• 6 hours ago
A captured P-47 Thunderbolt gave German pilots the chance to test the American fighter for themselves—and their findings revealed why its weaknesses rarely decided the air war. After a lost U.S. pilot landed in occupied Normandy, Luftwaffe test pilot Hans-Werner Lerche examined the aircraft, discovering that it was sluggish down low but formidable at high altitude and in a dive.

This military history documentary follows the Thunderbolt from Lerche’s test flights to the experiences of German ace Günther Rall and American pilots Robert Johnson and Joe Powers. Explore the P-47’s durability, turbo-supercharger, long-range escort role, and the tactics and upgrades that changed the fight over Europe. A detailed WW2 aviation story for viewers interested in the Luftwaffe, U.S. Army Air Forces, fighter aircraft, and the history of aerial combat.

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00On the afternoon of November 10th, 1943, on an airfield outside Caen in occupied Normandy,
00:06a German test pilot climbed onto the wing of an American fighter and looked down into its cockpit.
00:12He had flown a long list of enemy aircraft. He had never looked into one like this.
00:18His name was Hans-Werner Lerke, a Hauptmann from the Luftwaffe's test center at Rechlin.
00:24His job was simple to describe and dangerous to do. Fly whatever the enemy left behind,
00:31find out what it could really do, and tell Germany's fighter pilots the truth.
00:37And the machine under his boots was the one every German fighter pilot in the West had been arguing
00:42about since spring. A Republic P-47 Thunderbolt. Not a wreck in a field, a complete airplane,
00:51standing on its own wheels. The first thing that hit him was the size. Lerke later wrote that the
00:59Thunderbolt's fuselage was bigger in cross-section than a pre-war Heinkel high-speed passenger plane.
01:06A fighter, fatter than an airliner. The second thing was the cockpit. And notice what a German
01:13professional chose to put in print. The P-47 cockpit, he wrote, could baffle even an experienced pilot.
01:21Switches he didn't recognize. Hydraulic flaps. A warning lamp for a turbine spinning in the exhaust,
01:28something no German fighter in service carried. And on the instruments, small painted arcs of red
01:35and green, marking where every needle was supposed to sit. Lerke guessed they were there for pilots who
01:41couldn't read English well. Whatever the reason, they told him something. This airplane had been
01:47built for a man who would sit in it for hours, with a great deal to watch and very little
01:52time
01:52to think. Then he noticed the room. After years in the narrow cockpit of a Messerschmitt,
01:59he found the Thunderbolt's cockpit pleasantly surprising and comfortable. He could move his
02:05shoulders. The canopy slid back smoothly. Everyone at Vechlin, Lerke wrote, was eager to see whether
02:11this fighter's performance was really so legendary as it was reported to be. Hold on to that word,
02:18legendary. Because over the following days, Lerke would find two things in this airplane.
02:24One was a weakness, exactly the kind German pilots were hoping for. The other very nearly killed him.
02:32And months later, one of the highest-scoring fighter pilots who ever lived would fly the same type
02:38and come away with a verdict he repeated for the rest of his life. That is what this story is
02:44about.
02:44Not what the Americans said about the Thunderbolt. What the Germans admitted, once they had flown it
02:50themselves. But first, the obvious question. How does an intact American fighter end up parked on a
02:57German airfield in Normandy? Three days earlier, on November 7th, 2nd Lieutenant William E. Roach had
03:04taken off from England with the 358th Fighter Squadron of the 355th Fighter Group. The group
03:11was new to combat. By one account, it was only his third mission. The job was escort over northern
03:17France. On the way home, the weather turned. One record puts the headwinds at more than 100 miles an
03:23hour. And a Thunderbolt, fighting that kind of wind, drinks fuel. Roach lost his bearings in the
03:30murk. The fuel gauge kept dropping. He watched his squadron leader go down in a crash landing.
03:37Then, through the clouds, an airfield. Roach put the big fighter down. A vehicle came out to guide him,
03:45and he followed it to a parking spot and shut down the engine. Only then, as the propeller wound to
03:52a
03:52stop and men gathered around his wing, did he understand. They were German.
03:58Roach would spend the rest of the war behind barbed wire at Stalag Luft 1 on the Baltic coast.
04:05His Thunderbolt, serial number 42-22-490, was given German crosses. And with it, the Luftwaffe got its
04:17first real chance to answer a question it had been fighting over for seven months. If you value the
04:23history of the American airmen who flew the Thunderbolt over Europe, take a second to like
04:28this video and subscribe. It helps keep the story of the U.S. Army Air Forces in front of the
04:33people
04:34who should hear it. So why did the Germans care so much? Because by November 1943, German fighter pilots
04:42had been meeting the Thunderbolt for months. And the picture they had of it didn't add up.
04:47Some called it a flying barrel. Big, heavy, slow to climb. A target. Others had poured a burst into
04:56one that should have finished it, and watched it keep flying. And a few had tried the oldest escape in
05:02the fighter pilot's book. When a German pilot got into trouble against a Spitfire, the standard answer
05:08was to roll over and dive. The Focke-Wulf and the Messerschmitt were fast going downhill. Point the
05:15nose at the ground, open the throttle, and you were gone. On April 15th, 1943, near Ostend on the Belgian
05:23coast, a Focke-Wulf pilot did exactly that with a Thunderbolt behind him. The American was Don Blakesley,
05:30a veteran of the Eagle squadrons, now with the 4th Fighter Group. Blakesley didn't think much of the P-47.
