• 18 minutes ago
Indian politicians debated domestic issues overseas focusing on economic data, governance, and national reputation.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Let's debate and discuss and let's try and understand what is the strategy with our politicians talking about India's internal
00:06politics on foreign soil.
00:07Joining me from the Bharatiya Janata Party, the party has been all guns blazing against Rahul Gandhi.
00:14BJP National Spokesperson Sanju Verma is joining us.
00:17Also the party that's expectedly defending their leader, Bhavya Narsimha Murthy, Congress National Spokesperson.
00:23And he's been a former senior journalist. He's joining us as an author, political analyst, Ashutosh as well.
00:30Let's start with Congress. Bhavya, help me understand this.
00:33Why would a leader of opposition of the country in the Lok Sabha, senior leader of the opposition party,
00:39consistently speak about these issues of India's internal politics, realities or defaming is subjective.
00:45But speaking about it on foreign soil, if it is not about asking for foreign actors to intervene, what else
00:52is it?
00:55So the problem is where he spoke or about what he spoke?
01:00Both.
01:00I just want to be sure before I answer.
01:02Both.
01:02Both.
01:03Okay.
01:04Starting with what he spoke, he stated facts from government agencies.
01:11Whether it is about inflation, the WPI inflation is 22% in October.
01:1912% in October, which was 11% in September.
01:24He's speaking about the price hikes, which is actually affecting the people of India.
01:30All right.
01:31Not just that.
01:32The top 1% of India's population is actually holding 40% of its wealth.
01:38And it is actually, the national income is 22.6% of national income has been held by top 1%.
01:46And I don't see anything wrong in what he spoke.
01:51Although now, coming to the point of where he spoke.
01:55Yes.
01:56Here, I would like to make two points.
01:58You know, I am an alumni of Columbia University and the same school, School of International and Public Affairs.
02:07There, the master's degree is public administration, where we, you know, prepare ourselves to be policy analysts and experts and
02:16policymakers.
02:17When you go there, and it is not just one country he is speaking in.
02:21Let me tell you, the class consists, during my time, it consisted of students from 89 nationals.
02:28People who are passionate about, there we just not study about India or America.
02:32We study about every country.
02:33The economy of every country, the politics of every country.
02:37All right.
02:37The second point is, when Narendra Modi can stand on a political platform in America and say that he's ashamed
02:45of India.
02:45India, you expect a leader of opposition not to speak about the government's inefficiency.
02:53Although, Mr. Gandhi did not speak anything.
02:54What comment are you referring to when he said…
02:56Let me finish.
02:57No, no.
02:58I'm just asking, what comment are you referring to about PM Modi saying he's ashamed of India?
03:01Oh, PM Modi has said he was ashamed of being an Indian before 2014.
03:0514.
03:07Yeah, he has said that.
03:08Okay, so you're saying it's the same.
03:10Mr. Gandhi has only said, and Mr. Gandhi has never spoken about India.
03:14The way BJP is portraying, BJP is a political party.
03:18BJP is not India.
03:20BJP is at the center forming a government today.
03:24They are not there forever.
03:25They cannot identify themselves as India.
03:28India is a country.
03:30Because Rahul Gandhi loves India, he's speaking for India and against every corruption that is happening here.
03:37Okay, point, point.
03:37And the inefficiency of the government.
03:40So, please do not term this as he's speaking against the country.
03:42Okay, let the BJP respond to that.
03:45Sanjeev, you heard.
03:46What was wrong, what he said, where he said it.
03:49It should be seen as common and normal.
03:52And after all, he's speaking against BJP government, not India.
03:57You know, Pooja, I'm an economist.
04:00You know, by education.
04:01I've worked in one of the world's biggest global investment banks, JP Morgan.
04:06I've served in desks across the United States of America, UK, Hong Kong, Australia.
04:11So, I know a lot more than just textbook economics.
04:15You know, I've been a high-profile investment banker, if that helps.
