Thousands of Iranians have been killed, hundreds more injured, and tens of thousands arrested during nationwide protests against the cleric-run regime. Families are desperately searching for missing loved ones as the government deploys heavy security forces and shuts down the internet. Analysts warn that Iran’s legitimacy is collapsing, and anger among citizens is growing despite the regime surviving this wave of unrest. Experts say the brutal crackdown has shattered trust, intensified socioeconomic grievances, and set the stage for future uprisings.
#iran #iranprotests #tehran #apt




Join this channel to get access to perks:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCpLEtz3H0jSfEneSdf1YKnw/join

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00To Iran now, where the deadly toll of widespread protests and government crackdown is becoming clearer.
00:07The US-based group Human Rights Activists Working in Iran say it has verified the deaths of over 3,000 people
00:14during the first 20 days of nationwide demonstrations against the regime.
00:19Over 2,000 more have been seriously injured and more than 10 times that amount have been arrested.
00:24The cleric-run regime's heavy deployment of security forces appears to have quelled the demonstrations in recent days.
00:31Iran's Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei accused US President Donald Trump of inflicting casualties on the Iranian people during the protests.
00:41Meanwhile, a huge number of families are now struggling to come to terms with the sudden and brutal death of their loved ones.
00:48Next, we meet the relatives of one such victim from Tehran.
00:54Robina Arminian was a fashion student in Tehran.
00:59Her family say security forces shot her in the back of the head at close range.
01:04Thousands of kilometers away, her aunt Hallie, who lives in Norway, scrolls through photos and videos of Robina.
01:11She knew that doing nothing would never bring the future she dreamed of.
01:23So she acted.
01:28She was practical and determined to gain her freedom.
01:32She went out unarmed, carrying only her voice and her body to call for freedom.
01:42And she was killed on her way toward freedom and a better life.
01:47Unrest in Iran started at the end of December as protests against economic hardship.
01:54As authorities cracked down, the movement swelled into widespread anti-government demonstrations.
02:01Rights groups say security forces have killed thousands of protesters.
02:04The government, in turn, says hundreds were killed because armed rioters hijacked the protests.
02:11These videos of a Morgan Tehran were posted on social media this week.
02:16There have been reports of family members searching for lost loved ones.
02:21Despite a nationwide blackout, Robina's aunt and uncle tried to find out what happened to their niece.
02:27What they describe, my family, is that there were hundreds, maybe thousands of bodies piled on top of each other.
02:40My sister was searching for Robina's face.
02:45She looked through so many beautiful faces, trying to find her girl.
02:52And what is so horrifying for me,
02:55is imagining what my sister felt as she searched for her daughter.
03:02Hundreds and hundreds of bodies.
03:07With no funeral possible, and little contact with their family in Iran,
03:12they mourn Robina alone.
03:15Joining me now is Simon Maben, a Middle East analyst at Lancaster University in the United Kingdom.
03:22Simon, thanks for joining us.
03:23Well, stories from families desperately trying to find their relatives,
03:28like the one we've just seen in this report, are hard to stomach.
03:33But they help us understand the scale of the human cost of this crackdown.
03:37What do we do with that knowledge, with understanding the scale?
03:42Yeah, it's a really difficult one, because these are very, very common stories.
03:49These are stories from people who do not know what has happened to their loved ones, in many cases,
03:53who have not been able to get in touch with families and friends back in Iran on a general scale,
03:59who do not know what, if anything, has happened to their families.
04:03I've spoken to colleagues and friends who found out just by chance that their family members had been arrested
04:11as part of this wider crackdown.
04:14And that produces so much anger, so much anxiety, so much concern.
04:18And I guess on a personal level, all we can do is be there to listen to and support people
04:22who have endured this and will continue to endure this.
04:25Because, sadly, I don't think this is over by any way, shape or form.
04:30So, from your perspective, I mean, how is the Iranian government spinning this recent protest
04:35and certainly the harsh response that followed?
04:39And are they successful in doing so?
04:43Well, we've seen Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei on X saying that this is the fault of Donald Trump,
04:51telling people to go on to the streets and protest.
04:54We've seen other prominent Iranian officials saying that this is a direct consequence of foreign unrest
05:00and external actors trying to manipulate what is happening.
05:04And this, of course, taps into long-standing narratives from Iranian history
05:07about American meddling, about British meddling, about Russian meddling, about Israeli meddling.
05:14Take your pick.
05:15There are lots of different examples from across history of foreign actors getting involved,
05:19trying to manipulate Iranian politics.
05:21And that's what they're clearly trying to tap into here.
05:23Whether it's landing or not, I'm not entirely convinced.
05:27I think there is a lot of anger on the streets of Tehran and across Iran more broadly.
05:31There's certainly lots of anger across the world at the brutal repression of a pro-democracy protest.
05:39So, I think it's landing amongst certain constituencies,
05:42i.e. those that are already favorable to such narratives.
05:45But amongst others, they are just hearing it for what it is.
05:48It's hollow words and an attempt to divert the blame away from the regime.
05:53So, for the time being, would you say the regime survived to this episode?
