00:26Sandra Aguinaldo
00:32Isang certified public accountant at dating compliance officer ng Anti-Money Laundering Council o AMLAC,
00:39si Atty. Rainer de la Fuente, ang ikapitong witness ng depensa.
00:43Sa pagtatanong ng depensa, ipinunto ang pagiging confidential ng mga bank records at hindi raw basta-basta pwedeng ilabas sa
00:52publiko.
00:53Tulad daw ng bank records si Vice President Sara Duterte at asawang si Attorney Manz Carpio na inilabas ng AMLAC
01:01sa House Committee on Justice.
01:03What is the propriety of aggregating confidential data from the CTRs and STRs and disclosing them to the public?
01:12Pag mga ganyang sinishare na information, may pamantayan, meron hong rules na nilalagay ang AMLAC as to how the information
01:21should be used and for what purpose.
01:25Nagpakita ang depensa ng video mula sa impeachment trial ni Supreme Court Chief Justice Renato Corona noong 2012.
01:35Gaya ng opinyo noon ni dating Senadora Miriam Defensor Santiago tungkol sa pag-withdraw ng ilang articles of impeachment ng
01:42prosecution at confidentiality ng bank account ni Corona.
01:46Kaya yung sinasabi niyo? Panangalo na kami dito sa tatlo. Kami yung magdesisyon niyan, hindi kayo. Agayabang niyo.
01:53Pero di na ito pinatapos ni Presiding Officer Jesus Codero.
01:58Ipinakita rin ang pahayag ni Corona na dahil raw sa maliumanong akusasyon na sira ang kanyang pangalan at apektado ang
02:06kanyang pamilya.
02:07I do not see the relevance of the alleged persecution experienced by the former Chief Justice about his alleged persecution,
02:17except that it is an appeal to emotion that I believe has no place in this impeachment trial.
02:23Hindi ito nagustuhan ng ilang Senator Judges.
02:26Pagpahingahin na po natin yung namayapa. That is a different case. This is a different case. This is a different
02:35set of senators.
02:37You're in a short lease, Attorney Mark.
02:39Diniscuss yung bank records, credit card records. I just appeal for a little bit of leeway for them to be
02:48able to serve their client well.
02:51Tinalakay din ng depensa ang ilang punto ng report ng forensic expert na witness sa prosecution na si Attorney Alexander
02:58Cabrera na nagsabing merong mahigit 800 milyon pesos na unexplained wealth si VP Sara.
03:05Isa rito ang tukos sa Gencorp, kumpanyang idineklara ni VP Sara sa kanyang salen pero di raw idineklara ang kinita
03:12niya mula rito.
03:13How would you characterize a report po that uses conjectures?
03:18Well, we cannot base, especially if it concerns financial investigation, hindi hulang basis sa conjectures. Dapat po, ito ay may
03:29facts.
03:29Para rin po sa mga publiko, ano po ba yung conjectures sa Filipino, if you know?
03:34Sa aking kong paghalang, ito ay mga haka-haka.
03:38Ipinakita rin ng abogado ng BICE ang salen ni Pangulong Bongbong Marcos na final noong 2023 at 2024 na nagpapakita
03:47raw na nagdeklara rin ito ng business interest.
03:51Tumaas din daw ang net worth nito sa pagdaan ng ilan taon.
03:55So, there's a portion po doon na business interest and financial connection.
03:59So, si PBBM listed two. One is Araka Resources Corporation.
04:06And then the other one is El Paraiso Farms Incorporated.
04:10As a financial investigator, what comments do you have on the financial and business interest portion?
04:16This portion po of PBBM sale.
04:18As far as I can remember, this is a harmless information.
04:23From P960,000 in a year, naging P1.1 billion.
04:28And then after another year, nag P200 million increase na naman.
04:33Naging P1.3 billion.
04:35Almost yearly, P200 million increase in the salen.
04:39Kailangan mabusising investigahan muna yan before we can make a conclusion based on this salens alone.
04:47Ilang oras nang nagbibigay ng testimonya ang witness ng depensa, nang tumayo si Sen. Rafi Tulfo.
04:53Is he a super witness, omni-witness?
04:56Ano ba klaseng witness nang pinapresent ng defense?
04:59Pati ba naman pati Amitchi Kurey?
05:02Nakakantok na.
05:04Parang hindi ka panipaniwala.
05:05Parang binubola lang tayo nito.
05:06Tito mo, nakangitinga siya.
05:07Kaya, smile means yes.
05:09Anyway, Mr. Presiding Officer, put him in a short leash.
05:12Na babother po ako, ginawong Pangulo, at naaalarma na hindi po siya ang DOJ, hindi po siya ang ombudsman, lalo
05:22na hindi po siya ang parte ng korte para magbigay po ng binding legal conclusions.
05:28He seems to be an expert in all already.
05:32But these are basic concepts and interpretations of the law which the court can and will do on its own.
05:37Given that we can and have taken judicial notice, especially of the constitutional and other legal provisions,
05:45especially given that he is not presented nor was he qualified as a constitutional expert.
05:52Paliwanag naman ng witness, yung sinasabi lang ng batas ang batayan niya.
05:56Hindi rin daw niya nakita ang mga confidential document kugnay kay VP Sara
06:01at maging pag-aaral ng expert witness ng prosecution.
06:05Dahilan para questionin ng ilang senador, ang kakayanan niyang basagin ang report ng isang financial forensic expert.
06:13Mr. Witness, any documents provided to you before appearing here?
06:20None-year-onor.
06:22Were any of these shown to you?
06:24None-year-onor.
06:25Kung hindi naman niya po nakita pala, mga dokumento, STRs, CTRs, what good is it?
06:32Para anong titistigon niya?
06:34Base lang ko sa batas, maaari ko na akong sagutin kung ano yung, kung nasa, na ito ba ay lawful
06:41or hindi.
06:42Si Lady Justice o yung babaeng Gustisya ay bulag nakatakip ang mata.
06:47Kasi hindi kinakailangan nabasahin ang bawat dokumento, alamin ang mga personalidad, dahil pantay-pantay.
06:55Personally, I would like to hear the thoughts and opinions of our witness.
07:02Sa pagtatapos ng presentasyon ng witness, ipinunto ng depensa na ang burden of proof para mapatunayan na may unexplained wealth
07:11ang bise ay nasa prosekusyon.
07:14At beyond reasonable doubt daw dapat ang batayan sa paghahatol dito.
07:19Sandra Aguinaldo na Katuto, 24 Horas.