- 1 hour ago
- #considerthis
The Health Minister has confirmed that nicotine vape liquids and gels are once again regulated under the Poisons Act, following the government's decision not to appeal a High Court ruling that overturned the 2023 exemption. But the government is now considering exempting liquid nicotine again, ostensibly to facilitate a vape ban. So what exactly is the Government’s policy direction on vaping? On this episode of #ConsiderThis Melisa Idris speaks with Azrul Mohd Khalib, CEO of the Galen Centre for Health and Social Policy, and Dr Ashok Phillip, Former President of the World Medical Association and Former Member of the Poisons Board.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:10Hello and good evening. I'm Melissa Idris. Welcome to Consider This. This is the show
00:15where we want you to consider and then reconsider what you know of the news of the day. The
00:19Health Minister has confirmed that nicotine vape liquids and gels are once again regulated
00:25under the Poisons Act, this following the government's decision not to appeal a High
00:30Court ruling that overturned the 2023 exemption. However, the government, as we hear, is now
00:38considering exempting liquid nicotine once again, ostensibly to facilitate a vape ban.
00:45So how do we think about this? What exactly is the government's policy direction on vaping?
00:51Well, joining me on the show to help us discuss this further, I have Azrael Mahmoud-Khalib
00:56who is the CEO of the Gallen Centre for Health and Social Policy. Azrael, good to have you
01:00back on the show. Thank you so much for joining me. Maybe we can get you to help catch us
01:04up
01:05with the latest developments. What exactly has changed about this issue since the 2023 exemption
01:12was first announced?
01:14You know, it's great to be on the show with you, Melissa, as always. Just to recap what
01:20also you mentioned just now is that since the 2023 exemption was introduced, we've actually
01:25had the control of smoking products for Public Health Act 2024 or Act 852, which was passed
01:33in Parliament and came into force on October 1st, 2024. So this law provides the regulatory framework
01:41for smoking products, including vapes and e-cigarettes. But the judicial review, which you mentioned
01:47just now filed to the KL High Court in May 15, 2026, this year, actually struck down the
01:56Malaysian government's 2023 decision to remove liquid and gel, nicotine use, vapes and e-cigarettes
02:02for the poisons list. And the court ruled that the decision by then Health Minister Dr.
02:10Zaliha Mustafa was actually irrational and unlawful as it was against the poisons for physician.
02:17Now, the government withdrew its appeal against this gentleman. This had three main effects.
02:25Firstly, it nullifies the early exemption, restricts the sale distribution of its products with
02:35nicotine to only just pharmacists and basically doctors, authorized health authorities, meaning
02:41there's no retail. It's effectively a ban. And most importantly for the government, it closes the door
02:49on excise duty or tax collection on e-cigarettes and baked liquids containing nicotine. And as we know all
02:57too well, the request to accept these products in the poisons list was once again put to the poisons
03:04board and this time came away with a different result. They approved the exemption. So that's where
03:09we stand. Okay, so I want to understand some of the conflicting statements and developments that have
03:19been happening recently. So we had in parliament Dr. Zoll replying that liquid nicotine is now subject to the
03:25Poisons Act. But then we also have the Poisons Board now endorsing MOH's proposal to exempt liquid
03:32nicotine from the poisons list. How do we think about that? It's now back as a scheduled poison,
03:36but then they want to re-exempt it again. How are you reading this, Azrul?
