- 5 hours ago
For 40 years, Georg Gärtner lived under a borrowed name after escaping a German POW camp in New Mexico. Then, with no FBI agent closing in, he walked into a California federal office and revealed who he really was.
This World War II history story follows Gärtner from the desert freight train that carried him to freedom to a life of work, marriage, and secrecy in America. The camp clerk had feared returning to his lost homeland, but his escape came at a cost: a false identity, a wife kept in the dark, and no way to live openly. When the truth finally surfaced, he chose to surrender—not to be caught, but to claim a lawful place in the country he had made his home. A remarkable military history documentary about escape, identity, and belonging.
This World War II history story follows Gärtner from the desert freight train that carried him to freedom to a life of work, marriage, and secrecy in America. The camp clerk had feared returning to his lost homeland, but his escape came at a cost: a false identity, a wife kept in the dark, and no way to live openly. When the truth finally surfaced, he chose to surrender—not to be caught, but to claim a lawful place in the country he had made his home. A remarkable military history documentary about escape, identity, and belonging.
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00September 11, 1985. San Pedro, California. The working harbor at the southern edge of Los Angeles.
00:07A man of 64 walks into the offices of the United States Immigration and Naturalization Service.
00:14He is tall, close to 6 feet, with the build of someone who has made his living on ski slopes
00:20and tennis courts.
00:22Two attorneys, one from Hawaii and one from Los Angeles, have arranged this visit in advance.
00:27He is not in handcuffs. No one has brought him here. And at this moment, no one in the United
00:34States government is looking for him.
00:36For 40 years, he has signed his name Dennis Wiles. Today, he gives the officers another one.
00:43Georg Gertner. Born December 18, 1920, in Schweidnitz, Silesia. Soldier of the German Afrika Korps. Prisoner of war of the
00:54United States Army.
00:56Escaped from a camp near Deming, New Mexico, in September 1945.
01:01Keep one detail in your pocket, because it comes back at the very end.
01:05San Pedro is where his American life began.
01:0940 years earlier, almost to the week, a Southern Pacific freight train carried a runaway German prisoner out of the
01:15New Mexico desert, and he ended up in this same harbor town.
01:19Now he has come back to the place where he first walked free in America. To hand that freedom back.
01:27And here is what makes it strange. The FBI had canceled his fugitive warrant nine years earlier, in 1976.
01:35The search itself had been marked inactive in 1963. No agent was closing in. No neighbor had matched his face
01:44to an old poster.
01:46By any practical measure, Georg Gertner had won. And on a Wednesday in September, he walked in and surrendered anyway.
01:57Why? That is the question this entire story turns on. And the answer is not the one most people would
02:04guess.
02:05Before we go back to that desert, please like this video and subscribe.
02:10It helps us keep telling these stories, of the American soldiers who guarded those camps, and the American agents who
02:16hunted the men who got out.
02:18To feel the weight of that surrender, you need one number first. Here it is.
02:23During the war, the United States held roughly 400,000 German prisoners, in camps spread across 46 of the 48
02:32states.
02:33Of all those men, 2,222 escaped. Think about that. Fewer than one in a hundred even tried.
02:44And most of the ones who did were back behind the wire within a day.
02:48They were caught by farmers who noticed a stranger crossing a field.
02:52By sheriffs, who noticed an accent. By railroad men and gas station attendants.
02:59Above all, they were caught by the sheer size of an American landscape that turned out to be a very
03:05hard place for a foreign soldier to disappear into.
03:08When 25 German prisoners tunneled out of Camp Papago Park in Arizona two days before Christmas 1944,
03:15the biggest breakout on American soil during the war,
03:18every one of them was back in custody within weeks.
03:23The system worked.
03:24The last German prisoners sailed home from New York in the summer of 1946.
03:30A year later, Time magazine reported that out of nearly half a million enemy prisoners held in America,
03:36just 24 German and Italian escapees were still at large.
03:42Then the FBI went to work on that short list.
03:45And one by one, the names came off it.
03:49Remember that phrase, one by one.
03:53Because each of those names is a chapter of this story.
03:57By 1963, a single file was still open.
04:02His.
04:04So the question in front of us has two halves, and they are tied together.
04:08First, how does a German soldier with an accent, no papers, and his face on an FBI poster vanish into
04:15America for four decades when almost nobody else could manage four days?
04:21And second, having pulled off the one escape the American system never closed, why did he walk back in and
04:28close it himself?
04:30Here is a first clue, and it is not what you would expect.
04:34Georg Gertner did not hide in a cellar.
04:37He did not live in the woods.
04:39He taught skiing in the Sierra Nevada.
04:42He taught tennis in California.
04:45He married an American woman and adopted her two children.
04:49And by his own account, in 1952, his photograph appeared in Life magazine, one of the most widely read publications
04:58in the country, while his face was still on FBI wanted posters.
05:03Nobody made the connection.
05:05To understand how that was possible, we have to go back to where the man in that photograph was made.
05:11Not in Germany.