04:18Now, let me tell you something.
04:19And this is what your audience needs to know.
04:22Rahul Gandhi was spewing gibberish and vicious lies.
04:26From Fragile 5, today, India last quarter grew at 7.8%.
04:31In the September quarter, we are expected to have a GDP growth of 7.7%.
04:36And let's not talk about wholesale inflation.
04:39Between 2023 and 2025, the wholesale inflation was negative.
04:44And at that time, Congress, Darbaris used to come on television channels and say,
04:48oh, wholesale inflation is not the correct yardstick.
04:50It is retail inflation.
04:52So, let me tell you, between May and October, average retail inflation is 4.8%.
04:59The fiscal deficit today is 4.4%.
05:02Under Congress, it was 6.7%.
05:04The current account deficit today is less than 1%.
05:07Under Congress, it was 5.9%.
05:10Forex reserves under Congress were $287 billion.
05:14Today, it is $720 billion.
05:17And guess what?
05:18You want to reveal the source also, Sanju.
05:20Where are you quoting this from?
05:21Pooja, Pooja, I heard her.
05:24You did not interject.
05:26I need my time.
05:26You can then question me.
05:27Sure.
05:28All these data points.
05:30Can I please, you are number one, Sanju Verma.
05:32Please hold your horses.
05:33Let Sanju respond.
05:34Yes, go ahead.
05:34Yes.
05:35I don't know why she gets so rattled and starts smiling in a stupid manner without having correct data at
05:40her disposal.
05:41No personal remarks.
05:41Now, don't interject me, Pooja.
05:44What is the source?
05:46The source?
05:47The source is finance ministry archives.
05:49The source is available in public domain.
05:52Okay.
05:53The sources, secondary sources, primary sources.
05:55The whole world knows.
05:57Forget Sanju Verma.
05:58IMF, World Bank, OECD, Asian Development Bank, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley.
06:06Till six months back, each of these institutions were saying India in FY27 will grow at perhaps 6.4%
06:14or thereabouts.
06:15Today, all of them are saying India will grow at 7% or more.
06:19And mind you, Goldman Sachs barely 48 hours back said the U.S. this year and next year, 2.3
06:26% and 2.4%.
06:27The world economy this year and next year, 2.7% and 2.8%.
06:31China this year and next year, 4.5% and 4.4%.
06:36And what does Goldman say about India?
06:38One minute.
06:39Goldman says Indian GDP growth will be 7.9% this year.
06:45And 7.2% next year.
06:47This is not WhatsApp universities saying so.
06:50No, we are also putting out data.
06:52We are also putting out data, quoting from the World Bank report.
06:55Situation is better.
06:55Sanju, second point, then second point.
06:58So, are facts the issue or the fact that he spoke in the U.S.A. is a problem?
07:02Quickly, then I will go to Ashutosh.
07:04No, I have one little point to make.
07:07What Modi Ji said in 2010 or 2012, I can turn around and say,
07:11Did Narendra Modi, when he was the chief minister of Gujarat, ever say that Bharat mein vote chori hoti hai?
07:18That there was vote theft?
07:19Did he lampoon and criticize the judiciary?
07:22No.
07:22And do you remember, Pooja?
07:24In 2013, at the UNGA meet, the then Pakistani prime minister, Nawaz Sharif,
07:29called the then prime minister of India, Manmohan Singh, Dehati Aurat.
07:35Who opposed Nawaz Sharif's deplorable comments?
07:38It was the BJP.
07:40It was the RSS.
07:41We said calling the sitting prime minister of India,
07:44then in 2013, Dehati Aurat is absolutely condemnable.
07:49But today, Rahul Gandhi, he's laughing like a spoiled, entitled brat,
07:54saying, vote chori gatti chori,
07:56jo log bote hai hai, bharat mein akar, on Indian soil, at an Indian event,
08:00Rahul Gandhi starts jeering, cheering, sneering and clapping.