03:40Well, you know, I don't blame you for being confused too. I think the minister's answer in parliament is
03:47confusing as it contradicts the actions undertaken to once again regularise and legitimise the sale of
03:55nicotine bait and e-cigarettes. It feels a bit of a lavender haze moment, I think. Does the government
04:02want to ban these products or not? The minister previously stated clearly that it was not a matter of
04:09if, but when. Malaysia is actually one of the few outlier countries actually left in this region which has
04:17not yet banned these products. The government seems very adamant to keep this industry alive,
04:23and it's important to note that Malaysia is actually a major manufacturer and exporter of these vape and
04:29e-cigarettes products. So it may be that we are unable to shake off the addiction to these products. Now,
04:37the
04:37High Court practically handed the ban to the government on a plate and oven ready, you know, with the
04:44judgment that it made earlier this year. So the government even dropped its appeal there, as you
04:49know. So the government could have given the industry then like six months period, you know, to prepare for
04:55the ban. But unfortunately, this unpredictability and lack of transparency and inconsistency of this
05:01policy are unfair and problematic for everyone, really, because it's conflicting. And as you heard in
05:09parliament, you know, it sounds like they want to basically go back to pre-2023, where basically you
05:20couldn't sell these products in retail. But you know, this is where we are today.
05:24Okay, so what about the Poison's Board decision, Azrul? How do we make sense of that? What do you
05:29understand about why the Poison's Board initially said no, or didn't allow for liquid
05:37nicotine to be exempted, but now this time around has allowed for this? What could have changed in
05:42the time that passed in between? Well, Melissa, I can tell you that nicotine hasn't gotten safer
05:49since 2023. It's still the same as it was back in 2023. And one of the problems here is that
05:57we are
06:00facing a situation where the government has been a bit of a blank space when it comes to this issue.
06:05You know, it's been opaque and silent ever since the High Court judgment. There's been no announcement
06:12made of the Poison's Board decision, which you know, we've spoken about, and there is no daylight or
06:17indication on whether the minister will actually issue an order to accept nicotine vape and e-cigarettes
06:24face in that decision. Because if he doesn't issue an order, then nicotine vape and e-cigarettes are
06:31technically illegal, notwithstanding the Poison's Board decision. Because the Poison's Board decision
06:38is just a decision by the Poison's Board. To operationalize that, the minister needs to issue an
06:45order to actively accept that. So until he issues the order, nicotine vape and e-cigarettes
06:52continues to be illegal to be sold in retail or outside of the authorized avenues. You mean right now,
07:02as in right now it's illegal? Technically, yes. It really is. That's why I said to you that the High
07:08Court has basically handed this ban to the government on a plate. And that is pretty much the case. And
07:16another issue here is concerning that tax collection, right? So the Treasury Secretary General Johan
07:22Mahmoud Marikan said in his affidavit back in 2003, which was filed in the nicotine case, that cancelling
07:29the exemption order would invalidate the government's collection of excise duties on e-cigarettes and vape
07:36liquids containing nicotine, which amounts to around more than 354 million at the moment in tax revenue,
07:44which has been collected as of June 11, 2026. So all that money, right, technically would have to be
07:50refunded to the industries or the ones who paid that tax because the court has basically determined
08:00that from 2023 all the way up until this point, no tax can technically be collected on an illegal product.
08:08So
08:08the government would actually technically have to refund all that money back. So in order for
08:13government to continue collecting tax on it, it would actually have to issue the order once again,
08:19as it did back in 2013. This is such a legal quagmire for the government. As you're looking at it,
08:29as you've been following the story for quite some time, what would you like the government to clarify?
08:33What information is still missing, is still opaque and not transparent that you would like to see the
08:39government explain so that you have a better understanding of the policy direction on vapes and
08:45can hold the government accountable? Actually, it's quite simple really, Melissa. I think for
08:51the government to really explain what is the end game for nicotine vape and e-cigarettes.
08:57Ban or not ban? That is the question. So it would be great if we could have a New Year's
09:03Day
09:03be greeted with a ban on nicotine vape and e-cigarettes. But if it decides not to ban, then it
09:09has to make
09:09clear its intentions. And this is not just for, you know, public health advocates, really.
09:15It's really also for the industry, which employs people, which invests in the manufacturing of these
09:25products, but also employs thousands of people as well. If you're deciding to go the path, the way of
09:31Singapore and other countries in this region to ban vape and e-cigarettes, then you should make it very
09:38clear. So I think it's important for the government to explain itself and not basically, you know, hope
09:46that everybody will get the message somehow. So we just need it to be made very clear.