05:12In an American prisoner of war camp in the New Mexico desert, where he was a 24-year-old clerk.
05:20In the camp's administration building, Gartner typed the paperwork.
05:24He spoke English.
05:25He translated for the other prisoners.
05:28And that job put into his hands something most prisoners rarely saw up close, American newspapers.
05:36By the late summer of 1945, the war was over in Europe and in the Pacific.
05:42Every man in that camp knew he was going home.
05:45For most of them, it was the best news of their lives.
05:49For the clerk, it was the worst.
05:53He had read those newspapers more carefully than anyone else in the camp.
05:57And somewhere in their columns that summer was a decision made by three men at a conference table in a
06:05place most of the prisoners had never heard of.
06:08That decision had just taken his hometown out of Germany.
06:13What those three men decided, and what it meant for a prisoner from Schweidnitz, is where this story really begins.
06:20May 9th, 1943.
06:23Northern Tunisia, near Bizerte.
06:26At 11 o'clock that morning, a German general named Fritz Krauss and five other generals surrendered to the United
06:32States Army's Second Corps.
06:35Behind them, in that one sector alone, came roughly 25,000 men.
06:41Four days later, the entire Axis army in North Africa was finished.
06:46Something like a quarter of a million German and Italian soldiers laid down their arms.
06:52Ernie Pyle was there, watching them come in.
06:55Many of the prisoners seemed almost cheerful.
06:58One of them, talking to a G.I. who had grown up in Brooklyn, put it bluntly.
07:03You Americans are saps.
07:05You're still in the war, and I'm out of it.
07:08Hold on to that line, because that German was more right than he knew.
07:12For tens of thousands of these men, captivity would not mean a cage in the desert.
07:18It would mean America.
07:20Somewhere in that flood of prisoners, taken near Tunis by British troops, was a 22-year-old from Silesia named
07:27Georg Gertner.
07:28As a boy, he had wanted to be an architect, until diphtheria, at 15, ended his schooling.
07:34He had reached Africa only months earlier.
07:37Now his war was over.
07:39Britain could not hold that many men.
07:41It was short of food, guards, and space.
07:45So it asked the United States to take a large share of them.
07:48The Americans said yes.
07:51Here is a fact most people today don't know, and it says a great deal about the American side of
07:56this war.
07:57The prisoners who arrived in American camps ate the same rations as American soldiers.
08:03That was not an accident.
08:05The Geneva Convention required it, and the United States followed it to the letter.
08:11An enlisted prisoner who worked earned at least 80 cents a day, roughly what an American private was paid.
08:17In script, he could spend at the camp canteen.
08:21Some camps showed films several nights a week.
08:24Prisoners taught each other English, mathematics, and business.
08:29Why would an army at war treat its enemies that way?
08:32Because the United States Army was thinking about its own men.
08:36By the last months of the war, more than 90,000 Americans were sitting in German prison camps.
08:41Every report of fair treatment in Texas or New Mexico was an argument for fair treatment on the other side.
08:49The rules were a shield for the GIs behind German wire.
08:54Now notice an irony, because it will matter later.
08:58Stalag Luft III, where thousands of captured American airmen were held, stood at Sagan, in Silesia,
09:04the province where Georg Gertner was born.
09:08The historian Arnold Kramer, who later spent years interviewing these men, summed it up in one sentence.
09:15I've yet to meet a German prisoner who doesn't tell me that it was the time of their lives.
09:21So remember what the American camp actually was.
09:25It was not only a fence.
09:27It was a place where an enemy soldier ate well, earned wages, watched Hollywood movies,
09:32and learned to speak his captor's language.
09:35For most prisoners, it was a pleasant interlude.
09:38For one prisoner in New Mexico, it was training he did not yet know he needed.
09:43At Deming, Gartner worked in the administration building as a clerk and typist.
09:48He translated for the other men.
09:51He read the American papers.
09:52And in the summer of 1945, those papers carried news from a town outside Berlin, called Potsdam.
10:00There, between July 17th and August 2nd, Harry Truman, Joseph Stalin, and the British Prime Minister,
10:08Churchill at the start, Clement Attlee by the end, redrew the map of Central Europe.
10:14German territory east of the Oder and Niza rivers was placed under Polish administration.
10:20That took in almost all of Silesia.
10:23Its German population was to be moved out.
10:26Schweidnitz was becoming Schwednitz.
10:29Think about what that meant for a man reading it in a camp office in New Mexico.
10:34His country had lost the war.
10:36That he could accept.
10:38But the town where he was born, the streets his parents walked, no longer belonged to Germany.
10:46Soviet troops held the region.
10:48In that September, after Japan's surrender, the prisoners learned what came next.
10:54They were all going to be shipped back to Europe.
10:56And from there, toward their home regions.
11:01Even that was not the whole story.
11:03Many Germans leaving American camps were never sent straight home.
11:07They were routed to Britain and France, and worked there for up to three more years.
11:13For men from the West, the news was bearable.
