A week after his historic win, New York City’s first Muslim and South Asian mayor-elect, Zohran Mamdani, has become both a target and a symbol of what’s changing and what isn’t in America. His rise forces a reckoning with how Muslim belonging is negotiated in public life, and whether representation can really challenge entrenched Islamophobia and inequality. On this episode of #ConsiderThis Melisa Idris speaks with Professor Salim Daniels, Professor of Anthropology at Hofstra University in New York, US.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Hello and good evening. I'm Melissa Idris. Welcome to Consider This. This is the show where we want
00:16you to consider and then reconsider what you know of the news of the day. New York City has elected
00:21its first Muslim and South Asian mayor, Zohran Mamdani. His win marks a milestone for
00:29representation but it was also one that played out against a backdrop of Islamophobia and widening
00:36inequality in America. So what larger story does this moment tell us about US politics? Joining me
00:44on the show today to discuss his father is Professor Salim Daniels who is a professor of anthropology
00:50at Hofstra University in New York. Professor Daniels, welcome to the show. It's good of you to join me.
00:55Thank you very much. So this is quite a moment in New York City where we have the win of
01:02mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani, first Muslim and South Asian mayor. I'm wondering, so you are
01:08an anthropologist that looks at the intersection of religion and identity and urban spaces.
01:19Talk to me a little bit. You're also a New York voter. I might add that.
01:22That's right. And I voted for Mamdani for sure and tried to mobilize my friends and family to vote.
01:28Oh, wow. Okay. So how are you reading this moment in time in terms of US politics as a whole?
01:34I think it's a very exciting moment on the one hand, but it's a very challenging moment. But it's,
01:40you know, we're all, I think, pretty extensively in the Muslim community, in the immigrant community,
01:47in the working class community, in various ethnic and racial communities in New York City, very excited
01:53about the example of, you know, of the election and having a Muslim mayor, having, you know, first
02:00South Asian mayor as well. He's from an immigrant background. But all of this, of course, is in the
02:07backdrop where we have President Trump and we have the rise of the far right, of the MAGA movement.
02:14And so it's a very challenging moment. I think for the last year or so, you know, some of my students
02:21have been distressed to really see the change of the Trump administration coming in, to see immigrants
02:28who are coming to work, try to make a living and improve their lives, the lives of their families back in
02:34their home countries, being shackled and arrested and, you know, you know, whisked away from their jobs.
02:41So it's a frightening moment. There's also the government lockdown. And I mean, there's a lot
02:46of things that have happened to tariffs. You know, he promised a better economy. The economy
02:51is very difficult. So all of this, I think, is a very hopeful moment. I think we're hopeful,
02:56we're excited. And we really hope that this example of having, you know, a progressive,
03:03you know, mayor win in New York City, will be spread around, you know, the United States and
03:11other areas. But as a social scientist, of course, I'm not so quick to, you know, to support such hopeful
03:18wishes. I think we really want it, but it's going to take a lot of work. It's definitely a challenge
03:23because the MAGA movement is still strongly entrenched across the United States.
03:29Talk to me a little bit about what life is like in New York or what life has been like in the past
03:34few years, decade even, if I may. When we in Malaysia read reports or we are on social media and hear
03:44New Yorkers talk about how the city is changing. What does it represent to you when, you know,
03:50when you think about how the city has changed? Tell me what you think or how you view the changes.
03:56I think there's definitely been persistent changes in New York City in terms of influxes
04:03of people from all over the world. I mean, you know, we've really embraced that in New York City.
04:09But I think over the last couple of years, there's been a lot of tensions because they've been sending
04:13in immigration police. There's been a lot of tension about the fact that New York City is a sanctuary
04:19city where we don't want to have, you know, immigration or police going around and checking
04:25the identities of people saying, you know, are you a citizen? We don't want that kind of environment
04:30in New York. So we've seen some of that change. And so there's been some tension. There's been
04:35some responses to that, I think, on the ground. We're also concerned with the leadership that we
04:42had from, you know, from Mayor Adams. His relationship, I mean, a lot of the corruption,
04:49his relationship with Trump, he tried to get out of. So I think, you know, those were some changes
04:54that I think were somewhat disturbing for New York because it's New York, you know, we're a city that
05:00we're accustomed to go into Manhattan and you see people from all over the world. And they're just not
05:06tourists, but they're there working and living and part of the fabric of New York society.
