• há 1 ano
El historiador Ilan Pappe nos habla acerca de la importancia de llevar en cuenta el contexto histórico al analizar los acontecimientos. Esto es de mucha relevancia para que no seamos llevados a tomar los síntomas como si fueran los factores causadores de los problemas detectados.
Transcrição
00:00Aplausos
00:02Aplausos
00:04Aplausos
00:06Aplausos
00:08Aplausos
00:10Aplausos
00:12Aplausos
00:14Aplausos
00:16Aplausos
00:18Aplausos
00:20Aplausos
00:22Aplausos
00:24Aplausos
00:26Aplausos
00:28não estão em um lugar mais confortável
00:30no auditorio
00:32espero que eu faça isso
00:34worth a while
00:35mesmo se você está estando
00:37e você está sequeando
00:39na próxima vez
00:41vamos tentar
00:42e conseguir um grande apoio
00:44o que eu gostaria
00:49de fazer hoje
00:50neste talk
00:51é tocar
00:54algo que eu sei que muitos
00:56of you are aware of
00:58mas eu acho que é muito importante
01:00para abordar
01:02e esse é o contexto histórico
01:06do contexto
01:07do que nós estamos
01:10testando
01:12em palestina e israel
01:14em geral
01:15e na Gaza Strip
01:18em particular
01:18nos últimos dois anos
01:21você pode lembrar
01:23que imediatamente
01:24depois da Hamas
01:26ataque
01:26no 7 de outubro
01:29de 2023
01:30o Unido
01:32General General
01:33Secretário
01:34Guadalupe
01:34disse que
01:37ele condenou
01:38o ataque
01:39mas ele adicionou
01:41que nós temos
01:42de lembrar
01:43que isso
01:44não foi feito
01:46em um banho
01:46o que ele
01:48significou
01:48que havia
01:49um contexto
01:50para o ataque
01:52Israel
01:53imediatamente
01:54reagiu
01:54por exigir
01:56que ele
01:57seja
01:57removido
01:58da sua posição
02:00e não
02:02só isso
02:02o governo
02:04o governo
02:05o ministério
02:06o ministério
02:07e os acadêmicos
02:09colocam
02:10pressão
02:11especialmente
02:11na universidades
02:13no mundo
02:15não
02:16para mencionar
02:17a palavra
02:18context
02:19maybe
02:20histórico
02:20context
02:21quando referindo
02:22aos eventos
02:24do 7 de outubro
02:26ou depois
02:26do 7 de outubro
02:28em algumas universidades
02:30no mundo
02:31isso
02:31ficou
02:32realmente
02:32absurdo
02:33como na Alemanha
02:35quando
02:35havia uma
02:36letra
02:37sentada
02:39para as acadêmicas
02:41pedindo
02:42não
02:42usar
02:43o palavra
02:44context
02:44em outras
02:46lugares
02:46foi
02:46menos
02:47efícil
02:48e talvez
02:48menos
02:49outraga
02:50mas
02:51foi
02:51acreditado
02:51que isso
02:52é algo
02:53que
02:53irritou
02:54muito
02:55os
02:55israelis
02:56que
02:57você
02:57pode apenas
02:58falar sobre
02:58o que aconteceu
02:59no 7 de outubro
03:00condena
03:01e
03:02e
03:03é
03:03e
03:03e
03:04e
03:04de
03:04isso
03:05devemos
03:06inferir
03:07sua
03:07moral
03:08posição
03:08sua
03:09política
03:09e
03:10e
03:10e
03:10e
03:10so
03:10on
03:10so
03:12ironically
03:12em
03:13many
03:13casos
03:14quando
03:15estamos
03:15falando
03:16sobre
03:16histórico
03:17context
03:17quando
03:18estamos
03:19dizendo
03:19que
03:19históricos
03:20são
03:20importantes
03:20para
03:21entender
03:22o que
03:22acontece
03:23hoje
03:23na
03:24Israel
03:24e
03:25Palestina
03:25eu
03:26diria
03:26que
03:26são
03:27importantes
03:27para
03:27entender
03:28o que
03:29vai
03:29acontecer
03:29maybe
03:30even
03:30o que
03:31pode
03:31acontecer
03:32em
03:32Israel
03:33e
03:33Palestina
03:33é
03:34quite
03:34ironic
03:35que
03:36é
03:36regarded
03:37em
03:38certos
03:38lugares
03:39porque
03:39do
03:40Israel
03:41lobby
03:42é
03:42algo
03:43que
03:44equate
03:45anti-Semitism
03:47,
03:48apoio
03:48terrorismo
03:49e
03:50todo
03:50costo
03:51denial
03:51mas
03:53nós
03:54estamos
03:54na universidade
03:55e
03:56é nosso
03:57trabalho
03:57como
03:57historias
03:58para
03:59dar
03:59contexto
04:00isso
04:01não
04:01é
04:01revolucionária
04:02a
04:02action
04:03de
04:03nosso
04:04behalf
04:04é
04:05não
04:05uma
04:05subversiva
04:06action
04:07isso
04:08não
04:08é
04:08pensado
04:09como
04:10racista
04:10contra
04:12ninguém
04:12e
04:13definitivamente
04:14não
04:15tem
04:15nada
04:15com
04:17anti-Semitism
04:18ou
04:18o
04:18denial
04:20é
04:20algo
04:21que
04:21só
04:22podemos
04:22fazer
04:22porque
04:24a
04:24media
04:24não
04:24tem
04:25espaço
04:25e
04:26tempo
04:27e
04:28paciência
04:28para
04:29explicar
04:30o
04:30histórico
04:31contexto
04:31e
04:33políticos
04:34são
04:34ainda
04:35menos
04:35interessado
04:36em
04:37esta
04:37explicação
05:08o que
05:09Hamas
05:09fez
05:10mas
05:11entendendo
05:12onde
05:13o
05:13outrage
05:14veio
05:14de
05:14angra
05:16veio
05:16de
05:17violência
05:18veio
05:19de
05:19mas
05:20também
05:20entendendo
05:21que
05:21não
05:22é
05:22mais
05:22importante
05:23porque
05:23Israel
05:24reaccia
05:25como
05:26ela
05:26reaccia
05:27desde
05:27o
05:287 de
05:28Octubre
05:29através
05:29de
05:29campanha
05:30de
05:30Jair
05:31de
05:31Jair
05:31de
05:32Jair
05:33de
05:33Jair
05:33de
05:33Jair
05:33de
05:33Jair
05:33de
05:33Jair
05:34de
05:35Jair
05:35de
