• 4 months ago
A controversy has erupted following Hockey India's decision to replace the traditional blue jersey with a saffron primary jersey for the men's and women's national teams ahead of the FIH Hockey World Cup.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Good evening, girls. You're watching To The Point. I am Preeti Chaudhary.
00:04Our top focus for generations on, Team India has always won't blue.
00:08Where our men's team is concerned, there were men in blue.
00:11Where women's team was concerned, there were women in blue.
00:14But now a jersey change in hockey has sparked a massive debate
00:18over identity, over symbolism and also over politics.
00:23Is this simply a sporting decision or has the colour saffron
00:27for Team India become the latest political battleground?
00:42For decades, India's sporting identity has been blue.
00:47Men in blue. Women in blue.
00:50From cricket to hockey to athletics, blue has been the colour of Team India.
00:56But ahead of the FIH Hockey World Cup, that identity is changing.
01:01For the first time, India's men's and women's hockey teams
01:05will wear saffron as their primary jersey.
01:08And that has triggered a political storm.
01:11The new kit unveiled by Hockey India replaces the iconic blue
01:15as India's primary playing jersey.
01:20Hockey India says the decision followed feedback from players and coaches.
01:24The blue jersey, it says, often blended with a blue turf, affecting visibility.
01:30Saffron was chosen because it symbolises courage and sacrifice
01:34and is inspired by the national flag.
01:37But critics aren't convinced.
01:40Former Indian captain, Virend Raskeena, has called the move embarrassing,
01:44saying India's sporting identity is blue.
01:46There's another twist.
01:49The Netherlands, one of Hockey's powerhouses, traditionally plays in orange.
01:53So when India faces the Dutch at the World Cup,
01:56it will have to switch back to its alternate blue jersey
01:59because of the colour clash.
02:02The controversy has now spilled into politics.
02:05The opposition has accused the BJP and RSS
02:08of trying to redefine India's identity through symbols.
02:12To make sure we can change uniform,
02:15we can change the education policy into our own
02:44The BJP has hit back, accusing the opposition
02:47of politicising the colour saffron.
03:19India's orange-dominated alternate jersey at the 2019 Cricket World Cup also triggered
03:24a political row.
03:26Even today's cricket jersey is no longer entirely blue, with orange stripes replacing the all-blue
03:32look of the past.
03:34Now, hockey has followed the same path, with saffron replacing blue as the primary colour.
03:40As the debate grows, one question remains.
03:44Is this simply a technical decision, or is the visual identity of Indian sport changing,
03:50one jersey at a time?
03:51Bureau Report, India Today.
03:58All right, let's quickly pull in experts from both politics as well as sports.
04:04Joining me is Nikhil Nas, my colleague and our sports editor.
04:08Sanjay Jha, political analyst.
04:10Ranjit Sethi, political analyst.
04:12Jagbir Singh, former Indian hockey captain, Olympian and Arjuna awardee.
04:17We also have Sharda Ugra, senior sports journalist.
04:21I'd like to begin with Nikhil, who has something to say Nikhil, with what we've seen in terms
04:27of change of jersey and a lot of conversation around that.
04:31Well, first things first, Preeti.
04:33It's not the first time that the Indian hockey team would be wearing orange.
04:36It's happened in the past as well.
04:38Different colours have been tried.
04:40I remember our second jersey used to be orange on multiple occasions,
04:43used to be white on multiple occasions.
04:45I think 2014 World Cup India also had yellow as their primary jersey.
04:49So this is not unprecedented.
04:51However, what's that one big thing that's changed?
04:53Is that your primary jersey is orange.
04:56Now, if you ask my personal opinion, I rather or much rather prefer the blue because, you
05:01know, for nostalgic reasons, I've seen Pargat Singh run through a host of Pakistani defenders
05:07in the blue jersey scoring a goal or a Dhanraj Pillay with his hair flying and, you know,
05:12running like the wind in the blue jersey.
05:14So for me, Indian hockey has been blue.
05:17We call them the men in blue.
05:18We have other phrases like bleed blue and so on and so forth.
05:22So, India's identity is blue just as Argentina is blue and white.
05:25Holland is orange.
05:27Pakistan is green and so on and so forth.
05:29So, I much rather prefer the blue.
05:31Having said that, I don't think this is an issue that we need to fret over because there
05:36are much larger issues that are plaguing Indian hockey at the moment.
