- 3 months ago
- #considerthis
Five months into the global energy and supply crisis, fuel subsidies and targeted assistance have helped cushion the immediate impact but concerns remain over rising fiscal pressures and what comes next. So how well has Malaysia weathered the crisis so far, and are we prepared for the next phase? On this episode of #ConsiderThis Melisa Idris speaks with Dr Nungsari Ahmad Radhi, Chairperson of Khazanah Research Institute and Board Member of Khazanah Nasional. He is also a member of the Policy Advisory Committee to the Prime Minister and the National Economic Action Council.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:10Hello and good evening. I'm Melissa Idris. Welcome to Consider This. This is the show
00:14where we want you to consider and then reconsider what you know of the news of the day. We're
00:19five months into the global energy and supply crisis now. The fuel subsidies that we've seen,
00:25the targeted assistance over this past few months, they've really helped to cushion the
00:30immediate impact of the crisis. However, concerns still remain over whether rising fiscal pressures
00:37can be sustained and what comes next for the country. So, how well has Malaysia weathered
00:43the crisis so far and are we prepared for the next phase? Well, joining me now to discuss this
00:49weather, I have Dr Nung Sari Ahmad Rady who is the chairman of Kazana Research Institute. He's also
00:55a board member of Kazana National and a member of the Policy Advisory Committee to the Prime
01:00Minister, not to mention part of the National Economic Action Council. Welcome to the show,
01:06Dr Nung Sari. You wear many hats. So, today... Thank you for having me. I want to talk a little
01:11bit
01:11about the crisis in the Middle East. So, when it first started, when it was first intensifying,
01:16I think there was a kind of thinking, a mindset that this would be temporary. But clearly, it has
01:23progressed, has prolonged and there's been waves of the crisis. So, five months on, can we say that
01:31we've actually weathered the crisis? Where would you say Malaysia stands today?
01:35Well, it looked like the crisis was abating, say three, four weeks ago. I think oil went down
01:44to below 80 for a bit. But now it's back up above 90. So, just to characterize the way the
01:52government
01:52has approached this, I think the government has always taken a serious view of it. I think the
02:00M10 started weekly meetings even in March. Even in March actually. So...
02:06Wow. In the... Masa Raya? Masa Puasa?
02:09Before Raya Puasa. Yes. Right through Raya Haji. And we... we... we... we... we... slow down a bit
02:37but we're starting again. There was a thinking that a few weeks ago that actually, okay, we've... we've managed... we've
02:44looked at everything, we've mapped it out, we've got a handle on this.
02:47Yes. Yes. But now the thinking is changed. Now because... because... because... you know, because the US and Iran signed
02:55the...
02:55Because of geopolitics. ...MOU. So... and then oil prices went down to... you know, went down and it stayed down
03:02for a... for a good while.
03:06Then we'll begin to... to sit on harder numbers. Okay.
03:11We can make assumptions. So right now if you were to ask me what would be my assumption for...
03:16crude at the end of the year, I wouldn't be able to give you that number.
03:20Because it's fluctuating so much, is it? No, because... okay, now it seems that the last couple of days, the
03:26US stopped...
03:26stopped... stopped bombing for a bit. Uh... but I don't think the Iranians are gonna... believe anything the...
03:33So it looks like this whole... this thing, the safer assumption, is to assume a scenario where...
03:39this thing will go on for a bit. Okay. But the intensity... uh... we don't know.
03:45So but... so the... the preparation has to be... uh... uh... continuous, in terms of... what we've looked at. We've
03:53looked at.
03:53We've had so many meetings every week. Well, okay. If I may just... um... interrupt you there and ask you.
04:00Help us... get inside government's head. Right? What... what is the thinking right now?
04:05What are the conversations happening? Because the situation seems to be so fluid again.
04:11Okay. So in terms of... I mean... I think March-April was crucial because we wanted to ensure...
04:17because... we characterise this as a supply... Supply crisis. Okay.
04:21Uh... knowing very well that... prices, of course, has gone up. So it was about securing enough supply of crude.
