00:20A political and cultural clash is brewing in New York ahead of a controversial event featuring RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat.
00:29American singer and actress Mary Milbin has publicly come out in support of the gathering at Madison Square Garden, while
00:38sharply attacking critics of the event, including New York City Mayor Zohan Mamdani.
00:44Milbin accused Bhagwat's opponents of being motivated by hostility toward Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the BJP.
00:52The gathering is scheduled for August 29th in Manhattan.
00:56Milbin delivered her criticism in a post on X, directly targeting Mamdani and other opponents of the gathering.
01:04She argued that critics were opposing the Madison Square Garden event because of their opposition to Modi and the BJP.
01:12Milbin also attacked what she described as socialist ideology among the event's critics.
01:17She even suggested a possible title for an opposing rally, Oneness.
01:23But the controversy is much bigger than a single venue.
01:27Bhagwat is scheduled to speak at a Manhattan event on Saturday, according to the organizers.
01:32The gathering is being promoted as the Universal Oneness Celebration.
01:37Organizers say it will bring together members of the Hindu-American community,
01:41while highlighting shared heritage, interfaith unity, and dialogue.
01:47American Hindus for Engagement and Dialogue says the event has backing from several Hindu-American organizations.
01:54But critics have raised concerns over Bhagwat's appearance because of the RSS's political history and ideology.
02:02Mamdani has made his position clear.
02:04The New York mayor said he does not support the rally, but questioned whether the city has the legal authority
02:11to cancel a private event.
02:12OK, question about the RSS.
02:15The Indian right-wing paramilitary organization is planning to have a rally this weekend at Madison Square Garden.
02:21And there are protests against this rally, including one right now, I think, at City Hall.
02:27Shahana Hanif, Brad Lander, and Lincoln Rustler have all called for it to be canceled.
02:32Opponents to the rally site, the RSS's treatment of religious minorities in India.
02:37That's something you've spoken out about.
02:38So just want to get your position on that.
02:40And then I also have a question about open primaries.
02:42You know, I also stand here as the first Indian-American mayor in our city's history.
02:47And my mother's family is all still in India.
02:50And the vision of India that I was taught by my family and the one that I grew up being
02:58very familiar with was of a pluralistic society, of a secular republic that believed in the belonging of each and
03:06every person who was from India.
03:09And it has been incredibly troubling to see the rise of a movement that is predicated on an exclusionary vision
03:17of any country, frankly.
03:19And so it is one that I find myself in deep opposition to, not only as an Indian-American, but
03:25also as the mayor of a city that believes deeply in the belonging of each and every person, no matter
03:30their color, their creed, their religion, their faith, wherever they're from.
03:33Should the rally be canceled, though, at MSG this weekend?
03:36I don't support the rally, but I don't know if the city has any jurisdiction on canceling a private event.
03:42For supporters of the gathering, the event represents an opportunity to celebrate Hindu heritage, community, and dialogue in the United
03:50States.
03:51For critics, Bhagwat's appearance raises questions about the RSS and the political direction associated with the organization.
03:59The RSS is widely regarded as the ideological parent organization of India's ruling BJP.
04:06That connection has made the event particularly politically sensitive.
04:11Milbin, meanwhile, has emerged as one of its most prominent American defenders.
04:16She has a long-standing connection with India and gained popularity there after performing India's national anthem at a Washington
04:24event before Modi's address in 2023.
04:27Milbin did not simply defend Bhagwat's appearance.
04:31She also said she hoped an opposing oneness rally could include meaningful dialogue about religious freedom in India.
04:39That proposal adds an unexpected dimension to the dispute.
04:43The debate is now extending beyond whether Bhagwat should speak at Madison Square Garden.
04:48It is becoming a wider argument over free expression, political ideology, religious identity, and India's image abroad.