What does it take to turn economic growth into lasting progress?
Drawing from McKinsey Global Institute’s new book, A Century of Plenty, NIAGA SPOTLIGHT brings the question home: as trade, technology and investment reshape the global economy, is Malaysia building the capabilities to thrive in the next era?
Tehmina Kaoosji speaks with Vidhya Ganesan, Managing Partner, McKinsey & Company Malaysia, about productivity, Malaysian companies, AI, ASEAN and the choices that could define Malaysia’s next growth model.
#501Awani #AwaniNews #MalaysiasNextGrowthModel #Malaysia
Drawing from McKinsey Global Institute’s new book, A Century of Plenty, NIAGA SPOTLIGHT brings the question home: as trade, technology and investment reshape the global economy, is Malaysia building the capabilities to thrive in the next era?
Tehmina Kaoosji speaks with Vidhya Ganesan, Managing Partner, McKinsey & Company Malaysia, about productivity, Malaysian companies, AI, ASEAN and the choices that could define Malaysia’s next growth model.
#501Awani #AwaniNews #MalaysiasNextGrowthModel #Malaysia
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:08Hello, I'm Tamina Kausjie and this is Niagara Spotlight.
00:11Today on Future Affairs, our spotlight falls on Malaysia's next growth model.
00:15Now, Malaysia has attracted record investment in recent years,
00:19but capital alone does not guarantee economic sustainability.
00:23McKinsey Global Institute's new book, A Century of Plenty,
00:26argues that lasting growth comes from something more.
00:29Investment matched by skills, innovation, technology and productive businesses working all together.
00:36So, as global trade is reshaped and new industries emerge,
00:39is Malaysia building an economy that can compete for the next decade
00:43or simply benefiting from today's momentum?
00:46What will it take for Malaysia's next growth model to deliver lasting competitive advantage?
00:52I'm joined today in the studios by Vidya Ganesan,
00:55Managing Partner of McKinsey and Company Malaysia, for this very timely discussion.
00:59A very good morning, Vidya. Thank you so much for making time.
01:02Morning, Tamina. Lovely to be here.
01:04Absolutely. So, Vidya, let's dig deep and let's start off with, of course,
01:09jumping off of A Century of Plenty, McKinsey Global Institute's new book,
01:13which argues that the extraordinary gains we've been seeing over the past century,
01:17they came from a, quote-unquote, progress machine of sorts,
01:21one that combines skills, investment, innovation, energy, cities, trade,
01:27and all of that combining and sort of peaking all at once.
01:31But at the same time, we're also now looking at another inflection point,
01:37starting this year and, of course, building up momentum towards 2030.
01:40So, tell us a little more about the shifts and the changes,
01:45the trends which have been observed.
01:47Yeah. No, that's a great question.
01:49The progress machine for Malaysia, Tamina, as you pointed out,
01:53has been a multi-factor progress machine, right,
01:55that's hinged on trade, on foreign investment,
01:59on our strengths in manufacturing.
02:01And we would argue at McKinsey that we should build on the tall shoulders
02:07of that progress machine and not reinvent the wheel.
02:09Well, having said that, every element of this progress machine,
02:13the bar for competitiveness, has started rising much more so than before, right?
02:18And therefore, that demands a few shifts that we need to thoughtfully make, right?
02:22I would argue there are three big shifts.
02:24One is a fundamental shift from volume to value, right?
02:28So, if you look at volume of, for example, exports in manufacturing,
02:31even quarter one of this year, Malaysia recorded a 7% growth in exports,
02:36driven primarily by our electronic semiconductor sector,
02:39and in the current global macro environment, that is a huge blessing.
02:43That's a win that we should count towards our benefit.
02:47Having said that, the important shift is to make from volume to value, as I said.
02:52It's not just recording growth in exports.
02:53It's really thinking about, is Malaysia moving up the value chain?
02:57What do I mean by that, right?
02:58We have 13% global share of the OSAT, assembly, packaging, and testing part of the semiconductor value chain.
03:05But is that where the highest value accrues to the domestic economy in terms of the high-scale jobs,
03:10in terms of the GDP multiplier effects?
03:12Not quite, right?
