convoys.
23:30On his return, Walker is hailed as a hero.
23:34And the U-boat count has just risen by five.
23:43With a growing number of destroyers
23:46and corvettes patrolling the Atlantic,
23:48more vital supplies reach our shores.
23:51And that very same month,
23:54Britain receives another major boost in its battle.
23:58America enters the war.
24:03The United States of America
24:05was suddenly and deliberately attacked
24:08by naval and air forces
24:10of the Empire of Japan.
24:13The strike on Pearl Harbor in the Pacific
24:15has huge consequences in the Atlantic.
24:20Now the U.S. is in the war,
24:23Admiral Carl Dönitz can send his U-boats
24:25hunting in American waters.
24:32Within four months,
24:34up and down the U.S. coast,
24:36U-boats sink more than 300 merchant ships.
24:41The Germans call this their second happy time.
24:49All the while, Admiral Dönitz's fleet is growing.
24:53He now has 91 U-boats in play.
24:59And in Britain,
25:00there's a new crisis on the horizon.
25:05For nine months,
25:06the Citadel here in central London
25:08has been receiving key ultra-intelligence
25:12from Bletchley Park.
25:13But on the 2nd of February,
25:15when the head of the submarine tracking room,
25:18Commander Wynne, arrives at work,
25:20he's about to discover
25:21that his ultra-intelligence
25:24is drying up.
25:29The Germans have modified Enigma.
25:32There was a sort of tense atmosphere at the time.
25:35There was an awareness that we were up against it,
25:37that we were failing.
25:38And that the Germans had outsmarted us.
25:41And just like that,
25:42the momentum in this epic battle shifts.
25:46By the end of February 1942,
25:49over 1,200 supply ships
25:52have been lost to the U-boats.
25:54The convoys have never been more vulnerable.
25:58Churchill knows he has to act.
26:25By early 1942,
26:27the Battle of the Atlantic
26:28has been raging for over two years.
26:31Thousands of lives have been lost,
26:34killed in large part
26:35by the Nazi U-boats
26:37hunting in wolf packs.
26:41These German U-boats
26:43had incredibly devastating effects
26:46on the Allied powers.
26:52There needs to be a change in fortunes
26:55if Britain is going to push back
26:56against the Nazi U-boats.
27:03The Allies are in trouble.
27:06Setbacks with Enigma code-breaking
27:08mean British intelligence
27:10is now racking its brains
27:11for other ways
27:12to penetrate Nazi plans.
27:24Behind the doors
27:25of a country pile
27:27in Buckinghamshire
27:28runs an operation so secret
27:30not even Parliament knows
27:32of its existence.
27:34The locals call it Spy House.
27:37And this place
27:38during the Second World War
27:40was one of the most
27:41top-secret sites
27:42along with places
27:44like Bletchley Park.
27:45And it was here
27:46that they bugged
27:48the conversations
27:49of enemy prisoners of war.
27:53Latimer House
27:54feels more Claridge's
27:56than Coldin's.
27:57But thousands of prisoners of war
28:00are kept in this jail extraordinaire
28:02so British intelligence
28:03can spy on them.
28:06Wow, what a room, eh, Helen?
28:08So this is the heart
28:10of the operations
28:11in many ways
28:12where intelligence
28:14was discussed,
28:16where key people
28:17were briefed.
28:19One of those key people
28:21is the great
28:22spy maker himself,
28:24Ian Fleming.
28:25He recruited
28:26the naval intelligence
28:27team here.
28:29And one of the interesting
28:30interrogators
28:31that he enlisted
28:32was a chap called
28:33Colin McFadyen.
28:36McFadyen's methods
28:37rely on stealth
28:39and cunning.
28:41Here,
28:42the walls
28:43have ears.
28:47In a set of secret chambers
28:50called M-Room,
28:51McFadyen's listeners
28:52are eavesdropping
28:53on conversations
28:54in cells
28:55and common rooms.
28:57And his spies
28:58have ways
28:59of making Nazi
29:00prisoners of war
29:01talk.
29:02Either a prisoner
29:03who'd been turned
29:05to work for us
29:06or intelligence officers
29:08would put on
29:10German naval uniform
29:11and pretend to be a prisoner
29:13and would lead
29:14the conversation
29:15in the cells
29:16to a particular way
29:17to try and get
29:18the information.
29:19And, of course,
29:20the real prisoner
29:20has no idea
29:22that there are
29:22microphones planted
29:24in the light fittings.
29:25And it is extraordinary,
29:27the detailed information
29:28that they were giving up.
29:30Prisoners were talking
29:31about Enigma
29:33and how the codes
29:34had changed
29:35and it's stuff
29:36which was passed
29:37to Bletchley Park.
