• 3 months ago
In this debate on Super Six, BJP spokesperson Bhaskar Rao and Congress spokesperson Bhavya Narasimhamurthy clash over the Karnataka government's decision to withdraw a proposed amendment affecting public park land in Bengaluru. Bhaskar Rao asserts that public uproar and BJP-led opposition forced a hasty retreat, stating, 'This Congress government has proposed. People of Bangalore have disposed. This government was under the mistaken assumption that parks are vacant government lands.' He accuses the ruling administration of pushing unscientific projects and neglecting public transport infrastructure. Defending the move, Bhavya Narasimhamurthy maintains that rolling back the amendment reflects a citizen-friendly democracy that listens to public sentiment and balances development with ecological concerns. Anchor Akshata questions both political representatives on infrastructure priorities and governance in Bengaluru.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Joining us on this broadcast to discuss what's really played out in the last few days
00:05and the political reactions is Bhaskar Rao, spokesperson of the Karnataka BJP.
00:09We've also got Bhavya Narasimhamurthy, national spokesperson of the Congress.
00:14Namaskara, good evening to both of you.
00:15Bhavya, I'd like to begin with you on what prompted this U-term.
00:19Will you concede, Bhavya, that there was considerable political and citizen pressure
00:23and that's what's led to this bill being withdrawn, the amendment?
00:28Isn't it a good thing?
00:29When we know citizens are not really, am I audible?
00:34Yes, yes.
00:35Isn't that a good thing?
00:36When you are a people-friendly government, it is important that we understand the pulse of the people
00:41and, you know, whatever we need to communicate, we need to do that through consultations,
00:47through discussions, through debates with, you know, civil society organizations,
00:51with the citizens, whoever is the stakeholder, you know, whoever this attracts.
00:56And that's why we have taken it out.
00:58And I'm sure, I'm sure, next time before bringing this, we will make more consultation to make sure
01:04we will get all our citizens on our side to make, and you know, so that these BJP politicians
01:13don't mislead them.
01:15We will communicate better, come up with a better bill.
01:18No, so are you saying, are you saying that this was an amendment that was wrong and you're conceding that,
01:24or you're saying there was misinformation by the BJP that led to people being mislead?
01:28No, Akshata, the thing is, you know, when it comes to development, development versus ecology,
01:35this debate has always happened.
01:38Every time, any government from that matter, you come up with a developmental project,
01:42it's always, you know, there is a foot, one step back when it comes to ecology.
01:49But, as good administrators or someone, if you want to give a good government,
01:54it's always about balancing both, to make sure that there is no harm done to the environment,
01:59but not at the cost of, you know, development, to make sure it is balanced.
02:04And most importantly, the citizens are happy and they do not have, are not affected by it.
02:10And sometimes, if anything that, you know, if there is anything that harms the citizens,
02:16we will consult them.
02:18That's exactly why we have withdrawn.
02:20And I think any democratic government, any sensible democratic government,
02:24will do that, right?
02:25Modi government has gone, taken U-turns in many things before.
02:29Agreed.
02:29It's not like, it's not the first time a government has done that.
02:32Mr. Bhaskar Rao, would you then say, sir, that this is a positive step taken by the government,
02:38that they've listened to the people's voices and they've said,
02:40you're not happy, we'll withdraw this bill.
02:42This Congress government has proposed, people of Bangalore have disposed.
02:48This government was under the mistaken assumption that parks are vacant government lands.
02:54Parks are performing an important function.
02:57And to please their chelas and chamchas, they wanted to take away 5% of the precious land,
03:04which they had no role in making, to give it away to their people as for political gifting over there.
03:10People of Bangalore risen and protested.
03:14Of course, BJP took the lead.
03:16But this issue was much bigger than a political issue.
03:20Bangaloreans have risen and taken the government to task and government has read the writing on the wall.
03:27And they have made a history retreat.
03:29And this is an absolute U-turn.
03:31And you already made the number of U-turns this government has made.
03:34The next U-turn this government is likely to make is the parking bill, which is going to be made
03:39over there.
03:40In fact, I am about to see that an entire cabinet, such so insensitive, they have approved this bill in
03:46the cabinet meeting.
03:47No, but Mr. Bhaskar Rao, you know, you had the Karnataka Chief Minister accusing your party, the BJP, of being
03:53anti-development.
03:54That any project they bring in, you oppose.
03:58She herself knows what kind of preposterous things these people come up with to destroy Bangalore.
04:03And they want to sell and dispose of Bangalore in a commercial manner with helping all the real estate mafias.
04:11The people of Bangalore are risen.
