• 5 hours ago
Ten American POWs walked past a Japanese guard in broad daylight—and he counted every one of them. In April 1943, at Davao Penal Colony on Mindanao, Navy officer Melvin McCoy, Army and Marine servicemen, and two Filipino guides used approved work details, carefully planned cover stories, and a homemade sextant to escape a camp no prisoner had left in ten years.

This World War II military history documentary follows the months of preparation, the perilous journey through swamp and jungle, and the escapees’ effort to carry news of the prisoners’ suffering to the outside world. Discover the real events behind the Davao POW camp escape, the Japanese guards’ misreading of the plan, and the courage and ingenuity of the men involved. A narrated WWII story for viewers interested in Pacific War history, American prisoners of war, and dramatic escape accounts. The Japanese guards never saw the escape happen—even as they watched the men walk out.

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00April 4th, 1943. A Sunday. The Davao Penal Colony, on the island of Mindanao, in the
00:07southern Philippines. Breakfast is over. At the gate of the prisoner compound, the work details
00:14are forming up in front of a Japanese guard with a chalkboard. His job is the same as every morning.
00:20He counts. Ichi. Ni. San. Shi. Every man who steps past him becomes a number. He chalks
00:30the total on the board and waves the detail out toward the fields. The first group through
00:36is six Americans under a United States Navy lieutenant commander named Melvin McCoy. On
00:42paper, they're going to the coffee fields to build a shed, a job McCoy had asked the
00:47Japanese to let him do on Sundays. Under his clothes, he is carrying navigation charts and
00:52medicine. Behind them, Marine Captain Austin Schaffner calls the Sunday plowing crew into
00:58line. His voice shakes, very slightly. Three Marines and an Army Air Forces pilot, the men
01:05who tend the camp's bulls while most of the colony rests. One of those Marines, 1st Lieutenant
01:11Jack Hawkins, 26, from Roxton, Texas, is wearing a battered sun helmet he bought in another camp
01:18for a pack of cigarettes. He would later say he felt as conspicuous as if he were dressed
01:23in prison stripes. Nobody looks twice. In McCoy's group, Army Major Stephen Melnick has a musette
01:30bag over his shoulder. A friend, Frank Carpenter, calls over with a grin.
01:35Hey, Steve! Your toothbrush is sticking out of the back of your musette bag. Are you planning
01:40to escape? Melnick pretends he didn't hear. Further on, McCoy's men march past a Japanese
01:47sentry on a prison road. McCoy calls, eyes left, and throws him a snappy salute. The sentry
01:55returns it. Then a coconut grove closes behind them. Hold on to this. Ten American prisoners
02:03of war left that compound on Sunday morning. Nobody cut wire. Nobody dug a tunnel. Every
02:10one of them walked within arm's reach of a Japanese guard, was looked at, counted out
02:16loud, and written down. And the Japanese would not grasp what they had watched until six o'clock
02:21that evening, when the count came up short. Remember that chalkboard. This whole story comes
02:27back to it. If you want to see how ten American servicemen walked out of a Japanese prison camp
02:32in daylight, and what it took to reach that gate, hit like and subscribe. It helps us keep
02:38digging. Every man in those two details had already lived through the worst of the Philippines.
02:43Captain Ed Dias, walking out with McCoy, had commanded a fighter squadron on Bataan, and
02:49then survived the death march. Captain Sam Grascio, on the plowing crew, had flown as his wingman.
02:56Shaffner, Hawkins, and Major Mike Dobrevich were Marines taken on Corregidor. With them were
03:03Army Lieutenant Leo Bolins and two sergeants, Paul Marshall and Robert Spielman. Somewhere
03:10ahead, in the jungle, two more men were waiting. Benigno de la Cruz and Victorio Jumarang were
03:17Filipino convicts serving time for murder. They had agreed to guide ten Americans through country
03:22the Japanese would only enter armed and in force. Melnick had put the reason in one sentence.
03:29We must tell the world what the Japanese are doing in the Philippines.
03:34To understand what happened at that gate, you have to understand the camp.
03:38The colony had been built before the war for Filipino convicts, about 30 miles northeast of
03:44the city of Davao. By the spring of 1943, it held roughly 2,000 American prisoners, guarded by about
03:52250 Japanese. Think about that. One guard for every eight prisoners. And on a normal day, about a thousand
04:02of those prisoners marched out to work rice paddies, cut timber, and plow, across a farm that stretched for
04:08miles. No garrison that size could watch that many men over that much ground. The Japanese didn't try.
04:16One account of the camp's routine puts it bluntly. Out on the work details, the sentry merely counts noses at
04:23noon
04:24and prior to return to camp. The old and sick men on the coffee and orchard crews had no sentry
04:30at all.
04:31So what held 2,000 men in a place with so few eyes on them? Not the wire around the
04:37compound. The
04:38prisoners walked out past it every morning. What held them was the land. Swamp around the colony, made all
04:46the worse by crocodiles. Beyond it, mountains, rivers, and hundreds of miles of Mindanao. In the ten years the
04:55colony had existed, no prisoner had ever escaped from it. And there was a second wall, one you couldn't
05:01see. At Kavanatuan, the camp most of these men had come from, prisoners had been divided into squads of
05:09ten. If one man escaped, they were told, the other nine would be shot. Three Americans caught after an
05:16escape attempt there were tortured for 48 hours. Two were shot. The third was beheaded. Nobody
05:25at Davao knew for certain whether that rule had followed them south. Every man stepping through
05:31that gate was bedding other men's lives along with his own. So the question isn't how ten Americans got
05:37past the Japanese guards. They never got past them. They walked straight through them, being counted.
05:44The real question is what these men spent three months doing so that a guard could look directly at
05:51an escape and see a Sunday work detail. And the first move in that plan, believe it or not, was
05:58a
05:58theft from a Japanese chicken farm. A theft that would be repeated 133 times. To find where this escape
06:06really began, you have to go back three months, to early January 1943, and to the least important work
06:14detail in the colony. Lieutenant Commander McCoy was put in charge of a coffee plantation detail.