29:38And how closely linked
29:40were these two sites,
29:41Bletchley and Latimer House?
29:43Incredibly close
29:44working relationship.
29:45What were they after?
29:46To understand
29:47the German fighting capability
29:50and, importantly,
29:51two,
29:51what new technology
29:53is being developed?
29:55The methods used
29:56by Colin McFadden
29:57and his listeners
29:58get results.
30:01They discover
30:02key pieces
30:03of information
30:04about U-boats,
30:05including how many
30:07have been produced
30:08and what their
30:08new capabilities are.
30:11The revelations, though,
30:12confirm
30:13Churchill's
30:14worst fears.
30:15The Battle of the Atlantic
30:17is about to get
30:19much tougher.
30:26It's hard
30:28to fight an enemy
30:29you can't see.
30:33And it's harder still
30:35in the middle
30:36of the Atlantic Ocean.
30:40The Mid-Atlantic Gap,
30:42an area of over
30:43180,000 square miles,
30:46is out of reach
30:47to the shorter-range
30:49Allied planes.
30:52Making convoys
30:54easy pickings
30:55for long-range
30:56enemy bombers.
31:01And the Wolf Packs.
31:05The hour was desperate.
31:08Something had to be done
31:09to provide aerial protection
31:11in that Atlantic Gap.
31:19This is the Royal Navy's solution.
31:27A ship that fires
31:29modified hurricane fighters
31:30from a ramp on the deck
31:32using a catapult.
31:35These are the Hurricats.
31:38Now, I've flown
31:39World War II aeroplanes
31:41myself,
31:42but I'm not sure
31:42whether this is sheer genius
31:44or total madness.
31:48To find out who will be brave enough
31:50to fly the Hurricats,
31:51I've come to meet
31:52Harry Raffel
31:53at RAF Hendon.
31:55Harry, when I hear
31:57about Hurricats,
31:58I often hear the name
31:59Louis Strange.
32:00Who is this guy
32:00and what did he do?
32:01Strange is an extraordinary
32:03individual.
32:04He'd won a distinguished
32:05service order medal
32:06from the First World War.
32:07And he goes on
32:08to lead the training
32:10for first Hurricat pilots.
32:13He makes it a point
32:14that he will do
32:15the first launches
32:15to show that
32:17not only is it safe
32:18and can be done,
32:19but that he has confidence in it.
32:21It's quite a mad idea,
32:23really, isn't it?
32:24I mean, taking an aircraft
32:24off something
32:25that isn't an aircraft carrier.
32:27I think the take-off
32:29is probably the bit
32:29which would be most concerning.
32:31You're going at 3.5 Gs.
32:33Instantly?
32:35Instantly.
32:37As they come off
32:38the catapults
32:38only just above
32:39stall speed,
32:40they have to keep
32:41flying level
32:42for enough time
32:43to get some speed
32:44before they pull up
32:45on the stick
32:45and start to climb.
32:47But a fleet
32:47Aeron pilot
32:48described it
32:49as the most exciting
32:50thing he'd ever done
32:51and that man
32:52had won the Grand National.
32:55These incredible
32:56catapult planes
32:57are hugely ambitious.
32:59It almost feels
33:00like their very creation
33:02shows an element
33:03of desperation
33:04creeping into Churchill
33:05and those around him's plans.
33:09This desperation
33:11is fueled
33:12by the obvious success
33:13of Germany's
33:14Wolfpack tactics.
33:17May 1942
33:18becomes the most devastating
33:20month of the war
33:21so far.
33:23U-boats continue
33:24to strike
33:25through that month
33:26sending a total
33:27total of 585,000 tonnes
33:31of shipping
33:32plus vital supplies
33:33like food,
33:34fuel and materials
33:37to the ocean floor.
33:40Now, it's also
33:41a hugely significant figure
33:43because Dönitz believes
33:45that if those losses
33:46continue over the next
33:47few months,
33:48Britain will have
33:50no choice
33:51but to surrender.
33:53So, at naval command,
33:55it's all hands on deck
33:57to unlock the secret
33:58strategy of the Wolfpack.
34:20After more than two years
34:22of fighting the Battle of the Atlantic,
34:24the outcome
34:25is looking bleak
34:26for the Allies.
34:27They've lost
34:28their key intelligence source,
34:30which had given them
34:30the edge
34:31earlier in the year.
34:33Ships
34:34and vital supplies
34:35are being sunk
34:36at a frightening rate.
34:38As a consequence,
34:39food stocks
34:40are running low.
34:42Defeat
34:42could be
34:43just a few months away.
34:52The Wolfpacks
34:53are stronger than ever.
34:55Admiral Karl Dönitz
34:57is closing in
34:58on his magic target
34:59of 300 U-boats.
