Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 days ago
If your axe keeps sticking in the wood, sharpening the edge may be making the real problem worse. The key is often the shape of the steel behind the edge: a convex cheek pushes wood apart, while a flattened ramp can grip the split and trap the axe.

Learn how to check for a dull edge in daylight, restore the curve with a file, and finish sharpening with an axe puck—without overheating the steel on a powered grinder. This practical woodworking and hand-tool guide also explains why scythe blades are peened and honed differently, plus essential axe safety. For anyone splitting firewood or maintaining traditional tools, discover axe sharpening, convex edge restoration, wood-splitting tips, and the difference between a sharp edge and a well-shaped axe.
Transcript
00:00You bring the axe down and it buries itself in the round and stops dead.
00:05And now you are doing the thing everybody does, which is rocking it back and forth,
00:10putting a boot on the log, lifting the whole lot up, and slamming it down again to shake the head
00:16loose.
00:17Three or four swings of real work to get one swing back out.
00:22So you decide it is blunt and you go and sharpen it, and it does exactly the same thing on
00:28the next round.
00:30I am Elias Yoder, and I have promised you this one more times than I care to count.
00:36So here it is at last, and I am going to start by telling you that your axe is probably
00:42not blunt at all.
00:44A knife cuts by slicing. The edge parts the thing and the blade follows through the gap it made.
00:51That is why a knife can be thin all the way back, and why the thinner it is, the better
00:57it cuts.
00:58An axe is not doing that. An axe is a wedge you are throwing.
01:04The edge starts the split, and then everything behind the edge has to push the two halves of that round
01:11apart and keep pushing until it lets go.
01:14So the edge is about a tenth of the job, and the shape behind the edge is the other nine
01:21-tenths, and that shape is the part you have never once looked at.
01:26My grandfather sorted this out for me in about four seconds when I was fifteen.
01:32I was swinging at a piece of elm and complaining that the wood was hard, and he came over and
01:38took the axe off me, and he did not look at the edge at all.
01:42He turned it sideways and looked at the flat of it, down near the cutting end.
01:47Then he handed it back and said the wood was fine.
01:51You have been sharpening the wrong inch.
01:54Sharp is not one thing. Each tool wants its own kind of sharp.
02:00Sharp. I gathered the whole of it into a book at EliasYoder.com.
02:06The book is the long version. If you want it, it is there. I will not mention it again.
02:13What he meant was this.
02:14I had been doing to that axe exactly what I had been taught to do to a knife.
02:20I had been laying the bevel flat on a stone and rubbing it until I had a thin, keen edge.
02:26And every time I did it, I was taking a little more off the cheeks and making the whole end
02:32of that axe flatter.
02:34And a flat axe is a wedge with straight sides.
02:38And a wedge with straight sides grips.
02:41It goes in, the wood closes on the flats, and it stays there.
02:47Which is precisely what a splitting wedge is designed to do,
02:51and precisely what you do not want from a tool you have to get back out of the log 20
02:57times a minute.
02:58So before anything else, let us find out whether yours is actually blunt,
03:04because half of you are about to fix a problem you do not have.
03:091. Take it out into daylight and turn the edge up toward the sky and look along it.
03:162. Do not touch it.
03:183. A sharp edge has nowhere for the light to land, so it disappears.
03:234. A dull edge has a tiny flat on it where the two sides have rounded off and failed to
03:30meet,
03:30and that flat catches the light and shows you a thin, bright line all the way along.
03:375. That is the whole test, and it has never been wrong.
03:426. Bright line, it is dull.
03:447. No line, it is sharp.
03:478. And if it is sharp and still sticking, then your problem is the shape and not the edge,
03:53and the rest of this video is for you.
03:569. Now look at it the way my grandfather did.
04:00Hold it sideways so you are looking at the flat of the head,
04:04and look at the last inch or two before the edge.
04:0710. What you want to see is a gentle swelling.
04:1111. The steel should curve outward as it comes down to the edge,
04:15like the side of an apple seed, fattest in the middle of that last inch,
04:20and then rolling in to meet the edge.