05:35Jair
05:36de
05:36Jair
05:37de
05:38Jair
05:38de
05:38Jair
05:39de
05:40historical context this evening and try to provide something that is very necessary
05:49even for those of us who think that we know already a lot of what's happening there and of course
05:58for those who are and are many of those in the world who became interested in palestine
06:04only because of what happened in the last two years
06:13there is a wider historical context there is a historical context which really takes you to the
06:21very beginning of the zionist project in europe and later to the zionist project in palestine
06:29this is not a distant event that has no relevance for us and we are only talking about it because
06:38we are intellectually interested no this is a formative period that helps to understand a lot
06:47what goes on today and what might happen and should as well in the future we have to remember where
06:56came the idea that the jews of europe and zionism only referred to the jews in europe in its very
07:05beginning where came this idea that the best place for the jews in europe in the late 19th century
07:14in the time of enlightenment in the time of the emergence of democracy where came the idea
07:22the best place is in the middle of the arab world in a country called palestine without consulting the
07:40people of palestine whether they are thrilled by the idea of receiving all the jews from europe
07:48uh because europe thinks that this is the best place for them and why did europe and europe when i say europe
07:57i mean european politicians european intellectuals european ideologues why did they come up with this idea
08:06because they felt they cannot accept the jews of europe as equals
08:10some of them could not accept them because they were racist and nationalists others and this is important
08:22to mention were evangelical christians who thought that the historical role of the jews was not to be in
08:30europe but to go to palestine so that this would precipitate the coming of the messiah the resurrection of the
08:39the dead and the end of time so a mixture of anti-semitism and religious evangelical christianity
08:52was putting forward this idea to the jewish community we're sorry in a way you will never be accepted
09:00as pure europeans so what about this idea we will help you to build a jewish state of course one can
09:11understand why they pointed to palestine both as christian and as jews because of the biblical
09:18connection but it's not surprising that the vast majority of the jews in europe when this idea was for the
09:27first time publicized were not excited about this they wanted to stay in germany they wanted to stay in
09:35poland they wanted to stay in russia they felt part of this country part of this civilization they saw no
09:42reason to go all over the world to a country they had no idea of going on there the language spoken there
09:52was alien to them and although they talked about the holy land description talked about the holy land
10:00it was a a religious place not a geographical political place
10:10but it did attract enough number of intellectual jews
10:15and jewish leaders that really came to the conclusion one should say this was the right conclusion
10:24unfortunately that in many parts of europe jews will not be safe and of course what happened in the
10:33second world war proved that they were that not only would they suffer from anti-semitic legislation
10:41and persecution they might suffer from extinction which indeed is what unfortunately happened in europe
10:51in the second world war but the incredible thing is that most of the jews still at that moment and
11:00quite a lot of other people were asking themselves is this really the best way to deal with anti-semitism
11:08to take the european jews out of europe and build the european state for them outside of europe
11:16the reason this idea that was not very practical in many ways and had a lot of moral problems
11:25the reason it became a project was because it also caught the eyes of the british empire
11:32as you probably know palestine until the end of the first world war was part of ottoman of the ottoman
11:40of the ottoman empire the ottoman petrish empire
11:44the britain during the first world war was still a very imperialist power wishing to extend its influence
11:54of the world into the arab world and in many ways because many of the british leaders during the second
12:03the first war including the prime minister of britain david lord george were themselves very religious
12:12in those days they also wanted palestine not only as a new trophy a new addition to the british empire
12:21empire but even some of them saw also in religious terms as general allenby who occupied palestine in
12:30the first world war defeated the terms and took palestine by force when he entered jerusalem he said
12:39i'm bringing back the glory of the crusaders those european uh uh people who occupied palestine
