- 23 hours ago
As West Bengal prepares for phase two of the assembly elections on April 29, the political battle intensifies across 142 seats in South Bengal and Kolkata.
Category
ЁЯЧЮ
NewsTranscript
00:00Good evening, you're watching NewsTrack with me, Maria Shaquille.
00:03After weeks of high-voltage campaigning, rallies, roadshows, temple runs,
00:08the curtains have come down, the loudspeakers have gone silent.
00:12Phase 2 voting in West Bengal is on April 29th and it is crucial.
00:17It covers key TMC strongholds where the BJP is pushing hard to make inroads.
00:24From urban centres to rural and minority-dominated belts,
00:28this phase tests anti-incumbency against Mamata Banerjee's welfare model.
00:34Women voters remain a decisive force,
00:37while identity politics could shape outcomes in some pockets.
00:42And having travelled across North and South 24 Parganas and Kolkata,
00:47one thing is clear, the fight is tight and it could swing either way.
00:51So why does Phase 2 matter so much?
00:55Who has the edge, Mamata Banerjee or the BJP?
00:59For Ibarthan or Prevalence, what will Bengal choose?
01:02Before I bring in the guests, here's a report.
01:20Phase 1 is done and now all eyes turn to the real battleground.
01:26Phase 2 of the West Bengal Assembly Elections
01:30Bengal's intense campaign trail has come to a close,
01:33marked by massive roadshows, packed rallies and temple runs.
01:40Ahead of the D-Day, Prime Minister Narendra Modi called for a Vixit Bengal,
01:44urging voters to choose development over division.
01:47And as he put it, say yes to faith and no to fear.
02:17Voting now enters its most crucial stretch.
02:20With Phase 2 scheduled for April 29th, this round is being seen as a potential decider phase of the electoral
02:28battle.
02:29Covering 142 seats across South Bengal and Kolkata, it is both large and politically critical.
02:37These regions have historically shaped Bengal's power equations and once again, they stand at the centre of the contest.
02:46Out of the 142 seats, the Presidency Division, Kolkata, Havra, Nadia, North and South, 24 Parganas, account for 111 seats,
02:55making it the political heartland of the state.
02:58This belt has long been a TMC stronghold under CM Mamta, delivering a sweeping performance in 2021.
03:23Ahead of the D-Day, Prime Minister Narendra Modi called for a Vixit Bengal,
03:35and the government, which is given as a 1.5 per km, which is provided to the prescription for 15
03:39rupees.
03:40It's available to be given in a 15 days.
03:43This is the same for the Vixit Bengal, which is available for the other people.
03:59We have to get an 18-year-old their husband.
04:00You will get an 18-year-old husband.
04:01Yes, you will get an 18-year-old husband.
04:01Yes, I will get an 18-year-old husband.
04:08At the core of this battle are North and South 24 Parganas, the twin districts that continue
04:13to define Bengal's political direction.
04:15With 33 seats in the North 24 Parganas and 31 in South, along with Kolkata's 11 and Havda's
04:2216, this region forms both the TMC's strongest base and the BJP's biggest strategic challenge.
04:34I've seen the Congress, I've seen the CPM and now I've seen the TNC.
04:38Now, if there are BJP, I can see them too.
04:41Which people are angry, are angry?
04:44No angry, they will die.
04:48They will die.
04:49They will end up.
04:50They didn't look at any of these.
04:51Everyone worked here?
04:53No.
04:55Just 4 days, now it's been closed.
04:59The other side of Kelvin has been caught in the middle of the building.
05:03so
05:03foreign
05:12foreign
05:13foreign
05:14foreign
05:28foreign
06:06As the second round of the ballot battle nears, the fight now slips out of the campaign arenas
06:12and into the People's Court. The question now is, who will Bengal finally hand the mandate to?
06:19Mamata or Modi? What next? Poribortun or Prevalence?
06:28With Maria Shakeel, Bureau Report, India Today.
06:36And joining me on the show tonight, Neerja Achwadri, senior journalist and columnist
06:41who has traveled in Bengal as well. She joins me live. Rahul Verma is the fellow of Center for Policy
06:50Research.
06:51We also have Sajjan Kumar, political analyst. Rahul, I'm going to begin with you.
06:55What's your assessment? What has happened so far? And what is your sense of phase two?
07:02Phase two is going to happen two days from now, right?
07:07So, the first phase, 152 seats, which went on April 23rd, the BJP has some presence there.
07:17Those are the areas of North Bengal and parts of Jungle Man.
