• 12 minutes ago
This India Today special broadcast anchored by Gaurav Sawant on India First examines the diplomatic outcomes of the Quad leaders' meeting held in Manila alongside the ASEAN and East Asia summits. Former Indian Ambassador to the United States Meera Shankar and strategic affairs expert Professor Brahma Chellaney analyse maritime reconnaissance aircraft exercises, resilient supply chains, trilateral rare earth mineral cooperation, and shifting US perspectives ahead of an APEC trilateral engagement. The broadcast also reviews Prime Minister Narendra Modi's address at the India-ASEAN summit focusing on Indo-Pacific stability. Meanwhile, a political dispute between the Congress and the BJP unfolds over India extending an invitation to Pakistan for the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation Civilisational Dialogue in New Delhi. While the ruling party cites mandatory multilateral obligations under the SCO charter, critics question the move following past terror attacks. The panel evaluates concerns regarding Pakistan deputing its climate change minister to address the Indus Waters Treaty amid bilateral tensions.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Hello and welcome to an India Today special broadcast that comes to you from Shenzhen in China.
00:04I'm Gaurav Savant. All eyes now on the trilateral between US President Donald Trump,
00:10Russian President Vladimir Putin and the Chinese President Xi Jinping
00:14that's scheduled to be held here on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Conference
00:20that will take place on the 18th and the 19th.
00:24But before that, the US President was in Manila.
00:27So was the Indian Prime Minister, the 11-member ASEAN body.
00:33They had the India-ASEAN summit.
00:37There was also the India-East Asia dialogue, the 21st and the 23rd edition of this.
00:45And while there was a lot of cooperation, talk of taking the relationship forward,
00:49for the moment I want to focus on the Quad leaders meeting.
00:53Remember, it's happened after a gap of two years.
00:56The last Quad meeting was held in the United States of America in 2024
01:00under the presidentship of former President Joe Biden.
01:05Incidentally, that was India's turn to host the Quad summit in India.
01:10But since that was Joe Biden's last year, he requested that if he could host it, and he did.
01:16After that, 2025 and 2026, US President Donald Trump couldn't come to India for the Quad summit.
01:24This time, it's been held after a gap of about two years, but just for about 55 minutes, just under
01:31one hour.
01:33What is the message here?
01:35So, first, let's decode what was said, and then we'll talk about the finer aspects of this.
01:42So, while US President Donald Trump spoke of maritime cooperation, he spoke of the first maritime reconnaissance aircraft joint exercises.
01:52Remember, you've had 30 rounds of the Malabar series of exercises, anti-ship warfare, anti-submarine warfare,
01:58checking interoperability, and those exercises have been going on for quite some time.
02:03But this time, the long-range maritime reconnaissance aircraft, the P-8 and the P-3Cs, the Orions.
02:10Now, India operates the P-8Is.
02:13Other Quad partners also operate the US P-8 series of aircraft.
02:18So, interoperability is also big.
02:21That's one aspect of this.
02:23There was also talk about India, Japan, and the United States catching up with China, perhaps, in the next 10
02:31months on rare earth minerals.
02:33A lot of effort is being done.
02:35A lot needs to be done.
02:37President Trump indicated in about 10 months, they will catch up.
02:41He didn't name China, but he said in the next 10 months, we will catch up.
02:44A lot of effort is being made.
02:46$85 million are being invested, including in various projects, including one in India,
02:52where from waste can rare earth minerals, can still from electronics, can it be recovered?
02:59Now, there was another aspect to this.
03:01While Prime Minister Narendra Modi insisted,
03:03Quad is all about ensuring partnership among democracies,
03:08ensuring that sea lanes of communication are kept open, free, and rule-based order is maintained.
03:14There's another picture.
03:16Now, take a look at this picture.
03:18The Prime Minister came up on stage along with other Quad leaders,
03:21and then the place which symbolizes or signifies where the Prime Minister was supposed to stand,
03:26the flag was there, the Indian flag.
03:28So, the Prime Minister picked it up and he kept it in his pocket,
03:31and the American President said, yep, I noticed that.
03:33Before I get you more on the story, let's listen in to US President Donald Trump
03:37and Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Quad.
03:39And then we decode, does Quad have a future?
03:43Is it meandering?
03:45Has President Trump lost interest in Quad?
03:47Is he losing interest?
03:48Or is there now a revival of Quad?
03:51We'll discuss that, but first, listen in.
04:10Also, the Prime Minister...
04:22that provide solutions for the Indo-Pacific solutions to the entire Indo-Pacific.
04:56These nations represent some of the most important partnerships in the entire world.
05:03They're the most successful, among the most successful nations in the world,
05:08and in certain ways among the most powerful nations in the world.
05:12Our countries are the four corners of a free, open, stable, and prosperous Indo-Pacific.
05:23So this is the first meeting after a gap of two years,
05:29but also it's happening on the 10th anniversary of the Quad Vision of late Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe
05:36about free and open Indo-Pacific and following rules-based orders.
05:42So that was the vision of 2016. This leaders' meeting happened in 2026.
05:48But what are key takeaways? Should we look at the maritime reconnaissance aircraft exercises,
05:56working on rare earth minerals together, India, Japan, and the United States?
06:00Or is there also another signal here?
06:03President Trump stopped in Manila, came for the Quad leaders' meeting,
06:07and then we'll be travelling to Shenzhen.
06:09Is there a message there for the Chinese President Xi Jinping?
06:14Let's help, to help us decode.
06:16Joining us on this special broadcast is Ambassador Meera Shankar,
06:20India's former ambassador to the United States of America.
06:23Ambassador Shankar, welcome.
06:25Ma'am, what are key takeaways for you from the readout of the Quad summit,
06:32of the Quad leaders' meeting?
06:34Is that impression going out that President Trump is either losing interest or has lost interest in Quad?
06:41The fact that this meeting happened after a gap of two years and was barely about 55 odd minutes?
06:47Well, I think this has been a question that President Trump is not invested personally in the Quad,
06:59and that his priority has been to try to work out a constructive relationship of strategic stability,
07:08as it has been called, with China.
07:10So I think it's significant that he did attend this summit.
07:18So that is political signalling of some sort that he remains invested in Quad.
07:26And the fact that it is happening on the eve of the trilateral summit with President Xi and with President
07:36Putin in Shenzhen,
07:38and I think sends its own message.
07:41This has also happened in the wake of the NVIDIA scandal,
07:47where, you know, through espionage or fraud,
07:51China is believed to have procured high technology NVIDIA chips.
07:57And this, again, coming on the eve of the trilateral summit,
08:04shows that there are differences about how conciliatory approach the US should follow with regard to China.
08:16And this will, in effect, mean that export restrictions on sending such chips abroad will be tightened,
08:31both for China as well as for third countries from which it may have procured,
08:37for instance, data centres in Malaysia or other countries.