12:48in the 11th and the 12th century we bring back the glory to jerusalem jerusalem has to be jewish and
12:57christian not muslim the idea of imposing a european problem on the arab world on the muslim world
13:12all the palestinians the problem they had nothing to do with could only be sustained by force
13:21could only be sustained by force and from the very moment the indigenous native people of palestine
13:30understood that they are not facing an immigration of poor jews who came from europe because they were
13:39looking for better life which the palestinians would have accepted but they are coming with an ideology
13:46that regards them the palestinians as aliens at best as foreigners and at worst as people who took by
13:55force from the jewish people back in the roman times the jewish kingdom the early zionists were talking
14:04about the palestinians as people who took illegally the land of israel and they saw themselves as taking
14:14back what belonged to them even if that belonged to them 2000 years ago
14:20how it is connected to what's happening today because that kind of ideology that kind of project is not
14:32unique to the jews of europe and is not unique to palestine if we think about it as a more global
14:41phenomenon we can see its impact today the jews were not the only european who were not welcome in europe
14:52there were a lot of outcasts in europe people who were persecuted because of their religion because of their
15:01economic situation because of their culture and as you know they were pushed outside of europe and like the jews
15:09they were looking for a europe outside of europe and they built a europe instead of the europe that didn't
15:17want them and they hold all of them including in brazil had the main problem that the jews had in palestine
15:27they chose places where someone else already lived indigenous native people and as the late uh professor
15:36uh settler uh settler colonialism patrick wolf used to say when the european settlers came to
15:46non-european lands and found out that someone else lived there he said a logic of the elimination of the
15:54native was activated elimination could be genocide except in north america it could be apartheid in south africa
16:04it could be ethnic cleansing as happened in palestine but he also said something that resonates with
16:12what's happening today he said a settler colonial move project continues either until it totally succeeds
16:22in eliminating the native people or it fails to eliminate the native people and it finds itself in
16:31perpetual conflict with them and bloodshed and guts everyone involved both the settler and the next
16:41generation and the indigenous people and the next generation so many ways what we see in the last two
16:49years is just another cycle of the fact that israel is still a settler colonial state that is unable to
16:58complete the separate colonial project of totally eliminating the native there is a resistance as
17:05always there is by the native indigenous population and the bloodshed is never limited to one side and
17:13never only affects one side and this is something especially for europe to think about because europe
17:22instead of offering the jews even after the second world war offering the jews of europe when it was clear
17:31what anti-semitism did which is the holocaust instead of 1945 to come and say to all the jews of europe
17:41come back to europe we will build a europe where it would be safe to be a christian a muslim a jew doesn't
17:48matter we are the enlightenment we are the civilization of the world instead of saying come back we will
17:56learn from the second world war how to build a better world we have a declaration of human rights we
18:02now believe only in democracy instead of that they said the best way to deal with what we did to the jews
18:10is to support even more the idea of a jewish state in palestine because in 1945 it was already clear
18:19that this is not just a project of jewish settlers this is a project of eliminating the palestinians
18:27and three years later in 1948 israel ethnically cleansed half of palestine's population destroyed 500
18:36villages of the one thousand villages of the palestinians most of the palestinian towns and massacred
18:43thousands of palestinians in the process three years after the holocaust and europe knew the european
18:51leaders european states including the united states knew exactly what was happening in 1948
18:58and decided that this is still the best idea of how to deal with anti-semitism allowing the jewish
19:06state to become effect even if the price is the disposition of the palestinians as one european
19:14politicians put it we created a small injustice for the sake of correcting a much bigger injustice
19:24and that is never a solution and because the message of the world in 1948 to israel was
