• 4 months ago
RSS leader Atul Limaye questioned the political impact of the CJP protests, while in Pakistan, seven police personnel were killed in a blast targeting their vehicle, prompting a security operation and investigation into the attack.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:01Good evening, you're watching India First. I'm Gaurav Savan. Senior Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh leader, Atul Limay, the Sehsar Kareva, he
00:12set the cat among pigeons, citing father of the constitution, Dr. Bhilrao Ambedkar's grammar of anarchy passage in the context
00:21of the recent unrest in the national capital.
00:23Now, Atul Limay described the Tawful Janda Party's protest as a case study of a student's protest that's been taken
00:31over by the left ecosystem and his assessment tried to subvert democracy.
00:38He said there is a need for students and he was addressing the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad or the ABVP
00:45and he said there is a need to understand this grammar of anarchy.
00:50Limay, addressing youth of the ABVP, insisted youth need to understand the entire process, the methodology, the support system, the
01:01ideological background of these protests and decode it.
01:06He made an interesting observation. A student protest that saw the presence and activities of various advocacy groups, for example,
01:15environment activists or those seeking the restoration of Article 370 in Jammu and Kashmir.
01:20Those talking about tribal rights, women rights, representatives of various minority communities, Muslim community, Christian community, labourers, in his view,
01:30journalists and legal aid providers participating either directly or indirectly in these protests.
01:37The RSS has sought a careful study and analysis of the speeches that were made, of the slogans that were
01:44raised.
01:45In his view, why were anti-Hindu voices heard on certain platforms?
01:53Why and how did the influence of left ideology suddenly increase within the movement?
01:58Was it all planned?
01:59Was it purely a student-led movement or did it transform into a political movement overnight?
02:06How did a student-led movement actually expand to garner support overseas?
02:13Was somebody pulling the strings behind the scenes?
02:16The language used by some young protesters, including young women protesters, and a statement of political activist, Yogendra Yadav, who
02:25reportedly said words to the effect,
02:27that democracy in future will not be determined by parliament, but by the streets, or not just by parliament, but
02:33also by the streets, not just by elections, but also by resistance.
02:37What's to that effect?
02:38Now, the battle lines are very clearly drawn in this extremely sensitive issue at a time when questions are being
02:45raised about selective outrage and selective silence over paper leaks.
02:51For example, there have been paper leaks in opposition-ruled states.
02:55Jharkhand. Jharkhand is erupting.
02:58There are protests in Punjab.
03:00There are protests in Karnataka, and we will talk about this in greater detail.
03:04But first, I want to bring you this report.
03:14One statement, one controversy, and eventually the birth of a political outfit, Cockroach Janata Party.
03:25But Abhijit Dipke's politics did not stop there.
03:32He went on to lead a movement in the national capital against the Modi government over the Neat Paper leak.
03:40A protest that drew support from across the opposition.
03:44But now, the RSS has entered the controversy.
03:48RSS Joint General Secretary Atul Limay has called upon the country's youth to conduct an in-depth case study of
03:56the recent CJP movement.
03:57Atul Limay has described the protest as anti-constitutional and anti-national.
04:05He suggested that while the initial student anger over the Neat Paper leak may have been spontaneous,
04:11the CJP-led protest was allegedly orchestrated with a larger political objective.
04:16He said, I don't trust the religion.
04:21He said, I don't trust the government against the Constitution.
04:47The CJP founder Abhijit Dipke has hit back.
04:51He has said that RSS has no authority to label anyone anti-national.
04:56He has also invoked one of the most contentious chapters in the organization's history,
05:02the assassination of Mahatma Gandhi.
05:26The Congress, too, has joined the attack, asking the Sangh to stay out of Dishu.
05:31And taking the confrontation a step further,
05:34the party has warned that once it returns to power, the RSS will be shown its place.
06:05And it isn't just the Congress.
06:09Several opposition leaders have now turned their guns on the BJP's ideological parent.
06:14The RSS-BJP's total concern is the state of the RSS-BJP.
06:19They have joined the government with three parties.
06:23They have not been running for 52 years.
06:26They have not been running for 52 years.
06:29They have been running for the RSS-BJP.
06:29So the biggest state of the RSS-BJP are the people who are the RSS-BJP.
06:50But the RSS appears to be looking beyond the political slugfest.
06:55Its next move is aimed directly at the country's youngest voters.
07:01RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat is set to pitch the Indian way to Gen Z and Gen Alpha in Mumbai on
07:08August 6th
07:09in what is being seen as a major youth outreach.
07:13Mohan Bhagwat is expected to interact with nearly 2,000 teenagers
07:17weeks after the July 20th protests brought young voices to the centre of the political conversation.
07:25Remember, the same RSS chief had called today's youth as imitative and emotional
07:31and had expressed concern about the growing influence of social media
07:35and peer pressure on their thinking and decision-making.
07:58And that's what makes this confrontation bigger than a single protest or one political party.
08:06Was the CJP-led protest a genuine grassroots movement or was there something more behind it?
08:13It's a question that will be asked time and again as the probe in the July 20th crackdown continues.
08:20Because the real battle is for control of the narrative in the minds of the youth.
08:25Bureau Report, India Today.
08:30The RSS says, you understand the chronology.
08:32And the questions we'll put to our guess is, what is the chronology?
08:35You understand the chronology.
08:36But beyond that, there are hundreds of students who are protesting in Jharkhand.
08:41They gathered at Rachi's Jaipal Singh Munda Stadium and they gathered on the 29th of July.
08:46They raised slogans.
08:47They waived the national fact.
08:49They demanded accountability from the Hemant Sorain government.
08:51The protest is now in its sixth day.
08:54And there are parallels that are being drawn with the Delhi Jantar Mantar protests.
08:58And there are questions that are being asked.
08:59Why are the same opposition voices and the Kokhrit Janta Party rather lukewarm to protest against opposition-ruled states?
09:09Why is the Kokhrit Janta Party, for example, not spearheading this movement just because it's in Jharkhand, an opposition-ruled
09:17state?
09:18Unlike Delhi, the CJP has extended support.
09:22They've made social media posts.
09:24They've supported this movement online.