03:13So, are we able to build on that foundation of having solid market share in basic assembly, packaging, and testing,
03:19to start moving much more towards advanced packaging, towards chip design, etc.?
03:24So, that is the shift I'm arguing about in terms of moving from volume to value, right?
03:30The second shift, I would argue, is we've recorded record FDIs, like knock on wood as I speak.
03:36Again, a huge blessing in the current macro environment.
03:39Actually, Malaysia recorded more FDI than even Vietnam in the last few years.
03:42It's a fact that a few people notice.
03:45Having said that, we need to move from headline numbers in investment
03:49to what is the capability absorption that is happening in our economy, right?
03:54So, as we have the data center boom, are our local companies progressing in terms of adopting AI?
04:00Are we seeing a growth in terms of Malaysian companies,
04:03which are starting to become regional and global champions?
04:07That is kind of the second shift that we should be starting to see, right?
04:10The third shift is one that is moving from pure hard asset investments to hard and soft investments.
04:18Now, don't get me wrong, right?
04:19Investment in factories, data centers, by all means, keep them coming.
04:22Malaysia benefits from it.
04:23We need it, right?
04:25But that alone will not suffice.
04:27We also need investment in capability development, in talent, in skill building, in R&E.
04:32And that combination is what will help move us up the value chain, right?
04:36So, the argument would be that, yes, we build on our strengths of the progress machine,
04:41but the machine needs a few shifts as we look ahead.
04:44That's our thesis.
04:45Absolutely.
04:46And, of course, if you're looking towards the next 100 years to come,
04:49what needs to be key is those very fast-moving industries.
04:53You've got AI, as you mentioned, semiconductors, etc.
04:56And Malaysia has interest spread really well across, at the moment,
04:59several ambitious industries, including semiconductors.
05:03There's also energy transition and even digitalization.
05:06So, speaking about all of these industries that involve thousands of companies
05:11and, of course, tens of thousands of workers and institutions,
05:15which also need to fundamentally start shifting how they operate.
05:19I would love to draw upon your experience, having observed transformations across countries
05:24and industries, to tell us a little more about what fundamentally separates economies
05:30which are able to translate grand national plans for ambition,
05:35which, of course, are very instructional.
05:37But once it comes to crunch time, together with poly crises that are also constantly evolving
05:43and keeping governance on its toes, what needs to happen better?
05:47Again, a great question, right?
05:49Transformation is always easy to talk about in terms of big speeches, headlines, jingoistic headlines,
05:56and so on.
05:57But the translation to where the rubber hits the road is where the fall-off, the leakages happen.
06:02So, again, it's a great question.
06:03So, if I really think about transformation and at scale, right, the two dimensions of your question,
06:09and let's first get the definitions aligned before we get into what separates the good from the great, right?
06:14If I were to argue that the transformation we are talking about is the AI, tech-enabled productivity improvement
06:20that happens for an entire country while retaining a significant portion of domestic value for Malaysia,
06:27if we argue that that is transformation,
06:30and at scale means you're moving beyond one-off success stories, one-off pilots, one-off lighthouses
06:36to really you're seeing the country move.
06:38You're seeing a significant portion of the population benefit from it, right?
06:42So, if that were the definition and we look at countries that have transformed at scale,
06:47one thing stands out as being instructive,
06:49which is it's very rare if you see in the history of progressive countries
06:53that you have all companies, millions of companies, including SMEs,
06:58adopting a bunch of five levers and making up five levers across AI and tech-enabled transformation
07:03and making, let's say, 10% productivity improvement across the board.
07:07That kind of uniform progress barely ever happens, right?
07:10But what our research at McKinsey Global Institute shows is that one of the key drivers of transformation of economies,
07:18especially when it comes to productivity, is driven less by policy shifts, etc.
07:22Again, those are important, but it's driven by large institutions, large companies, right?
07:27They have a disproportionate multiplier effect on the economy.
07:30So, the argument would be to say if you have some standouts or lighthouses, as we call them,
07:37of large companies which are able to make step change in adoption of tech-enabled transformation,
07:43AI-enabled transformation to make huge leaps in productivity,
07:46when done well, what that does is it lifts the entire ecosystem of suppliers, vendors,
07:53of the talent that they work with together with them, right?