04:29Uh-huh. And also... uh... you know... all your... petrochemicals... uh... that are derived from crude. For plastics. Yeah.
04:37So we were focusing on that. I think in terms of... uh... securing alternative supplies of crude...
04:42I think the government, you know... you know... Petrona has gone around the world. Even PM has gone around the
04:48world.
04:48Uh... you know... signing stuff. So we've secured... uh... we are in better shape in terms of... securing supplies.
04:57Uh... but... uh... price-wise... it's still... subject to global prices. And I think... uh... from a fiscal point of
05:05view... I mean the concern... you know... as... the longer this thing goes on... the higher... the longer the prices
05:11stay up...
05:12Uh... the pressure on the fiscal side will... still be on. Okay. So let's talk about that. The... fact that
05:19the government has...
05:20in the past few months... really... subsidised... um... fuel prices... given the current oil price... uh... global oil prices.
05:28There's no doubt that these fuel subsidies have actually...
05:30been insulating us. Oh yeah. The input prices... insulating households from the real pain. Yep.
05:37In your assessment, Dr. Nung Sari, how effective has that been? Talk to me... give me... um... paint for me
05:42a scenario...
05:44of what could have happened if we didn't have these subsidies. No. If we have not done... both the...
05:50uh... if we have not done... the Budi 95... uh... most households would be... uh... would be affected. And then
05:58we've reduced it from 300 to 200.
06:00But you know... 90 over percent of households never use up their... quota of 300. So they're not affected. So...
06:07It cuts both ways. That's why I think in Malaysia you have a sense of... there's nothing going on... because
06:13life is okay. Yeah, yeah. Uh... the traffic jam... during Raya Haji... Raya Puasa...
06:19Even during thunderstorms. So... so... that really insulated the household side. Yeah. And then the targeted... uh... diesel subsidies. That's
06:32more for businesses.
06:34And then the... the broadening of Budi to diesel. I think that also insulated... uh... many... uh... you know... sectors
06:43in businesses. Uh... and then the... you know...
06:48One good thing actually... that this whole thing has done is actually we've managed to... uh... cut off a lot
06:53of the... smuggling lah.
06:56Okay. The leakages, right? Yeah. The leakages. So... but... surely... most businesses and... almost all households... have been insulated by
07:05this.
07:05They don't quite feel the... intensity of the... of the crisis. Is that a good thing or a bad thing?
07:11It's a... it depends. It's not like... it's... it... it... it builds... it develops... uh...
07:17uh... resilience from a macro country point of view. But I don't think it develops...
07:23resilience from a... individual household and firms point of view. What do you mean by that?
07:28Because you know... I mean... this is a real crisis, right? I mean... it... it amplifies... something that's already... not
07:35good, right? I mean...
07:36we have... 800 over 1,000 new cars a year, right? We've been using... petroleum like nobody's business in this
07:44country.
07:45We've not been very... particular about say... the kind of... uh... light... electricity... and... and... and the way we use...
07:54energy.
07:55So we've not been very... um... what do you call... efficient... energy user. Notwithstanding... we have our own... sources of
08:04energy.
08:05So that... that... that... has taken... you know... from a macro point of view... has taken away... resources that could
08:10have been... used somewhere else...
08:12but instead we use it for... energy, right? So even... in terms of... you know... the credit market... the financial
08:19market... quite a bit of it has gone to... you know... buying cars... and all these things... and people have...
08:24So I think from an efficiency point of view... it would have been a good time... to... to modify behaviour...
08:31but we chose to... largely insulate...
08:35uh... households... from having to make that... that hard decision. So I think the government has done... too good a
08:40job... uh... insulating households... and firms... from... from... making alternative... uh... uh... or better choices.
08:48Okay. Can I... can I... um... can we unpack something you said? You said... we don't realise... just because...
08:54we've been insulated from the pain... we don't realise... that it's taken away... resources. Yeah.
08:57And I want to point to the fact that... the government has already directed... ministries to cut...
09:02up to 10 billion ringgit... in costs. The one that got... viral. Yes... that... well that's true... but... that is
09:08our... opportunity cost, right?