06:20About 35 officers, most of them older men, the kind the camp considered too worn out to be worth much
06:26in the rice paddies. Remember what we said about those crews. The old and sick men on the coffee details
06:32had no sentry at all. Only one other officer on that detail was young enough to be dangerous.
06:38Major Stephen Melnick became McCoy's assistant. Somewhere between the coffee bushes, the two men started
06:44talking about getting out. By McCoy's account, Melnick gave it careful thought before he said
06:49yes. So the plan that would break that colony's 10-year record began on ground the Japanese had
06:55decided wasn't worth watching. Their first idea was easy to say, and close to insane, to attempt.
07:02Break out of the prison farm, slip the guards, reach the coast, steal a sailboat, and sail it to
07:08Australia. One of the sergeants who joined them later asked McCoy how far that was.
07:13McCoy told him. About 1,600 miles to the nearest point. And he claimed that, with workable instruments,
07:21he could put them within 10 or 15 miles of any spot on the map. 1,600 miles. Roughly New
07:29York to Denver.
07:31Across open sea, in a stolen sailboat, navigated by men who had been starving for a year.
07:37Those two sergeants were Paul Marshall and Robert Spielman. At Melnick's suggestion, they were assigned to the
07:45coffee detail, as cooks for the work party. Think about what that gave the plan. A cook handles food
07:52all day. Nobody asks a cook why he's carrying it. And that brings us to the chickens. Not far from
08:00the fields,
08:00the Japanese kept a chicken farm. About 3,000 birds. For prisoners living on rice, it was the richest thing
08:08in sight. Spielman, McCoy, and Melnick began raiding it. They ran it like a military operation.
08:15Watchers were posted. And they set themselves a rule, which McCoy recorded with obvious pride.
08:21They made it a point of honor never to take fewer than two birds per raid. Now here is the
08:28number I
08:29promised you. Over three months, they took 133 chickens. But the figure that matters is a smaller
08:37one. The Japanese didn't notice anything was wrong until about 75 birds were gone. 75. Let that sink in.
08:46A farm run by the same army that searched prisoners for food lost 75 birds before anyone on the Japanese
08:56side registered a problem. And when they finally did, the raiders didn't stop. They kept going,
09:03working, as they put it, with infinitely more guile. Roughly 58 more birds vanished after the
09:11Japanese started looking. Keep that in your head, because it's the first glimpse of something this
09:17whole story turns on. A system that counts things doesn't see the things. It sees the count. And a
09:24count can absorb a remarkable amount of loss before it moves. The danger was real. Work parties were
09:32searched for forbidden food. And one of the men doing the searching was a Japanese lieutenant named
09:37Hosume. The prisoners had a name for him. The Crown Prince of Swat. He beat men personally.
09:46So what did the chickens buy? Some were eaten at the detail's noon meal. And that mattered more than it
09:53sounds. In March, after the Red Cross supplies ran out, the Japanese cut off the vegetables. And the
10:00prisoners were back on rice and thin soup. Men in that condition do not cross swamps. The rest of the
10:08birds became currency. Inside the camp, they were traded for quinine and sulfa drugs. Quinine for the
10:15malaria waiting in the swamp. Sulfa for the cuts and infections that kill men in the jungle as surely as
10:21bullets. Meanwhile, in the prison workshop, Lieutenant Leo Bolins was building a sextant. Melnick found an
10:29astronomy book. McCoy worked out star and sun tables and altitude corrections, and he kept a pocket watch
10:35for time. Months later, when he finally checked that watch against a radio signal, it was only 15 seconds off.
10:44Then, in early March, the plan doubled. Marine Captain Austin Schaffner came to McCoy and Melnick
10:51with an escape plan of his own. His group was Ed Dias, Sam Gratio, Leo Bolins, and two more Marines,
10:59Jack Hawkins and Mike Dobrovich. They had the nerve and the muscle. What they didn't have was a navigator.
11:06The two groups merged, and McCoy was offered command. The two guides came from the colony's
11:12Filipino convicts, Benigno de la Cruz and Victorio Jumarang. Both had been kept on at the prison
11:19to help supervise farm work. Notice that. Even the guides were part of the camp's daily routine.
11:26Then the ten Americans made a decision that tells you a great deal about them.
11:30They would bring in no other American prisoners. The point was not only that fewer people would know.
11:37Anyone the Japanese questioned afterward could honestly say he had known nothing.
11:43When a friend asked McCoy to take him along, McCoy said no. By the middle of March,
11:50they had ten men, two guides, stolen food, traded medicine, and a homemade sextant.
11:56What they didn't have was a way to get any of it outside the compound.
12:01Work parties going out could be searched, by men who beat prisoners for carrying forbidden food.
12:08So how do you move a whole expedition's worth of supplies past a sentry who is looking for exactly that?
12:16The answer they found came from the one thing that sentry wanted from them.
12:21Friday, March 26, 1943. Nine days before the gate.
12:26A bull cart creaks out toward the guardhouse. Driving it are two of the escapers,
12:31Captain Ed Dias and Major Stephen Melnick.
12:34In the bottom of the cart lies the escape.
12:37Food. Equipment.
12:39Over it, a load of small logs.
12:42And on the back, in plain sight,
12:44a burlap bag of star apples,
12:47a sweet tropical fruit from the colony's orchards,
12:50on its way to the Japanese quartermaster.
12:53The sentry at the guardhouse was fond of star apples,
12:56so he did what he always did.
12:58He took his usual rake-off from the bag,
13:00and he waved the cart on.
13:03That's how the escape left the camp.
13:05Not hidden from the guard,
13:07handed to him, with a tip.
13:10Put that image next to the chicken farm.
13:13With the chickens,
13:14the Japanese lost what they were counting,
13:16and didn't notice.
13:17With the cart,
13:18the sentry was actually looking,
13:20and what he saw was exactly what he expected to see.
13:23Plus, a little something for himself.
13:26The routine was paying him to wave it through,
13:28and he never knew he was being paid.
13:31The gear went into the edge of the jungle.
13:34The next day, Saturday, more followed.