07:56The entire tide rises.
07:57Now, of course, the flip side of that is it starts to feel a bit like we are picking winners,
08:02which we cannot afford, right?
08:03Especially in a country like Malaysia where MSMEs contribute to 40% of our GDP
08:09and 50% of the country's employment, right?
08:12But mind you, only 14% of the country's exports actually come from MSMEs.
08:15So, there's a huge gap there, and they need to be lifted as well.
08:19So, thinking about the whole how do you create an environment for the standouts,
08:24the lighthouse, large companies to emerge,
08:26while having very well thought through supplier development programs,
08:30while ensuring that the broad MSME community has access to specialist talent,
08:38has access to capital, has access to moving up the value chain
08:42in terms of digitalization, digital tech-enabled platforms,
08:45that becomes super important, right?
08:47So, it's a bit the Madani principle of raising the ceiling
08:50in terms of growing a few global regional champions while raising the floor,
08:55which is targeted supplier development programs
08:58that don't protect existing business models endlessly,
09:01but what they do help the suppliers with is enabling adoption of technology,
09:08building capabilities, and moving up the value chain.
09:10That we have seen, this combination of it,
09:12is the formula for transformation at scale for countries.
09:16Exactly.
09:16And that reminds me of the fact that because you're speaking and holding in on suppliers,
09:21so Malaysia's got a great track record as far as fulfilling projects
09:24in the manufacturing at least sector go about 85% odd have been completely fulfilled,
09:30less than a 5% rate of abandoned projects.
09:33Wonderful.
09:34From 2021 to 2026.
09:35Which brings us into the key questions.
09:39So, what actually shifts a Malaysian company
09:42from being a really efficient supplier that has great demand
09:46to being one that actually is able to leapfrog into the role of a regional
09:52or even perhaps a global leader, at least in their arena,
09:55rather than remaining at that consistent but sort of less evolved level.
10:02The distinction you're calling out between what I would call a world-class supplier
10:08versus a standout shaper, for lack of a better word,
10:12is actually a very important one, right?
10:14Again, don't get me wrong, being a world-class supplier is by no means easy.
10:17To your point, having 85% to 95% delivery in full on time,
10:22which demands cost competitiveness, it demands quality, it demands reliability,
10:27is in and off of itself no mean feat.
10:30And kudos to the Malaysian supply ecosystem across different value chains
10:34and different sectors.
10:35We are talking about the semiconductor example,
10:37but we have many sectors where we have globally competitive Malaysian suppliers.
10:41That in and off of itself, getting to that level of efficiency,
10:44is no mean feat, right?
10:45So now we are talking a bit about good to great.
10:47How do you go from that to being a bit of a shaper, right?
10:51Again, if we look at, there are many examples which are instructive
10:54in different sectors around the world as countries have matured.
10:57Whether you look, for example, in the automotive sector in Germany,
11:00or you look at more apparel manufacturers in Sri Lanka and Vietnam,
11:04or you even look at TSMC in Taiwan, right?
11:07Many of them started with humble beginnings as contract manufacturers,
11:11who all they did was took instructions well from global OEMs,
11:14did very well on reliability, quality, cost,
11:17but over a period of time really started owning parts of IP,
11:22owning parts of the value chain, what I call control points,
11:25and moving up the value chain made themselves indispensable.
11:28So what did they do differently, right?
11:30If you look at these examples, they did one or more of three things right.
11:34One is they started to invest in some measure of R&D
11:38before the demand was certain,
11:40whether it is for apparel manufacturers in Sri Lanka that said,
11:43I'm going to start doing performance fabric testing
11:46even before a Nike or an Adidas comes and tells me,
11:49go manufacture exactly this, right?
11:51I'll have it ready before they come to me.
11:53Exactly, exactly, right?
11:54So that is one example.
11:56The second is really thinking about how to scale, right?
12:01Whatever you're doing in your current scale as a contract manufacturer,
12:05how do you go from that to regional global scale
12:08by using access to talent, by dynamically reallocating capital?
12:13That's a second thing that they do very well, right?