08:42And then we have to see if China retaliates in time by imposing restrictions on critical minerals.
08:50So we really don't know where this will go.
08:54As regards the outcome of the Quad leaders meeting itself,
09:02you have their reiterating their commitment to a free and open Indo-Pacific.
09:10They commit to ensuring...
09:14So let's take this step by step, ma'am.
09:15Let's take this step by step.
09:17Let's talk about the key takeaway.
09:19Is a key takeaway, you know, the long range maritime reconnaissance aircraft exercise for anti-submarine warfare.
09:27President Trump himself spoke of, you know, 30 rounds of the Malabar series of exercises that have already taken place.
09:34But then now they're bringing in, you know, the P8s and India operates the P8i, as you well know, ma
09:39'am.
09:39The P3C Orions, which India doesn't operate.
09:42But then those are, you know, the P3Cs also being brought in.
09:46Is that a step forward?
09:48Is that again a signal?
09:49Because if you're doing anti-submarine warfare or anti-ship warfare,
09:52who's the signal being sent out to, if not China?
09:56Well, I think that it's a step up from what the Quad countries were doing earlier with regard to maritime
10:05surveillance.
10:06And they last year, they agreed on a maritime surveillance framework.
10:12And under that framework, they are now proposing to actually have exercises of their surveillance aircraft, the P3 and P8,
10:23as you have said, which will take place in 2027.
10:27So that's certainly a step up in their efforts to work together on generating greater maritime domain awareness and ensuring
10:39the safety and security of sea lanes.
10:44Secondly, I think they have agreed on a business leader summit again next year, which would be an effort to
10:53step up economic cooperation amongst the Quad countries.
10:57The third element is the third element is the, you know, effort to welcome increased connectivity, particularly cable connectivity, both
11:10in telecom as well as communication links, as well as energy in the Indo-Pacific.
11:17Then there is cooperation with regard to cyber security and the AI accelerator, which would mean deploying, you know, access
11:30and deployment of trusted AI.
11:35Yes.
11:35So these are the specifics that they have agreed to while continuing their efforts on critical minerals and resilient supply
11:44chains.
11:48So when President Trump says that in the next 10 months, India, the United States and Japan will catch up
11:55with them.
11:57Do you see real effort happening in India, US and Japan trying to catch up with China on rare earth
12:03minerals and whether it's manufacturing of chip or harnessing technology?
12:08Is that trust there?
12:10Because when it comes to President Trump, the impression is he says something on Monday, he may say something completely
12:15different on Tuesday and things will be very different the third day.
12:19And look at the manner in which, you know, India started engaging so well with the United States of America
12:24when he was sworn in and after his inauguration and suddenly those Trump tariffs came and hit us.
12:32Is the relationship returning on an even keel?
12:35Will the next two years be better or will it be more of the same in your view, ma'am?
12:41Right now, you know, on the tariff issue, I don't see much change.
12:45You know, we are still at a stage where we are, the agreement we are supposed to sign with the
12:55US, the interim one is still awaiting, you know, clarity about the US tariff structure and the degree of preference
13:05that India will get vis-a-vis other countries.
13:08So that's something we are waiting for.
13:10So then, you know, on many other issues, the Trump administration has not been very forward looking in its relationship
13:22with India, whether it's sharing technology or, you know, giving, treating India as being of strategic consequence.
13:32I think on all these issues, there have been doubts about where India stands vis-a-vis the US.
13:40Whether this will all clear, we don't know.
13:43But the fact that Trump has now attended the Quad Leaders Summit, which he was loath to do earlier, is
13:53sending a signal.
13:54If that signal, if that signal will be sustained going forward, is a question.
14:00But clearly, the rest of the establishment in Washington wants a more conventional foreign policy where they work with partners,
14:14strategic partners, and with alliances which they have to improve stability and balance in the Indo-Pacific region.
14:31So, you know, we've seen this, we've seen this meander so much that it changed, it changed Ambassador Shankar, it
14:39changed from Indo-Pacific to Asia-Pacific.
14:42Again, he said Indo-Pacific. It just seems that either the US administration or the White House, they don't care
14:49about what's happening here, they don't know what's happening here.
14:52Or do you see a method to their madness that they want this region to remain in turmoil?
14:57And if he wants to stabilize relationship with China that is seen as a competitor, if not a rival in
15:03decades to come, but he wants to upset countries like India that are seen as strategic partners, somewhere down the
15:08line, the Trump administration functioning doesn't seem to add up into what they want to do, either internally or externally.
15:18Well, I think there is a degree of strategic coherence about the policy, and some of it flows from Trump's
15:28tactics, which involve blowing hot and cold at the same time on most issues, and with most countries, including alliances,
15:40allies and strategic partners.
15:42So it, you know, it introduces a degree of confusion about the way, about the US perspective on this region.
15:55But again, as I said, there's some political significance in the fact that President Trump did come for the Quad
16:05Summit on the eve of his meeting, and that the, you know, scandal with NVIDIA and the espionage allegations against
16:18China in this regard,
16:20will perhaps lead to a hardening of, or could, I won't say will, could perhaps lead to a hardening of
16:30perspective in the US.
16:32Again, we have to wait and see, because with President Trump, things are always fluid.
16:43So right now, is Quad a footnote and the trilateral at Shenzhen the major headline, and do you see a
16:50new architecture, some kind of a G3 emerge, or it's too soon to look at it as an architecture for
16:57G3?
16:57I mean, this is grabbing big headlines, but for the three of them to find areas of convergence is easier
17:03said than done.
17:06Yes, I think it's the fact that they are meeting, which is grabbing eyeballs, but there's no agreed agenda for
17:15the meeting as yet.
17:17President Xi has said that they will discuss world peace and what the three countries can do to help stabilize
17:24the world.
17:27And then I think President Trump has said he wants to discuss nuclear disarmament or nuclear arms limitation, and that's
17:38because all the arrangements between Russia and the Soviet Union, on the one hand, and the US for arms limitation
17:48and strategic stability in Europe have broken down or come to an end and have not been extended.
17:55And President Trump says he wants to draw China into the fold of those negotiations, because he says China's arsenal
18:09has grown and is growing.
18:14So they cannot leave it out of the strategic calculus while working out limits on the deployment of US and
18:25Russian nuclear arsenals.
18:27Okay.
18:27They feel China needs to be brought in, but China opposes this fiercely.
18:33So where all this is going to go, we don't know.
18:37It's too early to say.
18:41So there are several balls, yeah, there are several balls up in the air, and we're tracking that story very
18:46closely here in Shenzhen.
18:47Ambassador Meera Shankar, as always, for joining me here on this India First special broadcast, many thanks.
18:53I now want to shift focus and talk about the India-ASEAN and India-East Asia dialogue.