13:37One account puts the main cache in a banana grove,
13:40near a shack in the fields
13:41where the plowing crew worked on Sundays.
13:44Canned corned beef.
13:47Bolos, the heavy Filipino machetes.
13:49Socks filled with rice.
13:52Dias handled another piece himself.
13:55He took Red Cross medical supplies
13:57from the camp hospital,
13:58and in their place,
13:59he left fruit as payment.
14:02Now look at how the two work details were built,
14:05because neither one was an accident.
14:07The plowing detail was a prized job.
14:11Outdoors, with the animals,
14:12and with better chances to snatch food.
14:15That made it hard to get onto,
14:17and harder to stay on.
14:19At one point,
14:20Hawkins and Dobrovich were pulled off it
14:22after a quarrel with other Americans
14:24over an onion-planting scheme.
14:26They had to plead to get back on.
14:29Picture it.
14:30Two Marines planning an escape
14:32through a swamp full of crocodiles,
14:34begging a fellow prisoner
14:35for their place back behind a pair of bulls.
14:38Schaffner worked the problem from the inside.
14:40The plowing crews were picked by Americans,
14:42so he arranged with the men who chose them
14:45to put the three Marines and Gratio
14:47on the Sunday shift.
14:48On Sundays,
14:50only four men tended the bulls,
14:52often under slack supervision.
14:54McCoy's half needed a reason of its own.
14:57So he went to the Japanese
14:58and asked permission for a work party
15:00to build a shed in the coffee fields.
15:02He offered to do it on Sundays,
15:04so as not to interfere with the normal work schedule.
15:07Think about that for a moment.
15:09He asked his captors
15:10to let him work on his day off,
15:12and presented it as a favor to them.
15:15They said yes.
15:17The route came from inside the colony, too.
15:20A Filipino convict
15:21who supervised the civilian inmates' farm work
15:24drew them a map
15:25showing two possible ways past the swamp.
15:28One followed an old railway line.
15:30The other was a footpath.
15:32They chose the footpath.
15:34The railway was exactly where anyone would look.
15:37The date was set for Sunday, March 28th.
15:40Then, at noon on Saturday, the day before,
15:44Lieutenant Hosume made an inspection.
15:46He came to Captain Schaffner's party.
15:49He opened Schaffner's bag and looked inside.
15:52In that bag was a bottle
15:54holding the entire quinine supply for the escape.
15:57Every dose they had traded chickens for.
15:59The only protection ten men would have
16:02against malaria in the swamp.
16:04The quinine was in plain view.
16:07Hosume was looking for forbidden food.
16:09He found no forbidden food.
16:12He slapped Schaffner's men around,
16:14and he moved on.
16:17Here's what I want you to notice.
16:19The most feared inspector in the camp
16:21looked straight at the most important thing
16:23the escapers owned,
16:24and didn't see it.
16:26Because it wasn't what the rule told him to look for.
16:29That's twice in two days
16:31that a Japanese guard
16:32has looked directly at this escape.
16:34It will not be the last time.
16:37That night, the luck turned.
16:39Word went through the barracks
16:40that Hosume had found forbidden food
16:42with one of the work parties.
16:44As a general punishment,
16:46all hands were ordered
16:47into the rice fields the next day.
16:50Sunday, the 28th.
16:53Escape day.
16:54No shed crew.
16:56No Sunday plowing.
16:58No way out.
17:00The escape was postponed by at least a week,
17:02and the gear stayed where it was,
17:05at the edge of the jungle,
17:06in the rain,
17:07where any patrol,
17:09any convict,
17:10any curious guard
17:12might stumble over it.
17:14Every day that week,
17:16the ten men went out to work
17:17knowing their food,
17:18their bolos,
17:19and their charts
17:20were lying somewhere out there.
17:22Every time a guard walked toward them,
17:24they wondered whether someone had found it.
17:27But the worst moment of that week
17:28didn't come from the cache.
17:30It came on Thursday,
17:32from a sentry in a tower
17:33and a hospital orderly
17:35holding a canteen of water.
17:36And it showed the escapers
17:38exactly what the Japanese meant
17:40when they said an American
17:41had been shot
17:42trying to escape.
17:44Thursday, April 1st, 1943.
17:47Three days before the gate.
17:50Just outside the stockade
17:51of the camp hospital,
17:53an American enlisted man
17:54named McPhee
17:55is digging kamotes,
17:57sweet potatoes,
17:58for the patient's diet.
18:00McPhee is a hospital orderly.
18:02He is not on any escape list.
18:04He knows nothing about any plan.
18:06It's very hot.
18:09McPhee calls to a buddy
18:10inside the stockade
18:11and asks for a canteen of water.
18:13The buddy passes it out to him.
18:16Up in a tower,
18:17a Japanese sentry shouts.
18:20McPhee does something
18:21that makes perfect sense to him.
18:23He pours a little of the water
18:24onto the ground
18:25to show the sentry
18:26it's only water.
18:28The sentry fires.
18:30McPhee is hit.
18:31He cries out,
18:33My God, don't shoot me again!
18:35The sentry puts
18:36two more bullets into him.
18:39Afterward,
18:39the Japanese announced
18:40that McPhee had been shot
18:42while trying to escape.
18:43They even expressed their regret.
18:46He had carried no food
18:47and no equipment.
18:49He had been holding a canteen.
18:52Now put that beside
18:53everything we've seen so far.
18:55A sentry who waves
18:56a cart full of escape gear
18:57through for a handful of fruit.
19:00An inspector who looks
19:01straight at a bottle of quinine
19:03and moves on.
19:04And a sentry who kills
19:06an unarmed orderly
19:07for pouring out water.
19:09These are not contradictions.
19:11They are the same system
19:13seen from two sides.
19:15A Japanese guard at Davao
19:17was not watching
19:17what a prisoner intended.
19:19He was watching
19:20whether a prisoner
19:21did something
19:22that didn't belong.
19:24McPhee did one
19:25small, strange thing
19:26in the wrong place
19:28at the wrong moment
19:29and it cost him his life.
19:32The ten escapers
19:33had spent three months
19:34making sure that nothing
19:35they did
19:36would ever look strange.