12:16And a third thing that's a common secret sauce
12:19is trying to get closer to the customer,
12:21trying to understand what are the pain points of the end consumer,
12:25even if I'm a measly contract manufacturer at this point,
12:28the curiosity to say, let me build some connections
12:31that help me understand what the end consumer wants
12:34and what are their pain points, unmet needs,
12:37whereby I can invest in R&D or in innovation
12:40to bridge that part of the value chain
12:42and become a control point, right?
12:44So these are the things these quote-unquote
12:47contract manufacturers did well to make themselves indispensable.
12:50And of course, it takes time.
12:51Over a period of time, moved really up the value chain.
12:54So I think those lessons are instructive for Malaysia.
12:56Absolutely. And I was also very interesting to read from your findings
13:01that fewer than 100 firms actually accounted
13:03for about two-thirds of positive productivity gains
13:06across a sample of roughly 8,500 companies which were surveyed.
13:11And this was looking at Germany, UK and US markets.
13:14Would you say that such evidence would also be translatable
13:18perhaps for the broader Asia-Pacific or Southeast Asian example though?
13:23So our thesis in MGI, by the way, we repeated the same piece of research
13:29not for Malaysia, but we repeated it for specific large countries
13:34within South and Southeast Asia.
13:35So it was done for India, Indonesia.
13:37The evidence holds actually across countries, across sectors
13:40that large institutions have disproportionate impact
13:45on productivity growth in the economy.
13:47Like I said, the lighthouses, the standouts, super critical to groom
13:51these handful to a couple of dozen, depending on the size of the country,
13:56of regional to global champions because they lift the entire ecosystem
14:01of talent, of suppliers with them.
14:04Now, what that also means is policy needs to support that in these countries.
14:08It's not just acknowledge them, but direct policy.
14:11Vidya, thanks so much for the conversation so far.
14:13We take a quick break.
14:14Don't go anywhere.
14:15We'll be right back with the rest of the discussion
14:17right here on Niagara Spotlight.
14:32Welcome back to Niagara Spotlight.
14:34Still with me, Tamina Kausjian.
14:35We have today Vidya Ganesan, managing partner with McKinsey & Co. Malaysia,
14:40talking to us a little bit more about Malaysia's next growth model.
14:43So, Vidya, jumping right back into the conversation.
14:45Now, let's look at whether Malaysia is still at the juncture
14:51where we are only really building capabilities,
14:53but are we able to also move beyond the paradigm
14:57of constantly having to outsource for them?
15:00So, Malaysia has been importing a lot of capital, technology,
15:04and also specialist expertise.
15:05And all of this has happened over a relatively short space of time,
15:09less than a few decades.
15:11But these capabilities being developed via the domestic economy,
15:15it does take a tick longer.
15:17So, how do we tell and what more can be done efficiently
15:20so that Malaysian companies are actually the ones
15:23that are able to carry on all of these initially purchased capacities
15:28so that we're able to replicate it not just at lower cost,
15:32but also then develop a local ecosystem
15:35for all of these essentials in the decades to come?
15:38No, absolutely.
15:40Again, the distinction you're drawing between purchasing
15:43and really building capabilities is a very important one, right?
15:46Because you could purchase the most world-class capabilities,
15:50whether it's in terms of access to technology or specialist talent,
15:54and you may never end up building local capability at all.
15:57And the world has a graveyard of countries with examples like that
16:01in terms of purchasing,
16:02but not quite building and grooming your own internal capability, right?
16:06So, again, a few things stand out in terms of what is important.
16:10Your first question was, how do we even measure them, right, to begin with?
16:13Let's take a value chain, a sector that is very familiar to Malaysia,
16:17again, going back to the semiconductor,
16:19the assembly packaging testing, the OSAT part of the value chain.
16:22Now, Malaysia owns a very impressive 13% of basic assembly packaging
16:27and testing of the semiconductor value chain of the world.
16:3013% of the world's OSAT comes from Malaysia,
16:32which gives us a lot of pride, and we are punching well above our weight.
16:35But if you look at that 13% of OSAT,
16:38and if you look at how much of it is developed or supplied by the local vendor ecosystem,
16:44local supplier ecosystem,
16:46this includes anything from chemicals, ingots, local development, start to finish, etc.,
16:52it's only about 40%, right?
