00:00I know you've discussed this as well on the Alec Baldwin case.
00:02Another surprising ruling out of Arizona
00:05where the judge tossed that case because prosecutors hadn't
00:08turned over bullet evidence that the defense had requested
00:13or didn't know about.
00:14One thing I do want to ask you about this is he's a celebrity.
00:18He has high-powered attorneys.
00:20Do you feel like that played into the decision
00:22to dismiss this case with prejudice against Alec Baldwin?
00:26I think the Baldwin case was more
00:28of a loss for the prosecution than it
00:30was a win for Baldwin and the defense.
00:32And obviously, Baldwin's lawyers, Quinn and Manuel,
00:34they did a very good job.
00:35They went to Harvard Law School, where I'm at right now.
00:38But every first-year law student knows
00:40that you have to disclose exculpatory evidence.
00:43It's a criminal law issue.
00:44It's a constitutional issue under the US Supreme Court's
00:48seminal decision in the United States versus Brady.
00:50So the fact that the prosecutors in the case, Morrissey
00:53and Johnston, received ammunition
00:56that suggested that someone other than Armour and Hand
00:59and Gutierrez-Reed supplied the live rounds that
01:02showed up on set and killed cinematographer Helena Hutchins,
01:05that was evidence that had to be disclosed to the defense.
01:07Because the argument is that Kenny, who has a prop store,
01:12he was the one who was responsible.
01:14And the fact that the prosecution
01:16didn't disclose this evidence was
01:18such a huge intentional error.
01:22That's the important part.
01:23When Morrissey took the stand, if she
01:26had testified truthfully that it was an inadvertent failure,
01:30maybe, just maybe, the case could have been salvaged.
01:33But it was clear that the failure
01:35to disclose this exculpatory evidence was intentional.
01:38The judge had no real choice but to issue the ultimate sanction.
01:43And that was dismissal of the case.
01:45I thought the prosecutor had also
01:47suggested that it was an inadvertent mistake,
01:49an oversight, that they had not turned over this ballistics
01:52evidence.
01:52Is that incorrect?
01:54I think that was because there was an affirmative decision
01:57to place it in another file that was not
01:59disclosed to the defense.
02:00And I think it was that decision that the judge in the case
02:03pointed to.
02:04And let's not forget, this isn't the first mistake
02:06made in the case.
02:07It was certainly the most serious.
02:09But from the beginning, the prosecution
02:11charged an unconstitutional enhancement.
02:14The New Mexico legislature passed
02:16a law that called for a five-year mandatory minimum
02:19sentence in a state prison for certain types of firearms
02:23enhancements.
02:23And obviously, we know that criminal laws
02:26can apply retroactively.
02:27That law was passed after the Rust shooting.
02:30Prosecutors tried to charge it, but that
02:32was stricken because it violated the ex post facto
02:35clause of the Constitution.
02:36Then the district attorney appointed
02:39a member of the Mexico State legislature
02:40to be a special prosecutor in the case.
02:42And we know that's a separation of powers issue.
02:44Prosecutors are part of the executive branch.
02:46And obviously, legislature is the legislative branch.
02:49And when it was clear that prosecutors
02:51weren't ready for a preliminary hearing,
02:53they just dismissed the case, go to a grand jury,
02:56and get indictment a year later.
02:58So really, this is the fourth mistake in the case, probably
03:02one of the most botched prosecutions
03:04in American history.
03:05And really, people should lose their jobs
03:08and potentially get sanctioned by the state bar.
03:11I mean, these are some really bad violations
03:14by the attorney's handle in this case.
03:16Yeah, it was almost a soap opera in itself.
03:18It could have been a movie like The Stumbles
03:20that kept appearing and kept happening in this case.
03:24Like you said, there were a lot of botched and missed
03:27opportunities, not making a judgment on whether Alec
03:30Baldwin was guilty.
03:31But the prosecution definitely missed a lot of opportunities.