00:00Come quietly and I'll make sure your story gets heard, Jenny.
00:03I'm Lily Zanuck, who has a faith, so give me this wonderful chance.
00:07For millions of movie lovers around the world,
00:10the Academy Awards represent the highest honor in cinema.
00:14It's the night when the best performances, the best directors,
00:18and the best films are supposed to be celebrated.
00:21But every now and then, something happens that leaves audiences completely stunned.
00:27Sometimes it's an unexpected upset.
00:29Sometimes it's a win that sparks outrage across the entire internet.
00:33And sometimes, it's a decision that people are still arguing about decades later.
00:39They changed the conversation about the Oscars forever.
00:42So today we're diving into some of the most debated Oscar wins in history.
00:46The ones that made audiences pause and say,
00:49wait, did that really just happen?
00:5110. Anthony Hopkins upsets Chadwick Boseman.
00:55The 2021 Oscars delivered one of the most shocking moments in recent award show history.
01:01After the tragic passing of Chadwick Boseman in 2020,
01:05many believed his performance in Ma Rainey's Black Bottom would earn him a posthumous Best Actor Oscar.
01:11Throughout the entire awards season, Boseman was widely seen as the clear frontrunner.
01:16Even the structure of the ceremony hinted at it as the producers unusually saved the Best Actor award for the
01:23very end of the night.
01:24But when the envelope was opened, the name announced was Anthony Hopkins for his performance in The Father.
01:31The result stunned audiences around the world.
01:34While Hopkins delivered an extraordinary performance, many fans felt the moment should have honored Boseman's final and powerful role.
01:43Hopkins later acknowledged Boseman in his acceptance message,
01:479. Will Smith, winning Best Actor after the Slap.
01:51The 2022 Oscars became unforgettable for all the wrong reasons.
01:56During the ceremony, comedian Chris Rock made a joke about Jada Pinkett Smith while presenting an award.
02:03Moments later, nominee Will Smith walked on stage and slapped rock in front of millions watching worldwide.
02:10The room fell into an uncomfortable silence as viewers tried to process what had just happened.
02:15Just minutes later, the ceremony continued.
02:19Later that same night, Will Smith won the Best Actor Oscar for his role in King Richard.
02:25When his name was announced, reactions were mixed.
02:28Some applauded his performance, while others felt the incident earlier in the evening overshadowed the win entirely.
02:35The moment sparked global debate about accountability, celebrity behavior, and whether the award should have been handled differently.
02:448. Bohemian Rhapsody, winning Best Editing.
02:47Bohemian Rhapsody was a massive commercial success and earned several Oscars in 2019.
02:53Rami Malek's Best Actor win for portraying Freddie Mercury received praise, but another award raised plenty of eyebrows.
03:03Best Film Editing.
03:04The editing of the film had already been heavily criticized online.
03:08In fact, one particular scene featuring a rapid series of awkward cuts between characters went viral,
03:15with many film enthusiasts pointing out how disorienting the editing felt.
03:19Critics argued that the film's pacing and structure were inconsistent, making the win surprising to many viewers.
03:26However, some defended the decision by pointing out that the production faced major challenges.
03:32The original director was replaced during filming, leaving editors to piece together complicated footage under tight deadlines.
03:407. Kevin Costner, winning Best Director over Martin Scorsese.
03:45Martin Scorsese is widely regarded as one of the greatest filmmakers in cinema history, yet for many years he went
03:53without an Oscar win.
03:55One of the most surprising moments came at the 1991 Academy Awards.
04:00Scorsese had been nominated for Goodfellas, a crime film that critics and audiences loved.
04:06Many believed it was finally his time to win Best Director.
04:09But when the winner was announced, the award went to Kevin Costner for Dances with Wolves.
04:15While Costner's film was successful and respected, many movie fans felt Goodfellas had a much greater cultural impact.
04:23The result left viewers shocked and disappointed.
04:27Scorsese would eventually win his first Best Director Oscar years later for The Departed.
04:32But for many fans, the Goodfellas loss still feels like a missed opportunity.
04:386. Cliff Robertson, winning Best Actor.
04:40To understand this upset, we have to travel back to the 1969 Academy Awards.
04:46That year, Peter O'Toole delivered a powerful performance as King Henry II in The Lion in Winter.
04:52Many critics believed his performance was strong enough to finally earn him the Best Actor Oscar.
04:57Instead, the award went to Cliff Robertson for the film Charlie.
05:02In the movie, Robertson played a man with an intellectual disability who undergoes an experimental procedure that increases his intelligence.
05:11While his performance impressed voters at the time, the win has since sparked debate among film fans and historians.
05:18Some critics later argued that the portrayal relied on stereotypes and didn't age well over time.
05:25Meanwhile, Peter O'Toole would become famous for being nominated multiple times without winning, making this loss feel even more dramatic.
05:345. Shakespeare in Love Beats Saving Private Ryan.
05:38The 1999 Oscars produced one of the most controversial Best Picture results ever.
05:45Steven Spielberg's Saving Private Ryan was widely considered the favorite to win.
05:50The film had earned enormous praise for its realistic and emotional portrayal of World War II.
05:56However, when the final envelope was opened, the winner was Shakespeare in Love.
06:02The romantic comedy-drama shocked audiences by beating the war epic.
06:07Many critics later pointed to the aggressive marketing campaign behind the film as a major factor in the outcome.
06:14Over the years, the debate has only grown stronger.
06:18While Shakespeare in Love remains a charming movie, many people still argue that Saving Private Ryan for Art Carney beats
06:26Al Pacino.
06:27Al Pacino's portrayal of Michael Corleone in the Godfather series is considered one of the greatest performances in film history.
06:35Yet surprisingly, Pacino didn't win an Oscar for the role.
06:40In 1975, Pacino was nominated for Best Actor for The Godfather Part II.
06:46Many believed his intense and layered performance made him the clear winner.
06:50But the award ultimately went to Art Carney for his role in the comedy-drama Harry and Tonto.
06:56Carney's performance was heartfelt and well-received.
07:00Pacino's performance as Michael Corleone has since become legendary, making the loss feel even more surprising in hindsight.
07:07Pacino eventually won an Oscar years later for Scent of a Woman.
07:11But fans still debate whether the Academy missed a historic opportunity.
07:16Three, Driving Miss Daisy Wins Best Picture.
07:20When Driving Miss Daisy won Best Picture in 1990, it seemed like a heartwarming and emotional choice.
07:27The film tells the story of the evolving relationship between an elderly Jewish woman and her black chauffeur over several
07:35decades.
07:36However, over time, critics began to reconsider the film's themes.
07:41Many argued that the movie treated serious racial issues in a very simplified way.
07:47Instead of deeply exploring the complexities of race relations in America,
07:52the story focused more on a gentle friendship narrative.
07:55This criticism became stronger as other films from that year gained recognition.
08:02In particular, Spike Lee's Do the Right Thing, which wasn't even nominated for Best Picture,
08:07has since been viewed by many as a more powerful and culturally significant film.
08:13Two, Roman Polanski wins.
08:15Three, Roman Polanski wins.
08:17Three, Roman Polanski wins.
08:19Three, Roman Polanski wins.
08:20Three, Roman Polanski wins.
Comments