05:11So you mentioned that Zaramam Dhani is young. He's of immigrant descent or immigrant background. He has
05:18South Asian, Ugandan descent. How does all of that in terms of his identity intersect with how New Yorkers
05:28see themselves in him, representation now in U.S. politics?
05:32I think we see that diversity and his identity as a Muslim, as a South Asian, as a youngster.
05:41Pro-Palestinian.
05:42Pro-Palestinian. All of that, I think, resonates with the New York City community. So his identity
05:50and this sort of intersections of all these different identities, you know, being an immigrant,
05:57being South Asian, being a Muslim and being a young person, all is symbolic.
06:02I think it becomes a symbolic sort of connection for him to relate to, you know, New York's diverse
06:09society, the immigrant community, the Muslim community, which has been challenged. You know,
06:16we've been under surveillance. I mean, especially since 9-11, there's been, you know, a lot of issues
06:22that the Muslim community has had. So I think we also see a Muslim sort of rising to be the
06:29executive of the city as something that's very symbolic, right? So I think his identities
06:36and the way they intersect is really symbolic of the marginalized communities. And when he said
06:42in October that he wants to come out of the shadows and be in the light, I think that resonates
06:49with people who are immigrants, who are of minority communities, including the Muslim community,
06:58you know, to come out of the shadows, from the out of the margins, and to embrace your identity
07:05and yourself as being an American, not just being, you know, someone that's in the shadows
07:10of migrants, but as American that has full rights and fully belongs to the American community.
07:16Now, tell me more about that, because, you know, it's since the primary, since, you know,
07:20he's had some time to build up the campaign. And a lot of people said, well, this is only going to
07:25resonate with young people. But it really is all the different identities of Zoram Amdani that I think
07:31resonates with the voters who see hope in him. Talk to me a bit more about that, about the idea of
07:38Muslim belonging, not just in the civic space, but also the political space. Do you see yourself
07:46represented in the current political landscape of America?
07:52It's very problematic, I think. I think that it needs to change a lot to be more open. And I think
08:01we can see from the backlash that he experienced. I mean, it's definitely the positive side of how
08:07his identity taps into the margins, it parts, you know, into Muslims, and develops this sort of sense
08:15of inclusion and belonging. But on the other hand, it's been a, you know, an identity has been
08:21attacked. And so you have right away after his success in the primary, and even earlier, they began to
08:31attack him, you know, attack him, you know, and he was different, you know, so we have all these
08:35expressions of xenophobia, that he should be denaturalized, he's not a real citizen, he doesn't
08:42belong. And then, of course, all the negative associations, Islamophobia with Islam, that he's a
08:48Muslim, and it's, you know, things about 9-11 came up, and terrorism.
08:53It was so explicit, wasn't it? The Islamophobia was so explicit, it went beyond dog whistling. It was
09:01outright Islamophobia. And, you know, what do you think that reveals about the way religion and
09:10identity and Islamophobia exists in America today?
09:15Yeah, I think it's changed a lot. But even before 9-11, Islamophobia has been part of America.
09:23American history. I mean, you know, a lot of people talk about the banning of Muslims during
09:30Trump 1.0, but the banning of Muslims goes back earlier into American history, you know, going
09:38back into the 18th century, there was the idea that to become an American citizen, you had
09:44to be white and you had to be Christian, see? But there were already Muslims that were enslaved
09:50the Africans who were Muslims. And some historians now are beginning to explore the fact that African
09:58Americans who, well, Africans who were enslaved later became Americans, were in a difficult
10:05situation, but many of them have maintained, there's some historical records that they maintained
10:09their Islam through that kind of barbaric situation of being chattel slaves in the U.S.