09:09Money that's been spent... uh... on fuel subsidies... Yeah.
09:13means that... are... taken away from... taken away from... taken away from... it has to be taken away... from something
09:18else. Yeah.
09:18Help us... think that through... the opportunity cost... of fuel subsidies... and what it is that we... are giving up...
09:27or... the trade-offs involved. Yeah.
09:28Yeah. Yeah. So people... people... I think... I think most people don't... don't quite... uh... get that... you know... when
09:35you go... when any government...
09:37goes to parliament... and propose a budget... uh... that's a commitment... that you need to withdraw... money... from the consolidated
09:43fund... to... to... to spend...
09:46uh... operating expenses... uh... operating expenses... no more than revenues... you can borrow to... to... to fund... development expenditures... build...
10:05stuff.
10:05Build new things. But you can borrow for that. But for... operating expenses... you have... you cannot spend more than
10:12revenues, right? Right. So...
10:14If, and subsidies are part of operating expenses, if you have budget X and now you're doing 5X, you have
10:22to find it from somewhere else within that, right?
10:25So that's the opportunity cost.
10:29So that's why you referred to that circular that should not have been made public, looking for cuts or savings
10:36in other parts of government to pay for this.
10:39It's because you have to take it from within this, right?
10:43Yes.
10:44Unless you broaden the revenue side, right?
10:48Which means...
10:49Tax.
10:50Which means tax.
10:52So something has to give.
10:53Something has to give.
10:54If you don't want to increase the revenue within this period, then you have to take it from within the
11:00operating expenditure.
11:01You can't go to the market and borrow to do this, right?
11:04If you say you want to build something, whatever, it's fine to borrow.
11:08So that's the thing.
11:09So this is not without opportunity cost.
11:41It insulates the economy.
11:42$20 billion.
11:43Right.
11:44Well, there's always the time lag, right?
11:47So the economy minister has warned that the crisis will become more significant this quarter, the third quarter.
11:53Yeah.
11:53He said, you know, prices, business costs, labor market, all of that's going to feel the impact.
11:58But I want to ask you, you're known as a plain speaking man.
12:03Okay.
12:05Strip away the policy language here.
12:08When he says or he's warning the country that the crisis will become more pronounced or more significant in the
12:15third quarter, what does that mean?
12:17What can Malaysians expect to see if that happens?
12:20I mean, the consumer price index has been contained quite a bit.
12:28I mean, it's been quite okay in terms of the CPI.
12:31But we begin to see on the producer's price index has beginning to rise.
12:37Because at the business level, if something is short, I can't get, I mean, I used to buy it from
12:44you, can't buy it from you.
12:47Then I buy it from an alternative source.
12:49Because I'm a businessman, as I shut down my business, I have to find an alternative supply app.
12:53So I'm buying from another source.
12:55I'm paying higher than what I used to pay you.
12:58So the producer's price index is beginning.
13:01All the input prices will go up as well.
13:03Yeah. So because of materials, right?
13:05Materials.
13:06So that's kicking in a bit.
13:07I think what the minister is alluding to, if this goes on, that sort of thing will kick in a
13:14bit more.
13:15In terms of consumption at the household level, probably because, you know, I used to spend, you know, I don't
13:22know, whatever, RM400 for Ron95.
13:26I'm still paying RM400, so I'm not really affected in terms of my purchasing power, right?
13:31But if you're a firm, you used to, your input cost used to be 100, now it's probably 150, right?
13:38At some point, I may need to pass through that additional 50 that I'm paying now.
13:44So I think that's, so that might kick in into the next stage, I think what the minister is alluding
13:49to.
13:49If this goes on, I might be looking at, maybe I should do less.
13:56So when you said modify behaviour, talk to me about what that means.
14:00No, I think at the household level, we were trying to say at the beginning in March, April, we were
14:06trying to say that actually, can you use less?
14:10Less petrol, I remember that.
14:11Try driving less, yeah.
14:13Let's lengthen the runaway for the reserve that we have.
14:17Use less, right?
14:18Was it successful, do you think?
