- 10 hours ago
Evil Lives Here - Season 19 - Episode 05: They all Saw his evil
Category
📺
TVTranscript
00:02Oh my, this picture, the twins, oh, they may have been two weeks old when we had this.
00:19It's strange when you look at this picture, how Philip can look so
00:25harmless. He looks like he's excited and happy to be a dad. How can you turn into such a vicious
00:33person?
00:44Susan Sutton has been waiting five long years for answers to what happened to her 19-year-old daughter.
00:50Becky Sutton went missing from a Hollister home in 2003. Her two-year-old son left behind.
00:56He was able to lie to me and get by so easily that I did not pick up on the
01:02cues.
01:04To go from this wonderful, loving nurse, compassionate, took his children to church,
01:14and to end up as a monster. How did he get to that?
01:25The feelings I have now, looking back, how he trapped me, it's embarrassment.
01:31I should have looked closer. I should have, I should have seen some signs, and I feel foolish.
01:40I just tried to be a good mom and a good, a good wife to him, and I was fooled.
01:47How could I have been so off?
01:50I just, I just don't understand.
01:56Sorry.
02:24I just don't understand.
02:39I was not looking for a relationship when I met Philip Dodd.
02:43I was not.
02:47My husband and I, at the time, went through a divorce.
02:51That was very, very devastating to me, realizing that I made a mess of something.
03:00Philip and I met in 2005, and I met him working at a long-term care facility.
03:09I was a registered nurse, and he was a licensed practical nurse, and I admired his practices as a nurse.
03:19Very competent, very caring.
03:22He also told me he had two children living with him that he had custody of, and that he took
03:29them to church.
03:30I thought, my gosh, it was almost like he was too good to be true.
03:58Philip was my first relationship after the divorce, and when I brought him to meet my family, I was so
04:06proud.
04:07I knew they were going to be impressed.
04:09I knew they would see what I saw, and I was showing him off to my family and gaining their
04:18acceptance and approval.
04:20When we were there, Philip seemed to be blending in fine with them.
04:25I saw him visiting with everybody.
04:28It seemed to be a good mood.
04:30I was thrilled.
04:32I thought he was getting along with everyone, but I was mistaken.
04:41After the family get-together, my brother said, hey, I wanted to let you know something.
04:47He said, you know, we really weren't impressed by Philip.
04:52He said, mom really wasn't.
04:56And I was confused.
04:58It did not portray that way to me.
05:02And I specifically asked him, what did Philip do or say that made you not like him or offended by
05:11him?
05:12He said, sis, I just felt he was a bad person.
05:20Very shocking.
05:21Very shocking.
05:22That's complete opposite of what I thought.
05:25And he said, mom thought exactly the same.
05:29And I said, did he say something?
05:31And he said, no.
05:33We just got that vibe from him.
05:35There was something wrong.
05:38I stayed with Philip because I didn't see what everybody else saw.
05:44I thought, maybe this one time, my family's wrong.
06:00I've been diabetic since I was 19, requiring insulin and frequent blood glucose checks.
06:08I believe with his nursing background, Philip wanted to care for me.
06:14He wanted to be checking to see if my blood sugar was good or if I needed to eat.
06:19He was very on top of that.
06:21It made me feel loved.
06:24It made me feel that he was very concerned and worried about me.
06:31One day, it was very odd.
06:37I became so sick.
06:40So sick.
06:42And I know my blood sugars were running high.
06:46And all I wanted to do was sleep.
06:51He appears to be taking care of me.
06:54He's checking my blood sugar.
06:56And oddly enough, he's giving me insulin.
07:00All I remember is him saying, I'm giving you some insulin.
07:07I remember nothing after that.
07:10Nothing.
07:12I was in a haze the whole time I was there.
07:17I couldn't tell you remembering eating or anything.
07:24It's almost like he kept me there on purpose.
07:30In this state that I was in, it was almost as if I had been drugged.
07:39I was there, I'd say, at least three days.
07:47Looking back at that event, after everything I found out later, it's frightening to say,
07:56but I've thought about that, if he could have been taking advantage of me while I was there,
08:02unconscious for those three days.
08:08That does, that does cross my mind.
08:11And to this day, I still don't want to know.
