00:00And joining me on the show tonight, Sanjay Kumar, former Indian High Commissioner to Canada and former Indian Ambassador to
00:05Japan.
00:06Ambassador, does this Italian leader in question, Giacomo Filibeck, Secretary General of the Party of European Socialists,
00:18he raised Rahul Gandhi's political slogan at this conference, which is called Bharat Conference.
00:23Do you see this crossing the line from international solidarity into interference in India's domestic politics?
00:34Absolutely it does. And Mr. Filibeck is not even an elected representative or member of parliament in Italy.
00:45So therefore, whatever he says should not be taken as the voice of Italy because he's unelected.
00:51He's just Secretary General of a political party, a party of European Socialists.
01:00In fact, there is one Miss Bergamini, who is from Forza Italia, which is a coalition partner of Prime Minister
01:11Milne's government.
01:14She has come out very strongly against it.
01:17And she has clearly said that Mr. Filibeck had no business in interfering with India's internal affairs.
01:25According to you, Ambassador, what diplomatic message does this send when a foreign political functionary uses an Indian platform to
01:34question the state of Indian democracy?
01:39It's bad in precedence. It's immature in diplomacy.
01:46And therefore, I will not put too much emphasis on this.
01:50He is not Italian-wise in any case.
01:52So why should we even put so much emphasis on what he said?
01:56The government has flagged a possible violation of conference visa conditions.
02:01Could this escalate into a diplomatic issue between India and Italy?
02:04And what are the implications, according to you?
02:08I do not foresee it escalating into a diplomatic issue between India and Italy.
02:15It is completely between the state of India and Mr. Filibeck, who has violated the conditions of the conference visa.
02:24So could you really elaborate for our viewers, how is this really a violation of conference visa?
02:32Because, you know, in the conference and the purpose of this visa did not allow him to interfere in the
02:39domestic affairs of India.
02:41Ambassador Sanjay Kumar, can a foreign political leader openly align himself with one side of India's political contest without undermining
02:50diplomatic conventions?
02:54It is undermining a diplomatic protocol.
02:57It is undermining of the maturity which a political leader must display.
03:03But at the same time, it is a violation of the visa conditions.
03:07You cannot go to a country and publicly interfere in the domestic affairs of the country.
03:13You know, many are asking this question also, and I perhaps as a former ambassador, you will be able to
03:19answer this.
03:20How is a speech really an interference with domestic political issues of India?
03:27No, the speech itself is not.
03:29The content of the speech is.
03:31And the content is very clear that he was trying to say that India is not a function, mature democracy,
03:40which itself is an interference in India's internal affairs.
03:46So, therefore, he may align with any political party.
03:51That's the business between the two political parties.
03:53But on a public platform in India, no foreigner can participate in the disruption of the domestic affairs in India.
04:05Does this incident expose a larger trend of European political groups seeking to influence political narratives in countries like India,
04:14such as ours?
04:16I would say India is very well respected in Europe, and that's why you are seeing India, European Union, FTA,
04:22very much on the envelope.
04:24So, I will not say that Europe has got anything against India.
04:28There could be sporadic European political parties, which do not have the best interest of European Union, India relations in
04:38their mind.
04:39Last couple of questions, Ambassador.
04:41Should India consider a formal diplomatic protest?
04:48It can, but does it serve any purpose?
04:51Because he is an individual.
04:53He is not an elected leader in Italy.
04:56He doesn't represent the government of Italy.
04:58So, I don't see any point in registering a diplomatic protest.
05:01But yes, the individual, if the violation is established, then he should be dealt with the law-governing visa violations.
05:12Okay.
05:13Let me try and sum this up for our viewers, Ambassador Sanjay Kumar.
05:18What does this controversy tell us about diplomatic conventions and protocol?
05:25So, one thing is very clear that whosoever is the organizer of any such conference, in this case Bharat Summit
05:312026, has to make it clear to the foreign participants that they do not have political rights in India, and
05:37therefore they should not try to interfere in elected matters of the elected governance in India.
05:43So, India is the largest electorate in the world, 970 million voters.
05:49So, therefore, no one should question that.
05:52As far as the principles are concerned, there could be debate discussions.
05:56But again, no foreign citizen is allowed to interfere in India's internal affairs on a valid visa, which doesn't mandate
06:07him or her to do so.
06:09All right, Ambassador Sanjay Kumar, pleasure speaking to you.
06:12Thank you for joining us and putting this story in context as far as protocol and convention are concerned.