U.S. singer and actress Mary Millben has backed an upcoming New York event featuring RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat, while criticizing opponents including New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani. The gathering is scheduled for August 29 at Madison Square Garden and has drawn sharp criticism from several New York organizations. Millben accused critics of opposing the event because of their views toward Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the BJP. She also criticized what she described as socialist ideology among opponents, intensifying an already heated political and cultural debate surrounding Bhagwat’s planned appearance in Manhattan.




#MaryMillben #MohanBhagwat #ZohranMamdani #NewYork #MadisonSquareGarden #RSS #India #Modi #BJP #Politics #USA #IndianAmerican #Culture #Diplomacy #WorldNews

~PR.498~HT.408~GR.510~VG.MX~

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:20A political and cultural clash is brewing in New York ahead of a controversial event featuring RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat.
00:29American singer and actress Mary Milbin has publicly come out in support of the gathering at Madison Square Garden, while
00:38sharply attacking critics of the event, including New York City Mayor Zohan Mamdani.
00:44Milbin accused Bhagwat's opponents of being motivated by hostility toward Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the BJP.
00:52The gathering is scheduled for August 29th in Manhattan.
00:56Milbin delivered her criticism in a post on X, directly targeting Mamdani and other opponents of the gathering.
01:04She argued that critics were opposing the Madison Square Garden event because of their opposition to Modi and the BJP.
01:12Milbin also attacked what she described as socialist ideology among the event's critics.
01:17She even suggested a possible title for an opposing rally, Oneness.
01:23But the controversy is much bigger than a single venue.
01:27Bhagwat is scheduled to speak at a Manhattan event on Saturday, according to the organizers.
01:32The gathering is being promoted as the Universal Oneness Celebration.
01:37Organizers say it will bring together members of the Hindu-American community,
01:41while highlighting shared heritage, interfaith unity, and dialogue.
01:47American Hindus for Engagement and Dialogue says the event has backing from several Hindu-American organizations.
01:54But critics have raised concerns over Bhagwat's appearance because of the RSS's political history and ideology.
02:02Mamdani has made his position clear.
02:04The New York mayor said he does not support the rally, but questioned whether the city has the legal authority
02:11to cancel a private event.
02:12OK, question about the RSS.
02:15The Indian right-wing paramilitary organization is planning to have a rally this weekend at Madison Square Garden.
02:21And there are protests against this rally, including one right now, I think, at City Hall.
02:27Shahana Hanif, Brad Lander, and Lincoln Rustler have all called for it to be canceled.
02:32Opponents to the rally site, the RSS's treatment of religious minorities in India.
02:37That's something you've spoken out about.
02:38So just want to get your position on that.
02:40And then I also have a question about open primaries.
02:42You know, I also stand here as the first Indian-American mayor in our city's history.
02:47And my mother's family is all still in India.
02:50And the vision of India that I was taught by my family and the one that I grew up being
02:58very familiar with was of a pluralistic society, of a secular republic that believed in the belonging of each and
03:06every person who was from India.
03:09And it has been incredibly troubling to see the rise of a movement that is predicated on an exclusionary vision
03:17of any country, frankly.
03:19And so it is one that I find myself in deep opposition to, not only as an Indian-American, but
03:25also as the mayor of a city that believes deeply in the belonging of each and every person, no matter
03:30their color, their creed, their religion, their faith, wherever they're from.
03:33Should the rally be canceled, though, at MSG this weekend?
03:36I don't support the rally, but I don't know if the city has any jurisdiction on canceling a private event.
03:42For supporters of the gathering, the event represents an opportunity to celebrate Hindu heritage, community, and dialogue in the United
03:50States.
03:51For critics, Bhagwat's appearance raises questions about the RSS and the political direction associated with the organization.
03:59The RSS is widely regarded as the ideological parent organization of India's ruling BJP.
04:06That connection has made the event particularly politically sensitive.
04:11Milbin, meanwhile, has emerged as one of its most prominent American defenders.
04:16She has a long-standing connection with India and gained popularity there after performing India's national anthem at a Washington
04:24event before Modi's address in 2023.
04:27Milbin did not simply defend Bhagwat's appearance.
04:31She also said she hoped an opposing oneness rally could include meaningful dialogue about religious freedom in India.
04:39That proposal adds an unexpected dimension to the dispute.
04:43The debate is now extending beyond whether Bhagwat should speak at Madison Square Garden.
04:48It is becoming a wider argument over free expression, political ideology, religious identity, and India's image abroad.

Recommended