Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 months ago
The Morning Shift breaks down the Atlanta Falcons quarterback situation after Michael Penix Jr. was ruled inactive. Mike Johnson, Beau Morgan, and Ali Mac debate whether Tua Tagovailoa can handle T.J. Watt in the season opener, what Tua's biggest key to success will be in Pittsburgh, and what this decision means for the future of Michael Penix Jr.

Category

🥇
Sports
Transcript
00:00Look, it makes sense.
00:01I don't know exactly the stuff coming out of Pennix's camp.
00:05We'll get into that later.
00:07But, I mean, as far as this football team goes, this is the move, to me,
00:09that always made sense as far as T.J. Watt goes, as far as season openers go.
00:15I know that Tua had, you know, hiccups as far as the snap in the preseason games.
00:21But, man, he's a veteran player.
00:23He knows how to be efficient with the football.
00:25As long as he's not putting it in harm's way in week one,
00:27I think he gives you a chance to win.
00:29Yeah, protect the football is the number one goal he has.
00:33There's none.
00:34And it starts literally with something that has plagued him the entire training camp
00:39and preseason.
00:39And you mentioned it.
00:42I will be very interested to make sure.
00:44I don't know what the weather's going to be like.
00:46It was obviously super hot the last week.
00:48And I don't know if you guys noticed how many college football players,
00:52quarterbacks, I should say, had the chalk, like Rosen type, on their hands
00:57to help with their grip because of the humidity that has plagued the America,
01:02essentially, everywhere with heat.
01:04So I'll be interested to see how that plays out because that will be a big deal.
01:07I'm disappointed.
01:08I wanted to see Michael Pennick start of the season.
01:11He's been cleared physically.
01:14And this is obviously something where he's not – it doesn't feel like he's mentally ready,
01:20either with what they're trying to do, asking him to do physically,
01:23or just the totality of the situation.
01:27And I have to respect him for saying, hey, you know what,
01:31I'm not going to go out there and put myself over the team.
01:33Then again, I don't criticize guys who – I wouldn't be criticizing him if he played week one.
01:39And, you know, he said, well, I wasn't necessarily where I wanted to be mentally,
01:43but I wanted to play and not let my teammates down.
01:46I wouldn't – I don't have a problem with either one because I don't think either one
01:48or – when people say that either one is selfish, I have a hard time coming to grips with that
01:54if you understand – actually understand a team concept
01:57and wanting to go there and be there with your teammates.
02:02But Tua is our guy, and I said yesterday on my video I posted, we need to support him.
02:08Everything goes behind Tua now.
02:10And support him as everything we can because whatever happens with Pennick,
02:15we want to be winning football games when he decides he's ready.
02:17Yeah.
02:18Well, and I think that'll be the next question is if you do come out and win football games,
02:22is it just – is it that simple as slotting Pennick back in?
02:25Because I don't necessarily think it is.
02:26Well, it was for Tomlin a few years ago with Justin Fields and Russell Wilson.
02:32And he was like, no matter what, when Russell's ready, it's his job.
02:36I don't know if that's how this played out, but that was supposedly a competition.
02:41And that's the most recent one I can go back to where the guy was probably going to be
02:45the starter of healthy, and then he wasn't healthy.
02:48And you had to go with someone, and they did win football games.
02:51I'm not saying they're exactly the same, but that situation has played out.
02:58Yeah.
02:59To me, I don't necessarily think it's as simple because we just haven't seen Michael Pennick's
03:02in this offense.
03:03We haven't seen Michael Pennick's do anything, and that's seemingly Michael Pennick's choice.
03:08And so I do think if you come out and are somehow successful – I don't know if you will
03:12be,
03:12but if you're somehow successful in the first game, and two starts the second game, and that
03:16leads into the Thursday night game, and you're somehow 2-1 coming out of that, I think there's
03:21going to be some tough decisions to be made, in my opinion.
03:23But you think record's the only – I don't think you believe this, and I don't believe
03:28that record is the only determining factor.
03:29If you're 2-1, and you've won, and two has got average stats with more turnovers than
03:36touchdown passes, or however you want to slice it, I don't think it's necessarily, well,
03:41but we did win two games.
03:42I think your decision's made for you.
03:44I think it goes both ways.
03:45I think if Tua comes out and, you know, after three games is thrown for 7.50, you know,
03:52and yet you're 1-2, and, you know, the run defense hasn't stepped up to the plate.
03:58And I think that's – when you brought up the Justin Fields thing, I think that's exactly
04:01what I went to.
04:02Like, yeah, I think the opener two years ago was a prime example.
04:06They won that game.
04:07Justin Fields didn't do anything other than scramble for a few first downs, it felt like.
04:11And that's why I think that Russell Wilson's job was going to be safe all along.
04:15Well, I don't know.
04:16I don't disagree.
04:17He was really good on the outside from 7 to 10 yards, but anything further in the
04:22middle that was non-existent, I'm just joking around with that.
04:26But, look, I don't care who plays quarterback at the end of the day if the team
04:30wins.
04:30That's my ultimate goal.
04:31My number one thing was to say that you need to figure out what MPJ is this year.
04:39And if you don't do that, then I don't really know where you stand with that