05:39I'm glad to see that the attention towards Indian hockey has come primarily because this has
05:44become a political issue.
05:46But I think the larger issues, you had a recent case of Asunta Lakra.
05:50She is a former Indian women's hockey captain.
05:52Just a few weeks ago, she came out and said that, listen, there are young girls in Jharkhand
05:57who have been, you know, at the receiving end of sexual harassment by a local coach.
06:03And guess what?
06:03There were no TV debates around that.
06:05There was no mainstream coverage.
06:07There were no keyboard warriors talking about it or amplifying it.
06:10You have Suresh Lata Devi, who is a former captain, won the gold in the Commonwealth Games.
06:16A few years ago, she had a case and filed a case of domestic violence against her husband.
06:21She's been fighting that case for many years, but no mainstream coverage, no trending on social
06:27media.
06:27No one is talking about it.
06:29As Shreejesh, I mean, he's a hero.
06:30Everyone knows Shreejesh.
06:31Hero behind India winning two back-to-back medals at the Olympic Games.
06:36He was removed as the junior coach of Indian team, unceremoniously, despite getting good
06:42results.
06:43He went to social media talking about it.
06:45Nobody, it wasn't trending.
06:46There was no TV debate there as well.
06:48Nobody on both sides of the political divide talking about how our national hero in Shreejesh
06:54has been treated like that.
06:55I'll give you two more examples.
06:56I mean, hockey examples.
06:58We just had the FIH Pro League, where India finished eight out of the nine teams.
07:03The only team behind India was Pakistan, and you know where Pakistan hockey is at the moment.
07:07Nobody is talking about the performance of Indian hockey and why there's been a dip.
07:11But yes, the color of the jerseys seems important, and it becomes a big issue.
07:15And finally, you know, we had the Indian women's team not make it to the Paris Olympics.
07:20I traveled there.
07:21Prior to that, in the Tokyo Olympics, they finished a creditable fourth.
07:24Next Olympics, they don't even qualify.
07:27Nobody spoke about it.
07:28My thing is that as soon as things become political, everyone wants to jump on the bandwagon.
07:33You want to make hay while the sun is shining.
07:36But when it comes to the real sport, nobody wants to talk about it.
07:40So in that sense, I'm glad something political happened with Indian hockey.
07:43Maybe, at least that way, we are talking about Indian hockey on a prime time debate.
07:48Well, you know, you seem to have quite a bit to get off your chest, Nikhil.
07:52But quite a compelling argument that Nikhil made there.
07:55I want to bring in Jagbir Singh, former Indian hockey captain as well.
07:59He's an Olympian.
08:00He's an Arjuna awardee.
08:01Thank you, sir, for coming on our show.
08:03I'd like to ask you, what do you make of the switch from blue to saffron?
08:09First, adding on what Nikhil finished, very, very unfortunate that hockey is being remembered
08:16only for wrong reasons, especially in the prime time shows.
08:19I see no reason why hockey should be treated this way.
08:24Very rightly so.
08:25There is a debate on the jersey colour, but there should be a debate on why this jersey colour
08:32has been changed and to what extent should it have been changed?
08:37Did we really need complete orange or there should have been a combination of orange and blue?
08:44Because you need some striking colours on a blue pitch, which was introduced in 2012.
08:51No issues were there.
08:53Changing colours of playing jerseys because the green pitch, you could play with any colour.
08:59But on a blue pitch, you need to have your stockings, your playing jersey and even the
09:05ball you are playing with, which is more visible, which is more TV friendly.
09:10I agree completely with the coaches and the team management saying that they need more striking colours.
09:17But to this extent, I also not expected.
09:21All right.
09:22You didn't expect it.
09:23So why is it really happened?
09:24Why that switch?
09:25Before I go to our two political analysts, allow me to bring in Sharda Ugra, senior sports journalist, into this
09:32conversation.
09:33Ms. Ugra, what do you make of the change in the hockey jersey?
09:36From blue to saffron, do you read politics or, you know, the pitch is blue or where, you know, the
09:41field is blue?
09:42So why not?
09:46I was not surprised when it showed up because this kind of thing has been building for a while.
09:50It showed up about 24 hours ago.
09:53And because of the reaction, you're seeing the kind of response that we've got and that people just do, they
09:58do not like it.