05:36He'd compared it to a truck. He followed the German down anyway. The Focke-Wulf went into the ground
05:43near Ostend, the first enemy fighter ever shot down by a Thunderbolt. Back at base, a fellow pilot
05:50reminded Blakesley he'd been told the Jug could out-dive them. Blakesley gave him one grudging line.
05:56Well, it damn well ought to be able to dive. The German pilot never got to report what he'd learned.
06:02Others would. And what they learned that summer is exactly what Lerke, sitting in that cockpit at Caen,
06:09would now have to test with his own hands. To understand what Lerke was really testing,
06:14you have to go back four and a half months, to a single Thunderbolt and a single German pilot,
06:20who spent an entire flight trying to answer the same question.
06:24June 26, 1943. 48 Thunderbolts of the 56th Fighter Group were escorting B-17s home from a raid on
06:34Villa Kublai Airfield near Paris. In one of them sat 2nd Lieutenant Robert S. Johnson, 23, from Lawton,
06:43Oklahoma. He was the son of an auto mechanic and had once worked as a part-time firefighter.
06:49He had soloed at 12, after less than six hours of instruction. Near Forge-les-aux, 16 Focke-Wulfs
06:58of the 2nd Gruppe of Jagdgeschwader 26 came down on the formation from above and behind.
07:04The first pass scattered the Thunderbolts. Listen to what happened to Johnson's
07:09airplane in those few seconds, because every detail is going to matter.
07:1521 20mm cannon shells hit his fighter. The hydraulic lines ruptured. The canopy shattered.
07:22Shrapnel went into his leg and a machine gun round grazed his nose. Hydraulic fluid caught fire in the
07:29cockpit and burned his face, half-blinding him. The Thunderbolt went into a spin. He kicked rudder,
07:37pulled the stick back, and got it level. The fire went out by itself. He tried to bail out. The
07:44canopy
07:45would slide back about six inches and no further. A cannon shell had exploded right behind his headrest
07:51and jammed the frame. He pushed. He hammered. He braced his feet. Six inches. His parachute snagged.
08:01So Johnson did the only thing left. He turned his wrecked airplane toward England and flew.
08:08Near the Channel Coast, a lone Focke-Wulf found him.
08:13Now put yourself in that German pilot's seat for a moment. Below you is an enemy fighter, trailing oil,
08:19its canopy smashed, flying straight and slow. A kill that any pilot in your Stoffel would take without
08:27thinking twice. You line up behind it and fire. It keeps flying. The German came around again.
08:35Johnson skidded the airplane with his rudder to throw off his aim, and once the Focke-Wulf overshot
08:40so badly that Johnson got off a burst of his own. The German circled back. Pass after pass.
08:48At one point, he pulled up alongside, close enough for the two men to see each other.
08:53Then he dropped back and sprayed the thunderbolt from one wingtip to the other. It kept flying.
09:00When the German's guns finally ran dry, he slid up next to Johnson one last time.
09:06He rocked his wings. Then he turned for France and went home.
09:11Some historians have suggested the pilot may have been Egon Mayer,
09:15one of the Luftwaffe's leading aces on the Channel Coast. Nobody has proven it. But the name hardly
09:22matters. What matters is what that man did. He emptied his guns into an American fighter that
09:29couldn't fight back. He looked at it from a few yards away. And then he saluted it. That salute is
09:37the
09:37first German admission in this story. And notice, it wasn't written down anywhere. It was flown.
09:45Johnson brought the thunderbolt down at Manston on the Kent coast. Standing beside it, without even
09:51walking around the airplane, he started counting bullet holes. He passed 200 and stopped counting.
09:58Five days later, he was flying again. Now here is the problem. The same day Johnson's airplane refused
10:06to die, the 56th fighter group lost four pilots killed. Two thunderbolts were written off, and at
10:13least five more were badly damaged. The Germans had come from above, picked their moment, and done real
10:20harm. So the German pilots who fought the thunderbolt that summer came home with two lessons that didn't
10:26fit together. Lesson one. The thing was almost impossible to kill, and you could not dive away
10:32from it. Blakeslee had proven that over Ostend. Lesson two. Catch it slow, catch it low, and catch it
10:41climbing. And it was in trouble. Even the Americans said so. Hub Zemke, who commanded the 56th, admitted the
10:50early thunderbolt accelerated poorly and climbed not too much better from a slow airspeed.
10:56He would spend months building tactics around that problem. Remember Zemke's name. He'll come back
11:02with an answer. So which picture was true? A flying tank that couldn't be killed and couldn't be escaped?
11:09Or a heavy, sluggish target that a well-flown Focke-Wulf could chew up from above?