04:2311. What most people have instead is two straight ramps running down to a point,
04:29because that is what a stone does to it over the years.
04:3212. The curved one is called a convex edge, and every axe worth owning came out of the factory with
04:40one.
04:4113. The straight one is what we do to them afterwards.
04:4514. And here is why the curve matters, because it sounds like a fussy detail, and it is the whole
04:53business.
04:5415. A convex cheek is always pushing the wood away from itself.
04:5915. At every depth, the wood is riding on a surface that is turning away,
05:03so it never gets to settle against a flat and grip.
05:0716. It goes in, it splits, and it comes back out.
05:1116. A flat cheek is the opposite.
05:1417. The deeper it goes, the more the wood lies flat along it,
05:18and wood that is lying flat along steel is holding on.
05:2217. That is the entire difference between an axe that works and an axe that fights you,
05:2717. And nobody has ever mentioned it to you.
05:3018. Four. So, putting it right.
05:3319. You want a file, and specifically a flat mill file, about 10 inches, which costs very little,
05:40and will outlast you. The stone comes later, and it cannot do this part.
05:4519. Secure the axe. In a vise, if you have one, head up.
05:4920. If you do not, lay it flat on a block with the head hanging over the edge and your
05:55boot on the handle,
05:5520. And work with the edge pointing away from you.
05:5920. Five. Now file the cheeks, not the edge.
06:0320. You are going to take metal off that last inch and a half behind the cutting edge,
06:0720. More in the middle of that band, and less as you come toward the edge itself,
06:1220. And that is what builds the curve back.
06:1521. Push the file, lift it, bring it back through the air, push again.
06:1921. A file only cuts going forward, and dragging it back under pressure dulls it,
06:2522. And does nothing for the axe. Work toward the edge, never away from it.
06:3022. Go slowly and turn it over often so both sides come back the same.
06:3523. Compare it against the shape of a new axe if you can lay hands on one,
06:3923. Or against the butt end of a wooden wedge, which is near enough the same curve.
06:4323. How do you know when you have gone far enough?
06:4624. Lay something straight across the cheek, the flat of the file will do,
06:5125. Running from the edge back toward the eye.
06:5324. If it sits flat against the steel all the way, you still have a ramp, and you have more
06:58to do.
06:5925. When the curve is right, you will see daylight under the middle of it, while the two ends touch.
07:0526. And be ready for the first one to take you a while.
07:0826. On an axe that has been flattened by 20 years of stone, you are looking at the best part
07:13of an hour
07:13with a file, and your arm will know about it. That is a one-time job. Once the shape is
07:19right,
07:2027. Every sharpening after it is a few minutes with the puck, and nothing more, because you are
07:25maintaining a curve instead of fighting one. 26. Only when the shape is right do you bring
07:31out a stone, and the right one is a round axe puck with a coarse side and a fine side.
07:37It costs about
07:38$10. Wet it, start with the coarse side, and work in small circles following the curve of the cheek,
07:4627. Both sides evenly. Then turn it over and do the same with the fine side. You are not changing
07:53the shape anymore at this stage. You are only polishing what the file left. 27. And here is the
08:00thing that will surprise you most. Stop before it is razor sharp. An axe edge that will shave hair off
08:06your arm with no effort is too thin for the work. It will roll over on the first knot, chip
08:12on the first
08:13bit of frozen wood, and then you are back at the file for an hour. You want it keen enough
08:18to shave
08:18with some effort, and no more than that. Sharp and tough, not sharp and delicate. The test I use costs
08:26nothing and does not involve your arm. Hold a thumbnail up and draw the edge very lightly across it,
08:32not along it. A properly sharp axe catches and wants to bite into the nail. A dull one slides across
08:39without
08:40catching. That is the whole of it, and when it catches cleanly along the full length, stop. That is the
08:47difference between a tool you use and a tool you look after. A kitchen knife gets looked after. An axe
08:53gets used. 8. Now the rule I most want you to take away, and it is the only thing in
09:00this video you
09:00cannot undo. Never put an axe on a powered grinder. That steel was hardened and then tempered, carefully, at the
09:08works, and the hardness in it lives at a temperature. A bench grinder puts an edge past that temperature
09:14in seconds, and you will watch it happen. The steel goes straw colored, then bronze, then blue, and the
09:22moment it is blue, the hardness in that part is gone, and it is gone forever. No amount of later
09:30sharpening
09:31brings it back, because there is nothing left to sharpen. You will have an edge that goes dull again
09:37in 10 minutes for the rest of that axe's life. A file cannot do that. A stone cannot do that.
