Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 day ago
Probably Will Not Reveal Presence in City as He Investigates Phagan Case

Colonel Thomas B. Felder said Wednesday that Detective William J. Burns had not yet arrived in New York from his European trip, but that upon doing so he would almost certainly set out immediately for Atlanta to work on the Mary Phagan strangling case.

Felder knows precisely when Burns is expected to reach the city but is deliberately withholding that information for the purposes of the investigation.

"There was no authority for the statement that Detective Burns would be in New York on Tuesday," Felder said. "The date of his arrival has been known in my office, but it had not been made public."

He added that Burns would very likely slip quietly into Atlanta without announcement, conduct his investigation, and depart before most people were aware from their own knowledge that he had ever been on the case.

In Touch With Burns Agency

Felder has remained in constant contact with Raymond Burns, son of the detective and secretary and treasurer of the Burns Agency, who operates out of the New York office. The agency is being kept current on all significant developments in the mystery as they emerge. A full outline of the case will be placed before Burns the moment he arrives at his New York offices.

Handwriting Evidence Grows in Importance

The significance of the two notes found beside Mary Phagan's body continued to grow Wednesday, when several handwriting experts were summoned before Solicitor General Dorsey.

At the Coroner's inquest, one expert had testified that in his opinion the notes were written by Newt Lee, the night watchman at the National Pencil Factory, and two other experts had offered unofficial corroboration of that view. Dorsey, however, has not been satisfied with that conclusion, and has since located experts who reach a different finding entirely.

The handwriting in the notes, these newer experts contend, shows a level of education and training that Lee does not possess. Lee would have required two or three months of instruction before he could produce writing of the quality found in the notes. His own natural handwriting displays a pronounced slant, while the writing in the notes approaches the vertical. The final letters of words in Lee's specimens end abruptly, while the same letters in the notes are carefully rounded, a characteristic associated with deliberate penmanship training.

Mary Phagan's Own Handwriting

A poem said to have been composed by Mary Phagan herself will be among the handwriting specimens compared against the notes found in the factory basement. The poem is titled "My Pa," and her stepfather, J. W. Coleman, says Mary was its author. It reads as follows:

My pa ain't no millyunaire, but, Gee! He's offul smart! He ain't no carpenter, but he can fix a feller's cart;
Transcript
00:00Secret Hunt by Burns and Mystery is Likely. Atlanta, Georgian, Wednesday, May 14, 1913.
00:05Probably will not reveal presence in city as he investigates Fagan case.
00:10Colonel Thomas B. Felder said Wednesday that Detective William J. Burns had not arrived as
00:14yet in New York from his European trip, but that as soon as he did, he undoubtedly would start at
00:19once for Atlanta to work upon the Mary Fagan strangling mystery. Colonel Felder is acquainted
00:24with the day and the hour on which the famous sleuth will reach this city, but for the purposes
00:28of the investigation, he is withholding the information. There was no authority for the
00:34statement that Detective Burns would be in New York Tuesday, said Colonel Felder. The date of
00:39his arrival has been known in my office, but it had not been made public. It is quite likely that
00:44the great detective will come quietly and unannounced into the city, make his investigation of the
00:49mystery and slip out before many persons are aware from their own knowledge that he has been working
00:54on the case. In touch with Burns Agency, Colonel Felder has been in constant touch with Raymond
01:00Burns, son of the detective, who is secretary and treasurer of the Burns Agency and has offices in
01:07New York. The agency is being placed in possession of the important new developments in the mystery as
01:12rapidly as they occur. An outline of the whole case will be laid before Burns the instant that he
01:17arrives at his New York offices. That increasing importance is being attached to the notes that were
01:22found beside the dead body of Mary Fagan was indicated Wednesday, when several handwriting experts
01:28were called before Solicitor General Hugh M. Dorsey. An expert testified at the coroner's inquest that he
01:35notes, in his opinion, were written by Newt Lee, the night watchman at the National Pencil Factory.
01:40The expert was corroborated by the unofficial testimony of two other experts. The solicitor, however,
01:47has not been satisfied with the evidence he had on this important point. Experts were found who
01:52disagreed with the conclusions presented to the coroner's jury. The writing in the notes found near
01:58the body of Mary Fagan, they declared, was much better than the normal writing of Newt Lee.
02:03Difference in the slant. The writing showed evidence of education and training which Lee did not possess.
02:09Lee would have had to be under instruction for two or three months, they said, before he could show the
02:13improvement that is evident between the test specimen of his handwriting and the handwriting of
02:18the notes. Lee's normal handwriting shows a decided slant. That of the notes closely approaches the
02:24perpendicular. The final letter in each of the words written by Lee ended abruptly. The final letters
02:30in the notes were rounded acrefully, indicating a considerable instruction in penmanship. A poem said
02:36to have been written by Mary Fagan will form one of the specimens of her handwriting, which will be
02:41compared with the notes found in the basement of the National Pencil Factory. The poem is entitled
02:45My Pa, and Mary is said by her stepfather J. W. Coleman to have been the author. The poem follows,
02:52My P. A. ain't no millionaire, but gee, he's awful smart. He ain't no carpenter, but he can fix a
02:57feller's cart. He ain't no doctor, but you can bet he handwriting of Fagan notes examined solicitor
03:02General Dorsey, working on new clue in the factory slaying mystery. Continued from page one.
03:08Alice knows just what to do to fix a boy what's got a bloody nose. My P. A. ain't president
03:12because,
03:13he says, he never run, but he could do as well as any president has done. A president may beat
03:18my P. A. at piling up the vote, but he can't beat him, I will bet, a whittling out a
03:22boat.
03:23My P. A. ain't rich, but that's because he never tried to be. He ain't no electrician,
03:27but one day he fixed the telephone for me. My P. A. ain't never wrote a book, but I know
03:31he could,
03:32because the stories that he tells to me are all as powerful good. My P. A. knows everything,
03:36I guess, and you bet I don't care, because he ain't president or rich as any millionaire.
03:40Whenever things go wrong, my P. A. can make him right, you see. And if he ain't rich or president,
03:45my pa's good enough for me, woman witness excited. Mrs. Mary Barrett, the woman who is said to have
03:51been in the factory the Saturday afternoon that Mary Fagan was killed, was in a state of great
03:56excitement when she emerged from the office of solicitor Dorsey Tuesday afternoon. She had been
04:00summoned by the solicitor to tell of what she saw while she was at the factory. It was evident that
04:06she believed her knowledge of the affair had been misrepresented. When she came from the office,
04:10she declared dramatically, if anyone has told any lies on me in connection with this murder,
04:16they will certainly suffer for it. The daughter of Mrs. Barrett was heard to tell the solicitor,
04:21I'll talk with her tonight and then maybe she'll do what you ask.
04:24Move for fingerprint bureau. The police commission at its meeting Tuesday night authorized a thorough
04:29investigation into the advisability of establishing a fingerprint identification system in Atlanta.
04:34This move was made largely as a result of the mystery that has continued to surround the Fagan
04:39case and the possibility that it might have been cleared up within a few days had the city had a
04:44fingerprint expert. There were several distinguishable fingerprints found in the factory basement.
04:49Persons who have had experience in detective work believe that they might have developed the
04:53most valuable clues in establishing the identity of the criminal. Chief of Police Beavers told the
04:59commission of instances in which fingerprints had fixed the guilt of prisoners when there were no other
05:04clues. He was appointed by the commission to work with one of the commissioners in making an
05:08investigation into the feasibility of the bureau plan.
Comments

Recommended