Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 6 hours ago
From - Season 4 - Episode 02: Fray

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:17Previously on From...
00:18You feel it?
00:19You do.
00:20When I walked inside the ruins, I think I went somewhere.
00:24You're a story walker, but you can't change a story once it's been told.
00:30Me and Jade, we tried to save those children and set them free.
00:33We've come back over and over again because we failed the first time.
00:37Knowledge comes with cost.
00:45Where's your father?
00:46He's not back yet.
00:48Wasn't he with you?
00:49Yeah.
00:50We just got separated.
01:04We need to tell people.
01:05We have no idea what happened out there.
01:07We don't even know if it's true.
01:08You, me, Jim.
01:09Jim's not home.
01:11Put that down.
01:12It's here to help.
01:14Sarah took his eye out with a screwdriver.
01:16Can you stitch him up?
01:17Once the baby was born, we were supposed to go home.
01:20No, it's okay.
01:21We got you.
01:21I got you.
01:22Do you think you're some kind of hero?
01:24What you did to that kid up there, you're a fucking monster.
01:31That you played a very special role in a very important story.
01:37I couldn't come to them as I was.
01:40No.
01:41With everything they learned.
01:44Are you all right?
01:44I'm lost.
01:50I'm sorry you won't be here to see what comes next.
01:53It's always my favorite part.
01:55This is when they tear themselves apart.
02:18Hey, Sophia.
02:20Hey, Sophia.
02:30Sophia?
02:36No.
02:37No, no, no, no, no, no.
02:38Sophia!
02:43Hey, hey, hey.
02:44Hey, okay.
02:45Come back inside.
02:46No, I can't.
02:47We need to get back inside.
02:48I can go back in there, please.
02:54Kenny?
02:57Okay.
02:58Get inside.
03:01Hey.
03:02Hey.
03:04What did I tell you?
03:06I told you, you don't go outside.
03:07I told you.
03:08He's dead.
03:12What?
03:13My father died.
03:16I'm sorry.
03:16I just...
03:17I don't...
03:19I don't know.
03:19Okay.
03:20Okay.
03:20I'm sorry.
03:20I'm sorry, bud.
03:21Okay.
03:22Okay.
03:22I just...
03:23You don't go outside, okay?
03:25I didn't mean to.
03:26I just...
03:26I'm sorry.
03:27I don't know.
03:28Hey, what's going on?
03:29He's gone.
03:30It's okay.
03:31I don't know what now.
03:33He's gone.
03:34Okay.
03:34I don't...
03:35I don't...
03:35Shh.
03:36Shh.
03:38I'm sorry.
03:39I'm fine.
03:40Okay?
03:40We're going to take care of you now.
03:41Okay?
04:01Boyd?
04:06Uh...
04:06Would you step back inside for a minute?
04:33What I'm about to say is not for me.
04:38It's for everyone here that people find out what happened.
04:45If people find out what you did, what we did, that's the kind of thing that could tear
04:53this place apart, and I can't let that happen.
05:01So, if anybody asks, and they will ask, you're gonna tell them that you lost your eye trying
05:12to help Bartima.
05:16And if I don't?
05:22Then I will tell everyone that you killed Tilly, and then I'm gonna put you in the box.
05:29You understand what that means, right?
05:33Right?
05:39Good.
05:52They're gonna find out.
05:55One way or another, the truth always comes out.
06:01Well, if I was you, I would make sure it does it.
06:30Good morning, good morning, good morning.
06:34Good morning.
06:36Nothing to do to save his life, call his wife in.
06:41Nothing to say, but what a day.
06:44How's your boy been?
06:47Nothing to do, it's up to you.
06:50I got nothing to say, but it's okay.
06:54Good morning, good morning, good morning.
06:58Though it's been work, don't wanna go, feelin' low down.
07:03And in the home, you start to roll, then you're in town.
07:09Everybody knows there's nothing fewer, and everything is gross inside the room.
07:13Everyone you see, you can't sleep, and you're on your own, you're in the street.
07:18After a while, you start to smile, now you feel cool.
07:23Then you decide to take a walk by the old school.
07:29Nothing has changed, it's still the same.
07:32I got nothing to say, but it's okay.
07:37Good morning, good morning, good morning, good morning.
07:43Good morning, good morning.
