00:00Engineer Jimmy, ito po bang nakalagay dyan na Barangay 74A Davao City, assessed value $82,046, market value, fair market
00:16value $2,051,150, 2024, sale $10,000,000.
00:22Yan po ba yung parehong property yung kanina pa niyo pinag-uusapan ni Atty. Lyndon na may kaugnayan sa TCT
00:29na nagtatapos sa 0775?
00:32Yes, Your Honor. That is the same property, Your Honor.
00:35Paano niyo nasabi yan?
00:36It is based on the tax declaration that was presented a while ago na nakalagay po doon yung 2,051
00:49,150 pesos that yung tax declaration na yun was cancelled after the sale.
00:59Naalala ko rin, binanggit niyo yung halagyang 82,046 na assessed value. Tama po ba?
01:04Yes, Your Honor.
01:06Ngayon, nakalagay sa deed of sale na pinresenta sa hukumang ito na 6 million lamang ang binayaran kaugnay sa property.
01:13Bakit po 10 million na nakalagay dito sa pananon ninyo? Ko alam niyo?
01:17I'm actually not aware, sir.
01:20Pero familiar kayo doon sa deed of sale na naglipat ng pangalan mula sa dating may-ari patungo sa mag
01:26-asawang Carpio?
01:27Based on the memoranda, nakalagay po doon na mayroong sale po.
01:31Na mayroong sale po?
01:33Yes, Your Honor.
01:33Pero hindi niyo po nakita yung date of sale?
01:37Probably during the transfer, usually, mayroong pong mga examination of document.
01:43That is why it is indicated in the memoranda na yung mga documents na in-attach po.
01:49Ngayon, maliban po doon sa fair market value at saka maliban doon sa assessed value na pinabanggit niyo, ano pa
01:56po ang basihan niyo kung meron man na itong Barangay 74A Davao City, residential lock, ayun nga pong 0075 nagtatapos
02:05na TCT.
02:06Kung meron pa po kayo mga ibang basihan.
02:08Meron po kaming basihan.
02:10And actually, we inquired from our comprehensive land use plan, where it is an ordinance, implementing the comprehensive land use
02:20plan.
02:22Nakalagay po doon, Matina Crossing, 74-A.
02:26And even in the Barangay office themselves, may mga pictures pong in-attach that Matina Crossing, nakalagay po doon Barangay
02:3774-A Matina Crossing.
02:41Ano pa po, kung meron pa?
02:44Again,
02:45Para sabihin, yun din po yun.
02:47Yun din yun.
02:48From the BCAD, meron din po kaming nirequest na certification.
02:52And it has been, kumbaga, parang naging common knowledge doon sa area na yung Matina Crossing is also the same
03:03with 74-A.
03:05Bakit po ba pinangala ng Matina Crossing yun?
03:09Based on our research, the name Matina Crossing is based on Republic 4354 issued in 1965.
03:26That meron na pong Matina Crossing, Matina Pangi, Matina… parang tatlo po yan.
03:35So, pangalan po ng Barangay Matina Crossing noon?
03:39Yes, Your Honor.
03:40Ngayon, ang pangalan na ng parehong barangay na yun na Matina Crossing ay Barangay 74-A.
03:45Pardon nyo, ano?
03:46Dati siyang Matina lang.
03:49Kumbaga, nagkaroon siya ng apelido.
03:51Nagkaroon ng Matina Crossing, Matina…
03:54And so, tatlo po yun.
03:55Tapos ngayon po, 74-A na ang pangalan ng barangay niya.
03:59Yes po.
03:59Pero iisa at parehong barangay lamang yun?
04:02Yes po.
04:03Okay.
04:04Your witness, attorney, Lyndon Ifeni.
04:06Your Honor.
04:08For the record, witness was confronted with the sal-en of the respondent as of December 31, 2024.
04:16May we also be allowed to confront the sal-en as of December 31, 2025, Your Honor.
04:23So, you're referring to lines, you do that, counsel.
04:27You're referring to the third and fourth to the last line of page three also.
04:33Correct, Your Honor.
04:34Proceed.
04:35Assisting counsel may approach the witness at any time.
04:42Please proceed, attorney Lyndon.
04:46Anong property po dyan, engineer, yung tugma o kaparehas ng assessed value at market value
04:57na sa mga tax declaration na in-identify mo kanina, sir?
05:02This leading owner, it assumes that there's a property there that corresponds with the property
05:08indicated in the TCT.
05:08If any, if any, counsel, if any, witness may answer.
05:16Pardon?
05:17Engineer Jimmy, pwede po isapagot.
05:20May katumbas po bang ari-arian dito sa salay na pinapakita sa inyo, yung mga in-identify
05:26yung dokumento kanina?
05:27Okay po, yung residential lot with a set value of $82,046, yun po yung pinakita kanina.
05:40And ito pong building commercial located in Barangay 74-A is the same dito po sa tax declaration
05:50na commercial building.
05:54And yung pong sa portion na binanggit nyo sa Salen, anong nakalagay na location nun sa statement of assets,
06:04liabilities and net worth?
06:06Ang location po?
06:07Anong location ng property na binanggit mo?
06:09Barangay 74-A, sir.
06:13Anong kinalaman ng Barangay 74-A sa Barangay Matina Crossing, kung meron man?
06:18Isa lang po yan sila.
06:20Isa lang.
06:21Okay, sir, so tama po na wala pong basihan yung sinasabi ng prosecution
06:27na hindi ito kabilang sa mga itiniklarang pag-aari ng vice-presidente sa kanyang Salen.
06:33The Honour of Objection will be supposed for an opinion.
06:36I will have to sustain the objection, counsel.
06:51I can all?
06:52The Honour of Portion says today, I'd not be able to inspire you.
06:52For more information Probably can also ignore you it.