11:14A fighter pilot in combat can't answer that. He sees a few seconds of a fight, through gun sight glass,
11:20at 400 miles an hour. To answer it, Germany needed a man who could fly the thunderbolt the way its
11:26own
11:27pilots flew it. Climb it, dive it, measure it, and write down the numbers. That man was now standing on
11:34a wing at Caen.
11:36Lerke made his first flight in Roche's Thunderbolt on the afternoon of November 10th.
11:41Then the Normandy weather closed in, and for two days, nothing flew. On the third day, the plan was to
11:47move the thunderbolt east, first to the fighter base at Cormais near Paris, then on into Germany in
11:53Recklin. For the first leg, Lerke didn't fly the American fighter himself. A German fighter ace from
12:00Cormais climbed into the cockpit. Lerke flew escort beside him in a Messerschmitt.
12:05Think about who that pilot was. A man who had spent the year fighting Thunderbolts. A man who knew,
12:12better than any engineer at Recklin, what that airplane looked like in front of his guns.
12:17And on that short hop to Cormais, he came very close to wrecking it. Not because of the weather.
12:24Not because of the engine. Because of something about the American airplane he simply never thought
12:30to check. Lerke was flying a few hundred yards off the Thunderbolt's wing when the two of them
12:34reached Cormais. Below, the airfield. Ahead, the big American fighter turning onto its final approach.
12:42Slowing down. Flaps extended. And its wheels still tucked up inside the wings. On the ground,
12:50the controllers saw it too. They began firing red flares into the sky.
12:55The German pilots had a nickname for them. Radishes. The man in the cockpit was, in Lerke's words,
13:03a highly decorated fighter pilot stationed at Cormais. One of the Luftwaffe's best on the Channel
13:09coast. A man who had spent the year shooting at Thunderbolts. And he was about to belly land the
13:16only intact one Germany owned in front of his own squadron. Lerke pushed his throttle forward,
13:23pulled his Messerschmitt alongside, and lowered his own undercarriage. Then he raised it. And lowered
13:29it again. Look at me. Look at my wheels. The ace understood at once. The Thunderbolt's gear came down.
13:39Both airplanes went around the field one more time and landed without a scratch. Lerke, ever the diplomat,
13:46later suggested the pilot had only wanted to show his comrades how the American fighter handled in slow
13:51flight. Maybe. But remember what Lerke himself had written a few days before about that cockpit.
13:59It could baffle even an experienced pilot. Here was the proof. The most experienced enemy of the
14:06Thunderbolt in the area, inside one for the first time, and the most basic check on approach had slipped
14:12past him. There's a lesson in that small moment, and it runs through this whole story. Knowing an
14:19airplane from behind your gun sight, and knowing it from inside its cockpit, are two completely different
14:25kinds of knowledge. From Cormier, Lerke took over. He flew the Thunderbolt low under poor weather to
14:33Deelen in Holland, where the night fighter crews came out and, as he put it, admired the machine.
14:39He left Deelen around three in the afternoon and reached Rechlin at almost half past four,
14:44circling with his recognition lights on as the mist thickened over the field. And then the measuring
14:50began. Here is the first thing Rechlin wrote down, and I want you to hear it carefully, because every
14:57German fighter pilot who later read it would have felt something close to relief. I could discover
15:03nothing of the speed for which the Thunderbolt was renowned, Lerke wrote, at least not near the ground
15:09level. Down low, he found the American fighter rather lame and sluggish. Rechlin's measurements put
15:17its top speed near the ground at scarcely over 500 kilometers an hour. Call it a bit over 300 miles
15:23an hour.
15:24For a fighter with 2,000 horsepower in its nose, that was a remarkably ordinary number.
15:31The airplane had other habits, too. If you forgot to lock the tailwheel, the big fighter wanted to
15:37swing on the runway. Lerke forgot once, and only just avoided a ground loop on landing.
15:43So, there it was. The weakness the frontline pilots had sensed, now measured by Germany's own test center.
15:52Down low, the legend was just a very large, very heavy airplane. That is admission number one.
16:00And it pointed to an obvious conclusion. If the Thunderbolt is weak near the ground,
16:05then get it near the ground. Fight it low. Fight it slow. There was just one problem with that
16:13conclusion. The Americans had reached it first. Go back to the spring of 1943, to an airfield in
16:21England, and a man named Hub Zemka. Zemka was 28 when he took command of the 56th Fighter Group.
16:29He had been a combat observer in Britain, and had even spent time in Moscow teaching Soviet pilots to
16:34fly American fighters. He came to the Thunderbolt with no illusions. He called the airplane, frankly,
16:41a big disappointment. It needed almost half a mile of runway to get 50 feet into the air.
16:47His group's first fights proved him right. In April, over the Dutch coast, the 56th tangled with
16:53the Germans, scored nothing, and lost two pilots. Zemka didn't ask for a different airplane. He asked a
17:01different question. Not, how do we make this fighter good where it's weak? But, how do we make sure we
17:08never fight where it's weak? The answer became the Wolfpack's whole way of war. Squadrons stacked at
17:17different heights. A low one, a middle one, and a high reserve above them both. Height was everything.
