00:00Amit Shah who is speaking in the Lok Sabha right now, the Home Minister introducing the new bills.
00:30Sir, I stand to oppose the introduction of JNK Reorganization Amendment Bill 2025, Union Territish Amendment Bill 2025, and the Constitution 130 Amendment Bill 2025, sir.
00:49Sir, this violates the principle of separation of powers, due process, undermines the right of the people to elected government.
00:55Sir, it gives executive agencies a free run to become judge and jury executioner based on frenzy allegations and suspicions, sir.
01:04Sir, only when an offence is proved beyond reasonable doubt, then only you can leave the post and the membership,
01:11but here a mere accusation, allegation, the punishment of losing one ministerial post will follow.
01:16Sir, Parliament, democracies, chief ministers and ministers can only be removed to true means.
01:21First, executive prime minister can recommend their removal if the second council of ministers lose confidence of the legislature.
01:28Now, this bill would empower the unelected executive bureaucracy to play the role of legislature.
01:35Sir, it undermines representative, parliament, democracy.
01:38This amendment would leave the minister and CM at the mercy of executive agencies.
01:42The severity of the amendment is not only in the fact that one loses their position if they are arrested,
01:47but even if they are detained, detention and administrative action doesn't require an offence to be made.
01:52Sir, the chief minister will not be able to accountable people.
01:55I want to know from the Honourable Home Minister, as he read Article 74-1,
01:59which says that the council of ministers headed by the prime ministers to aid and advise the president,
02:04who shall in excise of his function act in accordance with such advice.
02:07Now, this bill clearly violates 74-1.
02:10Sir, this is the 1933 Gestapo when Gestapo was formed in Germany.
02:16This government is hell-bent on creating a police state.
02:19This will be a death knell and leash an elected government, sir.
02:22Indian constitution is being amended to turn this country into a police state.
02:26BNS 152, the Home Minister promised in this house that seduction would not be used.
02:32Section 316, Section 9 of BNS, PMLA Section 4, all these can be used to destabilize an elected government, sir.
02:41That is why I oppose the introduction of all these three bills.
02:45This is nothing but creating a Gestapo to ensure that our democracy does not survive.
02:51And may I tell the Honourable Home Minister, despite his promise on BNS 152,
02:56152 has been used against the Senior Generalist Hidhar Varadhan Assam also.
03:01That is why I oppose this introduction of the three bills, sir. Thank you.
03:09Speaker, sir, I rise to oppose the introduction of these three bills under Rule 70 to 1,
03:19of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Lok Sabha.
03:23This bill is squarely destructive of the basic structure of the Constitution.
03:30You are innocent until proven guilty.
03:35This bill stands that fundamental maxim of jurisprudence on its head.
03:40It makes an investigating officer the boss of the Prime Minister of India.
03:45The second ground on which I oppose this bill, it violates Article 21, the Due Process Clause,
03:50F.I.R., Arrest, Charge Sheet and even Framing of Charge.
03:53The second ground on which I oppose this bill, it violates Article 21, the Due Process Clause,
03:59F.I.R., Arrest, Charge Sheet and even Framing of Charge.
04:00The second ground on which I oppose this bill, it violates Article 21, the Due Process Clause, F.I.R., Arrest,
04:14Charge Sheet and even Framing of Charge does not in any manner substantiate guilt.
04:18In fact, you plead not guilty only after charges are framed against you.
04:30This bill turns the fundamental jurisprudence of Article 21 on its head.
04:35Number three, it distorts parliamentary democracy, which is again basic structure,
04:41by displacing the will of the people through mere custody, bereft of judicial determination.
04:48Adyaksh Ji, I am a very obedient person.
04:51I have two more binders. I have a gripea.
04:54Okay.
04:55Okay.
04:56The fourth ground on the fourth ground is, it opens.
05:00Please.
05:01Maanye Sadashay,
05:04Aap Niam 72 के तर शिरोट कर रहे हैं.
05:08Ajak जिब कुलिया जब कभी बिल आपका सदन बाया है,
05:11जब आप डेटेल में चर्चा करते हैं.
05:13Ajak जी.
05:14Aap Niam 72 के बोब कर दूद शारा इंग बोलने की पर्मिशन देता.
05:18is
05:48this bill opens the door for political misuse by instrumentalities of the state
06:00whose arbitrary conduct has been repeatedly frowned upon by the supreme court and finally
06:07it throws all existing constitutional safeguards to the winds collective responsibility judicial
06:14review no confidence motion and disqualification and conviction and this makes this amendment
06:21excessive unnecessary and unconstitutional
06:25because i strongly oppose the bill 130th constitutional amendment bill as well as the other two bills i
06:28strongly oppose
06:48constitutional amendment bill as well as the other two bills I strongly oppose on four
06:55grounds. So the first ground is the bills are to be introduced according to the rules
07:01and procedure of the House. The bill is not circulated among the members. Yesterday after
07:07one o'clock we have received the copy of the bill and I would like to know from the Honourable
07:12Minister. What is the undue haste and urgency in bringing such a constitutional amendment
07:19bill? What is the emergent need of having such a bill? That means the introduction of the
07:25bill itself is lacking bona fides. The bill is lacking bona fides. That is why I would like
07:32to say that this is with a malafide intention to destabilize the opposition ruled states
07:38in various parts of the country. Number one.
07:45ín así que a malafide
08:07Sir, I do agree with the Honourable Minister, but at the same time, the members are having
08:23the right to oppose the bill at the time of introduction.
08:26This is the legitimate constitutional right of each and every member to oppose the bill
08:31at the time of introduction.
08:33That is being contained and the second one is calling...
08:40Sir, sir, sir, I rise to oppose the introduction of the constitution, I mean, maybe 25, the
09:00government of the territory.
09:03Sir, sir, this bill is to support the federal system of this country.
09:07This bill is to support the basic principle of the constitution of this country.
09:13Sir, BDAP people are telling this bill is to bring morality in politics.
09:19Can I ask a question to the Honourable Home Minister?
09:26When he was the Home Minister of Gujarat, he had been arrested, sir.
09:32The Honourable Home Minister of Gujarat, the Honourable House Minister of Gujarat, the
Comments