16:55For a country that has, we've been in this space for decades,
16:58and it is not the most complex part of the value chain.
17:01There is no inherent reason why we should not be,
17:03structural reason why we should not be owning much more of it.
17:06Now, of course, the National Semiconductor Plan puts a brave,
17:10bold target of moving the 40% to 50% in two to three years already.
17:14So, we are working towards it, right?
17:16But what are some of the real markers of whether we are truly building capability
17:20and not just purchasing them?
17:22First is, when we bring in new technology, is our workforce,
17:26especially talking about the engineers, the technicians, etc.,
17:29are they just doing what the OEMs are instructing them to do,
17:34what the supplier of the technology is instructing them to do,
17:37or are they genuinely interacting with it, problem-solving,
17:40and they are able to add a layer over a period of time
17:43where they go back with suggestions and say,
17:45you know what, I can make better this technology.
17:48That's a very important marker of countries like Taiwan,
17:51which have effectively moved up the value chain.
17:54How are my engineers and technicians interacting with purchase technology?
17:57Yeah, fulfillment versus actually collaborative expertise, right?
18:01Exactly.
18:02And the second is, within organizations,
18:04you can have a technology overlay on a process.
18:07That's the easiest thing to do, right?
18:09To buy, I don't know, a chatbot for a call center,
18:11making this up as a very simple example that we should all relate to.
18:14But if you're not rewiring your process flows,
18:18and if you're just putting a technology overlay
18:20to automate all or a few steps of the process,
18:23the lean engineers, the Toyotas of the world,
18:26would argue passionately that you're automating waste, right?
18:29If there's waste in the process,
18:31first eliminate the waste, rewire the process,
18:34and then put in the technology overlay.
18:36So are we going that deep in terms of rewiring
18:39and rethinking our process flows for the sectors that matter
18:43before we just add a technology overlay, right?
18:46And the final one is, are we going beyond pilots,
18:49beyond pockets of organizations
18:51where there's adoption of this technology,
18:53pockets of sectors where there's adoption of technology,
18:56to scaling, right?
18:57Are we thoughtfully, systematically doing what Germany did
19:00with the automotive sector, like finishing schools, right?
19:02To make sure we have engineering talent at scale.
19:05The National Semiconductor Plan says
19:07we should have 30,000 engineers.
19:09Correct.
19:09We have about 18,000 now.
19:10We are making way, slowly but surely.
19:13But are these engineers then operating at the bar of,
19:16we're not just using technology, we are able to add value.
19:19We are able to interact with it in a way
19:21that over a period of time we add value.
19:22So that distinction is an important one
19:24and we need to keep our eye on the ball
19:26of ensuring we build capabilities.
19:29So keeping the eye on the ball, Vidya,
19:31would also definitely involve that
19:33we are not, in a sense,
19:35distracted by high productivity numbers
19:38as equating to the ability of companies
19:41to consistently upscale in a shifting market
19:45that changes literally now every economic quarter.
19:48So when it comes to that,
19:49how does Malaysia go past the challenge
19:53when it's not simply about having highly productive companies
19:56but also having your better technology,
19:59ensuring that you're investing enough in R&D
20:01and also, at the same time, management practices,
20:04particularly to capture not just the initial employment
20:09but also the career advancement
20:11of young technology professionals,
20:14domestic as well as regional.
20:16But of course, we want to build a domestic too, right?
20:18Of course.
20:19Your question brings a statistic to mind
20:22from one of our other books,
20:24North Century of Plenty,
20:25but there's another McKinsey book called Rewired,
20:27which looks into a couple of hundred organizations
20:30globally across sectors
20:32that are in the midst of successful
20:34AI-driven tech-enabled transformations
20:36and what really separates them out from the rest.
20:39The interesting statistic I was going to go to
20:41was the 90-46 rule, right?
20:44Now, if you speak to 90% of organizations,
20:46this seems to be true across countries,
20:48across geographies,
20:4990% of the CXO CEOs will tell you,
20:51we are adopting AI, Gen AI,
20:53in some way, shape, or form in our company, right?
20:5690% of them will tell you,
20:57and you can relate to it.