17:24Find the enemy below you. Dive on him with all that weight and speed. Shoot. Then don't stay in turn
17:32with
17:32him. Use the speed from the dive to zoom straight back up to where he couldn't follow. On June 12th,
17:391943,
17:40near Ypres, the group finally scored. The next day, Zemka led the 61st squadron to two more.
17:48Now put the two pieces side by side. In November, a German test pilot measured, carefully and honestly,
17:56exactly where the thunderbolt was weak. And for six months already, the Americans had been building
18:01a way of fighting designed so that the thunderbolt would almost never be there. The German finding was
18:08true. It just described a fight the Americans were refusing to have. That leaves the obvious question.
18:16If the thunderbolt wasn't meant to live low, then where was it meant to live?
18:21Leiche could only answer that one way. He had to take Roche's airplane up to where Zemka's pilots actually fought.
18:29Up past 25,000 feet. Up past 30. He did. And his own account of that flight ends with a
18:38sentence
18:39no German test pilot ever expected to write about an enemy fighter. That the American airplane he was testing
18:46had probably saved his life. Somewhere above 20,000 feet, the airplane that had felt so heavy
18:52near the ground began to change. Leiche noticed it first in the climb. The needle kept winding up,
18:59and the thunderbolt kept going, with none of the struggle he expected from seven tons of fighter.
19:05Remember that warning lamp in the cockpit? The one for a turbine spinning in the exhaust?
19:10This was what it was for. Most fighters of the day, German ones included, carried a supercharger,
19:17driven by the engine itself, and the higher they climbed, the more that thin air strangled them.
19:22The thunderbolt had a second stage. Hot exhaust gas, which other airplanes simply threw away,
19:29spun a turbine in the rear fuselage and rammed thick air back into the engine.
19:34I was astonished, Lerke wrote, to note how lively the thunderbolt became at higher altitudes.
19:41Astonished. That's a German test pilot's word. Chosen in print, about an enemy fighter.
19:48Then he gave the numbers. Thanks to what he called its excellent exhaust-driven turbo supercharger,
19:54the thunderbolt climbed to 11,000 meters, about 36,000 feet, with ease. At around 29,500 feet,
20:03its top speed came out at roughly 400 miles an hour. Now set that against what he'd measured down low.
20:10A bit over 300 miles an hour near the ground. Close to 400 near 30,000 feet. The same airplane,
20:18nearly 100 miles an hour faster in the place where the American bombers actually flew.
20:24Up there, the lame and sluggish machine from the ground tests didn't exist.
20:30And it was up there, somewhere between 9 and 11,000 meters, that something went wrong.
20:36Lerke never fully knew what. His best guess was that the oxygen supply simply wasn't enough.
20:42What he did know is how it felt, and his description is chilling.
20:47Altitude sickness, he wrote, works like an intoxication. You feel so well that you don't
20:52notice yourself slowly growing drowsier. Then, nothing.
20:58In his words, he was temporarily dead to the world.
21:02Picture that airplane. A captured American fighter, high over northern Germany, with an
21:08unconscious German at the controls. Engine still running. Nobody flying it.
21:14When Lerke came to, the altimeter read about 4,000 meters, roughly 13,000 feet. The thunderbolt had
21:22come down something like 20,000 feet, with no one at the controls. The engine was throttled back and
21:28had cooled so much that it wouldn't pick up power. Carefully, he closed the cowling gills to let the
21:34engine warm, then eased the throttle forward a little at a time, until the big radial caught and ran.
21:41He found his way back to Recklen and landed. He couldn't remember the descent. He could only
21:47reason it out afterward. And here is the sentence he wrote. The strength of the thunderbolt in dive
21:53was particularly impressive, and to this I probably owe my life. Stop and think about what that means.
22:00In June, a German pilot had emptied his guns into Bob Johnson's thunderbolt,
22:05and watched it carry its pilot home with more than 200 holes in it.
22:10In April, a Focke-Wulf had tried to dive away from one and never pulled out. And now, in the
22:17winter,
22:17the German testing it had gone down the whole way, unconscious, and the airframe simply held
22:23together and gave him back his life. Same airplane. Three Germans. The only one who survived his long
22:31ride down in it was the one sitting inside. That's admission number two, and it's bigger than the
22:37first. Laerke put his conclusion plainly. The thunderbolt's strong points, he wrote, did not lie in
22:44dogfighting or at heights under five or six thousand meters. It was excellent at high altitude, in diving
22:51attacks, and at maximum boost. Read that sentence again with Hube Zemke in mind. High altitude, diving
22:59attacks, don't dogfight. Germany's own test center had just written down, almost word for word, the way
23:07wolfpack had been fighting since the spring. And Laerke went one step further. In escort work at high
23:14altitude, he wrote, the thunderbolts were always the decisive factor. He knew exactly what that meant,
23:20because the proof had already happened. On September 27th, 1943, six weeks before Roach landed at Kong,
23:30eight fighter command sent 262 thunderbolts from six fighter groups to cover American bombers
23:36attacking the port of Emden on German soil. That day, the thunderbolts flew with a new drop tank slung
23:43under the belly. A 108-gallon tank made of pressed paper, built to be thrown away. One of the six
23:51groups was the 355th. Roach's group. Pressed paper, compressed air spun by waste exhaust, and a cockpit
24:00roomy enough for a man to sit in for hours. None of it looked like a secret weapon. Together, it
24:06put
24:06American fighters over Germany, high, with fuel to spare. So by the end of 1943, the German picture
24:13was finally clear, and it was honest. Up high, the thunderbolt was the master. Down low, it was
24:22ordinary. In a dive, nothing could touch it. Which left German fighter pilots exactly one escape that
24:29still worked. Not diving. Climbing. If a thunderbolt was on your tail, pull up, hard and steep, and let
24:39that heavy machine fall behind. Zemke knew it. His pilots knew it. And over that winter, mechanics in
24:46England made two changes to the thunderbolt. One was a new propeller. The other, Lerke himself would
24:53later wave away in a single sentence, as nothing fundamentally new. German pilots in the air over
25:01Germany would not find it so easy to wave away. January 1944. Headquarters of 8th Fighter Command
25:08outside London. The 8th Air Force had a new commander, Major General Jimmy Doolittle,
25:14the man who had led the raid on Tokyo. He was visiting his fighter chief, Major General William
25:20Kepner, when he noticed a sign on the office wall. It read,
25:25The first duty of 8th Air Force fighters is to bring the bombers back alive.
