00:08This case is important because it is a reminder of how relevant and timely this issue is. It can
00:16seem oftentimes that the war is 80, 90 years ago and that these cases surely must be receding into
00:22the past. And here we have a seller who's owned it since 1975 and it's been in private hands. So
00:31as long ago as this issue seems and the war seems, it's a reminder that these claims and
00:37these cases will keep coming up.
00:47Traditional Nazi-era art claims focus on either confiscation by the Nazi government,
00:53that is to say government actors or agents who are forcibly taking art from other people,
00:59or the bigger category of what we call forced sales, where the fact of the transaction is deemed to be
01:06coercive because of where it happened and because of who was involved. So for example,
01:10a Jewish collector selling something in Berlin in 1939 will be deemed presumptively invalid because
01:16that seller really didn't have the freedom to say no to the transaction because of the prosecution
01:22around them. The idea of Fluchtgut or flight goods has evolved more as a historical term than a legal
01:28one to address the category of claims and situations where the owner had left Germany or German allied
01:35countries and sold something while they were in flight, hence the name, to finance either their
01:41further escape or their maintenance or whatever else. This is a more complicated set of claims because
01:46that dynamic selling artwork in a country that is not controlled by the Nazis is not generally going
01:53to be considered something where the transaction will be invalidated because that larger coercive dynamic
02:00is not present.
02:11I think it's hard to read too much into the strength of it from the fact of the settlement
02:17because the story broke so late and so close to the auction that both sides including the sellers
02:22probably felt a fair amount of pressure to get a deal done. So it's it's hard to read too much
02:28into it
02:28in that respect. Certainly its significance is in its newsworthiness. It's a very valuable painting
02:35and for me the significance is because it falls into this category of claims that's somewhat outside
02:41the traditional group of arguments that that happen about forced sales and deals instead with a sale
02:49by an owner who had left Germany before the sale.
02:56I think it's a combination of the evolving legal landscape which may or may not be evolving as
03:02quickly as some people would like or believe and the intersection of that and ethical considerations.
03:09There's no question from the evidence that the Fisher family was in Vienna because of persecution to
03:15begin with and so reaching a compromise that acknowledges that to some extent is really more
03:22of an ethical consideration than a legal one.
03:28Well I think what struck me at first was how close to the sale it came up.
03:33That's fairly unusual. The catalog has been available online for some time. It's available worldwide. It's searchable.
03:40One of the checks that the auction houses do at the very beginning of the consignment relationship
03:46is to review databases like the art loss register or the lost art database in Germany so they catch any
03:52existing claims and can deal with them as as soon as possible. It was somewhat surprising to me that
03:58the claimants say they didn't know anything about the sale until I think November 7th which put it in a
04:05very
04:05compressed time frame which you know happily I guess you know they were able to reach an agreement but
04:11that makes it very hard to have a meaningful conversation because there are often further
04:16research points that have to be pursued and it takes time for people to you know digest another
04:21side's offer and things like that so that struck me and I was certainly worried over the weekend that
04:27that might derail the whole process because there wasn't enough time so I'm happy it was able to come to
04:33sale tonight.
04:38A Jewish owner in Germany proper anytime after 1933 is going to be subject to persecution and that is
04:47going to be a sale that is highly suspect and so moving forward from there on the timeline depending
04:51on whether German occupation had yet come to that country will make a big difference so a sale in Vienna
04:57like this one in 1936 is very very different than a sale in Vienna in 1939 after the Anschluss and
05:04the same
05:04considerations will apply to the occupation of France or Belgium or the Netherlands and once we establish
05:10that timeline in that combination of who went and where the second level question is what we know about
05:16the transaction because even with that presumption if it can be shown that the sale was for a valid price
05:23and that the seller received the full proceeds the transaction may get survived those other things
05:29are harder to prove and they tend to be true less often because of the circumstances many of these
05:34sales especially in Germany in the 30s were conducted to finance the exit from Germany and pay what was
05:41called the flight tax and so it is less common that someone will meet that burden to defend a transaction
05:48in
05:48a German occupied territory but it's this sort of matrix of the place and the time and the person
05:54and what we know about the sale that really goes to the question
06:01I think a common misconception which has come out again in this case is how not understanding how much
06:07work goes into it by the auction house on the front end in any consignment either the time the contract
06:14is reached or leading up to the sale the auction house in this case Sotheby's will do an enormous
06:18amount of work with a really deeply experienced expert team to scrutinize the provenance of everything
06:24that comes to sale because the auction house wants only to sell works with the provenance that it can
06:30defend it wants the buyer to get good title so I think the misconception here that I've seen is the
06:37idea that somehow that work on the front end didn't take place I don't see any evidence of that the
06:43provenance that Sotheby's published in the catalog weeks ago is very detailed it's actually more
06:50detailed than is often available just as it happens in the sale of paintings and the provenance sets out
06:58that timeline that I was talking about before in terms of it places the object in certain places at
07:04certain times and so we can follow it from the Fisher family to the consignment with Paul Kassir in
07:10Amsterdam to the sale in 1936 and get a much clearer picture than is often possible about a sale on
07:17that
07:17direction right now at a very近 curve and it does not matter