09:59And that's why you have this really half believable kind of explanation that they've come with and said, oh, we
10:05asked the players and we asked this thing.
10:07I don't believe any of it.
10:08I think it's it's been done from the top.
10:11I am sort of reliably told that the playing community had no idea of it, including those that are in
10:18the administration.
10:19So this has just been imposed on the team as such.
10:23And my question is what's going to happen when you play Netherlands, who also play in orange, who have been
10:28orange for decades.
10:30And they said, you know, orange is part saffron, orange is part of our flag, but so is white and
10:34so is green.
10:35So that's that's my opinion on it.
10:37I'm not surprised, though.
10:38There's been a push to kind of do this across across with the cricket team as well some time ago,
10:44which they refused to accept or believe or or even accept that it happened.
10:49This is not a surprise.
10:51In my view, it's a sort of almost like a distraction kind of thing that they've done.
10:54It's a it's a two in one kind of trick that they're trying to pull off a patriotic or, you
10:59know, catering to one lot of people as well as a kind of a diversionary kind of trick that hockey
11:06India people are playing.
11:07Ms. Sugra, before I go to the rest, what do you mean diversionary trick?
11:11You know, what do they not want to speak of? What are they trying to divert attention from?
11:18From what is an important issue, actually, at the moment, which is sexual harassment and abuse allegations against a coach
11:26in Jharkand, under whom the Secretary General of Hockey India, which is Bola Nazi.
11:34He threatened the player who took the complaint forward, who was a former India hockey captain of the women's team.
11:41And Hockey India has launched an ethics committee sort of a probe against the player, against Asunta Lakha, who made
11:50the complaint that about 30 national and international players had complained about this Jharkand hockey coach.
11:56Bolanath Singh also happens to be a former vice president of the Wrestling Federation of India when Bridge Bushan Saran
12:02Singh was the president.
12:04So that's why I'm saying it's a distraction tactic, along with, you know, upsetting a lot of former players and
12:09so on.
12:11Whoa, Miss Ugra, you've detonated a bit of a bombshell in the newsroom here by making those allegations.
12:17I'm going to bring in Nikhil, but allow me, Nikhil, to bring in our two other guests and I'll come
12:20right back to you.
12:21Because Nikhil also, in his opening remarks, had mentioned this very point of allegations of sexual harassment.
12:27But it's also become political. And Sanjay Jha, you read politics in all of this.
12:33I do. And by the way, let me tell you, I have immense respect for Sharda.
12:38And I have been, by the way, I funded and I ran a cricket portal for a long time.
12:44So I understand sports. And I do know, actually, I learned my politics because of sports.
12:49Full credit to the BCCI. I owe them full credit for my blossoming political career.
12:54But let's go to the chase. I do believe and, you know, I need to give you credit for this,
13:00Preeti, including, by the way, your brilliant soliloquy yesterday, which I thought was outstanding.
13:06I need to congratulate you publicly for it. Well done. Well done. We need more like you.
13:11But I'm a little disappointed with my friend Nikhil today. Let me be absolutely brutally honest.
13:17Nikhil, this isn't about just a color.
13:19You know, I'm glad that Indian hockey is coming to the limelight because of the current controversy.
13:26But this isn't about color. I mean, we all know you cannot look at the saffronization of the jersey of
13:33the hockey players,
13:34once hockey considered to be India's national sport, as just another, you know, kind of a step taken because of
13:41the color of the turf.
13:43This is a political project, even in cricket, Nikhil, where you and I have defined cricketers as men in blue.
13:50There has been an attempt. Saffron has entered there as well, right?
13:53Saffron has entered into the non-playing field jerseys that they wear.
13:57It's a this is a basic and let me call it out pretty an insecure political organization that may rename
14:07cities, renames monuments, will change historical dates.
14:11They will obliterate history. They will do this.
14:14I'm promising you this. They will do to cricket one day.
14:17I'm telling you that they will. If supposing they were to win power again, we will all have to wear
14:23saffron when we come for TV shows.
14:25By the way, my blue tie is a coincidence. I just returned from work.
14:28But the larger message here is this is a political project.
14:32Sports federations are controlled by politicians. There is money. There is power.
14:37There is fame. There is influence. There is networking.
