00:00Good character arises during the conduct of the trial on the issue as to whether a jury
00:09should convict or not. So there's a role for good character to be considered by a jury
00:15before they decide whether somebody is or is not guilty. And that's a historical matter
00:23and it applies in every trial where character arises, good character arises. And then if a person
00:31is convicted, then it's been traditional both at common law and under statute for good character
00:37to be available to be considered by the court on the issue of what sentence should be imposed.
00:46Okay. And now, Anthony, changes to that character reference is being taken out of that
00:52last process that you're talking about there, the sentencing. How big a part has character
00:56references played when it comes to sentencing and what other factors are there that go into that?
01:03Well, I think it's a not unimportant factor. It's true, as the majority report says here,
01:11and I think we should bear in mind that there's a majority report that recommends the abolition of
01:17good character altogether, both at common law and under statute. And there's a minority report that
01:24is against that proposal. So when you come to a trial and somebody's convicted and they are a person
01:34of good character, I think it has been decided by the High Court that you have to give consideration to
01:43that fact. You can't just say, well, I'm not going to take it into account at all. That's what happened
01:47in the case of Father Ryan, a priest, a pedophile priest who admittedly had a pretty, pretty,
01:57pretty terrible series of convictions to confront. But he had been in many parts of his life
02:04quite, apparently quite a decent person. So you have this conundrum as a sentencing judge. Does it
02:16affect your decision? Do you, in fact, give it much weight? Well, I think the answer to that is
02:21every single case depends on its own situation and its own circumstances. And that's what I think is the
02:29beauty of being able to consider a factor like good character. It may have very little weight at all
02:37in the majority of cases. It certainly would have probably very little weight in a case where a very
02:45serious crime has been committed. But, you know, the whole idea of sentencing is that the punishment
02:51should fit the crime. But it also needs to fit the person who has been convicted of the crime.
02:59In other words, what I'm saying is justice should always be individualised. And once you get to the
03:05point where you say courts can't consider this factor at all, then I think you're running into
03:13a trouble. I think that you're getting into a society that is being dominated by populist demands,
03:22no doubt well meant demands, and no doubt demands that have some, you know, justification. But to just
03:30deprive a person who's convicted of any consideration being allowed for the fact that he or she may have
03:38lived an unblemished life before committing a crime, it seems to me to be a step too far.
03:44I mean, you used to sit on the New South Wales Sentencing Council. I believe that there wasn't
03:48a unanimous consideration for this. There were some dissenting votes on this. So just to be clear,
03:55you would stand against abolishing this, would you? Yes, I would. In the same way that I'm against
04:01imposing mandatory sentences on juvenile defenders or even on adult offenders. I think that you need to
04:10leave the discretions with the court and you need to recognise that every single person who comes
04:16before a court for sentence is an individual and will have individual circumstances that flow into
04:24explaining, if you can find the explanation for why the crime was committed, for what sort of person they
04:30are, for what their prospects are for rehabilitation, whether they're likely to re-offend, whether the
04:36community is, you know, at risk if the person is not sent to prison and so on. All these considerations
04:43are very personal and very individualised. Once you bring in a blanket rule to say you have no discretion
04:50at all to consider what has been a factor for many, many years in the sentencing process,
04:57then I'm afraid I can't agree with that. And so we have a group of sexual abuse survivors who have
05:04been fighting for this. On the other side, others say it might limit defendants' rights. Just how tricky
05:10is that role of the sentencing judge when balancing the victims and their trauma that they have to go
05:16through and the rights to a fair sentence? Well, it's complex and it is difficult. But I think,
05:22you know, from my experience and looking at the fine role other men and women have played as judges in
05:28the Supreme Court and in the District Court and in the local courts, I think as difficult and as complex as
05:36it is, judges and magistrates do a very fine job in reaching the right conclusion. And we have appeal
05:43structures that are there if, in a particular case, a decision has been reached that is not the right
05:49one. So I think that our present system doesn't need this heavy-handed approach of ruling out what have
05:58been traditionally, you know, allowable approaches to sentencing. And just finally, Anthony, can I just
06:05ask your expertise on this is what's going on in New South Wales? How does it compare to other states
06:10and territories? Well, I think that following the Royal Commission into institutionalised sexual abuse,
06:16a recommendation went out to say that child sexual offences should be put into a separate category.
06:23And if, in a particular case, it could be observed that a defendant may have been able to commit
06:30these offences because of his good character and because of the position he held in society,
06:36then in that case, character should not be taken into consideration. So that's been adopted,
06:45I think, pretty well throughout Australia. I don't think that, as far as I know,
06:52there's been another state where character has been ruled out altogether. This is the start of
06:59it and I assume that it'll follow a pattern of replication in other states, but I don't think it's
07:07a good thing. Anthony Wheeler, KC, good of you to take time to speak with me. Thank you.