09:45Only heat
09:46can, and a file and a stone make no heat. That is the whole reason the old way is the
09:53right way here,
09:54and it is not sentiment. If a man offers to put your axe on a wheel for you, take it
10:01home.
10:029. And while you have it in your hands, look at the head and the handle where they meet. If
10:10there
10:10is any movement in it at all, deal with that before you ever swing it again. I went through hanging
10:17a
10:17head and wedging it properly in the video about the things a farmer repairs, so I will leave that one
10:24there, except to say that a loose head is a different order of danger from a dull edge.
10:31Now, the scythe, which is an entirely different creature, and which almost nobody alive knows how
10:38to do. 10. A scythe blade is not sharpened the way anything else is sharpened. It is hammered. The
10:48working edge of a good scythe is thinner than you would believe, thinner than a kitchen knife,
10:53and you cannot get it that thin by grinding it away because there would be nothing left. So you do
11:00not take metal off. You move it. The blade goes on a small anvil, and you tap along the last
11:08few
11:08millimeters of the edge with a hammer, cold, working your way along the whole length. The steel spreads
11:16under the hammer and draws out thinner, and it work hardens as it goes, so the edge you finish with
11:23is
11:23both thinner and harder than the one you started with. That is peening, and it is how it has been
11:31done for several hundred years. There are two ways to do it. The old way is a peening anvil driven
11:38into a
11:39block, and a cross-peen hammer, and it is all judgment. Light blows, a great many of them,
11:47overlapping, keeping the same distance back from the edge the whole way along. Too hard, and you will
11:54stretch it into waves. Too far back, and you are doing nothing. A man who has done it for thirty
12:01years
12:02makes it look like nothing at all, which is the usual sign that it is not. The other way is
12:09a
12:09peening jig, which is a little device with a cap and a pin that you drive with an ordinary hammer,
12:15and it does the judging for you by controlling how far the steel moves. If you have never peened anything
12:23in your life, get the jig. It costs a modest amount, it is very hard to go wrong with, and
12:30you can learn the
12:31freehand way afterwards on a blade you do not mind spoiling.
12:3711. And then you hone, constantly. A whetstone lives in a holder on your hip with water in it,
12:45and you stop every few minutes of mowing and draw it along the edge a few strokes aside and carry
12:52on.
12:5311. Mowing with a scythe is mostly walking and stopping, and the stopping is this. The stroke matters.
13:02The stone lies nearly flat against the blade, not up on an angle the way you would hold it to
13:09a knife,
13:09and you draw it from the back of the blade out toward the edge, following the curve, alternating sides as
13:17you go.