19:32as far as far as you are concerned as far as the palestinians are concerned and despite the fact
19:42that we have now a new human a declaration of human rights despite the fact that we have created the
19:49united nations despite the fact that we learned our lessons from the second world war and we will never
19:56allow the world to deteriorate in a similar way in a similar way despite that fact we tolerate what you
20:04did to the palestinians we know what you did the message to israel was as far as you are concerned you
20:12have an exceptional status because we in europe do not know how to deal with racism in general and racism
20:19towards the jews in particular this to my mind is the best explanation for the continued human healing
20:29political elite silence about the genocide maybe there are other explanations strategic economic the role of
20:40USB but for me the most important explanation for why we cannot protect especially western europe
20:50but europe as a forum to take firm action against the genocide because that would mean taking firm action
20:57against a european project that would mean that they are condemning themselves
21:03porque eles veem a Israel
21:05como parte da Europa
21:06e Israel veem a itself
21:08como parte da Europa
21:09o que eles não esperavam
21:12em 1948
21:14que esse filho
21:16ou filho
21:17ou filho da família
21:18de uma família
21:19seria um bom membro da família
21:22eles não esperavam
21:25que eles teriam que face
21:27esse tipo de Israel
21:29eles esperavam que
21:30ou que eles queriam acreditar
21:32a liberal zionista
21:33que após essa posição
21:37e a cleansing
21:38Israel ainda é um democracia
21:40ele ainda é parte do
21:42da Europa
21:42sistema
21:45eles acham que é muito difícil
21:47na última 2 anos
21:48encontrar o sistema
21:50na forma que Israel se vê
21:52não só para os palestinos
21:54mas também para as suas suas sociedades
21:59então eu acho que
21:59esse é um contexto
22:01que nós temos que discutir
22:04que é
22:05a essência de zionismo
22:07como um ideologia
22:08the idea
22:10of the basic idea
22:11of zionismo
22:12that antisemitism
22:13can be solved
22:14only by
22:15imposing
22:17a European state
22:19on the Arab world
22:20at the expense
22:21of the Palestinians
22:22it's not practical
22:23it's not practical
22:23it's not moral
22:24but it's working
22:26because there is
22:27a very powerful alliance
22:29that believes
22:30that this project
22:31serves its own interests
22:33this alliance
22:34is much smaller
22:35than it used to be
22:37because it's not that easy
22:38to support Israel anymore
22:40and I'm optimistic
22:41because I think
22:42unfortunately
22:44the way Israel progresses
22:45would make this alliance
22:47even smaller
22:48in the future
22:50now there is
22:51a more recent
22:52context
22:53and this is something
22:57again
22:57we should talk about
22:58as historians
22:59because
23:00it helps to understand
23:02especially
23:03the situation
23:04in the Gaza Strip
23:06and this
23:07goes to the fact
23:09that
23:09not many people
23:10are aware
23:11that there was
23:13no Gaza Strip
23:14before 1948
23:15the Gaza Strip
23:17the Strip
23:18is an invention
23:19of Israel
23:20Gaza was a small town
23:22with a lot of nice
23:24villages around it
23:25on the road
23:26between Egypt
23:27to Turkey
23:30a very cosmopolitan
23:32place
23:33where Jews
23:33Muslim and Christian
23:34lived in the same place
23:36and Israel
23:37in 1948
23:39when it began
23:41to massively
23:42expel the Palestinians
23:44it was looking
23:46for destination
23:48for the expulsion
23:49so it expelled
23:51the Palestinians
23:51of the north
23:52to Lebanon
23:53and to Syria
23:54and expelled
23:56the Palestinians
23:57in the center
23:57of Palestine
23:58to Jordan
24:00and the West Bank
24:01but there was
24:03a problem
24:03with the Palestinians
24:04in the south
24:05hundreds of thousands
24:06of the Palestinians
24:07because Egypt
24:08did not allow Israel
24:09to push the Palestinians
24:11into Egypt
24:13into the Sinai
24:14Peninsula
24:15so the Israeli
24:16politicians said
24:17if we can't push them
24:19into Egypt
24:20we will create
24:21for them
24:22a small strip
24:23we push them
24:24into this
24:25and created
24:26a strip
24:27which was the biggest
24:28ever
24:29mega refugee camp
24:31in the world
24:32260
24:34and they pushed
24:36hundreds of thousands
24:37of people
24:37into that
24:38Gaza strip
24:4070%
24:42of the people
24:42who live in Gaza
24:43today
24:44are descendants
24:45of those
24:47who were
24:47pushed into
24:49the Gaza strip
24:50by Israel
24:50in 1940
24:51there's another
24:53chapter in this
24:54many of those
24:56who were pushed
24:56lived
24:57in villages
24:58and towns
24:59that were destroyed
25:01in 1948
25:02and on the ruins
25:04of these villages
25:05and towns
25:05Israel built
25:07a settlement
25:07that some of them
25:09were attacked
25:10by the Hamas
25:11by Hamas