14:19No, it wasn't.
14:20No.
14:21Because people actually look just at prices, because it's still RM199.
14:25And it's still RM215, yeah?
14:27We are a very price conscious society, so if the prices don't move, you actually don't modify your behaviour.
14:33But the trade-off at the policy level is because the economy is about 60-some percent consumption, you know,
14:41the size of the economy.
14:43So if you take away, you know, increasing, I mean, reducing subsidies would be tantamount to increasing the price, run
14:51prices, right?
14:51And then that would impact consumption.
14:52That would impact the consumption on the other things, right?
14:55And that might have a dampening effect on the economy.
14:58So there's always a trade-off.
15:00Okay, well, then talk to me about that.
15:02Because the government cannot continue to subsidise increases in global prices indefinitely.
15:08For sure.
15:09When you think about the trade-offs of subsidising fuel versus the impact it will have on consumption, how do
15:17you make that balance?
15:18Yeah, so at some point, they must, at the end, this bit that I was talking about, that becomes a
15:26real constraint, right?
15:28You have revenue, must equal to your operating expenditure, right?
15:33At the end, that's your binding constraint, right?
15:38Whatever it is, you have to work within this, right?
15:41So there will be hard choices and that will have to be made as this thing goes on.
15:47And this is from the fiscal point of view, right?
15:50So, you know, I mean, hospitals need to operate, the police needs to do their rounds, you know, the government
15:59needs to function, right?
16:01You cannot stop doing all those things.
16:03What options are on the table for the government?
16:05A, reduce fuel subsidies.
16:07B, cut ministry budgets.
16:10C, increase tax.
16:11B is a given.
16:14Down to the...
16:15Oh, down to the bare bones.
16:16Okay.
16:17So, talk to me about A and C options.
16:20What was it again?
16:21A would be to reduce fuel subsidies.
16:24Yeah.
16:24So there might be both P or Q, price or quantity.
16:29Okay.
16:29So right now, it has stayed the same at $199.
16:33These things come down from $300 to $200.
16:36So those are the two levers, right?
16:38Yeah.
16:39On A.
16:40We don't want to talk about B.
16:41And C would be to increase tax revenue.
16:45Oh.
16:47This year?
16:48Are you kidding?
16:49Okay.
16:50Because as you famously said at a BNM symposium, that policies are often made by more than just economists.
17:00It's decided in the political market.
17:02So we just had Johor, we were having Negeri Sembilan, and we were having Melaka next.
17:08Melaka, not yet announced, but on the calendar.
17:12Sarawak on the calendar.
17:14So pain is not something you want to serve while doing all these things, I suppose.
17:20So the third option, C might be off the table, or at least from a tax-based revenue, right?
17:30I don't know if they can squeeze non-tax revenue from somebody somewhere within the government.
17:37But we need to close the number because this government has also imposed onto itself through
17:47the Fiscal Responsibility Act, right?
17:49Yes, that's right.
17:50And it has been improving.
17:52It has been declining.
17:53So, I mean, there are several numbers there in terms of the percentage of deficit as a percentage of GDP.
18:01The total debt as a percentage of GDP.
18:04So the fact that we had a good second quarter, and a very good, much better first quarter,
18:11so we can take a bit of a slowdown and still get a, say, a nice number like high force
18:15or...
18:16Okay, so there's some buffer at that space.
18:18Because from the fiscal side, the debt to GDP, as long as the economy is growing at five, right,
18:27and your debt is not growing, your debt is growing slower than five, so the ratio is...
18:32So that's a silver lining.
18:34I mean, we've done some things right.
18:38Yes, we've done some things right.
18:40It didn't happen because...
18:41And it didn't happen overnight.
18:43Yeah, and it didn't happen without effort.
18:46It's a lot of effort.
18:47Yes, I remember trying to push through that reform.
18:50I remember the concerted effort, yes.
18:53So, had we not done that, say, two years ago,
18:57then we would not have the sort of space to do this.
19:00Right, this is why we do reforms when the times are good.
19:04Yeah, when the time...