11:16For a man from Silesia, it meant being sent toward an occupation he feared far more than anything the Americans
11:25had ever done to him.
11:27Decades later, in his book, he described that moment in four words.
11:33My fate was sealed.
11:36Here is where the story turns.
11:39The safest place Georg Gärtner had been since the war began was an American prison camp.
11:44And it was about to send him away.
11:47So he started watching the railroad.
11:50Southern Pacific freight trains ran past within a few miles of the camp.
11:55He studied them.
11:57He worked out the timetable.
11:59When they came through and where they slowed, he measured the desert between the wire and the tracks.
12:05And he picked a night when every other man in the camp would be looking in the same direction.
12:11At a Hollywood Western on the mess hall screen.
12:15But the most important decision he made had nothing to do with the fences or the train.
12:21It was a rule he set for himself before he ever moved.
12:25And that single rule is why, when the army came looking for answers, not one prisoner in Deming could tell
12:33them anything at all.
12:34The rule was simple.
12:36Tell no one.
12:37Not a bunkmate.
12:38Not a comrade from the Afrika Korps.
12:41Not the men he translated for every day.
12:43Escape plans in prison camps all over the world ran on shared secrets.
12:48Maps passed hand to hand.
12:50Lookouts.
12:51Forged papers.
12:53Gärtner wanted none of it.
12:54A secret shared with one man could be pulled out of that one man.
12:58A secret kept by nobody could not be taken from anybody.
13:03On the night of September 21, 1945, some accounts say the 22nd, the prisoners at Deming crowded into the mess
13:11hall for a movie.
13:12It was an American western.
13:14The men jeered and shouted at the screen the way soldiers do.
13:18And while the whole camp was watching cowboys, the camp clerk slipped out.
13:23He knew where the searchlights left gaps.
13:26He crawled under two gates.
13:28Then he ran into the desert, toward railroad tracks several miles away, and waited for a southern Pacific freight he
13:35already knew was coming.
13:36He pulled himself into an open car.
13:39By most accounts, it carried him west for three days, all the way to California.
13:44Behind him, the camp came up one man short.
13:48When the army questioned the other prisoners, it ran into the wall he had built.
13:53Nobody had helped.
13:54Nobody had known.
13:56There was no one to break.
13:59He had made a bet like this once before.
14:02In officer training at Heidelberg, candidates were told to cross the town without being caught by their instructors.
14:08The others tried rooftops, sewers, disguises.
14:13Gartner got on a streetcar and rode through the middle of town.
14:17Hiding, he had learned, works best when you stop looking like a man who is hiding.
14:22The freight train brought him to the harbor town of San Pedro.
14:26Yes, the same town where, forty years later, he would walk into the immigration office.
14:32There he became Peter Peterson, a Norwegian immigrant.
14:36A Scandinavian story could explain an accent.
14:39He washed dishes.
14:41He cooked.
14:42He took day labor.
14:43Then he moved north into the farm country around Fresno and became a migrant worker, picking fruit beside American families
14:50who had come west with almost nothing.
14:53One of those men, a migrant father he lived and traveled with for a time, was named Dennis Wiles.
15:00Gartner borrowed the name.
15:01He would keep it for forty years.
15:04And then came the step that should have stopped him cold.
15:08To work steadily in America, a man needed a social security number.
15:13Gartner got one.
15:14As Dennis F. Wiles.
15:17He invented a past to go with it.
15:19An orphan, raised in institutions.
15:22No family to call.
15:24Later, he would say he had been born in Albany, New York and gone to school in Connecticut.
15:30How hard was that card to get?
15:32Here we have a witness.
15:34Another German escapee, Reinhold Pabel, walked away from a camp in Illinois that same year.
15:40He later described what came next.
15:43Only ten days after my escape from prisoner of war camp, I walked into a social security administration office in
15:49Chicago.
15:50And then?
15:51Once I obtained my social security number, I could go to work anywhere in the United States.
15:57Pabel added one more sentence, and I want you to sit with it for a moment.
16:01If I had escaped from a Russian prisoner of war camp, I'm sure I would have been recaptured within a
16:06few days.
16:07That is the first layer of how Georg Gartner vanished.
16:11Not genius.
16:12Not luck.
16:14America in 1945 did not ask a working man to prove where he came from.
16:19There was no national identity card, no internal passport, no police register of residence.
16:25A country built by people who had arrived from somewhere else did not interrogate newcomers about their past.
16:31It asked whether they would work.
16:33But do not mistake that for a country that wasn't looking.
16:37In 1947, the FBI printed a wanted poster with his photograph.
16:42It described him exactly.
16:44Almost six feet tall.
16:46171 pounds.
16:48Eyes blue.
16:49Hair brown.
16:51Nationality.
16:52German.
16:53Escaped prisoners of war were federal business.
16:55And the Bureau worked those files with the same method it used on bank robbers and kidnappers.
17:01And the method was working.
17:03That same year, Time reported the number of enemy escapees still at large across the entire country.