14:39And there is all kinds of games that are played, including, as my friend Sharda said, trying to cover up
14:45a sexual harassment case.
14:47Do we have a bigger example than Bridge Bhushan Singh? And we saw what the prime minister said at that
14:51time.
14:52OK, I want to bring in Rajat Sethi into this conversation. Rajat, Sanjay alleges that this is an attempt at
15:00inception by what he terms an insecure government.
15:04Piti ji, you, when you were introducing Sanjay ji, you said that he sees politics in everything, which is literally
15:11true.
15:11He saw politics even in colors. I mean, see, if you start attributing strawberry and vanilla flavors of ice cream
15:20and start bracketing and bringing politics into it, where will we end up?
15:24So, simple point remains that, I mean, you can draw this and keep dragging this conversation on and on without
15:30any fruitful outcome.
15:31If at all, you know, the administration of Indian hockey wanted to deflect attention from the core harassment, sexual harassment
15:40issue, they have actually brought the focus on to that issue.
15:43So, I think it would have been quite foolish as a strategy if at all they did this strategy.
15:48And again, I don't think that, you know, that the BJP president has no other work but to actually look
15:53for which jersey should I change and give past the political instructions to the Ministry of Sports and get that
15:59done.
15:59I mean, that is a bizarre assertion. Branding and rebranding happens all the time.
16:06A lot of, you know, a lot of efforts of marketing giants go into rebranding various publicly known and very
16:13passionately owned by fans, various commodities that are out there.
16:18And if this is an exercise merely in rebranding and trying to give a fresh look to the team, so
16:24be it.
16:24We have been knowing them as Team Blue, we will know them as Team Saffron.
16:28How does that materially change anything? Do you think that Prime Minister Modi is going to get five extra votes
16:32out of this?
16:33I don't think so. If you remember, even in G20, when the logo was introduced, there was a lotus in
16:38that.
16:38Poor lotus. If you start attributing even politics to even logos of G20, where do you end up?
16:44Do you think that that G20 logo helped Prime Minister Modi in 2024 elections?
16:48The answer is a clear no. So, don't read all of these things purely as a political assertion of sorts.
16:56If you start attributing and seeing it, BJP will see that fine, I mean, this could be an ideological project,
17:01let's further push it.
17:02Because Sanjay Jhaji thinks like that.
17:04No, but Rajat, it's not limited to Sanjay Jha. I'll tell you why it's not limited to Sanjay Jha. If,
17:10you know, if you actually go back and listen in to all the former hockey captains, Rajat, most of them
17:18have come out and said that they don't quite agree with it.
17:20We have someone who's sitting right there. Janbir Singh, former Indian hockey captain says that maybe it wasn't a good
17:26idea. So, it's really not what Sanjay Jhaji thinks.
17:27There are a lot of brands. There is a lot of pushback on several brands. Look, iPhone. Apple iPhone came
17:33up with a saffron colour. Was there a BJP project behind it?
17:36Of course not. A lot of people hated that colour. A lot of people loved that colour. Leave this judgement
17:41to people. Some people like strawberries, some like vanilla.
17:43Okay, 20 seconds. Sanjay, I'll go back to Nikhil and Jagbir Singh. Sanjay, you want to come in for 20
17:51seconds?
17:52Yeah, very quickly. I can tell you this for a fact. Colour matters. Rajat city, show me a picture where
17:58the Prime Minister Narendra Modi is wearing a green cap or a green, you know, dupatta or he's wearing a
18:04green bandi or a green bandh gala.
18:06Show me one. Colour matters, my dear friend. Don't try and ignore it.
18:10Oh, come on.
18:10Let me tell you something. The comparison with Apple is a bad one.
18:14The comparison with Apple is a bad one because Apple's market capitalization is higher than India's GDP.
18:21So, Apple cannot be bullied by you. Yes, I agree with you completely.
18:24Okay, allow me to bring in. Okay, Rajat, 10 seconds.
18:27Well, PTG, again, I said, I brought in Apple to make a point that a lot of people said that
18:33saffron has dominated Apple's choice of colours.
18:35Because now iPhones are being made in India. Such bizarre comments will keep on coming in.
18:40Okay, allow me to bring in. We need to have a large-hearted approach to colours.
18:42Okay, Jagbir Singh ji, I'm going to bring in Nikhil back into this conversation.