08:03When I was just a little boy
08:08I asked my father what will I be
08:14Will I be handsome, will I be rich
08:19Is what he said to me
08:23Que sera, sera
08:28Whatever will be, will be
08:31The future's not ours to see
08:36Que sera, sera
08:42What will be, will be
08:53Now I have children of my own
08:59They ask their father what will I be
09:05Will I be pretty, will I be rich
09:10I tell them tenderly
09:14Que sera, sera
09:18Whatever will be, will be
09:22The future's not ours to see
09:27Que sera, sera
09:32What will be, will be
09:36What will be, will be
09:37Que sera, sera
09:54What will be, will be
10:22Oh god no, oh god no
10:24Oh god
10:27No, no, no, no
10:30No, no, no, no
10:33What's that
10:37Mom what is that
10:38Hey
10:39No mom, what is that
10:41What's in the bag
10:42What happened
10:42Nothing, it's okay
10:44Mom
10:45Ethan, come on
10:47Ethan, no no no no
10:48No no no
10:49Is that my daughter
10:50No no no
10:50Tell my dad
10:51Is my dad in there
10:53Hey, everything's okay.
10:57Hey, Mom.
10:58Okay?
10:59Everything's okay.
10:59Honey, you shouldn't be here, honey.
11:00It's not him, right?
11:02It's not him!
11:03No, no, no, no, no.
11:04Listen to me, okay?
11:06You're gonna go, uh...
11:07You're gonna go with your sister.
11:10You're gonna go down to the barn, okay?
11:11You're gonna check on the barn.
11:12No! No!
11:13Yes, please, please, Julie.
11:13It's not him, right?
11:14Listen.
11:15It's not him.
11:15Listen to me.
11:16Julie, please.
11:17No.
11:18I need you to go to the bar with Ethan.
11:20I need you to be brave.
11:23Can you do that?
11:24Okay.
11:25Take him.
11:26Okay.
11:27Just try to breathe.
11:27Look at him.
11:28Ethan, we're gonna go for a walk.
11:30It's not him.
11:31We'll go find him, right?
11:32Come on.
11:32We'll find him, please.
11:33Right?
11:34Go, Ted.
11:34Hold on.
11:45Tabitha.
11:46Oh, my God, boy.
11:47Tabitha.
11:47Oh, my God.
11:48Oh, my God.
11:51Get it down.
11:52Okay.
11:54Just...
11:55Hey, Jade.
12:04It's not him, right?
12:06We need to go find him.
12:10Julie?
12:12We're gonna find him, right?
12:15We're gonna find him.
12:19You promise?
12:28Okay.
12:30I got it.
12:32Okay.
12:33Okay.
12:34Good.
12:34Good.
12:34Get him.
12:45Nice.
12:47Please.
13:17Okay.
13:18Stop.
14:00I told you.
14:03I told you.
14:03I told you.
14:17Oh, my God.
14:29No, no, no, Hulk.
14:30Oh, no, no, no, come here, come here, come here.
14:34Oh, my God.
14:35Oh, my God, no.
14:39Oh, no.
14:41Oh, Jesus.
14:42Oh, no, no.
14:51Oh, my God.
14:52Oh, no, no, no, no, hey, hey, hey.
14:57Oh, my God.
15:24Why? Why did I tell that to him?
15:28Why? Why did I tell that to him?
15:53Yeah. Of course.
16:06What happens now?
16:11Um...
16:14Well, I'll talk to Boyd about a burial.
16:17Who's Boyd?
16:19He's the sheriff.
16:20He's the one that helped get you out of the car.
16:24He seemed kind.
16:28He is...
16:30He's the kind of thing that holds this whole place together.
16:43Hey, if you want, we could take a walk down into town.
16:47You know, I could show you around a little bit
16:49and maybe get you a spare set of glasses from the storage room.
16:53I'd like that very much. Thank you.
16:57Okay.
16:59I hate it here!
17:02I hate this place!
17:03Hey!
17:05You need to stop, okay?
17:06What did you do? Why did he come home?
17:09I did nothing!
17:10You're lying! You're a liar!
17:13You guys always fight!
17:16I want Dad!
17:18I hate it here!
17:19I hate you!
17:20Please.
17:23We didn't fight!
17:27It doesn't matter.
17:32It doesn't matter.
17:38I got it.