13:1712. A few strokes each side is plenty. Keep the stone wet, which is what the water in the holder
13:24is for,
13:25because a dry stone glazes over and stops cutting. If you find yourself leaning on it, the edge has gone
13:33too far and wants peening rather than honing. That is the signal. People see somebody mow with a scythe
13:42and think the skill is in the swing. The skill is in the edge, and the swing is easy once
13:49the edge is
13:50right. How often you peen depends on the grass and the ground, but think in terms of a few hours
13:57of
13:57mowing and not a few minutes. The honing is the frequent one. 12. And one thing to know before you
14:07pick up a hammer. There are two very different blades out there. The thin European sort, the Austrian
14:15pattern, is the one that is peened. The heavier American blade is thicker steel of a different
14:21sort, and it is filed, more like the axe, and you will do it no good at all by hammering
14:27it. So find out
14:28which you have before you start. If the edge is thin enough to flex between your fingers, it is the
14:35peened
14:36kind. If it is stiff and heavy, it wants a file. And across both of these tools, a word on
14:43being
14:43careful, because sharp things get respect, and dull things get people hurt. A dull axe is more dangerous
14:52than a sharp one, which sounds backwards and is not. A sharp axe bites where you put it. A dull
14:59one
14:59glances off and goes somewhere you were not expecting, usually toward your own leg, and that is how
15:06most axe injuries happen. Test an edge by drawing your thumb gently across it, never along it. Keep
15:14the blade pointed away from you, whatever you are doing to it. Put a cover on a scythe blade the
15:20moment
15:21it leaves your hand, because a bare one lying in grass is the worst thing on any farm.
15:28Now, who gains from the fact that none of this is common knowledge anymore?
15:33Go and look at what is on sale for sharpening. Pull through gadgets with little carbide wheels in
15:39them, electric sharpeners, systems with jigs and clamps and angle guides. Every one of them is built
15:46around the idea that there is one correct angle and the job is to hold it. That is a knife
15:53idea. It is a good
15:54idea for a knife and it is sold to you for everything, because a jig can be manufactured and a
16:01judgment
16:01cannot. There is no product that puts a convex curve on an axe, and there is certainly no product that
16:09peens a scythe, and so neither of those things gets mentioned in any shop you will ever walk into.
16:16Nobody is deceiving anybody. The tools that can be sold are the tools that get talked about,
16:22and the knowledge that cannot be packaged quietly stops being passed on. That is worse than a
16:30conspiracy, because a conspiracy can be exposed. It is just that a file and a judgment do not have a
16:37marketing department. And here is the part that has stayed with me since I was 15. My grandfather did
16:44not teach me anything about sharpening that afternoon. He taught me to look at a different part of the
16:50tool. I had spent a year looking at the last 30 seconds of an axe, and he turned it sideways
16:57and
16:57showed me the inch behind it. Nearly everything I know about this kind of work is that same move.
17:04The window is not the problem. The air in the house is. The icicle is not the problem. The attic
17:12is.
17:13The sill is not the problem. The ground is. The edge is not the problem. The inch behind the edge
17:21is.
17:21It is one habit, not 40 pieces of knowledge. And the habit is to look one step back from whatever
17:29is annoying you. And I think the reason it keeps working is that the thing in front of you is
17:35always
17:36the thing that moves. The edge is where the cutting happens, so the eye goes there. The window is where
17:43the water appears. The icicle is the only part you can see from the road. Whatever is loudest gets the
17:51attention. And the cause is nearly always one quiet step behind it, not doing anything dramatic at all.
17:59A man who learns that about one tool has learned it about a house and a farm and most of
18:06the rest
18:06of it besides. My grandfather was not teaching me about axes that afternoon any more than he was
18:13teaching me about elm. Sharp is not one thing. Each tool wants its own kind of sharp.
18:20So go and get your axe out of wherever it lives, take it into the daylight and turn the edge
18:26up to the sky.
18:28Then turn it sideways and look at the inch behind the edge. Two minutes and most of you are going
18:35to
18:35find a wedge where a curve ought to be. Then come down to the comments and tell me what you
18:41found.
18:43Bright line or no bright line and curve or two flat ramps because I would like to know how many
18:50of you
18:50have been sharpening the wrong inch for years the way I was. And tell me what you actually cut with.
18:58An axe,
18:59a mall, a chainsaw, or nothing yet. I have a feeling the answers are going to be more mixed than
19:06people expect.
19:07Next time I want to talk about buying cheap ground because everything I have said today is about looking at
19:13the
19:13part nobody looks at and a piece of land going cheap is the purest example of that there is.
19:20Thank you for sitting with me. Go and look at the inch behind the edge.
19:25The people who built this country with their hands knew that, and we are only just starting to remember it.

Recommended