09:51Right. As well, do you think, I'm going to ask you, do you think this is about the money? Do
09:56you think
09:56that this is about the how much money the government has collected on the tax and excise duties? Or do
10:03you
10:03think this is about how politically unpopular, unpalatable this could be? And I wonder whether
10:11it is more unpalatable to have a vape ban or more unpalatable not to have a vape ban? What do
10:16you think?
10:16Well, that is the question, right? I think when we look at where we are today, especially in terms of
10:23this being at least a 2 billion ringgit industry, which employs people, pays tax, invests, and most
10:32importantly, also creates a section of an industry that contributes to the national GDP, there needs
10:39to be a serious question of where we want to go with it. Because it is possible for us to
10:44move away
10:45from this industry just the same way that we moved away from, you know, tobacco, you know, when it comes
10:52to growing tobacco. So the problem right now here is the lack of clarity. And therefore, this obviously has
11:01major implications concerning the politics of it, but also the financial aspect in terms of tax collection.
11:09But here's the thing. With regards to the way that government has treated this issue, we are seeing
11:17the problems such as the need to refund, you know, what more than quarter of a billion ringgit back
11:25because they didn't do it properly. And therefore, this should really be something that the government
11:31is decisive of and makes it very clear, not later, but now, because it's going to be very expensive
11:40if it works.
11:41Okay. So what will you be watching out for in the coming days for more clarity on this? What are
11:47you, who are you
11:47watching? What are you looking for in terms of signs and signals?
11:50Well, I think for us, it's just going to be whether or not the health minister issues his order.
11:57If he issues the order to operationalize the board's decision concerning the nicotine
12:05exemption on liquid nicotine and e-cigarettes, then that means we have a clear signal that the government
12:13is moving ahead to regularize and basically do what it's been doing for the past couple of years.
12:18If it doesn't, if the health minister's order does not come, then essentially we are
12:26not necessarily in a limbo moment, but it will be as what the health minister has answered in parliament,
12:34which is that liquid nicotine used for e-cigarettes are now subjected once again to the Poisons Act,
12:42notwithstanding the Poisons Act position and other issues. So let's wait to hear what the health minister
12:49has to say.
12:50All right. Azra, thank you so much for joining me on the show. I appreciate your time. Azra Mamak-Khalib
12:53from
12:54the Gallen Centre for Health and Social Policy. We're going to take a quick break here to consider this.
12:58We'll be back with more. Stay tuned.
13:20Hi, welcome back to Consider This. I'm Melissa Idris. Let's continue our discussion about the nicotine vape
13:27liquids, which are now back under the Poisons Act after the government decided not to appeal
13:33a High Court ruling that overturned their 2023 exemption. However, the health minister is now or may now be
13:41considering a fresh exemption. This is the signal that we're getting after the Poisons Board recently endorsed
13:48his proposal to re-exempt liquid nicotine from the poisons list. Now, joining me on the show,
13:54I have Dr Ashok Philip, who is the former president of the World Medical Association. He's also a former
14:00member of the Poisons Board. Dr Ashok, thank you so much for joining me on the show today. First one,
14:06I'm curious to know what you think or what your thoughts are on the recent developments surrounding
14:11what we see with liquid and gel nicotine. Thank you for having me on the show.
14:19Yes, well, it's interesting is what I can say about these recent developments. When I was on the Poisons
14:25Board, as you mentioned, that was when a previous health minister had sent a proposal to exempt liquid
14:33or remove liquid nicotine from the poisons list. And at that time, the board voted against it.
14:42I'm mentioning this now because, as you know, this was taken to court. So the matters are already in the
14:50public domain. And therefore, there's no question of official secrets or anything. So the board then,
15:00on the advice of the professional members, voted against removing nicotine from the poisons list.