17:41It's heavy.
17:49Just put it over.
17:52It's heavy.
18:08I'm gonna go check on Tabitha and the kids.
18:12I'm good. I'm good.
18:17Yeah.
18:22I'm gonna need some help.
18:24Hey.
18:27Yeah, OK.
18:30Oh.
18:56What's that?
19:01It's okay.
19:08It's okay.
19:13All right.
19:15All right.
19:33We need to clean him up before Tabitha and the kids see him.
19:38Yeah.
19:44Look, knowledge comes at a cost.
19:49The fuck does that even mean?
19:54We need to talk.
20:06Sarah.
20:09Sarah, what's...
20:11What's going on?
20:14They found Jim in the bar this morning.
20:21Is he, um...
20:29Uh...
20:31Uh...
20:32I'm gonna... I'm gonna need you to head back up to the clinic.
20:36But... but you said we get new glasses.
20:40Are you going to the storage room?
20:43Yeah.
20:45Uh...
20:45I can take her.
20:48No, um...
20:49You're... Sofia, right?
20:52I'm Sarah.
20:52I used to work at the diner.
20:54I know where all the good stuff is.
21:00Okay, okay. Yeah.
21:04I know you two are close.
21:06I'm sorry.
21:07I'm sorry.
21:13Come on.
21:16Come on.
21:29The children.
21:31The seven kids, they kept saying this word over and over again.
21:37And cooey.
21:40Okay.
21:42When we played the song at the tree, it was like something...
21:46Unlocked.
21:48And we finally understood.
21:50And cooey.
21:52It means remember.
21:55And we did.
22:00Knowledge comes at a cost.
22:03That's why they wrote it.
22:07They killed Jim because of us.
22:10If we pushed too hard, something would push back.
22:15What's that?
22:16Something Sarah said once we were out in the woods.
22:20Her brother, he had a theory about this place.
22:23He didn't think looking for answers was a good idea.
22:26What?
22:29So what do we do now?
22:33Assuming you're right.
22:34That you and Tabitha have been coming back here over and over and over.
22:38That these kids keep calling you back to help them.
22:41How do we do it?
22:43I mean, how do you even begin to save something that's...
22:47already dead?
22:49I don't know.
22:52I'm working on it.
22:54Yeah.
22:55Work harder.
23:00Come on.
23:18Give me a second.
23:19Mm-hmm.
23:25Hey.
23:28Are you alright?
23:30We're not friends.
23:33Don't talk to me like we're friends.
23:38Okay.
23:43Sorry, through here.
23:45Come on.
24:09Ethan?
24:15Ooh.
24:31And then...
24:32Oh, man.
24:32Oh.
24:37I wish I was wrong.
24:38Oh.
24:40I'm fine.
24:40I did nothing.
24:48Julie?
24:53Where's my mom?
24:56Uh, she'll be back.
24:57She just had to, uh, step out for a minute.
25:01Can I get you something?
25:03I'm going for a walk.
25:05I want someone to go with you.
25:08It's the middle of the day, Donna.
25:09I'll be fine then.
25:11I just need to...
25:12Okay.
25:14Uh, Ethan's asleep.
25:17Julie?
25:19If you need anything,
25:22you just ask me, okay?
25:37Randall?
25:44What the hell do you want?
25:49Hey, what happened?
25:53My dad is...
25:59Jesus Christ.
26:03Hey, look, I'm sorry.
26:04No, don't, don't.
26:08I need your help.
26:12Yeah, okay.
26:14I need you to come back to the ruins with me.
26:17Why?
26:19Because I'm going to save him.
26:29Joy.
26:49Tabitha.
26:53Get out.
26:54No, listen, please.
26:55I just...
26:56I said get out!
26:59This means it's real.
27:03The memories.
27:05Everything they showed us.
27:08It's real.
27:10It is real.
27:15I don't give a shit.
27:17Do you understand?
27:18I don't fucking care.
27:20I can't even imagine what you're going through.
27:24I know you don't want to hear this right now,
27:25but what they did.
27:27This message.
27:30I think they're doing it to stop us from digging further.
27:33They're trying to make us afraid.
27:36Well, then it worked.
27:42Because I'm fucking terrified.
27:47My husband's dead.
27:50Do you understand?
27:52My husband's dead.
27:55You have to think about your children now.