09:26But should they have been on ground the way they were in Delhi?
09:30And is there merit in the criticism that a student's movement was actually hijacked by opposition parties?
09:37Our Jharkhand Bureau gets us more.
09:52Delhi's student uprising has found its echo in Rachi.
09:55After Jantar Mantar, the battle over jobs, paper leaks and recruitment has now reached Jharkhand.
10:03Jaipal Singh Munda Stadium has turned into the epicentre of a growing youth movement.
10:09Tricolors flutter and students have launched an indefinite Satya Gray,
10:15alleging deep-rooted corruption in Jharkhand's recruitment system.
10:20The students are protesting over alleged paper leaks in State Public Service Commission and Staff Selection Commission exams,
10:29evaluation errors and OMR discrepancies,
10:33years of delayed recruitment examinations,
10:36irregularities in the recruitment process,
10:39repeated exam delays,
10:40and rising unemployment.
10:42Yeah,
11:19The face of the movement is Devendranath Mato.
11:23Mirroring Sonam Wangchuk's hunger strike during the Jantamantar agitation,
11:28Mato has now begun an indefinite fast,
11:31wowing to continue until the students' demands are heard.
11:58The demands are clear.
12:03CBI and ED probe into recruitment scams,
12:06cancelled tainted exams and results,
12:09fresh, fair and transparent examinations,
12:12time-bound recruitment calendar,
12:15action against paper leak culprits,
12:18leak-proof exam and recruitment system,
12:22transparent JBSC and JSSC recruitment.
12:27The parallels with Delhi are impossible to miss.
12:31Protesters say the Jantamantar movement inspired them to launch this fight.
12:35They claim the Heman Sorain government has yet to engage with them.
12:41The agitation has now acquired a political edge.
12:44Kokraj Janta Party founder Abhijee Deepke spoke to the protesters and extended support to their movement.
13:07The BJP, meanwhile, has stepped up its attack.
13:31The spark that ignited Jantamantar Mantar has now reached Ranchi.
13:36And with the movement gathering momentum and politics escalating,
13:40the pressure on the Heman Sorain government is only mounting.
13:44With Satyajit Kumar, Bureau Report, India Today.
14:14And that anti-national and anti-Hindu slogans and conversations were injected in this protest.
14:20Joining me on India first is Ratan Sharda, author.
14:24Conflict resolution, the RSS way.
14:27Though I may add here that this conversation may lead to another conflict.
14:32But that's a conversation that we will have with Ratan Sharda.
14:36Saira Shah Haleem is an author and a left leader.
14:39Vikram Singh is a security expert and former DGP of UP.
14:42Nikhil Jain is a political analyst and advocate.
14:45Before I come to our guests, for a moment, I also want you to listen in to actor Bhumi Pednekar.
14:50She's also weighed in on the protest.
14:52She's condemned not just the abusive language that was used by students and the online hate
14:59In a video that she shared on social media, Bhumi Pednekar highlighted that people have every right to voice their
15:06concerns
15:07over very serious issues like education and the alleged paper leak.
15:10However, she also underscored that dissent should remain respectful and should not turn abusive.
15:18She appealed to the younger generation to uphold the values of a civil discourse,
15:24adding that the country can move forward only through unity.
15:27Listen in.
15:29So, I want to speak with the teachers and the great leaders of our country,
15:34that we can do the wrong things.
15:35Guys, this is not our culture.
15:37This is wrong.
15:38And this is why I wanted to come out and kind of address this.
15:43That one country's pride will come in.
15:46When we are collectively, together with unity,
15:49we talk about the flaws and the good things about it.
15:54And our backbone, our culture, our value system, we don't want to go far away from that.
16:01Otherwise, we don't communicate in the right way and it will never be implemented and change.
16:12I just want to leave this thought for you.
16:15I saw a video on the internet where a young girl who was in protest was giving an interview and
16:22she looked visibly broken and shaken.
16:24There was a video that was viral and they were getting non-stop rape threats and death threats.
16:30They are only getting their mother and family and that is unacceptable.
16:36We cannot bully a young girl.
16:39We can't put psychosis in any child's mind because we disagree with her opinion.
16:45As women, we deal with harassment and as a public figure, I have gone through this experience.
16:51So, I am not able to tell you how deep, lasting impact has someone's mental health.
16:56We all just want to leave this thought behind.
17:13Let me now throw this open to our guest, Ratan Sharda.
17:16RSS Sahas Kareva Atul Limay cited Dr. B.R. Ambedkar's grammar of anarchy, passage or speech.
17:23How are students protesting in the national capital seeking clean exams, anti-paper leak mechanisms being put in place, being
17:31seen as either unconstitutional or anti-national, sir?
17:36Well, Gaurav, first of all, let me take this Jharkhand issue out before I speak on that.
17:42In Jharkhand, students have been fighting for last eight days.
17:44There is no news.
17:45There is no support from any quarter.
17:47Now, today, Dipke has spoken.
17:49And just because they are not abusive, just because they are not violent, that is the reason.
17:53Secondly, there is a case of Jharkhand or Jharkhand, Karnataka, Punjab, Kerala, everywhere.
17:59But why Dipke and the company never asked for the resignation?
18:03So, this is a political move. It is not a student move at all.
18:06Now, coming to the main issue.
18:08The most important part that has been missed out is that Limay ji is saying that
18:17he says clearly we should talk, discuss with Gen Z and don't just criticize them.
18:23Have positive conversation.
18:25Then he goes on to explain that this particular agitation which began as a student agitation
18:30was hijacked by forces who were inimical to the national issues, which is very clear the way it has been
18:39politicized.
18:39So, student movement became a political movement.
18:41He talks of chronology.
18:43The person from USA sends a tweet.
18:47That tweet or Instagram conversation becomes hugely viral.
18:52It cannot happen without any support from some quarter who paid for this.
18:56You know how the tweets are and how the social media algorithm works.
19:00So, there is a lot of money involved.
19:01Then he comes, there is nobody who is ready to work with him.
19:04He moves all over the country, doesn't get support.
19:07He sits on Jantar Mantar, it is a kind of, you know, wet towel.