15:07And we advised the minister to that extent, but she decided to ignore our advice and went ahead and
15:15removed liquid nicotine from the poisons list. I was on the board as the MMA representative at the
15:22time, and I felt that it was wrong to do so, and therefore I resigned. But the MMA did not
15:28leave the
15:28Poisons Board. That is not what I would have advised. I resigned as a matter of personal principle,
15:36because, not because of nicotine, but because the advice of the Poisons Board, though legally it is
15:42just advised, should have been considered. And it was not. Now, what has happened is, from what I
15:48understand from public news reports, is that a secret ballot was held on this matter with the Poisons Board.
15:56And by a majority, they agreed to the removal of liquid nicotine from the Poisons Board, from the Poisons
16:03list, and to put it under Act 8.5.2, which is about tobacco and tobacco products. So, as far
16:14as I understand,
16:15they have not actually done this yet, but it is proposed. And I feel that it is
16:22a backward step. The Ministry of Health has said that it plans or hopes to ban vape completely.
16:29And if it hopes to do that, then I think that we should be moving towards making liquid nicotine
16:35more difficult for people to get. We should not be removing it from the Poisons list and then putting
16:41it under a separate Act, which is as yet untested, a very new Act. So, I feel that this was
16:48a backward step
16:49and not a good thing for public health. Dr Ashut, can I ask you about how the Poisons
16:57Board decisions are made or the meetings are made? So, you mentioned a secret ballot. I'm wondering,
17:02how much information is confidential and what can the public reasonably expect to know or to be informed
17:14of? Are we allowed to know the composition of the Poisons Board? Are we allowed to know who voted,
17:20how they voted, and whose interests are represented at the table? As far as I know, the Poisons Board composition
17:29is no secret at all. You can find out just by asking the Ministry of Health. As far as most
17:37government
17:37meetings go, when you go as a representative from another body, you have to sign a document saying
17:44that you will not disclose what is happening to the public. But generally, we do have an exemption.
17:50For instance, if I'm representing the Malaysian Medical Association, I am expected to brief my
17:55association on what has happened. So, normally, when I was in the Poisons Board, there were no secret
18:02ballots. The matters were discussed openly and we would, if necessary, show of hands. More often than
18:09not, it was just consensus. So, whether or not the deliberations and voting of the Poisons Board in
18:18this particular matter can be made public would be up to the Minister, I think, because the Poisons
18:27Board comes under the Ministry of Health and it would be up to the Minister to decide whether to
18:30declassify or make public the deliberations of the Board on this matter. Does the fact that a secret
18:37ballot was held, is that concerning to you? Well, of course, I don't think there's anything against the
18:45law in having a secret ballot, but it suggests that it is a controversial matter. It suggests that the
18:52Ministry of Health or the government felt that an open vote would have gone against them.
18:58So, it also then suggests that they understand that liquid nicotine is a controversial matter.
19:05And as such, I think they should have had more consideration put into the matter before they
19:11went forward with it. They should have had more consultation with interested parties because
19:17though the Poisons Board is quite widely representative, it doesn't have representation from,
19:23say, specialty societies like addiction societies, pediatric medicine, chest medicine. So, it doesn't
19:30have that sort of representation. I think the Ministry of Health should have taken into account these
19:35specialty societies' views first before deciding to go ahead. Do you think that the rep from the
19:45Malaysian Medical Association should stay on? You said you took the personal view of resigning after your
19:52advice was not taken into consideration, but what do you think should be the right move? Should
19:57out of protest or to register protest that the people who dissented against this should remove themselves
20:05from the Poisons Board? I don't think so. The Poisons Board's activities and responsibilities are very
20:13broad. For instance, whenever a new drug is brought into the country, they have to decide whether it goes
20:18under a B drug or C drug, whether moving drugs from class B to class C. All these things are
20:27discussed and
20:29voted on by the Poison Board. So, those are important to doctors, to vets, to dentists.