19:00Now, this is extremely significant.
19:01It's very high on symbolism, but it's also very substantive.
19:06So take a look at those images of Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the Gurdwara Sahib.
19:11Now, there's a century-old Gurdwara Sahib.
19:14Prime Minister Narendra Modi went to that Gurdwara Sahib because it's now being redone in a very big way.
19:22There was conversation around the civilizational ties between India and the entire region.
19:29Very strong civilizational ties, historic ties, cultural ties, people-to-people ties, and of course, business-to-business ties.
19:36Now the effort is, as the Prime Minister said, to take it to the next level.
19:41Start skilling together.
19:44Start upskilling together.
19:45Start working on technology together.
19:48Work for the greater good.
19:49Look at each other as, you know, working together and not as competitors, but as people who are cooperating on
19:58a project.
19:58Because this would be a win-win, both for India and for ASEAN countries.
20:02He also saw a performance of the Ramayana yesterday in Manila.
20:07Again, something that shows the civilizational and historical proximity between the people of the two regions.
20:14And a lot more is being done to bring the people of both India and the ASEAN block together.
20:21And it is a very significant block.
20:23The economy of this entire block, 11-nation block, is about $4 trillion, similar to India.
20:28So cooperating closer together is a win-win for both.
20:32Before I get you more, listen in to Prime Minister Narendra Modi in Manila.
20:58Thank you very much.
21:07Thank you very much.
21:18ॐ ॐ ॐ ॐ
21:41ॐ ॐ ॐ ॐ ॐ
21:59ॐ ॐ ॐ ॐ ॐ
22:06ॐ
22:09ॐ
22:10ॐ
22:11ॐ
22:12ॐ
22:12ॐ
22:12ॐ
22:28१
22:29when you talk about in the wake of the trilateral that the whole world is looking at.
22:35Professor Brahma Chalani, one of India's foremost strategic voices,
22:38joins me on the special broadcast.
22:39Also with me is senior journalist Sandeep Unnithan.
22:42Professor Chalani, welcome.
22:44Your key takeaway from the Quad leaders meeting after a gap of two years,
22:50but on the 10th anniversary of Shinzo Abe's vision of a free and open Indo-Pacific.
22:55What is your reading of the joint naval exercises,
22:59and especially the long-range maritime reconnaissance aircraft, sir?
23:03Well, these are symbolically important initiatives.
23:08I say symbolically important because these are not substantive initiatives.
23:14But I think the pre-meaning photo op in Manila
23:19vividly captured the underlying friction and asymmetric power dynamics
23:25currently defining the Quad.
23:28There wasn't this easy camaraderie among equals.
23:32Absent was the animated warmth that characterized earlier Quad gatherings.
23:38Trump held court as the sole protagonist.
23:43He treated the brief photo op as an impromptu, solo press conference.
23:47And with patronizing familiarity, he turned to each leader,
23:52each of the three leaders flanking him,
23:55and handed out casual superlatives.
23:57And Modi's notably stone-faced expression
24:03showed that he was visibly uncomfortable
24:05with Trump's media banter.
24:10And I think there's a larger issue, Gaurav,
24:13that we should not forget,
24:14which tends to get obscured in the Indian discussions,
24:18which is that of the four Quad members,
24:22the U.S., Australia, and Japan
24:24already have trilateral strategic mechanisms.
24:27They don't need the Quad to collaborate.
24:30The Quad makes sense only if you include India.
24:34In fact, the Quad was established to co-opt India
24:37in a larger strategic coalition.
24:42The problem is this,
24:43that there is a reassessment in Washington
24:45of India's rise.
24:48Washington no longer appears to view India's rise
24:51as a jali benign.
24:53And the U.S. Deputy Secretary of State,
24:56Christopher Landau,
24:57stated bluntly on Indian soil
24:59that America will not make his China mistake with India.
25:04So, what we are seeing is that
25:06India's role in U.S. policy
25:08is being downgraded.
25:11And this eroding salience of India in U.S. policy
25:14is also weakening the Quad.
25:16Because if U.S.-India ties,
25:19or at least India's role in U.S. strategy
25:22diminishes,
25:23the Quad cannot remain equally important
25:26to U.S. strategy.
25:29So, what we are seeing is the linkage between the two.
25:32So, Quad is not equally important
25:33for the United States of America,
25:35is the U.S. shooting itself in the foot once again,
25:39first letting China grow in the manner in which it did,
25:41and now, you know,
25:43trying to stop India's growth, Sandeep?
25:46Because when you talk about Quad cooperation,
25:49now,
25:49Quad becomes extremely important,
25:51and especially the maritime cooperation,
25:54which is intense,
25:55perhaps has been yielding results so far.
25:58There have been 30 rounds of exercises,
26:00the Malabar series of exercises.
26:02And, Sandeep,
26:03do they remain very basic,
26:05or are Malabar now
26:06very intense exercises,
26:09where even interoperability
26:11is being talked about?
26:12And, you are now looking at
26:13anti-ship warfare
26:15and anti-submarine warfare,
26:16which means you are hunting
26:17for hostile submarines, Sandeep.
26:19Absolutely.
26:20Gaurav,
26:20and, you know,
26:21what we have seen in the Malabar exercises
26:23is a, you know,
26:24a level of complexity
26:25that keeps increasing
26:27with several exercises.
26:28And,
26:29because the Quad partners,
26:31particularly the U.S.,
26:32India,
26:33and Australia
26:34operate the same,
26:35the similar platforms,
26:36like the PA-TI,
26:37Poseidon,
26:37made by Boeing,
26:39which is primarily
26:40an anti-submarine hunter.
26:42You know,
26:42it's also a long-range
26:44maritime patrol strike,
26:45but it's primarily
26:46an ASW platform.
26:47And, if you notice,
26:48President Trump mentioned
26:50this thing of
26:50submarine warfare
26:52in Asia.
26:53They're particularly concerned
26:54about China's
26:55submarine-building capacity.
26:57It is one of the
26:58biggest,
26:59you know,
26:59explosions in
27:01submarine-building capacity
27:02since the Cold War
27:03ended 35 years back.
27:05So, China has literally,
27:06has the ability today
27:07to saturate
27:08the Indo-Pacific
27:09with submarines.
27:10They've, of course,
27:11sold eight submarines
27:12to our friendly neighbor
27:14to the West
27:14to, you know,
27:16possibly tie the Indian
27:17down to the Arabian Sea
27:19while they pursue
27:20their strategy
27:22of expanding
27:22through the Indo-Pacific.
27:24So, submarine,
27:25submarines have been
27:26a very big area
27:27of concern,
27:28particularly for
27:29the Indian Navy.
27:30We've seen
27:31Chinese patrols
27:32enter the Indian Ocean
27:33for the first time
27:34in 2013.