19:11Then finally you suddenly see all leftists, ISA, SFI and all the leftist unions whether human rights in the name
19:20of human rights, in the name of Jihad, in the name of whatever they all come together.
19:25It's not illegal to have a left ideology in this country, at least not so far.
19:29So, what if ISA students and SFI students are there?
19:32Just a moment.
19:33Gaurav, let me complete the statement.
19:35So, when you see this, what kind of slogan start appearing?
19:38You support Shalji Limam.
19:40There are people who sing for Shari Jivran.
19:42There are people who say, who are taking the portrait of Hidma, the Naksal person who was killed in the
19:48encounter as hero of the place.
19:50There are people who talked of cutting the chicken head.
19:52Their hero was there.
19:53There are people who abused Hindutva who were there.
19:56Hindus were insulted.
19:57All these people, all the divisive forces took over the agitation.
20:00Why did Dipke give them platform?
20:02Okay.
20:02So, that is the issue that why they should be given platform.
20:05Not only that.
20:06Every trade union was there and they just said, what is it?
20:09Yogendra Yadav, sir, Mohi Pandali.
20:11I'll come to Yogendra Yadav in just a moment.
20:14You've raised several points.
20:15Sir, you've raised several points.
20:16I'll come to Yogendra Yadav's point in just a moment.
20:18Last statement.
20:19Please, please.
20:20Yogendra Yadav says, now parliament won't work.
20:23It will work only through road street, not through parliament.
20:26And it will be resistance, not persuasion.
20:29That is what tells me it is anti-national, it has a constitution.
20:32Anti-national and anti-constitutions are very strong words, sir.
20:36Saira Shahalim, a student's movement, the RSS has taken over…
20:40Yogendra Yadav.
20:41Yes, fair enough.
20:42Taken over by leftist forces.
20:44I heard you.
20:46I…
20:46No, that's what I said.
20:48Taken over by leftist forces.
20:49Okay.
20:49Can I comment now?
20:50Taken over by leftist forces.
20:51You know, hear my full sentence, sir.
20:53The presence of left students' unions understood their students.
20:57But, what about leaders like Brindakara, John Brittas?
21:01Was this a left politics versus, you know, the government and the statement of Yogendra Yadav?
21:09Okay, can I comment now?
21:11Yes.
21:11Okay, so I listened to Mr. Ratan Sharda and without any interruption,
21:14so I would request him to hear the same.
21:16So, firstly, it is very ironic that today the RSS is quoting Ambedkar's warning on constitutionalism, right?
21:25And if we go back in time in history, it is very clearly the public records that say that historically
21:31and ideologically, texts of the sangh, okay, the certain sects of the sangh who categorically resisted the Indian constitution in
21:411949, in favor of the ancient texts like Manusmriti and all that.
21:45So, it becomes really, you know, ironic and surprising that they're quoting grammar of Anarchy and all that just to
21:52sound intellectual.
21:53Now, let's get back to labeling the left-wing who was present there, you know, which happened much after the
22:01movement started as anti-national or, you know, what you call piggy-bagging on the movement and all that.
22:08Because, firstly, we all know that labeling a spontaneous movement and giving it a name like left hijacked or anti
22:17-national is a classical distraction technique.
22:20It shifts the focus away clearly from the government incompetence and policy failures.
22:26And it's time that the government takes ownership of its incompetency, which has been all along, especially what we witnessed
22:35during the NET paper leak.
22:37Where was the accountability then?
22:39The students are pushed, you know, pushed beyond the limit.
22:42That is why they all came out on the streets.
22:45And some wrongs, I'll categorically say, are so urgent and so irreversible that a year stolen from the young cannot
22:53be handed back to them on a later date or later pool and everything.
22:58Now, coming back to Ambedkar.
22:59When he used the statement, grammar or anarchy, he was not abolishing the citizen's voice.
23:05Let us be very categoric here.
23:08Yes, but he was talking about remaining in the constitution.
23:12The next day, protected speech and peaceful assembly.
23:15It is very, very clearly said.
23:18But he very specifically mentioned what should be avoided.
23:22Peaceful assembly.
23:22And the students of Jandar Mandar were not carrying swords.
23:27They were not carrying guns.
23:28They were carrying a copy of the Indian constitution where Mr. B.R. Ambedkar played a very pivotal role.
23:36I will get Dr. Vikram Singh to respond to that.
23:39Article 19-1B guarantees speech and peaceful assembly.
23:42So, let us be very clear.
23:44Was that assembly peaceful, Dr. Vikram Singh?
23:47That you are able to hear these hard facts.
23:48Sure, but was that assembly peaceful?
23:53Initially, it was.
23:54But that is the point that Atul Limai raises.
23:56Did it remain peaceful?
23:58Because when he says, Dr. Ambedkar warned about anarchists a long time ago.
24:03Now, he says decode this movement.
24:06Is it take precautions against such anarchist forces which are detrimental?
24:10Your thoughts on his assessment?
24:14Gaurav Ji, good evening and esteemed panellists.
24:16I would say that I have seldom seen such peaceful protests and such protest marches where 150 policemen, including lady
24:24police personnel, are brutalized, bashed up, their skulls broken, cranial fractures, hip fractures, and 30 vehicles absolutely turned to dust.
24:35I mean, I have seldom seen such peaceful movement.
24:38What to talk of that, the manner in which they were brutalized.
24:41I would say that the police, the Delhi police, displayed exemplary forbearance and patience.
24:47Now, coming to the so-called peaceful, their procession became illegal the moment they defied the provisions of Section 163
24:54of the BNSS at Jantar Mantar.
24:56Anything more than 1,000, then they have to go to the Ramlila ground.
25:00Then when they go to the Ramlila ground, it will be the Burari ground if they are more than 10
25:03,000.
25:04Every section of the war was violated and so it was peaceful.
25:08Then how these 150 Delhi police personnel got injured, I would say that they had come fully prepared.
25:14And let me tell you, Gaurav Ji, it is a non-kinetic war against India.
25:18And the ingredients of electromagnetic warfare, information warfare, psychological warfare, cyber warfare are all there.
25:26That's a very strong point to make, sir.