19:05Yeah, I mean, for rainy days like this.
19:07For rainy days like this.
19:08Had we not done that in, what, 2023,
19:11we would not have the space to do this.
19:14Which is why I'm also quite encouraged by Kwan,
19:16by the National Trust Fund, yes,
19:21which is for intergenerational savings, right?
19:24We're saving today for future generations.
19:26It is actually, I think the FRA,
19:30it's a damn good reform,
19:32which has been underappreciated.
19:34I'm also speaking on behalf of wearing one of my hats.
19:39You know, it's actually a fundamental reform.
19:43Yeah, you know, the Minister of Finance,
19:47which has some of the most powerful discretionary powers,
19:52has given up his powers, right?
19:54Through the Act.
19:54Yeah, so that's a major reform.
19:58And the Kwan Act,
20:02they repeal the old one and put in a new one,
20:05it's in a way a commitment, right?
20:07A commitment that says,
20:09I will put some things aside, right?
20:14Especially those that I get from exhaustible sources, right?
20:18Yes, so like Norway did.
20:20Yeah, we did it earlier than that, actually.
20:23Yes, but we never actually utilized it the same way Norway did.
20:27We did it the Malaysian way by saying,
20:28takpelah, when you have to do it, you will work.
20:31So now we're saying,
20:32every year, you have to put it in.
20:34Okay.
20:35Right?
20:36Every year.
20:36And you can only use it,
20:38you can't use the principle,
20:41you can only use the income from the principle.
20:45And for what purpose?
20:46One, two, three.
20:47And you can't do it through the executive branch,
20:51you have to go to parliament.
20:52So I saw someone describe this as intergenerational justice,
20:57which I feel is quite an apt description.
21:01Yeah, because we don't want to use everything up.
21:03We don't, and we want to leave it a little bit better
21:05for the generation after.
21:07Also didn't realize that when people say,
21:08why are we having this problem?
21:10Petronas is around, isn't it?
21:13People forgot that actually our crude oil production has gone down.
21:19It's a finite resource.
21:20Yeah.
21:20And then we're using more than what we have.
21:24Okay.
21:24Even for crude oil.
21:25Well, so are there other opportunities?
21:27Because every major crisis actually forces countries
21:31to rethink all assumptions.
21:32Are there opportunities there?
21:34Could this be an opportunity for Malaysia
21:36to quote-unquote you modify behavior?
21:39Yeah.
21:40I mean, if you look back at the crisis,
21:42I mean, we've had so many crisis for Malaysia,
21:44but the one crisis that looks like this crisis is 1973, 74, right?
21:49The war, the Arab countries had an oil embargo.
21:53Oil, okay.
21:54So we had that problem.
21:55So that crisis, 74, 73, the Israeli war 73,
22:01resulted in 1974 formation of Petronas.
22:05So we knew then we need to have energy security, right?
22:09So we did something.
22:11And people forgot, I think,
22:14in the intent meeting,
22:15they showed the real,
22:17Tuan Razak did a buku hijau.
22:20Because one of the things that came out from that was,
22:23we need to figure out our energy thing.
22:25Then the other thing is,
22:26food.
22:28Yes.
22:29So in this crisis in March,
22:31back in March,
22:32the first thing that we were looking at,
22:34under the worst case scenario,
22:36do we have enough food?
22:36Food security.
22:37Yes.
22:38So back in 74,
22:40they already had the buku hijau,
22:41it was about food.
22:43But then, you know,
22:44things got better,
22:45we got richer,
22:46then we forgot about that.
22:47We got complacent, right?
22:49Yes.
22:49So now we're looking at like,
22:50wow, rice self-sufficiency at 50-something percent,
22:54having to import 45%.
22:55So we were scrambling to secure,
22:58to ensure that our rice stockpile
23:00is enough for X number of months and so on.
23:03And then mindful that
23:04the people that we buy rice from,
23:07you know,
23:07the Chinese,
23:08the Thais,
23:09the Vietnamese,
23:10they are also behaving like,
23:11I'm not going to sell rice
23:13to anybody else,
23:14I'm going to make sure that
23:15my people have enough rice.
