00:20The point being is, the betrayal of public trust was already been consummated when she publicly
00:29admitted. There is already an admission that she contracted a killer, a mamamatay tao or asasin, to kill the president.
00:39Ito ang pinanindigan ni NBI Director Melvin Matibag sa pagkapatuloy ng cross-examination sa kanya
00:46ng abogado ni Vice President Sara Duterte sa impeachment trial gate ni Matibag.
00:51Taliwas ito sa pinanungpaan ni Duterte na ipatupad ang batas bilang pangalawang pangulo ng bansa.
00:58Pag nagbala kang pumatay at ginawa mo yan, that is no justice to every man. It's not execute the law.
01:06Execute the president yung gusto mong gawin dyan.
01:09Sinubukan tayo bagin ng depensa ang sinabi ng prosekusyo na may pattern of violence si Vice President Duterte.
01:17Pinalabas nila ang anilay konteksto ng kontrobersyal na pahayag ng bise noong October 2024.
01:24Kwento ito ng bise sa nangyari umano nang dumalos sila ni Pangulong Marcos sa isang graduation sa Philippine Military Academy.
01:33Inulit ng bata, louder this time, Mr. President, can I have your watch as a graduation gift?
01:43At sagot niya,
01:47Why?
01:48Why will I give you my watch?
01:51I saw the humiliation sa face ng bata.
01:56I wanted to help him.
01:59Gusto sabihin sa ba niya,
02:01Itong relo ko na lang.
02:02And then I realized na baka mas lalong mapahiya yung bata.
02:07If I do that, so I just
02:12imagined myself
02:13cutting his head.
02:19Sa sunod nito,
02:21tinanong ng depensa si Matibag.
02:23Didn't you take BP Sara's statement out of context?
02:27Mahira po para sa aming law enforcement
02:29na yung ganyang mga statement ay aming pong babaliwalayin.
02:33Katunayan, alam naman po natin, kahit nga biro,
02:35alimbawa po, yung bomb joke nga po sa eroplano,
02:39hinuhuli natin.
02:40Sa aming po sa law enforcement,
02:42we have to give credence to that
02:44and i-process po namin.
02:46Kaugnay nito,
02:47binalikan din ang pahayag ni Davao City Mayor Baste Duterte
02:51sa paglalungsad ng Rage Coalition noong Abril.
02:55Tama na yan, that's okay.
02:57Isang ulo lang naman ang kailangan namin,
02:59ang ulo ni Bongbong Marcos!
03:02Tanong ng depensa,
03:03hindi ba saklaw ito ng freedom of expression?
03:06Unless we are under martial law again,
03:08Mayor Baste should be able to freely express his dissent to the government.
03:13But the freedom of expression has limitation also
03:15kung ito po ay nagba-violate na ng batas.
03:18Banta po sa kaligtasan ng Pangulo
03:21na naging banta na rin po sa pambansang siguridad po.
03:25Kinwestyo naman ni Senator Judge Panfilo Lacson
03:28kung bakit hindi inimbestigahan
03:30at kasuhan din si Mayor Baste.
03:32We will be contemplating also on piling a grave threat
03:35and inciting to sedation as well.
03:37Baka mayroong double standard.
03:39Bakit kaya nag-focus kay Vice President
03:41pero hindi nyo in-apply kay Mayor Baste?
03:44Sapagkat ang isa po din na-develop namin dito
03:47na jury po is yung sabwatan.
03:50And alam po natin,
03:51if we go to court using the jury of conspiracy,
03:54medyo mas mahirap po na ipasok na kaso.
03:57Kaya it's taking much time to develop the case po.
04:01Tinilaki rin ng depensa ang panig ng bisis sa insidente
04:04ng panununtok sa isang sheriff noong 2011
04:08kung kailan alkalde pa ng Davao City si VP Duterte.
04:12Ayon sa depensa,
04:13nangyari ito sa gitna ng planong demolisyon
04:16ilang araw lang kasunod ng isang flash flood
04:19kung saan may mga nasawi.
04:21The demolition that you mentioned
04:24involved the demolition of informal settlers in that area?
04:30Opo. Kaya po may order of eviction,
04:32ibig sabihin po informal settlers po yung papalis.
04:34Are you aware that 30 people died during that incident?
04:38I have no knowledge of that.
04:39So in other words,
04:41are you also aware that
04:44it was the sheriff's refusal
04:46to provide that two-hour extension?
04:49That's why VP Sarah got angry.
04:51Well, that is the claim of the then mayor.
04:54If you know only, if you know.
04:56I have no knowledge of that.
04:57Alright.
04:58Binalikan din ng depensa ang affidavit
05:00ng nagpakilalang Davao Death Squad hitman
05:03na si Arturo Lascañas
05:05na witness din laban kay dating Pangulong Rodrigo Duterte
05:09sa kanyang kasong crimes against humanity sa ICC.