25:29But you must back it with, how do you say that this is psyops or information warfare or psychological warfare
25:35against India?
25:36I mean, these are students protesting, sir.
25:39These are students and there are two groups of students.
25:41One group who have been wronged, as Saira Ma'am has mentioned, and we are all with them.
25:46My children are old, not being that good, but my grandchildren are very much.
25:50And I have full sympathy with those who have been wronged by paper leaks and I stand strongly with them.
25:55But those who came prepared for mayhem marched to the parliament and marched to the PM house, I take the
26:00strongest exception.
26:01What more did you expect?
26:03It was just touch and go as far as the PM was concerned and touch and go went for the
26:07parliament.
26:08And I stand by the side of my brethren and my sisters of the Delhi police and the withdrawal of
26:13the cases.
26:14And look at the temerity of the agitators.
26:16They say, if the government cannot keep up its words, we'll negotiate with the Supreme Court.
26:21I mean, are you aware of what you're talking?
26:24Would you take a burger and a pizza dare to the Supreme Court and offer to the Supreme Court judges?
26:30Gentlemen, please do this.
26:31Otherwise, we will resort to hunger strike here in the parliament.
26:35Let me bring in Nikhil Jain.
26:36Let me bring in Nikhil Jain to take this conversation forward.
26:40Because Nikhil Jain, you heard Atul Limai and you've just heard Ratan Sharada on this broadcast.
26:44They're citing the example of Yogendra Yadav's statement, words to the effect that the future of democracy will be decided
26:52by the street and not the parliament.
26:54Do you agree with that argument?
26:56Or is this the grammar of anarchy that Dr. Ambedkar cautioned against?
27:03Well, that's the scene with the RSS and everybody who supports the RSS, that misinformation and taking things out of
27:09context is the main and key tool that they work with.
27:11Whenever we say that these people come from the country and come from the country, democracy functions with the street
27:17and the parliament, that's perfectly kosher to say.
27:19That is how it happens.
27:20That is what the BJP did during the India Against Corruption Movement.
27:23That is what the CJP and the Congress Party are doing today.
27:26That is what the students in Jharkhand are doing in Ranchi.
27:29And that is how it happens across the country.
27:31It's perfectly all right and kosher for students, farmers, youth, wrestlers, elders, anybody to come out to protest and create
27:40pressure on the government.
27:41That is how governments are held to account.
27:42So what Yogendra Yadav has said that this is a way to keep the government in check, that's perfectly fine.
27:47I don't really understand.
27:47How do you start comparing it with anarchy and overthrow of the Indian state and all of that?
27:52That being said, I find it rather hypocritical when the RSS talks about the constitution like one of the previous
27:59speakers has already mentioned before.
28:01And when we are trying to draw comparisons between the Jantar Maktar CJP protests and what the students from Jharkhand
28:09are doing, I'll tell you what the differences are.
28:11Of course, there are similarities.
28:12Both of them are about paper leaves.
28:14Both of them are asking for accountability from the governments.
28:16But the differences are nobody has called the students anti-national so far.
28:20The Congress Party, which is in the ruling alliance, their working president has actually sent out water supplies and food
28:25supplies to the protesters.
28:26He's not made a personal visit himself, which is very well understandable and practical.
28:30You can't, you know, go and be seen in a protest against your own government.
28:34But he is supporting the right of the students to protest.
28:37Nobody has fired pellet guns on them.
28:40So far as I know, no tear gassing has been done.
28:42And nobody is saying that these students are trying to overthrow the state.
28:45And most importantly, on the point of accountability, the PCS chairman has already been removed.
28:50Unlike in the neat paper leak, where the government initially denied that there was a paper leak, only after a
28:56lot of pressure that they changed the NTA chairman.
29:00And they took quite a lot of time, quite a lot of time.
29:02It wasn't something that happened promptly, unlike in the case of Jharkhand.
29:06And this is what democracy is all about.
29:09Ratan Sharda wants to respond on both the points that you raised.
29:12One small point, if I may make.
29:14One small point, Mr. Sharda can take that as well.
29:17I think this government also epitomizes something we, in common parlance, called Mo Pe Ram Bagal Me Chhoori.
29:22If these students are indeed anti-nationals, trying to overthrow the Indian state and this and that, why the hell
29:28were you negotiating with them?
29:29Why did J.P. Nada and J.T. Inder Singh sit with them?
29:32They should have been thrown there and bars, but you can't do that.
29:34Ratan Sharda, Ratan Sharda is responding on the points that Atul Limai made.
29:38What was anti-national, what was anti-Hindu in students' protest when Atul Limai said, words to the effect, why
29:44anti-Hindu voices were heard on these platforms?
29:47Why were individuals raising or supporting controversial anti-national slogans there, sir?
29:53You heard, you know, Mr. Jain, you may respond now.
29:57You know, already, you have video records, all the TV channels have video records, what kind of statements are made
30:03there against Hindus, what kind of statements are made against the state, the government, and what kind of statements are
30:08made in favor of terrorists supporting its divisive politics and separatist people.
30:14It's all well known, it is there, recorded by all of you.
30:17Secondly, he talks of Ambedkar and all these two people talk to Ambedkar.
30:21Ambedkar's election agent was Mr. Dattopan Tengdi, a very senior Pracharak, who was his election agent when he was debated
30:29by the Congress people.
30:31Secondly, when you, at that time, when you, when the questions were raised about constitution, please read debates of the
30:37constitution where so many people very openly criticized, saying that this particular constitution has been copied from various western countries
30:45where Mr. B.N. Rao went all over the world to gather those gems of wisdom.
30:49But not one scripture, not one Indian knowledge has been referred to in the entire constitution.
30:56This is said by Congress leaders, constitutional assembly people.
30:59At that time, when constitution was being underwriting, people had their views.
31:04So, will we call those people anti-constitution?
31:06That was a view which was later addressed.
31:09No, the point, Ratan Sharada, the point Mr. Jain raises, sir, the point he raises is, Jharkhand, no pellet guns
31:16were fired at students.
31:17In Jharkhand, no pellets were fired at students.
31:20No students were called anti-national.
31:23There was an attempt to malign students protesting in Delhi.
