- 5 hours ago
After 17 years at Tesla, Colin Campbell knows a thing or two about solving difficult engineering problems. Now he's helping turn one of those problems into a potentially enormous new business.
Campbell is chief technology officer of Redwood Materials, the battery recycling startup founded by Tesla cofounder JB Straubel in 2017.
Redwood started by extracting valuable metals and minerals from old EV batteries. It's now expanding into energy storage, using retired batteries to help power AI data centers, factories, and other facilities.
Campbell is chief technology officer of Redwood Materials, the battery recycling startup founded by Tesla cofounder JB Straubel in 2017.
Redwood started by extracting valuable metals and minerals from old EV batteries. It's now expanding into energy storage, using retired batteries to help power AI data centers, factories, and other facilities.
Category
🤖
TechTranscript
00:00I'm excited to welcome Colin Campbell, Chief Technology Officer of Redwood Materials.
00:07Colin spent 17 years at Tesla building some of the hardest engineering projects in the world, especially in the business
00:17world.
00:18And now he's leading one of the most interesting transformations in American business, which is taking old batteries, mostly from
00:27EVs, and turning them into valuable new materials and increasingly using that to power the AI revolution.
00:35I've actually visited Redwood's enormous campus in Nevada earlier this year, and I've been following the company's evolution very, very
00:44closely.
00:45So I'm really excited to hear how Redwood has been doing lately and what its future is.
00:52So, Colin, welcome. Thanks for joining us.
00:55Ali, thank you. It's a real pleasure to be here.
00:58So you spent 17 years at Tesla. It's a long, long time.
01:04I'm sure very, very hard work.
01:06You're working on some of the most important parts of electric vehicles and energy storage.
01:11Now, Tesla was founded by, sorry, Redwood was founded by another Tesla veteran, J.B. Straubel.
01:18I'm interested in what you both learned at Tesla that made you realize a company like Redwood needed to exist.
01:25Yeah, I think the foundational insight was if you're standing next to like a Model 3 production line, right?
01:35You're making, call it a million cars a year, and you're watching battery packs go into those cars every 30
01:41seconds.
01:43You get to wondering after a while what's going to happen to all of those batteries once the cars are
01:48at their end of life.
01:49You know, they're highly engineered.
01:51They're incredibly robust and durable, but they do have a finite life.
01:54And that just got us to thinking, you know, we really need to make sure both that we're doing the
02:00responsible thing with those battery packs at the end of life,
02:03but also that there's just a tremendous amount of value remaining at them, even when they're no longer like quite
02:10perfect to be in a consumer's vehicle.
02:13And so for folks not familiar with Redwood, who buys the materials that you extract from these older batteries?
02:21Yeah, so it's changed over time.
02:23I think the story of our recycling and refining business is one of both increasing volume as the number of
02:30batteries coming off the road kind of increases inevitably with time,
02:34as with the aging and the maturity of the electric vehicle fleet.
02:38And it's also been one of increasing levels of refining.
02:41So we, as time goes on, we have increasingly separated and refined the nickel, the lithium, and the cobalt.
02:49And they go into, you know, many different places in the metals market today.
02:55And the thing that really shocked me when I got to your campus was just the sheer scale of the
03:03operation and, you know, how difficult it is.
03:05So what is the hardest part of making all these complicated things work at true industrial scale?
03:13Yeah, well, I think, first off, I want to pause on that for a moment.
03:17It's really important to us that it be at industrial scale, that we have a real impact on the world.
03:22That is what drew me to Redwood.
03:24I know that's a large part of what motivates the entire company is to have impact at industrially relevant scale.
03:31I mean, the, I think the hardest part is really just the capital and the size of business required to
03:41process the sheer tonnage of that material.
03:43We have great technology.
03:45I think that's well proven, certainly at the lab scale and the pilot scale.
03:49But bringing it to something that can process economically tens of thousands of ton of material a year is, it's
03:57quite capital intensive.
03:58You have to be very thoughtful and very innovative about how you construct those plants.
04:03And so actually, probably related to that, when you moved from engineering at Tesla and you moved to Redwood and
04:12really got involved, what was the biggest surprise in that move coming from Tesla to Redwood?
04:18Yeah, I think the primary thing for me, and it was part of what motivated me, was wanting to learn
04:24about a totally new business.
04:26So the metals industry, it's not a consumer sales business, you're not selling to individuals, you're selling into a market,
04:33a globalized market, their pricing is set very differently, and margins are made very differently.
04:39And it's taken, took me personally just a little while to adapt to that business and the way of operating
04:46it.
04:47So I would say that was the biggest change for me.
04:51And I'm interested in getting into, you know, knowing when to change direction with any, really any type of business.
04:59And one thing I learned when I was visiting was that Redwood used to make copper foil for batteries.
05:06And then, you know, that big metals market, you know, changed and you decided to pause that business.
05:13Kind of what happened there and then more broadly, like how do you decide when to double down on a
05:19technology and when to change direction?
05:21Yeah, I think the story of that is of one of standing at the threshold, again, of large capital investment
05:28and just doing your diligence on reviewing the business case of like, okay, we're about to invest in incremental triple
05:36or double digit millions of dollars on this.