18:46But I'm sure you're listening in and you have also spoken to a lot of your colleagues.
18:50Some of them, you know, have come out and said that they just don't agree with the saffronization of the
18:56hockey uniform.
18:58But some of them have said it's only a colour move on. Game is a game. You have to play
19:02sports.
19:02Pargat Singh is one of them. But there are other hockey captains who staunchly oppose the change.
19:08Will you read politics, Jagbir Singh ji, in all of this?
19:11I would say, till date, I have friends from overseas who still want the Indian blue colour.
19:18The Indian jersey colour back home. They want at least, if not the current one from the former players.
19:26It's the Indian blue colour they always talk about.
19:28But let's not forget a very technical point which the coaches and the management has put in here.
19:33They have put in, which has been going on for quite some time, be it in the previous edition of
19:39World Cup or the earlier one.
19:41The striking colours on the blue turf which the boys have been playing.
19:46The visibility of the ball and the sidelines.
19:49These are all technical issues which have been in discussion for quite some time.
19:53But the timing is maybe not the right one.
19:57And the colour combination is not as good as we players expected.
20:02We wanted more of blue and a contrast of, I would say, an orange, a striking orange.
20:09Let's not forget the previous Olympic Games which we won a bronze medal.
20:14We wore orange colour socks when we played and won a medal.
20:18So it's not the colour. Please forgive hockey from politics.
20:24Please excuse us. We don't want politics.
20:26As such, none of the discussions were there.
20:29None of them, none of the praises or good words were being flashed around
20:34when our under 18 hockey fives, we recently won the Asia Cup.
20:41Fair point. Jagbir Ji, you're echoing Nikhil sentiment right and right.
20:43Why only bring in hockey for the wrong reason? Just give it a thought.
20:48Come back. Come back to the thought again.
20:51Hockey has been our national sport.
20:54It's a national pride.
20:56Please bring it in a good taste.
20:58Bring it in a good light every time.
21:00It's not just about colour.
21:02It's about the combination of colours.
21:04Complete orange, no, no.
21:07There should be blue with the contrast.
21:09Okay, so you're just not happy.
21:10You want a nice mix of blue because ultimately blue.
21:13And Nikhil, you know, the fact is, it's not really about colour,
21:16but it is about colour.
21:17You've always envisioned the Indian team in blue.
21:21You know, blues are colour when sports is concerned.
21:23That's true, Preeti.
21:24And I think just taking forward Jasbir's example,
21:27I was there at the Paris Olympics, saw every India match.
21:31I think they were wearing a white, predominantly a white jersey,
21:34which had a bit of blue in it.
21:36And nobody seemed to have a problem with that.
21:38So yeah, I mean, if you want to look at a different colour
21:40because of technical reasons, there are many other colours you can look at.
21:43In fact, I have the jersey, I should have got it to the studio today,
21:46the hockey jersey with which the Indian team were playing on multiple games.
21:50But just going back to the point that, you know, Sanjay Jha made and, you know,
21:53for years he and I discussed sport on television.
21:56It's, you know, one of those rare occasions where I'm on the sporting side,
21:59he's on the political side.
22:00And I'll tell you what, I started my argument by saying,
22:04I don't believe, I love the blue, but I don't see the politics in it.
22:07And I'll give you an example why.
22:09And thank God for that, he made the transition into political analysis.
22:12I remained with sport because then I see sport and I see the interest of sport.
22:17I do not take sides like sometimes political analysts do,
22:20which is why quite often when I see political debates,
22:23the debate is over, why does the leader of opposition go on a holiday?
22:27Or why does the Prime Minister travel abroad?
22:29These things don't matter.
22:30It doesn't really matter that you have debates on these things,
22:33which are of no consequences to the country.
22:36You need to stick to the things, these are diversionary tactics.
22:38You need to stick to the things of what is good for India,
22:41what is not good for India, leader of opposition taking holidays,
22:44or the Prime Minister on foreign tours does not do anything to India's economy,
22:48jobs, meat, all of these things.
22:50So that's what political analysts specialize in.
22:52As far as sports is concerned, no diversion, straight penalty corner in the goal.
22:57And that's our focus.
22:58All right. Okay, Nikhil, we will take this conversation offline.
23:02But thank you.
23:03I thank all our guests who took the time out this evening and joined us.
23:07Thank you so much.

Recommended