Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 7 months ago
From power-hungry tyrants to corrupt leaders, the papal throne has seen its share of scandalous occupants. Join us as we count down history's most controversial pontiffs who damaged the Church's reputation! These unholy fathers turned the sacred office into platforms for personal gain, military campaigns, and even bizarre posthumous trials.
Transcript
00:00Everything I heard about you was true. It is disgusting.
00:04Is there anything you wish to add to your list of crimes against this most holy of offices before I tell the world?
00:10Welcome to WatchMojo, where we'll be looking at history's least pious popes ever.
00:16Leo transformed Rome into a cultural center and political power, but he depleted the papal treasury in the process.
00:22Julius II. Also known as the Warrior Pope, Julius II ruled the papal states from 1503 to 1513.
00:33As an artistic patron, he was incredibly successful.
00:36This included him commissioning Michelangelo to paint the Sistine Chapel, among other magnificent projects, which all cost a fortune.
00:43He was also responsible for aggressive military campaigns, personally leading troops into battle, which was highly contentious for a pope.
00:51His rule was more focused on politics and war instead of piety.
00:55Julius' actions thus deepened Europe's religious crisis, which led to Martin Luther's revolt and the Protestant Reformation.
01:02So while he was a highly influential Renaissance figure, he wasn't exactly a good pope.
01:07Clement VII. Ten years after Julius II's death, Clement VII became the papal state's ruler.
01:14He's often considered history's most unfortunate pope, ruling at a particularly tumultuous time.
01:19He inherited the papal states while the Protestant Reformation was picking up steam, which led to an immense power struggle.
01:25Within eight years of Luther's 95 Theses, you're already beginning to see those tensions, those political, social tensions within Protestantism,
01:35which begin to spill out for the next hundreds of years.
01:38Both France and the Holy Roman Empire demanded his allegiance, which led to the sack of Rome in 1527.
01:45Another major blunder included largely ignoring the Protestant Reformation.
01:49This spiraled further out of control when he refused to let Henry VIII divorce his wife, Catherine of Aragon.
01:55He wants to leave his wife Catherine of Aragon and marry his lover Anne Boleyn.
02:01But Pope Clement VII refuses to annul his marriage.
02:04As a result, the Tudor king broke away from the Catholic Church.
02:08Boniface VIII.
02:09Despite being fairly intelligent, his papacy was controversial and immensely disastrous.
02:14The Bishop of Rome, Miss Holiness, Pope Boniface.
02:19One of his biggest blunders was the Unam Sanctum in 1302, which proclaimed, quote,
02:24"...it is absolutely necessary for salvation that every human creature be subject to the Roman pontiff."
02:29This outraged almost everyone.
02:32Boniface took papal authority to the max, becoming obsessed with papal supremacy.
02:36This got him into a couple of conflicts with France, with Boniface excommunicating their king, Philip IV.
02:43To put it simply, submit or be damned.
02:48This caused the French to capture him in 1303.
02:52They locked him up for three days, alongside assaulting him.
02:55A month later, Boniface died a humiliated and broken man.
02:59John XII.
03:00When John became Pope, he may have been the youngest Pope in history.
03:04Historians estimate he was between 17 and 25 at the beginning of his rule.
03:09He mainly got the job because of his father, Alberic II of Spoleto, a Roman prince.
03:14As Pope, he turned the Lateran palace into what his contemporaries described as a brothel.
03:20Allegedly, he frequently committed adultery and debauchery.
03:23According to one source, he died while fornicating with another man's wife.
03:28To protect against the Lombards, he made King Otto I of Germany the Holy Roman Emperor.
03:33John quickly betrayed him, causing Otto to march on Rome and depose him, although he regained his position temporarily.
03:40Sergius III.
03:42Next, we have one of history's most corrupt popes.
03:45He ascended to the papal throne after being backed by the Theaphylact family, who dominated Rome during the 10th century.
03:51Sources claim he imprisoned and then murdered two ex-popes.
03:56Alongside this, he also supposedly fathered a child out of wedlock.
04:00Highly controversial for a pope.
04:02This child went on to become a pope himself.
04:04One of his most bizarre decisions was re-endorsing Stephen VI, who had gone so far as to put the corpse of Pope Formosus on trial.
04:13On the bright side, he rebuilt the Lateran palace, which had been destroyed by an earthquake.
