Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 minutes ago
🗣️ "Even as a Gen Z who lives on her phone, I was genuinely shocked by the sheer wall of screens in that crowd."The Standard’s Madelaine Dowds shares her take on Carnaby Street’s viral ‘Black Mirror-esque’ sea of phones.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00The Carnaby Street Christmas light switch on happened nearly two weeks ago,
00:03so why is everyone suddenly talking about it now? Here's a clue. Footage from the night has
00:08gone viral on social media, not because of the spectacle of the lights twinkling overhead,
00:12but because of what was happening down below. Look, I'm Gen Z. I love my phone and I quite
00:19literally live on social media, so I'm definitely not here to lecture you like some sort of tech
00:24hating grandma. Full disclosure, I was there on the night filming the moment too. Granted,
00:28I was literally being paid to get the video for work, and perhaps if I wasn't working,
00:32there's a fair chance I'd have whipped out my phone to capture at the moment anyway.
00:35Even so, standing in the middle of that crowd, I was genuinely taken aback by the sheer ocean of
00:41devices all pointing up in the air. People in the streets were packed, like sardines,
00:45pushing and shoving just to get the cleanest shot. One person behind me actually shouted,
00:50put your phone down, and I'm pretty sure they were the only person in Soho not recording the
00:55countdown. It was so noticeable that host Laura Whitmore clocked it on stage, not once, but twice.
01:00Look at the phones, everyone else. And then again, moments later, when Baby Joel singer Jamie
01:05Miller joined her on stage. So London, run! The phones are off. They're both incredible, thank you.
01:11Honestly, a part of me genuinely felt bad that he wasn't performing to a crowd of people,
01:16he was performing to a wall of smartphones. The most ironic part? This year's display is called
01:20Press Play on Christmas, inspired by the 90s. Organizers say it's meant to celebrate a time
01:25when culture was experienced together in person, and Christmas was all about shared,
01:31spontaneous moments. Laura even said as much right before the switch on.
01:35We're going back to the time, folks. A time in shopping brings us all together,
01:39not just scrolling online. And I go to every single one of your faces here, because that's what it's all
01:44about. Except she wasn't looking out to a sea of faces. She was looking out to a sea of screens.
01:55And again, hypocritical for me, because I too was filming. But since the clips have blown up online,
02:00people have compared the whole scene to an episode of Black Mirror, with EastEnders legend Natalie
02:04Cassidy calling it scary and depressing that nobody was watching the display with their own eyes.
02:10Interestingly, psychologists actually have a name for what happens when we do this. It's called
02:14photo-taking impairment, where relying on a camera to capture a moment stops your brain from properly
02:19remembering it. Now, maybe some people wanted a keepsake to send to family who couldn't be there.
02:24But having grown up on social media myself, I know firsthand how we use it as a highlights reel.
02:30It's the whole pics or it didn't happen mentality. But it makes me wonder who these videos are actually
02:35for and what they're trying to prove. Because if we're so busy trying to show off what a cool night
02:40we're having, it raises some pretty big questions. Did we actually even see it? And were we really even
02:45there?

Recommended