17:1024.
17:11Out of nearly half a million prisoners, 24 men.
17:16And that number was going to keep shrinking.
17:19So here is the contest that now begins.
17:22And it will run for the next 16 years.
17:25On one side, a man with a borrowed name, a social security card, and a story about an orphanage.
17:33On the other, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, with his photograph, his description, and a very long memory.
17:44For a while, the borrowed name held.
17:47Then, in 1953, the contest changed.
17:50One of the most widely read magazines in America printed the FBI's problem for the whole country to see.
17:57The escaped German prisoners the Bureau had never found.
18:01There were five names on that list.
18:03One of them was Georg Gertner's.
18:06And within months of that article, the men on it started coming off it, one by one.
18:11January 13, 1952.
18:14The Sierra Nevada, near Yuba Pass, 17 miles west of Donner Pass.
18:19The westbound streamliner, City of San Francisco, is fighting its way through a blizzard when the mountain stops it cold.
18:26Winds of 100 miles an hour pile the snow into drifts.
18:30Within hours, the train is buried under 12 feet of it.
18:33On board are 196 passengers and 30 crew.
18:37The rotary plows the railroad sends to dig them out freeze to the tracks near Emigrant Gap.
18:43What happened next is one of the great American rescue stories of the century, and most people have never heard
18:49it.
18:50Hundreds of men turned out.
18:52Railroad crews, highway workers, volunteers from the mountain towns.
18:56They fought to clear US Route 40, which ran close to the stranded train.
19:01For more than three days, the passengers waited in the cold while the snow kept falling.
19:06Then the rescuers broke through, and the people aboard were let out and carried down the highway to Nyack Lodge.
19:13One of the volunteers in that rescue was a ski instructor from Norden, Dennis Wiles.
19:19By his own account, a ski group was organized to help reach the train.
19:23And afterward, Life Magazine photographed the men who had done it.
19:27I want you to picture that.
19:30An escaped German prisoner of war, wanted by the FBI, standing in the snow with a crew of American volunteers.
19:38His picture taken for one of the biggest magazines in the country.
19:42And nobody, not the photographer, not the editors, not a single reader,
19:48saw anything but another American who had come to help.
19:53That is the second layer of how he disappeared.
19:56And it goes deeper than the first.
19:58A social security card got him in the door.
20:01But what kept him hidden was something else.
20:04He did not stand apart from American life.
20:07He threw himself into it.
20:09The more he worked, volunteered, taught, and belonged,
20:13the less anyone thought to ask who he was.
20:16In a country like this one, the safest place for a fugitive was right in the middle of the crowd.
20:21But a crowd can also look back.
20:25In 1953, Collier's Magazine ran a spread on the German prisoners of war the FBI had never found.
20:32It named five men.
20:34Harry Gerth, Werner Paul Lewick, Kurt Richard Westphal, Kurt Rossmeisel, and Georg Gertner.
20:44Millions of Americans turned those pages.
20:46And now, every one of those readers was, in a small way, working for the Bureau.
20:53Watch how fast it worked.
20:55Harry Gerth was a former German paratrooper.
20:59In America, he had become Henry Colmar, and he was engaged to be married.
21:04His future mother-in-law opened that issue of Collier's and recognized the face of the man about to marry
21:09her daughter.
21:10At her urging, he surrendered that same year.
21:14One magazine, one American reader, and a name came off the list.
21:19That same year, two FBI agents walked into a used bookstore on Chicago's north side.
21:25The owner was known as Phil Brick.
21:28He had washed dishes after the war, saved his money, and built a successful business.
21:34He was married, with a child and another on the way.
21:38The agents asked him one question.
21:41Was he Reinhold Pable?
21:44He could not deny it.
21:46He was jailed and charged with entering the country illegally.
21:50And here is where the American side of this story does something remarkable.
21:55Pable's case drew national headlines.
21:58And one of the men who stood up for him was an American who had known him as a prisoner
22:02during the war in Italy.
22:04Paul Lindsay, by then a lawyer.
22:08The argument made on Pable's behalf was simple, and I want you to remember it,
22:13because it comes back almost word for word in 1985.
22:17Pable had not sneaked into the United States.
22:20The United States Army had brought him here, as a prisoner, against his will.
22:26The government did not simply wave him through, but it did not throw him away either.
22:32The compromise was that Pable would spend a waiting period of about six months in Germany,
22:36and could then come back to America legally.
22:39He did.
22:41The system that caught him also gave him a lawful way back in.
22:45Think about how that looked to anyone still in hiding.
22:49Being caught did not end in a firing squad or a Soviet camp.
22:53It ended in a courtroom, with Americans arguing on your side.
22:59And yet the men still on the list did not come forward.
23:03In 1954, another name came off.
23:06Werner Paul Leuch, who had escaped from the camp at Las Cruces, just down the road from Deming,
23:12was found living in Mexico.
23:14Now count what is left.
23:16In 1947, time had counted 24 escapees at large.