28:01What?
28:03Fuck you.
28:05Fuck you.
28:07What do you know, huh?
28:09What do you know?
28:11Do you want to go back to the bottle tree and play your stupid violin?
28:17Because you've got nothing to lose.
28:21Because you don't give a shit about anybody but yourself.
28:26That is not true.
28:31Should have been you.
28:35Hanging from the fucking rafter.
28:39Should have been you.
29:01Fuck it.
29:26Hey.
29:29Fuck.
29:31Hey, hey, whoa!
29:33Turn it off!
29:34Fuck!
29:36Turn off the engine!
29:37Get out of the ambulance!
29:39No, no!
29:40No!
29:41Finn!
29:42Are you insane?
29:43Get the fuck out of the ambulance!
29:45You want to go for bed?
29:45I'm coming with you.
29:48Jesus Christ!
29:49It's okay, it's okay, it's okay.
29:53Fine.
29:56Hey!
29:57Stop!
30:09I heard about Jim.
30:14Yeah.
30:16They left us a message this time, that's new.
30:20Yeah, Jade has a theory about that.
30:24Sure, everybody's got a theory.
30:26No, there might be something to this one.
30:29Boyd!
30:31Christy's in trouble.
30:32What?
30:33Acosta took the ambulance, she's got Christy inside.
30:45A tad big.
30:47Okay.
30:51Um...
30:52Nope, those do not work.
31:00How about these?
31:02Those look good.
31:07So, um...
31:08It's so sad.
31:10All these...
31:11All these things, they, uh...
31:13They belong to people that were trapped here?
31:17Yeah.
31:21I wonder who these belong to.
31:25Um...
31:26It's kind of nice, though.
31:27I mean, there's a part of them that's still here.
31:30A part that's...
31:32Not forgotten.
31:35I've never really thought of it that way.
31:47What happened this morning to that man?
31:51Does that sort of thing happen a lot?
31:55It never used to.
31:57For a long time, after Boyd found the talismans, things were...
32:02It happens a lot more often now.
32:09I'm sorry.
32:10I-I shouldn't have said that.
32:12It-it's okay.
32:14It's important to be honest about things.
32:16Um...
32:17My-my dad used to always say that.
32:23Do you have family here?
32:27No.
32:29Not anymore.
32:38Uh...
32:39You must be hungry.
32:40We should get some food.
32:42Yeah, I am.
32:43I'm-I'm starving.
32:46Come on.
33:09What the fuck?
33:18Here they come.
33:19Look.
33:20Hey!
33:22No way to the-
33:26What's going on?
33:27Acosta's got Christy in the ambulance.
33:30Where the fuck are they going?
33:37Goddamn Acosta.
33:38Hey, what the hell?
33:39All right.
33:54So everyone says there's no way out, right?
33:56You just go round and round?
33:57Well, I didn't.
33:58The night I got here, we drove in, we stopped in the road, and then everything just-
34:02It all fucking exploded, and then I took all of you at your word.
34:06Why should I believe a single thing you people say?
34:10Look, is this about Elgin?
34:13Look, you need to under-
34:14No, I don't need to understand shit, all right?
34:16Fuck, you're a doctor.
34:18You're supposed to help people.
34:19You're really okay with that?
34:20Oh, I'm not okay with any of this.
34:23And you're a cop.
34:24And what you're doing is gonna get people hurt.
34:26No.
34:27What I'm doing is getting out.
34:29Right fucking now.
34:35Julie?
34:39Julie, slow down.
34:40Slow down.
34:42So while we step inside the ruins, and then what?
34:45We walk through time?
34:47Ethan called it story walking.
34:48Okay, great.
34:49That doesn't make it any fucking better.
34:50Julie, stop, you kid.
34:51What?
34:55Like, what happened?
34:57But you're dead.
35:00What you're going through right now?
35:02Hey.
35:04You gotta take a breath.
35:07And what?
35:10What do I do then?
35:11Huh?
35:13I am telling you.
35:14When I walked into those ruins, I went somewhere.
35:17Okay?
35:19If I did it once, I can do it again.
35:22Even if there's the slightest fucking chance.
35:25I have to try.
35:27Please.
35:33Just tell me what you need me to do.
35:40Just tell me what you want.
35:42Okay.
36:27Why didn't you come home, Jim?