25:31Doolittle asked who had put it up. Kepner said it had been there when he arrived.
25:36Doolittle told him to take it down. It was wrong. A new sign went up in its place.
25:42The first duty of 8th Air Force fighters is to destroy German fighters.
25:48Hear what changed in those few words.
25:51Until then, American escorts had been told to stay with the bombers.
25:55Weave above them, slow down to their pace, chase an attacker off, and come right back.
26:01A German pilot could dive away from a thunderbolt knowing it probably wouldn't follow him far.
26:06That was the rule. Now the rule was gone. The fighters could range out ahead of the bombers,
26:13hunt, and follow the enemy wherever he went.
26:16Doolittle later called it the most important and far-reaching military decision he made during the war.
26:22But a fighter pilot freed to hunt still needs an airplane that can catch what it hunts.
26:28And remember the one escape the Germans still had against the thunderbolt?
26:32Not diving. Climbing.
26:36That winter, the Americans went after it.
26:39The first change was easy to miss on a flight line. A new propeller with much broader blades,
26:45wide as canoe paddles. Pilots called them paddle blades. A propeller is really a wing that spins,
26:52and these wider blades could bite far more air, which mattered most in exactly the place the old
26:59thunderbolt was weakest, the climb at lower speed. Accounts differ on the exact figures,
27:05but the gain ran to hundreds of feet a minute. Thunderbolts in England were being refitted with
27:11them in the early months of 1944. The second change was water. A system that sprayed a mix of water
27:19and
27:19alcohol into the engine, cooling the charge so it could take far more boost without destroying itself.
27:25And here we have a German witness. Lerke, at Recklen, measured exactly what it did.
27:32With water injection, he wrote, the thunderbolt's power went from 2,000 horsepower to 2,300.
27:39300 extra horsepower, on demand, when a pilot needed it most.
27:44So follow the moves on the board. The Germans learned not to dive away from a thunderbolt.
27:49They learned to climb away instead. The Americans answered with a new propeller,
27:54and an extra 300 horsepower, and a new rule that said, chase him.
28:01Now come back to a man we've met. Bob Johnson, the Oklahoman whose airplane carried him home from
28:07France with more than 200 holes in it, was still flying with the 56th. And in the first months of
28:131944,
28:14something happened to his score. Between January 5th and May 8th, he was credited with 17 German aircraft.
28:2217 in four months. On May 8th, he passed Eddie Rickenbacker's first World War record and became,
28:30for a time, the top-scoring American ace in Europe. 27 victories, every one of them in a thunderbolt.
28:39Same pilot as in June. Same type of airplane, more or less. What changed was what the airplane could now
28:46do, and what the rules now let him do with it. He wasn't alone in that squadron. Flying in the
28:5361st
28:54alongside him was another Oklahoman, Joe Powers, from Tulsa. Born June 8th, 1920. He'd been a student at the
29:02University of Oklahoma when Pearl Harbor was bombed. His combat reports from that winter are pure working
29:09pilot. On one mission, near Minden in Germany, he wrote that his engine began to detonate and he
29:15could get no closer. He still claimed his Fock Wolf, and he nursed his thunderbolt home. Remember Joe
29:23Powers. In a few months, his name will turn up in the memory of one of the most famous German
29:28fighter
29:29pilots of the entire war. Not in a combat report. In that German's own account of the worst day of
29:36his career. Meanwhile, the numbers on the German side were becoming impossible. Historians of the
29:42campaign calculate that the Luftwaffe in the West wrote off about a third of its fighter strength in
29:47January 1944. In February, more than half. Doolittle summed it up later. Germany was losing pilots faster
29:56than it could replace them. Now step back and look at what Lerke's test report had really told the Luftwaffe.
