• 2 years ago
Neama Rahmani, President of West Coast Trial Lawyers, joined Forbes Senior Legal Editor Liane Jackson on "Forbes Newsroom" to discuss the Alec Baldwin dismissal in the "Rust" shooting.


Fuel your success with Forbes. Gain unlimited access to premium journalism, including breaking news, groundbreaking in-depth reported stories, daily digests and more. Plus, members get a front-row seat at members-only events with leading thinkers and doers, access to premium video that can help you get ahead, an ad-light experience, early access to select products including NFT drops and more:

https://account.forbes.com/membership/?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=display&utm_campaign=growth_non-sub_paid_subscribe_ytdescript


Stay Connected
Forbes on Facebook: http://fb.com/forbes
Forbes Video on Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/forbes
Forbes Video on Instagram: http://instagram.com/forbes
More From Forbes: http://forbes.com

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00I know you've discussed this as well on the Alec Baldwin case.
00:02Another surprising ruling out of Arizona
00:05where the judge tossed that case because prosecutors hadn't
00:08turned over bullet evidence that the defense had requested
00:13or didn't know about.
00:14One thing I do want to ask you about this is he's a celebrity.
00:18He has high-powered attorneys.
00:20Do you feel like that played into the decision
00:22to dismiss this case with prejudice against Alec Baldwin?
00:26I think the Baldwin case was more
00:28of a loss for the prosecution than it
00:30was a win for Baldwin and the defense.
00:32And obviously, Baldwin's lawyers, Quinn and Manuel,
00:34they did a very good job.
00:35They went to Harvard Law School, where I'm at right now.
00:38But every first-year law student knows
00:40that you have to disclose exculpatory evidence.
00:43It's a criminal law issue.
00:44It's a constitutional issue under the US Supreme Court's
00:48seminal decision in the United States versus Brady.
00:50So the fact that the prosecutors in the case, Morrissey
00:53and Johnston, received ammunition
00:56that suggested that someone other than Armour and Hand
00:59and Gutierrez-Reed supplied the live rounds that
01:02showed up on set and killed cinematographer Helena Hutchins,
01:05that was evidence that had to be disclosed to the defense.
01:07Because the argument is that Kenny, who has a prop store,
01:12he was the one who was responsible.
01:14And the fact that the prosecution
01:16didn't disclose this evidence was
01:18such a huge intentional error.
01:22That's the important part.
01:23When Morrissey took the stand, if she
01:26had testified truthfully that it was an inadvertent failure,
01:30maybe, just maybe, the case could have been salvaged.
01:33But it was clear that the failure
01:35to disclose this exculpatory evidence was intentional.
01:38The judge had no real choice but to issue the ultimate sanction.
01:43And that was dismissal of the case.
01:45I thought the prosecutor had also
01:47suggested that it was an inadvertent mistake,
01:49an oversight, that they had not turned over this ballistics
01:52evidence.
01:52Is that incorrect?
01:54I think that was because there was an affirmative decision
01:57to place it in another file that was not
01:59disclosed to the defense.
02:00And I think it was that decision that the judge in the case
02:03pointed to.
02:04And let's not forget, this isn't the first mistake
02:06made in the case.
02:07It was certainly the most serious.
02:09But from the beginning, the prosecution
02:11charged an unconstitutional enhancement.
02:14The New Mexico legislature passed
02:16a law that called for a five-year mandatory minimum
02:19sentence in a state prison for certain types of firearms
02:23enhancements.
02:23And obviously, we know that criminal laws
02:26can apply retroactively.
02:27That law was passed after the Rust shooting.
02:30Prosecutors tried to charge it, but that
02:32was stricken because it violated the ex post facto
02:35clause of the Constitution.
02:36Then the district attorney appointed
02:39a member of the Mexico State legislature
02:40to be a special prosecutor in the case.
02:42And we know that's a separation of powers issue.
02:44Prosecutors are part of the executive branch.
02:46And obviously, legislature is the legislative branch.
02:49And when it was clear that prosecutors
02:51weren't ready for a preliminary hearing,
02:53they just dismissed the case, go to a grand jury,
02:56and get indictment a year later.
02:58So really, this is the fourth mistake in the case, probably
03:02one of the most botched prosecutions
03:04in American history.
03:05And really, people should lose their jobs
03:08and potentially get sanctioned by the state bar.
03:11I mean, these are some really bad violations
03:14by the attorney's handle in this case.
03:16Yeah, it was almost a soap opera in itself.
03:18It could have been a movie like The Stumbles
03:20that kept appearing and kept happening in this case.
03:24Like you said, there were a lot of botched and missed
03:27opportunities, not making a judgment on whether Alec
03:30Baldwin was guilty.
03:31But the prosecution definitely missed a lot of opportunities.

Recommended