10:16So you have that sort of history. So early in the 20th century then, there were some Arabs
10:23from the Middle East coming in and they were sort of vetted and there's some research on
10:27this and court records where they were allowed to become citizens when they verified that they
10:33were non-Muslims, that they were Christians from Lebanon or something like that. So there's
10:39some research sort of looking at the history of American Islamophobia. And then in the early
10:4320th century you have the emergence of African-American sort of neo-Islamic movements early in the
10:5420th century, you know, Nation of Islam, a lot of people know about that. There was the Morse
10:58Science Temple in other places as well. And so there was already sort of the government
11:03sort of looking at these groups in a suspicious way and some of the leaders were, of course,
11:08imprisoned because of their refusal to go and fight in American imperialistic wars in that
11:14time period. And then of course there's more knowledge about the Nation of Islam in the
11:181960s. So it was already this sort of longer history of Islamophobia even in the 20th century
11:25prior to 9-11. But with 9-11 we have to sense that, you know, this targeting of Muslims that
11:33became very extensive. And then there was a development of several, you know, several structural
11:39forms of Islamophobia using the state, using immigration, using homeland security, all these
11:46sort of governmental agencies to put Muslims under surveillance. And of course the New York City
11:53Police Department was also very active in that. And so, I mean, that sort of shapes my feeling as a Muslim.
12:02I think there's a lot that still needs to change in the American political system. I'm very excited
12:09and I'm overjoyed with the victory of Zahra Mamdani in New York City. And I'd like to see that become
12:19sort of duplicated in cities across the United States and of course global cities around the world.
12:25But I think it's a real challenge because the MAGA, sort of the far right movement is really entrenched
12:33in American society. So he won up north. He didn't win, right? He didn't win in Alabama. He didn't even
12:40win in one of the swing sort of cities in the swing states of Ohio or Wisconsin or Pennsylvania where
12:48Trump had a landslide victory. So as a social scientist, you know, I sort of have sort of a
12:55sobering sort of perspective on it. But still, I'm joyful and I'm excited. I'm really happy he's won.
13:01And I'm looking forward to these new policies coming into New York City.
13:05Well, well, you know, I live half a world away from New York City and I can name the three,
13:11the policy platform that Zahra Mamdani ran on. So it was freeze rents and free buses and universal
13:20childcare. What do you think about those policies and why they resonated with New Yorkers?
13:27And why his campaign was so effective that half a world away, people know his campaign promises?
13:35Because those, I think, are really central working class concerns. They have the free buses,
13:43the transportation, they get to work, you know, on trains or on buses, right? So I think it's really
13:50more extensive. And they have rent control because the rents and the mortgages, the house, you know,
13:55is really very high in New York City. And so to have some of that, some of those rents come down to be
14:01stabilized and to freeze them from constantly being inflated, I think, are concerns for the working
14:09class and, of course, the free daycare for, you know, families. Most women are working as well,
14:17you know, because it's so expensive. Families are pushed to have the two incomes. But there's a lot
14:23of single women who are also working. So, I mean, you find that New York City fabric of diversity that
14:28also extends into gender and into the, you know, the various sort of ethnic communities as well.
14:34Everyone's involved in different, and some people are working two or three jobs because it's so
14:39expensive. So they say that you're going to bring some of those expenses down, the freeze to rents
14:44that are very, very high. I mean, you could have a small apartment and it could be, you know,
14:49$2,500 a month, you know, USD. And so I think all of those concerns really resonate with the working
14:58class, which is where he's been able to sort of connect his policy platform with the sense that,
15:07with his identity, right, you know, connecting with marginalized symbolism of his identity
15:12sort of connects very strongly with his policy platform. Can I ask you, Professor, that there
15:18were some commentators or concerns that, you know, Zora Mamdani built his campaign on a,
15:26on emotional appeal. So really appealing to, to all these different identities that he represents,
15:32but also, you know, younger people and even the, just New Yorkers in general. But there was a concern
15:37that maybe his policy platforms are not as pragmatic and expectations are sky high at the
15:44moment for the mayor elect. And given Donald Trump's response to all the threats that he had about,
15:51you know, not funding, cutting funding to New York City and all of that, do you think that the way
15:57this is all playing out is risky? Because, you know, there was a lot of emotional appeal in Zoran's
16:04campaign, but then you have threats on the other side, you have promises that you need to achieve.
16:09How do you see it? I think it's going to be difficult, but I, you know, I really appreciate
16:14the fact that he's putting forward these bold platforms. And they're not totally new. I mean,
16:20if we look back, even going back to Obama's campaign, you know, we go back to, to that time period,
16:272008 and 2012 and so forth, there was the sense of having universal healthcare, right? There was,
16:36oh, that's outrageous. We, you know, we can't do that. And, you know, and the change the tax policy
16:43to have more taxation of the rich so that you can have more of these social programs. So I think
16:48they're not new, but I think he's leaning in more. What's happened with the Democrats is they've been
16:54very timid, right? They put these things forward and then they were timid and wouldn't lean into it.