05:13Ayon kasi sa NBI,
05:15ginamit nilang open source intel
05:17ang sinabi umano ni Lascañas
05:19na may kinalaman ang visa
05:21sa extrajudicial killing
05:23noong alkalde siya ng Davao.
05:25Without verification,
05:27you decided to believe
05:29the contents of the document
05:31that you obtained?
05:32Isinama lamang namin po ito,
05:35isa dun sa mga factors
05:36na sinasabi po natin
05:37yung mong pattern of violence na tinatawag.
05:40At doon po,
05:42na doon sa paragraph 270,
05:44sinasabi nga po
05:45na may kinalaman
05:47sa extrajudicial killing
05:48si dating Mayor Sara Duterte
05:51at in fact,
05:51ang sabi pa nga niya,
05:53huwag nyo nang barilin,
05:54kiindapin nyo na lang.
05:55Did you decide to believe
05:57the contents of the document
05:59without verifying it with Lascañas?
06:01Yun nga po yung sagot po.
06:03Opo, hindi ka agad.
06:04Kaya po ikinikwento ko nga
06:05kung paano po namin nagamit yun.
06:07Pero may question ng depensa
06:09kaugnay sa umano'y kaso
06:11ni Lascañas.
06:12This is the same Lascañas
06:14who was charged
06:15by the Senate panel
06:17led by then
06:19Senator
06:20and still Senator
06:21Panfilo Lacson
06:22with a recommendation
06:24for perjury.
06:25Is he not?
06:26Hindi ko po nabalitaan nyo
06:27kung sinar siya ng perjury.
06:29You mentioned na
06:30pinapaniwalaan nyo na siya ngayon
06:31as clarified by the chair.
06:33So are you saying that
06:35pinapaliwalaan nyo na ngayon
06:36without issuing a subpina
06:38to Lascañas
06:39and verifying it?
06:41Hindi po nag-issue
06:42ng subpina kay Lascaña
06:43pero meron pong
06:45naging verification process.
06:46May nilinaw naman
06:48si Lacson.
06:49Gusto ko lang i-correct
06:50na hindi ako
06:52nagpanang perjury.
06:53Binusisi rin
06:54ang pahayag ni Matibag
06:55na patuloy
06:56ang investigasyon nila
06:57sa mga persons of interest
06:59na posibleng
07:00makapagturo
07:01kung sino ang kontratistang
07:03asasi ng BICE.
07:04Paano pala
07:05hunin nyo ito
07:06na palisod
07:07o natunto
07:07ng informasyon ito.
07:08Gayong
07:09sa kanya pong
07:10press code
07:11wala na po pong
07:12siyang sinabi
07:12kung sino mga taong
07:13ito siya.
07:14Nag-re-rely po kami
07:15sa iba't-ibang
07:15intelligence report.
07:17At lumalabas po rito
07:18alam natin
07:19yung kasaysayan
07:20malawak po
07:21ang kanyang
07:22tinatawag na connection.
07:24Nakadevelop po ito
07:25ng mga relasyon
07:26unang-una na
07:26sa mga
07:27men in uniform
07:28vice president
07:29sa security group
07:33at yung mga
07:34double death squad.
07:36So tinignan po natin
07:37at tinignan
07:38by process of
07:39elimination
07:40yung mga tao po
07:41na maaaring
07:42dun nang galing
07:43o maaaring
07:44nakakaalam.
07:45Kasama ba sila
07:46sa persons of interest
07:48itong
07:48vice president
07:50security group?
07:51Paano sila
07:52nagiging
07:52persons of interest
07:53na merong
07:54potentially
07:55manggaling
07:56sa kanila
07:57itong
07:58pagkukontrata?
07:59Yun po yung
08:00precisely the reason
08:01na
08:01ayaw po natin
08:03na yung term
08:04na tinatawag
08:04na masunog
08:05yung atin pong
08:05lead na kinukuha.
08:06Yung nakausap nyo
08:07is hindi pa
08:08actual na nakontrata?
08:10Hindi po po natin
08:11masiguro
08:12dun po sa
08:12natitirang numero.
08:13Meron pong
08:14personalidad
08:15na kasama ron.
08:16Dagdag na tanong
08:17ni presiding
08:18officer
08:18Jesus
08:18Cudero
08:19kay Batibag
08:20may bayad bang
08:21kapalit
08:21ang pagkontrata
08:23kung meron man?
08:24Tumbukay ko na po
08:24yung mga
08:25punto ko.
08:25Sa inyong
08:25investigasyon
08:26may bayad po ba
08:27yung kinausap
08:28ni VP Sarah
08:29para patayan?
08:30Di o man
08:31o ang Pangulo
08:32may bayad po ba
08:32yun o libre?
08:33That is the part
08:34of the investigation
08:35po that we have
08:36to establish po.
08:38Sandra Aguinaldo
08:39nagbabalita
08:39para sa GMA News.
08:41do
08:42o
08:43o
08:44o
08:44o
08:45o
08:45You
Comments