08:16Do you think he's capable of that?
08:19I honestly think he's capable of that, yes.
08:24But again, I saw him as this great nurse.
08:29And he was taking care of me.
08:34So I tried to overlook the bad.
08:43Phillip and I, we were together five months before I found out I was pregnant with the twins.
08:52I was excited, but I could tell he wasn't excited.
08:58I thought he was acting differently towards me because he really didn't want the babies.
09:03And it was kind of sad.
09:07And throughout the pregnancy, I didn't have anything for a child, a baby.
09:13And it was at that time when I told him I was going to go get some furniture and some
09:19clothes and diapers.
09:20He told me absolutely not.
09:24And I specifically asked him then why I couldn't go buy anything.
09:31And he told me the twins may not make it.
09:39I was shocked.
09:41I've never heard of anyone, a spouse or partner, saying that to any female that was pregnant, that they may
09:51not make it.
09:53When there was no reason to say that.
09:57He said it was because of my health.
10:01Just a generic response that he knew that they probably wouldn't make it.
10:09For me, seeing this side of him, it breaks my heart.
10:16It breaks my heart for my children that he could actually feel that way and not love them.
10:28But this goes deeper.
10:31A person that can say that to me is a monster.
10:35Monster.
10:36I don't know that he was planning on doing something to me to lose the babies.
10:41But it made me even more protective over him.
10:45It did.
10:46I knew.
10:49I knew something wasn't right.
10:59My ex-husband was a police officer at the time in Carl Junction and came up to me one day
11:10and he said,
11:12I think there's some issues you need to look into because he's not who he seems.
11:20That Phillip had a past and I needed to do my research.
11:29No, this is not my Phillip.
11:31This is not Phillip that I know.
11:34Be careful.
11:36I assumed that he was just being jealous that I was having a good life and moving on without him.
11:45Even though I didn't fully believe my ex-husband, it was still in the back of my brain.
12:00That evening, I went to ask, and I said to Phillip...
12:04Okay.
12:06My ex-husband said, I need to look at you.
12:10You know, and I just kind of laughed it off, but I was still looking.
12:14And I said, why would there be someone saying that you're a person of interest?
12:20He tensed up a little bit.
12:23He goes, I didn't do anything.
12:26He goes, the reason I am a person of interest is because when I lived in Branson West,
12:33there was a girl in Hollister I was hanging around with that he just went over to party
12:41and have sexual encounters with her and that she didn't really want to do anything with him.
12:49So he left and doesn't know what happened after.
12:52But the next morning, she ended up deceased.
13:08It was shocking when he told me that it was actually regarding someone that had died.
13:16The thought of him doing something so horrible with as kind as he is, no, it didn't.
13:22It didn't end up.
13:24And I still believe to this day, I didn't want to believe that.
13:30I continued to deny the signs and say, that's not Phillip.
13:50As I'm pulling up to my house, there are patrol cars outside, state patrol cars.
13:59And I can see they've already gone in.
14:03I walk in the door.
14:07It was like a punch in the stomach for me.
14:11Officers are in there just going through my stuff.
14:15Personal things of mine, even.
14:18It's, I can't explain that feeling.
14:20When someone is going through your life, your house, your things.
14:27If they're going to find something, what are they looking for exactly?
14:32I don't know.
14:34I realized the search had to do with Rebecca's murder.
14:38And realizing, yes, they're looking for clues.
14:43Regarding Phillip and this murder.
14:48The officers had the things and left.
14:52And then it was just Phillip and I in the room.
14:56I was, I was a nervous wreck.
14:59I was very unhinged at the time.
15:02And he is just appearing very confident to me.
15:08Like, they're not going to find anything.
15:12I did ask him, why are they still after you?
15:17What, what could be with this case that they're not finding or ruling you out?
15:25Why do they continue?
15:29And he responds like they've just got him singled out.
15:34Did you believe him?
15:39I partially believed him.
15:42It could happen to anyone.
15:43They could be singling him out, the wrong person.
15:47But I'm realizing at this point, something's not adding up.
16:04Susan Sutton has been waiting five long years for answers to what happened to her 19-year-old daughter.
16:10We're re-examining the evidence.
16:11We're talking to witnesses, past witnesses.
