3
2
- 1 year ago
The US-China superpower rivalry is on full display in Taiwan. Beijing wants control of the island and is willing to use force to get it. Washington has been ambiguous about how it would respond but is expanding its military presence in the region. Taiwan is at the center of the US first island chain strategy to contain China. A standoff seems almost unavoidable. But what factors give the tiny island such an outsize importance for both superpowers? And why is neither side backing down?
We speak to foreign policy experts Victor Gao (Center for China and Globalization) and David Sacks (Council on Foreign Relations) and find out what people in Taiwan think of the tensions.
Chapters
00:00 All eyes on Taiwan
01:12 Taiwan's strategic location
04:13 US "first island chain" strategy
07:24 Taiwan's TSMC: An economic powerhouse
09:34 A history of old loyalties
12:19 Taiwan's complicated status quo
14:14 Big ideas for a small island
We speak to foreign policy experts Victor Gao (Center for China and Globalization) and David Sacks (Council on Foreign Relations) and find out what people in Taiwan think of the tensions.
Chapters
00:00 All eyes on Taiwan
01:12 Taiwan's strategic location
04:13 US "first island chain" strategy
07:24 Taiwan's TSMC: An economic powerhouse
09:34 A history of old loyalties
12:19 Taiwan's complicated status quo
14:14 Big ideas for a small island
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Chinese soldiers preparing for battle.
00:05This is what Beijing wants to show the world.
00:08With each military drill, China is drawing ever closer circles around Taiwan.
00:14China has a clear goal to gain control over the island.
00:19China will surely be reunified.
00:23Are you willing to get involved militarily to defend Taiwan if it comes to that?
00:28Yes. That's a commitment we made.
00:31The United States is building up its military presence in the region
00:35and is practicing how to sink Chinese ships.
00:43We're not going to come to an agreement over Taiwan.
00:46Wait for their unification to be achieved.
00:48Peacefully, I hope. Non-peacefully. I dread.
00:53But why are these two superpowers so fixated on Taiwan?
00:57What's in it for China and the US?
01:00And how do people in Taiwan feel about it?
01:04It's Taiwan's location that makes it a geopolitical flashpoint.
01:22Taiwan has 23 million inhabitants, and its main island lies only 130 kilometers away from China's mainland.
01:31These tiny islands right off the coast are also under Taiwanese control.
01:38And Chinese military drills around the whole of Taiwan are getting bigger and more frequent.
01:44In recent videos released by China's People's Liberation Army, Beijing has threatened to encircle the island.
01:55It sees Taiwan as part of its territory and says it's ready to use force if necessary to get it back.
02:05We'll talk more about the history and Taiwan's status later.
02:10For now, you need to know that in the late 1940s, there was a civil war in China between communists and nationalists.
02:18The communists won and took control of mainland China.
02:22And the nationalists fled to Taiwan.
02:27That laid the groundwork for today's tensions.
02:32The US has an ambiguous policy towards Taiwan.
02:35Since the late 1970s, it's recognized communist Beijing as the only legitimate government of China.
02:41But it has informal ties with Taiwan and is seen as the island's protector.
02:48OK, let's go back to the map to understand why the US and China can't quit Taiwan.
02:55In some ways, Taiwan's strategic importance is about three choke points around the island.
03:01To the west, there's the Taiwan Strait.
03:04It's a key trade route for both Beijing and Taiwan, and also for everybody else.
03:09Almost all the world's biggest container ships pass through here.
03:14To the north, the Miyako Strait.
03:17It runs between Taiwan and these Japanese islands.
03:21And in the south, the Bashi Strait.
03:24It runs between Taiwan and the Philippines.
03:27For China, these two straits on either side of Taiwan are key strategic gateways to the Pacific Sea.
03:33Taiwan is in the middle of the Chinese coastline, which is very important.
03:41This is Victor Gao.
03:43He's a former Chinese diplomat and vice president of the Center for China and Globalization.
03:48A Beijing think tank some say is close to the Chinese Communist Party.
03:54Taiwan island faces the Pacific directly.
03:58And if Taiwan is occupied by a foreign country, for example, it interrupts the continuity of the Chinese coastline and also prevents the Chinese access directly to the Pacific Ocean.
04:13The U.S. says it has no troops permanently stationed in Taiwan, but the island plays an important role in U.S. strategy.
04:22To understand why, let's look at the military bases in the region.