19:38Keep that thought.
19:39It's another piece of the answer,
19:41but it isn't the whole answer yet.
19:44The escapers watched it
19:45happen to McPhee
19:46and they took the lesson.
19:48In McCoy and Melnick's own account,
19:50there was no thought
19:51of turning back.
19:53They grew more cautious.
19:55They told no one else.
19:57And they waited.
19:58One of them later wrote
19:59that Friday and Saturday
20:00were the two longest days
20:02in my memory.
20:04Sunday, April 4th.
20:06McCoy got up early.
20:07He began hiding things
20:09on his body.
20:10His homemade charts,
20:11extra clothing,
20:13medicines.
20:14Into an inner pocket,
20:16very carefully,
20:16he slid three fragile handkerchiefs
20:19of piña cloth,
20:20the fine Philippine fabric
20:22woven from pineapple fiber.
20:24There was barely room
20:25under his clothes
20:26for his mosquito netting.
20:28An elderly American
20:29lieutenant colonel noticed.
20:31Where are you going
20:32with the mosquito netting?
20:34McCoy had his answer ready.
20:36This net?
20:37I'm going to wash it
20:38during the noon rest hour today.
20:39It's full of bed bugs again.
20:41And he added that he was
20:43taking part of his detail out
20:44to build a rain shelter
20:45in the coffee plantation.
20:47For the extra layers,
20:48there was another answer.
20:50And it was perfectly believable
20:51after a week like that one.
20:53We've been coming in
20:54soaked every night.
20:56Notice who McCoy
20:57was deceiving that morning.
20:59Not a Japanese guard.
21:01A fellow American.
21:02The plan required the escape
21:03to be invisible to everyone.
21:06Because anyone who knew
21:07could be made to talk.
21:09You've already seen
21:11what happened next.
21:12The count at the gate.
21:13The toothbrush.
21:14The salute.
21:15The coconut grove.
21:17So let's go past the grove.
21:20The two parties met
21:21at the hidden cache.
21:23In McCoy and Melnick's words,
21:25the equipment was
21:25now soggy from a week of rain
21:28and much of it useless.
21:30A week in the open
21:31had done what no Japanese patrol
21:33had managed.
21:34It had ruined part of the escape.
21:37And one of the guides
21:38wasn't there.
21:40They waited, as they put it,
21:41a fearful and impatient wait
21:44for more than an hour.
21:46Ten Americans crouched
21:48in wet jungle
21:49within reach of a prison farm,
21:51every minute adding to the chance
21:53that some work party
21:54or patrol would wander past.
21:56Then the rain came down.
21:58Hard.
22:00And finally,
22:01the guides appeared.
22:02By one account,
22:03it was about 10.30 in the morning
22:05when the group started out.
22:07Here's a detail that tells you
22:08how thin the margin really was.
22:10Of the two guides,
22:12only Victorio had ever made the journey
22:13through that jungle before.
22:15Within an hour,
22:16he had to admit he was lost.
22:18So the men did what McCoy
22:20had prepared them to do.
22:22They decided to travel
22:23wholly by compass.
22:25Soon they were in the swamp.
22:27Water to the knees.
22:29Coogan grass,
22:30with edges sharp enough to cut,
22:32growing higher than their heads.
22:34We had to hack our way every step.
22:38At one point,
22:39they realized they had been
22:40walking in circles.
22:41Stop for a moment
22:43and consider the position
22:44of these ten Americans
22:45by early afternoon.
22:46They were soaked,
22:48starved,
22:49lost,
22:50carrying ruined gear,
22:52and moving by compass
22:53through ground
22:54that had kept every prisoner in
22:56for ten years.
22:58And back at the colony,
22:59nothing had happened.
23:01No alarm,
23:02no search,
23:04no shots.
23:06On a Sunday,
23:07with a shed crew
23:08that had no sentry
23:09and a plowing crew of four
23:11under slack supervision,
23:13nobody had any reason
23:14to look for them yet.
23:15McCoy had figured
23:16they might have
23:17as much as eight hours
23:18before the Japanese
23:19discovered they were gone.
23:21He was close.
23:22At six o'clock that evening,
23:24the work details
23:25came back to the gate,
23:26and the guard
23:27with the chalkboard
23:27began to count.
23:29What happened
23:30in the next few minutes
23:30says more about how
23:31the Japanese saw this camp
23:33than anything else
23:34in the story.
23:35Six o'clock in the evening,
23:37Sunday,
23:37April 4th, 1943.
23:40The work details
23:41come in from the fields
23:42and form up at the gate,
23:44the way they have
23:45every evening
23:45since the Americans arrived.
23:47The guard counts.
23:49The number is wrong.
23:51So he does what any man
23:52in his position would do.
23:54He decides he has made a mistake.
23:56He counts again.
23:58The number is still wrong.
24:01He counts a third time.
24:03Think about what those
24:05three counts really mean.
24:07For the whole day,
24:08the only instrument in that camp
24:11that could have detected
24:12ten missing men
24:13was the count.
24:15Nobody had seen them go.
24:17Nobody had heard anything.
24:19The escape existed
24:21only as a difference
24:22between two numbers
24:23on a board.
24:24And even when the board
24:25finally showed it,
24:26the first instinct
24:28on the Japanese side
24:29was not that
24:30ten Americans had gone.
24:31It was that the counting
24:33had gone wrong.
24:35Then it sank in.
24:36Ten prisoners were gone
24:38from a colony
24:39nobody had ever escaped.
24:42The Japanese commander
24:43was furious.
24:44He accused the prisoners
24:45who were left
24:46of helping the escapers
24:48and he threatened them
24:49with death.
24:50Guards beat the American
24:52camp commander.
24:53They beat the barracks leaders.
24:55They beat the men
24:56who had slept beside
24:57the escapers
24:58trying to get information
24:59out of them.
25:00And here,
25:01the decision you heard
25:02about earlier paid off.
25:04Those men could not give up
25:06what they did not know.
25:08The ten had kept the plan
25:10from every other American
25:11in the camp
25:12for exactly this night.
