00:00Attorney?
00:01Ito na-aban naman ako, diba?
00:06Ito si tatay.
00:07Kasalanan ko to yun.
00:08Yung mga nangyari sa PAS, wala na yun ngayon.
00:12Gusto ko lang ngayon.
00:13May magkakasama tayo ulit.
00:15Tingin mo ba makakangiti ng ganyan si Ryan
00:17kung siya talagang pumatay kayong doon?
00:19Sinong niloloko mo?
00:20Gumawa lang kayo ng video
00:21para may pang-alabay kayo sa krimen.
00:23Yan ang sasabihin sa akin ng Piscal
00:24pag-present ko yung forwarded video.
00:27You killed my son!
00:28If you had held him accountable for his actions,
00:31di pa'y aabot dito!
00:33Kayo ng mga kaibigan mo,
00:34you all deserve to die!
00:36Kanina tinanong ko ni Ryan,
00:38umilaban ba talaga kami?
00:39Hindi ko mapangako sa kanya
00:40na matutulungan ko siya.
00:42Makatama sa iyo to.
00:43Baka wala akong mahiligtas na kahit isa.
00:46Hindi na magsasada ko sinuha.
00:47Ay nilangan ba akong singil eh?
00:49Kailangan ko ito pa rin na ang pangako ko kaya Tony.
01:02Alan pangako sa or地方 pangako sa kaisxton sa.
01:04Ah fungo,
01:09Kailangan ko iwaobi maipola...
01:13Dudu Kailangan is down the path is over.
01:21Oh, my God.
02:09Oh, my God.
02:22Oh, my God.
02:27Tingnan mo.
02:29Ito na yung pinag-uusapan ng lahat ngayon.
02:33Yung pagkamatay ni Anton Montenegro dito sa Amuraw.
02:38Lahat dito nakatutok.
02:43Ilang araw na lang, makakakalimutan nila yung kung sa babae yun.
02:52Ito talaga niya nilibig yung babae yun.
02:54Malapit itong kay Ella.
02:54Malapit ito na yung pag-aari ko.
02:56Malapit ito na yung pag-aari ko.
02:57Malapit ito na yung pag-aari ko.
03:09Malapit ito na yung pag-aari ko.
03:37Malapit ito na yung pag-aari ko.
03:40Malapit ito na yung pag-aari ko.
03:42Malapit ito na yung pag-aari ko.
03:42I'll go back to it again.
03:47Ella is my first one.
03:53But she's not my favorite.
03:56But she's my first one.
04:00In all the days of that day,
04:05Ella is the most beautiful smile.
04:09Lula!
04:24Lula!
04:26Lula!
04:36Alice.
04:38Bethany is to talk to us.
04:40Why? Is it about Ryan's case?
04:50Oh my God! Tim!
04:58We're here.
05:00We're still here.
05:02When we called Erica and Beto to ask if we can help,
05:05of course, we said yes.
05:07And, of course, as girls,
05:10we're not able to help.
05:12Don't worry.
05:14Because we got you.
05:17Really?
05:22Okay.
05:24Yes, MJ.
05:26Okay, confirm.
05:28Casa Rosas Hotel, Yonora Hall.
05:31Okay, thank you.
05:39Tim said,
05:41when we called Beth and Erica,
05:44I never thought I would hear your names
05:47in one sentence like that.
05:50That's okay.
05:51Actually.
06:10Do you want to go over yung counter evidence ko para sa inquest bukas?
06:15Kaya ka matumawag?
06:18Gawin na natin.
06:20Payag na ako.
06:24Erika.
06:35Erika,
06:36yung sinabi mo dati.
06:37Sabihin na natin sa lahat.
06:40Yung tungkol kay Edong.
06:48Tingin ko kasi wala na magagawa yung Beth.
06:52Nila mo na si Edong ng galit at paghihigante niya.
06:57Kahit paaminin natin yung totoo, hindi siya titigil.
07:01Patunay yung nangyari kay Anton.
07:05Kay Ryan.
07:08Tama si Marco.
07:11Kailangan natin gawin.
07:13Hanapin at pigilan siya.
07:17Erika, hindi ko to gagawin para kay Edong.
07:21Para to sa akin.
07:23At sa pamilya ko.
07:27Sabi ni Chloe kanina.
07:29Gusto niya ng reset para sa pamilya namin.
07:34Yung mabalik kami sa dati.
07:37Masaya.
07:39Magkakasama.
07:42Na-realize ko.
07:45Ako yung pwedeng mag-press nung button na yun.
07:48Para sa amin.
07:51Yung pagsisinungaling ko.
07:54Ilang taon ko na bit-bit yun eh.
07:58Para siyang sumpa na ayaw ako pakawalan.