25:13on the 7th of October
25:142020
25:15it doesn't justify
25:17what they did
25:18in those
25:19Jewish settlements
25:20but it also
25:21explained
25:22the way they
25:23perceived
25:23these settlements
25:25as built
25:27on the ruins
25:28of their own
25:28the villages
25:29of their great parents
25:30and sometimes
25:32even of their
25:32parents
25:34this is
25:36a very important
25:37part of the history
25:38we should remember
25:39the last
25:40historical perspective
25:42is more recent
25:44and it begins
25:45with the occupation
25:46of the Gaza strip
25:47in 1967
25:48and the occupation
25:50of the West Bank
25:51because
25:53the ethnic
25:54cleansing
25:54of Palestine
25:56in 1948
25:57was incomplete
25:59Israel expelled
26:01only 50%
26:03of the Palestinians
26:04and took over
26:05only
26:06nearly 80%
26:09of historical
26:10Palestine
26:10so half
26:11of the Palestinian
26:12population
26:13still remained
26:14in Palestine
26:14and there were
26:16still areas
26:16of Palestine
26:17that were not
26:18part of Israel
26:19before the June
26:2167 war
26:22like any
26:24settler-polonial
26:25project
26:26it has
26:27two dimensions
26:28geography
26:29and democracy
26:30space
26:31and population
26:32so
26:34Israel wanted
26:34more space
26:35to have the
26:36whole of
26:37historical
26:37Palestine
26:38but like
26:39settler-polonial
26:40movements
26:40in the past
26:41they had
26:42this problem
26:42like when
26:43the Americans
26:43moved more
26:45and more
26:45to the West
26:45to the Western
26:46Coast
26:47of the United States
26:48the more
26:48you take
26:49territory
26:50the more
26:51you get
26:51the population
26:52you don't want
26:53and that's
26:54what happened
26:54in 1967
26:55they got
26:57a larger
26:57number of
26:58Palestinians
26:59under the rule
27:00than they had
27:01expelled originally
27:02from Palestine
27:03in 1948
27:04and in the book
27:06that
27:06published
27:08The Biggest Prison
27:10on Earth
27:10I used the
27:11Israeli
27:12cabinet's minutes
27:13to show
27:13that in 1967
27:15the Israeli
27:16government
27:17for a moment
27:18said
27:18in order
27:19to solve
27:20this problem
27:21to have
27:21the territory
27:22without the
27:23people
27:23maybe we
27:25should do
27:25what we
27:25did in 1948
27:26namely
27:27expel the
27:28people of
27:29the West Bank
27:30and expel
27:30the people
27:31of Gaza
27:31but then
27:32they decided
27:33against it
27:34because
27:35they understood
27:36that the
27:36historical
27:37circumstances
27:38in 1967
27:39were very
27:40different
27:40from 1948
27:42you could not
27:43rely on
27:44the world
27:45to say
27:46okay
27:46you can
27:47do it
27:47again
27:471948
27:49was very
27:49unique
27:50in that
27:51respect
27:52so they
27:55came up
27:55with an
27:56alternative
27:57idea
27:57what do
27:58you do
27:59with millions
27:59of people
28:00that you
28:01want
28:02the territory
28:03they live
28:03on
28:04you decide
28:05not to
28:06expel
28:06them
28:06but you
28:08don't want
28:09them to be
28:09included
28:10in your
28:11demography
28:11because you
28:13believe that
28:14the only
28:14true democracy
28:15is a
28:17Jewish
28:17democracy
28:17Jews always
28:19have to be
28:19the majority
28:20otherwise
28:21there's no
28:21point in
28:22the democracy
28:23so what
28:24do you do
28:25if you
28:25don't
28:26expel
28:26them
28:27then came
28:28the idea
28:29that was
28:29devised by
28:30the Israeli
28:31ministers of
28:32defense
28:33Moshe Dayan
28:34the Israeli
28:35minister of
28:36agriculture
28:36all of
28:38these people
28:38in 1967
28:39were ex-generals
28:41from 1948
28:42there were
28:43very young
28:44generals
28:44in 1948
28:45in the
28:4620s
28:46now in
28:4767
28:48in the
28:4840s
28:49they became
28:49politicians
28:50and they
28:52said we
28:52have a
28:53solution
28:53we will
28:54create the
28:55West Bank
28:55and the
28:56Gaza Strip
28:57as a
28:57mega prison
28:58where we
28:59can control
29:00the people
29:00we will
29:02not give
29:02them the
29:02right to
29:03vote
29:03we will
29:04not give
29:04them the
29:05right to
29:05be elected
29:06we will
29:07give them
29:08no say
29:09in their
29:10own future
29:11and we
29:12will let
29:12them live
29:13their life
29:13if they
29:15are willing
29:15to accept
29:17our strategy
29:17and our
29:19strategy is
29:20that parts
29:22of their
29:22land
29:22will be
29:23taken by
29:24us
29:24to build
29:26Jewish
29:26government
29:26and part
29:29of their
29:30rights
29:31will be
29:31taken for
29:32them
29:32in order
29:33to secure
29:34our
29:35sense of
29:37defense
29:38but otherwise
29:39you know
29:40they can go
29:41along with
29:42their daily
29:43life
29:44of course
29:45this was not
29:47accepted by
29:48the Palestinians
29:48who in the
29:49world would
29:50accept to
29:50live in a
29:51mega prison
29:52so the
29:53inevitable
29:53already started
29:54in 67
29:5668
29:56the first
29:57Palestinian
29:58attempt to