04:44situation, especially if you're losing football games.
04:47Completely agree.
04:48It's easier to handle if you win, in other words.
04:51Well, and I know we're all the smartest guy in the room looking at hindsight, but you
04:54did see Tua getting all the preseason games.
04:57Pennix was cleared for 11-on-11.
04:58Still didn't feel comfortable playing that final game.
05:00So, the dots do connect.
05:02But were you surprised in how it came down?
05:05Because Tua is obviously QB1, and then Cooper rushes his backup, and Michael Pennix will
05:08be inactive.
05:09I know disappointed is definitely a word you felt, but were you surprised to see the
05:15swing of the pendulum like that?
05:18Personally, no.
05:19I mean, personally, no.
05:20I think I let out a tweet after the final preseason game.
05:23It was like, I saw one too many people, you know, after the game that were saying, I've
05:30seen enough of Tua.
05:31I've seen enough of Tua.
05:33Well, we haven't seen anything of Pennix.
05:35You know what I mean?
05:35Like, how can we see enough of Tua, and we haven't seen Pennix at all?
05:39It just, it's been a weird situation.
05:41I remember us having Dave Archer on when he was cleared, and it was like, yeah, he's
05:44got to play.
05:46You know, if we're going to have a quarterback competition, he's got to play.
05:48And once he didn't, I thought everything was on the table.
05:51I'm like, at that point, who even knows where this entire thing goes?
05:55I don't think you get a two-week ramp-up to the regular season, and then, like I've said
05:58all along, trot him out there against T.J.
06:00Watt in week one and say, all right, man, go get him.
06:02Like, I thought this was probably going to be the calculated play, for whatever reason,
06:09to me, that I saw, you know, coming the whole time.
06:12So, when knew you trot him out there?
06:13Because it's not like T.J.
06:14Watt's the only dominant pass rusher you'll face all year.
06:17I mean, it's not like you don't have a Bosa on there.
06:19Every team in this league has a guy, for the most part, that can come get after you.
06:24So, when do you, I understand the concept, but I think it's flawed in my mind that we're
06:32like, well, it's only two weeks.
06:33Well, then one is enough.
06:37And I don't believe, I'll be 100% with you, I believe this is Michael Penix's decision.
06:42I believe if he went out there and said, I'm ready to go, he'd be out there starting.
06:46So, I can't jump on board with saying, well, only because it was two weeks, you didn't
06:53want to trot him out there against T.J.
06:54Watt.
06:55I just, I can't go with that.
06:57And I don't, never discredit Mike.
06:59He played, he understands this way more than I do.
07:01It's just hard for me to hear that and say, well, so week two against Carolina, they got
07:06a pretty good pass rush.
07:08Week three, when you go to Green Bay, or do you wait till, what, week four against New
07:12Orleans, they got a pretty good pass rush.
07:14Or week five, Baltimore, like, when is it going to be?
07:18And so, to me, this is a decision where he said he doesn't feel comfortable, and I'm
07:25not sure what he needs to feel to feel comfortable.
07:29We're completely on the same page, and I think that's exactly what I mean.
07:33Like, I think that this has to be something where he feels comfortable, and I don't know
07:37how coming out of preseason that you're like, you know what, this is the one.
07:40You know, like, if he doesn't feel comfortable going in a preseason game, you know, after
07:44just a couple of days, and then you add, what, five practices to that, I was struggling with
07:49that.
07:50And look, I'd have been riding with Michael Penix.
07:53I think that Michael Penix, we've got to figure out what he is.
07:56But if you want to put everything surrounding him to where he can go out there and put his
08:00best foot forward, then you don't rush it, right?
08:02And if you guys remember, my projection three months ago was the fact that I think that there's
08:09going to be somebody starting the first four, and there was going to be somebody starting
08:12like the next eight, and then there was going to be somebody else to finish the season.
08:15And I still stand by that.
08:16I really feel like that's the way this was going to go all along.
08:19If that's the way it plays out, then you have no quarterback on this roster that you
08:22love.
08:24I would say that's probably fair.
08:25Because I don't want to, I'm not going to go to that projection, because ultimately
08:28that to me just says that you don't believe in either quarterback.
08:33Which I think you would, I don't know how you feel, and I know that you believe in
08:37Penix and everything else, but wouldn't you say that the odds are right now that you feel
08:42like this would be trending towards drafting somebody?
08:44Well, as we sit right now, we've got one quarterback that doesn't, that mentally doesn't feel
08:49comfortable playing, and the other guy that I don't necessarily feel comfortable with him
08:53playing, for a multitude of reasons.
08:55So yeah, you could definitely make that argument, but I'm not going to sit here and say that
09:00after 12 games I've given up on Michael Penix Jr. completely.
09:03If that's where you are, that's fine.
09:05I'm not going to argue with people over it anymore, but the reality is, is I'd like to
09:08see more from a guy than 12 games, because if you look around the league, there's quite
09:13a few quarterbacks who've been given up on, who have made playoffs, won Super Bowls, made
09:20NFC Championship games, you know, golf, Mayfield, Sam Darnold, people had wrote off Bryce Young.
09:28We still need to see more from him.
09:31If we're talking about we need to see more from Bryce Young, I'm not sure how you can write
09:34off Michael Penix Jr. yet.

Recommended