30:03The Thunderbolt is a master at height, ordinary down low, and unbeatable in a dive. In other words,
30:10don't fight it high, don't try to out dive it, and if you're in trouble, climb. By the spring of
30:171944,
30:18the Americans had taken away the climb. And with Doolittle's new rule, they'd started taking away the
30:24low ground, too. Chasing German fighters down toward the deck. Toward their own airfields. The German
30:31finding hadn't been wrong. It had just become out of date. And that brings us to the most revealing
30:38sentence in Lerke's entire chapter. He wrote it after he got his hands on a second Thunderbolt,
30:44a newer one, with the water injection fitted. That airplane wasn't waiting at a quiet airfield in
30:51France. It was in Italy, near Rome, in the spring of 1944, with the American 5th Army closing in on
31:00the
31:00city. To bring it back, Lerke had to cross Italy by road, under skies that now belonged to the Allies.
31:09And the trip very nearly ended before he ever reached the cockpit. The call came at the end of May,
31:171944. An American lieutenant, flying a brand new Thunderbolt, had landed at Rome's Littorio
31:23airfield. In Lerke's words, he had probably lost his way. The Germans in Rome had already ordered fuel
31:31for the airplane, and had the wingtips and nose painted yellow, the American markings covered with
31:37German crosses. Lerke flew a Junkers 88 to Munich that same evening. At 16 minutes past 5 the next morning,
31:46he took off again, and was in Bologna by half-past 6. From there, the only way to Rome was
31:53by road.
31:54It took until midday just to find a car and a driver, borrowed from a flak unit. At lunch,
32:01a German general gave him a piece of advice. Make sure, he said, that our own flak doesn't shoot you
32:08down on the way home. Then they drove south. They avoided the coast road, the Via Aurelia,
32:16because enemy fighters were hunting along it. The mountain roads were no better because of partisans,
32:21so they took the old Via Cassia, through heavy traffic, crawling. Around midday the next day,
32:28an ammunition truck ahead of them had been hit and the road was blocked. The driver turned onto a side
32:33road, and on a dry Italian side road, a car throws up dust. Four Mustangs saw it. They came down
32:42in the
32:42dive. The driver slammed on the brakes, and both men threw themselves flat against the slope as the
32:47fighters made their run. Lerke, pressed into the dirt, shouted up at them, your shooting is terrible.
32:54It was. They hit nothing. But think about where that leaves us. The Luftwaffe's own test pilot,
33:01on a mission to collect an American fighter, lying face down in a ditch because American fighters
33:07owned the road. He reached Littorio in the afternoon. A handful of men were left.
33:13The guard told him that one narrow strip of the airfield had not yet been mined,
33:17and gave him two lanterns and a tent for the night. The Americans, everyone said, would be in the city
33:23within two days. Lerke spent his last evening in Rome with old friends and drank to the flight home.
33:29The thunderbolt itself was in fine shape. The engine, he found, ran perfectly.
33:35At ten minutes to five on the morning of June 3rd, in the half dark, he took off from that
33:40narrow,
33:41unmined lane. No escort. He'd ruled out the coast and the mountain routes and flew north alone,
33:47low, following the Via Cassia and navigating by lakes. Siena and Florence passed under him around
33:54half past five. He swung wide of Bologna and picked up the river Po and then the Adige.
34:01Now listen to how he approached Vicenza, a German airfield, in his own country's airspace.
34:08Undercarriage down. Flaps down. Firing identification flares.
34:14He called it a humble attitude. A German pilot, coming home, so afraid of being mistaken for the
34:21enemy that he flew the whole approach like a man with his hands up. He landed before half past six.
34:28Then air raid alarms kept him on the ground all day. He couldn't leave until twenty-five minutes to
34:33six that evening, tucked behind the Junkers in cloud over the Alps. Near the Tegensee, he rocked his wings,
34:40broke away, and landed at Munich. The next day, in bad weather, he reached Rechlin at eleven twenty-three.
34:49The day Lerche reached Rechlin, American troops of the Fifth Army entered Rome. Two days after that,
34:56Allied armies landed in Normandy. Now we come to the sentence.
35:01After all that, Lerche examined the new Thunderbolt and wrote his verdict.
35:06Except for the extra 300 horsepower from water injection, he wrote,
35:11this new P47D variant did not feature any fundamental innovations.
35:17Was he wrong? Technically, no. It was still the same big airframe, the same engine, the same turbo.
35:25A test pilot looks for new ideas. And there weren't any.
35:29But look at what the man had just lived through to write that sentence.
35:33He'd had to fly into Italy at dawn and cross it by car. He'd been dived on by four Mustangs
35:40on a back
35:40road. He'd taken off before sunrise from a strip between minefields, flown low and alone so nothing
35:47would see him, and landed at his own airfield with his hands up. Then he'd sat out a whole day
35:54of air
35:55air raid alarms before he dared cross the Alps. The innovation was not in the airplane. It was all
36:01around the airplane. It was the sky. And Lerche, honest man that he was, put that in his chapter too.
36:10The Thunderbolts' strengths, he wrote, made it ideal as an escort fighter. And numbers helped.