27:35Long-range
27:36nuclear-powered
27:37attack submarine patrols,
27:38which have
27:38kept up with
27:40this pace
27:40and momentum.
27:41As China
27:42becomes more
27:42and more confident
27:43with its
27:44nuclear-powered
27:45submarine fleet,
27:46it's building
27:47a very large
27:48fleet of nuclear-powered
27:49attack submarines.
27:50It basically
27:50wants to
27:51displace the United
27:52States
27:52from the Indo-Pacific.
27:54The U.S.
27:54is, of course,
27:55the preeminent
27:56submarine operator
27:57in the world.
27:58It's got 60
27:59nuclear-powered submarines.
28:00It's got more
28:01nuclear submarines
28:02than the rest of the
28:02world put together.
28:04That is a place
28:05that China would
28:05like to occupy.
28:08And that is one
28:09of the areas
28:10of concern for
28:11India and the
28:12Indian Navy as well.
28:12When you say
28:13the Indo-Pacific
28:15needs to be open
28:16and we're looking
28:17at submarine warfare
28:19as a key aspect
28:20of that.
28:20Yes.
28:24And this is where
28:25that strategic
28:25incoherence in U.S.
28:27policy becomes
28:27so apparent.
28:29You know,
28:29considering the
28:30kind of statements
28:31the U.S.
28:31makes about
28:32India's rise
28:33and not letting
28:34India rise
28:34the way it let
28:35China rise,
28:36U.S. appears
28:37to be shooting
28:37itself in the foot.
28:38But is there
28:41some kind of
28:41mid-course correction
28:42or is this just
28:44strategic signaling
28:45or tactical signaling
28:46to China
28:47that he holds
28:48a Quad leaders
28:49meeting before
28:50he comes here
28:50to Shenzhen?
28:52Is there some
28:53kind of a message
28:53being sent to China
28:54in your view,
28:55Professor Jalani?
28:56Definitely.
28:58The very fact
28:58that the Quad
29:00meeting in Manila
29:02was hurriedly
29:04arranged that
29:06to just before
29:08Trump travels
29:10to China
29:11was clearly
29:13intended to
29:14signal to China
29:15that the U.S.
29:17has
29:18different
29:19forms of
29:20leverage
29:21vis-à-vis
29:22Beijing.
29:24But that
29:25actually undermines
29:26the Quad's
29:27very purpose.
29:28It's, you know,
29:28it's not supposed
29:29to be a
29:30disposable
29:31bargaining chip
29:32in U.S.-China
29:34relations.
29:35But on the
29:36larger issue
29:37of what's
29:38happening,
29:38we should not
29:39forget one thing
29:40that I
29:41mentioned about
29:42the, you
29:43know, the
29:44deep connection
29:45between
29:47India's role
29:49in U.S.
29:49strategy
29:50and the
29:51importance of
29:52the Quad.
29:52And so when
29:53India's role
29:55diminishes,
29:56the Quad
29:56also weakens.
29:57Now, the
29:58deeper shift
29:59in Washington's
29:59thinking about
30:00India began
30:01in the latter
30:02half of the
30:03Joe Biden
30:04presidency.
30:05And it's
30:05likely to
30:06outlast Trump.
30:07So there's
30:08an institutional
30:08element.
30:09So you don't
30:09see a mid-course
30:10correction.
30:10Sir, that,
30:12yes, you
30:13don't see any
30:14mid-course
30:14correction and
30:15you don't even
30:15see an attempt
30:16at mid-course
30:17correction.
30:17You see
30:18India-U.S.
30:19relations remain
30:20turbulent
30:20even for the
30:22remaining two
30:22years of Trump
30:23administration?
30:25Look, the
30:26institutional
30:27correction that
30:29is underway in
30:30Washington is
30:32to see India's
30:33rise as a
30:36potential long-term
30:39threat to
30:40America's
30:41economic
30:41primacy in
30:43the world.
30:45So, which
30:46is the reason
30:46why what
30:48Christopher Landau
30:49said in New
30:50Delhi was
30:51not an
30:52isolated
30:53statement.
30:54If you look
30:54at State
30:55Department's
30:55five-year
30:56strategic plan
30:57that was
30:58unveiled a
30:59month or
31:00two before
31:00Landau made
31:02that statement,
31:03that also
31:04refers to
31:06the Chadha
31:06mistake not
31:07being repeated
31:08again.
31:09So there
31:10is a
31:10rethink in
31:11Washington,
31:13rethink or
31:14reassessment in
31:15Washington of
31:16India's rise,
31:17and Trump has
31:19accelerated that
31:20shift by
31:22stripping away
31:22much of the
31:23diplomatic cushioning
31:24that once
31:25softened bilateral
31:26differences.
31:27You know, we
31:27tend to now
31:28focus only on
31:29the Trump
31:29administration,
31:30the Trump
31:31era, friction,
31:34tending to
31:35forget the
31:36friction that
31:37began during
31:39the Joe
31:39Biden
31:40presidency.
31:41So there
31:41is a
31:43pattern that
31:44began.
31:44No, that
31:44point taken
31:45entirely.
31:46That point
31:46taken entirely.
31:48But be that
31:49as it may,
31:49Professor
31:49Chalani, if
31:50India has to
31:50grow into a
31:51$30 trillion
31:52economy by
31:532047 or
31:54even a
31:54$25 trillion
31:55economy, as
31:56some analysts
31:57say, India
31:58would need
31:58cooperation or
32:00some kind
32:00of association
32:02both with
32:02China and
32:03with the
32:03United States
32:04of America,
32:05whether we
32:05like it or
32:06not, Sandeep,
32:07India would
32:07still have to
32:09love it, hate
32:11it, but still
32:12have to go
32:12through this
32:13entire process
32:14and try to
32:14make the best
32:15out of all.
32:15And perhaps
32:15that is why,
32:16Sandeep, India's
32:17diversifying
32:18engagement, you
32:19know, Quad,
32:20Prime Minister
32:21didn't even
32:21mention it in
32:22his statement
32:23initially, but
32:24look at the
32:25engagement between
32:25India-Asia and
32:26engagement between
32:27India-East Asia,
32:29engagement on
32:30other platforms,
32:30Sandeep?
32:32Absolutely,
32:33Gaurab.
32:33You know, and
32:33the fact is
32:34that India has
32:35no option but
32:35to partner with
32:36the United States,
32:38at least in the
32:38near foreseeable
32:39future.
32:40We have no
32:40other option.
32:41The kind of
32:42partnership that
32:43the strength that
32:45the US brings to
32:46the table is
32:47enormous, whether
32:48it is military,
32:49technical, economic,
32:50all of that, and
32:51the diaspora
32:52connect.