29:59fight against
30:00the occupation
30:01so there
30:03came another
30:03border
30:04okay
30:04if you
30:05don't like
30:06the mega
30:07prison we
30:07offered you
30:08in 67
30:08we will
30:10suggest a
30:11worse kind
30:12of prison
30:12with a lot
30:13of punishment
30:14you will be
30:15punished for
30:16not accepting
30:16what we
30:17suggested
30:18punishment
30:19meant
30:19imprisonment
30:21without
30:21trial
30:22meant
30:23demolishing
30:23of houses
30:24meant
30:26allowing
30:26the settlers
30:27to
30:28extend
30:28allowing
30:30the settlers
30:30to do
30:31their own
30:32violent
30:33attacks
30:33on the
30:34Palestinians
30:34arresting
30:36people
30:36deporting
30:38people
30:38punishing
30:39collectively
30:40villages
30:41and towns
30:42with closures
30:43and curfews
30:45in fact
30:46violating
30:47every law
30:49in the book
30:50of international
30:51law
30:51in order to
30:52punish
30:53the Palestinian
30:54people
30:54for unwillingness
30:56to live
30:56as inmates
30:57without
30:58any basic
30:59civil rights
31:00and human
31:01rights
31:01in the
31:02biggest
31:03prison
31:03on earth
31:04as I
31:04call it
31:05both in
31:05the West
31:06Bank
31:06and the
31:06Gulf
31:06and this
31:08continued
31:08from 67
31:09until 2023
31:11so part
31:12of what we
31:13saw
31:13the outburst
31:14both in
31:16the West
31:17Bank
31:17and the
31:17Gulf
31:18is the
31:19outburst
31:19after living
31:20for 57
31:21years
31:21in a
31:22condition
31:23no other
31:23people in
31:24the world
31:24have ever
31:25experienced
31:26to be
31:27at the
31:27mercy
31:27of the
31:28military
31:29that can
31:29do
31:30whatever
31:30it wants
31:30to you
31:31at the
31:31mercy
31:32of
31:32settlers
31:32not having
31:34any
31:34normal life
31:35not able
31:36to know
31:37whether
31:37you will
31:38make it
31:38to your
31:38job
31:39to your
31:39university
31:40to your
31:41school
31:41to your
31:42field
31:43and being
31:44all the
31:46time
31:46under the
31:47sense
31:47of
31:47danger
31:48when you
31:49cross
31:49a
31:49checkpoint
31:50you don't
31:51know
31:51if you
31:52will
31:52make it
31:53to home
31:53or you
31:53will
31:54disappear
31:54in an
31:55Israeli
31:56prison
31:57the
31:59mega
32:01prison
32:01of the
32:02West
32:02Bank
32:03was bad
32:04enough
32:04and
32:05somehow
32:07Israel
32:07succeeded
32:08in convincing
32:10its allies
32:11in the
32:11West
32:12that this
32:13is a
32:13temporary
32:14arrangement
32:15Israelis
32:16always like
32:17to say
32:18peace is
32:20around the
32:20corner
32:21if there
32:21would be
32:22anyone
32:22we could
32:23talk to
32:24on the
32:24Palestinian
32:25side
32:25but unfortunately
32:26there's no
32:27one we can
32:27talk to
32:28on the
32:28Palestinian
32:29side
32:29and therefore
32:30we have
32:31to maintain
32:31this kind
32:32of rule
32:33and
32:34it was
32:35very convenient
32:36to the
32:37United
32:37States
32:37and the
32:38West
32:38to say
32:38okay
32:39that
32:39makes
32:39sense
32:40so
32:40we're
32:40not
32:41pressuring
32:41Israel
32:42to change
32:43its policy
32:44towards
32:45the
32:46Palestinians
32:47and then
32:49came the
32:49first
32:49Palestinian
32:50uprising
32:51in
32:511997
32:52then came
32:54the second
32:54Palestinian
32:55uprising
32:56in
32:572000
32:57in between
32:58that we
32:59had so
33:00called
33:00peace
33:01process
33:01like the
33:02Oslo
33:02peace
33:03process
33:03which
33:03was
33:04not
33:04a
33:04peace
33:04process
33:05this
33:05was
33:05an
33:06attempt
33:06by
33:06Israel
33:07allies
33:07such as
33:08Norway
33:08to sell
33:09to the
33:10world
33:10the prison
33:11as a peaceful
33:13solution
33:13and
33:14some
33:15people
33:15rightly
33:16rejected it
33:17when they
33:17understood
33:18there was
33:19no genuine
33:20wish
33:21either by
33:21Israel
33:22or the
33:22mediators
33:23to really
33:24allow them
33:25freedom
33:26and liberation
33:27from the
33:28mega prison
33:28that Israel
33:29built
33:30for them
33:31and
33:33while Israel
33:34continued
33:35to succeed
33:36with this
33:37policy
33:38of punishment
33:38and giving
33:40some privileges
33:40and then punishment
33:41and privilege
33:42really like the
33:43relationship
33:44between a jail
33:46and its inmates
33:47in the West Bank
33:48it didn't work
33:50in the Gaza Strip
33:51it didn't work
33:53in the Gaza Strip
33:54for two
33:54main reasons
33:55I think
33:56first of all
33:57Israel could not
33:59convince enough
34:00Jewish settlers
34:00to go to the
34:01Gaza Strip
34:02while 800,000
34:04Jewish settlers
34:05went to the
34:05West Bank
34:06only 5,000 Jews
34:08were willing
34:08to settle
34:09in the Gaza Strip
34:10so Israel
34:11felt it doesn't
34:12have an important
34:13presence
34:14there
34:15secondly
34:16the people
34:17of Gaza
34:18lived in the
34:19worst condition
34:19all over
34:20historically
34:21Palestine
34:21and therefore
34:22were much
34:23more committed
34:24than anyone
34:24else
34:25to resistance