36:32I was waiting for you.
36:36Why didn't you come home?
36:42I'm so angry at you.
36:48All night I thought about what I wish I said to you in the woods.
36:56I thought about the fact that I've loved you since the first moment I saw you.
37:12There was me so much fighting, so much pain.
37:19You were still my person.
37:26You were my everything.
37:28I'm so afraid you didn't know that.
37:37How are we supposed to do this without you here?
37:51We're going to be okay.
37:55Julia, Nathan.
38:00I don't know how.
38:03But I'm going to find a way to take care of them to keep them safe.
38:08You don't have to be afraid.
38:21I love you, too.
38:30Goodbye.
38:41Okay, so slow down.
38:48Slow down.
38:50Slow down.
38:51Stop, stop, stop.
38:55Eddie, fast enough.
38:58Fuck, you're going way too fucking fast right now.
39:02We've been through town twice already.
39:03What more do you need to say?
39:04There's got to be a way.
39:05I'm not just going to sit around and wait for those things to pick us off one by one.
39:08You guys just hang your rocks at night.
39:09You pretend you're safe thinking that Sheriff Boyd is going to what somehow save you.
39:13Let me tell you something, Boyd.
39:15Boyd doesn't know what he's doing.
39:16None of you people know what the fuck you're doing.
39:18But you do.
39:19Yeah, well, at least I'm trying.
39:23That was a lot faster.
39:25Yeah, that's the pattern.
39:26She's looking for a way out.
39:28She's just going to get more and more.
39:30What do we do?
39:32Get the strip.
39:33Yeah.
39:37Victor?
39:37Victor?
39:41You in here?
39:54You shouldn't have come here.
40:04Hey, I, uh, I heard about, about Jim.
40:09I'm sorry.
40:11You should, you should have come here.
40:13You should never have come to this place.
40:17Uh, have you gone to see, uh, Ethan yet?
40:22No.
40:23No?
40:23Okay.
40:23No.
40:25I can't.
40:26You can't?
40:27Uh, well, Victor, he's, he's your friend, and, and he needs you, so when you're ready.
40:34No, God, those words on the wall.
40:37The words, sure.
40:38You see, this, it takes everything good, it takes everything, everything good away.
40:46And then what if, what if it takes you next?
40:50Me?
40:51Well, I'm not going anywhere.
40:53Hey, no, no.
40:54Uh, you don't know that.
40:58No.
40:59You don't know that.
41:01Okay?
41:01So you just shouldn't have come.
41:03You shouldn't have come to this place.
41:08You should never, never come.
41:10Hey, hey, hey, hey, listen.
41:11No one should have come to this place.
41:15Hey, hey, none of us.
41:18But, you know, we're here.
41:21You and me, and we're together.
41:23I'll, I'll take that any day of the week, no matter what gets written on the, on the walls.
41:29We, we face this together.
41:33Okay?
41:34Okay?
41:36No.
41:39Oh, hmm.
41:46So you just walk inside?
41:51Yeah.
41:53And then what?
41:55Then I find my dad.
42:02You go first.
42:03What?
42:04Just walk inside.
42:06Why?
42:07Will you just do it?
42:08Please?
42:28What's supposed to happen?
42:30Nothing.
42:33I, I, I, I just had to make sure that the same thing wasn't going to happen to you when
42:36you come in to get me.
42:38Come back.
42:42Look, look, look.
42:44I need you to give me some time before you pull me out.
42:47Okay?
42:50Okay?
42:50Even if it looks bad.
42:51What do you mean if it looks bad?
42:54Julie, what's going to happen?
42:56Promise me.
42:57Please.
43:00Okay, fine.
43:02You have to promise.
43:04Promise.
43:05I'm right, yes.
43:06I promise.
43:07Okay.
43:09Okay?
43:16I don't know.
43:42I don't know.
44:13I don't know.
44:19Dad!
44:21Dad!
44:27Dad!
44:29Dad!
44:30Dad!
44:31Dad!
44:34Dad!
44:40Dad!
44:43Dad!
44:44Dad!
44:48Dad!
44:50Dad!
44:51Dad!
44:53Dad!
44:55Dad!
45:05Dad!
45:07Dad!
45:08Dad!
45:08Don't pull me out!
45:09There's no one here to help you.
45:12No!