25:14It didn't spare anyone
25:16a beating,
25:17but it meant there was
25:18nothing to beat out of them.
25:20What nobody in that compound
25:22knew yet
25:22was the thing
25:23everyone feared most.
25:26Back at Kavanatuan,
25:28an escape could mean
25:29nine men shot
25:30for every man who ran.
25:33Would that rule
25:34be applied here?
25:35Hold that question.
25:37We'll come back to it.
25:39Out in the swamp,
25:40the ten Americans
25:41had no idea
25:42any of this was happening.
25:44That first night,
25:45they found a spot
25:46where the water
25:47was only ankle deep.
25:48Every one of them
25:49was close to exhaustion,
25:50and they slept,
25:51in McCoy and Melnick's words,
25:53the sleep of the dead.
25:55They woke to find themselves
25:57half-floating in their beds.
25:59The water had risen
26:00in the night.
26:01On the second morning,
26:03McCoy woke up sick.
26:05The man who was supposed
26:06to navigate them
26:071,600 miles
26:08could barely walk.
26:10The swamp did not let up.
26:13Two men at a time
26:14took the lead,
26:15hacking at the undergrowth
26:16with bolos
26:17while the others rested,
26:18then rotating.
26:20The compass kept them
26:21on a northeasterly course.
26:23It was the only thing that did.
26:26By the second evening,
26:27men were breaking.
26:28Some were sick.
26:30Some were delirious.
26:32All of them were starved
26:33and soaked,
26:34and nobody knew
26:35how far there was still to go.
26:37Ed Dias turned to Sam Gratio
26:39and asked him
26:40to lead them in prayer.
26:42Gratio was a Catholic.
26:44He knelt in the swamp
26:45and began the Memorare,
26:47an old prayer
26:48to the Virgin Mary,
26:49one sentence at a time.
26:51The others repeated
26:53each line after him.
26:54The historian John Lukacs,
26:55who reconstructed this night,
26:57wrote that the effect
26:58of Gratio's words
26:59was instantaneous,
27:01calming,
27:02and curative.
27:04Gratio himself
27:05said it more simply,
27:06I thought a miracle
27:07had occurred.
27:09That same night,
27:10around eight o'clock,
27:12they heard gunfire,
27:13rifles and machine guns,
27:15two or three kilometers away,
27:17in the direction
27:17they had come from.
27:19Remember the map
27:20and the two routes
27:21past the swamp,
27:22the old railway line,
27:24and the footpath.
27:25They had chosen the footpath
27:27because the railway
27:28was where anyone would look.
27:30Later, they learned
27:31what that gunfire had been.
27:33A Japanese search party
27:35had gone looking for them
27:36along the railway.
27:38Filipino guerrillas had met it
27:39and driven it back.
27:41Somewhere along the way,
27:43the escapers also came across
27:44what that search party
27:46had left behind.
27:47The remains of food
27:48it had eaten.
27:49The Japanese had searched
27:51exactly where the plans
27:52said they would.
27:54On the third day,
27:55Melnick cut his left hand
27:57badly with a bolo
27:58while clearing a path.
27:59The water got deeper.
28:00At times,
28:01it reached their armpits.
28:03The jungle was full of leeches,
28:05which moved through the water,
28:07as McCoy and Melnick
28:08described it,
28:08with a jackknife motion.
28:11By the end of the fourth day,
28:13by their own reckoning,
28:14they had come
28:15not more than 12 miles
28:16from their escape point.
28:18Let that number land
28:20for a second.
28:2112 miles in four days.
28:24About three miles a day.
28:25The kind of distance
28:26a healthy man walks in an hour.
28:28And these were the men
28:30planning to sail
28:301,600 miles to Australia.
28:34Then the jungle
28:35opened onto a trail.
28:36And on that trail,
28:38they met a Filipino
28:39who agreed to take them
28:40to the guerrillas.
28:41The guerrillas had been
28:42watching them already.
28:43Two of the men
28:45Dias had glimpsed
28:46among the trees
28:46were guerrillas.
28:48One of them confessed
28:49something that must have
28:50made Dias go cold.
28:52He had taken him
28:53for a Japanese soldier.
28:55He had aimed carefully
28:57at Dias
28:57and pulled the trigger.
28:59The cartridge,
29:00or the firing pin,
29:02failed.
29:03That's how close it came.
29:05A captain who had
29:06survived Bataan,
29:07the Death March,
29:08and a year of prison camps
29:10came within one
29:11bad cartridge
29:11of being killed
29:12by his own allies
29:13four days into freedom.
29:16But the guerrillas brought
29:17something more valuable
29:18than safety.
29:19They brought news
29:20from the other side.
29:22They knew what the Japanese
29:23believed had happened
29:24at Davao.
29:25And the Japanese explanation
29:27was so far from the truth
29:29that it tells you,
29:30better than anything else,
29:32why the guards
29:33had never seen
29:34ten Americans
29:34walk out of their camp.
29:35What the guerrillas told them
29:37was this.
29:38The Japanese believed
29:39the ten Americans
29:40had not run away at all.
29:42They believed the escapers
29:44had gone out
29:44to round up guerrillas
29:45and come back
29:46to attack the prison.
29:48Read that again,
29:49slowly,
29:50because it may be
29:52the most revealing sentence
29:53in this entire story.
29:55Ten starving men,
29:57one of them sick,
29:58one with a gashed hand,
30:00wading through armpit-deep water
30:02at three miles a day,
30:04and the Japanese command
30:05at Davao
30:06saw an assault force.
30:08Their response matched
30:10what they thought
30:10they were facing.
30:12About 200 reinforcements,
30:14in McCoy and Melnick's words,
30:16were hastily added
30:17to the prison garrison.
30:19Remember the size
30:20of that garrison,
30:22around 250 men.
30:24200 more nearly doubled it
30:26to guard against an attack
30:28that was never coming,
30:29by men who were trying
30:30with everything they had
30:32to get as far
30:33from that prison
30:33as they could.
30:35And from the Japanese side,
30:37you can almost see the logic.
30:39Mindanao was not quiet.