08:03Baka pag inamin ko yung tungkol kay Edong.
08:06Pwede na ako magsimula ulit.
08:09Hindi ko na kailangan magpanggap sa lahat.
08:13Wala na ako ikakahiya sa anak ko.
08:17At baka sakali.
08:21Mapatawad kayo ang sarili ko.
08:25Dahil doon sa selfish na desisyon na nagawa ko.
08:29Na sumira sa akin.
08:32At yung dahilan kung bakit nasasaktan yung mga mahal ko.
08:42Erika, please.
08:44Tulungan mo ko.
08:49Sigurado ka ba?
08:52Oo, sigurado na ako.
08:54Uy, alam mo, okay lang sa amin ni Erika kung hindi kayo sumama sa gagawin natin ha.
09:00Siyempre alam namin may mga pinagdadaanan din kayo.
09:03Kaya na namin ni Erika to.
09:33I'm in.
09:34Baka makipagbardagulan ako doon sa Fiscal.
09:38At saka, napagusapan din namin ni Ryan na kahit anong mangyari, dapat matuloy itong gagawin natin.
09:44Siyempre.
09:58Siyempre.
09:59Siyempre.
10:03Siyempre.
10:28Siyempre.
10:29Attorney Melendez, I am fully aware that this is irrelevant to Mr. Mora's case.
10:39May nakinala na akong ganyan.
10:41A man long regarded as having good moral character.
10:47A figure of faith, loved, worshipped by his kingdom.
10:52Walang gulo, walang kaaway, kundi si satanas.
10:56Malinis ang record sa barangay at sa polis.
11:01Until girls as young as 12 began speaking up about sexual abuse he committed against them.
11:13Attorney, kahit san to, lumalaga pak.
11:18So, yes, these certificates looks impressive.
11:23But in my office, papel lang ito.
11:26Mga papel na madaling masunog kapag katotohanan ay nasindihan.
11:32Itong nawalang ka ng malay.
11:34Self-serving.
11:35Walang medical justification.
11:37I am not wasting my time arguing about something that technically did not happen.
11:47Tinawagan kayo na Edong Santiago at inamin niyang siyang may kagagawa ng lahat.
11:53Kaya ngayon, sinasabi niyong frame up ng lahat ng ito.
11:58Yes, Fiscal.
11:59Makikita niyo sa call logs.
12:01Yung number na tumawag sa amin ang parehong number nagbigay ng anonymous tips sa mga polis.
12:05And you know our history with Edong.
12:07He clearly has a motive.
12:10Nabasa ko na yan, Attorney.
12:12Hindi ko kailangan ng lecture mo.
12:15Alam ko na rin yung history niyo.
12:17At niyang si Santiago.
12:19Marami-rami na rin kayong perwiso na dinala dito.
12:23Damay ang buong amoraw.
12:28Let us be clear.
12:30Your claim na tinawagan kayo na Edong Santiago at inamin niya.
12:34Self-serving din.
12:36Walang independent proof.
12:38Walang recording.
12:40Walang witness.
12:42And a phone call does not prove anything sa nangyaring pagpatay sa biktima.
12:49But Fiscal, the matching phone numbers.
12:52The call logs only prove na may tumawag sa inyo.
12:55At kahit pa maihisang galit si Santiago sa inyo.
12:59Hindi automatic na siya ang pumatay kay Mr. Montenegro.
13:02At hindi rin ito pinatutunayan na hindi si Mr. Mora ang pumatay sa kanya.
13:09Sir, I'm not asking you to treat it as a full confession.
13:12I'm asking you to see it as part of a pattern.
13:15Isang lalaking may motibo.
13:17Tumawag para magbanta sa buhay namin.
13:19Gamit ang parehong number na tumawag sa mga polis para puntahan yung crime scene.
13:24Where the evidence is just too neat to be organic.
13:27This is not just drama.
13:29This is orchestration.
13:30At sa ngayon, ang malinaw na datos na meron ako,
13:34bangkay ni Anton Montenegro na natagpuan sa shop ni Mr. Mora.
13:40Ang murder weapon na nasa tabi niya hawak ng kliyente mo.
13:46Ang mga nakita, dugo ng biktima, finger prints ni Mr. Mora, at walang bakas ni Santiago.
13:56Sa palagay mo ba, attorney, hindi pa ba sapat ito para ituloy ang kaso?
14:02Yan pa ba dapat ang tinatanong natin ngayon, fiscal?
14:05Hindi ba dapat kung may realistic chance of conviction na?
14:08Or are we simply sending somebody to trial because he is the most convenient body at the scene?
14:14Attorney Melendez, are you trying to ask questions?
14:18Or are you trying to school me?
14:20Gaya ng pagpapasikat mo sa mga congressional hearings mo.
