Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 days ago
From a pope who put a dead predecessor on trial to one who sold the papacy, history’s worst popes left behind scandals worthy of a political thriller. This historical commentary weighs cruelty, personal corruption, political chaos, and lasting damage to the Catholic Church, examining figures including Stephen VI, John XII, Benedict IX, and Leo X. Their stories reveal how papal power, family ambition, greed, and the sale of indulgences helped shape the Church—and how Leo X’s policies contributed to the Protestant Reformation. Explore medieval and Renaissance papal history, Vatican scandals, and the debate over who deserves the title of worst pope in history.

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00Picking the worst pope in history is surprisingly difficult, my friends.
00:04Not because they were all saints, but because the competition is just so stiff.
00:10Forget your average workplace drama.
00:12The Vatican has seen plots and scandals that would make a soap opera blush.
00:17So grab your holy water and buckle up, because today we're digging through the dirtiest
00:23laundry in all of Christendom.
00:25Now, with nearly 300 popes stretching back 2,000 years, there's a lot of candidates
00:32to choose from and plenty of sins of which they are guilty.
00:36But this leads us to a tricky question.
00:39What does it mean to be the worst pope?
00:42Do we judge our candidates by the sheer scale of their personal depravity, or by their catastrophic
00:48political blunders, or perhaps by the lasting damage they inflicted on the Catholic Church
00:54itself?
00:55To be clear, there are strong contenders in each category.
00:59We have your garden variety sexual deviancy, venerable heaps of abuse and murder, and the
01:06odd heresy here and there.
01:08So to make the cut in this ranking, popes had to have performed some truly vile acts.
01:14Perhaps the vilest was committed towards the end of the 9th century by Pope Stephen VI.
01:20Unlike most other popes in this list, he wasn't known for his debauchery, but rather for his
01:27cruelty.
01:28He was a bitter enemy of his predecessor, Pope Formosus.
01:32So after becoming pope, Stephen called together a special synod to judge his already dead arch-nemesis.
01:40He dug up Formosus' corpse, put it on trial, and after it failed to defend itself against
01:46the levied accusations, found it guilty.
01:50He then cut off Formosus' fingers and threw whatever was left of him into the Tiber River.
01:57This wasn't the end of this ghastly ordeal though, since Formosus' corpse washed up ashore,
02:03and supposedly healed the fisherman who retrieved it.
02:06Before long, the whole of Rome was up in arms, and Pope Stephen was deposed, imprisoned and
02:13finally strangled, a very fitting end for the man who we here at Sidequest award as the cruelest
02:20pope.
02:21If we swing in the other direction, however, we can find a very long list of popes who
02:26did not shy away from enjoying the finer pleasures of life.
02:29As we all know, the Catholic Church enforces a strict law of celibacy upon its clerics.
02:36But what happens when the man at the top stops practicing what he should preach?
02:41We get a pope like John XII who took up the reins of the papacy at the ripe old age
02:47of 18.
02:49He came from a powerful family of Roman nobles and had already acquired a taste for fine wine
02:55and finer women by the time his father secured his election as Pope.
03:00The new job title didn't sober him up.
03:03In fact, he turned the Lateran Palace into a brothel that housed more mistresses than it
03:09did ministers.
03:11John racked up large debts by gambling and hosting feast after feast for his family and lovers,
03:18two groups that sometimes overlapped.
03:21In some legends, the papacy was actually said to have been run by one of his mistresses,
03:27a woman named Joan, which is a curious story that we covered in another side quest from
03:33way back when.
03:35In any case, John's scandalous pontificate lasted nearly a full decade before his sins
03:41finally caught up to him.
03:43As the story goes, a nobleman found John bedding his wife and proceeded to beat the pope so badly
03:50that he perished from his wounds a few days later.
03:54But while John XII's papacy was perhaps the lewdest of them all, which, to be clear,
04:00is a very closely contested race, another pope desecrated the institution in a very different
04:06way.
04:06Allow me to bring to your attention Pope Benedict IX who, according to some historians, beats
04:13John by just a few years to claim the title of youngest pope in history, having been elected
04:19when he was just twelve.
04:22Benedict was, in fact, the grand-nephew of John XII and the nephew of the immediately
04:28preceding pope.
04:29As befits his outrageous family, Benedict's reign was spicy from the start, with his father
04:35having secured his election through bribery.
04:38While not quite as sexually prolific, his rule routinely featured torture, robbery and
04:45murder.
04:46And after twelve painfully long years, the Romans finally got sick of him and forced him out.
04:53Not one to go down without a fight, Benedict returned six months later with an army at his
04:59back, becoming the first pope in history to be elected more than once after he deposed his
05:05short-lived successor.
05:06A mere two months later, however, Benedict had a sudden realization that his cousin was
05:12extremely attractive and that he wanted to give up the papacy so that he could marry her.
05:18The rapidly deteriorating political situation in Rome probably also helped with his decision.
05:24But Benedict, being the smart lad that he was, didn't just abdicate his position as pope.
05:30No.
05:31In order to set himself and his sweetheart up with a nice cosy retirement in Alban Hills,
05:37he decided to sell it.