08:03Shame on Rahul Gandhi, shame on Congress party,
08:06and shame on that Italian no-butter.
08:08Is it about, even when you're targeting the prime minister,
08:11the manner in which is it being done, is it fair?
08:13Ashutosh is joining us, also Sujata Pandey is joining us as a political analyst.
08:17Ashutosh, first to you, you've been a journalist as well,
08:19and as political analyst, you tell me,
08:21what is your understanding, and this is not about BJP or Congress,
08:24but an opposition leader going on and on,
08:25constantly about what India has become, according to him.
08:29Is this fair? Does it look fine?
08:31Especially when the electorate back home,
08:33getting ready for elections is watching.
08:36See, Pujat, there are three things.
08:37First of all, who started it?
08:39The prime minister, Narendra Modi, had gone to Seoul in May 2015.
08:43And you know what he said?
08:44But before me, people said that we had done a wrong job,
08:49and we had done a good job that I had to be born in Hindustan.
08:52You know, can anything be more dangerous than this?
08:54Can it be more insulting to India than this?
08:57And then, you know, when the question was asked here,
09:01Sudhansu Trivedi has said,
09:02no, no, no, no, no, no, he was not attacking the India,
09:04he was just only talking about the policy paralysis in the country.
09:06So, now the word has changed in 12 years.
09:11Now, if the Rahul Gandhi has said something,
09:12now what Rahul Gandhi has said,
09:13I heard the entire conversation,
09:15he has said that India is sitting as an economic disaster.
09:18Is it not a true?
09:20Is it not truth?
09:21The fact of the matter is,
09:22even the foreign...
09:23How are we sitting on an economic disaster?
09:25IMF says we are a bright spot in the dark horizon.
09:29Pooja, let me come.
09:30Let me come.
09:31Let me come.
09:32Please, please.
09:32And Sanju Varma was quoting the foreign institutions,
09:36World Bank and all and all.
09:37He has forgotten.
09:39IMF a few months back has said,
09:41India's data should be put in the category C.
09:43That means Indian data is doubtful.
09:46Then former finance secretary who has worked in the Narendra Modi,
09:51when the data came 7.8% GDP growth,
09:54he said it is not 7.8%, it is 2.6%.
09:58The Surjit Bhalla,
09:59the member of the Economic Advisory Council,
10:01he said in 2013-14,
10:04India was in the Frasile 5.
10:05Now, India is in the Frasile 2,
10:07along with Turkey.
10:09These are the people who have worked with Narendra Modi,
10:12the Prime Minister.
10:13And they do not have a very high opinion
10:15about Indian economy.
10:17Let me put the third thing.
10:19The WPI inflation is something around 12.29%,
10:24except the retail is 6.09%,
10:27beyond the RBI's apprehensions.
10:31Food inflation is 8.3%,
10:33which is affecting every Indian in the country.
10:35The fuel and the power inflation is 32.84%.
10:39Then, above all,
10:42India was known as a software superpower.
10:47In 2011 and 2021-22 to 2024-25,
10:54there is a drop of almost 30% in India's software exports.
10:58Now, a country which was supposed to be the software superpower,
11:02there is a drop from 11.59 lakh crore to 7.75 lakh crore.
11:10That speaks volume about it.
11:12So, first of all,
11:13the BJP should answer to Subhash Garg,
11:16who said India's economy is not going at 7.8%,
11:18but 2.6%.
11:20Let everyone have their say,
11:21and I will come back to you.
11:23Sujata Pandey is also joining me.
11:24Sujata, what do you think?
11:26Do you think that India's image has changed
11:28on the global stage compared to
11:30even what our leaders have been saying earlier,
11:33that compared to, let's say, 2014 or 20 or 2000,
11:37in 2026, that pride is more visible
11:39or all of that has been just rhetoric?
