Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 year ago
Anthony Whealy KC is a former New South Wales Supreme Court judge and gives his reaction to today’s sentencing of Erin Patterson.

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:00Well, I think it was a very clearly constructed sentence. It was well explained by the judge.
00:11I think the people who watched with interest throughout the trial and who then came along at this last concluding phase for the sentence would understand perfectly well the legal principles the judge had applied and how he came to the conclusion he did.
00:28And the conclusion, I must say, seemed to me to be the correct one and a very fair one.
00:34When it comes to making that decision, what would Justice Beale have been taking into consideration with the sentence, with respect to what weight is given to punishment, to justice, to the victim impact statements, etc.?
00:49It's a complicated process, but the way the judge explained it, it came across quite clearly.
00:55So, in a nutshell, the judge's task is to weigh up the objective seriousness of the offence and because of the statutory provisions in Victoria, he does that in part by looking at what are called aggravating features and mitigating features.
01:13Having determined the features that aggravate the offence, make it more serious, and having seen whether any mitigating factors carry significant weight or not.
01:26He then determines punishment by what's known as a kind of individual synthesis.
01:34In other words, it could be said, loosely speaking, that he draws on his experience to find the correct sentence to impose.
01:44Here, of course, the maximum sentence is set by statute, and he had no difficulty in seeing that these murders and attempted murder were cases that fell right at the point of the maximum sentence.
01:58So, there was no complication about that.
02:00The only complication for the judge was to determine whether he should set a non-parole period or not.
02:06And in coming to his final conclusion, and he did set a non-parole period of 33 years, he effectively punished the offender.
02:18He carried out the task of ensuring deterrence, not only on this person, but on other people in the community who might be minded to take terrible, violent actions against their family members.
02:36He protected the public because this woman will be in jail for many years.
02:41So, he did all the things that the law requires of him as the canons and purposes of setting a sentence.
02:49You mentioned there, Anthony, 33 years non-parole.
02:52Are there any appeal options for Erin Patterson, and do you expect one?
02:57Well, I think she'll probably appeal the verdict because she still maintains her innocence.
03:02She'd have to show that the jury's verdict was unreasonable, or that the judge made some important errors in the directions he gave the jury, or that there was some other manifest inadequacy in the conduct of the trial.
03:18As to the sentence, in a sense, her counsel's submissions won favour with the judge.
03:25The argument was the Crown said there should be no non-parole period.
03:29The defence argued there should be.
03:31I suppose it's still open to her to say 33 years is too long, and maybe it should be 25 years or something like that.
03:39I imagine that there probably will be an appeal.
03:42There'd be no reason why she wouldn't keep appealing.
03:46And we'll see what happens.
03:47But the saga really is over now in every real sense.
03:53And the factor that really struck me, Catherine, was the judge's finding that her betrayal of trust to these family members was a really significant aggravating factor.
04:07And I think we'll all reflect on that because this was a family that had been kind to this woman.
04:14Her children were fond of her grandparents, of their grandparents, and yet she callously and deliberately killed them.
04:24So a betrayal of trust lingers in my memory as a very important aspect of the judge's findings.
04:32Another first with this is that it was broadcast live from the Victoria Supreme Court, not just around the country, but you would imagine around the world.
04:41What is the benefit of live sentencing?
04:44Why do you think the Victorian Court chose to do this?
04:47Well, I think it was an important trial.
04:49It was a very, it was a trial that drew enormous public attention to it.
04:54So, I mean, those factors alone would warrant having the sentence live broadcast.
05:02But I think also just in a broader way, you know, we do hear a lot of controversy in the community when sentences are passed on people.
05:11You often hear the kind of more loudmouthed shock jocks saying that the sentences are too light and judges are out of touch and so on.
05:24So to have the ability to see a judge actually explain carefully to the public by live broadcast what principles he applies and how he comes to that decision, I think is very good.
05:36It's transparent. It makes people understand that this is quite a complex task and it enables them to see whether justice has been done and people might have different opinions about that.
05:48But there it is. The judge has explained himself and we can all see how he reached his conclusion.
05:54And that's good.

Recommended