05:56It looks like it for now.
06:00But the latent anger, the latent causes of this unrest, the socioeconomic pressures,
06:07the rising prices, food prices rose 70%, for example.
06:12The continued crackdown on any form of dissent, the repression and closure of the internet,
06:18and indeed the legacy of the brutal killing of thousands.
06:24We don't know how many, but some estimates have put it around 20,000 people being killed
06:28in this series of protests.
06:30That will remain.
06:31That will not just go away.
06:33And that generates more and more anger.
06:35So, there will be another round of protests.
06:37I'm sure of that.
06:38And for now, it's survived.
06:42But it has not in any way, shape or form addressed the deep underlying factors that led to the
06:47protests in the first place.
06:49In fact, they've only made them worse.
06:51So, Simon, the anger remains, perhaps is even growing.
06:55So, this is certainly not the last protest that we've seen.
06:59But what could tip the scales to really topple the Iranian government?
07:04And could it happen from within Iran or would it need to have outside, I don't know, support?
07:13I mean, what are we looking at?
07:16I think if we look at other examples from across the Middle East in recent years,
07:20when there has been a fall of what is essentially an authoritarian regime,
07:25it has required, necessarily required, the defection of key regime military officials.
07:34It's required people in the armed forces, other prominent government officials,
07:39to say, no, enough is enough.
07:40We are not standing by this.
07:42It happened in Syria in 2011 with the Arab uprisings.
07:46It happened later on, of course, when Assad eventually fell.
07:50It happened in Egypt.
07:51It's happened in lots of different cases where we see authoritarian leaders falling.
07:56As of now, though, it has not happened in Iran.
07:59And so, until we start to see the cracks within the regime,
08:02i.e. members of the Revolutionary Guard Force deserting Khamenei
08:07or other prominent officials deserting the supreme leader,
08:12then I think the regime will be able to deal with domestic unrest.
08:17But then the question is, what happens if external actors get involved?
08:21What happens if the U.S. decide to bomb?
08:23Will that, as some have led to believe, lead to a rally around the flag effect?
08:28Or will it actually just culminate in the fall of the Iranian state?
08:33So, we just don't know.
08:35There's too many unknowns right now, I think.
08:38All right.
08:38Middle East analyst Simon Maben at Lancaster University in the United Kingdom.
08:43Thank you so very much for sharing your insights.
08:48Well, Sarah Khameneian is a researcher in international relations at the University of Sussex.
08:54She joins us from Brighton in the UK.
08:56Great to see you.
08:57Good to have you with us.
08:58We're hearing painful stories of families searching morgues for missing loved ones.
09:04What do these stories tell us about the scale and the impact of the crackdown?
09:09Thank you for having me.
09:13I think the stories we hear these days, although admittedly they cannot be fact-checked, yes,
09:18but prove that the speculated high number of death tolls that we had earlier is most likely correct.
09:24They prove high levels of unacknowledged death, enforced disappearances, and a more systemically enforced terrorization of people
09:32by taking very brutal measures in killing people, showing it to the public, putting it into display,
09:38by dehumanizing the dead, by torturing families.
09:41So this pattern indicates, I think, a strategy aimed at both physical oppression and psychological terror,
09:47through which the state tries to prevent future uprisings through instituting public trauma.
09:53These protests began over economic hardship but grew into much more, even if they have now been suppressed.
10:01How are Iranians feeling toward their government, especially after the killings of so many of its citizens?
10:08Well, indeed, the protests initially erupted over economic hardship, and this is what I talked about earlier when I was at Deutsche Welle.
10:18But their spread towards marginal cities and other social groups turned them into a display for people showing their demand for the removal of the state.
10:28And we were expecting the state's response to become more and more violent as the protests were spreading through other spaces and other cities.
10:35What we hear these days from, indeed, limited channels, but still, they show that people feel like they have entered a no-return way,
10:44that they are terrorized in a way, but also have no doubt that, for instance, a reform or their life cannot redeem this state,
10:53and a state that has so brutally killed its own civilians cannot be redeemed through, like, a reformation route.
10:59It is fair to say, then, that even though the Islamic Republic has lost its hegemony at the moment,
11:08had lost its hegemony actually before the unrest, but no, its legitimacy is even more widely questioned,
11:14and I think the state is knowing a question that it cannot really maintain its dominance other than through militaristic means.
11:20So, ideology doesn't really work anymore.
11:23And this means that, well, it has lost its hegemony to its people, its legitimacy to its people completely, and people really want it gone.
11:32Yeah.
11:32As to how the Iranian government is spinning the recent protests and the harsh response that followed,
11:38how successfully, rather, are they doing it?
11:41Who's still listening?
11:42I think the official narrative is because, well, they have been able to, we hear in some narratives,
11:51that they have been able to take control of, for instance, urban spaces,
11:55even though we also hear that people's resistances continue.
11:58But what is more important in the way they are kind of, they are spinning the recent protests,
12:02is that the official narratives advanced by the Islamic Republic frame the protests as externally orchestrated unrest,
12:10driven by foreign enemies, interventions, separatists or terrorist groups.