20:59Only 40% will tell you that AI has had,
21:02I use AI also as a proxy
21:04for tech-enabled transformation, right?
21:05Only 40% of them will say,
21:07AI has had some dent on my profit before,
21:12my P-Bit number, effectively,
21:14my bottom line number, right?
21:15Only 40%.
21:16Now, only 6% of them will say,
21:19I've had at least 5% or more impact on my P-Bit.
21:23It's not a huge number, 5% or more,
21:25that can be directly attributable
21:27to some AI-driven intervention.
21:29It can be on growth,
21:30it can be on the cost side.
21:31So, therefore, let's make no mistake,
21:33it's not easy, right?
21:35While everyone's trying and piloting,
21:37driving tech-enabled transformation
21:39that lasts in the manner that you described,
21:41that drives bottom line impact,
21:43that builds capabilities sustainably,
21:45is not easy.
21:45But the organizations that actually
21:47are in that 6%
21:49do a few things differently.
21:51They start not as a hammer
21:53looking for a nail,
21:54going after the cool, shiny toy
21:56that they find in terms of technology
21:58or AI use case,
21:59letting a thousand flowers bloom,
22:01which was the methodology,
22:02to be honest,
22:03even a couple of years ago, right?
22:04Let everyone do their own use case.
22:06We're running hackathons.
22:07But perhaps there was a pre-pandemic,
22:08I would say.
22:09Yes.
22:09Whereas now,
22:10it's really about thoughtfully,
22:12systematically thinking value-backed,
22:14about which are your business domains,
22:15which, if you transform using AI,
22:18will have material impact
22:20on your competitiveness
22:21as an organization.
22:22Then the second thing is,
22:23for those process flows,
22:25for those, for example,
22:27for a bank,
22:27it could be about
22:28how relationship managers
22:29interact with more wealth customers, right?
22:32That's such an important part
22:33of what makes or breaks
22:35their competitiveness, right?
22:36Now, having a co-pilot
22:38for a relationship manager
22:39allows him or her
22:41to interact meaningfully
22:42with 200 customers a day,
22:45whereas otherwise,
22:46he or she would have been able
22:47to do 20 customers.
22:48And the moment I pick up the phone,
22:49I'm able to say,
22:50Tamina, I know your daughter
22:52is going off to study
22:53in the UK this month.
22:54Sorry, just to use an example.
22:56Yeah, that hyper-personalized information,
22:58which, in a sense,
22:59you actually have access to that
23:01within wealth management,
23:02for example.
23:03Correct.
23:03But giving that co-pilot tool
23:05to a relationship manager
23:06allows every relationship manager
23:08to operate as though
23:09they are in top decile performance.
23:11So personal.
23:12I know you as a customer.
23:13Just to use one example, right?
23:14So for every business,
23:16it's important to figure
23:16what is that flow
23:17which is going to be needle-moving
23:19from a competitiveness perspective
23:21for my business.
23:22And within that flow,
23:24where does AI play a role?
23:25Which, in this case,
23:27was about the co-pilot.
23:28But mind you,
23:29we're not replacing the RM.
23:30The idea is not to automate
23:32every workflow end-to-end.
23:33There is still room.
23:35There is still an important place
23:36for human in the loop
23:37where the RM comes in
23:39with empathy,
23:40with context,
23:41with judgment,
23:41and potentially orthogonal
23:42creativity sometimes
23:44which no AI tool would do.
23:46So that's step two.
23:47Mapping out the flow,
23:47saying what's the role
23:48of the human,
23:49what's the role
23:50of the AI tool
23:52in the loop, right?
23:53Three is then
23:54redesigning the workflows.
23:55To my point earlier,
23:56I'll never automate waste.
23:58Clean sheet,
23:58reimagine the workflows
23:59after you have the benefit
24:01of what's the value from it,
24:03where do you need humans,
24:04where do you need AI.
24:05Then you need
24:06all the enablers in place
24:07in terms of your cyber security,
24:09your data governance,
24:10your scarce niche talent,
24:12whether it's data engineers,
24:13et cetera,
24:13that you need access to.
24:15And last but not least,
24:16closing the loop
24:16with always measuring outcomes.