14:26Yan ang sinasabi niyo sa akong video?
14:53Yan ang inaasahan mong video na magbabago ng lahat.
14:57Sir, kung makukumpleto niyo yung clip?
14:59Eh kung makukumpleto.
15:01Sa ngayon, meron lang tayong video na vertical, shaky, corrupted, madaling i-edit, madaling i-forward.
15:09At wala pa akong medical legal na magsasabing hindi kaya ng timeline ni Mr. Mora ang krimen.
15:18Without that, that video is just noise.
15:23Then let's focus on what we do have, fiscal.
15:25Crime scene report shows na hindi enough yung dugo sa shop sa severity ng...
15:30Attorney Melendez, hindi ka forensic expert.
15:33Sin notes are not conclusive kung wala pang medical legal.
15:38Your theory is nothing but mere speculation.
15:42You're trying to outrun a report that has not even formally arrived.
15:49I have no choice, kundi kasuhan itong si Mr. Mora.
15:56Sir?
16:00Fiscal Relucio?
16:02Lieutenant Colonel.
16:03I have with me the preliminary medical legal report.
16:06Fiscal?
16:08Here's your governor, sir.
16:10Attorney?
16:32Uh, Fiscal, if I may.
16:35Go ahead, attorney.
16:37Fiscal, the report is clearly leaning towards the secondary scene.
16:40Hindi nangyari ang pagpatay sa shop ni Mr. Mora.
16:44This is a preliminary findings, attorney Melendez.
16:47Ang TOD estimate at ang mga pattern na yan ay maaari pa rin magbago sa final.
16:52The report says that Mr. Montenegro likely died at 2.30 in the morning.
16:58We know from the sworn statements of Edgar Mata and Art Lacuna that there was a video sent at 3
17:03.17 in the morning of Ryan Lucid at nagsusupervised ng trabaho sa shop.
17:08That's 47 minutes after the estimated killing.
17:10The video shows, once we see the full clip, that it's not just a pa-cute content for pangga.
17:16It's an objective alibi that you're TOD anchored.
17:19It's still an estimate, attorney.
17:21TOD windows have margins of error.
17:24At hindi pa natin nakikita ang sinasabi mong full clip na yan.
17:30Pwede pa rin may mangyaring magic sa 47 minutes na sinasabi mo.
17:34Yes, Fiscal.
17:36That's a valid trial theory.
17:38If the forensics supported the cleanup and release staging within the shop.
17:42Pero hindi yun ang sinasabi ng report ninyo.
17:44No high velocities pattern on the walls, the ceiling, the tools.
17:48No cast off patterns.
17:50And blood pooling suggests prior pooling and transfer.
17:54Foreign fibers that don't even belong in this environment.
17:57The report is telling you that the shop is not where he was beaten to death.
18:01The shop is where his body was delivered.
18:10Sige, for the sake of argument,
18:13I assume natin na secondary scene ang shop.
18:16He could still help him bring the body,
18:18stage the scene, and hit the victim somewhere else.
18:23I appreciate the argument, attorney.
18:26Pero wala pa rin akong dokumento sa harap ko
18:28na nagsasabing imposible ang participation ni Mr. Mora.
18:43Ano?
18:44Wala pa rin?
18:45Wala pa rin?
18:46Wala pa rin na tayong mag-start.
18:48Wala pa rin eh.
18:50Wala pa rin eh.
18:50Wala pa rin eh.
18:50Kahit si Erica wala pa rin ang text eh.
18:55Paano kung...
18:56Paano kung nakasungan na si Ryan?
18:58Paano kung di pala nakasagot ng tama?
19:01Kung minsan pa naman madali mataranta yun.
19:03Kaya nga lagi kaming tandem nun eh.
19:07Puntaan ko na kaya.
19:09Puntaan ko na ano?
19:10Mahal!
19:13Mahal!
19:38Mahal!
19:40Kaya nga tumakita.
19:47Sir.
19:48Ito yung cellphone
19:49nang isa sa mekaniko ni Mr. Mora
19:50na si Edgar Mata.
19:52Masira po ito.
19:53Pero maayos na ito bumuksan na.
19:55Fiscal,
19:56we'd like to present to you
19:57the original source
19:58of the video sent to Edgar Mata's girlfriend.
20:00This contains the full video
20:02with the original metadata.
20:03Sige.
20:04Play it.
20:05Ang...
20:07Gusto mo ipakilala ko sa'yo
20:09ang...
20:09chicks ko?
20:10Pangga?
20:11Chicks ko?
20:12Magkasama kami,
20:13maggamag.
20:14O ay ano?
20:15Kikita mo naman ah.
20:17Gar!
20:18Ano yun gar?
20:19Ibadensya muna naman kayo yung day?