45:13Dad!
45:23I got you!
45:25Go!
45:26Go!
45:27Go!
45:27Go!
45:28Go!
45:28Go!
45:28Go!
45:28Go!
45:29Go!
45:29Go!
45:30Go!
45:31I saw him!
45:33I saw him!
45:35I saw him!
45:36I have to go back!
45:37No!
45:37No!
45:37Stop!
45:40No!
45:41No!
45:41I have to go back!
45:51Ethan!
45:55Ethan!
45:57Can I come in?
46:00Ethan?
46:10Donna?
46:13Ethan's not up there.
46:15What?
46:16I was here the whole time!
46:18Ethan?
46:20Tabitha!
46:20He was upstairs!
46:22Ethan!
46:29Ethan!
46:31Ethan!
46:34Perfect!
46:35You got it?
46:35Yeah.
46:37Hey, she's gonna be okay.
46:47My mom's she hell.
46:49She always believed in hell.
46:52But you know what I think?
46:54I think hell is for people who think that they deserve to suffer, and I don't.
46:59I am a good person, and I don't deserve to be here.
47:02None of us deserve to be here.
47:04I don't know that.
47:05I don't.
47:06I don't know a single thing about you people.
47:08And you know, maybe the real reason that you don't try harder is that deep down you think that you
47:13deserve to be here.
47:14The real reason we don't try harder is because every time we do, somebody fucking dies.
47:19Do you know how many people I've known who thought they knew exactly what this place is?
47:23How many theories I've listened to on why we're all here, or brilliant ideas on how to get out?
47:28You wanna know what they all have in common?
47:30They're all fucking dead.
47:32There is no way out.
47:33Do you understand that?
47:34No!
47:35Okay?
47:36There's a way.
47:37There is a way.
47:39There is always a way.
47:47Ethan.
47:47Ethan.
47:56Okay, pull over.
48:02He's fine.
48:03He's a fucking kid in the woods whose father just died.
48:06Pull over!
48:16No, no, no, no, no.
48:18Hey, come on.
48:19Let's go, let's go, let's go.
48:21Fuck.
48:24Stop!
48:30Chrissy!
48:32Are you okay?
48:33Hey!
48:33Get the fuck out of the car.
48:35Get the fuck out!
48:37Hey, you again?
48:38Yeah.
48:39What the fuck is wrong with you?
48:41Huh?
48:42You could've killed somebody, you know that?
48:44Turn around.
48:48Fucking driving like a crazy fucking person out here.
48:53Huh?
48:54Answer me!
48:55Boyd!
49:06Let's go.
49:07Let's go.
49:08Ethan.
49:09What?
49:10Ethan.
49:11He was walking on the road.
49:12What?
49:13Yeah.
49:33How much.
49:55Huh?
49:55Uh-huh.
49:59Huh?
50:15Dad?
50:19Ethan.
50:33What are you doing out here?
50:35I came to get the radio.
50:41It's broken.
50:43I thought maybe I could send Thomas a message.
50:46The real Thomas.
50:49That he should look for you,
50:51so you wouldn't be alone.
51:00What's wrong?
51:03Everything's okay.
51:06Do you remember what I told you
51:08last time we were here at the RV?
51:11That when bad things happen,
51:13we have to look after each other
51:15and always do our best?
51:17That's right.
51:19And your mom and your sister,
51:22they need that from you now,
51:24more than ever.
51:28You're not staying, are you?
51:33I wish that I could.
51:40Dad.
51:42What's happening?
51:48I need you to do something very important.
51:52The night we arrived here,
51:54we crashed the RV
51:55and we were trapped inside.
52:00You had a dream.
52:03Do you remember
52:04what you dreamt about?
52:07The Lake of Tears?
52:09That's right.
52:11Do you know why?
52:16It's here.
52:18And I need you to find it.
52:21Why can't we find it together?
52:24Ethan!
52:30Ethan!
52:35Dad?
52:37Dad, where are you?
52:39Ethan!
52:40Come back!
52:40Dad!
52:41Please, come back!
52:42Ethan!
52:44The baby.
52:45Why are you here?
52:46I was so worried.
52:47I saw Dad.
52:49He was right here.
52:52Oh, my baby.
53:21I was so worried.
53:22No, he was still
53:40so happy to live
Comments

Recommended