07:21But it's the second phase where TMC dominates. It's in some ways TMC's fortress.
07:27Out of 142 seats, last time TMC had won 123 and BJP had 18.
07:33So, second phase comes into play only if BJP has overperformed in phase one.
07:41Because even in phase one, last time TMC has led, they had 192-odd seats there.
07:47So, unless BJP manages to sort of like get somewhere around 80-85 seats, there is no point, like, you
07:55know, you can have, like, there are going to be elections in phase two.
07:59But BJP can only be in competition if it overperforms in phase one and manages to make some decent inroads
08:07in phase two.
08:08Okay. So, that's your assessment, Neerja Chowdhury, as someone who was on the ground, this phase has South 24 Parganaz,
08:17which is Mamata Banerjee's bastion, against Havra, again, Huggly.
08:22These are considered to be her fortress.
08:30That's right. But, you know, I talked to a lot of women. I went to Canning, Pura, Pashtim, and that's
08:37in 24 Parganaz, South.
08:39And I heard even women's voices calling for change.
08:44There were a large number of voices of women and others who were for TMC continuing.
08:51But there were voices that called for change.
08:55And there were also voices of women, Muslim women, who were thinking of voting for the Indian Secular Front.
09:05They said, neither Mamata nor Modi.
09:08Now, that may not be a large number, but that also was an opinion.
09:11So, you know, this time, I mean, I didn't travel extensively, Calcutta and certain parts of the 24 Parganaz, South.
09:19But the sense I got was that at least I felt more of anti-incumbency being expressed than I had
09:30personally expected.
09:32And I felt that Mamata, the election is about Mamata.
09:38Mamata is standing there like a rock trying to stop what could have been a deluge.
09:44The extent to which she'll be able to stem this, that will determine the outcome.
09:49And somewhere, I think the women's vote also might get dented.
09:55It may be 10%, 15%, 20% or more, we don't know.
09:59But many women who are voting to TMC said,
10:03So, that also, it might get dented.
10:10So, whether Mamata's own personality, her fighting spirit, the Bengali card she's played,
10:16of Bengali nationalism, whether that'll work, remains to be seen.
10:22Yes, so, I tend to agree with you, Neerja Chowdhury, because I got a similar sentiment traveling in several parts
10:29of Bengal.
10:30So, Sajjan, I agree with Neerja that it is Mamata Banerjee which is standing between BJP and Nabanna,
10:37which is the seat of power in Bengal.
10:39And at the same time, when you speak to people, they speak about cut money, corruption, all that is problematic.
10:49But they speak in the context of Trinamul Congress, the party which has been founded by Mamata Banerjee.
10:55But when it is about the chief minister herself, many are of the opinion that she has done a decent
11:00job.
11:01But then if you reverse that logic or flip that logic,
11:04it is also about a significant population which say that it's about the local candidate.
11:09I think that's where the real challenge for the TMC is.
11:14Yes, precisely. And that is why you see TMC underwent a change of candidate almost on 35% of its
11:23seats.
11:23Either they changed the candidate or changed the constituency.
11:26So, that is a well-known strategy across India to neutralize the anti-incumbency at the local level.
11:33But nevertheless, compared to the 2020 election, the challenge is Herculean for Mamata.
11:38One, because her own popularity.
11:41Remember 2021, she played the son of the soil, you know, sentiment that Bengal needs its own daughter, Bahiragato.
11:48So, outsiders are trying to take over Bengal.
11:51That is completely missing this time.
11:53While TMC is trying to employ that.
11:55You do not see that sentiment working.
11:57And it will have it repercussions in the second round because Kolkata, Havra, Hooghly and lots many adjoining area of
12:04South 24 Pargana
12:06does have this, you know, what you call the Hindi speaker, Hindi Bhashi versus the Bengali Bhashi fault line, which
12:12Mamata played last time, right?
12:14This time you do not see that happening.
12:16So, that is why of the much-douted AAA, Mathwas signifying larger Dalit, not just the Mathwas, Muslims and Mahila.
12:24It is the Mahila which people are talking about, which way they would turn into.
12:28So, you find clearly that like analysts, it is the women who are hedging.
12:33So, while the urban and working women, you know, they seem to have lost the charm of Mamata magic, you
12:42know, in significant number.
12:43In the rural area, you find many of the women, you find split voices.
12:47While there are significant number who may consider Lucky Bandar because it is a continuing scheme.
12:53And that we found as a tangible factor to consider, despite not being very happy, there are many rural women
12:59also who are beneficiary of this scheme.