05:40And so, on the 1st of May 1045, Benedict became the first and only pope to sell the papacy.
05:48To his godfather, for one thousand pounds of silver.
05:51This proved to be a timely exit, as the very next year the Holy Roman Emperor finally had
05:58had enough of these pontifical shenanigans and crossed the Alps to restore order.
06:03He had Benedict's godfather deposed and installed a German pope in Rome, which should have been
06:10the end of this story.
06:11But Benedict just didn't know when to quit, so he waited patiently for the new pope to
06:17expire from natural causes, before making a third grab at the papacy.
06:23This final pontificate lasted just over six months before the Germans definitively kicked
06:29him out into relative obscurity.
06:31We know that Benedict died no later than 1056, supposedly repentant, but we'll probably
06:38never know for sure.
06:40Yet while Benedict did a good job of ruining Rome's political stability for a good two decades,
06:46we can look towards the early 16th century for the pope who arguably dealt the most damage
06:52to the Catholic Church as a whole.
06:55But speaking of dealing damage, you can partake in massive damage dealing on the high seas
07:00with today's sponsor, World of Warships Legends.
07:05Command great historically accurate warships from 11 different nations in this fierce naval
07:11game of strategy and cunning.
07:13You can play with your friends across PlayStation, Xbox and mobile, engaging in epic 9v9 battles
07:19or 12 player battle royales across more than 20 different maps.
07:25More content and ships get added every month, from nimble destroyers to impenetrable battleships,
07:31so the excitement never stops.
07:33World of Warships Legends has already amassed over 8 million players and now is the best time
07:41to join with the game's new 4th of July update.
07:45It has a ton of new American themed content, including the legendary tier Louisiana battleship
07:51with monstrous 406mm guns and deadly torpedo airstrikes.
07:57You can earn all sorts of rewards during this limited time event, from unique camouflages
08:03to the powerhouse legendary cruiser Puerto Rico.
08:07So if you want to experience the full thrill of naval combat and to deal some serious naval
08:12damage, download World of Warships Legends for free by clicking on the link in the description.
08:19Now back to a different kind of damage, the kind inflicted on the Catholic Church.
08:24The man who dealt it is Pope Leo X, who hailed from the stupendously wealthy Florentine banking
08:31family the Medici.
08:33What was even more stupendous was Leo's profligate spending.
08:38Despite his own personal wealth and the papacy's worldwide income, he managed to drain the Catholic
08:44Church's coffers dry.
08:46He fought costly wars in Italy to carve out kingdoms for his brother and nephew, even diverting
08:52funds from a planned crusade against the Ottoman Turks.
08:56Now, to Leo's credit, some of his exorbitant spending did go towards the arts.
09:03He sponsored some of Raphael's most famous paintings, commissioned many sculptures from
09:08Michelangelo and even partially rebuilt St. Peter's Basilica.
09:13To pay for all this, Pope Leo had to resort to some truly desperate measures like pawning
09:19off the papal jewels and the Vatican's furniture.
09:22But, by far, his greatest feat of financial wizardry was his widespread sale of indulgences.
09:30To be clear, the concept of paying the church for salvation predates Leo by several centuries,
09:37yet he took the idea and turned it into a fat and luscious cash cow.
09:44Leo sold indulgences all across Europe from Portugal to Sweden, but especially in Germany, raking
09:51in vast sums of money that nevertheless vanished from papal coffers as quickly as they appeared.
09:58The Germans quickly caught on that their tithes weren't going where they were supposed to,
10:03and in 1517 Martin Luther wrote 95 theses against Pope Leo and his corrupt indulgences.
10:12Pope Leo had just concluded a council pushing for reform, so he was in no mood to change his
10:19indulgence practices. In fact, he intensified them in the years that followed and branded Martin Luther
10:26as a heretic. Before long, Luther was preaching his own brand of Christianity, and the Protestant
10:33Reformation was in full swing precisely in the territories where Leo had peddled his indulgences the most.
10:40The worst part is that all the indulgences were ultimately for nothing, as upon his death in
10:47December 1521, Leo left the papacy in more debt than it had ever been up to that point.
10:54So, through his unbridled greed, Pope Leo precipitated the greatest schism in the history of the Catholic
11:01Church, far beyond the damage any other pope managed to inflict. Now, you'll notice that one pope keeps coming up
11:09with the
11:09silver medals in our unholy ranking, Alexander VI, also known as Rodrigo Borgia. His spicy
11:19story touches on almost all the sins we've covered so far, and while he didn't truly excel in
11:25any category, his story is nevertheless so interesting that we might just cover it in another one of
11:31our pontifical sidequests. But until then, my friends, I hope you'll send your prayers, and perhaps an indulgence
11:38or two, on our Patreon. Stay blessed and stay tuned for the next sanctimoniously transactional episode of
11:47SideQuest.
11:50How does the Pope make holy water? He boils the hell out of it!
11:55And then on to the next minute, Google asks a split-up thing in yourents when the Pope
11:55You know, what I do sly have a little link, I don't know.

Recommended