36:17Then the line we've already heard. The Thunderbolts were always the decisive factor as escort fighters
36:24for bomber attacks at high altitudes. That's admission number three, and it's the hardest
36:30one for a German to make. The problem was never one airplane. It was how many of them there were,
36:36how far they could reach, and what the Americans were now free to do with them.
36:41But Lerche was a test pilot. He flew the Thunderbolt over an empty German sky. He never had to face
36:48it
36:48in a fight. Three weeks before his dawn takeoff from Rome, another German had faced it. One of the
36:56highest-scoring fighter pilots in history, a man who would later fly the Thunderbolt himself. On May 12,
37:031944, he led his group down into a formation of P-47s. When he came home from that fight,
37:11he was missing his left thumb. And the name of the American he believed had done it would stay with
37:17him for the rest of his life. May 12, 1944. Over central Germany, more than 800 American bombers were
37:25heading for the synthetic oil plants that kept the Luftwaffe in the air. Major Gunther Rahl had been
37:31commanding the second Kruppe of Jagdgeschwader 11 for only a few weeks. He'd come from the Eastern
37:37Front with more than 270 victories. Few men alive knew more about killing an enemy fighter.
37:45His plan was standard German home defense. The Fockewulfs would go for the bombers. Rahl's Messerschmitts
37:52would stay high and tie up the escorts. He brought his formation down from above 30,000 feet and ran
37:59straight into Thunderbolts. They belonged to the 56th Fighter Group, Hubzemke's Wolfpack.
38:07Rahl did what he did best. He shot down two of them. Then more Thunderbolts arrived. One of them got
38:15behind his Messerschmitt and fired. .50 caliber rounds tore into the engine, the cooler, the cockpit,
38:21and his left hand. Rahl went over the side and came down by parachute into a field. His left thumb
38:28was
38:28gone. Infection set in and it kept him out of a cockpit for months. Years later, he put it in
38:35one
38:35plain sentence. A P-47 Thunderbolt shot my left thumb off. Twelve fighters and 46 bombers didn't come home
38:44to England that day. But the oil plants burned. Albert Speer, Hitler's armaments minister, later
38:52said that on that day, the fate of Germany's technical war was decided. And here is what
38:58happened next to Rahl, because it closes the circle of this story. While his hand healed, he was put in
39:04charge of the Luftwaffe's school for fighter leaders. And at that school, Germany's frontline fighter
39:10commanders got what Lerke had at Recklen. Captured American airplanes. Lightnings. Mustangs. Thunderbolts.
39:20Rahl said he was eager to learn and evaluate them. He and his pilots flew them for about 300 hours.
39:27So now, we finally have the thing the title promised. Not a test pilot over an empty sky. A frontline
39:35ace,
39:35who had shot Thunderbolts down and been shot down by one, climbing into the cockpit of the airplane
39:41that had taken his thumb. What did he admit? First, the respect.
39:48The P-47, which, as you know, shot me down, we knew right away, he said. He remembered its
39:55tremendous diving speed and set it against his own Messerschmitt. He also said the P-47's structure
40:02was much stronger. Remember Johnson's 200 holes. Remember Lerke coming down 20,000 feet unconscious.
40:11Rahl was saying the same thing, as a man who had tried to break one.
40:15But then he said something that goes deeper, and it takes us right back to the first minute of this
40:20story. To Lerke, standing on a wing at Kong, surprised by how much room there was in the cockpit.
40:28The cockpits of all of these enemy aircraft, Rahl said, were much more comfortable. And then he
40:35explained why that mattered. You could not fly the BF-109 for seven hours. The cockpit was too tight,
40:41too narrow. Talking about the American escorts, he put the whole war into one line. They flew for seven
40:49hours. And we flew for one hour and 20 minutes. Now let's put every admission side by side. Because
40:57together, they answer the question. Lerke admitted that low down, the Thunderbolt was lame and sluggish.
41:04That was the weakness Germany hoped for. Lerke admitted that high up, it was lively, it climbed with
41:11ease, and in a dive, nothing could touch it. And that it was the decisive factor as a bomber escort.
41:18Lerke, flying out of Rome at dawn with his hands up, admitted, without meaning to, that the airplane
41:24itself held no secrets. No fundamental innovations. What was different was everything around it.
41:31And Rahl, sitting in it after it had cost him his thumb, admitted the rest. It was stronger. It was
41:38faster downhill. And it was built for a man to sit in for seven hours. So here is what German
41:44pilots
41:45discovered when they finally flew the Thunderbolt. They were looking for its weakness, and they found
41:51one. It was real. But it only mattered in a fight the Germans got to choose. A fight down low,
41:58close to home, short, on German terms. And the American air war had been built, piece by piece,
42:06so the Germans wouldn't get to choose. Zemke chose the altitude. The paper drop tank
42:14chose the distance. The roomy cockpit and the turbo let a young man from Oklahoma sit at 30,000 feet
42:21over Germany for hours and still be sharp when the fight came. The paddle blades and the water
42:28took away the climb. Doolittle's sign took away the rest. Chase them. Down to the ground if you have to.
42:37The weakness was in the airplane. The answer was in the men and the system that flew it.