32:52You know, we
32:53have a lot more
32:54in common with
32:55the United States
32:56than, you know,
32:58the difference
32:59and I do
33:00agree with what
33:01Professor Chalani
33:02mentioned, that
33:02the US sees
33:03India as a
33:04potential threat
33:06to its hegemony
33:07in the distant
33:08future, but in
33:08the short term,
33:09in the next 10,
33:1015, 20 years,
33:11India has no
33:12option but to
33:12partner with the
33:13United States.
33:14And that is the
33:14reason that you've
33:15seen out of
33:17South Bloc,
33:17through the MEA,
33:19and through this
33:19entire period of
33:20this, the lowest
33:22point of the
33:23India-US
33:23relationship that
33:25we have seen in
33:2525 years in
33:27Delhi.
33:27The MEA has
33:28been fairly
33:30anodyne in the
33:31kind of statements
33:32that it's been
33:33releasing, despite
33:34the fact that
33:35there's been great
33:36provocation, the
33:37kind of statements
33:37that have been
33:38coming out of
33:38Washington is not
33:40the kind of
33:40language that you
33:41would use for a
33:42strategic partner.
33:43And despite that,
33:44you see a very
33:45conscious attempt by
33:46India to preserve
33:48this relationship
33:49with the US to
33:50ensure that
33:51possibly this is
33:52just a Trump
33:53administration thing
33:54and we could
33:56have better ties
33:56with the next
33:57president, of
33:58course, the big
33:59thing is that if
34:00there is an
34:00administrative
34:01thing in the
34:03US, that's huge
34:04cause for concern.
34:06So I think we'll
34:06have to just wait
34:07and watch and
34:07ride out the
34:08storm with the
34:10Trump administration
34:10in the next two
34:11years or so,
34:12Gaurab.
34:16Oh, you're
34:16absolutely right.
34:18You know, try and
34:18make the best of a
34:19bad situation and
34:20this is a story we'll
34:21continue to track
34:21closely.
34:22Professor Chalani
34:23and Sandeep
34:23Unnithan, as
34:24always, many
34:24thanks for joining
34:25me.
34:25Let me go straight
34:27to that story for
34:28the moment.
34:28There's a big,
34:29big political
34:30fight now between
34:31the Congress and
34:32the BJP over an
34:34invitation that's
34:35been extended to
34:35a minister from
34:37Pakistan as part of
34:38the Shanghai
34:39Cooperation
34:39Organization
34:40Civilizational
34:41Dialogue.
34:42And what is this
34:43fight all about?
34:44The Congress has
34:45hit out with the
34:45BJP saying,
34:47now you will serve
34:48biryani to
34:49Pakistanis, the
34:50same Pakistanis
34:51who were killing
34:52our people in
34:53the Baisaran
34:54Valley.
34:55The government
34:56has actually
34:56responded.
34:57Government says
34:58this invitation is
34:59not to Pakistan
35:00for a bilateral
35:02conversation.
35:03This is an
35:03invitation that's
35:04being sent out
35:05to all SCO
35:07member states
35:08and as part of
35:09SCO, an invitation
35:10has also gone out
35:11to Pakistan.
35:12Of course,
35:13Pakistan, nothing
35:14that happens with
35:14Pakistan you can
35:15take at face value
35:16because when the
35:17Minister of Heritage
35:19and Culture was
35:20invited, Pakistan is
35:21sending their
35:22minister for climate
35:23change because they
35:24want to talk, it
35:25seems, about the
35:26Indus Waters Treaty
35:27that was held in
35:28abeyance since the
35:31Pahalgam terror
35:31attack.
35:32India launched
35:33Operation Sindur,
35:34but before that,
35:35India made one thing
35:36very clear, blood and
35:37water cannot flow
35:38together.
35:39The Indus Waters
35:40Treaty was held in
35:41abeyance and that's
35:42a point perhaps
35:43Pakistan intends
35:44to raise, but will
35:45there is a bilateral
35:46issue in a
35:48multilateral platform,
35:49in a multilateral
35:51fora?
35:51We will discuss that
35:52in greater detail,
35:53but listen in to
35:55what India and
35:56Pakistan have to
35:57say about this.
35:58We'll also get you
35:58political reactions.
36:03Several countries
36:04including the SCO
36:05members have been
36:07invited for this
36:08dialogue which is to
36:08take place in New
36:09Delhi and that is
36:11where it is.
36:11we look forward to
36:13holding or hosting
36:15this civilizational
36:16dialogue.
36:17where it comes from
36:18S.C.O.
36:18S.C.O.
36:19S.C.O.
36:19is a multi-lateral
36:21platform.
36:22A multi-lateral
36:23platform.
36:25S.C.O.
36:30in the country.
36:32We will not be aware of that.
36:44There is no such thing.
37:00We will not be aware of that.
37:01We will not be aware of that.
37:07India has made one thing very clear.
37:09Blood and water cannot flow together.
37:11But look at the kind of obnoxious statements
37:13that come from Pakistan.
37:14The same Pakistan Congress Party says
37:16is now being invited for
37:18the civilizational dialogue in India.
37:21Now, is the Congress objecting
37:22to Pakistan being invited
37:24to India on a civilizational dialogue?
37:27Are they trying to say that Pakistanis
37:28are not civilized? That's why they shouldn't be.
37:30Or is there a deeper meaning
37:32or objection here?
37:34Let me bring in Brijesh Kalappa,
37:36senior advocate,
37:38senior spokesperson of the Congress Party.
37:40Joining us on the show, Pradeep Bhandari,
37:42national spokesperson of the BJP with me.
37:44And Sushant Sareen, few people understand
37:46Pakistan and the mindset of
37:48a terrorist state better than
37:51Sushant Sareen. He is a
37:52senior fellow at the Observer Research Foundation.
37:54Gentlemen, welcome.
37:56Pradeep Bhandari, respond
37:58to the Congress Party saying,
38:00they kill people.
38:01Now, you will call them
38:02to buy Biryani.
38:04This the Congress Party says
38:06is treason or words to the effect, sir.
38:13Well, we do not need any lectures
38:14from those who are permanent anti-national
38:16and who we saw Rahul Gandhi just two days back
38:19was inviting an Italian
38:20and was asking him to interfere in India's
38:22elections by chanting the slogan
38:25which Rahul chants.
38:26Now, let's be very clear.
38:27It's not a diplomatic consensus.
38:29It's a diplomatic multilateral obligation.
38:31If the Congress would have read the
38:33SEO charter and the SEO obligation,
38:35any host country invites member countries.
38:37Now, we do not need lectures on national
38:39interest from the Congress Party which
38:41in 2009, this is an India Today article
38:43which I am sharing, who on Sharmul
38:45Sheikh had gone, then Prime Minister,
38:47Dr. Manmohan Singh had conceded and said that
38:49India was operating in Balochistan
38:51and had compromised India's national interest
38:53in sovereignty for vote bank politics.