23:22By the time the last German prisoners went home,
23:24the Bureau's list of German fugitives had been cut to about a dozen.
23:29Colliers had printed five.
23:32Girth had surrendered.
23:34Pable had been arrested.
23:36Luke had been found.
23:38The circle was closing.
23:39One by one.
23:41Exactly the way it had closed on almost every escapee since 1943.
23:47Only two men from that magazine spread were still unaccounted for by the late 1950s.
23:52One was a ski instructor in the Sierra Nevada who had once been photographed for life.
23:57The other was a former Africa Corps lieutenant named Kurt Rossmeisel, living quietly in Chicago under the name Frank Ellis.
24:06In May of 1959, after 14 years of freedom, Kurt Rossmeisel walked into an FBI office in Cincinnati and turned
24:15himself in.
24:16Nobody had dragged him there.
24:18So the question at the heart of this story was asked once before, 26 years before Georg Gertner's own surrender.
24:26Why would a man who had beaten the system for 14 years give himself up?
24:33Rossmeisel's answer is the first real clue to Gertner's.
24:36Kurt Rossmeisel did not slip quietly back into custody.
24:40That same year, 1959, he told his whole story in a six-part newspaper series in the Toledo Blade.
24:47The escape, the train to Chicago, the routine of a man named Frank Ellis, and the day it ended.
24:54One of those installments carried a headline that says more than a whole chapter could.
24:59Illness strikes, luck runs out for escapee.
25:04Stop on that for a moment.
25:06Because it is the first real clue to Georg Gertner's surrender.
25:11Rossmeisel was not run down by agents.
25:13He was not betrayed by a neighbor.
25:16What broke his hiding was something no FBI file could predict.
25:20His own body.
25:23A borrowed name can hold a job.
25:25It can rent a room, open a bank account, get a man through a thousand ordinary days.
25:31But a false life is built for ordinary days.
25:35When something big happens, sickness, marriage, old age, the paperwork reaches back into the past.
25:42And for a man like Rossmeisel, there was no past to reach.
25:48Remember that idea.
25:49A false identity is safest when nothing happens.
25:53It is most dangerous at the turning points of a life.
25:57With Rossmeisel's surrender, the list was down to one.
26:01Of the dozen German fugitives still at large after the last prisoners went home, only Georg Gertner was left.
26:07And four years later, in 1963, the FBI changed the status of his case.
26:14The search for him was now inactive.
26:18The army ended its own search the same year.
26:20Notice the word, though.
26:23Inactive.
26:24Not closed.
26:26The poster had not been withdrawn.
26:28The warrant was still valid.
26:31Somewhere in a federal building, there was a file with his photograph in it, waiting for one tip, one fingerprint,
26:39one careless sentence.
26:42And that is the precise moment Dennis Wiles chose to build a family.
26:47He was living at Norden, near the top of Donner Summit, teaching skiing at resorts like Sugar Bowl.
26:53At a YMCA dance there, he met an American woman named Jean Clark.
26:58She was a social worker with two children from an earlier marriage.
27:02In 1964, they were married.
27:04He was 43.
27:06She was 39.
27:07He adopted her children.
27:10Now think about what Jean Wiles knew on her wedding day.
27:13She knew a tall, athletic, charming man who skied beautifully and spoke with a faint European accent.
27:20She knew he had grown up an orphan, with no family to invite, no relatives to visit, no box of
27:26old photographs in a closet.
27:29A man without a past is not that unusual in a country full of people who came from somewhere else.
27:35A social worker, of all people, had met plenty of them.
27:39What she did not know was that her husband was the last escaped German prisoner of war in the United
27:45States.
27:46For years, the marriage carried the secret without anyone noticing its weight.
27:51They moved around California.
27:53He sold pre-hung doors.
27:56He worked as a construction estimator.
27:58He taught tennis in the East Bay.
28:01Later, the couple ran a tennis club and pro shop at the Aptos Country Club near Santa Cruz.
28:06Around the middle of the 1970s, they moved to Hawaii, where Jean worked for the state in social services,
28:12and where her husband, an escaped soldier of the Africa Corps, worked as a construction estimator on military building projects
28:20for the United States.
28:22Pause on that one, because it is almost too strange to believe.
28:26The American military that had once held him prisoner was now, without knowing it, paying for his estimates.
28:33But the secret had a price, and it was paid in small ways.
28:38He could not get a passport.
28:40Applying would mean proving a birth in Albany, New York.
28:43That had never happened.
28:45So when Jean traveled abroad, she traveled without him.
28:48He turned down jobs that would have meant a background check.
28:52Every promotion, every government form, every official question had to be measured against the risk of a single honest answer.
29:01Over the years, the two of them increasingly lived apart.
29:05And on the other side of the world, the story had another family in it.
29:09Gartner's parents had escaped from Silesia to West Germany, just as he had feared they would have to.
29:15They were still alive in the 1960s.
29:18On their kitchen table, they kept a photograph of their son, the one who had never come home from America.