30:41The guerrillas
30:42who were now feeding
30:43the escapers
30:44had recently ambushed
30:45a Japanese party
30:46of more than 80 men
30:47with only 16 fighters,
30:49and killed 10.
30:51McCoy had already noticed
30:53that the Japanese
30:53would not go into
30:54the Philippine jungle voluntarily,
30:56unless they were armed
30:57and in force.
30:59To a garrison
31:00that thought that way,
31:01the jungle
31:02was where the enemy lived.
31:04The camp
31:05was where prisoners lived.
31:07Ten prisoners
31:08crossing over
31:09into the jungle
31:09could only mean
31:10the enemy was growing.
31:12What the Japanese
31:13could not picture
31:14was the simpler truth,
31:15that ten prisoners
31:17had used the camp's
31:18own routine
31:19to walk out
31:20and were heading
31:21not toward the guerrillas' war,
31:22but toward Australia.
31:24Now go back
31:26to the colony,
31:27because the men
31:28who paid for that escape
31:29were the ones
31:30still inside it.
31:31About a week
31:32after the escape,
31:33the Japanese commander,
31:35Major Maeda,
31:36called the prisoners together.
31:38Everyone knew
31:39what the rule
31:39at Kavanatuan had been.
31:41One man escapes,
31:43nine men die.
31:45Here,
31:46ten had gone.
31:47Every man in that assembly
31:49could do the arithmetic.
31:51Maeda announced a sentence.
31:53Then he began
31:54calling out names.
31:56The American camp commander
31:57and his assistants,
31:58the barracks leaders,
32:00the men who had slept
32:01next to the escapers.
32:03One by one,
32:04they were ordered forward.
32:06They were not shot.
32:08According to the account
32:10of these events
32:10in the history
32:11Saints at War
32:12in the Philippines,
32:13about 560 prisoners,
32:16roughly a quarter
32:17of the camp,
32:17were moved
32:18into a special compound
32:19of wood
32:20and wire mesh cages.
32:22Anyone who had been
32:23close to the escapers
32:24was in there.
32:26Their sentence
32:27was one month.
32:28They were directed
32:29to reflect their faults,
32:32to spend their days
32:33in meditation
32:34of the past incident.
32:36One prisoner
32:37described them as
32:38like caged animals
32:40in a zoo.
32:41And then the line
32:42that the whole camp
32:43had been holding
32:44its breath for.
32:46There would be
32:47no summary executions.
32:49Nobody can say
32:50for certain why.
32:52The shooting squad rule
32:53had never been
32:54formally announced
32:55at Davao,
32:56and it had never
32:57been applied
32:57consistently anywhere.
32:59But you should know
33:00what the ten Americans
33:01did not.
33:02Their comrades
33:03would live.
33:04They would pay
33:05in other ways.
33:06The one Japanese lieutenant
33:08the prisoners
33:09had considered
33:09somewhat friendly
33:10was removed.
33:12The guards
33:13grew more hostile,
33:14and beatings
33:15came faster
33:16for smaller things.
33:17Hours in the rice fields
33:19went up.
33:20Searches for food
33:21got tougher,
33:22and punishments
33:23harsher.
33:24Rations were cut again.
33:26But look closely
33:27at the next two changes,
33:29because they matter
33:30more than they seem.
33:31The Japanese
33:32stopped the work details
33:34to the fruit orchards
33:35and vegetable gardens,
33:36the small,
33:37quiet crews
33:38where the old
33:39and the sick
33:40had worked,
33:40often without a century.
33:42And they abolished
33:43the camp's
33:44religious services
33:45and its Sunday
33:46evening entertainment.
33:48The orchards.
33:49The gardens.
33:51Sunday.
33:52Do you see
33:53what the Japanese
33:54had done?
33:55Without ever saying it,
33:57they had pointed
33:58straight at the hole.
33:59The escape
34:00had not come
34:00through the wire
34:01or the gate
34:02or the guards.
34:03It had come
34:04through the soft,
34:06familiar,
34:07unwatched parts
34:08of the routine.
34:09The parts that
34:10had made camp life
34:11a little less
34:12like slavery.
34:14So the Japanese
34:15cut them away.
34:17One account of the camp
34:18after the escape
34:19sums it up
34:20in a single sentence.
34:22Davao had suddenly
34:23reverted
34:24to a cruel
34:25slave labor camp.
34:27So now you have
34:28both halves
34:29of the Japanese reaction.
34:30Two hundred more soldiers
34:32to guard against
34:33an enemy outside.
34:35And an end
34:36to the routine
34:37to close the gap
34:38inside.
34:40The first response
34:41was aimed
34:42at something
34:42that did not exist.
34:44The second
34:45was aimed
34:45at the truth.
34:46But only after
34:48the truth
34:48had walked
34:49out of the gate.
34:50Meanwhile,
34:52deep in Mindanao,
34:53the ten Americans
34:54were alive
34:55and still running.
34:57Japanese patrol boats
34:58with three-inch guns
34:59were working the coast.
35:01At one point,
35:02a Japanese landing
35:03of about 200 men
35:05came ashore,
35:06with five fighter planes
35:07covering it.
35:08The escapers
35:09kept moving north,
35:10toward the guerrilla forces
35:11in the northern part
35:12of the island,
35:13and toward a radio
35:14that could reach
35:15the outside world.
35:16And somewhere along the way,
35:18McCoy and Melnick
35:19began to work out
35:20for themselves
35:20how they had done it.
35:23Why the Japanese
35:24had never seen them go.
35:26They would eventually
35:27write their answer down.
35:29It is honest,
35:31it is reasonable,
35:32and it is only half right.
35:34May 6th, 1943.
35:37A guerrilla radio station
35:38in northern Mindanao.
35:40It is exactly one year
35:42since Corregidor surrendered.
35:44Lieutenant Commander
35:45Melvin McCoy,
35:46a month out of Davao,
35:48sends a message
35:49to Allied headquarters
35:50in Australia.
35:51It lists the escapers
35:53by service and rank,
35:54all captured on Bataan
35:56and Corregidor.
35:57And it ends with a line
35:59nobody outside the Philippines
36:00had heard before.
