Skip to playerSkip to main content
Forbes Breaking News
  • 8 months ago
During the Oral Arguments for 'Diamond International, LLC v. EPA', Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh questioned an attorney about the effect of California EPA standards on the markets.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Thank you, counsel. Justice Thomas, anything further? Justice Kagan? Justice Kagan? Justice Kavanaugh?
00:09I'm not sure there's a huge amount of difference between the rule and the backup position.
00:16I mean, the rule is based on the common sense predictable effects in a particular context,
00:22but either way you go, you get to the same destination. I guess I'm not seeing a huge gap.
00:28I agree, Justice Kavanaugh, we should win no matter what the court says, but I do think that a case like this,
00:39it's not that there should be daylight in the right outcomes, it's that once we make it about evidence,
00:47we're going to have to come in every case and there's going to be a debate, like,
00:50well, what do you have to show to trigger a common sense inference, and how common is that common sense?
00:54Well, what we said last year in FDA versus Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine,
01:00just summarizing the standing law should be, kind of gets at it, doesn't it?
01:06I would have thought so too, Justice Kavanaugh, but here we are.
01:08But look, I'll be the first to grant that if you take that paragraph in Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine
01:12and you say, look, even if we're not going to call it a rule, there are certain categories where we've said
01:17the effects seem awfully predictable, and this falls into one of the categories,
01:21that starts to look pretty much like a rule to me, but I'll grant that if that's language
01:25that the court thinks squares more comfortably with its standing precedents in general,
01:30it gets us to the, it should get us to the same place.
01:33Justice Kavanaugh.
Be the first to comment
Add your comment

Recommended

Sonia Sotomayor Lays Into Attorney Over CA Emissions Rule Case: ‘That Is Really Unfair’
Forbes Breaking News
8 months ago
Supreme Court Hears Oral Argument In California Vehicle Emissions Standards Case
Forbes Breaking News
8 months ago
‘Why Do You Care?’: Amy Coney Barrett Presses Attorney About California Fuel Standards
Forbes Breaking News
8 months ago
Ketanji Brown Jackson Presses Attorney On How California Fuel Rules Affect All Businesses
Forbes Breaking News
8 months ago
Elena Kagan Slams Attorney During California Emissions Rule Case: ‘You Didn’t Put On Much Evidence’
Forbes Breaking News
8 months ago
Ketanji Brown Jackson Asks Attorney About How CA Fuel Rules Will Affect Soybean And Corn Farmers
Forbes Breaking News
8 months ago
Chris Van Hollen Grills EPA Head Lee Zeldin On Claims Deemed Baseless In Federal Courts
Forbes Breaking News
7 months ago
California Attorney General Rob Bonta Pressed About The Expected Court Response To California’s Lawsuit Against Trump
Forbes Breaking News
8 months ago
Supreme Court Hears Oral Arguments In Disability Lawsuit Against Laboratory Corporation Of America
Forbes Breaking News
8 months ago
A California man has been charged with the attempted murder of Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh. Let us explain what’s happening …
Brut America
4 years ago
'I Disagree': Trump Lawyer Fires Back At Ketanji Brown Jackson In Nationwide Injunctions Case
Forbes Breaking News
7 months ago
Jon Ossoff And EPA Head Lee Zeldin Get Into Testy Exchange Over Cancelled EPA Grant
Forbes Breaking News
7 months ago
Sonia Sotomayor Presses Attorney About Past Rulings In Case Challenging The Affordable Care Act
Forbes Breaking News
8 months ago
Justice Samuel Alito Asks Trump’s Lawyer: 'What Is The Point Of This Argument About Universal Injunctions?'
Forbes Breaking News
7 months ago
Morgan Griffith Blasts California For 'Imposing Its Preference On The Rest Of The Country' Through Air Rules
Forbes Breaking News
8 months ago
'Today's A Great Day For The Rule Of Law': Deputy AG Todd Blanche Touts SCOTUS Injunction Ruling
Forbes Breaking News
6 months ago
'The Day He Raised His Right Hand And Took The Oath' He Broke The Law: California AG Rob Bonta Shreds Trump
Forbes Breaking News
5 months ago
The Supreme Court Hears Oral Arguments In Case About FBI Conducting Raid On Incorrect House
Forbes Breaking News
8 months ago
California AG Rob Bonta Reacts To Supreme Courts Granting Trump Admin Stay In LA ICE Raids
Forbes Breaking News
3 months ago
CA Lawmaker Joe Patterson Accuses Dems Of Acting As 'Ruling Dictator Party' Of California
Forbes Breaking News
4 months ago
Bitcoin Slides To $85K
Benzinga
2 days ago
Trump's Net Worth Surges
Benzinga
2 days ago
Trump Crypto Picks Confirmed
Benzinga
2 days ago
Stories Behind the Top Photos of 2025: Nuns at St. Peter's Square [VERTICAL]
TIME
4 days ago
In Memoriam: A Tribute to Those We've Lost in 2025 [VERTICAL]
TIME
4 days ago