16:14Becky Sutton went missing from a Hollister home in 2003.
16:17Her two-year-old son left behind.
16:25It makes me angry.
16:28Angry that someone could do that to her, 19, and a two-year-old child.
16:37I feel guilty seeing this.
16:40My heart goes out to that little boy that doesn't even have a mom.
16:44A child without a mom.
16:47How can you do that?
16:50What kind of person does that?
16:53I didn't want to believe then he had done something like that.
16:58You don't want to believe that.
17:04It's just beyond imagination.
17:10I stopped staying with Philip immediately after the police came.
17:16I tell him I'm not coming back.
17:19I will not be back.
17:22I have moved out.
17:24I think I know this person.
17:26But what if I don't?
17:30That's the way I felt with Philip.
17:42This picture is right after the twins were born.
17:48At this time, he and I were separated.
17:55I was scared.
17:58Not knowing what the future held with me and them, but I was going to make it work.
18:08They renewed me.
18:11Oh, I love those kids.
18:14Looking back, it's hard to believe they could be so tiny and helpless.
18:20And I knew I wanted to protect them with all my might.
18:25Nothing else mattered in my life right then.
18:39I had no one else to turn to but Philip Dodd.
18:43I hadn't seen anything violent from him.
18:47I didn't believe he could do something violent.
18:51And again, I got scared and thought I had to have him.
18:55And I'm sure that happens to a lot of people getting scared of their future without, you know,
19:04someone that's capable of working and help bringing in income.
19:09It would have been two or three weeks after the babies were born that Philip and I got back together.
19:16I just wanted to fix it.
19:18He definitely knew I was vulnerable.
19:21He definitely knew that.
19:23And I do think he took advantage of the situation, but I was hoping that he would go back to
19:30the Philip I knew and loved when I first met him.
19:34So caring and confident.
19:48We were over by this wedding place where you can walk in and walk out and get married.
19:54He's like, hey, you want to get married?
19:58It came up off the cuff.
20:01I had shorts on and tennis shoes and...
20:05I'll have to admit, that did seem romantic, him being spontaneous like that.
20:11Yes, that got my attention.
20:13That would be the man that I fell in love with.
20:16Yes.
20:18It's okay.
20:19Let's do it.
20:20And we walked in there and got married.
20:24I was full of hope.
20:35This was the wedding ring Philip gave me.
20:42It meant so much to me.
20:46I've kept it all these years.
20:50I don't know why.
20:53I lived a nightmare with him, but this represents my dreams I had with him.
21:03I actually was in love with him at a time.
21:07A long time ago.
21:20So one day, I was in the passenger seat.
21:23Philip was driving.
21:25The twins were in the middle seat.
21:27And his kids were in the seat back behind there, both of his boys.
21:31I found out Philip had some severe money problems.
21:37It appeared it was all related to his gambling addiction.
21:41I make a comment offhand.
21:45He angers like that.
21:49I had never seen him that angry.
21:52I had seen him angry, but I'd never seen him like this.
21:56And I looked into his eyes.
21:59I didn't know who he was.
22:03The next thing I know, he's reached over from the driver's seat.
22:09He's got his hands around me, choking me.
22:14I thought, what do I do?
22:18I've never had anyone choke me, so I didn't know what to do.
22:21You just automatically grab and try to get their hands off of you.
22:27I'm crying out.
22:28Please.
22:29Please don't do this in front of these kids.
22:32I was screaming, get off of me.
22:35Please leave me alone.
22:38I was crying.
22:40And finally, he came too.
22:45And he took his hands off me.
22:54Very traumatic.
22:56I know it had to have been traumatic for his kids, seeing that.
23:00And to him, it was nothing.
23:02It's like, you deserved it.
23:06You got me mad.
23:07You deserved it.
23:09I'm still crying and screaming.
23:13I was saying, you son of a bitch, get out of my damn vehicle.
23:18I said, don't come around me or these twins again.
23:23Don't ever come around us.
23:24You will never see me or the twin.
23:25And I got the heck out of there.
23:34Knowing that he would attack me physically, then it was becoming real.
23:45It was becoming real.
23:48If the kids hadn't been in the car, I believe he would have taken it another step.
23:55I truly believe that.