36:01Have extensive info
36:03regarding brutalities
36:05and atrocities
36:06with extremely heavy
36:07death toll
36:08to war prisoners.
36:10In Brisbane,
36:11the intelligence staff
36:13didn't believe it.
36:14Ten men
36:15out of a Japanese prison camp
36:17was too much to accept.
36:19Some suspected
36:20a Japanese trick.
36:22So an American officer,
36:23Lieutenant Colonel
36:24Allison Inde,
36:26radioed back questions
36:27that only the real
36:28McCoy could answer.
36:30The right answers
36:31came back.
36:33Hold that moment
36:34up against Davao.
36:35In Brisbane,
36:37an American staff
36:38wouldn't accept
36:39even the truth
36:40until they had tested it
36:41against the man.
36:42At Davao,
36:43a Japanese guard
36:44had accepted a number
36:46on a chalkboard
36:46as proof that ten men
36:48were exactly
36:49where they belonged.
36:51Which brings us
36:52back to the question
36:52this whole story
36:53has been building toward.
36:55McCoy and Melnick
36:56did give their own
36:57explanation.
36:58They wrote that
36:59perhaps one reason
37:01they were not discovered
37:02was that the Japanese guards
37:03were not the highest type
37:05of enemy soldier
37:06they had met.
37:08Many were former
37:09white-collar workers
37:10and Formosan reservists.
37:12Japan,
37:13they suspected,
37:14needed its seasoned
37:15fighters elsewhere.
37:17That's probably true,
37:18as far as it goes.
37:20But test it against
37:21what you've seen.
37:23The guards at Davao
37:24were not asleep.
37:25A sentry in a tower
37:27put three bullets
37:28into an orderly
37:29for pouring water
37:30out of a canteen.
37:32Hosume opened bags
37:34and beat men
37:34for carrying fruit.
37:36These were not
37:37careless men.
37:38They were alert.
37:40The question
37:41is what they were alert to.
37:44Here is the answer.
37:45The camp's security
37:47rested on one belief.
37:48The swamp
37:50held everyone.
37:52Nobody had escaped
37:52in ten years.
37:53So a guard's real job
37:55wasn't to stop and escape.
37:56It was to make sure
37:57every prisoner
37:58was where he was
37:59supposed to be.
38:00Count the details out.
38:02Count them at noon.
38:04Count them back at six.
38:05Search them for food.
38:07Shoot anything
38:08that doesn't belong.
38:09The Americans
38:10never tried to beat
38:11that system.
38:12They fed it.
38:14Think back
38:14through every step.
38:16The coffee detail
38:17was an assignment
38:18the Japanese had handed out.
38:19The shed was a job
38:20the Japanese had approved
38:22on a day McCoy
38:23had offered to them
38:24as a favor.
38:25The plowing crew
38:26was picked the normal way
38:27by the normal men.
38:29The cart carried
38:30the normal fruit
38:30to the normal quartermaster
38:32and the sentry
38:33took his normal share.
38:34The quinine sat in a bag
38:36being searched for food
38:37and food was all
38:38the inspector was there to find.
38:40On the road,
38:42the sentry got a salute.
38:43At the gate,
38:44the guard got exactly
38:45what he expected,
38:46a work detail forming up
38:48the way it did
38:49every morning.
38:50So when that guard
38:51counted ich, ni, san, she
38:53and chalked the number
38:54on the board,
38:55he wasn't failing
38:57to see the escape.
38:58He was certifying it.
39:00From that moment
39:02until six o'clock,
39:03the camp's own record
39:05said ten Americans
39:06were out on approved work.
39:09Anyone who checked
39:10the record
39:10found nothing wrong.
39:12The chalkboard
39:13that should have caught them
39:14became their alibi.
39:16That is why the guards
39:18never saw
39:18ten Americans walk out.
39:20Everything the guards saw
39:22was something
39:22they had already approved.
39:25And there is the other half,
39:27the half the Japanese
39:28showed us themselves.
39:29When ten men
39:30were finally missing,
39:32the Japanese saw gorillas
39:33and an attack
39:34on the prison.
39:35They expected an escape
39:37to look desperate.
39:38They had just shot a man
39:39for one odd movement.
39:41What they never pictured
39:42was an escape
39:43that looked like staff work.
39:44A Navy navigator,
39:46a sextant made
39:47in the prison workshop,
39:49cooks,
39:50quartermasters,
39:51two separate cover stories,
39:52a chosen route
39:53and a chosen decoy,
39:55and a rule of total secrecy
39:57to protect the men
39:58left behind.
40:01A Navy officer,
40:02an Army coast artilleryman,
40:04Army Air Force's pilots,
40:06Marines,
40:07and two sergeants,
40:08running it as one operation
40:10while they were starving.
40:12The guards were watching prisoners.
40:14What they were up against
40:15was an American staff.
40:17Two months after the radio message,
40:20on the night of July 9, 1943,
40:23the submarine USS Trout
40:24surfaced in Pagadian Bay
40:26off Mindanao's Moro Gulf.
40:29McCoy, Melnick, and Dias
40:31climbed aboard.
40:32With them went
40:33the guerrilla supply officer,
40:35Lieutenant Commander Charles Parsons,
40:37and Charles Smith,
40:39the man whose compass
40:40had found the rendezvous.
40:41Most of the others
40:43stayed behind
40:43to fight with the guerrillas.
40:45Schaffner became
40:45an operations officer
40:47in a guerrilla division
40:48and would not reach Australia
40:49until November.
40:51At five minutes past six,
40:53on the evening of Friday,
40:54July 30th,
40:56McCoy, Melnick, and Dias
40:57walked into General Douglas MacArthur's
40:59office in Brisbane.
41:01MacArthur would pin
41:02the Distinguished Service Cross
41:04on each of them,
41:05and he promised them
41:06that the Japanese
41:07would pay for that
41:08humiliation and suffering.
41:10MacArthur meant to tell
41:11the world,
41:12right away.
41:13Years later,
41:14he remembered it this way.
41:16I directed the issuance
41:18of the story
41:18to the press.