29:25Here, then, is the full shape of what this man had won.
29:29He was free.
29:30He was married.
29:32He had a home, a trade, and a place in an American community.
29:37But he could not leave the country.
29:39He could not take the jobs he wanted.
29:41He could not tell his own wife his real name.
29:44And he could not tell his own mother he was alive.
29:48In 1976, the FBI took the last formal step.
29:52It canceled his fugitive warrant.
29:56There was no announcement.
29:57No headline.
29:59And no way for Dennis Wiles to know that the thing he had feared for 30 years was over.
30:05So he kept hiding.
30:07From a hunt that no longer existed.
30:10And then, in the early 1980s, Kurt Rossmeisel's lesson arrived at his own front door.
30:17It came at one of those turning points of a life.
30:20Not sickness.
30:21Retirement.
30:23Jean began gathering the documents a couple needs to retire.
30:26And among the first things she went looking for was her husband's birth record from Albany, New York.
30:32What she found in Albany, and what she did next, is the moment this whole 40-year story had been
30:38waiting for.
30:39The answer from Albany was nothing.
30:42No birth record for a Dennis Wiles who matched her husband.
30:46Jean tried the school in Connecticut he had always mentioned.
30:49Nothing there, either.
30:51As a social worker, she had spent years helping other people untangle their records.
30:56She knew what an ordinary paper trail looked like.
30:58The birth certificate, the school file, the old address that leads to an older one.
31:04Her husband's trail did not fade out somewhere in the past.
31:08It simply started, fully grown, in the late 1940s.
31:13So she asked him.
31:14And he deflected, the way he had been deflecting for 20 years.
31:19Mix-ups.
31:20Lost files.
31:21An orphan's childhood with gaps in it.
31:24This time, it did not work.
31:27Picture the scene, because it is the real climax of the hunt for Georg Gartner.
31:32And no federal agent was anywhere near it.
31:37Jean Wiles packed her bags.
31:38She called a cab.
31:40With the taxi waiting, she turned to the man she had been married to for two decades,
31:44and asked him the question the FBI had never been able to put to his face.
31:50Was he a criminal?
31:52Think about everything that hung on his answer.
31:55For almost 40 years, he had held the line.
31:59He had told no one in the camp at Deming.
32:02He had told no one on the freight train, in the kitchens of San Pedro, in the orchards around Fresno,
32:08on the ski slopes, on the tennis courts.
32:11He had never told the men he worked beside, or the children he raised.
32:16The rule he set himself in 1945, tell no one, had beaten the United States Army and the Federal Bureau
32:25of Investigation.
32:27And now the cab was in the driveway.
32:30He told her.
32:31The man she knew as Dennis Wiles was Georg Gartner.
32:37He had been born in Silesia.
32:39He had served in the Africa Corps.
32:42He had been a prisoner of war in New Mexico.
32:44And in September 1945, he had crawled under the fence and jumped a freight train.
32:50And everything she knew about him since then, had been built on top of that night.
32:55Most accounts date this confrontation to 1984.
32:59And here is what makes Jean Wiles one of the central figures of this story.
33:04She did not get into the cab.
33:06Decades later, she was asked the question everyone asks.
33:11How could you have lived with him all those years and not known?
33:15Her answer about the moment of the confession was four words.
33:19It explained so much.
33:22It explained the missing family.
33:24It explained the passport he never applied for.
33:28The trips she took alone.
33:30The jobs he turned down.
33:31The silences when the conversation turned to childhood.
33:3620 years of small mysteries suddenly had one answer.
33:41But now look at where that left the two of them.
33:44Because this is where the story turns again.
33:47The secret had been his alone.
33:50Now it was hers, too.
33:52Jean was an American citizen and a state social services employee,
33:55married to a man living under a false name,
33:58holding a social security number obtained under that name.
34:02As far as either of them knew, there was still a federal warrant out for him.
34:07They had no idea it had been cancelled eight years earlier.
34:11Every day they kept quiet, she was keeping his secret with him.
34:15And she would not do it.
34:18So here is the question the title has been pointing at all along.
34:22And now it is sharper than ever.
34:24Telling Jean solved the problem inside the marriage.
34:27She stayed.
34:29Why not leave it there?
34:31Why not go on quietly as Dennis Wiles with one more person in on the secret
34:36for whatever years they had left?
34:38He was in his sixties.
34:40Nobody had come for him in four decades.
34:43There was every chance nobody ever would.
34:46Why walk into a government office and say his real name out loud?
34:50Part of the answer is in what Jean pushed for.
34:53By every account, it was at her urging that he decided to come forward.
34:57The life she wanted with him could not be lived as a secret.
35:01But the other part of the answer begins earlier.
35:04And it surprised even the people closest to the story.
35:08Because Jean may not have been the first American he told.
35:11In 1979, a historian at Texas A&M University named Arnold Kramer
35:17had published the standard book on German prisoners of war in the United States.
35:21It was called Nazi Prisoners of War in America.