38:56This is Congress for you.
38:57So, Congress Party does
38:59downward pranam in front of Pakistan.
39:01This is where after 26-11 they did not attack.
39:03Now, I will tell you a difference between them and us.
39:05In Tianjin, where you are right now in China,
39:08this is SCO into when the SCO summit happened.
39:11This is honorable prime minister who exposed
39:13the Pakistani terror in Pergaan in front of Pakistan.
39:16You saw Mr. Jai Shankar going in Pakistan SCO summit
39:19and exposing the Pakistani terror.
39:21So, this is the government which has called out
39:22the nuclear blackmail.
39:23This is the government which has done Operation Sindur.
39:25This is the government which has hit Pakistan
39:27deep inside.
39:28A multilateral diplomatic obligation
39:31should not be treated as a matter of change of policy.
39:34Even if in this forum it is needed,
39:35we will expose the Pakistanis.
39:37Fair enough.
39:41Fair enough.
39:42Vrijesh Kalappa, why is the Congress Party objecting
39:45to Pakistan being invited to a multilateral forum?
39:49The governments made it clear this is not bilateral.
39:51They do not want bilateral dialogue with Pakistan.
39:54But this is an obligation that will have to be fulfilled, sir.
39:59Yeah, I think as far as the number of attacks
40:03which Pakistan has launched on India,
40:07and let me give out a few of the details.
40:09Patankot, 2nd January 2016.
40:13Uri, where 19 soldiers were killed, 18th September 2016.
40:18Uluwama, where 75 persons were killed, 14th February 2019.
40:22Riyasi Pilgrim attack, where 51 people were killed,
40:27and that's on the 9th of June 2024.
40:29Pahlkam, where 26 people were killed,
40:32that's on 22nd April 2025.
40:34The Red Port explosion, where 13 were killed,
40:3710th November 2025.
40:39In 2018, Kashmir saw the highest violence attack,
40:44and 451 deaths in 2018, all thanks to Pakistan.
40:48Then there was a Bangalore explosion, where 6 were killed,
40:52and that's on 28th December 2014.
40:54In Jammu, 16 were killed, that's on 20th March 2015.
40:59Gurdaspur, 25 were killed, that's on 27th of July 2015.
41:03Pampur, 30 were killed, that's on 25th June 2016.
41:08Kokrajar, 29 killed, and that's on the 3rd of October 2016.
41:13Baramula, 5 were killed, and that's on the 5th of August 2016.
41:18Nagarota, 10 were killed, that's on the 29th of November 2016.
41:21Sir, kindly make the substantive point.
41:23Sir, kindly make the substantive point.
41:25Sir, the point is this.
41:26Make the point, sir.
41:27If you read out the entire list, the entire half hour will go.
41:29More point, make your point, sir.
41:31These many attacks which have killed hundreds of our people,
41:34have not brought this government to their senses.
41:37Even after Mr. Modi went to Nawaz Sharif's house,
41:40enjoyed the biryani and came back,
41:42then I don't know what will infuse some sense into their heads.
41:46Now, giving this answer that this is a multilateral summit,
41:52I think is not taking the matter further.
41:54You don't call Pakistan for a civilizational dialogue,
42:00which has been proven to be uncivilized.
42:03It's an uncivilized nation.
42:05It was not our Prime Minister who went to Pakistan.
42:07It was Mr. Modi who went to Pakistan.
42:10So, he has always been showing Pakistan his hand of friendship.
42:14Fair enough.
42:15I will have to put a timer on this broadcast,
42:17both for Bridges Kalappa and for Pradeep Bhandari.
42:19But I want you to quickly respond to this.
42:21Pradeep Bhandari, you wanted to come in before I bring in Sushant Sareen.
42:23Respond.
42:26Well, I just have a 30 seconds interjection.
42:29I do not understand what is his substantive.
42:32Can he tell us between 2004 and 2014 when the Congress was in power,
42:36any multilateral forum where India was a host country and India did not invite any of the member countries.
42:43Can he give a simple example?
42:45He does not have a simple example.
42:47Point number two.
42:488000 civilians lost their lives because of terror attacks in the Congress regime.
42:51Congress did not attack Pakistan.
42:53In all that he listed, we have attacked Pakistan.
42:55We have not just gone to POK.
42:57We have gone inside Pakistan and finished Pakistani terror.
42:59So, what is he speaking about?
43:00Is he telling us that as a host country in SEO, are we not to invite any member country?
43:06In which clause allows the host country to not invite a member country?
43:10Stop being so kiddish.
43:11We don't need lectures from you.
43:12You guys cried for butla.
43:13You guys called Hafiz Saeed as Hafiz Saeed Ji.
43:15You even wanted to give clean chit to Ajwal Kasaab had it not been to Tukara Momle.
43:20So, we don't need lectures from Pakistan's B team out here.
43:26May I respond to that?
43:27Oh, that's a very strong allegation to make and since you've made it, Sushant Sareen,
43:30you want to quickly…
43:31Yes, sir.
43:32Yes, sir.
43:32Since a direct allegation has been made, I mean, you know, kindly response, sir.
43:37See, I have one more dozen of attacks which I think if I continue to read out and if you
43:43permit me to read out…
43:44Answer which obligation…
43:46BJP may develop some…
43:48No, sir.
43:48We will be losing time.
43:50Sir, I am sorry.
43:52I am sorry.
43:52I am sorry.
43:53When did you not invite a member country as a host country?
43:57Stop beating around the bush.
43:59Stop giving me the filibuster.
44:01Answer a specific question.
44:03You have no substance.
44:04You have no substance.
44:06Okay, hold on.
44:07Hold on.
44:08Hold on.
44:08You guys used to give clean chit to the Pakistanis.
44:12Answer the substantive.
44:13As a member country.
44:15Okay.
44:15As a host country.
44:16When did you not invite a member country?
44:18Okay.
44:18Gentlemen.
44:20Gentlemen.
44:21Gentlemen.
44:22Gentlemen.
44:23One at a time.
44:25One at a time.
44:26I am sorry.
44:27Continuously.
44:28Hold on.
44:28Okay.
44:29All faders go down.
44:31I only want Sushant Sareen on the screen for a moment.
44:34All faders go down.
44:36Sushant Sareen.
44:37Sushant Sareen.
44:38I want you to respond.
44:39What do you make of the Congress party's objection?
44:41Is there merit in the Congress saying.
44:43Why invite a Pakistani.
44:46Who will come to India.
44:47And spew venom.
44:48And we invited the culture minister.
44:50They are sending the climate change minister.
44:52So you know.
44:53Is there merit in the Congress saying.
44:55Ab a Pakistaniyo ko bula ke biryani khellaenge.