11:43So, Puja, first of all,
11:45I think Rahul Gandhi is sitting in a constitutional post
11:47and nowhere in the world you'll have an example of a LOP
11:50going to a foreign...
11:53and in the financial capital of the world
11:55and going and bashing his own country.
11:57This is Rahul Gandhi's own country as well, isn't it?
12:00It is not just Narendra Modi's country.
12:02It is Rahul Gandhi's country as well.
12:04And then I think it is just not bad optics,
12:06it's bad politics also.
12:08Because, you know, today,
12:09what does the youth look for?
12:11What Rahul Gandhi is raising?
12:13Unemployment issues and education issues.
12:15And what is he denting at?
12:16He's denting the same investor
12:18which would come here
12:19and provide education,
12:21you know, investment in the education sector
12:23and, you know, help the youth get employed.
12:27Then second thing is,
12:28I think neither Ashutosh or,
12:30I don't know, the other panelists is an MBA.
12:32I think Sanju and me can show their MBA degree
12:34and tell that how are the ratings of the,
12:36you know, whole, you know,
12:38this global education,
12:40global fintech,
12:41you know, the ratings have gone up.
12:42You know, S&P upgraded India's rating
12:45in 18 years.
12:46It made it BBB.
12:47In the last 18 years,
12:48it has never done that.
12:50Because IMF has said it on record
12:51that India's,
12:52the way India's has been taking people
12:55out of poverty line
12:56is something that is for the books.
12:58Then from the IMF,
13:00to the World Bank,
13:01to the S&P,
13:01to the Fitch,
13:03all of these reports are on the thing.
13:05So I think, you know,
13:06they would know much more better economics
13:08than Ashutosh for that matter.
13:11I think from an LOP perspective,
13:14he can definitely criticize government,
13:16but in here,
13:17when he goes out,
13:18he has to have data to show
13:20how Congress government
13:22was better than Modi government.
13:23But he knows that those will not
13:25fall flat on his face
13:27because the numbers can't even be compared.
13:29We were in Brazil 5.
13:31We were on the world.
13:32But our God was getting on stage.
13:33Bhabha, you want to respond to that.
13:35She's made a good point,
13:36which is with the kind of statements
13:39going from Rahul Gandhi,
13:40aren't you spreading a fear?
13:42There could have been actually investors,
13:44educationists who would be actually interested,
13:45Aukhin,
13:46to invest in India
13:47or take talent pool from here.
13:49Instead, you're giving this negative image
13:51that will impact India and Indians
13:53because going by the data,
13:54it appears that extreme poverty has come down.
13:57The GDP has seen a growth as well.
13:59The real GDP growth at about 7.8%
14:01in the first quarter year.
14:04I'm quoting some of the statistics
14:05that has come in
14:06from international organizations as well.
14:08Is this fear-mongering?
14:10Are you bringing in actors
14:11who need not interfere
14:12in our internal issues?
14:18You're asking me?
14:19Bhabha, yes.
14:20Please go ahead.
14:20Because your voice was breaking before.
14:22Yes.
14:28Bhabha, for you, yes.
14:29Is this fear-mongering?
14:30Let me state some facts.
14:31Let me state some facts.
14:32Go ahead.
14:33If I state facts,
14:34maybe it's easy for you to understand.
14:36Let me read it out.
14:43Quickly, Bhabha.
14:44The government's latest release.
14:46The government's latest release.
14:48No, I'm reading the facts
14:49from the government websites
14:51that I have researched.
14:53The government's latest release,
14:55the July-September 2026 quarterly bulletin.
14:58All right.
14:58That was released on 10th of November.
15:00Shows the national youth number
15:02easing to 15.3%.
15:03But the improvement
15:04in entirely rural story.
15:06The rural youth unemployment
15:07fell from 14% to 13%.
15:10Rural youth employment,
15:11meanwhile,
15:12rose to,
15:13unemployment rose to 18.9%.
15:17Over the same quarter.