24:18Did this use case,
24:20in this case,
24:20the RM co-pilot,
24:22did it improve
24:23my RM effectiveness?
24:24Did it improve
24:25the ability
24:25of my relationship managers
24:26to solve issues
24:28much faster
24:29than they would have?
24:30Did they manage
24:30to upsell and cross-sell
24:31much more
24:32than they did before?
24:33That measurement
24:34is super important
24:35closing of the loop
24:35because you also need
24:37to fail fast.
24:37If a use case
24:38or a domain
24:39is not quite delivering
24:40the value that you imagine,
24:42move on to the next one.
24:43Don't be wedded
24:44to sunk cost.
24:45So I would say
24:45these five things
24:46differentiate that 6%
24:48that really capture
24:49value sustainably.
24:50So everything is speaking
24:51towards actually identifying
24:53and then moving along quickly
24:55rather than just going along
24:57with the flow.
24:58So as we look to land
25:00the conversation with you,
25:01now does Malaysia
25:01need to choose its place
25:03in ASEAN's value chains
25:04a little more deliberately
25:06moving forward
25:07considering not just
25:08the highly competitive nature
25:10across ASEAN
25:11but at the same time
25:12also the fact
25:13that manufactured exports
25:15do make up a bulk
25:16of the region's
25:18capital markets too.
25:20It's a great question.
25:22My answer would be
25:23yes, Malaysia needs
25:24to be deliberate
25:24and thoughtful
25:26about picking its place
25:27but I mean less so
25:29in the context of
25:30hey, geopolitically
25:31we need to pick
25:33one or another.
25:34That's less what I mean.
25:36What I mean more
25:37about being deliberate
25:38and thoughtful
25:39is where do you play
25:41in the value chain
25:42of the different sectors
25:43that play to our strengths
25:45where we have competitive
25:47starting point advantages
25:49that make us indispensable.
25:50Again, going back
25:51semiconductor, OSAT
25:52part of the value chain
25:53is a great starting point.
25:54So let's pick and choose
25:56where we play
25:57and not try to be
25:58everything to everyone
25:59or not try to pick sides
26:01and force ourselves
26:02into an or function
26:04where there can be
26:05an and function.
26:06Our relative
26:06geopolitical neutrality
26:08has played to our advantage.
26:11It has allowed us
26:12to use our strengths
26:13meaningfully
26:13to grow our exports, right?
26:15Globally
26:16over the last couple of years.
26:18If you look at trade
26:19going out of ASEAN as well
26:21both to US and China
26:22and the rest of the world
26:23has grown materially.
26:25Again, I'm knocking on wood.
26:26So the region overall
26:27is a force for the good
26:29and the way we should think
26:29about Malaysia's role
26:31in the region
26:31is less competitive
26:33with each one
26:34of the ASEAN countries
26:35but more together
26:37the whole will be
26:38much more
26:39than the sum of the parts
26:40and being very clear
26:41on our place
26:43within that puzzle
26:44and delivering reliably
26:45competitively
26:46on whatever piece
26:47of the puzzle we choose.
26:49I picked OSAT part
26:50of semiconductor value chain.
26:51There are others.
26:52There are like green energy.
26:53where you started
26:55earlier on energy transition
26:56where we have
26:56a very important role
26:57to play.
26:58So I do believe strongly
26:59the distinct parts
27:00of important value chains
27:02where Malaysia
27:03has a role to play
27:04can own control points
27:06but it's important
27:06that we play this
27:07collaboratively
27:08and we rise together
27:10with the rise
27:11of ASEAN as a whole.
27:12Absolutely.
27:13So clearly a case
27:14to be made
27:14for moving into
27:15higher value activities
27:16not necessarily
27:17narrowing sectors.
27:19Vidya, thank you so much
27:20for the conversation so far.
27:21It was most insightful.
27:22Thank you, Tamina.
27:23Well, the opportunity
27:24is clearly here.
27:25The essential question
27:26is whether Malaysia
27:27can turn it
27:28into lasting
27:28economic strength
27:30and equity.
27:31Thanks very much
27:31for watching Niaga Spotlight.
27:33Please do join us again
27:34next week
27:34for more economic analysis.
27:36I'm Tamina Koushi
27:37signing off for now.