44:58No, I think.
44:59I think what the Congress party's position is.
45:02Pure politics.
45:03And they think that they can use this issue.
45:05To make the government look bad.
45:07So they are playing domestic politics on this issue.
45:09But I think what will happen.
45:12Gaurav is that.
45:13The Pakistanis are going to be very disappointed.
45:16Because the Pakistanis had pinned their hopes on Rahul Gandhi.
45:19As the great white hope for Pakistanis.
45:22Getting what they want from India.
45:23And the position that the Congress party's taken right now.
45:26If you look at the reactions from Pakistan.
45:29They are very disappointed in the Congress party.
45:31I hope the Congress party was to stick to the position.
45:34That Mr. Kadappa is taking out here right now.
45:37But unfortunately.
45:39Between 1991 and 1996.
45:42When Mr. Narsimha Rao was the Prime Minister.
45:44And later.
45:45Between 2004 and 2014.
45:47When Dr. Manmohan Singh was the Prime Minister.
45:50You know.
45:51One could rattle off maybe.
45:52200 attacks.
45:53Terror attacks that took place.
45:55But it was not as though the government of the day.
45:57Did not engage with the Pakistanis.
45:59Did not invite them.
46:00So clearly.
46:02I think the position that is being taken.
46:03Is purely political.
46:04And it's quite disingenuous.
46:06But I think.
46:06You know.
46:07They are entitled to play their politics out here.
46:09The issue.
46:10However.
46:11Is that.
46:12And I think.
46:12That is where the government's position holds.
46:15That you know.
46:16This is a multilateral thing.
46:17If we have to hold a multilateral meeting.
46:19In which Pakistan is a member.
46:21How do we say that.
46:22Everybody can come.
46:23But not them.
46:24One last point.
46:25If Gaurav you have the time.
46:26You know.
46:26We keep talking about Sharm al-Sheikh.
46:28And frankly.
46:29I think.
46:30To include a reference to Balochistan.
46:32But the reference was not.
46:34Of the kinds that.
46:35Pradeep has counted out.
46:37Yeah.
46:37The reference was.
46:39That the Prime Minister of Pakistan.
46:41From the Prime Minister of India.
46:42Of certain developments in Balochistan.
46:44That was an own goal.
46:46That the Pakistanis committed.
46:47We did not latch on to that.
46:49We suddenly went on the defensive.
46:51If the Pakistanis want to discuss Balochistan with us.
46:54We should discuss Balochistan with them.
46:56After all.
46:56It's occupied territory.
46:57So I don't know.
46:58Why we.
46:59You know.
46:59Reduce Pakistan into a domestic.
47:01It indeed is.
47:03And an own goal.
47:04That the Pakistanis were doing.
47:05We let.
47:06Let them off the hook.
47:08Ideally.
47:08That reference should not have been made.
47:10But the way the reference was made.
47:12An own goal by the Pakistanis.
47:13And we let them off the hook.
47:17Okay.
47:18Fair enough.
47:19Pradeep Bhandari.
47:20You want to respond to the fact.
47:21That Congress party says.
47:22Aba Pakistaniyo ko bula ke.
47:23Is desh mein biryani kehilayenge.
47:25The minister you invited.
47:26The culture minister.
47:27The heritage minister.
47:29He's not the one Pakistan is sending.
47:30Pakistan is sending the climate change minister.
47:33The environment minister.
47:34He's the same chap.
47:35Who said words to the effect.
47:36That if any hand.
47:37Stops the.
47:38Stops our waters.
47:39We will chop off those hands.
47:41Uh.
47:42If a.
47:42If a different individual.
47:44Is being sent.
47:45Is the government.
47:46Well within its rights.
47:47To deny him a visa.
47:48Or let him come.
47:50You say.
47:50He will also be sorted out.
47:52Uh.
47:53You know politically.
47:54Is the message.
47:54What is the government playing at sir.
47:56What is the party's view on this.
48:02Gaurav.
48:02We've stopped water.
48:04It's this.
48:04It's PM Narendra Modi's government.
48:06Which has put.
48:06Indus water treaty in abeyance.
48:08What have they been able to do.
48:10The same minister.
48:11What have they been able to do.
48:12It's not the congress party in power.
48:14It's PM Narendra Modi's government in power.
48:16The Pakistanis dare not do anything.
48:18We'll go inside Pakistan.
48:20Uh.
48:20Take care of their terror targets.
48:21Like we did.
48:22This is 2024.
48:24Pakistanis were praying that.
48:25Rahul Gandhi should be the prime minister.
48:26For Pakistan.
48:27There were more jubilant celebrations.
48:29In Pakistan.
48:30Praying for Rahul Gandhi.
48:31Than in India.
48:31This is.
48:32Pakistan for you.
48:33So we don't need lectures.
48:34From congress party.
48:35Which takes instructions from Pakistan.
48:37I have a very substantive.
48:38And a technical.
48:38And a logical point here.
48:40Okay.
48:40Can the congress to me.
48:41Leave aside this forum.
48:43Between 2004 and 2014.
48:45When the India was a host.
48:47Of any multilateral forum.
48:48Can congress tell me.
48:49A single instance.
48:51Where the congress.
48:52Did not invite a member country.
48:53And does a multilateral forum.
48:55Allow the host.
48:56To not invite a member country.
48:58Okay.
48:58That's my specific.
49:02Fair enough.
49:03Vrijesh Kalappa.
49:04You want to respond to it.
49:05Because.
49:05The BJP.
49:06Hits back.
49:06Saying.
49:07That.
49:07Apart from multilateral forum.
49:09Congress.
49:10Even invited.
49:11You know.
49:11Pakistan.
49:11For a series of bilateral.
49:13Conversations.
49:14Despite terror attacks.
49:15And.
49:15You heard.
49:16You know.
49:17Pradeep Bhandari.
49:17These big attack.
49:1826-11 happened.
49:20166 people.
49:21Lost their lives.
49:22The Indian air force.
49:23Came to the government.
49:24Saying.
49:24We can hit terror targets.
49:26They were not given permission.
49:55See.
49:57A situation.
49:57Where in Sindhu.
49:58Not a single country.
50:00Not even a single country.
50:02Supports India.
50:03Right.
50:03And this.
50:04We have.
50:04A prime minister.
50:06Who is.
50:08Excelling in.
50:09Foreign policy.
50:10Right.
50:10The same prime minister.
50:12You know.
50:13Invited.
50:14Pakistani counterpart.
50:16For his swearing in.
50:17And he also.
50:18Went.
50:18On an unshakable visit.
50:20To Pakistan.
50:21So.
50:21What does it tell you.
50:22It tells you.
50:23That he's bending over backwards.
50:25To accommodate.
50:26The Pakistanis.
50:27Now.
50:28After the fact.
50:28That I've read.