15:19With unemployment
15:19among the urban young women
15:21at 26%
15:23and urban young men
15:24at 16%.
15:25This is not Congress data.
15:28This is not some random
15:29third-party research
15:33person's data.
15:34This is the government's data
15:35recently released.
15:37All right.
15:38When you interpret data,
15:40you just want to be selective
15:42about the data
15:43you want to present.
15:44But let's talk about
15:46very common things
15:48that's affecting
15:48the common people.
15:50The petrol price,
15:52the diesel price,
15:53the LPG price.
15:55Most importantly,
15:56what's happening
15:57to the rupee.
15:58Dollar and rupee.
15:59To which,
16:00quoting Prime Minister
16:01Modi Bhavia for you,
16:02he spoke at the Bharat conclave.
16:03What I'm telling you
16:04is what the government says.
16:05Government says
16:06the price rise
16:07for the few else
16:08could have actually
16:09gone much higher
16:10because of the West Asia war.
16:12It was actually
16:12the government
16:14absorbing a lot
16:15of that pressure.
16:19Then,
16:20why is that pressure
16:21only
16:23forced upon
16:24the poor
16:25when the top 1%
16:27of population
16:28is holding
16:2940% of the wealth?
16:30Okay, let's take
16:3122% of national income.
16:33No, no, wait, wait, wait.
16:34One more point.
16:35Ms. Sujata
16:36I'm not sure
16:38if you actually
16:39heard what Mr. Gandhi
16:40said in
16:41Columbia University,
16:42if you had heard,
16:43you wouldn't say
16:44he was bashing India.
16:46He was, yes,
16:47he was exposing
16:49BJP's
16:50state of economic
16:50disaster.
16:51He was exposing
16:52the economic
16:53disaster.
16:54Okay.
16:54Sanju,
16:55the fact is,
16:57okay,
16:57there are some real
16:58concerns
16:59like unemployment,
17:00especially
17:03so if the leader
17:04is talking about
17:06Bhavya,
17:06Bhavya,
17:07time's up,
17:08time's up.
17:08Let Sanju respond now.
17:09Because if there are
17:10some real issues
17:11that he's speaking
17:12about in the USA,
17:15is that really
17:15a concern?
17:16Do you think that
17:17he's either
17:18exaggerating it,
17:19lying about it?
17:20Because some of
17:20these are concerns.
17:21Unemployment,
17:22inflation is a
17:22concern for India.
17:25Pooja,
17:26now I don't wish
17:26to be heckled.
17:27Bhavya Narasimba
17:28is a rapid liar.
17:30I have the data
17:32from the Ministry
17:33of Statistics
17:33and Programme
17:34Implementation
17:35and this is
17:36the actual data.
17:37Let your audience
17:38know this dim-witted
17:39spokesperson
17:40knows nothing
17:41about economy.
17:42Oh my God.
17:43Sanju Verma,
17:44what are you saying?
17:45Pooja,
17:46can I finish?
17:46You know,
17:47you're speaking
17:47on a national chelly
17:48with Deacon Crosscheck.
17:50Remember Deacon Crosscheck,
17:51you have learned
17:52about everything.
17:53I did not
17:54have the check now.
17:54You have been running
17:55your whole life
17:55on our television.
17:57Bhavya,
17:57let Sanjuski.
17:58Can you moderate
17:58the debate?
17:59Remember,
18:00can you moderate
18:00the debate?
18:02Can you moderate
18:02the debate,
18:03Pooja?
18:03You can't get
18:04the debate.
18:05Let me speak.
18:05Let her finish
18:06your point.
18:06Let her make her clean.
18:07If it's a clean,
18:08let her make.
18:08Ladies please.
18:09You liar.
18:10Okay, Sanju,
18:11Sanju,
18:12no person.
18:12Can I finish?
18:15We'll restrict
18:15with personal remarks.
18:17Sanju,
18:18only the facts.