05:39Does the business case, does the business case, does the business case still stand, has the geopolitics of this changed,
05:44has the local economics of it changed, and making a prudent decision at that moment.
05:51And so we, you know, we are not wedded to the original business plan.
05:57I think that is not a good way to operate a business.
06:00I think it's very dangerous to just plow ahead, regardless of the current economics, two or three years later after
06:07you made the business plan.
06:08So it's just a really practical decision.
06:11We still sell copper.
06:12It's not in a foil form.
06:14We're still returning that metal back into the metals at market and into the value chain.
06:19Just that particular business we decided was not one that made sense to invest heavily in.
06:24And talking of things changing quite rapidly, I'm interested in this fascinating pivot that Redwood has done in recent years.
06:35So, you know, you're focusing on EV batteries and the existing businesses.
06:41And then the AI boom arrives, creates this enormous demand for electricity.
06:46And, you know, I certainly have known Redwood for years and I did not see this coming.
06:51So, you know, Redwood realized that it could use some of the old EV batteries to help meet that demand.
06:58Can you describe kind of how that how that opportunity emerged?
07:02Yeah, absolutely.
07:03Yeah.
07:04So it's I really want to emphasize the materials business, the metals and refining business still exists and is still
07:10growing and is strong.
07:11And, you know, majority of the company working on that.
07:14We do have this exciting, I think, of additional opportunity in the energy storage business.
07:21It's one link in the chain of extracting as much valuable as we possibly value as we possibly can from
07:28these old batteries.
07:30And it's maybe a similar story to the founding story, which is we're standing next to our the front end
07:37of our recycling business, you know, which is, you know, roughly speaking, a large shredder watching these big battery packs
07:45go into it.
07:46And with the background that we had in the executive team, in the engineering team, in energy storage, in vehicle
07:54batteries, we looked at those and we say, hey, these still store a lot of energy.
07:59We can still cycle them.
08:01You know, a consumer might be really frustrated with them if they're driving around to work and getting groceries, but
08:06they still have a lot of economic utility.
08:08And I think that was really uniquely sort of latent in the minds of the people at the company.
08:15And we were able to really review that business case and like, oh, hey, if we if we can really
08:21cheaply, really efficiently connect these high variety of different kinds of batteries to the grid, we can use them to
08:29store energy for another five years, another 10 years, maybe.
08:34I've been outside the main campus and all the old batteries are lined up and, you know, back in the
08:42day, they were there to, you know, let the remaining energy go down.
08:46And obviously, you're using that in a really inventive way now.
08:50And one of one of the new things I've noticed is that you're now able to take batteries from completely
08:56different electric vehicles, GM, Vivian, VW, whatever.
08:59And then you get them to work together as one giant energy storage system.
09:04The pack manager kind of explain how that worked, how you came up with that.
09:09And I assume that was difficult to build.
09:13Yeah, you've you've nailed it.
09:14The the hardest part of this is this huge variety of cars that are in the world and the huge
09:21variety of EV manufacturers.
09:23And we see all of it, you know, you mentioned a few a few names of the different kinds of
09:28packs we see.
09:29And so what is necessary in these recycling businesses where you are dealing with what something else somebody else thinks
09:37is is trash, basically, is a really efficient way to recover value from that trash.
09:44And so what that means for our energy storage business is we need to develop this pretty sophisticated piece of
09:50in-house power electronics.
09:51This is called the pack manager, which is a universal translator, both for the digital language that these electric vehicle
09:59packs use to communicate and talk about their health and the state of charge inside their cells.
10:05And also for the actual power flows.
10:07Some of these packs are low voltage packs.
10:09Some of these packs are high voltage packs.
10:11Some of them can are made for a Porsche.
10:13Some of them are made for a like relatively slow economy car.
10:17And we need made one device that is universal to all of those packs and can plug into any one
10:22of those packs and kind of abstracted away so that we don't see the variation of each pack in the
10:29large energy storage site.
10:31So no one asks for a Porsche battery, like electricity from a Porsche battery?
10:37No, they do.
10:38It's the those batteries are incredibly high performance.
10:41And so, you know, making something cheap that can use them alongside like a more economic, like call it a
10:48Nissan Leaf, was the real power electronics engineering challenge that our teams were able to to complete and tackle.
10:56Now, particularly looking at this, this business, you know, powering the AI boom, I'm interested how how big it could
11:04become compared to the original operation.
11:07And then and then double bow question midterms happened last week.
11:12Some backlash against the the AI data centers.
11:17Do you think that's a problem risk for Redwood?
11:21How do you assess that so far?
11:22Well, yeah, so to answer your first question on the potential size of the business, I think it's easily as
11:28large as the metals and refining business.
11:32I think it remains to be seen how much value we can extract from these packs.
11:39They have lasted longer than anyone expected so far in the sites we've seen.
11:43And we've been able to integrate them really, really rapidly and really, really affordably into increasingly large sites.
11:50So I would say at least as large as the metals business, maybe larger and to your question on sort
11:58of maybe how tightly coupled we are to the AI boom and the data center boom.