04:26Here are some of China's main naval bases close to its coast.
04:31And the U.S. has some of its key bases in South Korea, Japan and the Philippines.
04:37If you connect the dots, you'll see the U.S. bases form a chain.
04:42Taiwan sits at the heart of what we call in the United States the first island chain.
04:47David Sachs is an expert at the Council on Foreign Relations, a think tank in New York City.
04:52In the past, he worked at the American Institute in Taiwan, which serves as the de facto U.S. embassy on the island.
05:00If you look at the first island chain, these are all formal treaty allies of the United States or close partners in the case of Taiwan.
05:06And with that, the way it is, the United States can project power close to China's shores, protect its allies and its interests.
05:14Conversely, it's very difficult for the Chinese military to project power outside of the first island chain and threaten the United States physically or our interests in the Indo-Pacific.
05:25To strengthen this island chain, the U.S. is expanding military cooperation with Japan and the Philippines, which are also wary of what they see as China's expansionist goals.
05:37For example, just last year, the U.S. gained access to military bases in the north of the Philippines, right next to the Bashi Strait, one of those Chinese gateways to the Pacific Ocean we mentioned.
05:50Here you can see American and Philippine troops conducting exercises in the waters nearby earlier this year.
05:59They even sank an old Chinese-built ship that the Philippine Navy used in the past, a clear message to Beijing.
06:08And obviously, China is not happy about the U.S. island chain strategy.
06:13Come on, we are not living in the 19th century. We are not living in the imperialist century.
06:22Using this outmoded way of thinking, as if you can set up a chain to block, for example, China from accessing the Pacific Ocean. It's ludicrous.
06:36Beijing is rapidly modernizing its navy, in part to be able to break through the chain of U.S. allies.
06:45For example, with the Fujian aircraft carrier. Here it is on sea trials earlier this year.
06:51It's China's third aircraft carrier and the biggest ship in the Chinese navy.
06:57The number one objective here is to keep the United States out of the region during a conflict.
07:04So what we call anti-access area denial.
07:07Prevent the United States from being able to defend our treaty allies and partners.
07:13So to sum up, Taiwan's location makes it essential to both sides as they try to gain the upper hand in the region.
07:20But the rivalry is also about money. Big money.
07:33Economically, the small island has an outsize importance for both China and the U.S.,
07:38even though neither officially recognize Taiwan as a country.
07:42Both China and the U.S. have significant trade links with Taiwan.
07:49And much of that business comes from just one company.
07:52TSMC, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company.
07:59It produces microchips.
08:02Taiwan makes 90% of the most advanced ones in the world.
08:06Both the U.S. and China are dependent on them.
08:09And so is everybody else.
08:11There's a good chance TSMC's semiconductors are in the device that you're using
08:18to watch this video right now.
08:21They're in new cars, fridges, and fighter jets everywhere.
08:28They're needed to develop new AI models.
08:31And U.S. leaders worry that losing Taiwan to China could permanently shift economic tides against them.
08:39We don't assume that a region under Chinese hegemony would be open to U.S. trade and investment.
08:45I think that China would reorder the region.
08:48They want the United States to basically supply them with raw materials that are turned into manufactured goods in China and then sold all over the world.
08:57And there isn't really a role for the United States or other industrialized countries in that.
09:02The Chinese economy is already larger than that of the United States if you use purchasing power parity.
09:07China produced more than 30 million cars in 2030.
09:11The Americans probably produced less than half of that.
09:15So why should anyone believe they can have some benefit of picking a fight with China?
09:21No, there is no benefit.
09:23China does not look at Taiwan from an economic or commercial perspective.
09:29So why is Taiwan so important to Beijing then?
09:40To understand, let's dive back into history.
09:43China lost control over Taiwan during what it calls the Century of Humiliation.
09:48These caricatures of China being carved up by various foreign powers might explain why.
09:54From the mid-19th until the mid-20th century, China was plagued by invasions and internal disputes.
10:01This is important because that notion of humiliation still plays a big role in Chinese state ideology even today.
10:09In 1895, Japan took Taiwan from China and made it a colony.
10:15After World War II, the Allies forced Japan to give it back.
10:19But at the time, China was in the middle of a civil war.
10:24The government of the Republic of China, or ROC, was led by nationalists under Chiang Kai-shek.
10:34Mao Zedong led communist forces against them.
10:38In 1949, the victorious communists marched into Beijing and established the People's Republic of China on the mainland.