18:19Go ahead.
18:19Your audience
18:20needs to hear this.
18:21Thank you,
18:21Pooja.
18:22The Ministry
18:23of Statistics
18:24and Programme
18:25Implementation
18:26has released
18:26this data
18:27for the month
18:28of October.
18:29The month
18:29of November
18:30data is not yet
18:30out.
18:31For the month
18:32of October,
18:33overall rural
18:34unemployment rate
18:354.2%.
18:37Rural male
18:38unemployment rate
18:404.3%.
18:41Rural female
18:43unemployment rate
18:443.8%.
18:46Overall
18:47unemployment rate
18:484.2%.
18:49Rural labor
18:51force participation
18:52rate,
18:53it's highest
18:53highest ever
18:54amongst females
18:55at 42%
18:57for males
18:58at more
18:59than 79%.
19:00And
19:01Bhavya
19:01had the audacity
19:02to say
19:03unemployment rate
19:03is 15%.
19:04I don't know
19:05I don't know
19:05where
19:05they talk
19:06about
19:06but I
19:07will end
19:08very quickly.
19:09Pooja,
19:10which is the
19:11second largest
19:11steel producing
19:14economy in the
19:15world?
19:15India.
19:16Which is the
19:17second largest
19:17cement producing
19:18economy in the
19:19world?
19:19India.
19:20Which is the
19:20second largest
19:21mobile phone
19:22manufacturer in
19:23the world?
19:24India.
19:24Which is the
19:25third largest
19:25automobile
19:26manufacturer in
19:27the world?
19:28India.
19:28Which is the
19:29largest two
19:30wheeler
19:30manufacturer in
19:31the world?
19:31India.
19:32Which is the
19:33fifth largest
19:33economy in
19:34terms of
19:35stock market
19:36capitalization.
19:37India overtook
19:38Taiwan last
19:38year to become
19:39the fifth largest
19:40in terms of
19:40stock market
19:41capitalization.
19:42But Sanju,
19:43are you saying
19:43that there is no
19:44unemployment?
19:45Can I finish?
19:46Now,
19:47now,
19:47now.
19:49IMF,
19:50the IMF,
19:51and this is for
19:52Ashutosh,
19:52yes,
19:53the IMF had
19:54flagged concerns
19:55pertaining to
19:56India six
19:57months back,
19:58but barely
19:59three weeks
20:00back.
20:01IMF applauded
20:02Narendra Modi
20:03for carrying out
20:03structural reforms
20:04and saying,
20:05the fact that
20:06the Modi
20:07government changed
20:07the base year
20:08from 2011-12
20:10to 22-23
20:12is a great move
20:13and as for
20:14Subhash Garg,
20:15I have nothing
20:16to say about
20:17a disgruntled,
20:18jobless man
20:19looking for
20:20opportunities.
20:21Well,
20:22you made your
20:22point.
20:23Sanju,
20:24you made
20:24your point
20:24and you
20:25made it
20:25how?
20:26But Ashutosh,
20:26because before
20:27I wrap up,
20:28I want everyone
20:28to have their
20:29say,
20:29Ashutosh,
20:29here's my
20:30question and
20:30you can of
20:30course respond
20:31to what
20:31Sanju is
20:32saying.
20:33Let's say
20:33what Rahul
20:34Gandhi had
20:34to say,
20:35some of
20:35those issues
20:36are pertinent.
20:37Make it
20:37back home.
20:38Elections
20:38are coming
20:39in.
20:40You're making
20:40these statements
20:41in the USA
20:42on foreign
20:43soil,
20:44which the
20:44BJP is
20:45cashing on
20:45to say,
20:48especially
20:50when
20:51Prime Minister
20:51Modi
20:51and the
20:52party
20:52still has
20:52a strong
20:53hold,
20:53especially
20:53in states
20:54like
20:54Uttar Pradesh.