13:02And yet, they are considering voting for change.
13:06So, which means that even Mamata's own persona, right, has taken a dip.
13:13What is the extent of the dip?
13:15We cannot say.
13:16That remains a riddle.
13:17Why?
13:18Because in this round, last time, TMC got absolutely around 43 lakh more votes compared to BJP, which is huge,
13:29right?
13:30So, if, as Rahul said, if BJP has to win this round, they need to not be around 80, 85.
13:37They need to be around 9,500 because demography is a big factor in this round.
13:42South 24 Pergana out of 31, you have zero, you know?
13:46You may increase to a couple of, say, but you won't enter into double, not 24 Pergana, 4 Pergana out
13:52of 33.
13:53In the Matua Belt and some adjoining areas, you may get, add, say, 10 more seats.
13:59But there is a limit to which you can expand in the second phase.
14:02So, crucial factor would not be the second phase or the women in the second phase because there are a
14:10lot of demography.
14:11So, Muslim women, you know, they may also not be happy with many of the TMC candidates' performance, but nevertheless,
14:20there is a community pressure.
14:22There is a community insecurity which consolidates, despite, grudgingly, you vote for TMC.
14:27Similarly, there are many others.
14:28So, that way, ultimately, it is the women who are hedging, the rural women who are hedging, and that makes
14:36Bengal, second round, contingent to first round, a riddle for all of us.
14:41Yeah, so it's a riddle.
14:42I think that's a great acceptance that we are seeing from analysts and sophologists that we do not know which
14:48way Bengal is going.
14:49There is a large sentiment of anger, there is a sentiment of anti-incumbency, but to what extent?
14:57There is that sentiment of even rural women that I have spoken to, Neerja Chaudhary, who have told me on
15:02record, and we have put those soundbites also out,
15:05that instead of giving us 1,500 rupees, the chief minister should give us 15 days of work, chakri.
15:11They have spoken about it.
15:13They have spoken about insecurities.
15:14They have spoken about other concerns as well.
15:16But the point that has been made by both Rahul Verma and Abai Sajjan Kumar, if there has to be
15:24a significant gain for the BJP, you know, because they are standing at 77.
15:30If they have to make that huge leap, it is this phase where they can make that gains.
15:36The question is, did you sense that kind of massive surge?
15:46Well, no, I would not say this massive surge, because in this area, in fact, I found more voices for
15:56the TMC than for change.
15:59There were voices for change also, but more for the TMC than, say, in the Kolkata area.
16:06You know, I also met many women who talked about, give us a job, 1,500, we can't live on
16:12that, or my daughter is graduate today, but 1,500, what will we do with it, and so on.
16:18But those were, I found, much more middle class women.
16:23The more you climb the ladder economically, the more that kind of a sentiment was expressed.
16:30The poorer people who were in the slums or in the rural areas, a 120-year-old woman, her daughter,
16:41all sticking by Mamata Banerjee, and they feel, they may be dissatisfied, they said, but they feel a sense, you
16:49know, of comfort with her, having delivered, and said,
16:55Ultimately, this is the state, and one young woman, in her own constituency, said to me, you know, when we
17:03are in trouble, we go to Didi, tomorrow if BJP comes, will we go to Delhi?
17:09So that this BJP is equal to Delhi, and a rule from Delhi is the message, Mamata has been having
17:17home, and somewhere it has hit home.
17:20So, as you said, none of us really know, SIR is the other imponderable, that's the wild card.
17:27How is it going to, how are these deletions going to pan out politically?
17:32So there are too many imponderables in the Bengal situation today.
17:37But one thing is clear, BJP is pushing forward, and Mamata is pushing it back.
17:44That much is clear.
17:46Now, will she succeed?
17:47We don't know.
17:48Okay, okay.
17:49So, Rahul Orma, you know, women as a constituency, we have seen invariably, are becoming the deciding factor, election after
18:00election, state after state.
18:02But my question is, from phase one to now, what are you sensing, particularly among the women of Bengal?
18:10And is it different in urban pockets and rural women?
18:16Urban women, rural women?
18:17Will you be making that distinction?
18:21Maria, I don't do that kind of, like, thinking on different groups.
18:27But let me say, tell you what is my thinking on this.
18:30In last three elections, with every election, Mamata or PMC's vote share and seat share has increased.
18:37Every election.
18:38What we know now, that there are some cracks appearing, and that crack creates an opening for the BJP.
18:46There is a narrow possibility which BJP has to be able to reach closer to majority mark.