04:12What kind of development are you talking about in the last two and a half months over there?
04:16Or what kind of development was the previous government?
04:18Your treasury is empty and you talk about development.
04:21We have done development.
04:22That is a separate subject itself.
04:24If Bhavia wants to engage, I can engage in that subject.
04:26Let us talk about the park right now.
04:28If you want to talk about development, we have done more capital expenditure related projects than the Congress government tell
04:34them.
04:34This is a revenue intensive government, not a capital intensive government.
04:37Our government was a capital intensive intensive government and we took up more amount of projects over there.
04:43So Bhavia is totally wrong in saying that we are anti-development.
04:47We are pro-development.
04:48We have spent more amount on capital.
04:50Please see your statistics yourself.
04:52Look at, you have a revenue deficit budget.
04:54Of course, that is not a part of...
04:56So this was what the Karnataka chief minister had said, sir.
05:00The Karnataka chief minister suggested that the BJP opposes every project that's brought in by the government.
05:06But Bhavia, go ahead.
05:07Your response.
05:08Yes, dangerous projects affecting the...
05:11Sure, very clearly Bengalurians were against it.
05:14We saw that.
05:15But Bhavia, go ahead.
05:16I didn't say you are anti-development.
05:19I mean, you don't care about development.
05:21All you care is about the politics.
05:24So any issue you get, whether it is a developmental issue or anything for that matter, you just want to
05:30oppose.
05:30Because we all know how...
05:33Actually, we...
05:34Let me say very clearly, although we are ruling right now, we would definitely want a very strong opposition.
05:42You people are not being very...
05:44I mean, strong opposition right now.
05:46But this, this is a respect we are giving the citizen of this Bengaluru, of Bengaluru, and we have withdrawn
05:53this.
05:54That doesn't matter.
05:55That doesn't mean, sorry.
05:57That doesn't mean BJP wins.
05:59No.
06:00This is the voice of citizens.
06:01But most importantly, the same bill after consultation...
06:06No, but you are saying BJP is anti-development.
06:07And at the same time, you are saying this is the voice of the people.
06:10Which is it?
06:11Have you buckled to pressure from the BJP?
06:13Have you buckled to pressure from the citizens?
06:14This is against this.
06:16Akshata, I didn't say BJP is anti-development.
06:19They don't care about development.
06:22So, it's not like they can't even think what development is.
06:25Here, they just want an issue.
06:27Any issue and every issue, they will come after it.
06:29But here, people have taken the whole issue up.
06:34They are concerned about the environment.
06:36I'm a Bengaluru.
06:38I'm born and brought up in Bengaluru.
06:40So, I also resonate with them.
06:41If there is anything, the government, it's the duty of the ruling government.
06:45So, you are against this particular step.
06:48You are against taking 5% of the parks as a Bengalurian.
06:52Akshata, this is not about an individual.
06:55And stop putting words into my mouth.
06:57I'm asking you.
06:58It's not so easy to manipulate me.
07:01All I'm saying is, as a citizen, I understand the uproar of citizens.
07:05And I know, as someone who is representing on a national channel, a ruling government,
07:10I know that any government, for that matter, needs to be citizen-friendly.
07:14And it is important.
07:16It's okay to take a step back, communicate to the citizens,
07:19take them along, and make sure their demands are met.
07:23As simple as that.
07:24As someone, as a Bengalurian, I'm speaking both as a Bengalurian,
07:27as a, and a, you know, party spokesperson.
07:31Okay.
07:31Mr. Bhaskar Rao.
07:33According to Bhavya, they are citizen-friendly.
07:36People should come hit the streets and criticize the government.
07:39Is this being citizen-friendly?
07:40That's democracy.
07:42At least we didn't go after them with pellet guns.
07:45Don't interrupt me.
07:46We had heard to them.
07:47I did not interrupt you.
07:49Please listen to me.
07:50We didn't go with pellet guns and AK-47 with them.
07:53Okay.
07:53I didn't interrupt you.
07:54When you spoke, I did not interrupt you.
07:56She talks about BJP being anti-development, not caring about development.
08:01BJP is the one which has carried out more number of development activities than Congress.
08:05Like what?
08:06What is it that you have done over there?
08:08You expect people to come and tell you and saying that this is an insensitive project
08:14and then you say we are being people-friendly.
08:16Why did you not think about this?
08:17This was absolutely a political program.
08:20It was an absolutely political program and people have taken you to task.
08:23That's why you have withdrawn...
08:24Now, why do you call it a political program, sir?
08:25Mr. Bhaskar Rao, why do you call it?
08:27Because they're saying that, look, you have to provide infrastructure in Bengaluru.