20:55So come
20:55make it
20:56back home
20:56if the
20:57parliament
20:57debated,
20:58why go
20:59all the
20:59way to
20:59the US
20:59or the
21:00UK to
21:00make such
21:01statements
21:01is what
21:02everyone's
21:02been asking
21:03Ashutosh.
21:04Say,
21:04Pooja,
21:05first of
21:05all,
21:05let me
21:05correct my
21:06two
21:06colleagues
21:07on the
21:07panel.
21:07One,
21:08Sujata Pandey
21:08has said,
21:09the leader
21:09opposition post
21:10is a
21:10constitutional
21:11post.
21:11It's not
21:11a constitutional
21:12post.
21:12It's a
21:12statutory
21:13post created
21:14in 1977
21:15by a law
21:16in the
21:16parliament.
21:17Okay,
21:17I'll tell
21:17you about this.
21:17Let's be
21:17very clear on
21:18this.
21:19Second
21:19point is,
21:20India doesn't
21:21manufacture
21:22mobile phones.
21:23It only
21:23assembles.
21:2475%
21:26of parts
21:28are
21:29Sanju,
21:30please,
21:31Sanju,
21:31please be
21:31civil.
21:32Sanju,
21:33please be
21:33civil.
21:34You are
21:34out of
21:35touch with
21:35unity.
21:36You are
21:37consumed by
21:38hatred for
21:38the
21:39Let him
21:40finish.
21:40Sanju,
21:41Sanju.
21:41The form
21:44that I
21:45use is
21:45manufactured
21:46in India.
21:47The form
21:48that
21:48Puja uses
21:49or
21:49Sujata
21:50will not
21:50let her
21:51speak.
21:52Sanju,
21:52there's
21:53limited
21:53time.
21:54There is
21:55an expansion
21:56that India
21:57has been
21:57doing in
21:58component
21:59in some
21:59assembly
22:00parts.
22:01I'm
22:01really
22:02aghast
22:04that the
22:04former
22:05banker
22:06does not
22:06know
22:06difference
22:07between
22:07manufacturing
22:08and
22:08assembling.
22:09India
22:10only
22:10assembles
22:11mobile
22:12phone.
22:12It is
22:12not
22:12manufacturing.
22:13Let's
22:14be clear
22:14on this.
22:15The
22:15point
22:15number
22:16two,
22:16have
22:16you
22:16heard
22:17from
22:17the
22:17BJP
22:18in
22:18the
22:18last
22:18six
22:18months
22:19that
22:19India
22:19is
22:20the
22:20third
22:20largest
22:20economy?
22:21No,
22:22because
22:22it has
22:22slipped
22:23from
22:23fourth
22:23to
22:23sixth.
22:24Have
22:24you
22:25heard
22:25that
22:25India's
22:26stock
22:26market
22:26has
22:26shrunk
22:27and
22:27that
22:27is
22:27why
22:27it
22:28has
22:28slipped
22:28from
22:28fourth
22:28position
22:29to
22:29the
22:29seventh
22:29position?
22:30Have
22:31you heard
22:31how India's
22:32stock market
22:32is doing?
22:33in the
22:33last one
22:34year,
22:3530
22:35lakh
22:36crore
22:36money has
22:38slipped
22:38out of
22:39the
22:39stock
22:39market.
22:4030
22:40billion
22:41foreign
22:42portfolio
22:42investment
22:43has gone
22:44out of
22:44India's
22:45market.
22:46And then
22:47she is
22:48critical about
22:49Subhash
22:49Chandi goes,
22:50fine,
22:50but what
22:51about the
22:51former
22:52chief
22:52economic
22:52advisor
22:53Arvind
22:53Subramaniam?
22:54He's
22:55saying from
22:55the
22:56rooftop,
22:56writing
22:57articles
22:57after
22:57article,
22:58that India's
22:58data is
22:59doubtful
23:00and suspect
23:00at least
23:01it has
23:02been
23:04artificially
23:04inflated
23:05by 2-3%.