20:21Ako day!
20:22Wag mong...
20:23Oh!
20:27Ano niniwala ka na?
20:42Fiscal,
20:43your own evidence shows Mr. Mora
20:46working,
20:47relaxed,
20:48even joking with his workers
20:4945 minutes after the estimated killing.
20:52And somewhere out there,
20:54we have a man with a motive
20:55who called us to announce
20:57what he was going to do.
20:58Using the same number
20:59to send the anonymous tip
21:01to the officers
21:01that led him straight to this setup.
21:03Pwede nyo sabihin na nagsisinungaling yung mga mekaniko
21:06na fake ang video.
21:08You can even say na
21:09approximation lang ang time of death.
21:12Pero kailangan nyo sagutin to, Fiscal.
21:14If this was a conspiracy to create a fake alibi,
21:18why would they risk killing Mr. Montenegro somewhere else?
21:21Having to move a body,
21:23stage a crime scene,
21:24hoping that the timing,
21:26the blood,
21:27the fibers,
21:28the TOD,
21:29and the video would all perfectly line up in their favor.
21:33Mas madali sanang patayin na lang siya sa shop.
21:36At hayaan magmokong natural lang lahat.
21:39Pero hindi ganun ang nangyari.
21:41Right now, the only thing tying Mr. Mora to this case
21:44is his physical presence in the room
21:46that your own forensics are screaming is staged.
21:49Pero nasan si Mr. Montenegro sa video?
21:51Walang bangkay sa paligid.
21:53Walang nimansya ng dugok.
21:55Walang sugat ni gasgas ang nasasaktal.
21:59Walang magic.
22:01So the question is not,
22:03can we technically file this case?
22:05The question is,
22:06do you honestly believe
22:07that there is a realistic chance of convicting him
22:10without lying to yourself about your own evidence?
22:13And if we still insist pinning this crime on him
22:17sa kabila ng katotohanan na nakaharap sa atin ngayon,
22:21then let's call it by its real name.
22:24Injustice.
22:39Injustice.
22:54What?
22:54Ibig sabihin ba na ito?
22:55Abswelto ka na?
22:58Mahal, ag-aggaling nga eh.
22:59Alam mo parang pelikula,
23:01Last Minute, damati yung preliminary medical legal report
23:03na dalawang oras nang patay si Anton
23:05nung matagpuan siya sa shop.
23:07Pero nahinahan pa rin ng fiscal doon.
23:09Buti na lang dumating si Marco.
23:12Siya yung may dala ng strongest evidence natin.
23:15Eh, sabi kasi nito na tagilid yung video kong the original source.
23:20Kaya pinahayos ko yung cellphone ng mekana ko ni Ryan.
23:22So yun na nga.
23:23Napatunayin sa video na magkasama sila,
23:27magtatrabaho.
23:28Kung si Ryan, maayos, walang sugat.
23:31Ilang minutes pagkatapos ng estimated time of death ni Anton?
23:34Sobrang thank you ah, Erica.
23:37Thank you talaga.
23:37Ang dami ko ng utang.
23:45Tilago ko to kasama nung
23:48lahat ng bagay na may kinalaman nung high school tayo.
23:52Sabi ko noon gusto ko mag-move on.
23:56Pero ang totoo,
24:00gusto ko siya kalimutan kasi nahihiya at nakukonsensya.
24:06Pero ngayon, suot ko siya.
24:08Okay lang ba?
24:18Ba't naman hindi?
24:20Of course it's okay.
24:22Saka, what do you expect?
24:24Sasabihin ko sa'yo na tanggalin mo yan.
24:26Ayaw kita maging friend.
24:27Of course not.
24:28Ayun lang kaya meron ako.
24:31Seriously.
24:32Masaya ako na kayo ang meron ako.
24:42Eh ay,
24:43ayaw.
24:44Ayaw!
24:44Ayaw!
24:45Ayaw!
24:46Ayaw!
24:47Ayaw!
25:03Ayaw!
25:06We ask you all to come here today to give a statement about the death of Anton Montenegro
25:15and an incident that happened 14 years ago.
25:46Hey, auntie, do you want me to come here?
25:49Don't you want me to come here?
25:51Do you want me to come here?
25:54We're not going here yet. We're going to change the story.
25:56We're going to try to fix the wrong thing.
25:58You're going to die!
26:00You're going to die!
26:02It's a good time for us to die.
26:09We're going to die.
26:11We're going to die. We're going to die.
26:15We're going to die to the end of Edong.
26:16Edong, we're going to die!
26:17We're going to die if we're not going to die.
26:20If you want to die, you have to die.
26:23We need to die.
26:24I'm not saying that this is a giant thing.
26:27You're dead!
26:29You're dead!
26:30You're dead!
Comments