12:16They are not even accepting responsibility for killing the people, for killing people, killing civilians.
12:20They say that it was the responsibility of these other groups, rather than as an expression of domestic discontent.
12:27So, violence by security forces is justified as a necessary response to chaos,
12:32while deaths are either denied, minimized, people are dehumanized, etc.
12:36But none of this was really unexpected.
12:38But what is very painful these days is that lots of Western media, we also see that they are giving presence to these voices from inside the government of Iran.
12:49What is unfortunate is that even Donald Trump, for instance, despite, very ironically,
12:54him being one of the persons the Islamic Republic identifies as an external source of conspiracy,
13:00but we hear some of these narratives through which the state tries to justify its violence from his words.
13:08For instance, he says that, well, he was denying that the Iranian state is actually committing these brutal,
13:17conducting these brutal measures for a long while and was repeating that if they kill people,
13:23if they kill people, even though they have killed thousands of people and they have confessed it today.
13:27Also, like, even very recently, he was showing happiness and he thanked the leaders of Iran for not executing 80 people.
13:39So, I think this is really sad that they are trying to use this narrative to justify their actions
13:45and that we hear it in Western media, we hear many Western leaders also using, also giving, giving, like, channeling these narratives and giving presence to them.
13:55Sarah Kamanian at the University of Sussex in Brighton.
13:59We'll leave it there and thank you so much.
14:04To talk more about this, I'm joined by historian and Iran expert, Professor Ali Ansari from the School of History at the University of St Andrews.
14:11Great to see you.
14:12We heard the numbers, you heard them too.
14:14According to human rights organisations, more than 3,000 people killed.
14:18How does this crackdown then fit in the context of the history of violence against citizens in Iran?
14:24Well, let's assume that the figures that we have at the moment are probably an underestimate.
14:29So, I think in looking at it historically, this is probably the greatest single slaughter of Iranian citizens by their government in about 150 years.
14:39I mean, it's, I think there have been, you know, more widespread levels of brutality, but it's been over a more prolonged period of time.
14:48So, certainly after the revolution, there was a great amount of bloodletting after the fall of the Shah.
14:53But that would have taken over, you know, a period of, say, 18 months as the revolution sorted itself out, so to speak.
14:59This, you know, conducted over about three days of a clampdown, of a crackdown, a very particularly brutal crackdown is unprecedented.
15:06Iran's supreme leader blamed thousands of deaths on Israel and the US while the protests were going on, specifically accusing Donald Trump of complicity.
15:17How many people in Iran still see the US and Israel as a bigger obstacle to a better standard of living than the Iranian regime itself at this point?
15:25I think the people who believe this sort of stuff are very much in a minority now in Iran.
15:31It's quite clear that what the brutality has actually done is it's made people extremely angry, extremely frustrated.
15:40And for the first time, you're really hearing a lot of people in Iran calling for foreign intervention, which is extremely unusual, I have to say, in Iranian political history.
15:51Most people would say, do not, you know, get involved. But I think people are getting extremely desperate now.
15:57This is not over by a long shot. I mean, I think we look at it now and we say that they've suppressed it for the time being, but at what cost?
16:04And it's quite clear as the Internet shutdown continues that they have not managed to suppress it all yet.
16:09And they certainly haven't been able to sort of clean up the mess they've created.
16:12But the level of brutality has ensured that I think the level of anger in wider society and certainly any sort of sense of social contract between state and society has been broken.
16:24It's fascinating, Ali.
16:25How then are, against that backdrop, how then are the clerics still holding on to power beyond the muscle of the security forces and the threat of jail and execution?
16:34How is it that they're still holding on to power?
16:36It's very difficult. It's very difficult to say. I mean, at the end of the day, these protests and many Iranians are calling them an uprising, by the way, rather than a protest.
16:44Then I think that's probably a better descriptor.
16:46But these protests are on the back of really they're symptomatic of the wider economic malaise.
16:52And the economic malaise is extremely serious.
16:54So this sort of clampdown, the crackdown, the shutting down of the Internet, the inability of businesses to work, it can't be helping.
17:01You know, it won't help the economic crisis and actually will accelerate that economic crisis.
17:06So they're very much in a very difficult situation, but a difficult situation of their own making.
17:11So just to underline before we go, the protests have subsided a little for now.
17:17What is your take then? Does this mean the regime has survived this episode?
17:21I think I think it's survived this episode, but I don't think this episode necessarily is finished yet.
17:28And I think there will be a return to more protests in the not too distant future.
17:32Even if that were not to happen, the regime will face enormous economic difficulties going forward.
17:38And we are you know, I don't see how they can sustain the current situation at all.
17:43So it's you know, there are difficult times ahead.
17:47People will have to digest, particularly in Iran, what has happened.
17:50There will be more information coming out, obviously, over the next few weeks.
17:54But just as in the aftermath of the Iran-Israel war back in June, the consequences will be long in gestation.
18:01And we will see we will see them in due course.
18:05Historian and Iran expert Ali Ansari.
18:07Great to get your input.
18:08Thanks so much.
18:08We'll see you in the next few weeks.

Recommended