31:25That's the point he's raising.
31:26I want you to respond to that, sir.
31:28See, Jharkhand, students have behaved very, very responsibly.
31:32They have not abused anybody.
31:33They have not turned violent.
31:35They have been indisciplined.
31:36That is the reason not being heard by people.
31:39You want people to become violent.
31:40You want people to abuse so that then only they will be heard.
31:43So, Jharkhand's student crime is that they have been disciplined.
31:46They have remained within bounds of law.
31:48And they have not run riot.
31:50And that is why are these people upset?
31:52Why are they not going to support them?
31:53Why are they quiet on this?
31:55Not just Jharkhand.
31:56There are cases, as I said, all over the various states.
31:59And you talk of student agitation.
32:00I was part of emergency struggle.
32:02I went to jail.
32:04We followed constitution to the T and suffered jail for one month to 19 months.
32:10All through these people who fought for it.
32:12ABP takes out agitation.
32:14It never crosses constitution bound.
32:16Gives suggestions.
32:18Have these people ever given one suggestion?
32:20Apart from saying Pradhan resign.
32:23Did they have any positive to say?
32:24So, do not mix up CJP, you know, ganging together with the opposition party and the students.
32:30Students, they were disappointed.
32:32They said openly that we came for needed education.
32:34We find this has been hijacked by these people.
32:37Nikhil Jain, you want to quickly respond to that?
32:39The difference between Jharkhand and Delhi, what you did not point out was the violence and vandalism in Delhi,
32:44which is absent in Jharkhand, sir.
32:482,800 criminals in the riot.
32:50Mr. Shadev, Mr. Shadev, that is just a claim.
32:53By sources of the Delhi police, the same Delhi police, which could not count the magnitude of people that could
32:59show up on the 20th of July.
33:00So, I will not get into that.
33:01The key point remains that the CJP protests were in Jantar Mantar for over a month before the 20th of
33:06July marched to the parliament.
33:08Until then, there wasn't a single incidence of violence.
33:10It was only during the morning and afternoon on the 20th of July when we have countless visuals of police
33:16brutality that incidents of violence started appearing from both the sides.
33:20Until then, the protest was completely peaceful.
33:22Not a single act of violence.
33:24Yet, the BJP and the RSS ecosystem was going around blaming these people as foreign funded by China, Soros, America,
33:30this, that, and all these things.
33:32And also, Mr. Shadev points out how ABVP and BJYM protests are very well within the bounds of the constitution.
33:37May I remind him that just three or four years ago, there was a protest that was done outside the
33:42residence.
33:42Mind you, the residence of the Deputy Chief Minister of Delhi by BJYM and ABVP and BJP workers.
33:48They entered into the house, broke the CCTV cameras, broke the barrier, entered into the office, ransacked the furniture.
33:55Tejasvi Surya, sitting member of parliament of the BJP, led those protesters.
33:58Not as single action has been taken so far.
34:00So, let's not try to be so rich here.
34:02You want to respond on, you know, the BJP or the RSS trying to malign a student's movement by branding
34:10it.
34:11They're saying that's typical RSS tactics that you start branding it as anti-national, anti-Hindu, anti-social and not
34:19address the core issue.
34:20That's the point Sairasha Haleem raised.
34:22Well, if these people believe that police is partial, that police does a right record and these are all fake,
34:29then why did you question the CCT cameras?
34:31Why did these people ask the CCT cameras were removed?
34:34How they were, CCT cameras were destroyed?
34:37Was that, was that not anti-constitution?
34:40As far as BJP attack on Deputy Chief is concerned, why you, why there was no case registered?
34:46They should have registered case.
34:47They should have been punished.
34:48Why are they delinquents?
34:49Nobody defended them.
34:51Nobody defended them.
34:52Nobody told them to speak in windows.
34:53But I want to bring in Sairasha Haleem on another point that has been raised.
34:57The kind of language that was used by some of the protesters, the RSS says Indian culture teaches one to
35:05view women with reverence, akin to a mother figure.
35:08I'm quoting them.
35:09Platforms associated with certain movements have witnessed the use of rather indecent language and behavior that RSS says stands in
35:17stark contrast to Indian values.
35:20As a political leader and as a parent and an analyst, your thoughts, Sairasha Haleem?
35:25The kind of abusive language that was used?
35:28See, one can refrain from abusive language, okay?
35:31But if you look at the ground reports that have come in, there have been allegations that Delhi police lathe
35:37charge on a couple of students and it had nails on the lathees, which is unfortunate.
35:43And also there were, there were random detentions.
35:46Some of them were minors who were detained.
35:49There were students who were asked to pull down the social media posts.
35:53So we have heard stories from the students' side as well.
35:58And right now, I am talking on behalf of the students, right?
36:02Because here, if you look at this, it was a peaceful protest.
36:06Everyone was walking with the Indian flag.
36:08They were carrying copies of the Indian constitution.
36:11There was no anti-national talk.
36:14The memes, they were...
36:16So, you know, a student's protest where leaders come and talk about restoration of Article 370.
36:20Is that kosher?
36:23A student's protest when certain comments have been made, which some people have found objectionable about Maryada Purushottam Shri Ram.
36:31A student's protest where a lot has been said in the kind of abusive language.
36:35And Dr. Vikram Singh's point, you are ignoring Dr. Vikram Singh's point of more than 100 policemen having very serious
36:42injuries.
36:44So, they are always, they would be a little collateral damage because it was such a humongous protest.
36:51There might be some people who might have infiltrated just the way they were people without uniforms, without identity badges,
37:00who couldn't identify themselves, who were marching with the Delhi police, who were thrashing these students.
37:05So, how did these people without identification markers on them, how were they escorting the Delhi police?
37:14Dr. Vikram Singh, you want to respond because it's a very serious point.
37:18It's a very serious point that's being raised.
37:22You know, lattes with nails being used, pictures went viral and as a former top cop and also as a
37:28vice chancellor of a university, your take on the kind of language, the abuses there in general.
37:34Can it be, you know, seen as just, this is Gen Z language or what does that reflect, the kind
37:40of language that we used?