12:04You know, we are a energy storage company, we have affordable, fast to deploy, scalable energy storage happens to be
12:14very safe, very domestic content.
12:17And one of the major users of those today is certainly AI data centers.
12:23It's not the only one.
12:25And so if that industry are our our business predates that industry in that boom, or at least the current
12:32boom.
12:32And we had a we have a fantastic business plan, even if it if it were to totally vaporize, it's
12:39certainly winded our back.
12:40And we appreciate the really the innovative spirit and the drive to build new things that a lot of those
12:47data center companies have.
12:48So where we are working together on some projects, it's really refreshing, actually, to see the integration and the desire
12:58for newness in this otherwise really slow power sector.
13:03Yeah, that makes sense.
13:05It's been the electricity markets been sleepy for decades.
13:08And now suddenly everyone needs more electricity.
13:11What's the biggest remaining obstacle to scaling that that particular technology and that business?
13:18I really think it is the technology is baked, it is deployed, we have some big projects that are not
13:26yet announced, but nearing completion.
13:31And it's at this point, one of from our perspective of maturing our supply chain, lowering our costs,
13:38and then starting to expand that business to capture sort of more and more of the interesting things that we
13:46can do.
13:47So like, for example, today, we make this pack manager, I think it's a really fascinating piece of power electronics.
13:55We've done an excellent job with it.
13:57Now we're scaling that and that's the challenge ahead of us.
13:59There are other pieces of power systems that we can internalize and we are internalizing to make, say, a solar
14:09and storage power plant really cheap and really fast to build, uniquely cheap, unusually cheap.
14:14And so those are the most interesting opportunities with the team we have to do new things and to the
14:22next challenges for us.
14:23And when you look, maybe also, you know, the main, the core business as well as the new business, who
14:31are the, who are the main competitors in your view, Redwood?
14:34Oh man, I mean, I, I, I hate to say this on the energy business, but like, I don't see
14:41any other companies that have the full stack from building, designing, manufacturing, power electronics,
14:50like at the little widgets on the circuit board level, all the way up to running the civil engineering and
14:56directing the bulldozers around a site,
15:00like writing the software that orchestrates all of these energy assets.
15:03There are very, very few companies, um, that can, that can do that whole stack.
15:08And I think, um, I think we're actually quite unique and discovering in the market is discovering that we're quite
15:15unique in that way.
15:17Um, speaking of the market, um, Redwood has raised, you know, a lot of money and attracted some very major
15:24investors, um, Google and Nvidia's venture, venture side for a couple of them that people would recognize.
15:32I'd be, I'd be covering Silicon Valley for a decade or more.
15:36And usually investors like to back software businesses.
15:41Normally they take a, take a little less money and, uh, you know, Redwood is a huge,
15:46physical infrastructure business.
15:48What have you learned about convincing investors to back a business that takes so much capital and time to scale?
15:55Yeah, well, I think it is really a matter first of finding the right partners, people who have patience,
16:04people who know that it's going to take some years to see the return and that the return will be
16:09more durable and more lasting, uh, once it's in place.
16:13Um, I think the most sort of missed item about Redwood as we talk about what we can do is
16:25not,
16:26you know, any one of these achievements.
16:27We've talked about sort of profitability and increasing profitability and metals and refining.
16:32We've talked about these new businesses that we were able to enter in energy storage, power electronics,
16:37down increasingly power systems.
16:39And the thing that I think, um, with people who get it, that they start to see is like what
16:45is behind
16:46all that is a set of capabilities and a team and a curiosity around systems engineering that leads to
16:52new durable businesses like that.
16:56And then, um, I'd love to wrap this up and I, and I really want to tap your, your long
17:01experience
17:02kind of combining very hard engineering projects with, with businesses and capital markets.
17:08So for founders watching today, today and other, other business people, what, what's the biggest
17:15lesson you've learned about turning a difficult engineering problem into, into a successful company,
17:20either from Tesla or from Redwood?
17:23Oh man, what a great question.
17:25Um, most valuable lesson it really is, is to get down to brass tacks and first principles about the
17:35problem that you're solving.
17:36It is a little bit of a cliche answer, but you would be surprised in like, call it the, call
17:43it the data
17:43center industry, how fractured that market is, how little anyone has looked at designing the
17:50system as a whole and understanding the physics of getting power from the power line all the way to
17:56the chip as a holistic system. And I think if you are able to identify something that the market has
18:04not optimized just because of history, you know, as a founder, and you really believe in that and
18:09you follow it all the way through, um, simplify it, make sure there are no unnecessary pieces in your
18:17proposal. It, it almost always, you know, I don't, I don't want to say it's not a ton of work.
18:22It's a huge amount of work and a huge amount of evangelism about your idea because the market is
18:27like so used to doing it a different way. But if you see that kernel of efficiency, like we could
18:32do
18:32this a different way and you can create a proof point, it, it will follow through.
18:37Um, well, Colin Campbell, CTA of Redwood materials. Um, thank you. Thank you so much
18:42for joining us. Fascinating conversation. Real pleasure. Thank you.