35:01The number he's calculated
35:02will deliver
35:03a mortal blow
35:04to the Allies.
35:10But the Royal Navy
35:11has been working
35:12on a plan
35:13of its own.
35:21On a train
35:22to Liverpool
35:22is a man
35:23with a secret mission.
35:26The Admiralty
35:27wants to unlock
35:28the mysteries
35:29of Wolfpack's strategy
35:30and they think
35:32Gilbert Roberts,
35:33a naval tactician
35:34with a talent
35:35for wargaming,
35:36might be the man
35:37for the job.
35:43So they're sending him
35:45to a top-secret
35:46command centre
35:47for the Battle
35:48of the Atlantic
35:49known as
35:50Western Approaches.
35:55Author Simon Parkin
35:57is taking me
35:57to the Inner Sanctum
35:58of Naval Command
36:00to follow in the footsteps
36:01of Gilbert Roberts.
36:07when he got here
36:08he met
36:09Percy Noble
36:10who was the
36:10commander-in-chief
36:11at the time.
36:13Percy Noble
36:14sort of met him
36:15with a high degree
36:16of scepticism
36:17and he said,
36:18well, you know,
36:18you can have a room
36:19on the top floor
36:20but don't bother me
36:21with all this game playing.
36:24Roberts is given
36:25a team of Wrens
36:26to work with.
36:27One of them
36:28is young Judy de Vivier.
36:31Well, my mother
36:32joined the Wrens
36:32when she was 19
36:33and was sent
36:34into Derby House
36:35to be a plotter
36:35on the main plot.
36:41But then
36:42she was moved upstairs
36:43into the Western Approaches
36:45Tactical Unit.
36:46Those women
36:46were very bright.
36:47They were selected
36:48for that.
36:48They were not selected
36:50to salute and say,
36:51aye, aye, sir.
36:51They were selected
36:52to argue.
36:53And they did that.
36:57The Wrens
36:58and Roberts
36:58get cracking.
37:01Drawing a grid system
37:02on the floor,
37:03they begin to play out
37:05in real time
37:06and attack on a convoy
37:07that took place
37:08the previous month.
37:10Roberts would be
37:11the U-boat commander
37:12thinking, right,
37:13how can I most effectively
37:14kill these convoys?
37:16He had the after-battle reports.
37:17He knew what had happened.
37:18So he was able
37:19to lay it out.
37:21The Royal Navy
37:22has always assumed
37:23the U-boats
37:24fire torpedoes
37:25from outside
37:26the convoy perimeter
37:27rather than
37:28in amongst the ships.
37:31But in their attic room,
37:33Roberts and the Wrens
37:34are about to make
37:35a startling discovery.
37:38It came late one night.
37:40Him and two of his
37:41senior Wrens
37:42were restaging the game,
37:43playing it over
37:44and over again.
37:46He realised
37:47that the battle
37:48could not have played out
37:49in the way that it did.
37:51The U-boats
37:52must have been firing
37:53from within the lanes
37:54of the perimeter.
37:55The wolfpacks
37:57are sneaking
37:57in amongst the ships
37:59to fire.
38:00This was just
38:02a completely
38:02transformative realisation.
38:04That was the
38:05Eureka moment.
38:06It was.
38:08Next morning,
38:10Roberts sends word
38:11downstairs
38:11to the office
38:12of Commander-in-Chief
38:13Percy Noble.
38:16Roberts describes
38:17Noble
38:18of coming into the room
38:19looking icy
38:19and snooty.
38:21But when Roberts
38:22reveals their
38:23exciting discovery,
38:24Percy Noble
38:25grasps its significance.
38:28Percy Noble
38:29shakes Roberts' hands
38:30and says,
38:31you've identified
38:32a fundamental
38:33misunderstanding
38:34in the Navy's
38:35approach to
38:36e-boat warfare
38:37and sends out
38:37a message
38:39to Churchill
38:40explaining,
38:41you know,
38:41what has been found.
38:43Wow.
38:46Roberts and the Wrens
38:47rewrite naval tactics
38:49for dealing
38:49with wolfpacks.
38:51It's a turning point
38:52for Allied strategy.
38:55But no war game
38:56could predict
38:57the deadly twist
38:58to come.
39:09The South Atlantic.
39:12900 miles
39:13off the west coast
39:14of Africa.
39:22U-boat 156
39:24is en route
39:24to Cape Town.
39:27As dusk falls,
39:29the crew
39:30sights a large
39:31liner-turned
39:32troop ship,
39:33the RMS
39:34Laconia.
39:36Although it was
39:37carrying a huge
39:38number of prisoners
39:38of war
39:39and civilians,
39:40it was a legitimate
39:40target.
39:41It was an armed
39:41vessel.