23:17So I think food security,
23:19and so food,
23:20energy,
23:21alternative energy,
23:23renewable energy,
23:24would be some of the areas
23:25that the crisis should spur.
23:29Okay.
23:29Alright, so where do we go next?
23:31In the time that we have,
23:31I want to ask you,
23:32what are you watching most closely?
23:34You said at the beginning of our conversation
23:36that if I were to ask you for
23:38crude prices at the end of the year,
23:39you wouldn't be able to tell me.
23:41But what are you watching?
23:42What are you most concerned about?
23:43There's been a lot of talk
23:44that global growth
23:45could slow sharply
23:47in the next quarters or so.
23:49Some countries could be,
23:51you know,
23:51on the brink of recession.
23:53What are you most worried about
23:54external risks and internal risks?
23:56I think externally,
23:57you cannot underestimate
23:59the problem in Ukraine
24:02because that can,
24:04that has a potential
24:07to flare up worse than
24:08in the Iran,
24:11Israel,
24:12U.S. war
24:13is somewhat contained there.
24:17Although it has all this
24:18supply shock effects.
24:20But the
24:21the
24:21the
24:22the Ukraine war is essentially
24:24NATO versus Russia, right?
24:27Again,
24:28on oil and energy, right?
24:30So that's one thing
24:31that I'm very worried.
24:32I'm looking at.
24:34I mean,
24:34I'm not even looking at
24:35Trump punya erratic behavior.
24:37I'm just looking at
24:38the development of that
24:39because that might have
24:40much, much larger
24:43consequences.
24:43And the other one
24:44I'm looking at
24:45er,
24:47maybe because I went through
24:48the 97, 98
24:50crisis.
24:51You always have this
24:52thing at your back
24:54your head that
24:55if there is a regional
24:56er,
24:58bad thing
24:58going on in one of the bigger
25:00economies around us
25:01because we are quite small
25:03and we're smaller than
25:04far smaller than
25:04Indonesia,
25:05smaller than Thailand,
25:06smaller than Vietnam.
25:07If anything
25:08were to happen in the region,
25:10there might be contagion
25:12effect on us
25:13in terms of flows.
25:15So you're watching
25:15our neighbors as well.
25:16Yeah, because
25:17yeah,
25:18because you know,
25:19you're too young.
25:21No, no,
25:21but institutional memory
25:22is good.
25:23Yeah, because
25:23because, you know,
25:24when Thailand
25:26had the BART crisis
25:27and Indonesia
25:27had the Rupiah crisis
25:28then we had the crisis.
25:30there were good reasons
25:32for why we had
25:32we got the
25:34we were afflicted
25:35with the crisis
25:36but there was also
25:37the contagion effects
25:39which was more
25:40original in character.
25:41The earlier point
25:42was slightly more
25:43global in a sense.
25:45So domestically
25:47as long as
25:48we can sit down
25:49and check up
25:50not the two of us
25:50the people having elections.
25:54Okay, so
25:55political peace
25:56is definitely
25:57political
25:58there will never be peace
25:59stability
26:00is the word?
26:01So long as
26:02we have government
26:03and political institution
26:05that can function
26:06and make decisions, right?
26:08Beyond the political cycles.
26:10You know,
26:10gaduh-gaduh
26:10but you have to govern, right?
26:12Beyond the gaduh
26:13as long as
26:14the country is run.
26:15The country, yeah.
26:16Decisions are taken
26:17and we address issues, right?
26:19Yeah.
26:20Well, Dr. Nung Sari,
26:21it's always a pleasure
26:22talking to you
26:22and thank you so much
26:23for being so candid.
26:24Yes.
26:25That's all the time
26:26we have for you
26:26on this episode
26:27of Consider This.
26:28I'm Melissa Idris
26:29signing off for the evening.
26:31Thank you so much
26:31for watching
26:32and good night.
26:35Thank you so much
26:47for watching
26:48and good night.
26:49Thank you so much for watching.
26:49Thank you very much for watching.
26:49Thank you so much for watching.