42:45That's why the most honest German verdicts read the way they do. Not, it was a better fighter than ours,
42:51but they flew for seven hours and we flew for one hour and 20 minutes. A German ace measuring the
42:59war
42:59in the size of a cockpit. As for the American who fired the burst on May 12th, Rahl said he
43:06knew
43:07exactly who it was. After the war, he became close friends with Hub Zemke, met the men of the Wolfpack,
43:13and told an interviewer, it was Joseph Powers. Joe Powers, the Tulsa kid from the 61st Squadron,
43:22whose engine had been detonating over Minden. Rahl would live to be 90. He would lead the West
43:29German Air Force and sit beside his old enemies at NATO. Joe Powers would not get that long. And to
43:36see
43:36why, we have to follow him and Bob Johnson and William Roach past the end of this war and into
43:44the next one. William Roach never flew in combat again. The young lieutenant who had followed a
43:50vehicle to a parking spot at Cannes spent the rest of the war in Stalag Luft 1 on the Baltic
43:55coast.
43:57On June 12th, 1945, the army records him as,
44:01returned to military control. 19 months after his landing. Long enough to hear, through the prison
44:09camp grapevine, what the 8th Air Force had done to the Luftwaffe in the meantime. He never knew a
44:15German test pilot had written about his airplane. That the cockpit had baffled him. That its roominess
44:21had surprised him. That in a dive, it had probably saved his life. Roach's mistake in the fog over
44:29Normandy had given Germany the best look it would ever get at the Thunderbolt. And everything Germany
44:35learned from that look, in the end, came back to the same place. It wasn't enough. At least one
44:43captured Thunderbolt in German markings was still around at the very end. According to the photographic
44:48record, one coded T9 plus LK was retaken by American forces at Göttingen in May 1945. The airplane that had
45:00been studied, flown, and admired by the men trying to beat it was back in American hands. Bob Johnson
45:08went home to Oklahoma with 27 victories. And then he did something almost poetic. He went to work for
45:15Republic Aviation, the company that built the Thunderbolt, as its chief test pilot. The man
45:22whose P-47 had carried him home from France with more than 200 holes in it, spent the next years
45:28testing
45:29the airplanes that came after it. He stayed in the Air Force Reserve, retired as a lieutenant colonel,
45:35and wrote his story in a book he simply called Thunderbolt. The airport terminal in his hometown of
45:43Lawton carries his name. He died on December 27, 1998, in Tulsa. He was 78. Gunter Rahl recovered. He led
45:54the
45:54West German Air Force in the 1970s and sat beside his old enemies at NATO. In 1977 he met American
46:02fighter
46:02pilots and learned for certain that the Thunderbolts that had beaten him on May 12 belonged to Zemke's
46:10Wolfpack. He became Zemke's friend. In May 1996 he spoke at the Smithsonian's National Air and Space Museum.
46:20Today the museum holds his flying glove. You can still see the damage the bullets did. He died in 2009.
46:30The flying glove of a German ace. In a museum in Washington, holed by an American .50 caliber round.
46:40In its own way, that's the last German admission in this story.
46:46And Joe Powers. He stayed in uniform. He finished the Second World War with 14 and a half victories, half
46:54a kill
46:55short of triple ace, with a silver star and five distinguished flying crosses. When the Korean War
47:03came, he went again with the 67th Fighter Bomber Squadron of the 18th Fighter Bomber Group.
47:10On January 18, 1951, Captain Joseph H. Powers was shot down over Korea. His remains were never recovered.
47:19He was 30. Think about the shape of those two lives. The German, who lost his thumb to Joe Powers,
47:27lived 91 and told the world by name who had beaten him. The American from Tulsa never got to hear
47:35him
47:35say it. So let's go back where we started. November 10, 1943. Caen. A German test pilot standing on the
47:46wing of William Roach's fighter, looking into a cockpit bigger than anything he'd ever flown.
47:52Everyone at Recklin, he wrote, wanted to know whether this fighter was really as legendary as reported.
47:58The Germans who flew it gave an honest answer. Low and slow, it was ordinary. High, fast, and in a
48:07dive,
48:07it was everything they feared. And the Americans made sure it was almost always high, fast, and diving.
48:15The Thunderbolt didn't win because the Germans couldn't find its weakness. It won because the
48:21Americans who flew it never let them use it. The legend was never just the airplane. It was a farm
48:27and small-town generation of American pilots, from Lawton and Tulsa and a thousand towns like them,
48:34who climbed into that roomy cockpit for seven hours at a time, flew it where it was strongest,
48:39and kept coming back. Some of them, like Joe Powers, came back right up until the day they didn't.
48:47Thank you for watching this one all the way to the end. If this story of the American airman who
48:52flew the Thunderbolt meant something to you, please give the video a like. It genuinely helps the story
48:57reach people who'd never otherwise hear names like Bob Johnson and Joe Powers. Subscribe, and turn on the
49:04bell so you don't miss the next one. And tell us in the comments where you're watching from. If your
49:09father,
49:10grandfather, or uncle served in the Second World War, we'd be honored if you'd share his name and the
49:16unit he served with. Every name you write down keeps one more of them from being forgotten.

Recommended