- 19 時間前
「推認」の罠：解散命令を巡る法理と危ういロジック
BGM
Otologic (https://otologic.jp) CC BY 4.0
BGM
Otologic (https://otologic.jp) CC BY 4.0
カテゴリ
🗞
ニューストランスクリプション
00:00Even though there are currently no instances of illegal activity, your organization
00:04It's disbanded. What would you do if the court told you that?
00:10Wait a minute, Macchan, isn't evidence everything in Japan?
00:16There's no precedent for disbanding, so that sounds like something out of a horror movie.
00:22Yes, it exists.
00:24Regarding the dissolution order of the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification,
00:29The decision made by the Kyoto High Court lacked concrete evidence.
00:34The magical word "sleep" is dancing around.
00:38If you watch this video to the end, you will understand why professional pastors are persuasive.
00:43Did they conclude that it didn't exist? And was the judgment made in the name of the law?
00:47How this threatens our everyday rights
00:50You'll see the whole picture of how it's built on flawed logic.
00:55Before we get to the main topic, I want to tell you something very important.
01:00The channel either supported or, conversely, incited criticism of specific religious groups.
01:05It is not intended to be a means to an end.
01:08Yes, I want to make that clear. We have absolutely no support.
01:13I neither agree nor disagree.
01:15This is purely from the perspective of a third-party religious figure, Pastor Dr. Kurose.
01:20Based on the written source, objectively analyze its logic.
01:24We will dissect it.
01:25This is based solely on legal and logical considerations, not on the prevailing social atmosphere.
01:30We will approach this neutrally so that everyone can feel at ease and think for themselves.
01:35I would like to provide some material for thinking about this problem.
01:39We will proceed with this stance, so please bear with us until the end.
01:43Hey, what exactly did you mean by the inference you were talking about earlier?
01:49of
01:50According to Dr. Kurose's observations, the decision to date was made by the religious group.
01:54The issue is the culture of relying on political donations.
01:57The cult leader solicits donations, sends money overseas, and sets a high target amount.
02:03When these are lined up, the amount of donations even after the compliance declaration
02:07Because nothing has changed, the same illegal collection methods as before are continuing.
02:11I concluded that it must be that way.
02:14Huh? The amount hasn't changed, so they must be doing something wrong?
02:19thing?
02:21It could simply be that the fans' enthusiasm continues.
02:26That's precisely the point that Mr. Kurose refers to as being short-sighted.
02:31The court may consider the possibility of illegal acts occurring in a socially acceptable manner.
02:37They're using the phrase "there is" but
02:40These aren't strictly legal terms used in criminal law, are they?
02:44The way the words are used is a bit vague.
02:48That's right
02:50If the ultimate punishment is to disband the group
02:54Specific examples of illegal activities currently taking place
02:59We have to point them out one by one.
03:02But there isn't a single example cited for deciding to date someone.
03:06Yo
03:07Really? Not a single one?
03:11The court is an amazing place that can also check investigations, but
03:15Didn't you do it?
03:17Since Mr. Kurose could not be mentioned, the total amount of donations was the only option.
03:21I suspect that was the basis for it.
03:24Illegal donations are being included among legitimate donations.
03:29They are making an assumption based on their own subjective opinion.
03:32This is incredibly frightening for a country governed by the rule of law.
03:36But Macchan, the cult has had problems in the past, so they should make a compliance declaration.
03:41You released it, didn't you?
03:42How does the court view this?
03:45The court hasn't acknowledged the current illegal activities either.
03:50But the fact that the same amount is being collected as before means that the system has changed.
03:55I strongly inferred that they either haven't shown any remorse or are not even remorseful.
04:00That means that someone who has done something wrong even once will continue to do bad things.
04:05Isn't that just labeling them as "it must be"?
04:08Emotionally, that's how it seems, right?
04:11But legally, even international money transfers must be done within the framework of current laws.
04:16It's an act that's being done
04:17Even if the cult leader used harsh language, that does not immediately violate civil law.
04:22That doesn't constitute an illegal act.
04:23Kurose calmly analyzes the situation.
04:27Certainly, there are language issues and illegal activities that could destroy an organization.
04:33The actions are two different things, aren't they?
04:36The court, in context, forced them to dissolve.
04:40It is linked to the base.
04:42Mr. Kurose is asserting that this is a subjective decision.
04:47Bringing up events from over 10 years ago in today's judgment and further pushing
04:51Confirmation
04:53With this, any organization can be shut down with just the word "fear."
04:58This could happen.
05:00If this leads to a decision to disband, then what the public is saying is that
05:05Will it be resolved?
05:07That's the biggest contradiction in this decision.
05:11Don't be surprised by what Mr. Kurose says.
05:14In reality, even if you strip a religious organization of its legal status, you cannot prohibit religious activities themselves.
05:19Yeah
05:21Huh? What do you mean?
05:23In other words, even if the group disbands, the followers can continue their activities.
05:27Donations and transfers can be resumed at any time.
05:30Nothing is prohibited about dating being problematic.
05:35It won't be resolved.
05:38So what was all that fuss about?
05:41Is it just about removing the organization's name?
05:44Exactly
05:46Mr. Kurose would rather not make a decision that doesn't solve the problem.
05:49We could have shown more direction for a solution.
05:53And that's a critique of the court's irresponsibility.
05:57The desire to simply punish has overridden the logic of the law.
06:02This may be the result of that.
06:04Today we looked at the other side of the word "inference."
06:09It seems that laws are far more influenced by people's emotions than we realize.
06:14It's something that's easily influenced, isn't it?
06:17I agree
06:19But the real work of succeeding Pastor Kurose starts now.
06:24This story was a distortion of logic.
06:27In the next installment, we'll discuss the hellish reality that this can lead to.
06:32This will be the case.
06:34A real hell?
06:36Next time, we'll discuss the disposal of assets after a dissolution order, which is, in a sense, a problem.
06:41Cut into the slimiest part.
06:44What will happen to those 50 billion yen in assets?
06:47What does it mean for a nation to become a thief?
06:51Is the state a thief?
06:53I can't just let that go.
06:56What should have been resolved with administrative guidance
06:58Why is this property confiscation a plot that fundamentally destroys religious freedom?
07:04Are we heading straight for that?
07:06What kind of disruption will occur now that producers have started recruiting rebuilders?
07:10Is something about to happen?
07:12Mr. Kurose even wrote that one should not take the order of heaven lightly.
07:17We will thoroughly explain the true meaning.
07:20This is something you absolutely can't miss.
07:24Make sure you don't miss the next video by subscribing to the channel and turning on notifications!
07:29I would like
07:31See you in the next video!
07:34See you in the next video!
07:36Let's meet
コメント