The Harsh Truth: Most Overrated & Underrated Games of All Time

jamesschierer

🎮 Overrated or Underrated? Today we’re diving into the most controversial topic in gaming — which titles truly lived up to the hype, and which ones didn’t deserve all the attention? From legendary fan favorites to hidden gems you might have missed, we’re breaking down the most overrated and underrated games of all time.  In this video, we’ll cover: ✅ The blockbuster hits that didn’t age as well as you think ✅ The forgotten gems that deserved way more love ✅ Why fan perception doesn’t always match reality ✅ Games that shaped (or missed) their moment in gaming history  Whether you agree, disagree, or have your own picks, this is a debate every gamer can jump into. 👾  💬 What do YOU think the most overrated and underrated games are? Drop your list in the comments — we might feature your answers in a future video!  👍 If you enjoyed this video, don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe for more gaming deep-dives, reviews, and rankings every week!

Transcript

01:00Today, we're tackling one of the most heated debates in gaming history, the most overrated

01:05and underrated games of all time.

01:08Now listen, overrated does not mean the game is bad, and underrated does not mean the game

01:13is flawless.

01:14It's all about how much hype or attention the game actually deserved compared to what

01:19it got.

01:20So don't grab your pitchforks just yet.

01:23But let's jump right in.

01:24First up, the overrated list.

01:26These are games that, while not terrible by any stretch, just don't quite live up to the

01:31reputation they've built.

01:34Number one, The Elder Scrolls V, Skyrim.

01:38Skyrim is a cultural phenomenon.

01:40Dragons, shouts, endless mods.

01:44But let's be real.

01:45The base game without mods, it's clunky.

01:48Combat feels like hitting a sponge with a stick.

01:51The story is forgettable.

01:52And the AI is, let's just say, questionable.

01:57It's a great sandbox.

01:58But the game's legendary status owes more to the modding community than Bethesda's actual

02:04design.

02:06Number two is Fortnite.

02:08Fortnite revolutionized battle royales, no doubt.

02:12But when you strip away the crossover skins and flashy events, it's a fairly standard shooter.

02:17The building mechanic is divisive.

02:20You either love it or hate it.

02:22Is it influential?

02:23Absolutely.

02:24But one of the greatest games of all time, yeah, the hype sometimes overshadows the actual

02:30gameplay loop.

02:33Number three is Final Fantasy VII.

02:36Okay, here's the spicy one.

02:38Final Fantasy VII is iconic.

02:41It brought JRPGs to the mainstream, gave us unforgettable characters, and that moment with

02:46therewith.

02:47But the story is messy, pacing is uneven, and the gameplay hasn't aged nearly as well as

02:54fans like to admit.

02:55It deserves respect for what it did for gaming history, but it's often treated like flawless

03:01perfection, and it's not.

03:04Number four, Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 from 2009.

03:10Modern Warfare 2 is beloved, and I played it to death too.

03:14But if we're being honest, a lot of that love comes from nostalgia.

03:17The multiplayer was fun, but completely unbalanced.

03:21One-man army noob tubes, commando knifing, predator missile chains, it was chaos.

03:28It was groundbreaking at the time, but if we actually go back, it's far from perfect.

03:35Number five, The Last of Us Part II.

03:37This one will definitely split opinions.

03:40The Last of Us Part II is visually stunning, with some of the best acting in gaming.

03:44But the narrative choices divided the fanbase for a reason.

03:49Some loved the risk it took, and others felt alienated by them.

03:52Does it deserve all the Game of the Year awards it swept up?

03:56Maybe not.

03:57It's ambitious, but not untouchable.

04:01Now let's balance it out with the unsung heroes, the underrated gems that deserve way more

04:06attention than they got.

04:08Number one, Spec Ops The Line.

04:11This game disguised itself as a generic military shooter, but underneath, it was a brutal deconstruction

04:17of war games.

04:19The story pulls no punches, and the moral choices leave you questioning yourself.

04:24Critics praised it, but commercially it flopped.

04:27It is one of the most important shooters nobody talks about.

04:32Number two, Sleeping Dogs.

04:35Sleeping Dogs took the open world formula and gave it a unique spin.

04:39Set in Hong Kong, you play as an undercover cop torn between duty and loyalty.

04:45The combat blended martial arts with brutal takedowns, and the story was way stronger than

04:50most GTA clones.

04:52It sold decently, but it never became a franchise, which is a shame because it was packed with

04:57personality.

05:00Number three, is Bulletstorm.

05:02The game was pure chaos, and I mean that in the best way possible.

05:07Instead of rewarding accurately, it rewarded creativity.

05:11Kicking enemies into spikes, pulling them with an energy whip, juggling them mid-air.

05:17The skill shot system was genius.

05:20It got lost in the flood of shooters at the time, but it's one of the most fun FPS experiences

05:26ever made.

05:26Number four, Alan Wake.

05:31Before Alan Wake 2 finally came along, the original was overlooked.

05:36It was part survival horror, part psychological thriller, with light literally as your weapon.

05:42The episodic structure made it feel like a TV series, and the atmosphere was unmatched.

05:47Fans loved it, but it didn't sell huge.

05:50Thankfully, it's finally getting the recognition it always deserved.

05:53Number five, is Fusion Frenzy 2.

05:59Now, this is one people barely even talk about.

06:02Fusion Frenzy 2 on the Xbox 360 was a chaotic party game packed with dozens of unique mini-games.

06:09Think Mario Party, but faster, wilder, and without all the board game downtime.

06:15The critics slammed it for being repetitive, but if you actually played it with friends or

06:20solo, it was a blast.

06:22Simple, frantic pick-up-and-play fun that never really got its due.

06:27For couch co-op nights, it was one of the most underrated gems of its era.

06:32So there you have it.

06:33My list of the most overrated and underrated games of all time.

06:38Remember, overrated does not mean the game is bad, and underrated does not mean the game

06:43is perfect.

06:44It's all about hype and recognition stack up against reality.

06:47Now, it's your turn.

06:49What games do you think are overrated or underrated?

06:52Drop your list in the comments, and let's get a proper debate going.

06:56If you enjoyed the breakdown, hit that like button, subscribe for more gaming deep dives,

07:01and ring the bell so you don't miss out on the next video.

07:04I'll see you next time.

Category

Transcript

Be the first to comment

Recommended