18:53That cannot happen without BJP being able to attract a large section of women voter.
19:00Because think of it, the way Bengal demography is arranged, BJP is not going to get any vote from 30
19:09to 33% of Muslim population.
19:11So their strike rate has to be really, really high among Hindu voters, and especially among women Hindu voters, because
19:19last time, Mantha Banerjee's lead among women voters was doubled.
19:24So if she led by six percentage point among women, the lead was almost 12 or 13 percentage point among
19:32women voters.
19:33And that lead was much more among poor and lower middle class women.
19:39And given that the kind of strike rate TMC had in sort of like presidency area, that area is much
19:52more urban than the phase one, which went on 23.
19:55So I think what everyone is saying, what Neerjaji said, Sajjan said, and what your sort of like clip showed
20:03in the beginning,
20:04I think there is a yearning or silent yearning for change among a small section.
20:11Whether that is big enough to be able to push now BJP close to majority mark, that is hard to
20:19find out.
20:21Why do you say it is hard to find out, Rahul?
20:24Because unless there is a ground swell, even if you met 100 voters, Maria, 40 of them are likely to
20:32be BJP voters.
20:3544 or 43 are likely to be TMC voters.
20:38So you have to see a swing of only five to six for this to happen.
20:43Think of it like when you met 100 voters, you need to know which are the four or five voters
20:49which are switching.
20:50That is why it is hard to find from the ground, unless you are meeting thousands of people, right?
20:58So that's what I'm saying.
20:59And given, like if you look at the constituency demographic, BJP's own strategy, to my mind, should be very clear.
21:08Forget about 90 to 100 seats out of 294.
21:12Focus on 170 or 180 odd seats.
21:15And in that 180 odd seats, BJP need a 80% strike rate.
21:21That's what the arithmetic of Bengal election is.
21:26Everything else is noise.
21:28The point that you made specifically about the strike rate, let's go back in time and bring in Sajjan now.
21:37Sajjan, 2021, the nature of strike rate, if you can tell our viewers.
21:42Yeah, last time, out of 294, BJP got 37.5% votes and 77 seats.
21:54TMC got around 48%, almost a 10% gap with 215 seats.
22:02So TMC's strike rate would be around 75%, right?
22:11That's a huge, huge sort of a thing.
22:13While that of BJP is around, if I'm correct, around 35 to something around that.
22:19Now, that's a huge gap.
22:21Now, here, let me add to what Rahul was saying more in a quantitative way, because Rahul takes data way
22:27more seriously.
22:29Let me add the quality of why it is difficult to, you know, understand or speculate or make an intelligent
22:35about the strike rate.
22:37Because while in rest of India, every political party wants to dominate the war of perception before actual elections, because
22:46war of perceptions helps you in rest of India to influence the fence eater, the undecided voter who go with
22:54the wind, right?
22:55So when you want to say that we are winning, your real target is there is a segment of voters
23:01who are undecided.
23:02You want to influence them because they go with the wind.
23:04That's the theory.
23:05In Bengal, war of perception is indispensable, even for your own voter to have the confidence to come out and
23:15vote that way you want to vote, particularly if you belong to opposition, right?
23:20So if in Bengal and many of us feel, you must have also seen, there is a subjective and objective
23:26gap.
23:27Subjectively, an overwhelming percentage of voters want to see change happening.
23:35But many of them, it is because they are not confident whether their desire, the party they want to see,
23:42that is BJP, will actually reach that finishing line.
23:46Yes.
23:47So the moment you are even, you have an aorta of doubt, even a couple of percentage of those voters
23:53will step back, not step, come out to vote or even come out to vote, will not be likely to
23:58be called out because there is a postal violence.
24:00That's why what we have seen, that's why, Sajjan, we have seen an extra push in this period from 23rd
24:07to now by Prime Minister Modi, by Home Minister Amit Shah and the entire BJP leadership because they know that
24:13that perception has to be generated that they are reaching the finishing line.
24:18That's why in the rallies, we have seen the BJP leadership say that they have already reached 116 out of
24:26152 seats.
24:27So I think that that is the effort and narrative building which has happened.
24:31Of course, today, the entire campaigning has ended.
24:35So Nija Chaudhuri, Rahul Verma and Sajjan Kumar, really appreciate your time.
24:37Thank you so much for joining us.
24:40On 29th, our special coverage begins early morning.
24:44So stay tuned.
24:45Lots more news and updates.
24:46Thanks so much for watching.
Comments