37:41Mr. Gaurav Ji, I have served 36 in the police and I have been associated with the police and now
37:46with the education industry now.
37:48I would say that I have three quick points to make.
37:50Number one, that it is not collateral.
37:53Unprecedented violence was inflicted on the Delhi policemen and women, 150 injured and 30 vehicles burned down.
38:00And to say that it was just an ordinary collateral damage.
38:02Now, coming to the fact that a lot of rumours, mongering and a lot of rumours and fake news and
38:07deep fake news were being churned out.
38:08It is not in the interest of the police to carry lattes that have nails.
38:13They have better things to do and they have everything in their arsenal, beginning from tear gas right up to
38:17solid bullets.
38:18They don't require these primitive weapons to inflict an injury if they want to.
38:23Now, the third, the language you said, the language you said was indecent.
38:26It wasn't indecent.
38:27It was absolute crash.
38:29And I thought that we in the police were the gold medalists as far as abusive and filthy language.
38:33But they have deprived me of my gold medal of abusive language.
38:37And to the contrary, I would say to the shock and horror of all the esteemed panelists and your viewers
38:42that this language is unheard of even in the lives of G.B.
38:45Roar.
38:45I would say that I think the strongest exception to the language used by them, they are not students.
38:50And I can tell you that if this happens in my university, any child using this kind of language will
38:55not be my student 40 times in eternity.
38:58And the parents will be caught and given a piece of my mind.
39:02Okay.
39:02Mr. Jain wants to respond to you.
39:04Go ahead, Mr. Jain.
39:07Gaurav, I think we can all sit here and condemn the abusive language used by students in their memes, posters,
39:12naras and whatever.
39:13No, no, memes and posters, as long as they are civil is okay.
39:16But the kind of cross abusive language that was used.
39:18No, no, I'm saying let's condemn it.
39:20I'm saying let's, no, no, I think all of us on the panel can condemn it.
39:23I think all of us can say it's not right, it's not cultured to use abusive language against anybody, prime
39:28minister, leader of opposition, anybody.
39:30I don't think it's fair, it's wrong, it should not be done.
39:33But does that mean the moment somebody abuses the prime minister or some other politician, you're going to start shooting
39:38them with pellet guns?
39:39Does it mean that you're going to start hitting them with tics that have nails on them?
39:43Does that mean you're going to dox their personal details publicly of 15-year-old girls and you're going to
39:48give them rape threats?
39:49Does that mean that the police is going to harass the child and their family?
39:53Does that mean that the government will continue to lie?
39:56Because Mr. Singh paints a picture wherein the police has really suffered a lot and I can understand that as
40:00a cop he would have his sympathies.
40:02But are you saying police did not suffer at all?
40:05Are you saying police did not suffer?
40:07Or are you saying, you know, as Saira Shah Haneem says, it's collateral damage, it's their job to suffer?
40:13No, God, I would be stupid.
40:15You call them collateral damage.
40:17I'm surprised they're human beings too.
40:19Are human beings collateral damage in any agitation?
40:22It is a spontaneous protest of that magnitude.
40:26If that is not grammar of anarchy, what else is?
40:29Is the usage of pellet guns, is the usage of pellet guns alloyed?
40:33Was it exceptional circumstances?
40:35Was there some kind of a threat from students that some of the cops use the pellet guns?
40:42Ratan Sharda wants to respond to that.
40:44Even the Supreme Court has said that the graded response should be if there are exceptional circumstances.
40:50So I want to ask, Mr. Ratan Sharda, what was the exceptional circumstances?
40:56When it comes for use, when it comes for use, when it comes for use, when it comes for use.
40:58Ratan Sharda, quickly, I have 30 seconds on this part of the show.
41:00Quickly, Ratan Sharda.
41:02People who abuse, the abusive people are very, very small margin, very few people.
41:07They have been magnified.
41:09But point is, such language was used.
41:11Secondly, when they were abusing, were they attacked?
41:13Because they were abusing, there are scenes where girls and boys were continuously taunting
41:18the policemen, insulting them.
41:20They still kept a constraint.
41:22So to believe, to sell the story that they were abused, that's why they were attacked.
41:28No.
41:28They were attacked.
41:29There is a story of policemen saying he saw girls on the top of the toilet.
41:33They were storing stones.
41:35They were throwing stones.
41:36He went up and was beaten to death, near death.
41:38And so, this is the kind of crowd that was there.
41:412,800 criminals.
41:42And you say they were not there.
41:43You are saying police is making a fake record.
41:45You are opposing CCTV.
41:47You are opposing AI.
41:48Because you want to shield those people.
41:50And you go to court, so there is no action is taken.
41:52No action will be taken as students, against minors.
41:55But it had to be taken against criminals.
41:57Are you defending them?
41:59Given to this degree.
42:00But that chronology of the unrest.
42:03We've got you all sides of the story.
42:04Now, as our viewer, you decide what you think is right.
42:09And who was creating unrest or fomenting trouble there.
42:13We'll track that story very closely.
42:15I want to thank all my guests.
42:16I quickly want to cut across to a big story that's coming from across the line of control.
42:21There are reports coming in.
42:22At least 17 people have been killed in a suicide attack in Khaybar, Pakhtun Qua.
42:28At what has been described as a peace rally.
42:31Those are images that are coming in.
42:34More updates are just coming in as I get you the story.
42:37This was a peace rally meant to promote harmony.
42:42And it turned into a scene of bloodshed.
42:44Amongst those killed are seven Pakistan police personnel.
42:48Several others continue to battle for their lives in hospital.
42:51The suicide bomber struck near the entrance of a police station.
42:55Where hundreds of people had gathered for a public demonstration.
42:59The latest input that's coming in, it's now being confirmed.
43:02At least 17 people are feared dead in this Khaybar, Pakhtun Qua suicide attack.
43:10The attack has once again exposed the persistent threat of unrest in Pakistan's Khaybar, Pakhtun Qua province.
43:20A region that has witnessed repeated violence despite years of military operations.
43:25We'll get you much more on that story.
43:27But for the moment, I also want to focus on the bigger picture that emerges from Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied
43:36Jammu and Kashmir.