10:47The defeated government of the Republic of China fled to Taiwan.
10:52That's why there are two governments that call themselves China.
10:56One on the mainland, the People's Republic of China, or PRC, and on Taiwan, the Republic of China, or ROC.
11:05The PRC government in Beijing sees Taiwan as a breakaway province and says there's only one China,
11:12even though they've never actually been in charge in Taiwan.
11:16Most of the world accepts this one-China policy, including the U.S.
11:21They don't recognize Taiwan as an independent country.
11:24Wait, so why is the U.S. supporting Taiwan then?
11:29There's also a history to that.
11:33After the civil war, the U.S. initially saw the nationalist government in Taiwan as the only real China,
11:39rejecting the communist government on the mainland.
11:42U.S. soldiers were even stationed in Taiwan under a common defense pact.
11:48The change came in the 1970s.
11:51The U.S. sought closer relations with Beijing.
11:55That meant closing the U.S. embassy in Taiwan and pulling out U.S. troops.
12:01Still, informal ties persisted, like that de facto embassy.
12:05And the U.S. still guarantees to sell Taiwan weapons.
12:09But they have a deliberately ambiguous policy on whether they would defend Taiwan.
12:14It's meant to prevent China from invading and Taiwan from declaring independence.
12:20But that strange limbo has been the status quo in Taiwan for decades.
12:25And it's created realities on the ground.
12:28Taiwan developed from a nationalist authoritarian regime
12:32into one of the strongest democracies in the region.
12:35There are elections, a free press, and civil liberties.
12:42Taiwan was first in Asia to legalize same-sex marriage.
12:46This year, a progressive party was re-elected for a third term,
12:50vowing to maintain that tense status quo.
12:54DW's Taiwan correspondent Yuchen Li can give us a sense of things on the ground.
13:00Here in Taiwan, the atmosphere is very different from you might read in the headlines.
13:05The tension has become part of daily life.
13:08One key reason is that people in Taiwan have been living under the threat of the Chinese Communist Party for many decades.
13:15The majority of the Taiwanese prefer to maintain the status quo with China.
13:20But how to do so is a rather polarized debate.
13:23If China wants to bully us, at least we still have the U.S. and Japan.
13:28They're our friends.
13:30I've always been skeptical of America.
13:36But we have no choice if we can't get stronger or have enough forces.
13:40It's tricky.
13:45We should have a friendly relationship with both of them.
13:49It's always been like this.
13:54Ever since the founding of the country, we've been caught up in this drama.
13:57But one thing is clear for many Taiwanese, Taiwan's voice is usually drawn out.
14:02Amid a U.S.-China rivalry, many feel that Taiwan is only a pawn in the game.
14:07And no matter what comes next, the island should have the right and autonomy to decide its own fate.
14:14But there's one more factor that stands in the way of that.
14:18Taiwan represents something for both superpowers.
14:27Taiwan has embraced the U.S. worldview, which promotes democracy and capitalism.
14:32China is a one-party system and a socialist market economy.
14:36And a major Chinese Communist Party narrative centers on Taiwan.
14:40Remember the century of humiliation we mentioned when China lost Taiwan?
14:48Well, Chinese President Xi Jinping sees bringing Taiwan back into the fold
14:52as an important step in overcoming that humiliation.
14:57This is part of the so-called national rejuvenation,
15:00a revival of the Chinese nation as a great power.
15:05With Xi Jinping, I think you did see some impatience.
15:07Xi Jinping has clearly put himself forward as a leader of, you know, world historic importance.
15:16He views himself in a very similar way, I think, to Vladimir Putin,
15:20that he's just not a run-of-the-mill leader.
15:22He's transformative.
15:23No one, no country, no single human being will be able to block the peaceful reunification of China,
15:32or the non-peaceful reunification of China.
15:35So we should all call on the United States.
15:38Don't play with fire.
15:40But for the U.S., supporting Taiwan also means keeping up key alliances in the region and promoting democracy.
15:47If China were to invade and annex Taiwan, we would see that democracy extinguished,
15:54and it could send chilling effects to democracies around the world.
15:58You would have deep questions being asked in South Korea, Japan, and the Philippines
16:02on whether they can rely on the United States for their security.
16:06Because of where Taiwan is and what it represents, neither China nor the U.S. are able to back down.
16:13And the rest of us are stuck watching the superpower rivalry play out.