41:20Then came the sentence
41:21that followed it.
41:23But that very day,
41:24Washington forbade
41:25the release
41:26of any of the details.
41:28Ten Americans
41:29had just walked out
41:30of a Japanese system
41:31that counted everything.
41:33Now they had walked
41:34into a system
41:35of their own government,
41:36and getting their story
41:38out of it
41:38would take longer
41:39than getting out
41:40of Davao.
41:40For the next six months,
41:42the story of Davao
41:43was a military secret.
41:45Ed Dias was sent home
41:46and kept out of sight.
41:48In September 1943,
41:51he was recovering
41:51at Ashford General Hospital
41:53in White Sulphur Springs,
41:55West Virginia.
41:55In October,
41:58General George Marshall
41:59wrote in a secret memo
42:00that the public's reaction
42:02to the atrocity story
42:03should be directed
42:04along carefully
42:05thought-out lines.
42:07Sam Gratio
42:08remembered it more simply.
42:10I was reminded repeatedly
42:12that my past
42:13was a military secret.
42:15Dias wanted to fly again.
42:17On December 22, 1943,
42:20he took off
42:21from Grand Central Airport
42:22in Burbank, California,
42:24in a P-38,
42:26an engine caught fire
42:27on takeoff.
42:28He could have bailed out.
42:30Instead,
42:31he stayed with the aircraft,
42:33steering it away
42:33from the houses below,
42:35and was killed
42:36when it came down.
42:37He was 27.
42:39The man who had walked
42:41the death march,
42:42survived Davao,
42:43and crossed the swamp
42:44never saw his story
42:46in print.
42:47It came out
42:48a few weeks later,
42:49in late January 1944.
42:52The Chicago Tribune
42:53called it
42:54The Biggest Bombshell
42:55Since Pearl Harbor.
42:57The day after
42:58the first account appeared,
43:00a young woman
43:01named Margaret Truman
43:02stood at a shipyard
43:03to christen a new battleship,
43:05the USS Missouri,
43:07and said,
43:08It should avenge
43:09the heroes of Bataan.
43:11On February 7th,
43:14Life magazine
43:14ran the escapers' account
43:16under the title
43:17Death Was a Part of Our Life.
43:19The magazine printed photographs
43:21of nine of the ten Americans.
43:24Sergeant Paul Marshall
43:25was left out by mistake.
43:27And in that same last week
43:29of January,
43:30back on Mindanao,
43:32Leo Bolins was killed.
43:34He had chosen to stay
43:36and fight
43:36with the guerrillas.
43:38The man who built
43:39a sextant
43:40in a Japanese prison workshop
43:42never left the island
43:43he had escaped across.
43:45The others kept going.
43:47Austin Schaffner,
43:49the Marine
43:49whose voice shook at the gate,
43:52led a battalion ashore
43:53at Peleliu
43:53in September 1944
43:55and was wounded there.
43:57In May 1945,
43:58on Okinawa,
43:59he took command
44:00of another battalion.
44:02He retired a brigadier general
44:04and died in Tennessee
44:05in 1999.
44:08Jack Hawkins,
44:09the lieutenant
44:10in the battered sun helmet
44:11who felt as if
44:12he were wearing prison stripes,
44:14fought on Okinawa too.
44:16I did my part
44:18in making it happen,
44:19he said of the victory.
44:20He outlived
44:21every other man
44:22who walked out of Davao
44:23that morning.
44:25He was the last of the ten
44:26when he died
44:28on May 17,
44:292013,
44:30at 96.
44:32In 1957,
44:35the airbase
44:35at Abilene, Texas
44:36was renamed
44:37for Ed Dias.
44:38It still carries his name.
44:41Now go back
44:43one last time
44:43to where this started.
44:45Sunday,
44:46April 4,
44:471943.
44:49A gate
44:50in the jungle
44:50of Mindanao.
44:52A Japanese guard
44:53with a chalkboard
44:54counting men out
44:55the way he did
44:56every morning.
44:57Ichi,
44:59Ni,
45:00San,
45:01Shi.
45:02He saw
45:03every one of them.
45:04He looked at their faces,
45:07counted their bodies,
45:08and wrote their number down.
45:10He was not careless,
45:12and he was not blind.
45:14He was doing exactly
45:15what the system
45:16asked of him.
45:17The system asked
45:18whether these men
45:19were where they were
45:20supposed to be.
45:21And for three months,
45:22ten Americans
45:23had worked to make sure
45:24the answer was
45:24always yes.
45:27The guards never saw
45:28ten Americans walk out,
45:29because the Americans
45:31made their escape
45:31look like obedience.
45:33Every step they took
45:35was one the camp
45:36had already approved.
45:37That's the trick.
45:39And it is only
45:40half the story.
45:41The other half
45:42is what it was for.
45:44Three months
45:45of stolen chickens,
45:46a homemade sextant,
45:48and borrowed Sundays,
45:49a swamp that nearly
45:50broke them,
45:51and a prayer
45:52in the dark.
45:53all so that
45:54one radio message
45:55could reach the world.
45:57That American prisoners
45:59were dying in the Philippines,
46:01and someone
46:01had to know.
46:03Ten Americans
46:04walked out
46:05under a guard's eyes,
46:06and they carried
46:07that message
46:08home.
46:10Thank you for watching
46:11this one all the way
46:12to the end.
46:13If this story
46:13meant something to you,
46:15please hit like.
46:16It's the simplest way
46:17to help a story like this
46:18find the people
46:19who should hear it.
46:20And if you want
46:21more of them,
46:22subscribe and turn on
46:23the bell so you'll know
46:24when the next one comes out.
46:26Tell us in the comments
46:27where you're watching from,
46:28and if your father,
46:29grandfather,
46:30or uncle
46:30served in the Second World War,
46:32whether with the American
46:34forces on Bataan
46:35or Corregidor,
46:36or in any Allied service,
46:38write his name
46:39and his unit below.
46:41Men like the American soldiers,
46:43sailors, airmen,
46:45and Marines in this story
46:46deserve to be remembered
46:47by name.

Recommended