34:26were much
34:27more resilient
34:28than anyone
34:29they were
34:30the heart
34:30of Palestine
34:31the people
34:32of Gaza
34:32were the
34:32heart
34:33of Palestine
34:33they were
34:34the heart
34:34of the
34:34resistance
34:35of Palestine
34:36and it's
34:37not surprising
34:38that it's there
34:39in Gaza
34:40that whenever
34:42a political
34:42faction
34:43whether it was
34:44a secular one
34:45or religious one
34:46whether it was
34:47Hamas
34:47or it was
34:48Fatah
34:48if it did not
34:49deliver
34:50an end
34:51to the suffering
34:52the other
34:53faction
34:53was given
34:54the confidence
34:55of the people
34:56to try
34:57and liberate
34:58Gaza
34:59and Palestine
35:00and this is
35:01what occurred
35:02in 2006
35:042007
35:05and the Israelis
35:06decided
35:06of another
35:08tactic
35:08we cannot
35:09control
35:09the jail
35:10from the inside
35:11in the case
35:13of the Gaza Strip
35:13we will control
35:14it from the outside
35:15and they started
35:17the siege
35:18and blockade
35:19of Gaza
35:20since 2007
35:21this was
35:22the worst
35:23kind of
35:24the model
35:25of prison
35:25that I was
35:26talking about
35:26this was not
35:27anymore a prison
35:28this was a ghetto
35:29this was a ghetto
35:31this was not a prison
35:32anymore
35:33this was much worse
35:34than a prison
35:34since 2007
35:36Israel decided
35:37to punish
35:38the Palestinians
35:39in Gaza
35:39for continuing
35:40the resistance
35:41to the early
35:42models
35:43of the prison
35:44for choosing
35:45a political
35:46faction
35:47that is committed
35:49to continue
35:49the struggle
35:50against Israel
35:51instead of
35:52going along
35:52with a faction
35:53that collaborated
35:54with Israel
35:55the Palestinian
35:56authority
35:57so they were
35:58punished
35:59and when they
36:00resisted the punishment
36:01of course
36:02Israel reacted
36:04with something
36:05that I don't know
36:06if happened
36:07anywhere in the world
36:08remember
36:09Gaza is 260
36:10square kilometers
36:12it's a very
36:13small part
36:14of the world
36:15and it has
36:16the densest
36:17population
36:182 million people
36:19what Israel
36:21did
36:21when the resistance
36:22continued
36:23from the Gaza Strip
36:24is to use
36:25air force
36:26artillery
36:28navy ships
36:30to bomb
36:31the people
36:31of Gaza
36:32they dropped
36:34more bombs
36:35on Gaza
36:36than were dropped
36:37on many cities
36:38during the
36:39second world war
36:40I don't know
36:41if anyone
36:42of you
36:42have experienced
36:43a one
36:44toned bomb
36:45falling
36:46not on his
36:47house
36:47but three
36:48kilometers
36:49away from
36:50his house
36:50this
36:52I experienced
36:53it only once
36:53and this
36:55traumatized
36:56need for life
36:57now they
36:58experienced it
36:59three times
37:01since 2007
37:03to 2023
37:05total
37:06carpet bombing
37:08by aeroplanes
37:09by artillery
37:11by tanks
37:12by boats
37:14with artillery
37:15and you know
37:17half of the
37:18population
37:18of Gaza
37:19is younger
37:20than 21 years
37:22old
37:22they don't know
37:23any other reality
37:24the only reality
37:26they know
37:27is living
37:27in this ghetto
37:28that three times
37:30was brutally
37:31attacked
37:31with the most
37:32cutting edge
37:33weapons
37:34that the world
37:35has
37:36and ironically
37:38and cynically
37:38Israel is using
37:40modern weapons
37:42against Gaza
37:43all the time
37:44because it
37:45increases the
37:46sales
37:46of the Israeli
37:48military industry
37:49people
37:50unfortunately
37:51also in Brazil
37:52people buy
37:54the Israeli
37:54weapons
37:55because they
37:56were already
37:56experimented
37:57successfully
37:58on human
37:59beings
38:00this is
38:02you know
38:03and inhuman
38:04that
38:06again
38:08doesn't justify
38:08everything
38:09but explains
38:11to us
38:11the anger
38:12the outrage
38:14of the 7th of October
38:15nothing
38:17that happened
38:18there
38:18I justify
38:19but I
38:19say
38:20let's
38:21let's have this
38:22this is even
38:23not an historical
38:24context
38:25I think this is
38:26also a moral
38:27context
38:27and you know
38:28and with this
38:29I will strive
38:30to name
38:31anti-colonialist
38:34movements
38:35that were engaged
38:36in decolonization
38:38never
38:39took upon
38:41themselves
38:41to have
38:43a process
38:43of decolonization
38:44that is nice
38:46it's peaceful
38:47is through
38:50giving flowers
38:51to the colonized
38:53and asking
38:53them patiently
38:54to leave
38:55decolonization
38:57is an ugly
38:57process
38:58it's a messy
39:00process
39:00it's a violent
39:02process
39:02because colonization
39:04is ugly
39:05and colonization
39:06is violent
39:07so don't expect
39:09decolonization
39:09in Palestine
39:10to be
39:11an event
39:13of Quakers
39:13this is
39:15what's happening
39:16and
39:17this is
39:18very important
39:19to remember
39:20in many
39:22many cases
39:23anti-colonialist
39:24movement
39:25had events