43:37Pakistan is literally burning on all fronts.
43:40From Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir's struggle for democracy and basic rights.
43:45For food and Pakistani security forces firing at protesters at point blank range.
43:50I want to get you that big story.
43:52Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir.
43:55They are burning on multiple fronts.
43:56And I want to begin with these pictures of unrest in Khaybar, Pakhtun Qua.
44:01There are repeated strikes that are also happening by Baluch freedom fighters in what they describe as Pakistan-occupied Baluchistan.
44:10There is also unrest simmering in the Sindh and Pakistan's Punjab province under Field Marshal Asim Munir.
44:20The country is hurtling from one disaster to the other with tensions high, not just on the AFPAC border.
44:28Along the Durand Line, the 2,600 kilometer border that divides Pakistan and Afghanistan.
44:34There is unrest on the AFPAC border, there is unrest on the Iran-Pakistan border and of course tensions are
44:39high along the line of control.
44:41That is the India-Pakistan line of control.
44:44So bad is the situation that Pakistan's Interior Minister Mohsin Nakwe, better known in India as Trophy Chor.
44:50Who incidentally harbors the ambition of being the next Pakistan Army appointed Prime Minister.
44:57He said that the system in Pakistan has all but collapsed or words to that effect.
45:03Several analysts see this as a precursor to Pakistan's Field Marshal Asim Munir.
45:09Now wanting to officially take over as the military dictator or the President of Pakistan while he remains Army Chief.
45:17And Mohsin Nakwe would be his puppet Prime Minister.
45:21Lots of reactions coming in. Listen in.
46:24Pakistan's Interior Minister Mohsin Nakwe, you just heard him saying the system has collapsed.
46:28He is now up the ante.
46:30He said the biggest corruption scam in the country's history is unfolding.
46:37So remember he said Pakistan's system had completely collapsed.
46:40Mohsin Nakwe has made another explosive claim,
46:43alleging one of the largest corruption scandals in the country's history is unfolding.
46:48He insists that judges, bureaucrats, political leaders, bankers, they are all part of a very corrupt nexus in Pakistan.
46:58Money was exchanging hands over 21 years and he says as Interior Minister he will bring accountability,
47:07he will punish everyone found responsible regardless of their position.
47:12His remarks have intensified the political speculation in Pakistan whether he now wants to be Prime Minister.
47:19He says make me the Prime Minister and I will cleanse the system.
47:22You can listen in.
48:02from the situation on ground to two people who keep a hawk
48:07eye on developments in Pakistan one is major a del Raja and ex-pakistan army
48:12major currently in the United Kingdom in virtually in exile Sandeeponeetan
48:16senior journalist join me on this broadcast Major Raja your take on the
48:21current situation, the country seems to be burning
48:23on all fronts and Mohsen Nakwe now
48:25says the biggest corruption
48:26scandal in Pakistan's history, 21
48:29years, political leaders, judges,
48:31everybody was a part of
48:33this. What do you make of it? Is he
48:34making grounds saying make me the Prime Minister
48:37and Asim Munir the President?
48:39Well, Gaurav, my answer
48:41is a single sentence.
48:42Look who's talking, yaar. Look who's
48:45talking. I mean, if
48:46what all he's saying has
48:49been happening in Pakistan, and definitely
48:51it has been happening in Pakistan, look at
48:53the Global Corruption Index, look
48:54at where they stand.
48:56I mean, all the patronage to
48:59this corruption has been accorded
49:01by the Pakistani military establishment
49:03and Mr. Mohsen Nakwe is
49:05a representative of that establishment
49:07being brother-in-law
49:08of the Army Chief, Field Marshal
49:11Asim Munir. And, you know,
49:12if he's talking about corruption, fine.
49:15Okay, corruption is the Pakistan's biggest
49:17issue. So let's have accountability
49:18Let's have accountability across the
49:21board. Let's have accountability
49:22of the islands of the generals
49:24Let's have accountability of his own
49:26brother-in-law's accounts in Macau
49:28Let's have accountability of
49:30the match-fixing scandals
49:32where millions of pounds and
49:34millions of dollars were laundered
49:36by Mr. Mohsen Nakwe. Let's have
49:38accountability of Mr. Mohsen Nakwe's
49:40own enterprises and his brother-in-law's
49:42enterprises and the various
49:44journals like the Internal Wings
49:46Director General of the ISI
49:49like the Director General
49:50Military Intelligence, my own
49:52family. In fact, let's have
49:54accountability of their assets and
49:56their sources beyond means. They all
49:58hold international properties. Let's
50:00have accountability of the Director
50:02General Inter-Services Intelligence,
50:04billions of rupees, hundreds of
50:06millions of dollars of property in
50:08Portugal. Let's have accountability
50:10across the board. So my answer
50:12is, look who's talking.
50:13Ye toh yaar bahana bana re hai hai to
50:15take over the system. It is as
50:17simple as that.
50:18Take over the system. So Mohsen
50:20Nakwe as Prime Minister and
50:22Aasem Munir, his brother-in-law, as
50:24President and Army Chief. Is that
50:26the game plan and will they succeed in
50:28your view, Major Raja?
50:30Well, one thing they are not going to,
50:33you know, change and that is what I
50:35reported in August 2025 that they
50:37want Army Chief Aasem Munir as the
50:40uniform president with the
50:41presidential powers which were taken
50:44away in the 18th constitutional
50:46amendment. They want it to be given
50:48back. Now, the Prime Minister may
50:50change. Mohsen Nakwe may have a
50:51separate designation, but the Prime
50:54Minister would remain somebody whose
50:57hands are tied behind his back and he
51:00would be there to run the economy
51:02because one thing the military is
51:03simply unable to do or understand is
51:05how to run the economy and how to
51:07gain investor confidence. Now, if
51:09they want investor confidence, they
51:11have to win public trust because at
51:13the end of the day, there is a huge
51:15trust deficit and if they have to win
51:18the trust of the people, they have to
51:19free Imran Khan. But if they free
51:21Imran Khan before bringing these
51:23constitutional amendments and the
51:25constitutional changes, well, obviously
51:27he's not going to agree to their
51:28terms. So, will Aasem Munir ever agree
51:31yes, to release Imran Khan. Clearly, that
51:34appears very unlikely. But I want to
51:36bring in Sandeep Unnithan. Sandeep, it
51:38seems... But there's a breaking news,
51:39Garab, I would like to tell you that as
51:41well. Sure, always for breaking news. Go on.