50:29Nearly 35.
50:30Terror attacks.
50:31Right.
50:32If this.
50:33Still.
50:33Has not brought.
50:34The prime minister.
50:35And the government.
50:36To its senses.
50:37Despite.
50:38I think.
50:40An attack.
50:41On the soul.
50:41Of India.
50:42And that has.
50:43What happened after.
50:44You know.
50:44Heard.
50:45India.
50:46Sir.
50:46Every terror attack.
50:48Including 2611.
50:49Was an attack.
50:49On the soul.
50:50Of this country sir.
50:51But.
50:51I'm telling you.
50:51Pradeep Bhandari.
50:52Wants to respond.
50:53But do.
50:53Keep one thing in mind.
50:54Politics apart.
50:55Every terror attack.
50:56Is an attack.
50:57On the soul.
50:58Mr. Sava.
51:02I am sorry.
51:03It did not prevent.
51:04The next terror attack.
51:05It did not prevent.
51:06The next terror attack.
51:07On our people.
51:08Pradeep Bhandari.
51:08Wants to respond.
51:10Mr.
51:11Gaurav.
51:14Gaurav.
51:14Just.
51:15Gaurav.
51:16Just.
51:16Just two points.
51:17After.
51:18He's lied.
51:19He's lied blatantly.
51:20That in Operation Sindhu.
51:22You did not have.
51:23Any member.
51:24Any world country support.
51:25In fact.
51:25Pakistan.
51:26Did not get any support.
51:27Point number one.
51:28Point number two.
51:29Mr.
51:30Mr.
51:30Kalappa.
51:30I was listening to you.
51:32Mr.
51:33Kalappa.
51:33You can't be speaking over me.
51:34This man is speaking over me.
51:37When.
51:37After 26-11.
51:38One by one.
51:39When India had a chance to attack Pakistan.
51:41He was on record.
51:43He said the statement.
51:44That I had orders from the top in UPA government.
51:46That I did not attack Pakistan.
51:48That is.
51:49We did not attack Pakistan.
51:50That is what you said.
51:51After 26-11.
51:53You did a bilateral with Pakistan.
51:54You wanted to do tattoo with Pakistan.
51:55And you did not even attack Pakistan.
51:58Leave aside.
51:59Going inside Pakistan.
52:00After Pahlgaam terror attack.
52:01We went not in POK.
52:02Deep inside Pakistan.
52:04We demolished the terror headquarters of Lashkar-e-Taiba.
52:06What are you saying my dear friend.
52:08And you know we were the first people to call out the nuclear blackmail of Pakistan.
52:11The nuclear broker of Pakistan.
52:13Now you answer me a question.
52:15A multilateral.
52:16You answer.
52:18Multilateral forums.
52:18We don't need that.
52:20Okay.
52:21When the parliament was attacked.
52:22You are the people who give.
52:23You took half his side.
52:25You are guys who give.
52:26Who call Osama.
52:26Osama.
52:27You are the guys because of it.
52:298,000 civilians lost life.
52:30You took cover.
52:31The Pakistani agent.
52:32And Javo and Kashmir.
52:33You are nothing but Pakistani Congress.
52:36You know if you fight.
52:38Once again.
52:40You've both spoken.
52:41You've both spoken.
52:42Sushant Sareen.
52:43India's war on terror.
52:45And Pakistan's state sponsored radical Islamist terror.
52:47Cannot be fought.
52:48When the government and the principal opposition party.
52:51Are at loggerheads.
52:53We have to have.
52:53One policy.
52:55Irrespective of government.
52:56In dealing with radical Islamist terror from Pakistan.
52:59How does one evolve that.
53:01Does that mean when.
53:02You know this climate change minister comes from Pakistan.
53:05India engages with him.
53:07Gives him a cold shoulder.
53:08Or send across a message that blood and water cannot flow together.
53:11Sushant Sareen.
53:12Look I would imagine that.
53:14The way to deal with this weasel.
53:16Who's going to be coming.
53:16And he is a weasel.
53:18He's a loud mouth and a weasel.
53:19So I don't take these characters.
53:22Syria.
53:22I don't take any civilian in Pakistan seriously.
53:25Number one.
53:25Number two.
53:26If this guy comes.
53:27He's coming as you know a diplomatic representative of his country.
53:30So I think whatever are the normal courtesies should be extended to them.
53:34But I don't think there will be any bilateral.
53:37More importantly Gaurav.
53:39And to your biradari I will caution.
53:41He is going to come and try and play you guys like a fiddle.
53:45And I am afraid that the Indian mainstream media forget about the Indian social media.
53:50The Indian mainstream media just simply has lost its marbles when it comes to Pakistan.
53:56There are a whole lot of print newspapers as well as you know your electronic media which
54:02will be falling over itself to give this guy a platform to platform this guy.
54:05I can tell you about India first.
54:08I will tell you about India first.
54:10I will very strongly tell you about India first.
54:13You know.
54:13There will be other shows on your channel that will be doing it.
54:15Not you.
54:16You are an honourable.
54:16Every Pakistani terrorist.
54:19You are an honourable exception.
54:20Every Pakistani terrorist and a terrorist supporter will be sorted out.
54:26Will be sorted out.
54:28And they have to be sorted out.
54:29Because Pakistan state.
54:31No.
54:32But trust me on this.
54:33Because I have just 20 seconds on this part of the show.
54:35And we will do another show on this.
54:37I promise you that.
54:38I want to thank all our guests.
54:39But do keep one thing in mind.
54:41Pakistan has been bleeding India for decades.
54:44And I am not even going back to 1947.
54:46When they sent in tribal raiders.
54:47And they raped and plundered Jammu and Kashmir.
54:50For three days in Uri and Baramola.
54:52Before they were you know.
54:54An effort was made to send them back.
54:561993 Mumbai serial blast.
54:58257 people were killed.
55:00Over 700 were injured.
55:02Now these were series serial blasts that happened.
55:042006.
55:05200 people were killed.
55:072611.
55:08166 people were killed.
55:09And I am not talking about regime A or regime B or regime C.
55:13It is India that bled.
55:15It is Indians that bled.
55:17While political parties may want to score brownie points.
55:20There is one language Pakistan understands.
55:22And that is the language of Brahmaw supersonic cruise missiles.
55:26Hitting the Lashkar-e-Taiba headquarters.
55:29And Bahawalpur of Jaish-e-Mohammad.
55:31And of course their military bases.
55:33That Operation Sindur must continue.
55:36Regardless.
55:37India must bash on.
55:39Regardless.
55:40Against radical Islamist terror.
55:41Sponsored by Pakistan.
55:42To be revening.
55:42Former BC абсолютноğimiz in Afghanistan.струкat
55:43.510
55:43the United Kingdom. Charlottesville.

Recommended