39:26like the 7th
39:27of October
39:28the FLN
39:29that fought
39:30against the
39:31French
39:32occupation
39:33of Algeria
39:34some of the
39:35FLN people
39:36massacred
39:37families
39:38many families
39:39of the settlers
39:40in Iran
39:41in July
39:421962
39:43people condemned
39:45rightly
39:45the massacre
39:46but they didn't
39:48say
39:48that because of
39:49that
39:50the FLN
39:51struggle
39:51for independence
39:52is unjustified
39:54and there's
39:55so many other
39:56cases
39:59in history
40:00where of course
40:01as I say
40:02this is a messy
40:03business
40:03it can be
40:04very violent
40:06also on the
40:07side of the
40:07anti-colonialist
40:09movement
40:10but that does
40:11not delegitimize
40:12the anti-colonialist
40:15struggle
40:16so I think
40:17what we should
40:19be saying
40:21in kind of
40:22conclusion
40:22is that if we
40:24know that
40:24history
40:25the deeper
40:26history
40:27the more
40:27recent history
40:28we first of
40:30all understand
40:31that when
40:32people say
40:33that the
40:34problem is
40:34the Hamas
40:35attack on
40:36Israel
40:36on the 7th of
40:37October
40:38or even
40:38the Israeli
40:39genocide
40:40of Gaza
40:40they are
40:41talking about
40:42the symptoms
40:43of violence
40:44but not
40:45about the
40:46origin
40:46of the
40:47violence
40:47it's like
40:48treating an
40:49illness
40:50through the
40:51symptoms
40:51but not
40:52knowing
40:52what is
40:53the source
40:54of the
40:55illness
40:55so it
40:56won't help
40:57the international
40:58community
40:59if its
41:00political leaders
41:01believe
41:01that what
41:02happens
41:03in Gaza
41:04now
41:04is a
41:06great concern
41:07not only
41:08for the
41:08Palestinians
41:09and not
41:10only for
41:10the Arab
41:10world
41:11and not
41:11only for
41:12the Muslim
41:12world
41:13but a
41:13concern
41:14for humanity
41:15in general
41:16they would
41:17have to
41:18deal with
41:19the origin
41:19of the
41:21violence
41:22not with
41:22the symptoms
41:23of the
41:23violence
41:24and in
41:25this respect
41:25I'm afraid
41:26to say
41:26the two
41:27state solution
41:28is dealing
41:29with the
41:29symptom
41:30of the
41:30violence
41:31and not
41:31the violence
41:32itself
41:32the only
41:33way
41:34is to
41:34face
41:35bravely
41:36you need
41:36to be
41:36very brave
41:37those of you
41:38who are
41:38activists
41:38in Brazil
41:39would know
41:40the only
41:41way
41:41to face
41:42bravely
41:43and to
41:43say
41:43we
41:44understand
41:45what
41:46Zionism
41:46meant
41:47in
41:47Israel
41:47we
41:48understand
41:48the wish
41:49of the
41:49Jews
41:50and God
41:50to be
41:51equal
41:51to have
41:52maybe
41:52even
41:53their own
41:53nationality
41:54but
41:56what
41:56it
41:57became
41:57on the
41:58land
41:58of
41:58Palestine
41:59is an
41:59ideology
42:00of
42:00secular
42:01colonialism
42:01of apartheid
42:03of racism
42:04of ethnic
42:05cleansing
42:06and
42:06Latin
42:07genocide
42:07and this
42:08is something
42:09we don't
42:09accept
42:10not because
42:11we are
42:11anti-Jewish
42:12in my case
42:13self-hating
42:14Jew
42:14not because
42:15we do
42:17not understand
42:18what happened
42:19to the Jewish
42:20people
42:20over the
42:21history
42:22and in
42:23the world
42:23but because
42:24exactly
42:25for the same
42:26reason
42:27that we
42:27oppose
42:28anti-Semitism
42:29we oppose
42:30Zionism
42:31that is
42:32very important
42:33and I
42:34think that
42:34historical context
42:36like this
42:36would force
42:37eventually
42:39political leaders
42:40in the world
42:41to say
42:42we have
42:43to admit
42:44that the
42:45Palestinians
42:46were totally
42:47ignored by us
42:48we never
42:49asked them
42:49from the very
42:50beginning
42:50until today
42:52we never
42:52asked them
42:53what they want
42:54what is their
42:55dreams
42:55for the future
42:56and in fact
42:57they would
42:58learn
42:59that if
43:00they would
43:00talk to
43:00the Palestinians
43:01they would
43:02find
43:03an incredible
43:04people
43:05that despite
43:06everything
43:06that happened
43:08to them
43:08in the last
43:09140 years
43:10they are not
43:11moved
43:12by the
43:13impulse
43:13of revenge
43:14they are not
43:15moved
43:16by the
43:17impulse
43:17of hatred
43:18what they want
43:19is normal
43:20life
43:20in their
43:22own homeland
43:22all over
43:24their homeland
43:24with all
43:25the people
43:26of the homeland
43:27including
43:27those
43:28who were
43:28expelled
43:29and this
43:30is something
43:31that was
43:31denied
43:31today
43:32and unless
43:34we face
43:35the Zionist
43:36ideology
43:36of the
43:37state
43:37of Israel
43:37not just
43:38its policies
43:38we will
43:40never be able
43:41to help
43:41the Palestinians
43:42to secure
43:43normal
43:44and natural
43:45life
43:45like any
43:46other people
43:47in the world
43:48thank you
43:48for
44:08the
44:09people
44:09who
44:10who
44:11who
44:11who
44:12who
44:12who
44:13Aplausos

Recomendado