39:42It carried
39:43well over
39:432,500 people.
39:54On board the
39:55Laconia,
39:56it's chaos.
40:0015 minutes
40:02after the
40:02torpedo strike,
40:03the great liner
40:05sinks beneath
40:06the waves.
40:08Although the
40:09Laconia has
40:10enough lifeboats
40:11for everyone
40:12on board,
40:13a significant
40:14number have
40:15now been
40:15taken out
40:16of action.
40:16And as a
40:17consequence,
40:18many of the
40:192,700 passengers
40:21now face
40:22dying in the
40:24water.
40:27The U-boat
40:28surfaces.
40:29The Germans
40:30are after the
40:31Laconia's
40:31captain,
40:32but they're
40:33shocked to see
40:34so many bodies
40:35in the water.
40:37They contact
40:38U-boat HQ
40:39and update
40:39on the
40:40situation,
40:41where Dönitz
40:42makes an
40:42incredible
40:43decision.
40:44He sends
40:44more U-boats
40:46to the
40:46area,
40:46but on a
40:47rescue mission.
40:51As many
40:52people as
40:52possible are
40:53either put
40:54into lifeboats
40:55or even taken
40:55on board
40:56the German
40:57submarine.
40:57And the
40:58U-boat signals
40:59out for help.
41:00It says we've
41:01sunk the
41:01Laconia,
41:02there are
41:03thousands of
41:04people here
41:04that need
41:05help.
41:05We won't
41:06shoot at
41:06you if
41:06you come
41:07and help
41:07them.
41:08But when
41:09the Allies
41:09receive the
41:10message...
41:11They don't
41:12believe it.
41:12They're like,
41:13can we trust
41:14this message?
41:15The Germans
41:16lay a
41:17red cross
41:18flag over
41:19the top
41:19of the
41:19submarine
41:20and they
41:20trail the
41:21lifeboats
41:22behind them
41:23on ropes.
41:24They hand
41:25out food,
41:25they hand
41:25out blankets,
41:26this kind
41:27of humanitarian
41:28response.
41:33Finally,
41:34the crew
41:35and survivors
41:36hear a plane.
41:38Eventually,
41:39you can imagine
41:39the scenario.
41:40On the horizon,
41:41the airplanes
41:41are coming.
41:42Hurrah, hurrah,
41:43we're going to be
41:43rescued.
41:44You know,
41:44it's pitiful
41:45because they're
41:46American bombers.
41:47They're
41:48bombing them.
41:52They're
41:53bombing them.
41:57Some of those
41:58bombs even
41:59hit the
41:59lifeboats.
42:02it's too
42:03dangerous for
42:04the U-boat
42:04to stay
42:05there.
42:05And so,
42:06with great
42:07reluctance,
42:07the commander
42:08of the U-boat
42:09tells the
42:09civilians,
42:10I'm really
42:10sorry,
42:11I'm going
42:11to have
42:11to leave.
42:13For the
42:13civilians,
42:14this is a
42:15terrifying time
42:15and many of
42:16them die.
42:17Very few
42:18of them
42:18actually get
42:19back to land
42:20safely.
42:22more than
42:231,600 men,
42:25women and
42:25children lose
42:26their lives
42:27in one of
42:28the most
42:28controversial
42:29incidents of
42:30the Battle
42:30of the
42:31Atlantic.
42:32Donitz is
42:33furious.
42:34He then
42:35issues the
42:36Laconia
42:37order where
42:38he says,
42:38right,
42:39there's no
42:39moral compunction
42:41to have to
42:42save the
42:43enemy,
42:44the drowning
42:44enemy,
42:45whether
42:45civilian or
42:46armed at
42:46sea.
42:47Laconia is
42:48one of 92
42:49ships lost
42:50to U-boats
42:51in September
42:52as the
42:53devastating
42:53count grows.
43:04The next
43:05few months
43:06will be
43:07critical for
43:08Britain and
43:08the Allied
43:09cause.
43:11But in
43:12autumn 1942
43:13at the
43:14Citadel in
43:15London,
43:15there's a
43:16major setback
43:17for the
43:17Allies.
43:18Roger Wyn
43:19collapses
43:20from over
43:20work.
43:21He won't
43:21recover until
43:22the following
43:23year.
43:25Despite the
43:26crucial work
43:27of the
43:27codebreakers,
43:28the tacticians
43:29and inventors,
43:30the U-boats
43:31are gaining
43:32the upper
43:32hand.
43:34Britain and
43:35her allies
43:36must find a
43:37way to fight
43:38back if they're
43:39to stand any
43:40chance of
43:41winning the
43:42Battle of
43:43the Atlantic.
44:17Other
44:17wars
44:17and
44:18others
44:18will