23:57But I don't, I don't think he would have held back.
24:02Do you think he would have killed you?
24:05I think he would have came close.
24:13After that, I didn't feel safe.
24:16I was honestly scared for myself, seeing him in such a rage like I'd never seen before.
24:24He was getting worse.
24:27And I didn't want to fear what would, what would come next.
24:44I didn't think anything of the robbery.
24:47I heard about it, but I only listened because that was the bank Philip and I used.
24:53You know, I just kind of wonder why they picked that bank.
24:57But no, nothing really seemed abnormal.
25:02It was approximately a week later, Philip called me at work.
25:09Hello?
25:11And he said, I need to talk to you about something.
25:15He said, did you know anything about that bank robbery over there in Joplin?
25:24And I said, I've seen it, you know, I've seen it on the news.
25:29I don't know anything about it.
25:32He goes, that was me that did it.
25:40I was like, that was when he said, I need you to meet me tomorrow at the park in Carl
25:53Junction.
25:54I will be there.
25:55I need to talk to you about something.
26:00Oh, I'm, I'm bewildered.
26:03I'm shocked.
26:05I didn't know what to say.
26:22I didn't want to call the cops just yet.
26:26But yes, I was planning on something.
26:30To be honest, I was scared to call the police.
26:35I cannot explain how scared I was.
26:42Because I knew if I called the police, I knew I would have hell to pay if he got out.
26:51And came to my house.
26:55And I wasn't, I wasn't willing to risk that.
27:01And he goes, they're after me.
27:07He said, someone from the FBI has been following me.
27:15And I said, really?
27:17He goes, yeah, they're, I can't get away from them.
27:21Everywhere I go, I, they're there.
27:27And I knew, at that point, I knew, I got him.
27:31I got him.
27:32He, he, he lost touch with reality.
27:36It was really bad, his paranoia at that time.
27:41And he goes, what do you think I should do?
27:46I said, Philip, you've got the FBI on you.
27:51He said, we need to go turn you in to the police department.
27:55He sat there for a minute.
27:57I, I was shocked.
27:59He was, you're right.
28:00I need to go ahead and turn myself in.
28:16When I walk through the front door of the police station,
28:19and I say, I've got the, the person that you all are looking for
28:26that robbed the Joplin Metro Credit Union.
28:30She was like, she didn't, she thought it was a joke.
28:35I said, he's right here.
28:40You know, I, I don't think people routinely turn themselves in
28:44at the front desk.
28:46And she goes, I'll, I'll call a police officer right now.
28:50The police officer came up, verified who he was.
28:54He confirmed that he had robbed the bank and they took him away in cuffs.
29:07I did speak to the patrolman for a moment and he did tell me, he said,
29:13Sherry, we, we didn't have any prospects.
29:16We had no idea who had robbed that bank.
29:20And he probably would have gotten away with it.
29:24So he would have gotten away with it if you didn't convince him to turn himself in.
29:30Does that make this moment a little sweeter for you?
29:33Absolutely.
29:35Absolutely.
29:37It was the best day of my life.
29:55Yeah, I went over there to get messed up and have sex with her and, you know,
29:59but I didn't go over there with the intentions of forcing her to have sex or anything else.
30:05I just remember, I was, I was trying to get her to stop fighting or whatever.
30:12I don't, I did it.
30:14I told you to tell her mother that I'd done it.
30:16I mean, I don't know why I'd done it.
30:18And maybe it was because she was, she was starting to reject me.
30:22When he confessed to killing Rebecca Sutton, it was real then that he was a murderer and I had been
30:32living with him.
31:02This is Philip's mug.
31:03shot from the Missouri Department of Corrections.
31:12The first look at this picture, it alarmed me.
31:20It frightened me.
31:24I didn't realize seeing him in a picture like this
31:29would bother me so much.
31:34I look at his eyes, and this is, this is frightening to look at.
31:43I know my pulse is racing, and my heart is beating fast.
31:47I didn't know I was still so frightened of him.
31:51The thing that he had adamantly denied all those years, he did it.
32:00And then I really wanted to know how he did it.
32:07I just remember, I choked her.
32:11I went into a rage, but I felt the life drain out of me.
32:15You know, my stomach, I got sick because it made me mad.
