• 8 minutes ago
What legally constitutes genocide, and how can prosecutors prove it? The 1948 UN Genocide Convention defines genocide as the deliberate attempt to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious group. From Rwanda and Srebrenica to Cambodia and Gaza, this explainer examines the five recognised genocidal acts, the importance of proving intent and landmark international court convictions. It also examines the UN inquiry's genocide allegations against Israel, which Israel strongly rejects.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:27So
00:28genocide is defined in the 1948 Genocide Convention, to which most states are party.
00:35And it's any of several enumerated acts such as killing, inflicting serious harm, creating
00:43conditions of life intended to destroy.
00:46But the point is that has to be committed with intent to destroy in whole or in part
00:53a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.
00:56So that intent is what sets genocide apart from other international crimes.
01:01It's not about the scale of the killing.
01:03It's about the aim to eliminate a group's existence.
02:37Genocide is notoriously difficult to prove. The legal threshold is extremely high precisely because of the seriousness of the accusation
02:46and the implications for both states and individuals found guilty of genocide.
02:52The most authoritative findings to date come from international courts and tribunals, as well as national courts exercising universal jurisdiction.
03:02Cases that have found genocide have come from the ICTR, the Rwanda Tribunal, which issued 61 convictions, many for genocide.
03:13The ICTY convicted several individuals for their role in the Srebrenica massacre, where over 8,000 Bosniak Muslim men and
03:22boys were executed.
03:24The ICJ has made rulings in relating to genocide, notably in its 2007 ruling in Bosnia and Serbia.
03:34But there, while it confirmed that genocide had occurred, it held that Serbia was not directly responsible, but had failed
03:43to prevent genocide.
04:03So there are several active genocide proceedings.
04:06The International Criminal Court is investigating Myanmar and Sudan for genocide.
04:13And the International Court of Justice is currently hearing cases brought by the Gambia against Myanmar and another by South
04:20Africa against Israel and both alleged genocide.
04:23So what's unique today is that genocide is increasingly being litigated, not only after the fact, but while it's unfolding.
04:33And courts are also using provisional measures to try to prevent further harm.
05:22The International Criminal Court of Justice
05:23The International Criminal Court of Justice
05:27Prosecutors have to show not only that certain acts occurred, and that can be mass killing, forced displacement, starvation and
05:34so on, but that they were carried out with the specific intent to destroy in whole or in part a
05:41protected group.
06:13Courts can look to circumstantial evidence, patterns of conduct, planning documents, orders from leadership, public statements from officials.
06:22So in cases like Rwanda and Srebrenica, genocide was established based on a combination of direct statements, systematic patterns of
06:32violence, the targeting of essential elements of a group survival, and today that same methodology is applied to ongoing cases,
06:42including the present report.
07:13The International Initiative
07:13of Ukraban
07:13The Internationalediater
07:13The International soybean
07:18Genocide is occurring in Gaza. We haven't gone into Palestine yet, we will, because
07:26this is a permanent commission. And we named the three individuals that we felt were responsible.
07:35And we said, and the one is the Prime Minister, the other the President, and the third is
07:40the former Minister of Defence. And we said that since they acted as agents of the state,
07:48then the state of Israel is responsible.
08:02So this report is legally momentous. It's the first time a UN mandated body has concluded
08:08that Israel is committing genocide based on direct evidence, such as public statements
08:14from senior officials and circumstantial evidence drawn from the military campaign itself.
08:20I'd emphasise that while it's not a judicial ruling, it does carry real weight, it will inform ongoing
08:27proceedings at the International Court of Justice, and could shape future ICC prosecutions.
08:32It also activates legal obligations for other states, not to be complicit, not to supply arms,
08:40and to take action to prevent and punish genocide.
09:04Genocide is the most serious crime in international law, and the legal community rightly applies its definition
09:12with caution. But the legal findings in this report are detailed, grounded in precedent,
09:18and reflect a growing convergence between legal scholarship and human rights documentation on Gaza.
09:24They also remind us that accountability is not only retrospective,
09:29but it can and must be used to protect lives now.

Recommended