35:25Kramer had gone through the records, he counted the escapes,
35:28and in his pages, he named the one escapee the American system had never found.
35:34Georg Gardner.
35:36Somewhere in the Hawaiian Islands, the man himself had read it.
35:40Now, the sources do not line up neatly here,
35:43and I want to be straight with you about that.
35:46Most accounts put Jean's confrontation in 1984.
35:49But Kramer gave a different date for the moment his telephone rang.
35:53And it was earlier.
35:55November, 1983.
35:57A man on the line said he had read the book.
36:00He said it was very accurate.
36:02And then he told the professor who he was.
36:05Imagine being that historian.
36:07You have written that one prisoner was never found,
36:10and the prisoner calls you to say you got it right.
36:13What Georg Gettner wanted from Arnold Kramer,
36:16and what the professor said to him when he complained about how the book had portrayed him,
36:20is where the last door of this story begins to open.
36:23Arnold Kramer did not get the conversation he might have expected.
36:27The man on the phone was not grateful to be remembered.
36:30He had a complaint.
36:32In Kramer's book, he was a line in a list of escapees,
36:35a German soldier who had vanished,
36:37and the title on the cover said Nazi.
36:41Kramer later recalled what Gardner told him.
36:43Well, you made me look like a Nazi.
36:46The historian did not soften it.
36:49Well, Georg, he replied, you were a Nazi.
36:53Hold on to that exchange,
36:55because it tells you who Georg Gettner was in 1983.
36:59He had been a soldier of Hitler's army.
37:01He had spent almost 40 years becoming someone else.
37:05And the man he had become no longer recognized the man in the history book.
37:10He wanted the record corrected.
37:12He wanted to be known, by his real name, with his real story, as what he now was.
37:19That is not the instinct of a fugitive.
37:23Fugitives want to stay out of the record.
37:25This man wanted back into it.
37:28Over the next two years, Kramer and Gattner worked together on a book.
37:32It would tell the whole story, from Tunisia to Hawaii, in his own voice.
37:38The publisher, Stein and Day, gave it a title built to sell.
37:43Hitler's last soldier in America.
37:46Kramer was frank about that later.
37:48It was designed to sell books, of course.
37:51Meanwhile, the legal side was handled the careful American way.
37:56Gartner hired two attorneys, Ronald Oldenburg in Hawaii,
37:59and Michael John Bieber in Los Angeles.
38:03They contacted the Immigration and Naturalization Service in San Pedro.
38:08Nobody was being arrested here.
38:10A surrender was being arranged.
38:12On a date.
38:13With a book, timed to appear the same month.
38:17Which brings us back to where we started.
38:20September 11th, 1985.
38:22San Pedro.
38:24A 64-year-old man gives the officers his real name for the first time in 40 years.
38:31What happened next took about as long as a press conference.
38:34Harold Ezell, the Immigration Service's Regional Commissioner for the Western United States,
38:39stood up in front of the reporters.
38:42He told them the FBI had canceled Gartner's fugitive warrant back in 1976.
38:47The Bureau had no further interest in him.
38:50And Ezell said the chances were good that he could stay in the country,
38:53because he was married to an American citizen.
38:57Think about that sentence for a moment.
38:59The thing that kept him in America in the end was not his forged paper trail,
39:03or his skill at hiding, or his 40 years of silence.
39:07It was Gene.
39:09An agency spokesman, John Belluardo, put it more plainly.
39:14We're not going to lock him up.
39:16And then came the reasoning, and you have heard it before in this story.
39:20Back in 1953, an American lawyer had argued that Reinhold Pable had never sneaked into the United States.
39:27The army had brought him here, as a prisoner, against his will.
39:32Thirty-two years later, the government applied the same logic to Georg Gartner.
39:36He was not, in the ordinary sense, an illegal immigrant.
39:40The United States had carried him across the ocean.
39:43He had committed no serious crime in his years here.
39:46There would be no prosecution.
39:48There would be no deportation.
39:51In time, he was granted permanent residence.
39:55That same week, he sat beside Jean in a television studio,
39:59across from Bryant Gumbel on NBC's Today show,
40:02and surrendered again.
40:04This time, to the whole country.
40:07So now we can answer the question this story has been asking since the first minute.
40:12Why did a man nobody was hunting give himself up?
40:16Not because he was caught.
40:18The FBI had stopped looking in 1963, and cancelled his warrant in 1976.
40:25Not because of guilt over the war, or fear of the Soviets.
40:30Silesia had been lost for forty years, and nobody was going to send him there.
40:34He gave himself up because hiding had won him everything except the one thing he actually wanted.
40:40Remember the lesson of Kurt Rossmeisel.
40:43A false identity holds up on ordinary days, and fails at the turning points of a life.
40:49Gertner had reached those turning points.
40:51Retirement, with papers that did not exist.
40:55A marriage his wife would only stay in on the truth.
40:58A passport he could never apply for.
41:02A name, his own, he could not say out loud.
41:07Forty years earlier, the American system had let him in without asking a single question.