32:18But I relived it in my mind, and I can't figure it out.
32:21And I can't tell you why.
32:24Immediately, immediately, went back to him choking me.
32:32And I thought to myself, I can't imagine this poor girl going through this and dying,
32:42dying by his hands, and I had his hands around my throat.
32:48That just sent chills up and down my spine.
33:00Oh.
33:05Oh.
33:18This is Rebecca Sutton.
33:20And this innocent-looking girl, this is who he murdered.
33:31Look at that.
33:32She doesn't, she didn't deserve that.
33:38Beautiful-looking girl, this young girl did not deserve to die by the hands of Philip.
33:47Who do I apologize to?
33:49Who do I apologize to?
33:50Do I apologize?
33:53What do I say?
33:54Nothing can, nothing can bring her back.
34:01I think that's what bothers me more than anything.
34:13I think that's what bothers me more than anything.
34:26That is frightening.
34:27That is frightening.
34:29That he could kill a couple of years before meeting me.
34:36You can see she's happy.
34:38Happy with her life.
34:42And to take that away from her and her family.
34:46She was gone so long and they didn't know where she was.
34:49They had no answers.
35:18I've never seen this picture.
35:20I've never seen this picture.
35:25This is the forest where Philip hid her body.
35:32I understood he hid it underneath a rock ledge.
35:39I can't believe she was found there.
35:45I can't imagine a more disgraceful thing to do to someone's remains.
35:55No more respect for life than that.
35:59Under a rock ledge.
36:02Just let them decay there.
36:05While the family's crying out.
36:08Where's our daughter?
36:19The family of Rebecca Sutton lined the first two rows of the Taney County courtroom Thursday.
36:24Ready and waiting for a killer's confession ten years in the making.
36:28Dodd admitted he strangled Sutton and dumped her body.
36:31Covering it with rocks.
36:33Pleading guilty to second degree murder.
36:35Had he pleaded the charge of second degree murder?
36:37I don't think guilty.
36:45I like that.
36:47I liked seeing him being judged.
36:57Judged for the crime that he committed.
36:59And seeing him admit that he did that.
37:03It's very satisfying.
37:05I know it was very satisfying for her family.
37:10It is a weird feeling that he did fly under the radar for so long.
37:20And was able to keep it so low key.
37:25He covered it very, very well.
37:31A master manipulator.
37:33I look back over those years and I think.
37:37What truth was there to it?
37:40Because he lied to me the entire time.
37:43There was no truth to that marriage.
37:48Along with the violence.
37:50And the emotional abuse.
37:53And the emotional abuse.
38:23And every prison.
38:29For some reason he looks
38:32He looks different.
38:40He looks frail.
38:44He looks very frail.
38:50oh he is definitely where he belongs
38:58definitely he just looks so weak to me when i think i'm not that strong
39:06i need to remember this
39:09i did this
39:15i was able to get him put away
39:21to keep him from hurting anybody else
39:26i did that
39:29i had the power that day
39:34and i feel seeing him like that it it gives me more power again
39:43i'm glad to see this
39:45he does not deserve to ever get out
39:48i truly believe he would kill again
39:55he's a killer
39:57that won't change
39:59you can die there
40:00i never want to see you again
40:14strangely with my family saying something was off with him
40:18now i can say i wish i did listen to them
40:22i was just trying to be strong then
40:24trying to be independent
40:26trying to handle my own problems
40:29the advice i would give my young self
40:32is
40:33trust your heart
40:35trust your feelings
40:38listen to other people around you
40:40don't think it's just
40:41what you think is right
40:43because sometimes you might be missing
40:46some of the picture
40:49my life post philip has been very good
40:53very good to me
40:56the twins
40:57they're doing very well
41:00very well
41:01just finished
41:02high school
41:03he's missed out on a lot
41:08i feel like a survivor
41:10i'm not that weak person anymore
41:12she's long gone
41:18he thought she was your everyday nice old lady
41:22she did hide all of it as much as she could
41:25john had no idea what he was getting into
41:28i knew she had this history of attempted murder
41:31i think john was a good guy
41:33junior
41:34into his men
41:34new
41:35summer
41:35was
41:35it
41:35hard
41:35to
41:36help
41:36help
Comments