20:34So, I think we should remain there. It's also very important to the pharmacists and they should remain in
20:39the board as well. It's not a single issue board. And if we step out, then, of course, we lose
20:49our
20:53say. Having said that, we object to this and we are, I think, quite rightly, I think, the President of
21:02the
21:02MMA has made his views very clearly known. One of the things that's different from the first time the
21:11Poisons Board denied exemption of liquid nicotine and now endorsing this exemption is the introduction of
21:19the, as you said, Act 852, Control of Smoking Products for Public Health Act. Is that enough to justify
21:27endorsing liquid nicotine? I think not because the long-term aim is to stop having these e-cigarettes, vapes,
21:38electronic nicotine delivery systems. So, if we make it easier now, or at least make it less regulated,
21:48I think, for liquid nicotine, then it makes it more difficult to remove vape from the landscape
21:54in the long-term because it becomes more and more lucrative for the dealers and for the government
22:02collecting tax. It becomes more and more difficult to stop to legislate against it. What is your
22:09concern? So, I'm just wondering if this is the policy direction of the government and that is the signal
22:15that we're getting around this. What safeguards do you think should be in place so that this decision
22:23doesn't lead to harm, particularly harm towards children, amongst children?
22:30I mean, I do believe the Act restricts the age of people who can buy such things, but this is
22:37a new Act
22:37and enforcement under this Act has not been, I mean, we don't have a real historical record of it. We
22:43don't know how good it's going to be. But what we're concerned about, of course, is that you will have
22:48preparations which are targeting young people, not necessarily children, but very young people,
22:56attractive packaging, flavors, synthetic flavors, which are very attractive to people who wouldn't
23:02traditionally smoke. And also, we are concerned that besides nicotine, who knows what goes into these
23:11liquids, you would need a whole apparatus to check what is going into these liquids, to collect liquids
23:19from so many different places, to check on them, to make sure that people who are not supposed to be
23:25buying them don't buy them. It's going to be a huge logistical challenge. And if you were to restrict
23:31it, keep it in the poisons list, then it's very much more difficult for people to get hold of it.
23:36So I think under this new Act, it is going to be much more difficult for us to regulate.
23:41Even if the penalties are there, even if the rules are there, it's going to be much more difficult to
23:45control the spread to young people, especially. Dr. Ashit, you have the unique view or the perspective
23:52that you can maybe help us understand better. Having been on the Poisons Board, having had all these
24:01consultations and following the science of and the impact of liquid and gel nicotine, what would you
24:09like us, what would you like the public to understand about the possible impact of the decision of the
24:15Poisons Board and the policy direction of the government? What would you like to see happen next
24:22about vaping? Dr. Well, I would like to see vapes removed from the landscape entirely because somehow
24:29the stigma that is attached to smoking doesn't seem to attach to vape. People vape with much more
24:35openness and perhaps with the sense that they're doing something very stylish. When you know young
24:40children, the young kids, they want to be stylish, they want to be hip, they want to be cool, so
24:45they will take this on. And nicotine is, in many people, highly addictive. Once you've taken it for
24:52a while, you become dependent on it and it becomes very difficult to stop. It has a place. I think
24:58these
24:58liquid nicotine delivery systems have a place for smoking cessation but under medical supervision with
25:06medical prescription. But people who have never smoked should not, under the impression that this is
25:13harmless should not start taking it. It is not harmless. There are harms associated with these
25:19because these systems, they heat a liquid and you inhale it into your lungs and it's not just nicotine,
25:27so many different combustion products. Not as many as cigarettes, but there are a lot of toxins that still
25:34go into your lungs. There are reports of people with severe lung damage from relatively short durations
25:39of vaping. So there are health hazards. So people who have never smoked should not start vaping with
25:47the impression that it's harmless. It has a role in helping smokers to stop. There is evidence that
25:55it works better than other methods, but only slightly better. And it must be under medical supervision.
26:00It's not for you to just, you know, like grabbing a pack of nicotine chewing gum. It's not the same
26:07thing. You have to be under medical supervision. Then it's more effective.
26:11Right. Dr Ashok, thank you so much for your time. That was Dr Ashok Philip, former member of the
26:16Poisons Board. They're wrapping up this episode of Consider This. I'm Melissa Idris,
26:20signing off for the evening. Thank you so much for watching and good night.