41:12That was how he disappeared.
41:14But a country that asks no questions also gives you nothing you can rely on.
41:19To belong in America, openly, legally, under his own name,
41:25he would have to answer every question it had never asked.
41:29So he did.
41:31In September 1985, Georg Gertner was not surrendering to be caught.
41:36He was surrendering to be let in.
41:39And here is the part that belongs to the American side of this story.
41:42When he finally walked through that door, the system did what it had done in the camps at Deming in
41:481945,
41:49and in a Chicago courtroom in 1953.
41:52It followed the rules.
41:54It looked at the facts.
41:56And it gave the last escaped soldier of Hitler's army something he had never been able to steal.
42:03A lawful place in the country he had chosen.
42:07Arnold Kramer summed up why the case was unique.
42:10Of all those escapees, what's different about Georg is that he wasn't found.
42:16He had never been found.
42:18In the end, he came in on his own.
42:22There is one more chapter.
42:23It is about what Georg Gertner did with his real name once he had it back.
42:28And about a small tile on a wall in Colorado that, for years, carried no name at all.
42:35Georg Gertner did not spend his last decades hiding from his real name.
42:39He spent them using it.
42:41For a while after 1985, he went back to Germany, the country he had left as a soldier and had
42:47not seen since the war.
42:49He returned to the United States and settled in Colorado, near the Front Range, in the shadow of mountains not
42:55unlike the Sierra slopes where he had once taught skiing under someone else's name.
43:00And then, according to most accounts in 2009, at the age of 88, he did the one thing a fugitive
43:07can never do.
43:09He stood up, raised his right hand, and became a citizen of the United States.
43:15Think about the distance in that single act.
43:19In 1943, he arrived in America under guard, a captured soldier of Hitler's army.
43:25In 1945, he left an American camp under a fence, in the dark.
43:30In 2009, he walked into a ceremony in daylight, gave his real name, and swore an oath to the country
43:38that had held him prisoner.
43:39He was not the only one whose story ended quietly.
43:43Reinhold Pabel, the bookseller from Chicago, came back to America legally after his months of waiting, then eventually took his
43:51family to Germany.
43:53He opened a bookshop in Hamburg.
43:55By one account, he died there in 2008, at 92.
44:01Kurt Rossmeisel's six-part confession ran in the Toledo Blade in 1959, and then he faded from the newspapers.
44:08The others on that Collier's list slipped back into private lives.
44:13Of all the German soldiers who escaped from American camps, only one stayed unaccounted for long enough to be called
44:21the last.
44:23Georg Gertner died on January 30, 2013.
44:27He was 92.
44:29His ashes were placed in a columbarium at a cemetery in Longmont, Colorado, box 41, behind a small engraved plaque.
44:39And here is the detail I promised you.
44:42A few years after his death, a documentary crew removed that plaque to film it.
44:48It was not put back.
44:50For about four years, the man who had spent four decades living without his name, rested behind a blank tile.
44:57When a reporter went looking for him in 2018, the cemetery promised to have the plaque returned within a week.
45:04It is an almost perfect last chapter for a man who had been so good at disappearing.
45:09But it is not where this story really ends.
45:12It ends where it began.
45:14San Pedro.
45:17In the autumn of 1945, a freight train carried a runaway prisoner into that harbor town,
45:22and he walked away from the tracks into America as nobody.
45:26No name, no papers, no past.
45:30Forty years later, almost to the week, he walked back into the same town, and gave the United States his
45:37real name.
45:38The first time, San Pedro was where he escaped America's rules.
45:42The second time, it was where he asked to live by them.
45:46And the person who brought him to that door was not an FBI agent, or a detective, or a historian.
45:52It was an American social worker named Jean, standing beside a waiting taxi, asking her husband one plain question,
46:00and refusing to leave until she heard the truth.
46:03In 2018, at 93, Jean Wiles was still answering the question everyone asks her.
46:11How could you live with a man for all those years, and not know?
46:15The answer is the whole story.
46:18She knew him.
46:19She knew the man America had made out of a prisoner.
46:23The only thing she did not know was his name.
46:27And when she finally learned it, she was the one who made sure he could say it in public.
46:33So why did a German prisoner, who escaped in 1945, give himself up in 1985, when no one was looking
46:41for him?
46:42Because America had given him everything a man can take by hiding.
46:46And he wanted the one thing it gives only to those who tell the truth.
46:52A place in it, under his own name.
46:56Thank you for watching this story to the end.
46:58If it stayed with you, please give the video a like.
47:01It genuinely helps stories like this one find the viewers who want them.
47:05Subscribe and turn on the bell so you won't miss the next one.
47:09And tell us in the comments where you're watching from.
47:12If your father, grandfather, or uncle served in the Second World War, perhaps as one of the American soldiers who
47:18guarded those camps, or in any Allied unit, please share his name and the unit he served with.
47:25Those names deserve to be remembered.
47:27Day 45
47:27Day 45
47:27Day 45