17:00And I think that's led to successive, you know, electoral defeats and what we have now with Trump.
17:07So I think on the ground, people were concerned, well, we really need to have these policies. We
17:12need someone who's going to lean into them. I mean, look at what Trump is doing from the far right.
17:17He said, I'm going to do this, this, this, and this. And he leaned into it. He did it.
17:21He did, yes. So we have the feeling we need to have someone that's more of a progressive leader
17:27that's going to lean in and not be afraid to implement these policies because, of course,
17:33they can tax. I mean, we have so many billionaires and, you know, some of the richest people in the
17:38world are in the U.S. So if we have the taxation structure that's going to redistribute some of that
17:45wealth to have the social programs, you know, we can do it. And so it's not so unreasonable.
17:51When you think about universal health care, even, I mean, people were sort of saying,
17:55wow, the U.S. is one of the most developed societies and they don't have universal health,
17:59but all these other societies do. Our neighbors, you know, in Canada and we look at Australia
18:06and look at Israel, who we've been funding, they have a universal health care program.
18:11So why can't we have one in the U.S.? So I think it is practical. We just need sort of bold
18:17political leaders that are going to lean in. And I think this is what we're excited and we're hopeful
18:23that Mount Donnie will do this because we think they are practical things that can be done.
18:28And he's put up front, you know, changing this taxation structure. He has a city council that I
18:34think are, you know, strongly behind him. And so if they can make some of these changes,
18:40then they'll have the funds to, you know, to fund these sort of social programs and to make some of
18:45these things free for New Yorkers. Are you concerned about the amount of money from the oligarchs and
18:51the billionaires that have been funneled to derail his campaign to, now I hope, I wonder whether
18:58they will funnel that money to derail his efforts as mayor-elect, as mayor, mom, daddy next year.
19:05Yeah, it's going to be challenging. I think, you know, those people are not going to go away.
19:11And they definitely put a lot into trying to derail his campaign, spreading, you know, the Islamophobia,
19:20the xenophobia and, you know, all these sort of attacks on him. But I think that with the
19:29support of New Yorkers, I think, look at what happened with the election, with all of these
19:33billions of dollars coming in to support Cuomo, who lost in the primary. And still, New Yorkers
19:41weren't affected by that, right? Most of the New Yorkers still maintained the vote. I mean,
19:48through a lot of age categories, of course, it was much stronger figures the same with the youth.
19:54And again, I can understand that with the youth because the youth have been sort of educated in
20:00an environment where we're making all these liberal changes. They have a sense that, you know,
20:04things are progressing. We're going to have a multi-ethnic, multi-racial sort of democratic system.
20:10And then to see the loss to Trump, it was devastating. I mean, some of my students were going to get
20:17help with counseling. And so I can see, you know, their excitement of getting involved with the
20:23campaign. And he really leaned into the youth with social media, involving the youth in the campaign.
20:30And so that's something that's very exciting. And so I'm looking for, when I get back to the
20:35university, hopefully seeing some happy and relieved faces as well of some of my student population.
20:40You talked a little bit earlier about how Islamophobia has evolved. Can we talk about how
20:46the responses to blatant or explicit Islamophobia may have changed? Have you noticed a change in the
20:53way people respond to it? And I'm asking in terms of either public discourse or even the media framing
21:00of maybe calling out some of the Islamophobia that came out as a counter campaign or counter
21:07argument to Zoran's platform.
