00:27So
00:28genocide is defined in the 1948 Genocide Convention, to which most states are party.
00:35And it's any of several enumerated acts such as killing, inflicting serious harm, creating
00:43conditions of life intended to destroy.
00:46But the point is that has to be committed with intent to destroy in whole or in part
00:53a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.
00:56So that intent is what sets genocide apart from other international crimes.
01:01It's not about the scale of the killing.
01:03It's about the aim to eliminate a group's existence.
02:37Genocide is notoriously difficult to prove. The legal threshold is extremely high precisely because of the seriousness of the accusation
02:46and the implications for both states and individuals found guilty of genocide.
02:52The most authoritative findings to date come from international courts and tribunals, as well as national courts exercising universal jurisdiction.
03:02Cases that have found genocide have come from the ICTR, the Rwanda Tribunal, which issued 61 convictions, many for genocide.
03:13The ICTY convicted several individuals for their role in the Srebrenica massacre, where over 8,000 Bosniak Muslim men and
03:22boys were executed.
03:24The ICJ has made rulings in relating to genocide, notably in its 2007 ruling in Bosnia and Serbia.
03:34But there, while it confirmed that genocide had occurred, it held that Serbia was not directly responsible, but had failed
03:43to prevent genocide.
04:03So there are several active genocide proceedings.
04:06The International Criminal Court is investigating Myanmar and Sudan for genocide.
04:13And the International Court of Justice is currently hearing cases brought by the Gambia against Myanmar and another by South
04:20Africa against Israel and both alleged genocide.
04:23So what's unique today is that genocide is increasingly being litigated, not only after the fact, but while it's unfolding.
04:33And courts are also using provisional measures to try to prevent further harm.
05:22The International Criminal Court of Justice
05:23The International Criminal Court of Justice
05:27Prosecutors have to show not only that certain acts occurred, and that can be mass killing, forced displacement, starvation and
05:34so on, but that they were carried out with the specific intent to destroy in whole or in part a
05:41protected group.
06:13Courts can look to circumstantial evidence, patterns of conduct, planning documents, orders from leadership, public statements from officials.
06:22So in cases like Rwanda and Srebrenica, genocide was established based on a combination of direct statements, systematic patterns of
06:32violence, the targeting of essential elements of a group survival, and today that same methodology is applied to ongoing cases,
06:42including the present report.
07:13The International Initiative
07:13of Ukraban
07:13The Internationalediater
07:13The International soybean
07:18Genocide is occurring in Gaza. We haven't gone into Palestine yet, we will, because
07:26this is a permanent commission. And we named the three individuals that we felt were responsible.
07:35And we said, and the one is the Prime Minister, the other the President, and the third is
07:40the former Minister of Defence. And we said that since they acted as agents of the state,
07:48then the state of Israel is responsible.
08:02So this report is legally momentous. It's the first time a UN mandated body has concluded
08:08that Israel is committing genocide based on direct evidence, such as public statements
08:14from senior officials and circumstantial evidence drawn from the military campaign itself.
08:20I'd emphasise that while it's not a judicial ruling, it does carry real weight, it will inform ongoing
08:27proceedings at the International Court of Justice, and could shape future ICC prosecutions.
08:32It also activates legal obligations for other states, not to be complicit, not to supply arms,
08:40and to take action to prevent and punish genocide.
09:04Genocide is the most serious crime in international law, and the legal community rightly applies its definition
09:12with caution. But the legal findings in this report are detailed, grounded in precedent,
09:18and reflect a growing convergence between legal scholarship and human rights documentation on Gaza.
09:24They also remind us that accountability is not only retrospective,
09:29but it can and must be used to protect lives now.