04:18Urban VI.
04:19The Western Schism was a huge split among Catholics in the late 14th century.
04:24It centered around two rival popes, one in Avignon and another in Rome, both vying for supremacy.
04:30This started when Urban was elected under intense political pressure.
04:34A Roman contingent had demanded a Roman pope.
04:37But instead, they got the Neapolitan Urban.
04:39As pope, he was harsh and paranoid, which alienated his allies.
04:43This caused his cardinals to quickly declare his election invalid, thus creating the schism and a series of rival popes.
04:50At one point, Urban even had some cardinals executed.
04:53Instead of fixing the schism, Urban doubled down, making matters worse.
04:58In the end, he died after injuries received from falling off a mule at his jubilee celebrations.
05:04Leo X.
05:05As we've already established, the early 16th century was a bit of a write-off for Catholicism.
05:10Born to the prominent Medici family, Leo X used this reputation to become pope.
05:15He was more an arts patron than an ecclesiastical leader, holding court with pomp and extravagance to underline his power and glory.
05:23This pope from the powerful Medici family wasn't interested in theology.
05:29Since God has given us the papacy, he said, let us enjoy it.
05:33As such, he governed the church like a Renaissance prince instead of its spiritual leader.
05:38This led to him authorizing tons of indulgences, which were payments in exchange for the forgiveness of sins.
05:44This directly led to Martin Luther's 95 theses in 1517, alongside the subsequent Protestant Reformation.
05:51His 95 theses attacking corrupt church practices were quickly circulated across the country.
05:57The pope threatened Luther with excommunication, but Luther responded by publicly burning the bull.
06:02Instead of addressing papal corruption, he excommunicated Luther, thus providing more fuel to the opposition.
06:08So while he wasn't necessarily cruel, his negligence led to an enormous divide and to multiple wars in the following centuries.
06:15Benedict IX.
06:16Only one person has been pope more than once, and that's Benedict IX.
06:21The first time over, it was done because of his dad bribing the voters.
06:25His age isn't confirmed, but historians guess he would have been 20 when elected.
06:30He was forced out in 1044, but regained the papacy in 1045.
06:34Controversially, later in 1045, he sold the papacy to his godfather, John Crosham.
06:40This was because Benedict wanted to marry his cousin.
06:43Soon after, he regretted this choice.
06:45When his godfather's successor died in 1047, Benedict installed himself as pope by force.
06:51This didn't last long.
06:53German soldiers drove him out a few months later, and he vanished into obscurity.
06:57Alexander VI.
06:58Also known as Rodrigo Borgia, this pope was extremely infamous.
07:03He used the papacy to empower his family, the Borgias, who sought to dominate Italy.
07:08There are rumors spreading throughout the Vatican that you are debauched and corrupt and not fit to hold the office of pope.
07:16He gave his relatives powerful positions, making the church feel like a private family business.
07:21Alexander became pope through bribery, and then became increasingly corrupt during his reign.
07:25He sold titles to whoever bid the most, alongside encouraging his son to conquer Italy.
07:30At age 72, he died of what was claimed to be malaria.
07:39Alexander left behind a legacy that few admired, becoming a symbol of everything wrong with the late medieval church.
07:45Before we continue, be sure to subscribe to our channel and ring the bell to get notified about our latest videos.
07:51You have the option to be notified for occasional videos, or all of them.
07:55If you're on your phone, make sure you go into settings and switch on your notifications.
07:59After being dead for seven months, Pope Formosus was put on trial by the newly elected Pope Stephen VI.
08:10This, the rotting corpse, was placed on a throne, then assigned a deacon to speak on his behalf.
08:16Stephen sought to discredit Formosus' legacy by this bizarre spectacle.
08:19The result wasn't a shocker.
08:21The dead pope was found guilty, being unable to defend himself.
08:24This caused his papacy to be rendered null, which, understandably, horrified tons of people.
08:30This caused him to lose his position after less than two years.
08:33Stephen was sent to prison, where he was eventually strangled.
08:36Who do you think was the most respectable pope in history?
08:39Let us know in the comments below.
08:40There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
08:54There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
08:55There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
08:56There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
08:57There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
08:58There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
08:59There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
09:00There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
09:01There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
09:02There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
09:03There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
09:04There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
09:05There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
09:06There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
09:07There is no other office in the world like the papacy.
Comments

Recommended