21:10Yeah, it was very positive to have some of the media outlets at least questioning it. Because of
21:16course they were also producing a lot of Islamophobia, when you think about Palestine and the Gaza,
21:22you know, the way that they framed and protected, I think, Israeli genocidal actions. But some media
21:30sources, you know, Guardian, even the New Yorker, I mean, some of them came out and they did some data
21:36checking and they found that there was this big increase in uptick of all of this Islamophobic
21:42attacks after he had the victory, right? And so they began to look at this and to consider
21:49you know what's going on with the way that the attacks have been framed and the way that
21:55some of the right wing media sort of sensationalizes that we need to denaturalize him, he's from
22:00Uganda, he's not a real citizen. So they began to look at that, some media outlets I think
22:05to really critically examine that and then some of them also looked into how he responded
22:11himself and his own agency and so and he responded to the you know the threats and the attacks
22:20and the accusations he was anti-Semitic, you know he cleared that up you know and so you
22:26know they made a distinction which I think resonates again with the youth and with you know more
22:32broadly in society with people who have been watching all of the social media live streaming
22:39of the genocide and everything like that we know is a difference between anti-Semitism and
22:45being critical of a state whatever their religion is that's committing genocide and so I think
22:51that those kind of things for the the media has been affected but I think a lot of people
22:56also who have seen that are saying no if we don't accept that that negative propaganda you know we
23:02can see the things that he's he's doing that he was reaching out actively into different communities so
23:08he's going to you know Latino communities from from areas areas of Latin America from West Indian
23:15community I mean you can see him socialized and there was so much excitement because he's dancing you
23:19know he's charismatic so he was doing you know a salsa he was doing some other dance you know from from from
23:25Jamaica and so people can see that but I think some people some segments are also saying looking at why
23:33are people saying all these negative things about Muslims we can see from his example that we need to
23:40look and study a little bit more about Islam and some people are really realizing that Islam is a faith
23:45that teaches good morals and good ethics you know helping people even some of his ideas that he calls
23:51democratic socialism resonates with what I've been studying in terms of Islamic economics for instance
23:58in Malaysia you know doing things and taking care of the poor right the Osnaf the poor and the needy
24:04with redistributing funds right that's very much an important part of the Malaysian system and I think
24:10more broadly of Islamic economic system and so he's saying let's do this with democratic socialism as an ideology out
24:18there but he's talking about helping the poor helping the needy helping you know communities
24:23that are working class that are struggling you know even with two incomes come into the home they're
24:29still struggling to survive with the the high prices and the inflation okay so in the minutes so that we
24:36have left can I ask you what comes next what are you watching out for to make sure that this spark of hope
24:42that's been that's spreading like wildfire in New York it doesn't go away that does momentum built on it
24:50and that you know all the sky-high expectations are are given a chance and met
24:55mm-hmm well first of all I want to see again you know the still excitement too because he's appointed
25:01women to be the co-chairs right transition team and so that's very exciting so we can see already
25:08the starting he's implementing right his sort of philosophy of being progressive and inclusive and
25:17so I'm really looking critically to see how we can move to change that tax structure to like you said
25:23practically to have the funds then to deal with free busing to deal with the free child care because
25:29you're right those are very expensive programs and so how is it going to be funded so that's one thing in
25:35in the city and there's going to be those attacks and and so forth against him but I think it's also
25:43will hopefully strike a fire within the Democratic Party because Democrats have at least as I noted used
25:51a lot of progressive sort of rhetoric we're going to do these things these are you know especially with
25:56domestic policy and so with international policy there's also the problem and I think Americans are more
26:03aware of that especially New Yorkers very much aware that there needs to be a change in both the
26:09Democrats and the Republicans when it comes to international policy and in particular the way
26:14they're so strongly connected to Israel right and you know the funds going in the weapons and and everything
26:23of that sort so that kind of you know change needs to happen in the Democratic Party just not with international
26:30uh policy but also with domestic policy but to do that we're going to have to change some of the old guard
26:37which Andrew Cuomo represented you know Kamala Harris and Biden and Obama and there's still this sort of of
26:46group the elites in the Democratic Party that are moderate and conservative because they're afraid that when
26:52they get to those swing states right they don't want to turn the voters off with these sort of uh
26:58programs but I think actually um if we had Sanders who also said he was a socialist if he was running I
27:06think some of those swing states they would have voted for him and so I think they're miscalculating
27:12so I think we're going to have to replace it change their ideas you know combined with maybe replacing some of
27:18those uh moderate to conservative figures in the Democratic Party to really make this move uh further on the
27:25national landscape because I think those swing states are winnable but I think again people in other
27:31places outside of New York just don't want to see the same old faces right they want to see some new people
27:37with some new ideas and with the spirit that they're going to implement their bold policies professor thank you
27:44so much for being on the show today and sharing some insights from what's happening in New York I
27:49appreciate your time thank you for the invitation that's all the time we have for you on this episode
27:53of consider this I'm Melissa Idris signing off for the evening thank you so much for watching and good night
28:14so
28:15thanks
28:16thanks
28:19uh
28:21you
28:23you
28:25you
28:27you
28:29you
28:31you
28:33you
28:35you

Recommended