23:06Final point,
23:07final point,
23:08the IMF
23:08World Economic
23:09outlook data
23:10says that
23:11Indian economy
23:12is growing
23:12at the rate
23:13of 4.2%,
23:14not 7.8%.
23:16And then,
23:18again I'll quote
23:19Sujit Balla,
23:19whose work as
23:20economic advisory
23:21council,
23:22that per capita
23:22GDP growth
23:23in US
23:24dollar is
23:246.
23:25Sanju,
23:25Sanju,
23:26but I need
23:26to get all
23:27views,
23:27because before
23:28I wrap up,
23:28I'm being told
23:36at this point,
23:39everyone's been
23:40asking,
23:40especially from
23:41the ruling
23:41party,
23:41and people
23:42are watching
23:42it too,
23:43people are
23:43also wondering,
23:44if you have
23:45any view,
23:46you're meeting
23:46leaders like
23:47Ilhan Omar,
23:48who's a known
23:48India beta,
23:49you're interacting
23:50with individuals,
23:51do have a
23:52questionable
23:52authority as
23:53well,
23:53and importantly,
23:54why are you
23:55going to the
23:55USA,
23:56to the UK
23:56on foreign
23:57soil,
23:57if you have
23:58these issues,
23:58valid issues,
24:00debate it
24:00here,
24:00on the soil,
24:01voters are
24:02going to
24:02eventually vote
24:03for either
24:03Congress or
24:04BJP,
24:05is it the
24:05electorate only
24:06that matters,
24:07Sujata,
24:08or do you
24:08think the
24:08worldview also
24:09matters?
24:11No,
24:12both matters,
24:13Pooja,
24:13but at the
24:14right forum
24:14and at the
24:15right stage,
24:16in my opinion,
24:18any electorate,
24:19whether you're
24:19a Congress
24:19supporter or a
24:20BJP supporter,
24:21doesn't like
24:22India bashing,
24:23especially on a
24:24global stage,
24:25and that has
24:26been done
24:26repeatedly,
24:26and that
24:27has been
24:27used by
24:28BJP to
24:29counter Rahul
24:29Gandhi
24:30repeatedly,
24:31and still
24:31Rahul Gandhi
24:32keeps on
24:32doing,
24:32I do not
24:33see as a
24:34political analyst
24:34that adds
24:35to anything
24:36to Rahul
24:37Gandhi's
24:37image,
24:37rather he
24:38dents his
24:38image,
24:39so I think,
24:39I'm quoting
24:40Prime Minister
24:41Modi,
24:41I think this
24:41was a completely
24:42different context
24:44and different,
24:45so you can't
24:45really give a
24:46panel,
24:46Prime Minister
24:47Modi never
24:48shamed the
24:48country,
24:49Rahul Gandhi
24:49shamed the
24:50country,
24:50and first of all,
24:51UP elections are
24:52coming,
24:52Rahul Gandhi should
24:53be here,
24:54not doing this,
24:55this foreign
24:57talk,
24:57the BJP
24:59spokesperson agrees
25:00to it,
25:00but I'm told
25:02that's all the
25:02time I have for,
25:03I really have to
25:04wrap up,
25:04I appreciate all
25:05of you for
25:05giving your views,
25:06eventually remember,
25:07janata dek rahi hai,
25:09the people will
25:10vote,
25:10in Uttar Pradesh,
25:12in Punjab,
25:12in other states as
25:13well,
25:13they will decide,
25:14if Rahul Gandhi
25:15is the next big
25:16leader,
25:17is it Prime Minister
25:18Modi again,
25:18is it Yogi
25:19Adityanath again,
25:20so I leave it
25:21to the people
25:21watching,
25:22eventually you get
25:23to decide,
25:23and that's the
25:24voter of India,
25:25thank you very
25:25much for watching
25:26this discussion,

Recommended