51:42Breaking news from today is that the
51:43Pakistan Imran Khan's party is being
51:46offered that he's going to be freed if
51:48the party gives vote for the
51:50presidential system because the system
51:53requires, the parliament requires two
51:55third majority and the present parties in
51:57power and elite capture are not willing to
51:59go ahead with it. They're not going to
52:01cut their own hands and add it over to,
52:03you know, Aasem Munir. So, they're now
52:05vooing the PTI party that, okay, we will
52:08free Imran Khan after you vote in the
52:11presidential system. Yes.
52:13No, but what will Imran Khan do? I want you
52:15to quickly respond to that. Will Imran Khan
52:16agree to this point? One, point two, will
52:19Imran Khan remain in Pakistan or do they
52:21want him to send him into exile either to
52:23Saudi Arabia, Dubai or United Kingdom?
52:26So, obviously, Imran Khan won't be able to
52:28do anything after the constitutional
52:29amendments have been made and after
52:31Imran Khan does not have two third
52:33majority to overturn the constitutional
52:35amendments. Firstly, secondly, he's not
52:37never going to agree. And thirdly, the
52:39offer is only to free Imran Khan. He might
52:42come back into power even, but with the
52:44current constitutional system which they're
52:46trying to make, which the military is
52:48trying to make, he won't be able to, you
52:50know, do any changes because he will have
52:52the oversight of a military general as
52:55president who can, you know, just send
52:57him home, send him back to jail, you know.
52:59So, obviously, Imran Khan has refused to go
53:01out of the country anyway. So, you know,
53:03they are trying to tie his hat down.
53:04So, I want to bring in Sandeep Unnithan.
53:06Sandeep, this is, this is actually history
53:09repeating itself in Pakistan again and again
53:11and again from Ayub Khan, Yaya Khan, Zia
53:15Ul Haq, Parvez Nusharraf and now Asim
53:17Munir. Yes, absolutely, Gaurav. And, you
53:20know, it's all about Pakistan's dictators
53:22and their supposed role of being, you
53:26know, godsend to save Pakistan from all its
53:28problems. Munir is the latest iteration of
53:30that. He's the fifth dictator that Pakistan
53:33has had. And he's, if you look at it,
53:36Gaurav, he's the most powerful military
53:39figure in Pakistan's history. He's only their
53:41second field marshal. He's their first chief
53:43of defense forces. So, there's tremendous
53:46speculation now that he could actually become
53:48like Parvez Musharraf. He could actually be the
53:50president of Pakistan and the chief of defense
53:54staff at the same time because he has to
53:56protect himself, Gaurav. He's made powerful
53:58enemies within the country up against Imran
54:01Khan. So, that battle with Imran Khan continues.
54:04But at the end of the day, Gaurav, all Pakistan
54:07military dictators, they're all trying to save
54:09themselves. It's never worse in the past. He's
54:12actually betting against the history. He's betting
54:14against the past. All four dictators have been
54:17disgraced. They've gone home. Some of them
54:20have, their bodies have not been found, Gaurav. I
54:23mean, you know what happened with President Zia
54:25ul Haqq. Musharraf died in his life. You know,
54:28there is no... Oh, absolutely. And died a broken
54:30man. So, does he intend breaking that trend?
54:34Major Raja, is that even possible? You know, he's
54:37riding a tiger. Major Raja, does he think that he'll
54:40buck the trend? Every other dictator did not, did not
54:44succeed in Pakistan. How does Aasip Munir hope to
54:47succeed?
54:49He said that thousands of dreams are like this, that every
54:53dream is gone. It's gone. It's gone. It's gone. It's gone.
54:56It's gone. It's gone. It's gone. But it's gone. It's gone.
54:57It's gone. Obviously, he wants to be the most successful
55:00dictator ever. You know, he wants to rule forever. That's why
55:05he... In the last constitutional amendment, he got lifetime
55:09immunity for himself. But the problem is, who is going to
55:12pay the bill? Who's going to foot the bill? Who's going to
55:15finance him? In the case of Zia ul Haqq, the Americans were
55:18funding Zia ul Haqq through the Afghan jihad. In the case of
55:21Ayub Khan, the previous field marshal, he was being funded by
55:24the Americans. In the case of Musharraf, he was being funded by
55:27the Americans. So far, the Americans have not funded Aasim
55:31Munir. Instead, Aasim Munir has been spending money on Trump
55:35family enterprises to earn the title of favorite field
55:38marshal. So who's going to, you know, foot the bill? So
55:42far, there is nobody in sight who's going to foot the bill. So
55:45they want to go after an accountability drive in which
55:49they are thinking that they will, you know, mint the money
55:52out of the politicians and presently selective accountability
55:56process. But they've already sorted out these issues, you
56:02know. So that is, there's a difference between what he wants
56:05and what's the reality. But Sandeep, the last 30 seconds I have
56:08on this part of the show, they've sold off PIA. They'll probably
56:11sell off POJK or POGB, Pakistan occupied Gilgit, Baltistan or Gwadar
56:16to China and hope to get some money to survive a couple of years.
56:20Absolutely, Gaurav. You know, Pakistan is a business, Gaurav. We should understand that. You know, the Pakistan army is not
56:27actually an army. It's actually a business enterprise. The 4G foundation is a classic case of that. It is the
56:32largest business conglomerate in Pakistan. The Pakistan army is a business enterprise. The CEO is the army chief. The security
56:41function is what they borrow against. It is the collateral that they deposit and they borrow against.
56:47And look at that big picture of Pakistan. It's burning on all fronts. It's burning on all fronts. Will it
56:53implode? Will it collapse? Or will it survive? Or will it remain jelly state Pakistan? That's a story we'll be
56:59tracking very closely. I want to thank both my guests. That is all I have for you on India First
57:03this evening. Many thanks for watching.

Recommended