08:30There are ways and means of doing it.
08:32They are coming up with preposterous methods.
08:34Now, they're having a tunnel road, right?
08:36Digging right inside.
08:37Without application of mind, a tunnel road is being conceptualized.
08:41When you know that the rocky layer is there below, there is no scientific approach.
08:4510,000 crores worth of kickbacks is going on.
08:49They need money to supply all over.
08:51Mr. Bhaskar Rao, you're leveling an allegation.
08:55There must be evidence to that allegation, sir, of kickbacks, saying this is a political project.
09:00There is no basis for having this 5%.
09:03There was no wisdom in having this 5% of land.
09:07But where does the land come from then?
09:09Where do you get space in Bengaluru?
09:11You don't have the space for development then.
09:13You have to develop public transport, madam.
09:15There is so much scope to develop public transport.
09:17We are not exhausted over there.
09:19Okay, Bhavya.
09:20We have to carry out these things.
09:21They have absolutely no idea about what urban governance is all about over there.
09:25Okay, Bhavya.
09:26Bhavya, you have a question.
09:27Go ahead.
09:29Sir, you said, you know, you are citizen friendly, but the citizens had to hit the street.
09:34You know, the difference is, when the same citizens hit the street in Delhi, 80 students
09:40had to get admitted in hospitals.
09:44One student had to lose his eyes because that government used pellet guns on them.
09:51In Bihar, they went after using an AK-47.
09:55Here, citizens came.
09:57They hit the streets because that's what democracy is about.
10:01Citizens, that's how they make the noise.
10:03And because we are, we believe in democracy, we did not use pellet guns.
10:09Show me one citizen who is harmed or injured in this protest.
10:12Instead, we withdrew the bill.
10:14That's the difference between BJP and Congress.
10:18Right?
10:19Okay, Mr. Bhaskar, how are your response?
10:20As simple as that.
10:23Don't try to divert the issue.
10:24We are talking about parts.
10:25I'm not diverting.
10:26Okay, okay.
10:26One more point.
10:27One more point.
10:28One more point.
10:28You have not been permitted.
10:30She asked me to please listen.
10:32No, no.
10:32One question.
10:33Sorry.
10:33No, no.
10:34I forgot to answer.
10:35Okay.
10:35Go ahead.
10:36Go ahead.
10:36Go ahead.
10:38You are talking about something else, about some other place.
10:40Today, we are talking about you taking a U-turn over there.
10:43It isn't friendly.
10:45Why?
10:45Give me a justification.
10:47Why you wanted to swallow Kaban Park and Lalbath for your tunnel projects, which are
10:51totally unscientific.
10:52It's a cut and paste job, which Secretary of State exposed it to you over there.
10:56And you think hundreds of people who are on the streets, are they fools or what over
11:00there to hit the streets for every legislation?
11:02Now, again, you have come out with that parking policy of yours, where you want to collect
11:05money from all the people who are parking their vehicles in front of them.
11:09Why have you not exhausted your public transport facilities?
11:12Come out with proper public transport.
11:15Why are you not investing on buses, pedestrians, footpaths?
11:18Okay.
11:18Fair question.
11:19Fair question, Mr. Rav.
11:20Final response, Bhavia.
11:21I'm running out of time.
11:22Final response from you on that.
11:23On the right way of developing Bengaluru versus this.
11:28I totally understand.
11:30You know, I resonate with sir.
11:31I do not deny.
11:32But do not take this as something.
11:35Don't act like because we are for something, we are against another thing.
11:39It's not that.
11:40But Bengaluru, it's a very fast growing city, right?
11:45The demands we need to keep 20 years ahead.
11:48We need to stay 20 years ahead because it is so fast, the development.
11:52I'm sure you people don't know that because you kept saying BJP has developed Bengaluru
11:56in a lot of ways.
11:57I can list down what exactly Congress has done.
12:01Can you list down anything that BJP has done for Bengaluru?
12:06I think, go ahead.
12:08No, no, but beyond the politics, I don't have time, unfortunately.
12:10I don't have time to give Mr. Bhaskar Rao the chance.
12:13But I can say this, that I think beyond any political party, unfortunately, nobody has
12:17done enough for Bengaluru.
12:19Nobody has done enough for Bengaluru.
12:21Either the BJP or the Congress, I will say that everyone's failed Bengaluru.
12:25We've seen that clearly in the traffic situation, in the infrastructure in the city.
12:30I'll leave it at that.
12:31Bhavyanar Simoguti as well as Mr. Bhaskar Rao.
12:33Thank you very much for joining us here on Super 6.

Recommended